Top Ten Saddest Star Wars Scenes / Moments - Star Geek

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 окт 2024
  • For this Top Ten episode, I took to Twitter and Facebook to hear what you wanted! I count down the saddest moments from the saga.
    "Intrepid" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
    creativecommons...
    SUBSCRIBE to Star Geek for WEEKLY Star Wars content!
    Facebook: www.facebook.c...
    Twitter: / stargeekyt
    Factor Beam BB-8: • Star Wars Factor Beam,...
    Top Ten ANH Scenes: • Top Ten Scenes from Ep...

Комментарии • 1,8 тыс.

  • @Xxbte96xX
    @Xxbte96xX 8 лет назад +212

    Number 1 hurts so much more after watching Star Wars The Clone Wars show.

    • @TheBenjaman
      @TheBenjaman 8 лет назад +3

      Yes, and also the death of vader/anakin

    • @WaterxWolfx100
      @WaterxWolfx100 8 лет назад +17

      It also made the deaths of the other Jedi much sadder for me as well, because we got to know so many of them

    • @TheBenjaman
      @TheBenjaman 8 лет назад +3

      Wolfie100 yes. they did an amazing job with building those jedi up, and then they are suddenly gone.

    • @wildmantis6614
      @wildmantis6614 6 лет назад

      Number 1 would hurt if you had never even heard of star wars before, that was the best...and worst scene ever recorded

    • @cozyluvjo8104
      @cozyluvjo8104 4 года назад +1

      Omlll yes because u see what anakin and obi wan went through together they were like brothers and he had no choice

  • @friedraVen
    @friedraVen 8 лет назад +329

    Yesss finally a star wars geek who´s not hating the prequels like crazy ^^

    • @kitvos2615
      @kitvos2615 8 лет назад +4

      Ain't that a good thing

    • @brookeshea8569
      @brookeshea8569 7 лет назад +21

      raVen I agree I saw The Phantom Menace recently and it was actually pretty good I know the rest of the prequels are pretty good too. I guess it's just people hate Jar Jar for no reason

    • @pigtasticpigtures7825
      @pigtasticpigtures7825 7 лет назад +23

      raVen agreed. I love the prequels. More than originals. Good to see this.

    • @JoshuaWSiegel
      @JoshuaWSiegel 7 лет назад +7

      Rewatched TPM, and actually liked it (although still not fond of Jar Jar). AOTC I'm not high on, but ROTS is my favorite of all 7.

    • @sofa5950
      @sofa5950 7 лет назад +2

      raVen I really don't like the prequels but they had some really, really great moments if you watch them

  • @ChocolateisIsNice
    @ChocolateisIsNice 8 лет назад +373

    Obi Wan's death is probably even more sad when you've seen the Prequels.

  • @TheGamerCrewofXbox
    @TheGamerCrewofXbox 8 лет назад +148

    That edit of Darth Vader hearing Obi-Wans words is a million times better than any special edition change

    • @spearfisherman308
      @spearfisherman308 5 лет назад +13

      I also think adding padmes voice where she's begging him to come back would also drive home the sense that Luke is one of the last things vader has of padme

    • @hooman999
      @hooman999 4 года назад

      True

    • @nicholasmahoney7820
      @nicholasmahoney7820 2 года назад

      I'm a casual Star Wars fan, not a purist.
      Yet somehow, that edit in this video made me tear up...

  • @lukeskywaiker2995
    @lukeskywaiker2995 8 лет назад +210

    If you watch the Prequels obi wans and Yodas deaths are more emotional

    • @randomthoughts6519
      @randomthoughts6519 6 лет назад +6

      Luke SkyWaIker your sister was very disappointed in you.

    • @thanos7073
      @thanos7073 5 лет назад +5

      Random Thoughts sweet home Alabama

    • @NorthSmile8089
      @NorthSmile8089 4 года назад +4

      Those aren’t the prequels

    • @Eiko-tt9ng
      @Eiko-tt9ng 4 года назад +2

      Even more emotional if you’ve seen all of the clone wars

    • @katblox5008
      @katblox5008 4 года назад +1

      Hi there my son

  • @oblebrun
    @oblebrun 4 года назад +41

    My top 5
    5. Padme’s funeral
    4. Han’s death
    3. Anakin turning into Vader while Padme was giving Birth and dying of sadness
    2. Order 66
    1. Anakin’s BBQ
    0. All of Jar Jars’s scenes

    • @SHOOPY2021
      @SHOOPY2021 4 года назад +1

      What About The Droid Attack On The Wookiees? HOW DARE YOU DIDNT PUT VADERS DEATH but you and I have opinions and I can respect that

    • @robloxisnotcoolhaha9002
      @robloxisnotcoolhaha9002 4 года назад +1

      lol number 1

  • @tricknickmedia
    @tricknickmedia 8 лет назад +163

    What about when Shmi Skywalker died right in front of her son Anakin. I thought that should have been at least top 3. Anakin hasn't seen his mother for ten years and when he finally reunites with her, she died shortly after. A really emotional scene to me one of the biggest influences of why Anakin went to the dark side. He hated that feeling of failing to save her. He promised to do whatever it took to not fail again which eventually led him to the dark side.

    • @kirtan_singh
      @kirtan_singh 8 лет назад +4

      That was a good scene

    • @stasikatr
      @stasikatr 8 лет назад +2

      I totally agree. That was a really sad scene.

    • @Ace_of_Horns
      @Ace_of_Horns 8 лет назад

      yah i forgot about that, that should've been in there

    • @andreskeever9887
      @andreskeever9887 8 лет назад +1

      I literally cried

    • @khayree7929
      @khayree7929 8 лет назад

      +Nick Lim actually, his biggest influence was padme dying at birth

  • @barbaro267
    @barbaro267 8 лет назад +84

    I agree with #1. I love Revenge of the Sith because the downfall of Anakin was set in stone, knowing the way the story goes in the original trilogy. For Anakin to fall, there had to be betrayal, hatred, pain, and pure emotion, and goshdarnit, we got it and more! The final film in the prequels was so much darker than any of the other 5 films. It was the finale, the ending to Anakin's descent to the dark side. We saw him grow up in slavery, lose his mother, and slowly become seduced by the temptations of the dark side due to his fears of losing his wife. There was so much bad in his life, and even the prophesy on his side didn't make his life any better. The counsel of the Jedi Order continually limited and held Anakin back, which conflicted with his desire to be more and do more, and ultimately led to him disowning it and embracing the dark side. People who hate the prequels miss the moments in the films that carried the emotions and characters well into the original trilogy, being Obi Wan, Yoda, and Darth Vader (not so much Palps...he doesn't change much lol).

    • @BiIIyLoomis
      @BiIIyLoomis 8 лет назад

      +barbaro267 It was the best in the prequel saga, but holy shit it was still bad.

    • @kitvos2615
      @kitvos2615 8 лет назад +8

      +Baraco Barner the prequels weren't even that bad. People need to calm down and just think about what makes it good for once. Just picture yourself watching the prequels as if the original trilogy didn't exist; would it be good then?

    • @elijahgipper1837
      @elijahgipper1837 6 лет назад

      1 2 and 3 are better then 6 and 3 is better then 4

    • @Jdudec367
      @Jdudec367 6 лет назад

      what about 5?

    • @goldenstatewarriors9418
      @goldenstatewarriors9418 5 лет назад

      @@Jdudec367 Empire Strikes Back is a different level.

  • @dionr1168
    @dionr1168 8 лет назад +20

    The Duel on Mustafar, while being one of my favorite lightsaber duels, would have to be my saddest scene because the dialogue both immediately before and after shows you just how much Anakin's fall to the Dark Side hurt his wife, his mentor and best friend, and ultimately himself, and how he had to live with the consequences of his choice to fall for Palpatine's lies for the rest of his life.

    • @dionr1168
      @dionr1168 4 года назад

      @Anton Saiko I also forgot to mention this; because of those consequences, his choice to turn on Palpatine to save his son cost him his life.

  • @Remkits
    @Remkits 8 лет назад +99

    My Top 10:
    10: Anakins Mothers Death
    9: Force Connecting
    8: Obi Wans farewell
    7: Darth Vaders Death
    6: Sacrifice of an Ewok
    5: Slaughter of the Younglings
    4: Order 66
    3: Padme's Death
    2: Han Solo's Death
    1: Obi Wans Farewell to Anakin

    • @thatoneguymatt987
      @thatoneguymatt987 4 года назад +16

      Happiest Star Wars Scenes :
      5. Slaughter of the Younglings
      4. Slaughter of the Younglings
      3. Slaughter of the Younglings
      2. Slaughter of the Younglings
      1. Slaughter of the Younglings

    • @meritmanman1794
      @meritmanman1794 4 года назад +3

      ChodeMaster where’s 99s death
      Or fives or heavy huh those were tragic

    • @stopmotionhq9743
      @stopmotionhq9743 4 года назад

      I hated padme

    • @madtitanthanos7898
      @madtitanthanos7898 4 года назад +2

      @@thatoneguymatt987 as long as the Ice Age Baby was a Youngling Anakin is a hero

    • @lil_frankster6959
      @lil_frankster6959 4 года назад

      Where is kanan jarrus

  • @StarWarsNerdyGuy
    @StarWarsNerdyGuy 8 лет назад +33

    'The only time my eyes ever welled up with tears in the Star Wars saga (I don't know why it's the only time) was on Padme's death. It may be forced, but the music and the reactions of baby Luke and Leia and even Darth Vader made it for me. Everyone says Darth Vader's "NOOOOO" is cheezy, but sorry! I was too busy FEELING for Darth Vader's loss of the one thing he could not live without.

  • @tomaslpg
    @tomaslpg 4 года назад +12

    A really sad and underrated moment is when Obi-Wan painfully says to Anakin "I have failed you"

  • @AroAceGamer
    @AroAceGamer 8 лет назад +168

    I'm surprised that the death of Anakin's mother isn't on the list. That scene was one of the saddest and most emotional in the saga.

    • @harrybruh5314
      @harrybruh5314 8 лет назад +2

      it's not for me

    • @harrybruh5314
      @harrybruh5314 8 лет назад

      ***** yup it wasn't,cause it's too short

    • @mushybagel5286
      @mushybagel5286 8 лет назад +2

      We barely knew her I didn't feel really anything, probably just cuz I don't carw

    • @LeonorFontes
      @LeonorFontes 8 лет назад

      +NoSheetSherlock Me to 😥😢

    • @LeonorFontes
      @LeonorFontes 8 лет назад

      +LeonorFontes *too

  • @realdarthrevan
    @realdarthrevan 8 лет назад +261

    Saddest Scene: When Jar Jar Binks is introduced.

  • @brookeshea8569
    @brookeshea8569 7 лет назад +38

    Obi-wan's farewell to Anakin: "YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!"

  • @benjaminroe1375
    @benjaminroe1375 8 лет назад +8

    Hearing Obi-Wan's speech during that Revenge of the Sith scene was incredible!!! Absolutely moving. That's how i'll probably always view that scene now

  • @CloneSquadConversations
    @CloneSquadConversations 8 лет назад +44

    Was #6 JUST because of order "66"

    • @969dramstik
      @969dramstik 6 лет назад +1

      Clone Squad Conversations lmao you have 6 likes

    • @BS-rm1hv
      @BS-rm1hv 6 лет назад

      lucas tomas moreno roman now 7

    • @goldenstatewarriors9418
      @goldenstatewarriors9418 5 лет назад

      20 now

    • @sachamnc17
      @sachamnc17 4 года назад +1

      For me, this is the saddest scene with the immolation scene (and Anakin's betrayal is my favorite movie's music).

  • @zAquilaa
    @zAquilaa 7 лет назад +50

    If the title was correct then the death of Fives and the leaving of Ashoka would be on the list

    • @jasonskeans3327
      @jasonskeans3327 5 лет назад +5

      Or fives 99 death

    • @Adrianrafael04
      @Adrianrafael04 5 лет назад +7

      Twitter AquilaXBL Fives death was the saddest death ever. No question about that.

    • @goldenstatewarriors9418
      @goldenstatewarriors9418 5 лет назад +1

      Yeah this clearly only included films. Otherwise Ahsoka leaving Anakin would be on the list (in my opinion, the Anakin-Ahsoka relationship was better then Anakin & Padme) . Fives would probably be tied with order 66, which should be much higher on the list. Also Ahsoka refusing to leave Anakin again in rebels would be there. For me #1 will always be Mustafar.

    • @therubygauntlet
      @therubygauntlet 4 года назад

      Yeah I agree, especially Ahsoka’s leaving. It was a great list but I really think scenes from the clone wars should have been included

    • @LW-cb7ep
      @LW-cb7ep 3 года назад

      @@Adrianrafael04 Yes.

  • @walkingsteak4134
    @walkingsteak4134 8 лет назад +80

    Every main character should be dead if storm troopers actually hit things.

  • @randomboy3316
    @randomboy3316 8 лет назад +28

    This is like the best channel Ever made u need to be the king of youtube

  • @potato4534
    @potato4534 8 лет назад +370

    You deserve way more subs

    • @StarGeek
      @StarGeek  8 лет назад +9

      +Hayden Hemstreet Thank you!

    • @ideologicallyindependent1222
      @ideologicallyindependent1222 8 лет назад +11

      +StarGeek I cried when I saw Jar jar in the originals :(

    • @StarGeek
      @StarGeek  8 лет назад +6

      +Lian Marzari You're right... THAT was the saddest scene.

    • @mannydanner1144
      @mannydanner1144 8 лет назад +1

      +StarGeek can You do top 10 Clones

    • @mannydanner1144
      @mannydanner1144 8 лет назад +2

      +StarGeek I cried when darth maul died

  • @shiftyshapers
    @shiftyshapers 4 года назад +8

    YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE!
    YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO DESTROY THE SITH NOT JOIN THEM!
    BRING BALANCE TO THE FORCE NOT LEAVE IT IN DARKNESS!
    i hateeeee YOUUUUU
    You were my brother Anakin.
    I loved you.

  • @mauricioreyes7359
    @mauricioreyes7359 8 лет назад +5

    OMG you just made the Darth Vader scene between good and evil so much more emotional

  • @mimi-hy2re
    @mimi-hy2re 8 лет назад +7

    I actually cried when Padmé died, and Obi-Wan and Anakin had the duel on Mustafar.

  • @WilliamStephanusArriel
    @WilliamStephanusArriel 8 лет назад +45

    Luke is emotionless in #9.
    dont overhype it.
    when Hayden is stiff in acting they hate it (still quite acceptable)
    yet when Luke expresses nothing when his only family who raise him died. they call it powerful

    • @lukefish331
      @lukefish331 8 лет назад

      I think you mean physical bc this scene had the most emotion in the movie besides HSD

    • @RageAdvisor
      @RageAdvisor 8 лет назад +2

      Don't forget the word "opinion" in your vocabulary.

    • @KentKaliber
      @KentKaliber 8 лет назад +1

      +William Stephanus Mark Hamill's performance as Luke Skywalker will ALWAYS over-shadow the mediocrity of Hayden. And truth be told, it's more LucasFilm's fault than Hayden ---- every aspect of the Prequels is flawed --- making it impossible for the Anakin character to succeed in the faulty manner he is presented.

    • @munozali1
      @munozali1 8 лет назад

      +William Stephanus I always found that scene sad, but not so much because of Luke. It was more about Vader. You're right about Luke's reaction.

    • @barbaro267
      @barbaro267 8 лет назад +2

      +Kent Kaliber "every aspect of the prequels is flawed"...does not include the incredible CGI/special effects, powerful emotional scenes, intriguing lore to the Force, outstanding fight choreography, parallels/continuity with the original trilogy, great casting (more or less Hayden though), new and interesting villains, and overall darker tone. If you hate something that much, it only fails to YOU. But people like me are much less biased and can see the good moments in the prequels.

  • @rknisple
    @rknisple 6 лет назад +1

    That edit where obi wan was speaking to darth Vader in his mind while Luke was being shocked by the emperor was so powerful. You set it up absolutely perfectly. That made me actually tear up.

  • @monkeymax1134
    @monkeymax1134 8 лет назад +62

    Ewok death is the saddest death

    • @nilsalol6138
      @nilsalol6138 8 лет назад

      +Monkeymax11 Right.

    • @izzatirfan1995
      @izzatirfan1995 8 лет назад

      exactly

    • @maxrebo6750
      @maxrebo6750 8 лет назад +1

      I legitimately cried in that scene

    • @trannguyen-qy8sd
      @trannguyen-qy8sd 8 лет назад +3

      Jar Jar death is best death

    • @rubihoxd6797
      @rubihoxd6797 8 лет назад

      +Monkeymax11 I agree... my eyes teared.. bcos innocent ewoks wants to help the rebels and they died... they were just living happily until that happened... WAAAAaaaa!!! ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-;

  • @TheOneTruePesky
    @TheOneTruePesky 4 года назад +8

    Personally, Padme’s death is always the one that gets me.

    • @maddierchd1
      @maddierchd1 4 года назад

      Pesky same for me

    • @xetzy5853
      @xetzy5853 3 года назад

      its always sad

    • @eeurr1306
      @eeurr1306 2 года назад

      What really gets me is the funeral scene and anakins transformation together with her death and order 66 and anakins duel with obi wan.

  • @sebastianrahbek4931
    @sebastianrahbek4931 8 лет назад +49

    WTF THE SLAUGHTER OF THE YOUNGLINGS IS NOT EVEN ON, THE, FUCKING, LIST!! 3/5

    • @StarGeek
      @StarGeek  8 лет назад +3

      +Fisker John It's a runner up!

    • @StyroNo1
      @StyroNo1 8 лет назад +2

      +StarGeek doesn't it still count as order 66?

    • @StarGeek
      @StarGeek  8 лет назад +2

      +Steven Clavijo True, but since it was focused on, I kind of separated it.

    • @StyroNo1
      @StyroNo1 8 лет назад +1

      StarGeek Oh Ok

    • @O-revisor
      @O-revisor 8 лет назад +9

      From my point of view the younglings are evil

  • @lukasnilsson3015
    @lukasnilsson3015 7 лет назад +36

    order 66 where by far the sadest moment in my opinion

    • @wildmantis6614
      @wildmantis6614 6 лет назад +1

      I think it was second only to anakin and obi wans scene

    • @thanos7073
      @thanos7073 5 лет назад +1

      lukas nilsson especially the music

  • @RadimPokorny
    @RadimPokorny 5 лет назад +5

    For me the saddest funeral was Padmé, she loved Anakin from the first sight, loved him, planned everything and eventually died the hand of Darth Vader

  • @matthewsixx9040
    @matthewsixx9040 8 лет назад +1

    Padmès death will always make me tear up.
    Seriously the setting, the song, the neckless. But most of all, the final step for Anakin to become Vader.
    Always makes me sad and feel bad

  • @HMMadsen
    @HMMadsen 8 лет назад +8

    11:10 - 11:30 Holy shit I love it!

  • @carolinereese7161
    @carolinereese7161 8 лет назад

    Absolutely loved this video-my new favorite one on your channel!! The edit you made of Darth Vader's change from the dark side to the light with Obi-Wan's words in the background almost brought me to tears!! And whenever I see Anakin and Obi-Wan's final goodbye I can't help but tear up! Great Video!

  • @albam.tejada0512
    @albam.tejada0512 8 лет назад +5

    The first time I watched Revenge of The Sith I cried like a little baby at Anakin and Obi Wan's after-fight scene, it obviously has to be #1 👍🏾

  • @basicalllyyy6245
    @basicalllyyy6245 8 лет назад +2

    That editing at #1 when Obi-Wan was speaking as Vader watched Luke get tortured. That should have been in the movie it made me feel emotional

  • @kirtan_singh
    @kirtan_singh 8 лет назад +33

    I loved the force awakens but wouldn't mind if George returned for one episode or something

    • @WilliamStephanusArriel
      @WilliamStephanusArriel 8 лет назад +2

      too similar to a new hope

    • @johnwerner69
      @johnwerner69 8 лет назад

      No

    • @kirtan_singh
      @kirtan_singh 8 лет назад

      +William Stephanus yeah it was quite similar but it had a few differences

    • @kirtan_singh
      @kirtan_singh 8 лет назад

      +John Werner I just hope he comes back to share some of his thoughts and ideas

    • @johnwerner69
      @johnwerner69 8 лет назад

      +BLACKCURRENT like the midiclorians?

  • @practicaldeduction6862
    @practicaldeduction6862 8 лет назад +2

    Another good thing about Clone Wars is that it expanded on Obi-Wan and Anakin's friendship... if you watch Episode three with that it makes it even harder.

  • @liammatthews2183
    @liammatthews2183 8 лет назад +5

    Glad to have the prequels on here. I'm a fan of them and I'm happy you're not an OT elitist who craps on those who like the prequels :)

  • @CraftsAndMore111
    @CraftsAndMore111 7 лет назад +1

    I totally agree with that list. The Obiwan and Anakin goodbye makes me cry every time.

  • @lordthanatos3564
    @lordthanatos3564 7 лет назад +40

    You were my brother Anakin! High ground!
    Let me know If you got what I was referencing

    • @lordthanatos3564
      @lordthanatos3564 7 лет назад +3

      Alex Iguanero I'll give it to your son some day... if your wife survives... but it doesn't look like she will, from up here, ON THE HIGH GROUND!

    • @CarnageKiller-rx5yu
      @CarnageKiller-rx5yu 7 лет назад

      TheEdgyOnion you were referencing obi wan when he had the high ground and goodie tissues anakin had the low ground and obi wan told anakin that he was like a brother to him

    • @ishallneverregretthis
      @ishallneverregretthis 7 лет назад

      TheEdgyOnion Haha, i got it ;)

    • @lordthanatos3564
      @lordthanatos3564 7 лет назад

      +Darth Logan Mostly Robot Chicken too

    • @lordthanatos3564
      @lordthanatos3564 7 лет назад +1

      +Alex Iguanero It's not the high ground wa-- I mean the jedi way!

  • @eamonmorrissey8887
    @eamonmorrissey8887 8 лет назад

    I got chills when watching the Vader scene with the Obi Wan dialogue over it. Great video as well, keep up the good work.

  • @ary5368
    @ary5368 8 лет назад +32

    Where was Master Windu's death?
    Like honestly I cried during that scene, so sad D':

    • @patgogan7324
      @patgogan7324 8 лет назад +9

      I always felt that was more of a horror death than a sad one at least Mace went down fighting

    • @brookeshea8569
      @brookeshea8569 7 лет назад +3

      Yeah Mace put up a good fight against Palpatine

    • @liljakesspokesman3337
      @liljakesspokesman3337 7 лет назад

      Besty1201 Videos y

    • @Xxandrew01
      @Xxandrew01 7 лет назад +1

      I honestly feel that, Mace Windu got what he deserved for not following the Jedi way and trying to kill Palpatine and not taking him to trial.
      Now the one scene i'm wonder why the Hell it's not here, is the death of Anakin Skywalker's mother on Star Wars Episode 2 Attack Of The Clones.
      That scene was so sad, due to Anakin not seeing his mother in 10 years after Star Wars Episode 1 The Phantom Menace and the Jedi not doing a damn to help him see what is up with his mother and to see her go from near death to death in his arms was a fucked up thing. I was glad when he wiped out the adult Tusken's (Not the child Tusken's though) as what they did to her was fucked up. The scene where he is holding her in his arms and putting her into a sand grave makes it all the sadder and what makes this shit worse? He suffered the same fate with Padame in Star Wars Episode 3 Revenge of The Sith.
      Man Anakin had the most hurt out of all the characters in Star Wars.

    • @ary5368
      @ary5368 7 лет назад +1

      Xxandrew01 Seriously, Palpatine is too dangerous to be kept alive. He had to kill him or Palpatine could have used his slyness to somehow turn the tables.

  • @SheevTalks
    @SheevTalks 8 лет назад

    When you put Obi-Wans dialog with Vader's return to the light side together it makes it so much sadder. I always loved the scene with Obi-Wan's speech but never as much as I do right now

  • @johntracy72
    @johntracy72 8 лет назад +3

    What about Vader's reaction when Emperor Palpatine told him that Padme's and his children were dead? Vader was quite upset at himself over it.

  • @Rivalilwani
    @Rivalilwani 7 лет назад

    Bruh, your edit of that return of the jedi scene where Luke is getting shocked was so legit awesome. I really got the feels...

  • @MrMarinus18
    @MrMarinus18 8 лет назад +6

    I don't consider the scene of Luke and Leia on the bridge to be a sad scene. A very tranquil scene for sure but not really sad.

  • @angelajedifaux8263
    @angelajedifaux8263 8 лет назад

    OMIGODDD you have dug deep into my feelings with that Obiwan edit into Return of the Jedi!! 💚💚💚

  • @ambientmoder
    @ambientmoder 8 лет назад +31

    WARNING ! COMMENT SECTION CONTAINS SPOILERS!
    (please like this comment so it can be the first one at the top)

  • @jaredkula4513
    @jaredkula4513 8 лет назад

    This should have been a top 15 list. To many sad moments, but you did a great job.

  • @TheCALLofDEAD
    @TheCALLofDEAD 8 лет назад +70

    #1 for me is Han's death by a long shot.

    • @godsofgaming2341
      @godsofgaming2341 8 лет назад +1

      Totally agree

    • @CosmicToad5000
      @CosmicToad5000 8 лет назад +1

      For me it's a tie between Han, order 66 and the death of mace, kit and the others.

    • @TheCALLofDEAD
      @TheCALLofDEAD 8 лет назад +1

      ya Mace's death was pretty harsh too, when Han got stabbed I swear I felt my heart sink.

    • @jmkproductions7292
      @jmkproductions7292 8 лет назад +1

      +TheCALLofDEAD I think most of us cried there

    • @StarWarsCommunitys
      @StarWarsCommunitys 8 лет назад +2

      +TheCALLofDEAD I think the Han scene was very powerful but I think since its was so obvious he was about to die it lost that moment of surprise which i think dulled the pain a little.

  • @yahyah8116
    @yahyah8116 8 лет назад

    The most emotional scene for me in Star Wars, is in ROTJ, at the end, when Vader is taunting Luke about Leia, when Luke goes "NOOOO!" and thrashes Vader. Just beautiful, the cinematography, the music, the emotion.. I LOVE IT SO MUCH!

  • @MartyMJC
    @MartyMJC 8 лет назад +36

    Top 10 Lightsabers?

  • @araeagle3829
    @araeagle3829 7 лет назад

    Wow! I believe you nailed it! When I saw you place Han in carbonite in third, I was on the verge of yelling at you, but compared to Vader/Anakin death, and Obi-Wan's farewell. I totally agree. Number 1 if you leave out Han's death is bang on. As I look back across all eight movies, the best performances, saddest moments, humor, gut wrenching, all point to Ewan McGregor. He is the true highlight on the Prequels. Your honorable mentions are awesome. Great video.

  • @Mallerd
    @Mallerd 8 лет назад +6

    Padme death isnt sad, its a breath of relieve

    • @sepantap
      @sepantap 8 лет назад +1

      Reporting this comment cause it's too savage

    • @angryfarfetchd3015
      @angryfarfetchd3015 8 лет назад

      +Movies4Life that's why it is so low on the list.

    • @Mallerd
      @Mallerd 8 лет назад

      Sepanta Payghamy
      bruh

    • @KentKaliber
      @KentKaliber 8 лет назад

      +Movies4Life Her death scene felt very "artificial" ----- pretty much like every minute of the Prequels HA!

    • @rhymfre4266
      @rhymfre4266 8 лет назад +1

      Natalie Portman is hot so I can see why it's sad

  • @linds552
    @linds552 7 лет назад +1

    I'm the weird person that loves the prequels more than the originals. I just love that there is hardly any like amusing moments and I feel as if there is so much more emotion, like during the third movie when Anakin and Obi wan are fighting, I just completely sob my eyes out everytime, and I love Padme and Anakins relationship

  • @championastartes
    @championastartes 7 лет назад +9

    that last one was good, I agree on what you said about Vader thinking of what Obi-Wan said to him, that was good

  • @scrumptiousbumptious1071
    @scrumptiousbumptious1071 4 года назад

    Obi Wan’s farewell to Anakin is definitely #1. Every time I watch it I get tingles on my face and it almost makes me cry.

  • @Sup3r6f0ur
    @Sup3r6f0ur 8 лет назад +6

    I think without a doubt Revenge if the Sith is the saddest of the movies. It dies a great job off setting up the fall of the Republic and rise of pure evil.

  • @sithlord1877
    @sithlord1877 8 лет назад

    I think that your edit of the electrocution scene was actually really good

  • @moverz668
    @moverz668 7 лет назад +4

    Han and leia's love story vs padme and anikan's love story
    like for padme and anikan
    Comment for han and leia's

  • @jachzpeter145
    @jachzpeter145 8 лет назад

    11:09-11:30, i've never thought of it that way, but it actually made me 'release a little tear'! I've never really loved your your channel but this video is definitely going to get a like😃

  • @parjai97
    @parjai97 8 лет назад +8

    top 10 sad clone wars moments pls

    • @StarGeek
      @StarGeek  8 лет назад

      +Nacho -Marti I could make a list of 100 for that... good idea!

    • @parjai97
      @parjai97 8 лет назад

      +StarGeek i always cry with satine's final episode! i mean, i love mandalorians and two of them perish in 10 minutes!

  • @Tollp
    @Tollp 7 лет назад

    Although I'm late to comment on this, I love how you handle spoiler warnings. Every youtuber should do this.

  • @benlipson6497
    @benlipson6497 8 лет назад +12

    Go would have put Hans death at number 1, but I think your justification for not putting it there at the moment is fair.

    • @benlipson6497
      @benlipson6497 8 лет назад

      *I would

    • @maxrebo6750
      @maxrebo6750 8 лет назад

      +Ben Lipson chewbaca's reaction :(

    • @benlipson6497
      @benlipson6497 8 лет назад

      Patrick Star I know 😢

    • @CrashJakFan1994
      @CrashJakFan1994 8 лет назад +1

      +iRival Robot's Props What about Leia sensing his death? Her expression said it all.

    • @seannelson3699
      @seannelson3699 7 лет назад

      Ben Lipson I didn't care much when he died. I did but at the same time, having a brother who told you his guesses during the movie and guessing that han would die after seeing how much of a rip off 7 was of 4 during the first half of the movie then saying very loudly as han died in a theater full of fans, "I knew it!!". yeah I wasn't very sad anymore

  • @atootam
    @atootam 4 года назад +2

    Hands down ‘you were my brother anakin, I loved you’

  • @CanucksGameVlogger
    @CanucksGameVlogger 8 лет назад +4

    You used my idea :)
    Next Top 10 things the prequels did wrong?
    (Unlikeable characters,too much cgi, bad acting,midichlorians, etc)

    • @darthjarjar2721
      @darthjarjar2721 8 лет назад

      It would be hard to restrict it to 10

    • @NicBrandon
      @NicBrandon 8 лет назад

      Oh my FUCKING god. The prequels were good. Respect Lucas. If you only like the originals, that is a 50%. AN F. You can't be a fan if the entire series gets a F FROM YOU

    • @darthjarjar2721
      @darthjarjar2721 8 лет назад

      Wow really? Respect Lucas? After he ruined the good movies and made three terrible ones? Also, if hating half the films doesn't make me a "fan" then I guess I can;t be a Star Wars fan anymore. Also, please explain how the prequels were good. Like, seriously. Please.

    • @NicBrandon
      @NicBrandon 8 лет назад

      +Darth Jar Jar They expanded on origins, had great combat, better emotion, and good story.

    • @darthjarjar2721
      @darthjarjar2721 8 лет назад

      Nice. Great combat. By combat do you mean a super choreographed ballet dance? And they expanded on things that didn't need to be explained, like midichlorians. The emotion was so forced as well. The story for Episode II was decent, but the way it was done is terrible. Prequels=Suck

  • @zoey9656
    @zoey9656 8 лет назад

    How does this guy not have millions of subs! He relates to me so much I am among the few people who liked the prequels and my favorite movie is TESB

  • @Mr_Bob_A_Feet
    @Mr_Bob_A_Feet 8 лет назад +4

    What?!? Why didn't you include me falling into the Sarlaac pit?

    • @StarGeek
      @StarGeek  8 лет назад +2

      +Boba Fett That scene was just too sad to even mention, I would have burst down in hysterics if I tried to talk about that for even a few seconds. So sad.

    • @gaozhanvieranaputra3348
      @gaozhanvieranaputra3348 8 лет назад

      +StarGeek LOL

    • @elijahblechman8633
      @elijahblechman8633 8 лет назад

      you got out tho..........that's was epic on how you got out by ripping out the tentacles and used that flame thrower, george lucas was a freaking for cuting that out of jedi

    • @gaozhanvieranaputra3348
      @gaozhanvieranaputra3348 8 лет назад

      +StarGeek but for me the saddest thing happened to star wars is boba fett death *killed by a blind man* and Han Solo death *spoiler lol

  • @ItsArrzee
    @ItsArrzee 8 лет назад

    Great video! I 100% agree with all of these. I know you didn't include clone wars but if you did I thought Ahsoka leaving would have been high on the list

  • @Yeagerbonebone
    @Yeagerbonebone 8 лет назад +5

    order 66 should have been #3 not #6

    • @Wade_Fucking_Wilson
      @Wade_Fucking_Wilson 7 лет назад

      darth cough cough How old are ya? Just asking

    • @hispanicbaljeet4076
      @hispanicbaljeet4076 7 лет назад

      ᏔᎪᎠᎬ FᏌᏟᏦᎥᏁᏩ Ꮃ ᎥᏞᎦ Ꮎ Ꮑ number one shouldve been the death of fives. I actually cared about the character compared to people like padme.

  • @bettylouisa
    @bettylouisa 6 лет назад +1

    My #1 will always be when Ahsoka left the order and that last talk she had with Anakin, I always cry during that scene...

  • @d1mensi0n70
    @d1mensi0n70 8 лет назад +3

    Han's death and Finn's near death

    • @d1mensi0n70
      @d1mensi0n70 8 лет назад

      So close...

    • @ThierryRocksTV
      @ThierryRocksTV 8 лет назад

      +GhostCrafter123 Finn's not dead he's just being treated.

    • @hotshotjalapeno5597
      @hotshotjalapeno5597 8 лет назад

      +Demon Rantz he said near death dumbass

    • @ThierryRocksTV
      @ThierryRocksTV 8 лет назад

      Hotshotjalapeno YOU DON'T HAVE TO TALK TO ME SO RUDELY!

    • @ValTheAsian
      @ValTheAsian 8 лет назад +1

      It wasn't that sad when Finn got sliced by Kylo ren like he saw it coming he had no experience with a lightsaber. Nobody expected him to win that fight anyway.

  • @04nbod
    @04nbod 7 лет назад

    'You were right about me' is even more emotional because its a reply to his wife's dying words 'There is good in him, I know there is, still'. Those words Luke told Vader on Endor 'I know there is good in you let go of your hate'. With the prequels that whole sequence, from Luke thinking about his mother to Vader's last words brings Padme back into the whole resolution when she hadn't been mentioned sequentially for 2 films.

  • @binjimdu3933
    @binjimdu3933 7 лет назад +3

    jyn and cassians death

  • @thehugeeuge1975
    @thehugeeuge1975 8 лет назад

    Wow that number 1 editing gave me goosebumps!!!

  • @pavlekrulanovic9839
    @pavlekrulanovic9839 8 лет назад +10

    sedest thing is han solos deth in force awekens

  • @MonsieurEldritch
    @MonsieurEldritch 4 года назад +1

    Anakin and Padmé looking out the window in different towers was the saddest scene for me

  • @mikaperzyna8230
    @mikaperzyna8230 8 лет назад +12

    george lucas is full of ideas. TOO full of ideas. JJ Abrams did the force awakens so well because he respected star wars as what it was. That's just my opinion.

    • @Phoenix2312
      @Phoenix2312 8 лет назад +2

      +Sci-Fi Pie Agree! You do wonder though what would have been had Lucas not threw his Baby out with the Bath water and actually worked with Abrams... I like the new film, but the pair together - A New Ben Hur Maybe???

    • @WilliamStephanusArriel
      @WilliamStephanusArriel 8 лет назад

      respected. didnt you notice he copies everything

    • @mikaperzyna8230
      @mikaperzyna8230 8 лет назад +1

      +Warren „Phoenix” Marris yeah, i guess that might have been cool.

    • @bradwright9477
      @bradwright9477 8 лет назад

      I couldn't agree more. JJ kept true to the original trilogys more focused story. Truly a great return for the franchise

    • @barbaro267
      @barbaro267 8 лет назад +3

      +Sci-Fi Pie I don't like that JJ is trying to continue what the originals did. George Lucas said that every Star Wars film is a separate chapter in one giant book. So why is JJ trying to bring back old characters and focus on things that have already happened? Why not have a NEW story, 100 years or more in the future following the events of episode 6, and have new human characters? No more Skywalkers, Solos, etc. But noooooo, JJ wants to appeal to the demographic that hates on the prequels. At least George Lucas was trying to do something new with the prequels, and succeeded, seeing how dark it got by episode III.

  • @silent6834
    @silent6834 8 лет назад

    I actually feel as if those were the words he was thinking of. Matches perfectly. Bravo.

  • @judeskater93
    @judeskater93 8 лет назад

    Dang you're right about mixing those two scenes at number one, that really does work well.

  • @gorehound3414
    @gorehound3414 3 года назад

    Kanan dying in rebels made me cry, the last episode of clone wars, the realisation that Vader is Anakin by Ashoka, the thought of Luke telling Ashoka that Anakin was redeemed. Yodas death, mauls death, Quigons death and obi wans. Vader’s redemption and his mask being taken off. Ezera being shot into hyper space with Thrawn. Kanans master being killed in front of him in bad batch. Order 66, it was literally like best friends turning on each other it was so hard to watch. Rogue one squad getting killed trying to get the plans for the Death Star.
    You watch the movies for the first time and don’t feel to upset. But once you’ve seen clone wars and rebels it brings so much Pain!

  • @sokandueler9578
    @sokandueler9578 7 лет назад

    jeez dude, nice editing. that rtj scene with obi-wan voice got me

  • @liaminator4950
    @liaminator4950 8 лет назад

    Funny enough, I'm sick today, so when you said "grab a box of Star Wars-themed tissues" I was one step ahead of ya.

  • @smoon2313
    @smoon2313 8 лет назад

    To think you made the emperors death scene more impactful through a fan edit, and now we're dealing with "nooooooo"

  • @TheBenjaman
    @TheBenjaman 8 лет назад

    solo's death hits me every timevI see the movie, the fist times my hartbeat went up to 200, I dropped som tears to that scene too, aswell as to the ending with luke and rey.

  • @maxeyre2024
    @maxeyre2024 8 лет назад

    If the prequels actually came before the original trilogy 11:09 the way you put it actually makes it awesome and emotional.

  • @MiniboyG
    @MiniboyG 8 лет назад

    OMG Obi wan's dialogue over Vader looking back and forth from the emperor to Luke works SO well

  • @Graystripe02
    @Graystripe02 8 лет назад

    I didn’t really care too much about the others, but damn, #1 was amazing. The scene with Darth Vader choosing between dark and light with Obi-Wan's voice in the background was brilliant!

  • @TheBurgerHut7
    @TheBurgerHut7 8 лет назад +1

    Let me tell you, the music that plays when Yoda disappears is the most emotional music ever

  • @r.b.oo7591
    @r.b.oo7591 4 года назад

    I even cried when Anakin and Ini Wan broke their relationship in the last scene. And cried a hell out of me while Obi Wan said by his sorrow ' You were my brother Anakin. I loved you' I think it's the most emotional dialogue ever.

  • @jokersfunnies1233
    @jokersfunnies1233 8 лет назад

    The scene with Darth Vader picking sides with Obi-Wan's voice made me cry. It is so sad in a good way!

  • @Chaos-94
    @Chaos-94 8 лет назад

    For me, It's always been watching Shmi Skywalker die in Anakin's arms. What really sold me on it was when she whispered "now I am complete," and attempting to choke out one last "I love you" before dying.

  • @guaty4788
    @guaty4788 8 лет назад

    Edit with Obi Wan's voice with Vader's turn back to the light was fucking awesome!

  • @Royal-kq6bw
    @Royal-kq6bw 4 года назад

    that edit with obi wans voice with the sence of ROTJ that gave me chills beecuase evrey time obi wan says i loved you it just hit me

  • @jamienewman2811
    @jamienewman2811 8 лет назад

    I thought that the editing was amazing for the last scene it fitted perfectly this is the first video I have watched of his and i though it was amazing that's why I subscribed to this channel

  • @shadowkeepr441
    @shadowkeepr441 5 лет назад +1

    Order 66 is #06 on the list
    Me: COINCIDENCE!, I THINK NOT!

  • @danameyy
    @danameyy 8 лет назад

    I think you should've included the scene where Anakin becomes Vader, but I was hoping for the whole video you'd pick the scene you did for #1! Great job!

  • @KidChardonnay
    @KidChardonnay 8 лет назад

    The editing of scene when Vader throws The Emperor with Obi wan's parting words to Anakin gave me goosebumps, and I think it gives a lot more emotion to the scene, even though without the speech you could still see Anakin's conflict about what to do, I think that it helps portray it a lot better, and if they are going to re-release it with more changes I kinda want this to be one of them.

  • @annatuira4678
    @annatuira4678 8 лет назад

    Omigoodness why did you have to kill my heart by adding Obi-wans lines to the scene where Darth Vader turns into Anakin once more. I would hate you for doing that, but you placed Ob-wans farewell at the very top, so I can't possibly hate you. Thanks :p