Being in a medical profession, I must confess myself, wat OSHO is saying is 100% true. It's hight time for all of us who r willing to offer a effective tool to treat psychological disorders to consider eastern vedic system to understand ourselves better before treating our patients.
Ive known psychologist who i truly believe are authenic in their ambition to help others but they are never able to create a true change in their clients. The help they offer is cosmetic and not a real transformation, they use theories and ideologies with great effort but never gets anywhere. A pity psychologist are in such high regard in the western world.
They say 'eyes are the window of soul', now look at OSHO. This guy never blinks and can talk with sense for a long period of time. This guy is powerful. Spiritually powerful.
I'm studying Psychology and all I can say imo is that Osho is so right about everything he said, which is one of the reasons i'm considering dropping the studies. Psychology knows nothing about who we truly are, all that psychology knows is at the most shallow levels of our existence, once you get to know yourself deeply, psychology as they teach it becomes a meaningless subject. I've learned about myself while doing the 10 days Vipassana course a whole lot more than a whole year.in University.
So does learning psychology in university is joke? Dude how do one know himself. How are you so sure that after doing Vipassana a person knows himself more as compared to that in the University? Maybe Vipassana could work but directly proclaiming words like we can learn more there is saying like I learnt more about modern science from religious books than from scientific papers.
@@shivammishra1720 The commentator has tried both. Studying in university and did vipassana. He says he has learnt more about himself doing vipassana than in university. And you ask him how he is so sure ? You tell me what he can do to be sure. He has tried both, I think its enough to be sure
It all boils down to purpose, why are you doing psychology? Sure you might love it but it is also for a job at the end because if not for a job then might as well study at home, we have alot of resources if not all with the internet nowadays. And what is the purpose of knowing oneself? How does one define what knowing oneself is? What exactly do you know? And what exactly do you want to know? And if you do come to know whatever it is you are searching for, I hope you find a good use for it.
Osho had such a great respect and reverence to Ramana, that once he told an interviewer that he had nothing to regret in life, except for one thing that he could not see Ramana Maharishi. That is the greatest tribute to Ramana. HARIOM TATSAT.
I am a psychologist and I completly agree with him, psychology can only go to a certain point, to reach something beyond that, only meditation is capable of giving it
Of course psychology and spirituality have split in this modern world, they can be conjoined, but the basics are fractured mostly by the scientific process of obscene rationalism.
Very true and insightful description of psychologists in general. A minority of psychologists now days, the intelligent ones, are studying mysticism to incorporate it in their practice.
I remember reading in Jung's alchemical essay's that the western man should not attempt to integrate the eastern methods of spirituality & mysticism. Everything OSHO was saying confirmed my previous suspicions whilst I was reading through Jung's essays. How could two human beings be told they are not allowed to sip from the same chalice? The intellectual caliber of Jung is undeniable but I fear that in our western universities we are learning more & more about less & less (actually I feel rather certain about this).
Psychologists provide a great service. I have relied on them at one point in my life, and I doubt even followers of Osho would deny their effectiveness in helping us improve our emotional health. But while a psychologist may know *about* himself and how his mind works, there is a greater chance the psychologist (especially at the time this recording was made) does not truly *know* himself. That is where meditative practice comes in.
Psychologist dont know themselves so they can't really help you, only those who are spiritualy Awakened could understand osho. Self discovery is the key to solve all human problems. Spirituality is the most advanced technology.
Very refreshing, I resonate with OSHO. I feel deeply connected to Ramana maharshi's teachings. Osho's talks are very much alive with PRESENCE energy. OSHO, Eckhart, Ramana maharshi. Such great teachers we are gifted with.!
Seeing psychologists myself, I have benefitted greatly and have immense respect for one woman who helped me the most in my entire life. I will be forever grateful and rember her always. If I am like an onion, she helped me peel off many layers to get to the center of myself but there was a stopping point. That point was the mind, only half way through the onion. She uncluttered my mind so well I'd walk out of her sessions feeling clear at peace and blissful. She nudged me the right direction and I left her practice for the last time. I had grown and come to know myself better through experience not intellect. She told me it'd be up to me now to go further. I was one of her biggest treatment stories and I know she was proud of it. And I was happy for her. She taught me how to see my thoughts and feelings and be aware of them with acceptance. How to reprogram my mind for positivity. Wonderful woman. I started reading Buddhist and Hindu scriptures and meditating as often as I could on a daily basis. This is the other half of the onion. And next week I will be attending my first 10 day vipassana retreat. The work have put in myself has trasnformed me and I will continue to be transformed every day. This is the path that psychologists didn't give. But she was in the ocean with me to help me keep my head above water when I couldn't myself. I am forever grateful. I agree with OSHO that they can't show you your true self, but there is a different benefit that is very real and positive. Thank you to my psychologist and OSHO alike. 🙏 The psychologist was using CBT - cognitive behavioral therapy if anyone was interested.
Yes I agree Osho. Wild Wild West was a slanted view of this man. They tried to portray him as "bad." I see a wise but human man. I wouldn't worship his feet but I see a mystic, with a deep spiritual understanding. His ranch became a mess and probably shouldn't have been made and yes he was part of that but a true mystic knows you only find the answers on your own. He's just a facilitator. The people who were in power of the ranch went too far and I'm not sure if Osho put them up to that. But the irony is the hypocritical people in America who were prejudiced from the beginning and continues to this day, anything that challenges what people have been brought up to believe. I also see he enjoyed the materialistic side of life, he did become excessive at points, which was not great and happens but that is also part of humanity. He was not a saint and I think that's what people need to get rid of, this black and white thinking. You must be a saint in order to be "wise." No. In order to be wise, one must first be a fool and be willing to face your own foolishness to grow in conscious awareness. He saw truth, he enjoyed and lived the human experience, the good, bad, and in between. I've always drawn much wisdom from his talks. Be a mystic, come to your own conclusions. If you're polarized and stuck in division, you will not be able to do this. The spiritual path can be isolating bc you must become your own guide.
*Opens RUclips to watch my daily dose of Osho, Indic spirituality, Gnosticism, Jungian texts, psychology video• *reads the title in my recommendations* Also me, a psych student aiming to pursue the field - *tears and panic* 🥲
@@aryapaar final year undergrad student.. and a little sceptical of continuing onto this path. Although I really am passionate about these disciplines and how they correlate to human psyche.
You’re not alone. I’m sooo passionate about psychology and yet every time I listen to Osho talking about therapy and psychology I panic. I want to pursue this career but osho makes me skeptical about it.
@@nostalgicgirrl6053 psycholohy is merely learning kinds of mask people wear, some sticky mask, and some others super sticky mask. Anyway, i'm about going to college next year, could you please give ur opinion whether i should enter psych or not?
Haha it seems we are on the same boat. In my view, theraphy doens't have to be about fixing a problem, a mental illness, but rather to embrace it and live with lovingly. Contradictory, that act of loving your shadow does diminish it's power, lessening the symptoms. The way that many old school psychologist did therapy is plainly wrong. Of course if you have one 'theory' or 'explanation' ready for your client's problems, before even hearing about them, you will misdiagnose them. When you have a hammer every problem looks like a nail. Psychologist shouldn't diagnose people, but instead give a platform for people to find about themselves, not to speak from moral highground of a degree, but meet people where they are. Continue on your path my friend
I love Osho,as usual he hits the nail on the head,its a shame he's not with us today ,for he would show up many of the modern day so called spiritual teachers abounding on RUclips and the well known ones from the past. His methods may be way out, but basically he knows what he is doing,he knows himself and is funny with it. Of course he still is with us in his recordings,thanks to the ones who undertook to do this, so we can share in his priceless wisdom.
True. They try to treat psychological problems with drugs rather than finding the core issue. Sometimes it could have happened due to imbalances in energy chakras. I heard that imbalance in manipura (naval) chakra will cause anxiety, depression and weight gain.
Has anyone noticed.........psychologists always label people with acronyms. This labeling most likely falls in line with the "conform to the norm and follow the follower mentality." No thanks, I'm allergic to acronyms and outside therapy." My feelings are within me not without me.
Eu curso Psicologia e eu não estou nem um pouco ofendido. Eu amo o Osho porque seu trabalho sempre foi abrir os olhos das pessoas. Gratidão, Mestre. Gratidão, Existência. ❤️🙏❤️
No psychologist is divine. We do not help people. We help people help themselves. And we too need that support because we are humans too. So when our lives or times are really bad we too go for help. Adding that to know oneself is not the aim of psychology. That is the aim of life. Happy are the ones who attained it. Psychologists who have difficult lives can and do suffer. But that does not mean we are unprofessional or cannot help others.
Dr. Nita Joseph, you are probably missing the point, unfortunately. You may want to check out “Beyond Psychology” and “Psychology of Esoteric” - two mind blowing lectures of Osho from 70s. I used the term Mind Blowing purposefully because Modern Psychology stops at the Mind. The point where Modern Psychology ends was the starting point for eastern mystics for tens of thousands of years; they knew what is beyond it. The sage Ramana is one of them who C GJung purposefully avoided. Osho is just awesome! Again, check him out.
You are technically correct... Osho is wrong here ... So many patients are healed because of doctors... Knowing self is different and helping others mentally is different
It is not the intention of psychoanalysis to make the individual know themselves, but rather to alleviate symptoms arising from psychological suffering
Brilliant, could you possibly share more videos of Osho. I would really like to see his discourse on the "enlightenment of Chikanzenji", I swear that was one of his best discourses.
''They knew nothing about themselves, so how can they help you to know yourself?'' So true! Now I understand why, more than 35 years ago, an ex-classmate from university who was a fan of Carl Jung was suggesting to me that being a fan of and studying J.Krishnamurti was a mistake. He he was asserting very strongly that we can't understand what these eastern mystics are saying! Sad... J. Krishnamurti has been a major influence in ''confirming'' and developing my spiritual health. Nevertheless, I am deeply disappointed that I discovered Osho only recently. What a waste of time! I consider him a master as great as Krishnamurti.
@Freedom and Art You got me here... So pardon me, it will be a little long. I did not say that studying K. was a waste of time. Studying K. has very far from being a waste of time. He has been a spiritual father for me and initiated me to meditation. I said that discovering Osho only recently was a waste of time. I should have added because of my prejudices toward him generated in large part by the propaganda against him, I stayed away from his talks all those years. 😒 I consider Osho to be a master as great as Krishnamurti. And I can see many links to K. teaching in his insights. But Osho is unique in the ways he approaches meditation and spirituality. On the one hand, K. is very cultured but far from being as cultured as Osho (Osho had a library of more than 150000 books...) On the other hand, K. is concerned about concentrating himself rigorously and strictly on the psychology related to self-knowledge and meditation, has a very rigorous intellectual approach in helping is listener to understand their thought processes in order to lead them to meditation. So it was far from being a waste of time studying Krishnamurti. As I see it from my relatively short exploration of Osho I have had to date, his approach is more pragmatic and direct in his ''pedagogy''. He doesn't try like K. to make the listener understand the psychological intricacies of the mind in a rather ascetic way, in order to initiate the listener to meditation. Osho put himself more at the level of the listeners and make them experience directly and ''experimentally'' glimpses of the meditative state in a playful way. Instead of trying to explain, he shares his meditation directly. As I see it, K. is an exceptional ''psychologist'' of authentic ''spirituality''. Not to say that Osho is not, far from it. He is very conscious of the value of his vision and awareness. But also, I think his exceptionally vast culture enable him to have a broader and more playful vision in his ''pedagogy''.
“There is a false saying: “How can someone who can’t save himself save others?” Supposing I have the key to your chains, why should your lock and my lock be the same?” -Nietzsche
After listening to so many problems of so many people... Psychologists and psychiatrists themselves have to survive on brain calming pills like serotonin pills etc.... however yoga ...meditation... pranayam... ayurveda... adhyatma... dispassion.....I think can be Solutions to many mental problems... please opine... ??
I agree allot of mental problems like suicide can be destroyed by not getting identified with the mind that is the whole problem with most mental problems. Being still and seeing your mind without judging while you still are. Is a whole other dimension of living. The mind has al kinds of illusions and tricks but if you are no longer identified with the mind you will see everything clear
Western psychology is existential dealing with external, in fact everything western man seeks is outside of himself. When you go in you find all answers.
Soho is referring to Ramana Maharshi, also known as Maharishi Raman. His teachings aim at self inquiry on Who or what am I? Once you realise your true self which must be distinguished from ego which is the illusory or false sense of self, you attain enlightenment. Carl Jung is afraid his whole life learning would be shattered or collapse in face of ultimate reality. Ibrahim Balyani a Spanish Moslem mystic said: What’s the purpose of understanding the whole world, if you don’t even understand your own self?
Yes, he made me think very differently too, even though I was on my way to discovering these things out for myself, it just happened sooner with Osho...My channel here is mainly influenced by Osho, George Carlin, The Thinking Atheist, and a couple other people including myself. Check it out if your interested.
I’m studying psychology and I agree with osho but at the same time I think psychologists ‘ methods can be useful for people with mental deseases even if they ( psychologists) can’t know themselves 100%. Anyway, psychologysts must do a lot of practice, studies and therapeutic sessions before they can become “ psychologists” cause they must be aware of what they are and what they do. Anyway, true psychologists try to “ give a name “ at the pain of the patience, but it doesn’t mean that they classify people just with a simply name, sometimes it helps to lead in one direction the therapist. Every patience is UNIQUE.
More like he contradicts himself, meditation won't remove the problems from your life. Only by facing it you can remove it. The more you runaway, the more you suffer.
Excellent insight🙏Osho is an enlightened Master a PHD professor of philosophy 🤗 Meditation is immensely beneficial unlike medication which has side effects😏
I absolutely love Osho and I know he had a reason for why he said this. I don't dare presume why but the way I view psychology is similar to the way I view religions, they actually can help, up to a certain point, and then they have to be dropped as the attachments that they are and one must move forward or they become obstructions. Psychology, self-help books, and even scriptures can help to a certain point, and even dare I say it...Osho talks, but then they must be dropped and you have to move forward as an individual. Osho did not want mini Osho's being created, he wanted individuals to realize their nature, not mimic or copy others. Saying this, I was enrolled in a Ph.D. program for Clinical Psychology and I woke up one day and realized that this field can no longer help me because I have moved past it, but I am still quite stuck on Osho ;)
Osho doesn't criticize Scientists, but throws light on PAID RESEARCHERS DISGUISED as Scientists who feed on the biscuits thrown by a few powerful politicians & tycoons at topmost hierarchy.
Who told you this thing? It's not the case. Prophets of the Creator have always been at the highest level of spirituality. And majority of them have been from the middle East.
there are different levels of psychologists. The best ones can help you. I say this because i saw a pyshologist who changed the way i am in the world for the better. I still have problems, but it changed for the better.
True Carl Jung was an absolutely brilliant psychologist. I don't think the world has still understood fully the significance of his work. He is one of those great minds whose work is understood over a millenium rather than a century.
In the aspect of knowing oneself, I will have to agree. A psychologist is not helping anybody to get to know themselves. That's mainly because it's not the point of the psychologist to make you know yourself. They are there to help you understand yourself, not know yourself. There is a big difference here!
Osho was an enlighted person. I believe that he knows better than you. if someone wants to understand himself first must know himself otherwise yoy cannot understand something if you dont know it. It is matter of logic
@@mirtiamirtia2198 You have to listen more closely to what he says and to what I say here. I'm not disagreeing, I'm just adding what I think to what he said. Don't just blindly listen to people, never do that, even Osho said so in one of his talks.
@@Nerex7 you are right in a sense. psychologists help you with your make up, with your mask, with your personality. atleast thats my take on it, i heard that they go more into meditation now too, then partially they do the same as osho, but they wont be able to guide you very far, as they dont know themselves ^^ they can only hand over the techniques osho talks about and in the end its better to listen to someone who has experienced it, instead of a parrot/well fed computer, science says that those vibrations one emmits make a huge difference in the subjective experience, thats why it is so powerful to be in the presence of a master
The problem with psychologists is that they never share their own diagnosis and shortcomings with their customers in the first place. (Yes customers not patients)The business is built on marketing the image of a problem free professional whom has sorted it all out and mainting that image at all costs. Their work is based on how much trust they can harness, just like any other lovely con artist :)
@@wanderingneone Sure. No one is just one thing but being aware of all sides of oneself and being open about them( like Osho) is a courage that not any ordinary human being posesses. ;-)
Having gone through a MFT training program I can tell you 1) Many people, IMO, go through an clinical psychology education because they believe that by having the tools that they are somehow "fixed" or a righting a wrong done TO THEM as a child without having cared for themselves enough to care for others. 2) Some actually do know themselves enough to realize that tools are not enough and its the person wielding them with compassion that will be the most helpful to their clients. 3) There is a serious level of understaffing at many clinics and yet that doesn't change the workload thus leading to issues of self-care, burn-out, depression, ect. 4) Every single human is flawed no matter the self-work (shadow work). 5) Trust is a basic human issue. In western cultures, IMO, trust is so abused in everyday culture that people want to trust but are deathly afraid to trust for good reason. So when someone mentions counseling to somoene who NEVER had any experience with therapy fear is the the most common response. be kind to yourself. If you can, be kind to others.
This is so not true! I read Jung a lot and he emphasized the importance of eastern psychology, he said and I'm quoting "the east have done introspective psychology for thousands of years while western man has started it this morning."
Your observation nails the nub of what AILS all Sciences, not just Psychology. All Sciences, including Mathematics and Medical Sciences are Congenitally Flawed and Fallacious AND what sustains them till date is the Tribal fatal disease called Peer Reviewing that gives them the unconscionable Academic Credence & Practice. Which in turn survives on the Trial & Error mode without any kindness spared for the Costs - the number of human lives lost in the process! Equally Tragic if not More: Philosophy, History , Spirituality , Transcendentalism, Spiritual Guidances and other such are also Just as Flawed, Half-Baked, Fallacious and PSEUDO as the Sciences themselves! Napoleon Bonaparte once said, " History is a set of LIES agreed upon".
@@avirajsingh1385what he's saying that institutes and universities are pumping academic papers at the rate of garbage in the dumping yard, it's all papers upon papers no quality checks (flawed peer reviewing) and that in term causes damages both in resources and human lives through the command of chain influenced by these garbage papers.
“There is no coming to consciousness without pain. People will do anything, no matter how absurd, in order to avoid facing their own Soul. One does not become enlightened by imagining figures of light, but by making the darkness conscious.” ~Carl Jung How shameful is it that he could not even stay on his own words
The funniest things in the comment section are people assuming that Osho didn't read Jung's opera. :))) He literaly said he read Jung's journal, jeez. Osho wanted to say that Jung knew psychology based on observation of other people, not through himself. Yet, Jung is probably one of the most influent scholar of the 20'st century. Osho is a big one too. Instead of taking sides, you should enjoy that we can watch the clash of two stars. Nowdays, in the 21'th century we weren't able to produce a new Jung, a new Osho, a new Sri Ramana, a new Nietzsche, etc.
Jung attained knowledge by observing others? Do you know anything about Jung's methods and findings? Ever heard about the red book? What complete bullshit, just google a bit ffs
I considered becoming a psychologist aswell, but through meditation/yoga, I don't see it beneficial for anyone. But meditation/yoga, I would recommend meditation for everyone..
Osho great.... but here i disagree. Some people don't even know they don't know themselves. Psychology, Sociology and Spirituality are just same thing but a different perspective of the same thing... science and spirituality combined in getting to know yourself is better than just the one. Psychology and Sociology allow you to challenge preconceptions, misconceptions and understanding shared reality.... no one gets to judge how someone finds themselves... not even Osho. He wanted a new man to spread the fire. A new man should be Meditative, Kind, Silent and understanding. Yet I see none of that here. Be the change.
they may know alot about diseases IN the world, in the brain. they may know alot about personality behavior patterns... and so on and so on. but still you have not come to anything INNER. the inner has no matter, conciousness is not matter. psychologists only study that which is already manifest in the world, how it appears, how it disappears. so it is not useless of course, it helps to understand the world. but as far as knowing yourself is concerned, you will have to go inwards as he describes, until you witness your witness. conciousness is concious of itself -> this is the moment when you see who you are. psychologist dont know this. with this all diseases automatically disappear i recommend going deeper into his teachings before making conclusions a person who does not know himself, only psychology, can help you to optimize your personality (your mask), but he cannot help you to know yourself, maybe on the way you realize something, maybe you even become more aware of certain things (same as he teaches), but the psychologist are nowhere near the ultimate reality, enlightenment, conciousness being concious of itself (described above) so in one sense you are right. psychology is also useful. it helps you navigate in the word. It is worldly. it doesnt show you who you are. knowing who you are is the "unworldy". of course knowing both will create an even more complete man as someone who only meditates in a cave and ONLY experiences the watcher. thats also exactly what he teaches, to be in both worlds. but the biggest difficulty is to know oneself first.
Psychology has been in the field on treating people for many years but have failed to understand the human mind the more it understand the more mysteries open
Psychology is like looking at a soup, eating it, studying all the flavors, admiring the colors, the smell and ignoring completely how the soup was made, vegetables harvested and sun shining over them.
One on my facebook comment name Lou Pan he is upgoing Psychologist he say that introvertion is isolation then i reply introvertion isnt an isolation because we dont love to be isolated we love solitude because we love the inner selves Lou Pan reply and explain every ingredients any flavorings on his words buts still he cant cook it thats why what i say to him hes futile meaning he has no sence in life and i dont reply to him because he keep replying to me for the right one but i dont because he himself can identify that thing hes just a experimental guy who doent care about the ingredients he serve to the menu
Psychologist uses tricks... They will show you that they know themselves but they not they do suicide when they theoriticaly tryin to solve a problem but they cant they just ended their life to an illusion
Being in a medical profession, I must confess myself, wat OSHO is saying is 100% true.
It's hight time for all of us who r willing to offer a effective tool to treat psychological disorders to consider eastern vedic system to understand ourselves better before treating our patients.
Ive known psychologist who i truly believe are authenic in their ambition to help others but they are never able to create a true change in their clients. The help they offer is cosmetic and not a real transformation, they use theories and ideologies with great effort but never gets anywhere. A pity psychologist are in such high regard in the western world.
They say 'eyes are the window of soul', now look at OSHO. This guy never blinks and can talk with sense for a long period of time. This guy is powerful. Spiritually powerful.
Look at any MLM selling u a product and look at his eyes .ull see osho.😂
better call him guru or osho bhagwan instead of this or that guy
Jump to 2:42
@@vrm_ravi if you're saying this then you've not learned anything from osho
ओशो इतने होश में थे कि पलक भी उनकी मर्जी के बिना नहीं झपक सकती थी.. Hats off to this super man
I'm studying Psychology and all I can say imo is that Osho is so right about everything he said, which is one of the reasons i'm considering dropping the studies. Psychology knows nothing about who we truly are, all that psychology knows is at the most shallow levels of our existence, once you get to know yourself deeply, psychology as they teach it becomes a meaningless subject. I've learned about myself while doing the 10 days Vipassana course a whole lot more than a whole year.in University.
Hello
So does learning psychology in university is joke? Dude how do one know himself. How are you so sure that after doing Vipassana a person knows himself more as compared to that in the University? Maybe Vipassana could work but directly proclaiming words like we can learn more there is saying like I learnt more about modern science from religious books than from scientific papers.
@@shivammishra1720 The commentator has tried both. Studying in university and did vipassana. He says he has learnt more about himself doing vipassana than in university. And you ask him how he is so sure ? You tell me what he can do to be sure. He has tried both, I think its enough to be sure
It all boils down to purpose, why are you doing psychology? Sure you might love it but it is also for a job at the end because if not for a job then might as well study at home, we have alot of resources if not all with the internet nowadays. And what is the purpose of knowing oneself? How does one define what knowing oneself is? What exactly do you know? And what exactly do you want to know? And if you do come to know whatever it is you are searching for, I hope you find a good use for it.
Bless you more
Osho had such a great respect and reverence to Ramana, that once he told an interviewer that he had nothing to regret in life, except for one thing that he could not see Ramana Maharishi. That is the greatest tribute to Ramana. HARIOM TATSAT.
I am a psychologist and I completly agree with him, psychology can only go to a certain point, to reach something beyond that, only meditation is capable of giving it
is this sarcasm 😂
@@Armz69 no it's not "really" sarcasm ... But sarcastic people will find it sarcasm .
comparto lo que decis Diego
Of course psychology and spirituality have split in this modern world, they can be conjoined, but the basics are fractured mostly by the scientific process of obscene rationalism.
@@Diegogreccooficial absolutely correct l have already said it I agreed with you 😀😀
Very true and insightful description of psychologists in general. A minority of psychologists now days, the intelligent ones, are studying mysticism to incorporate it in their practice.
Nice mention about the great Ramana Maharishi - the Man who knew Himself
Right.
I remember reading in Jung's alchemical essay's that the western man should not attempt to integrate the eastern methods of spirituality & mysticism. Everything OSHO was saying confirmed my previous suspicions whilst I was reading through Jung's essays. How could two human beings be told they are not allowed to sip from the same chalice?
The intellectual caliber of Jung is undeniable but I fear that in our western universities we are learning more & more about less & less (actually I feel rather certain about this).
@@hangman2515 Haha you're quite funny🤣
ओशो इतने होश में थे कि पलक भी उनकी मर्जी के बिना नहीं झपक सकती थी.. Hats off to this super man
my future psychologist just lost a client.
I m a Clinical Psychologist. Absoluetly True. Carl Jung & Osho inspiring
Psychologists provide a great service. I have relied on them at one point in my life, and I doubt even followers of Osho would deny their effectiveness in helping us improve our emotional health. But while a psychologist may know *about* himself and how his mind works, there is a greater chance the psychologist (especially at the time this recording was made) does not truly *know* himself. That is where meditative practice comes in.
Psychologist dont know themselves so they can't really help you, only those who are spiritualy Awakened could understand osho. Self discovery is the key to solve all human problems. Spirituality is the most advanced technology.
Most psychologists are deeply disturbed themselves. Hence the major reason they studied this discipline.
Wrong,they become deeply disturbed after studying psychology.The subjects propels u to think a lot,often disturbing
True! A relative who was a psychiatrist said: „The choice of profession in this area in itself is symptomatic.“ 💯
It's like saying a doctor get sick by studying disease 😂😂😂
Yes.
Very refreshing, I resonate with OSHO. I feel deeply connected to Ramana maharshi's teachings. Osho's talks are very much alive with PRESENCE energy. OSHO, Eckhart, Ramana maharshi. Such great teachers we are gifted with.!
Seeing psychologists myself, I have benefitted greatly and have immense respect for one woman who helped me the most in my entire life. I will be forever grateful and rember her always. If I am like an onion, she helped me peel off many layers to get to the center of myself but there was a stopping point. That point was the mind, only half way through the onion. She uncluttered my mind so well I'd walk out of her sessions feeling clear at peace and blissful. She nudged me the right direction and I left her practice for the last time. I had grown and come to know myself better through experience not intellect. She told me it'd be up to me now to go further. I was one of her biggest treatment stories and I know she was proud of it. And I was happy for her. She taught me how to see my thoughts and feelings and be aware of them with acceptance. How to reprogram my mind for positivity. Wonderful woman. I started reading Buddhist and Hindu scriptures and meditating as often as I could on a daily basis. This is the other half of the onion. And next week I will be attending my first 10 day vipassana retreat. The work have put in myself has trasnformed me and I will continue to be transformed every day. This is the path that psychologists didn't give. But she was in the ocean with me to help me keep my head above water when I couldn't myself. I am forever grateful. I agree with OSHO that they can't show you your true self, but there is a different benefit that is very real and positive. Thank you to my psychologist and OSHO alike. 🙏
The psychologist was using CBT - cognitive behavioral therapy if anyone was interested.
Ogres have layers, onions have layers
Very good point made.
Help can also be done non spiritually.
Not everybody is a "Truth Seeker".
Yes I agree Osho. Wild Wild West was a slanted view of this man. They tried to portray him as "bad." I see a wise but human man. I wouldn't worship his feet but I see a mystic, with a deep spiritual understanding. His ranch became a mess and probably shouldn't have been made and yes he was part of that but a true mystic knows you only find the answers on your own. He's just a facilitator. The people who were in power of the ranch went too far and I'm not sure if Osho put them up to that. But the irony is the hypocritical people in America who were prejudiced from the beginning and continues to this day, anything that challenges what people have been brought up to believe. I also see he enjoyed the materialistic side of life, he did become excessive at points, which was not great and happens but that is also part of humanity. He was not a saint and I think that's what people need to get rid of, this black and white thinking. You must be a saint in order to be "wise." No. In order to be wise, one must first be a fool and be willing to face your own foolishness to grow in conscious awareness. He saw truth, he enjoyed and lived the human experience, the good, bad, and in between. I've always drawn much wisdom from his talks. Be a mystic, come to your own conclusions. If you're polarized and stuck in division, you will not be able to do this. The spiritual path can be isolating bc you must become your own guide.
*Opens RUclips to watch my daily dose of Osho, Indic spirituality, Gnosticism, Jungian texts, psychology video•
*reads the title in my recommendations*
Also me, a psych student aiming to pursue the field - *tears and panic* 🥲
hard relate. are you a masters student?
@@aryapaar final year undergrad student.. and a little sceptical of continuing onto this path. Although I really am passionate about these disciplines and how they correlate to human psyche.
You’re not alone. I’m sooo passionate about psychology and yet every time I listen to Osho talking about therapy and psychology I panic. I want to pursue this career but osho makes me skeptical about it.
@@nostalgicgirrl6053 psycholohy is merely learning kinds of mask people wear, some sticky mask, and some others super sticky mask. Anyway, i'm about going to college next year, could you please give ur opinion whether i should enter psych or not?
Haha it seems we are on the same boat. In my view, theraphy doens't have to be about fixing a problem, a mental illness, but rather to embrace it and live with lovingly. Contradictory, that act of loving your shadow does diminish it's power, lessening the symptoms. The way that many old school psychologist did therapy is plainly wrong. Of course if you have one 'theory' or 'explanation' ready for your client's problems, before even hearing about them, you will misdiagnose them. When you have a hammer every problem looks like a nail. Psychologist shouldn't diagnose people, but instead give a platform for people to find about themselves, not to speak from moral highground of a degree, but meet people where they are. Continue on your path my friend
I love Osho,as usual he hits the nail on the head,its a shame he's not with us today ,for he would show up many of the modern day so called spiritual teachers abounding on RUclips and the well known ones from the past.
His methods may be way out, but basically he knows what he is doing,he knows himself and is funny with it.
Of course he still is with us in his recordings,thanks to the ones who undertook to do this, so we can share in his priceless wisdom.
@@jonsmith4669 He was , is and will remain alive with us
@@jonsmith4669 😄😀🙏🏽🙏🏽
Psychologists are more likely to give you advice on how to cope for the rest of your life than how to face your insecurities.
True. They try to treat psychological problems with drugs rather than finding the core issue. Sometimes it could have happened due to imbalances in energy chakras. I heard that imbalance in manipura (naval) chakra will cause anxiety, depression and weight gain.
@@infinitebeing1119 Energy Chakras?
bruhhh that's how i see it.
I have mentioned something related to this as a comment on the video "science and inner journey". And it is in total support of Osho here.
Has anyone noticed.........psychologists always label people with acronyms. This labeling most likely falls in line with the "conform to the norm and follow the follower mentality." No thanks, I'm allergic to acronyms and outside therapy." My feelings are within me not without me.
te recomiendo meditar todos los días
Eu curso Psicologia e eu não estou nem um pouco ofendido.
Eu amo o Osho porque seu trabalho sempre foi abrir os olhos das pessoas.
Gratidão, Mestre.
Gratidão, Existência.
❤️🙏❤️
Psychologists become psychologists looking for answers to their own problems.
Can you please give examples ??
Like a doctor with a broken arm trying to fix other peoples broken arms.
Lol.. Can't stop laughing.. Very true
i would love to see a debate between jung and osho
Jung leaves the chat.
@@anoridinaryhumanbeing70 😂😂😂LOL
@@AniMeLoVeR23451 would be super most and beautiful debate
as said psychologist are business majors n noting else
Great wise man, thank you for your contribution to the world. I love you Osho ❤.
No psychologist is divine. We do not help people. We help people help themselves. And we too need that support because we are humans too. So when our lives or times are really bad we too go for help. Adding that to know oneself is not the aim of psychology. That is the aim of life. Happy are the ones who attained it. Psychologists who have difficult lives can and do suffer. But that does not mean we are unprofessional or cannot help others.
Dr. Nita Joseph, you are probably missing the point, unfortunately. You may want to check out “Beyond Psychology” and “Psychology of Esoteric” - two mind blowing lectures of Osho from 70s. I used the term Mind Blowing purposefully because Modern Psychology stops at the Mind. The point where Modern Psychology ends was the starting point for eastern mystics for tens of thousands of years; they knew what is beyond it. The sage Ramana is one of them who C GJung purposefully avoided. Osho is just awesome! Again, check him out.
Maneesha
i know what you can do to know yourself, but it will go more deeply than "yourself"
I have seen many feedbacks which is was indeed back thrashing OSHO and doing nothing much but this reply was quite professional
You are technically correct...
Osho is wrong here ...
So many patients are healed because of doctors...
Knowing self is different and helping others mentally is different
It is not the intention of psychoanalysis to make the individual know themselves, but rather to alleviate symptoms arising from psychological suffering
Brilliant, could you possibly share more videos of Osho. I would really like to see his discourse on the "enlightenment of Chikanzenji", I swear that was one of his best discourses.
''They knew nothing about themselves, so how can they help you to know yourself?'' So true!
Now I understand why, more than 35 years ago, an ex-classmate from university who was a fan of Carl Jung was suggesting to me that being a fan of and studying J.Krishnamurti was a mistake. He he was asserting very strongly that we can't understand what these eastern mystics are saying! Sad...
J. Krishnamurti has been a major influence in ''confirming'' and developing my spiritual health.
Nevertheless, I am deeply disappointed that I discovered Osho only recently. What a waste of time!
I consider him a master as great as Krishnamurti.
@Freedom and Art
You got me here... So pardon me, it will be a little long.
I did not say that studying K. was a waste of time.
Studying K. has very far from being a waste of time.
He has been a spiritual father for me and initiated me to meditation.
I said that discovering Osho only recently was a waste of time. I should have added because of my prejudices toward him generated in large part by the propaganda against him, I stayed away from his talks all those years. 😒
I consider Osho to be a master as great as Krishnamurti.
And I can see many links to K. teaching in his insights.
But Osho is unique in the ways he approaches meditation and spirituality.
On the one hand, K. is very cultured but far from being as cultured as Osho (Osho had a library of more than 150000 books...)
On the other hand, K. is concerned about concentrating himself rigorously and strictly on the psychology related to self-knowledge and meditation, has a very rigorous intellectual approach in helping is listener to understand their thought processes in order to lead them to meditation.
So it was far from being a waste of time studying Krishnamurti.
As I see it from my relatively short exploration of Osho I have had to date, his approach is more pragmatic and direct in his ''pedagogy''.
He doesn't try like K. to make the listener understand the psychological intricacies of the mind in a rather ascetic way, in order to initiate the listener to meditation.
Osho put himself more at the level of the listeners and make them experience directly and ''experimentally'' glimpses of the meditative state in a playful way.
Instead of trying to explain, he shares his meditation directly.
As I see it, K. is an exceptional ''psychologist'' of authentic ''spirituality''.
Not to say that Osho is not, far from it.
He is very conscious of the value of his vision and awareness.
But also, I think his exceptionally vast culture enable him to have a broader and more playful vision in his ''pedagogy''.
i prefer Osho, Krishnamurti had a mistake about meditation
“There is a false saying: “How can someone who can’t save himself save others?” Supposing I have the key to your chains, why should your lock and my lock be the same?” -Nietzsche
Both are out of the world
@@brahmaputramoskva1215 And Meera knows Krishna , only one, 🙏🏽🙏🏽
After listening to so many problems of so many people... Psychologists and psychiatrists themselves have to survive on brain calming pills like serotonin pills etc.... however yoga ...meditation... pranayam... ayurveda... adhyatma... dispassion.....I think can be Solutions to many mental problems... please opine... ??
Yeass for sure brother. Do yoga visit the page @ishafoundation
im hindu. but i can say buddism is solution for that. because buddism is actually not a religion but a way of life!
yes, meditate every day at least 20 minutes, gradually it will change your life, over the years it will change your life forever, it did with me
I agree allot of mental problems like suicide can be destroyed by not getting identified with the mind that is the whole problem with most mental problems. Being still and seeing your mind without judging while you still are. Is a whole other dimension of living. The mind has al kinds of illusions and tricks but if you are no longer identified with the mind you will see everything clear
Western psychology is existential dealing with external, in fact everything western man seeks is outside of himself. When you go in you find all answers.
He was a professor of philosophy.
I’d rather hear someone who can say I don’t know myself than who says I know you better than you do.
Yup!
He is right I went to two-three psychologists what they are doing is they pull us to their understandings.
Soho is referring to Ramana Maharshi, also known as Maharishi Raman. His teachings aim at self inquiry on Who or what am I? Once you realise your true self which must be distinguished from ego which is the illusory or false sense of self, you attain enlightenment. Carl Jung is afraid his whole life learning would be shattered or collapse in face of ultimate reality. Ibrahim Balyani a Spanish Moslem mystic said: What’s the purpose of understanding the whole world, if you don’t even understand your own self?
Listening itself to the Grand Master is like being in a meditation state. I feel it
Sometimes I check my internet when Osho stops talking
I know right. it’s like spit it out already!! 😂
🤣
@@gigachad94 don't say that God bless you 🙏🏽🙏🏽 otherwise He-----------
that is a solid point.
Osho changed my life! 🙏🌹
Yes, he made me think very differently too, even though I was on my way to discovering these things out for myself, it just happened sooner with Osho...My channel here is mainly influenced by Osho, George Carlin, The Thinking Atheist, and a couple other people including myself. Check it out if your interested.
I’m studying psychology and I agree with osho but at the same time I think psychologists ‘ methods can be useful for people with mental deseases even if they ( psychologists) can’t know themselves 100%. Anyway, psychologysts must do a lot of practice, studies and therapeutic sessions before they can become “ psychologists” cause they must be aware of what they are and what they do. Anyway, true psychologists try to “ give a name “ at the pain of the patience, but it doesn’t mean that they classify people just with a simply name, sometimes it helps to lead in one direction the therapist. Every patience is UNIQUE.
Calm. Osho always provokes, if necessary, he even lies...
@@d.l.7399 because it works for him man
I think that this mans speaks like he has the absolute truth , sometimes I agree with him but not always
sometimes i feel he hits the nail irght on the head - others, not so much. important that the viewer uses his judgement eh
@@CHIKIPLEITOS u say He has the absolute truth It is said that truth is God nd God is truth.right.
@@CHIKIPLEITOS It means u agreed with that Bhagwan Osho is God🙏🏽🙏🏽
Thank you so very much Osho.
Psychologists are narcissists that enjoy dissecting or speculating anyone in a thousand different angles. It's a sport marketed as a profession.
Not for the good one that goes direct to the problems instead of exploiting their patients.
OMG! He is destroying psychologists into thousand pieces 🤭
No one know who they are because we are not immortals .or eternals
More like he contradicts himself, meditation won't remove the problems from your life. Only by facing it you can remove it. The more you runaway, the more you suffer.
@@sudheshsankarkk Yes u won't have to remove the problems as well You get energy doing meditation to face them🙏🏽🙏🏽
Merci beaucoup Monsieur Osho, vous avez raison!!!
Osho should have lived at least to the age of 70's.
He himself explained why Yogi's live a short life
every man needs to hear this
so true, i love you Osho
Excellent insight🙏Osho is an enlightened Master a PHD professor of philosophy 🤗
Meditation is immensely beneficial unlike medication which has side effects😏
He has not read any newspaper that’s the first step towards spirituality.
Even monks watch one hour of news once a week
Yes you are right.He is God
Not a monk at all.
Bedankt Osho , voor deze uitleg .
I absolutely love Osho and I know he had a reason for why he said this. I don't dare presume why but the way I view psychology is similar to the way I view religions, they actually can help, up to a certain point, and then they have to be dropped as the attachments that they are and one must move forward or they become obstructions. Psychology, self-help books, and even scriptures can help to a certain point, and even dare I say it...Osho talks, but then they must be dropped and you have to move forward as an individual. Osho did not want mini Osho's being created, he wanted individuals to realize their nature, not mimic or copy others. Saying this, I was enrolled in a Ph.D. program for Clinical Psychology and I woke up one day and realized that this field can no longer help me because I have moved past it, but I am still quite stuck on Osho ;)
So what are you doing now ?
Anyone who seeks help is doomed!! But you have to seek truth by yourself!!
If ONLY those who seek bogus
Spiritual Help KNEW This
All Important TRUTH....!
My bachelor degree in psychology is staring at me for watching this.
Hahahaha
the study of what other humans do
Osho doesn't criticize Scientists, but throws light on PAID RESEARCHERS DISGUISED as Scientists who feed on the biscuits thrown by a few powerful politicians & tycoons at topmost hierarchy.
Why all spiritual teachers are from india
Who told you this thing? It's not the case. Prophets of the Creator have always been at the highest level of spirituality. And majority of them have been from the middle East.
@@asianbuilder3344 why so much insecurity.. all they just few can be counted on figures...many stole knowledge from Indian sages Alas.
Alan Watts
@@asianbuilder3344 No spirituality in Abrahamic religions. Hell and heaven are not in SPIRITUAL world.
@@asianbuilder3344 in India we have all population of prophets.
there are different levels of psychologists. The best ones can help you.
I say this because i saw a pyshologist who changed the way i am in the world for the better. I still have problems, but it changed for the better.
I love Osho but Carl as well they both are helping me in they own unique way!
True Carl Jung was an absolutely brilliant psychologist. I don't think the world has still understood fully the significance of his work. He is one of those great minds whose work is understood over a millenium rather than a century.
@@HarshSingh-qr5lm Yeah but his teachings are eastern influenced.
i noticed that osho changed around 1990. Osho looka very calm in his hindi videos but looks very different in English videos...
changed in 1990? do you mean 80. He died in 90
In the aspect of knowing oneself, I will have to agree. A psychologist is not helping anybody to get to know themselves. That's mainly because it's not the point of the psychologist to make you know yourself. They are there to help you understand yourself, not know yourself. There is a big difference here!
Osho was an enlighted person. I believe that he knows better than you. if someone wants to understand himself first must know himself otherwise yoy cannot understand something if you dont know it. It is matter of logic
@@mirtiamirtia2198 You have to listen more closely to what he says and to what I say here. I'm not disagreeing, I'm just adding what I think to what he said.
Don't just blindly listen to people, never do that, even Osho said so in one of his talks.
@@Nerex7 "I believe that he knows better than you"
that says all you need to know about their ability to reason.
More like to understand your thoughts, not yourself.
@@Nerex7 you are right in a sense. psychologists help you with your make up, with your mask, with your personality. atleast thats my take on it, i heard that they go more into meditation now too, then partially they do the same as osho, but they wont be able to guide you very far, as they dont know themselves ^^ they can only hand over the techniques osho talks about and in the end its better to listen to someone who has experienced it, instead of a parrot/well fed computer, science says that those vibrations one emmits make a huge difference in the subjective experience, thats why it is so powerful to be in the presence of a master
The problem with psychologists is that they never share their own diagnosis and shortcomings with their customers in the first place. (Yes customers not patients)The business is built on marketing the image of a problem free professional whom has sorted it all out and mainting that image at all costs. Their work is based on how much trust they can harness, just like any other lovely con artist :)
unfortunately I have to confirm this to some point. But there are some good sides to them as well I reckon ;-)
@@wanderingneone Sure. No one is just one thing but being aware of all sides of oneself and being open about them( like Osho) is a courage that not any ordinary human being posesses. ;-)
Absolutely right 👍
Fun fact: Carl jung himself wrote a foreword(praising Maharshi) for Arthur Osborne's book on Raman Maharshi!
Thats what Osho means. Raman maharishi was a great personality.
"Psychologists are not helping"
Liked the video.
Osho was brilliant
Thank you so much ... 🌹🌹🌹
Knowing yourself has many definitions.
you could sell that line to Hallmark cards, just like all that stupidiity from Dalai Lama
"There are no role-models, for being an individual"...."Cause we live, in a world, of our own "-;!
Thnx Osho for this valuable information 🙏🙏
There is only one person who can help, yourself.
Well, others can help, but they can't save you.
No, it's wrong. Only the Creator can help you through His revealed knowledge. Hence, read Qur'an.
Who created the creator?
@@cesaosales Bhagwan Osho
I mean an Enlightened Guru must be in ur life always
That was always my conclusion about Psicologists. Thank you so much, beloved Osho for confirming and affirming this fact!
Having gone through a MFT training program I can tell you
1) Many people, IMO, go through an clinical psychology education because they believe that by having the tools that they are somehow "fixed" or a righting a wrong done TO THEM as a child without having cared for themselves enough to care for others.
2) Some actually do know themselves enough to realize that tools are not enough and its the person wielding them with compassion that will be the most helpful to their clients.
3) There is a serious level of understaffing at many clinics and yet that doesn't change the workload thus leading to issues of self-care, burn-out, depression, ect.
4) Every single human is flawed no matter the self-work (shadow work).
5) Trust is a basic human issue. In western cultures, IMO, trust is so abused in everyday culture that people want to trust but are deathly afraid to trust for good reason. So when someone mentions counseling to somoene who NEVER had any experience with therapy fear is the the most common response.
be kind to yourself. If you can, be kind to others.
Very well said. The irony of the interviewer telling Osho that he has traveled.
This is so not true! I read Jung a lot and he emphasized the importance of eastern psychology, he said and I'm quoting "the east have done introspective psychology for thousands of years while western man has started it this morning."
I agree with most things, however some psychologists do help people a lot and Jung's writings have most certainly helped millions of people.
Jung was tremendous
What a great explanation. No question or doubts remain in mind
True.... As always he presented truth without any polish.. bare and just...
Affirmative. Over half of studies in psychology fail to even replicate. A coin toss now seems more preferable to peer reviewing. Less cumbersome 💀
Your observation nails the nub of what AILS all Sciences,
not just Psychology.
All Sciences, including Mathematics and Medical Sciences are Congenitally Flawed and Fallacious AND what sustains them till date is the Tribal
fatal disease called Peer Reviewing
that gives them the
unconscionable Academic Credence & Practice.
Which in turn survives
on the Trial & Error mode
without any kindness spared for
the Costs - the number of human lives lost in the process!
Equally Tragic if not More: Philosophy, History , Spirituality , Transcendentalism, Spiritual Guidances and other such are also Just as Flawed, Half-Baked, Fallacious and PSEUDO as the Sciences themselves!
Napoleon Bonaparte once said,
" History is a set of LIES agreed upon".
Explain your position cuz now I am generally curious@@schwaarnkreddy7805
@@avirajsingh1385what he's saying that institutes and universities are pumping academic papers at the rate of garbage in the dumping yard, it's all papers upon papers no quality checks (flawed peer reviewing) and that in term causes damages both in resources and human lives through the command of chain influenced by these garbage papers.
Phycologists know about mind...not about self.....osho didn't blink eyes....wonder....osho is soul....
Osho is money, he didn't know moksha as he owned 93 Rolls Royces when still alive.
Sadhguru is nothing compared to him.
@@gskpvarma6192 You can explain this what is Moksha for u haven't 93 rolls royce or money as well .Even then I request to you to know Him please
Tomatoes analyzing tomatoes: How can it work at all?
Osho was Professor of Philosophy and Religion at Jabalpur University Jabalpur MP India
“There is no coming to consciousness without pain. People will do anything, no matter how absurd, in order to avoid facing their own Soul. One does not become enlightened by imagining figures of light, but by making the darkness conscious.” ~Carl Jung
How shameful is it that he could not even stay on his own words
Osho is lying about jung though, i am almost certain Jung never said he was afriad of a man who knows himself lol what complete bullshit
@@spartatrif1758 He literally just googled that bruh
The funniest things in the comment section are people assuming that Osho didn't read Jung's opera. :))) He literaly said he read Jung's journal, jeez. Osho wanted to say that Jung knew psychology based on observation of other people, not through himself. Yet, Jung is probably one of the most influent scholar of the 20'st century. Osho is a big one too. Instead of taking sides, you should enjoy that we can watch the clash of two stars. Nowdays, in the 21'th century we weren't able to produce a new Jung, a new Osho, a new Sri Ramana, a new Nietzsche, etc.
Jung attained knowledge by observing others? Do you know anything about Jung's methods and findings? Ever heard about the red book? What complete bullshit, just google a bit ffs
His mere expressions cracks me up 😂 unique comedian . But he has spoken highly of Shri Ramana Maharshi who I have read about and agree .
2:24 That goosebumps moment for tamilans
Why ?
@@aslikush because Ramana Maharshi was in Tamilnadu
He is right, I studied both, and evolutionary psychology is 100 times more powerful than university Psychology.
I considered becoming a psychologist aswell, but through meditation/yoga, I don't see it beneficial for anyone.
But meditation/yoga, I would recommend meditation for everyone..
Osho great.... but here i disagree. Some people don't even know they don't know themselves. Psychology, Sociology and Spirituality are just same thing but a different perspective of the same thing... science and spirituality combined in getting to know yourself is better than just the one. Psychology and Sociology allow you to challenge preconceptions, misconceptions and understanding shared reality.... no one gets to judge how someone finds themselves... not even Osho. He wanted a new man to spread the fire. A new man should be Meditative, Kind, Silent and understanding. Yet I see none of that here. Be the change.
they may know alot about diseases IN the world, in the brain. they may know alot about personality behavior patterns... and so on and so on. but still you have not come to anything INNER. the inner has no matter, conciousness is not matter. psychologists only study that which is already manifest in the world, how it appears, how it disappears.
so it is not useless of course, it helps to understand the world. but as far as knowing yourself is concerned, you will have to go inwards as he describes, until you witness your witness. conciousness is concious of itself -> this is the moment when you see who you are. psychologist dont know this. with this all diseases automatically disappear
i recommend going deeper into his teachings before making conclusions
a person who does not know himself, only psychology, can help you to optimize your personality (your mask), but he cannot help you to know yourself, maybe on the way you realize something, maybe you even become more aware of certain things (same as he teaches), but the psychologist are nowhere near the ultimate reality, enlightenment, conciousness being concious of itself (described above)
so in one sense you are right. psychology is also useful. it helps you navigate in the word. It is worldly. it doesnt show you who you are. knowing who you are is the "unworldy". of course knowing both will create an even more complete man as someone who only meditates in a cave and ONLY experiences the watcher. thats also exactly what he teaches, to be in both worlds. but the biggest difficulty is to know oneself first.
@@matthigginson6865 agreed totally
आप ऐ जो प्रवचन है उसे हिंदी में डब करके हमको सुनाने की कोशिश करें,,आपकी महेरबानी,, धन्यवाद सद्गुरु ओशो
THE GREATEST OSHO ❣️❤️
Ramana Maharshi In Tamilnadu
Psychology has been in the field on treating people for many years but have failed to understand the human mind the more it understand the more mysteries open
Because they treat symptoms - they do not know the root cause
Yeah osho has explained in his book on Bodhidharma
Such beautiful words of wisdom.
such sheer & total bullshit
Don't know who you are. Remember who you are.
One and only one way in the world is ----- Osho and meditation
Osho is the great person in the world
his eyes are so intense, rarely blinks.
sure sign of the mental defective that he is
@@KuldeepSingh-kq9yj there is no space for blinking bcoz full with compassion love for others
Psychology is like looking at a soup, eating it, studying all the flavors, admiring the colors, the smell and ignoring completely how the soup was made, vegetables harvested and sun shining over them.
Wow man, that's beautiful
One on my facebook comment name Lou Pan he is upgoing Psychologist he say that introvertion is isolation then i reply introvertion isnt an isolation because we dont love to be isolated we love solitude because we love the inner selves Lou Pan reply and explain every ingredients any flavorings on his words buts still he cant cook it thats why what i say to him hes futile meaning he has no sence in life and i dont reply to him because he keep replying to me for the right one but i dont because he himself can identify that thing hes just a experimental guy who doent care about the ingredients he serve to the menu
Psychologist uses tricks... They will show you that they know themselves but they not they do suicide when they theoriticaly tryin to solve a problem but they cant they just ended their life to an illusion
@@inlumina_punctro Beautifully said