Let me know what you think about this new video format. I worked so hard on it. Also, I just noticed a small mistake at the beginning of the video. It's 2010, not 2001. Sorry about that. 😊
You did a great job making this video BUT I must say that I liked the text better. The "quiet" in the video made it super scary and more realistic. Hearing just the aircraft and pilots conversation is much more interesting for me.
Agreed. I also think it would help to not have the text and the narration contradict each other with the text showing that this flight was flown years before the narration says that the airplane was manufactured. :-/ Whoops.
Damn, you can call that 9 years old Boy lucky, but he lost his whole Family in that crash. What an Aftermath... I read he lives with his uncle in the Netherlands now. May the Family of this brave Boy rest in peace.
I read while eating all the time. I prefer the texts, especially during those times I must watch with no or low sound and I don't have any headphones. *turns video off*
The narration was good however I do prefer the old format with reading the subtitles Edit: I think he narrated because I think new RUclips rules state you have to commentate on videos for them to be monetised or something along those lines :/
That could also be just at the start of the video, I wouldnt mind that actually. But throughout the rest of the video I prefer the old concept. And by looking at the reactions, a lot of us do.
Just hybrid the two formats you'll do fine having narration will probably help pick up new viewers who don't want to read but there is something cool about just hearing the aircraft and the flight crew. what I don't get is why this pilot no Matter how tired and distracted would just noise it into the ground when they were already on a go around
omg you changed the format. It was great but i prefer the original because it had a different feel to it. I know you worked so hard so i dont want to seem ungreatful its still amazing and ill never stop watching xxx
I agree too! Really appreciate the effort on making it more dynamic, but the format with captions is more interesting. Good job anyway, amazing video as usual
I, for one, really enjoyed your narration. Your voice is clear, even, and easy to listen to. Your explanations are easy to understand. You've put a lot of time and effort into this and it shows. It seems I am in the minority as many other viewers seem to prefer no audio narration. Perhaps a good compromise would be to narrate only two portions of the animations: - The beginning... giving a brief summary of the plane info, pilot info, and flight plan. - The end... the explanation of the crash report and the lasting impact the crash had on the industry, etc. This way, the combination of music and sound effects can continue to create the suspenseful moments up to and during the crash. It is a unique aspect to your videos we have all grown to love and enjoy.
The pilots 'felt'? What happened to looking at the instruments? "Hey, John, it feels like we're too high." "No, it feels too low to me." "Look at the instruments." "Instruments? What are instruments?" "Those little round things in front of us." "Oh, I always wondered what those were."
Somatogravic illusion gives a very powerful sensation in this case as if the aircraft was pitching up, it has happened many times during go-arounds with no visibility (e.g. Flydubai 981), it is apparently quite difficult to overcome your need to put the nose down by convincing your own brain that your inner ear is transmitting false signals. Moreover, landing is often the most stressful part of a flight, especially with low visibility and poor approach systems, you also have a very short amount of time to react, and possibly the pilot perceived a false horizon. All these things have to be taken into account.
you are on the right track with this format!! stay the course, no transition is easy. you are setting yourself apart from the rest of the pack. the production is much more digestible for a broader audience. i think it’s just wonderful in every way. you really got something with this!
There was a reverence and respect in the silence, given that the vid predominantly about tragic loss of life. No emotion superimposed, only the viewer’s emotion. And cockpit communication are very important. “In their own words”.
As I said before, I personally love the older format, but either way, I want you to know we subs love all your videos , either way ! Very very professionally made! Now that we do get to hear your voice, however, now curious minds want to know, where are you from originally. I have lived all over, traveling with my husband in the military, I cannot place your dialect, but the accent is quite lovely. Thanks for all your hard work!
Today I did a ILS to minimums at Chicago Midway airport. It was too foggy so I went around. On the second approach we saw the approach lights and descended 100 feet above touch down zone elevation. Then we saw the runway and landed. A routine leg on a routine day. Try to keep off The Flight Channel except as a spectator. FLY SAFE! FLY DISCIPLINED! (KLM also flies Tripoli to Amsterdam. Pay the extra money and arrive alive!
Love and watched all your videos man! But I gotta say I personally prefer the older format of just music and subtitles. You get to really focus on the scenes and the situation more, at least for me. How about adding subtitles along with your voice-over?
Quite opposite. When you have to read the text you can't really focus on the scenes and events. The narrated version is way more easier to follow than the "subtitled only" format.
Shows your dedication, but like the others, i love the previous format. But, WTF, this crew had made the SAME mistake before, went unreported and then did it AGAIN, killing everyone except for 1 child??? Holy hell!
hollywood0770 it’s like having the best of both worlds, I think he did it this way to keep the old format people happy and the voice over in the first part for the change is good crew
OMG that was fantastic... absolutely LOVED hearing your voice... really hoping you do more of these ... well done well articulated. much love and respect from Scotland xoxox
I don't like the new format of the video I'd prefer the old one with sentences instead of voices. Most of the people are better when reading a sentence, not listening to an audio. This looks like a podcast instead of a Flight Investigation..
We appreciate all your efforts and hard work. We too prefer the old text format, as opposed to the voice over. The audio, at least on my computer speakers, has too much bass, or low frequency response. We always look forward to your brilliant productions; they are extremely helpful in understand the complex world of commercial aviation. Bob
I flew with Afriqiyah from London on that route a few months before that, including flight number 771 on the return leg. I'd been so impressed with every aspect of my flying experience - including a spanking new A330 between Tripoli, Johannesburg and return - that I had no hesitation in choosing them to fly London - Dhaka and back a few weeks later. On the return leg from Dhaka I was even given a free upgrade to Business class! The only downside was the sorry state of Tripoli Airport at the time, but a big shiny new terminal was under construction, due to open not long afterwards. My blood ran cold when I heard the news. I still had the stub of my boarding pass for Flight 771. Worse was to follow not long after, with Libya being reduced to chaos by war. Last I heard Tripoli Airport was still closed. BTW, Afriqiyah Airways didn't have the livery shown in the video at that time.
The flight channel videos are very good. Full information, on flight details, Crew names, what exactly happens while in air, and complete analysis, and final conclusions. Excellent sir, keep it up.
This reflects a loss of scanning ability that comes from relying on automation. Pilots are losing their manual flying skills. Did they not check their altitude over the final approach fix??? Bust their minimums, and were fooled by the Go Around sensations of acceleration that proficient instrument flying would have overcome.
I've got very lazy with navication in my care coz of phone GPS, but hopefully I wouldnt' let that happen if flying a passenger jet with responsibility for hundreds of lives
There is something unique and amazing about your older style... written words, as opposed to audio translation. I enjoy listening to podcasts, but when I watch the flight Channel, I mostly look forward to the music and reading the story.
This is very well made but I also prefer the old format. The text and the music blended so well together. Runway map was a good addition. This is a most instructive series. Thank you.
Definitely something different, it is pretty cool to have a voice over, but I like the subtitles a bit better. I think it will be cool once in a while. You did a great job on the voice over, keep up the great work!
Hey buddy, I have watched almost all of your videos, now I came across this one and I have to say: This format is FAR BETTER than the other one you use. Just using texts is bad to retain attention (too much information to read), and after watching this video I felt the combination of narration + visuals + texts on display is much better. I hope you narrate future videos.
I LIKE VOICE narration. this way, I can just listen and focus on watching the plane. not having to place one eye on the text and the other eye on the plane at the same time.
Dear tfc, i love to watch your old format. The old format was really awesome video with the very matching background music. Moreover my friend is deaf person, he couldnt hear your voice in new format, he only can read subtitle. For sure so many people same like him. Please continue the old version dear. Really appreciate for your action. Thank you 😊
I guess modern planes practically fly themselves, otherwise so stupid and incompetent that you wonder how he lasted that long. Of all the causes they didn't mention recruiting, training and monitoring of pilots as a major cause, because pilots like this simply should not be allowed to fly passenger planes and it would be easy to detect if better monitoring and training was in place.
@@partytill10 you guys did not get the impression that the pilot was micro managing the copilot instead of the plane's altitude?, why let a copilot do the landing if youare going to final decide to land or abort?
The editing is amazing!!!!! Wonderful job!! I like your voiceover as well :) But would it be possible to add subtitles for videos when you do voiceovers? I think it would be easier to follow ^-^ Honestly, well done, everything looks awesome!!!!
Great job on the video man, a lot of work goes into this type of video and its appreciated.i must say that the old format is what I’d personally prefer.so much detail in the text and easy to imagine it with the way you lay it out. Thank you again for getting me hooked on aviation 🇨🇮🇨🇮
The new format is great. You continue to do an amazing job. Thank you for all the hard work. Do not get discouraged by the reply comments that criticize the new format. It is a personal preference and in all honesty, you did ask which way your viewers prefer. So, we simply let you know which way we like better. Me personally, I’d still watch either way. The videos are great.thank you.
You have no idea how much I love this channel. It's amazing. I prefer the old format. The subtitles only allow me to use more of my own imagination in recreating the experience in my mind.
I love how you’re experimenting with new video formats, love your videos always! I think I prefer without the voice over though, just the music and the subtitles create such an immersive experience which I think is perfect for these air crash investigations. Always looking forward to new videos :)
You have obviously put a great deal of time and effort into this video and it’s good, but sorry, I have to say I prefer the old style. For me there was more tension build up and emotion.
Dear Flight Channel. I THOUROUGHLY enjoyed the fact that out of your MANY videos, this is the 1st time I did not have to READ the story, but could in fact LISTEN to the STORY. PLEASE. MORE NARRATIONS!! I LOVE that FORMAT! I'm so busy that I always miss critical information by taking my eyes off the screen, but hearing it has changed it for me... KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!! Apparently, I'm one of the FEW of many that enjoy the voiceover.. Perhaps you can make BOTH?!?!? Just a thought (Since you can't please everyone- hahaha).
Not sure about the voiceover, although it was synced and articulated well, maybe I’m just use to hearing my own voice in my head while reading your script. The music is also synced to the video for a nice effect but a bit too happy for such a tragic incident. The jury is still out on this one with the v/o.🤷🏻♂️ Keep up the great work!
Please do NOT go back to the old format. The voice over is waaaay better and I don’t have to stop looking at the scene to read what’s going on! Please continue with this format and don’t worry about what all the other people are saying about they liked the old format better, they just don’t like change.
I love the new format! And I’ve always liked the way you change photo to photo in time with the music. That’s a level of drama this kind of video needs. Great job! 👍😊
The graphics are exceptional, but I think the old format suits this type of videos better..You can really immerse into the atmosphere of the flight, you make some kind of connection..anyway, we all love your work..keep it up! :D
Dear owner of the flight channel I just love your videos and the way you explained all the crashes in your previous videos , none of the other channel did the same way..There is a little request I want to make that if you will read this please I want you to go back to the old format in which you used to include texts instead of voice it actually creates a kind of suspense and it make investigation even more interesting ..I still like your video and I really appreciate your hardwork you are doing a great , brilliant job but its a request if you can make videos with the text not voices than I will be very very thankful to you...And thankyou once again for doing such a hard work for us .
I think it would be great to have both. I enjoyed being able to listen to the video without having to constantly watch the screen while I was getting ready for work. It would be nice to keep subtitles for the hearing impaired.
@@deeanna8448 offc but the problem is that there's no more sound of an aircraft, there's no more intensity like before with music etc..Just documentary..
Sorry to say this, but I never like the new format. I missed the old format, which is more serious and dramatic with the background and subtitles rumbling throughout the videos, despite your clear audio. This new format have lost its serious mood of the story. I didn't like that. Old format was way better than that.
You do GREAT work! Loved the animations and even the voice over, it was great. You can tell you put a lot of work into it. Honest opinion - sure I like the old format as well but it was very refreshing to watch this new format. I suppose I preference the old format but would absolutely love to have a few this new format thrown in every now and then too. You do awesome work man. Many thank yous.
Friend, when I first turned the video on and heard a voice, I thought I had stumbled onto someone else's channel. It was great as are all your videos; put together very well and with good visuals. However, like many rock bands out there, sometimes it can be good to branch from your roots, but not always. Point is, stick to your original formula. It works. Among many different videos of this nature, there is something about yours that draws me in. I find that I pay much more attention when there is no dialog, but just subtitles and calming music. Even better when you can hear the real radio transmissions. It really sticks and really keeps me attended. And its why I certainly enjoy watching these. I know you put a lot of work into them. And it shows. BTW, are you going to get around to doing some on Flight 800 (1996), the Air France Concord disater, the Potamic River crash, and one years ago when the plane flipped on landing and cart-wheeled down the runway? There were survivors on that one. And please excuse me, as I don't remember the flight names or numbers of these particular accidents. Would enjoy seeing your take on them.
I actually like both formats. You have a very pleasant voice so your new format has my ultimate vote. I can't imagine how hard you work to put these videos out every week. Thank you.
Oh me too! I worked in international insurance in the City of London, and I helped to insure airlines. Also assisted with their (usually huge) insurance claims. Seeing how crashes happened in the confidential reports has made me totally scared of flying.
This is by far the best I've seen. It surpasses your past efforts if that is possible. The production value is immense. The music is fantastic and the audio is superior. The voice is excellent, commanding you to listen, spoken with authority yet still sensitive. Timber and accent are delightful. Don't change a thing friend. I've too have seen many of your past productions, and enjoyed them immensely. Don't give in and listen to all who say your past is superior. People get accustomed to things. It takes time to transition to a new experience. Loosen up people shake off the chains of familiarity and habit. Let's explore this new format. I find it has more dimensions, I don't need to read subtitles and therefore can sink deeper into the drama unfolding in front of me. Please don't get discouraged friend. It's Good. It's very Good.
I really like you voice, but the old format seems more dramatic and can brought us in the real situation than this. Just my opinion bro, I appreciate your hardwork. keep it up 😉
Appreciate your efforts. The previous version of titles and music is better than the new voice version. Thank you for your continuous efforts for making this channel better and better.
The graphic at the beginning shows the date as 3/2001 the actual date was 3/2010; I LOVE all the Videos! However, I prefer the old text descriptors over the new narration, keep the fantastic videos coming, Thanks!
Nice job but love the old format, that's what makes the channel unique. I see you only like the positive comments here but don't take it personally brother, be grateful that people tell you what they like. I'been a long time subscriber.
It's not good to generalize either. He can't please everyone. When I'm working, I like some background noise. It's difficult to watch a video with subtitles and work at the same time. At least he's appealing to individuals who would like to do something else while listening to the story.
I'd just like to mention that I LOVE this format. I like the text format too but when I'm working from home and would like to listen to something in the background, this format is much more preferable. Thank you for appealing to all members of your audience!
I find myself having to concentrate harder with this new format. Thanks for all your efforts, but I find the old style more involving. Really appreciate your channel, thank you!
well to be honest i like the old one, the old one has the tense, i can feel the sadness from the back sound too. this ver feels like you are the news anchor. keep up the good work bud!
Those stupid mistakes really piss me off . I’m no pilot but come on . Crashing a perfectly functioning plane ....those people shouldn’t of died . Horrible .
Let me know what you think about this new video format. I worked so hard on it.
Also, I just noticed a small mistake at the beginning of the video. It's 2010, not 2001. Sorry about that. 😊
Thank you so much for your channel. It’s my best channel. ☺️
I’m sorry if you find this offensive but I liked the old one better except for when you said the full names of the pilots
Yes im sorry. The old one is better. So much feels
Old format please.
First of all you dont have to be sorry about the mistake you did we are humans we make mistakes and your content is amazing
You did a great job making this video BUT I must say that I liked the text better. The "quiet" in the video made it super scary and more realistic. Hearing just the aircraft and pilots conversation is much more interesting for me.
Agreed
Agree!
I agree. I was like wtf when I heard voices
Agreed. I also think it would help to not have the text and the narration contradict each other with the text showing that this flight was flown years before the narration says that the airplane was manufactured. :-/ Whoops.
And also the quiet one is better if you watch the video while eating. You can chew without risk of missing out on information.
I'm not feeling the audio explanation of this particular crash. I prefer the old format used previously.
I agree.
yes, way better without voice over.
I have to agree. The voiceover isn't necessarily an improvement. (And please do have someone proofread all on-screen notes.)
I like the CGI dramatization of the plane crashs .. it's way better than this narrative .. this is boring as hell 😏
Absolutely agree.
Damn, you can call that 9 years old Boy lucky, but he lost his whole Family in that crash. What an Aftermath... I read he lives with his uncle in the Netherlands now. May the Family of this brave Boy rest in peace.
Yes, lucky he survived.....
Finally i can eat lunch freely without eating and reading the descriptions. Great job!
kaimanson K right!?😹💕
you eat while people dying?
My thoughts exactly Ma'am .
I read while eating all the time. I prefer the texts, especially during those times I must watch with no or low sound and I don't have any headphones. *turns video off*
You can't eat and read at the same time?
The narration was good however I do prefer the old format with reading the subtitles
Edit: I think he narrated because I think new RUclips rules state you have to commentate on videos for them to be monetised or something along those lines :/
Ya same
That could also be just at the start of the video, I wouldnt mind that actually. But throughout the rest of the video I prefer the old concept. And by looking at the reactions, a lot of us do.
What? That's absurd.
Just hybrid the two formats you'll do fine having narration will probably help pick up new viewers who don't want to read but there is something cool about just hearing the aircraft and the flight crew. what I don't get is why this pilot no Matter how tired and distracted would just noise it into the ground when they were already on a go around
I really don’t think there is any such rule, that wouldn’t make any sense.
omg you changed the format. It was great but i prefer the original because it had a different feel to it. I know you worked so hard so i dont want to seem ungreatful its still amazing and ill never stop watching xxx
i dont want to seem ungrateful*
Wtf is wrong with my phone
I agree I kinda miss the old music and style! This video was very well made but I originally subscribed because of the original format
I agree too!
Really appreciate the effort on making it more dynamic, but the format with captions is more interesting.
Good job anyway, amazing video as usual
“I lIkEd ThE oLd FoRmAt MoRe”
With larger subtitles, previous version is good
I, for one, really enjoyed your narration. Your voice is clear, even, and easy to listen to. Your explanations are easy to understand. You've put a lot of time and effort into this and it shows.
It seems I am in the minority as many other viewers seem to prefer no audio narration.
Perhaps a good compromise would be to narrate only two portions of the animations:
- The beginning... giving a brief summary of the plane info, pilot info, and flight plan.
- The end... the explanation of the crash report and the lasting impact the crash had on the industry, etc.
This way, the combination of music and sound effects can continue to create the suspenseful moments up to and during the crash. It is a unique aspect to your videos we have all grown to love and enjoy.
The pilots 'felt'? What happened to looking at the instruments? "Hey, John, it feels like we're too high." "No, it feels too low to me." "Look at the instruments." "Instruments? What are instruments?" "Those little round things in front of us." "Oh, I always wondered what those were."
It baffles me how 3 IFR rated pilots can misread their position this badly.
Somatogravic illusion gives a very powerful sensation in this case as if the aircraft was pitching up, it has happened many times during go-arounds with no visibility (e.g. Flydubai 981), it is apparently quite difficult to overcome your need to put the nose down by convincing your own brain that your inner ear is transmitting false signals. Moreover, landing is often the most stressful part of a flight, especially with low visibility and poor approach systems, you also have a very short amount of time to react, and possibly the pilot perceived a false horizon. All these things have to be taken into account.
I watch all of your videos. Prefer the original format and music. If you keep this format please go back to original music
Yes.. His old music is awesome.. I totally agree.. The music with the text made it good to watch
@@ghost.protocol Agreed. I LOVE the music.
Map , graphic and video demonstrations are very good but sorry I dont like voice presentation
Cenk Köse then turn the sound off and the captions on 😂
I like the suspense of the old videos. Keeps you guessing where they make the mistakes. This formats ok but I like the old ones better.
SullyC mectoo
SullyC q
you are on the right track with this format!!
stay the course, no transition is easy.
you are setting yourself apart from the rest of the pack.
the production is much more digestible for a broader audience.
i think it’s just wonderful in every way. you really got something with this!
I thought I was in the wrong place when the narration started!
Me too
I paused to check the channel thinking I was in the wrong place also :-D
Old format with Old branded music, starting from departure airport was best for me.
Missing Music
@Paul Kersey You still killing thugs that run in your neighborhood PAUL?
Agree ,stand by Kedar..miss the music
música para qué. Qué obsesión con la gente que no puede estar sin música,hasta en un velorio
Is that the sad music playing ?? I want the song
Oooowaayooooooohhhh
I didn’t mind the narration but I will say this! it’s far more intense, anxiety inducing and sad with just the text.
I prefer the verbal narration.
I prefer verbal narration.
I can also pause to learn some flight procedures in detail and know what was the real cause of the error!
I agree, Jack.
Get someone to proof-read the text.
Appreciate your efforts but I liked the text version than this....😊
had a certain feel to it
@@98723asf agree....It built certain amount of tension which was missing in this one.
Me too
Thank you for the audio. I’m sight impaired and cannot read all the videos with text. Wish you had more like this
There was a reverence and respect in the silence, given that the vid predominantly about tragic loss of life.
No emotion superimposed, only the viewer’s emotion.
And cockpit communication are very important. “In their own words”.
the other format is better, and what you say it's true, it gives more reverence to those who died
Larry..well said!!
Well put.I respond better to visual info .Guess it comes from mum.ARE YOU LISTENING?
@@grantjohnston5817 no it does not, it depends on the nature of each of us
? r e visual info
As I said before, I personally love the older format, but either way, I want you to know we subs love all your videos , either way ! Very very professionally made! Now that we do get to hear your voice, however, now curious minds want to know, where are you from originally. I have lived all over, traveling with my husband in the military, I cannot place your dialect, but the accent is quite lovely. Thanks for all your hard work!
Sounds like a Dutch accent to me. I agree it's very easy on the ear.
I personally prefer the videos without a voiceover, but you’re always explaining everything very well, no matter whether it’s written or spoken.
Copilot = The plane will crashed
Pilot = its ok
Calvin sebastian What
Non-native speaker of English like me!
Your voice is soo relaxing and peaceful. Why didn't you talk in the videos before?
I was wondering what ppl would say. I like it.
Good question
Roldyk Rojas exactly
When you're in doubt, GO AROUND!!!
noooo, it costs profits and earnigns for the shareholders! land faster!
@@mikumikuiyada lol
poorly trained crew actually.. fly KLM
They eventually were in doubt and did attempt a go-around, just not successfully.
Today I did a ILS to minimums at Chicago Midway airport. It was too foggy so I went around. On the second approach we saw the approach lights and descended 100 feet above touch down zone elevation. Then we saw the runway and landed. A routine leg on a routine day. Try to keep off The Flight Channel except as a spectator. FLY SAFE! FLY DISCIPLINED! (KLM also flies Tripoli to Amsterdam. Pay the extra money and arrive alive!
It’s nice to hear your voice. You sound good, and narrated well. Thanks for the great content!
Love and watched all your videos man! But I gotta say I personally prefer the older format of just music and subtitles. You get to really focus on the scenes and the situation more, at least for me. How about adding subtitles along with your voice-over?
I agree
Agreed
Quite opposite. When you have to read the text you can't really focus on the scenes and events. The narrated version is way more easier to follow than the "subtitled only" format.
Love the narration! However i still like it with the subtitles despite the clear audio
Me too bro!
Me too
Shows your dedication, but like the others, i love the previous format. But, WTF, this crew had made the SAME mistake before, went unreported and then did it AGAIN, killing everyone except for 1 child??? Holy hell!
Adwaid S Kumar hey bro!
Just turn on "CC" in the lower right corner. You will get subtitles. It's not that hard.
Somehow liked the previous format a lot better, I enjoyed the 2nd half of the vid more. Great work.
hollywood0770 it’s like having the best of both worlds, I think he did it this way to keep the old format people happy and the voice over in the first part for the change is good crew
OMG that was fantastic... absolutely LOVED hearing your voice... really hoping you do more of these ... well done well articulated. much love and respect from Scotland xoxox
1:55 lol he didn't even try pronouncing his last name
I don't like the new format of the video
I'd prefer the old one with sentences instead of voices.
Most of the people are better when reading a sentence, not listening to an audio.
This looks like a podcast instead of a Flight Investigation..
We appreciate all your efforts and hard work. We too prefer the old text format, as opposed to the voice over. The audio, at least on my computer speakers, has too much bass, or low frequency response. We always look forward to your brilliant productions; they are extremely helpful in understand the complex world of commercial aviation. Bob
Not fond of the voiceover. I liked the old format better.
I flew with Afriqiyah from London on that route a few months before that, including flight number 771 on the return leg. I'd been so impressed with every aspect of my flying experience - including a spanking new A330 between Tripoli, Johannesburg and return - that I had no hesitation in choosing them to fly London - Dhaka and back a few weeks later. On the return leg from Dhaka I was even given a free upgrade to Business class! The only downside was the sorry state of Tripoli Airport at the time, but a big shiny new terminal was under construction, due to open not long afterwards. My blood ran cold when I heard the news. I still had the stub of my boarding pass for Flight 771. Worse was to follow not long after, with Libya being reduced to chaos by war. Last I heard Tripoli Airport was still closed. BTW, Afriqiyah Airways didn't have the livery shown in the video at that time.
The flight channel videos are very good. Full information, on flight details, Crew names, what exactly happens while in air, and complete analysis, and final conclusions. Excellent sir, keep it up.
I loved the older format... Something about the music you chose that told the story perfectly.
Agreed
This reflects a loss of scanning ability that comes from relying on automation. Pilots are losing their manual flying skills. Did they not check their altitude over the final approach fix??? Bust their minimums, and were fooled by the Go Around sensations of acceleration that proficient instrument flying would have overcome.
I've got very lazy with navication in my care coz of phone GPS, but hopefully I wouldnt' let that happen if flying a passenger jet with responsibility for hundreds of lives
I find the voice narration distracting
There is something unique and amazing about your older style... written words, as opposed to audio translation.
I enjoy listening to podcasts, but when I watch the flight Channel, I mostly look forward to the music and reading the story.
This is very well made but I also prefer the old format. The text and the music blended so well together. Runway map was a good addition.
This is a most instructive series. Thank you.
Definitely something different, it is pretty cool to have a voice over, but I like the subtitles a bit better. I think it will be cool once in a while. You did a great job on the voice over, keep up the great work!
Music and captions format was much better.
I love it📸📸📸📸📸📸📸💿📀🔭📼💶
0:36 there you have an error dude, is 2010 not 2001
Yeah, I'm sorry about that.
Hey buddy, I have watched almost all of your videos, now I came across this one and I have to say: This format is FAR BETTER than the other one you use. Just using texts is bad to retain attention (too much information to read), and after watching this video I felt the combination of narration + visuals + texts on display is much better. I hope you narrate future videos.
I LIKE VOICE narration. this way, I can just listen and focus on watching the plane. not having to place one eye on the text and the other eye on the plane at the same time.
I prefer text over voice. however still great job! Keep up!
Me too, as I am hearing impaired.
@@edwardmolen5127 same here!!
Turn subtitles on
Dear tfc, i love to watch your old format. The old format was really awesome video with the very matching background music. Moreover my friend is deaf person, he couldnt hear your voice in new format, he only can read subtitle. For sure so many people same like him. Please continue the old version dear. Really appreciate for your action. Thank you 😊
It is a balanced combination of voice and text, and great quality of simulations/images.
I like it much - top work!
You had us there, I was convinced this would be a "survivor"
17,000 flight hours and the captain still managed to screw that up.
You're correct. However he only had just over 500 hrs on that type of plane
I guess modern planes practically fly themselves, otherwise so stupid and incompetent that you wonder how he lasted that long. Of all the causes they didn't mention recruiting, training and monitoring of pilots as a major cause, because pilots like this simply should not be allowed to fly passenger planes and it would be easy to detect if better monitoring and training was in place.
@@partytill10 you guys did not get the impression that the pilot was micro managing the copilot instead of the plane's altitude?, why let a copilot do the landing if youare going to final decide to land or abort?
The editing is amazing!!!!! Wonderful job!!
I like your voiceover as well :) But would it be possible to add subtitles for videos when you do voiceovers? I think it would be easier to follow ^-^
Honestly, well done, everything looks awesome!!!!
Great job on the video man, a lot of work goes into this type of video and its appreciated.i must say that the old format is what I’d personally prefer.so much detail in the text and easy to imagine it with the way you lay it out. Thank you again for getting me hooked on aviation 🇨🇮🇨🇮
This video is absolutely great! It’s very nice to see you trying new things like the voiceover or the graphics! Keep going, your channel is awesome :)
The new format is great. You continue to do an amazing job. Thank you for all the hard work.
Do not get discouraged by the reply comments that criticize the new format. It is a personal preference and in all honesty, you did ask which way your viewers prefer. So, we simply let you know which way we like better. Me personally, I’d still watch either way. The videos are great.thank you.
You have no idea how much I love this channel. It's amazing.
I prefer the old format. The subtitles only allow me to use more of my own imagination in recreating the experience in my mind.
I love how you’re experimenting with new video formats, love your videos always!
I think I prefer without the voice over though, just the music and the subtitles create such an immersive experience which I think is perfect for these air crash investigations.
Always looking forward to new videos :)
Thank you for all your hard work, but i prefer the text version over this narrated version.
Me too
You have obviously put a great deal of time and effort into this video and it’s good, but sorry, I have to say I prefer the old style. For me there was more tension build up and emotion.
Can't believe no one caught the typo in the date at the beginning of the video. It was written as 2001 but is actually 2010.
Dear Flight Channel. I THOUROUGHLY enjoyed the fact that out of your MANY videos, this is the 1st time I did not have to READ the story, but could in fact LISTEN to the STORY. PLEASE. MORE NARRATIONS!! I LOVE that FORMAT! I'm so busy that I always miss critical information by taking my eyes off the screen, but hearing it has changed it for me... KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!! Apparently, I'm one of the FEW of many that enjoy the voiceover.. Perhaps you can make BOTH?!?!? Just a thought (Since you can't please everyone- hahaha).
Not sure about the voiceover, although it was synced and articulated well, maybe I’m just use to hearing my own voice in my head while reading your script. The music is also synced to the video for a nice effect but a bit too happy for such a tragic incident. The jury is still out on this one with the
v/o.🤷🏻♂️
Keep up the great work!
Prefer the old format. More detail retention with reading text. New music is awful and actually sounds happy in places.
Hi friend,
Good to see you with technical efforts ,cheers
Please do NOT go back to the old format. The voice over is waaaay better and I don’t have to stop looking at the scene to read what’s going on! Please continue with this format and don’t worry about what all the other people are saying about they liked the old format better, they just don’t like change.
Include CVR audio and this format will be amazing
Like air crash investigation, but better and without the Hollywood dramatization
Great video but I still prefer the subtitles even though the audio quality was really good.
I love the new format! And I’ve always liked the way you change photo to photo in time with the music. That’s a level of drama this kind of video needs. Great job! 👍😊
There's no channel I'd click so fast on notifications from. Also the voice over is amazing
Btw how's the intro music called? Thanks in advance
Tomas Kilian The track is Kevin Graham - Boundary
The graphics are exceptional, but I think the old format suits this type of videos better..You can really immerse into the atmosphere of the flight, you make some kind of connection..anyway,
we all love your work..keep it up! :D
Dear owner of the flight channel I just love your videos and the way you explained all the crashes in your previous videos , none of the other channel did the same way..There is a little request I want to make that if you will read this please I want you to go back to the old format in which you used to include texts instead of voice it actually creates a kind of suspense and it make investigation even more interesting ..I still like your video and I really appreciate your hardwork you are doing a great , brilliant job but its a request if you can make videos with the text not voices than I will be very very thankful to you...And thankyou once again for doing such a hard work for us .
Nope !
I still prefer with subtitles..
I think it would be great to have both. I enjoyed being able to listen to the video without having to constantly watch the screen while I was getting ready for work. It would be nice to keep subtitles for the hearing impaired.
@@deeanna8448 offc but the problem is that there's no more sound of an aircraft, there's no more intensity like before with music etc..Just documentary..
@@Anna-ym5mh that's true too. It seems most people like the original format better. I'll watch either way!
Ahh the craftsmanship on the video, the detail and time put into this video. Thanks for making these videos!
Sorry to say this, but I never like the new format. I missed the old format, which is more serious and dramatic with the background and subtitles rumbling throughout the videos, despite your clear audio.
This new format have lost its serious mood of the story. I didn't like that. Old format was way better than that.
👏👏
I like the old format. Your work is amazing but subtitles without voice over is much better.
You do GREAT work! Loved the animations and even the voice over, it was great. You can tell you put a lot of work into it. Honest opinion - sure I like the old format as well but it was very refreshing to watch this new format. I suppose I preference the old format but would absolutely love to have a few this new format thrown in every now and then too. You do awesome work man. Many thank yous.
Re-upload?
Wow. That was brilliant and so well explained. Thank you for posting. RIP those on board.
Its a good video but i much preferred subtitled videos. Thank you for the upload!
Friend, when I first turned the video on and heard a voice, I thought I had stumbled onto someone else's channel. It was great as are all your videos; put together very well and with good visuals. However, like many rock bands out there, sometimes it can be good to branch from your roots, but not always. Point is, stick to your original formula. It works. Among many different videos of this nature, there is something about yours that draws me in. I find that I pay much more attention when there is no dialog, but just subtitles and calming music. Even better when you can hear the real radio transmissions. It really sticks and really keeps me attended. And its why I certainly enjoy watching these. I know you put a lot of work into them. And it shows.
BTW, are you going to get around to doing some on Flight 800 (1996), the Air France Concord disater, the Potamic River crash, and one years ago when the plane flipped on landing and cart-wheeled down the runway? There were survivors on that one. And please excuse me, as I don't remember the flight names or numbers of these particular accidents. Would enjoy seeing your take on them.
Thank you for talking during the video, older people have trouble reading the print.Thanks again.
I can BARELY tell that English isn't your native tongue. It sounds really, really good. Bravo.
What is his native language?
Personally, i prefer to hear the aircraft sounds, rather than the voice-over.
I actually like both formats. You have a very pleasant voice so your new format has my ultimate vote. I can't imagine how hard you work to put these videos out every week. Thank you.
im so f*cking scared of flying yet i keep watching these
Same bro
Oh me too! I worked in international insurance in the City of London, and I helped to insure airlines. Also assisted with their (usually huge) insurance claims. Seeing how crashes happened in the confidential reports has made me totally scared of flying.
Playford Seven oh honey i have a better life than you on any day
Playford Seven you should get a life you’re the one trolling 14 year olds on youtube
@@mlol6000 Haha, can't see the other guy's comments but I guess you won xD
This is by far the best I've seen. It surpasses your past efforts if that is possible.
The production value is immense. The music is fantastic and the audio is superior.
The voice is excellent, commanding you to listen, spoken with authority yet still sensitive.
Timber and accent are delightful.
Don't change a thing friend.
I've too have seen many of your past productions, and enjoyed them immensely.
Don't give in and listen to all who say your past is superior.
People get accustomed to things. It takes time to transition to a new experience.
Loosen up people shake off the chains of familiarity and habit.
Let's explore this new format. I find it has more dimensions, I don't need to read subtitles and therefore can sink deeper into the drama unfolding in front of me.
Please don't get discouraged friend.
It's Good. It's very Good.
put tex in some where
I think the voiceover / music choices & timing made this less suspenseful than usual
I really like you voice, but the old format seems more dramatic and can brought us in the real situation than this. Just my opinion bro, I appreciate your hardwork. keep it up 😉
I like the other style better, I hope you make both video styles.
Appreciate your efforts. The previous version of titles and music is better than the new voice version. Thank you for your continuous efforts for making this channel better and better.
The graphic at the beginning shows the date as 3/2001 the actual date was 3/2010; I LOVE all the Videos! However, I prefer the old text descriptors over the new narration, keep the fantastic videos coming, Thanks!
Nice job but love the old format, that's what makes the channel unique. I see you only like the positive comments here but don't take it personally brother, be grateful that people tell you what they like. I'been a long time subscriber.
It's not good to generalize either. He can't please everyone. When I'm working, I like some background noise. It's difficult to watch a video with subtitles and work at the same time. At least he's appealing to individuals who would like to do something else while listening to the story.
Great I love your vids also rip da people.Your the best that voice tho. Also this is the first comment.
I love the new voice
And excellent work
Keep it up
Thanx for giving me a 💓
@10 subs with no videos where you said "I got 20 subs"
And
"We both are same"
@10 subs with no videos Adam air 574
The flight channel
@10 subs with no videos same 😂
@10 subs with no videos I like your profile pic
I'd just like to mention that I LOVE this format. I like the text format too but when I'm working from home and would like to listen to something in the background, this format is much more preferable. Thank you for appealing to all members of your audience!
I find myself having to concentrate harder with this new format. Thanks for all your efforts, but I find the old style more involving. Really appreciate your channel, thank you!
I like the deep details about the airport and the runway , that’s really awesome , I hope we can see all the next videos like that
Great job 👍🏻👍🏻
well to be honest i like the old one, the old one has the tense, i can feel the sadness from the back sound too. this ver feels like you are the news anchor.
keep up the good work bud!
I live the flight channel ,the old format , text and music were perfect , please don't keep this format it's not the same
Those stupid mistakes really piss me off . I’m no pilot but come on . Crashing a perfectly functioning plane ....those people shouldn’t of died . Horrible .
I lived in Tripoli for six years and feel extREMEly fortunate to have survived flights in and outta that hell hole.