Why was Vinesh Phogat Disqualified Before her Gold Medal Bout? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024
- Why was Vinesh Phogat Disqualified Before her Gold Medal Bout? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat was disqualified ahead of her final in the 50 kg women's wrestling event at the Paris Olympics. Vinesh weighed around 100 grams over the permitted limit on the morning of her bout. Why did her weight fluctuate over the two days of competition? Is there any evidence of foul play? Palki Sharma tells you.
---
Paris Olympics 2024 | Vinesh Phogat | Paris Olympics | Paris 2024 | Firstpost | World News | News Live | Vantage | Palki Sharma | News
#vineshphogat #wrestling #parisolympics #indianwrestling #paris2024 #paris #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.c...
Hard reality is that people without medals are forgotten soon.
PT Usha isn't forgotten
@@HomoErectus-xg5odwho
@@HomoErectus-xg5odhe said soon not forgotten
That's not true; it depends on the person. If they are superficial, yes, they'll forget. If they truly saw what happened and empathized with her efforts, they would not and probably even get inspired.
Olympics is modern circus and these players are slaves
I always think I am the most unlucky person without an ounce of luck. But this girl’s luck is worst than mine. God, that was horrible. Terrible! I can’t even imagine her pain… All that hard work for years, facing bullying and almost reached the top but had to turn back. This is the saddest thing I have heard in a while.
Karma...she was chanting vile words for our PM
@@HomoErectus-xg5odwow you are the worst
her team did do everything to help her to get the weight right like not drinking water and eat food, cutting her hair off, shortening her clothes, etc...over weight is over weight..she was just 100 grams over the limit or the weight of a deck of card. Olympic doesn't bend the rules just for her. hell no. Imagine superpower India wins their 4th medal in this olympic, the whole nation will go wild!!! still stuck at 3 medals and #64 place as of today, we need Modi to come out and grill team India.
@@HomoErectus-xg5od bro now is not the time for this
@HomoErectus-xg5od. No freedom of speech in your country ?
As an Indian, I am deeply concerned about two significant issues: why, with such a vast population, we are not producing more renowned scientists and why we have so few medals in the Olympics and Commonwealth Games. Mainstream media often focuses on promoting government agendas and narratives, while debates frequently center around religion, caste, and creed. Despite our immense talent and potential, political parties seem to only act when they perceive political gain. For example, where is Modi when our wrestlers are seeking justice against a criminal politician within the party? He has remained silent, failing to support our athletes. If we treat our sports stars this way, how can we expect to inspire others? It is truly a shame. To date, how many notable figures have we produced? How many major brands have we established? As a technical professional, I struggle to find a single popular app or website that was developed in our country.
Very well stated!
Sad but true
blame the reservation , indian do great thing but they do it in abroad bcz there they do not have shackles that hinder their growth new people like arvind shrives & ashok elluswamy are doing great work .As for sports event it may be bitter to say but its true that we do not have the fund to give a proper grooming to our players . They do not get the same exposure from young age as our western counter part get & when they get some lime light then they are mostly at the end of their carrier . the events like Olympics have a avg expenditure of 30-40 lakh per player & we are still a developing country all the govt bjp & cong barely provide a sustainable lively hood facility, there is no proper water light education facility in many areas so can we just blame the govt for not endorsing player properly bcz we have millions who are barely educated and needs the fund . The most sustainable way would be that private firm like ambani adani endorse the new generation players so they get the correct training without burdening the govt
The more the population, less the value for individual life and talent. We have more average and below average humans than quality ones. Look at all the criminals and their uneducated/ unemployed background. Other countries hone talents even if they be small in number.
The recent mishandling of a woman in bike in lucknow tells you how the unemployed youth(men) are a menace.
Indian population quantity > quality
You struggle to find a single website or app developed in our country? What are you living in 90s? 😅
We agree with Jordan Burroughs Vinesh should get Silver.She went to final when she was under weight
Actual red line is 50.5. but dy maintain 52 . Her original segment is not 49 kg. Rule is made to stop corruption.
If she got silver then that would disadvantage another athlete and I am sure there be a would protest. Everyone accepts competition rules and that is the way of the sport.
@@arv-Hackney-London nope, not at all... she wasn't over the red line 50.5, so atleast they could have given her considerations. Not everything is black and white, if it was so, then we can bring up the case of the unpaired boxing match.
@@arv-Hackney-London She defeated Cuban undisputed in Semi Finals how can Cuban enter finals either dont give silver at all or give joint Silver.
Brutal rule needs to be changed because it just doesn't make sense. When someone has earned a medal, snatching it away from them is nothing but a mental murder. She hasn't done anything illegal here. What has been achieved cannot be termed null and void.
Not her fault. Her team failed her.
palki is trying to blame it on the olympic. It is not superpower india's fault. I'm like don't they have a team to look out for their atheletes. Palki is like it ain't us, it's them. Palki needs to understand their are rules and restrictions in olympic competition. Palki is like playing dumb here.
her team did do everything to help her to get the weight right like not drinking water and eat food, cutting her hair off, shortening her clothes, etc...over weight is over weight..she was just 100 grams over the limit or the weight of a deck of card. Olympic doesn't bend the rules for just her. hell no.
She could have wrestled at a heavier class
And your parents failed you
@@itsdakshaYour Father Brijbhusan didn't Fail you
I am an american, and I will say this: Vinesh Phogat is the uncrowned queen. She was destined to win, no doubt on my mind. Very unfortunate
how come she was within weight every match but not the final, who calibrated the weight machine?
China plays dirty roles, it’s nothing surprising again………
D opposite way, that disqualified her rightly.
@@AeonMusicRecord This news anchor elaborated that these all ( for all weight restricted sports ) athletes have full blow dietary restrictions especially the day before the game. They don’t eat solids, a lot of saunas and exercise. So she was weighing around 49 on the previous fight… Then she took food and that added her 3 kgs. The evening before of final day the team realised she was 52kgs… They started everything. Exercise, cut her hair, even took some blood out… But unfortunately over night she could only get down from 52 to 50 kgs & 100gms. She disqualified because of those extra 100 gms. The team even asked the olympics committee to give some time… But they didn’t. Its was a very unfortunate situation. It’s not problem with machines or anything…
@@varsharaos294 Very unfortunate. What if if she had been withdrawn from final, saying that she is injured, will she get a silver medal in that case?
@@skappen123 you dont get a medal from withdrawing
She perfectly clarified a part of champion !! India women are outstanding !!
too low，连自己的嘴都控制不住
If your natural weight is 56 kg it’s impossible to compete in an event like this for a bout under 50kg. The olympic event usually last for days or weeks . It’s just impossible to do. I can see someone cutting so much weight for a day but not for a week tournament . But kudos to her . Truly a fighter
Paris Olympics had gone worst in every way possible. I mean how the hell her weight suddenly increased after playing 3 matches....on same weight
They Increase...if you don't know stay silent...don't put last cell here
They can do away with a man competing as a Woman...this is injustice at peak towards Indians...even at fifa with cameras..we had to give up ...my Egyptian professor mam is so biased towards Indian students...no matter how hard one works she gives us less scores
Ok, not sure how they are related, if she is discriminating, complain to your dean
See what happened with vinesh is extremely sad and as an Indian I am sad but don't talk dumb! The person you are talking about is not a man! She is born a biological girl! She has an abnormal hormonal issue which is seen in many women!! You shouldn't disgrace a woman to support another! Protecting both is our duties!
@@Delllatitude7490 she is the dean unfortunately
@@Delllatitude7490 I mean racist against Indians is not in one field..it's in sports , education, work
@@deepamurthy198why do you wanna play victim?
😂😂within 10 years people won't value Olympics.
Like PPL value it now 😂. All wants cricket & western world ❤ FIFA.
It only happens in 4 years tho
Not all Sports are entertainment
don't say that. it is still a dream to win Olympics for millions of athletes all around the world and they work really hard for that
@@sridharkumar1802 They dont value it now.
Some countries like the Golden medal only not sport. It already shifted from the original purpose.
i am a Pakistani by nationality but i am proud of her courage, hats off for her courage
I called it a Hypocrisy Of The Olympics .
Allowing a Man To Fight a Woman in Boxing Match .
And here.
You are rejecting her because she's just 100 grams extra than Required .
Two are two different things...which you need to understand
She came till final, then they can give silver medal, without fighting. That advantage can be given to the opponent. Till the last round they maintained the requirements. It will be a painful for any sports person.
That's what i am asking.
@@kumarblore2003 technically no because she got disqualified, aka kicked out of competition. She ain’t getting silver or aluminum. She got busted.
@@ninersnation3298 thats what were saying its a bit unfair of a rule. she should get silver. the weigh-in in the morning is a fair rule. we accept the disqualification from the final. but why no silver? whats the basis? i mean if someone gets injured mid-match you give the other person advantage and give them gold, very rightfully so. why not here? the one that lost from her also lost from USA. easy and unfair silver for her.
Tough break for Vinesh. Trying to cut weight before the weigh-in can be brutal.
Olympics is good with LGBTQ, but not on 100 grams overweight
Even the LGBTQ people know NOT to be 100 grams overweight! She has brought shame on India!
They dont allow athletes to compete in gender they were not born in. It's better you stop propogating a lie
Actually she is fit for 55 kgs group. Entering 49 kg group with 52 kg is over advantage. D actual limit is 50.5 kg. Wrong mindset. Right justice happend.
@@zz-ly4qdpolitics and fights so put in 50kg
It sad but she cross weight limit so it still illegal cuz her opponent sacrifice alot just like her if the situation is reverse we will be soo angry at her so it all fair
My disappointed is her conditioning coach she could hve easily loose 100 gm
Indeed we are with Viñesh. with our golden words.
India 🇮🇳 is proud of you QUEEN 👑
Poor Palki, Now have to do a show on Vinesh. Never spoke a word when she was protesting.
She did you dummy. Check it
Palki is pure thug of a lady
Palki didn't have to do anything. She picks the topics exercising her freedom as News Editor & Anchor. Likewise, you don't have to watch her videos since you clearly hate her. We always have the choice.
@@vakarthi4Its the duty of the news reader to pick relevant issues and bring it out to the public.
Brother at least she didn't bashed vinesh now and as she is a godi media
Disqualified, but she's a winner for us. She conquered arena and proved herself a shero. Big round of applause for reaching final. Take a bow to this roaring Tigress.
"Maybe the100 grams was her Invisible Gold Medal."😢😢😢 what a line palki ma'am.
Honestly after all the backlash, trolls and abuses she received from her own country still she did her best to reach this far and to represent India not just herself and still many of her own country people are against her shamelessly. Shame on those people 👎
Once she knew she can't make - why did she not withdraw citing injury from the finals ? She would have gotten the silver isn't it ?
if caught this could lead to suspension of indian wrestling federation , So no that was never the option .But i hope that CAS judgement is in our favor bcz she truly deserve it
Yes, that was an option. This is a technique very commonly used. Now why her team didn't withdraw citing injury even though they knew she wouldn't pass the weigh-in, raises many questions.
1.5 Billion population, more resources but 0 (Zero) Gold 🤣🤣😁 Thats INDIA SUPERPOWER 🤣
Eveythings is about funds here in india sports are given less fund cause we have to focus more in other stuffs .Westerns have huge fund already they give most funds to their sports organisations.Evrythigb depends on how much u can invest .
@@electrowizard2658 once a upon a time, there was a country which called the GOLDEN BIRD 🤣 INDIA SUPERPOWER 🤣
log kahta hai luck nahi hota luck hota hai agar bhagya mein na ho to kuch nahi kar sakta as a indian feeling so bad for her i can understand how much pain she must be going through it will take time to overcome this setback. hard luck
I’m not Indian and I’m heartbroken 💔 for her!
Not at all. Rules are rules and they apply to all, otherwise they're not rules.
Firstpost again delivering news to the highest quality!! Thanks!!
It’s not her fault, looks like Indian management is still not that professional. She just missed her gold medal these chances doesn’t come again and again. There should be an investigation.
This feels so unfair! This is horrible. These people go through so much emotionally, they give their every ounce of hard work for this? If I I feel this horrible I cant even fathom the downpour of disappointments and defeatist feelings this girl must be going through...I so wish there were something to bring her back. She took down a legend just 24 hours ago and 24 hours later they say she is disqualified for 0.1kg without any alternative for her to buy some time to get to the desired weight. This feels just horrendous.....I just want this girl to bounce back...Come back stronger and unbeatable Vinesh! India and Indians everywhere are always with you! You go girl!
This is the Olympic, where professional athletes compete, not some backyard wrestling, rules must be strict. If she was professional, she should know the rules and do everything she can to stay qualified. Being in wrestling, boxing, etc weights are a big rule, thats why they have different weight class. She should have weigh herself hour before the final, even she is needs to eat, drink etc. If she finds herself over weight, she could have easily resolve the problem by doing long quick job, poop out the weight in food, pee out out the weight, put on different clothings that has reduce weight.
@@SiriusV23 you need to get your facts straight before commenting. Do you know the ordeal she went through to bring down her weight? She continued to work out, eliminated fluids, and went to extremes in order to shed weight that she ended up in a clinic. These are people who take their sport so seriously that nothing else matters to them except the sport. You think your “little tips” are something they aren’t aware of?? You talk about not eating an hour before the fight, these people have gone days without, leave alone solids, even fluids are cut out of their intake. Know your facts first.
A tolerance of 200 Gms should be give in all weight categories.
500gms to 1 kg weight keeps increasing and decreasing almost every day in human beings.
A 200g tolerance would simply change nothing. All you would be doing is changing all the weight classes by 200g. Athletes try to push up to the max allowed weight within their class, while staying outside of the next weight class, because more muscle mass gives you a competitive advantage.
There is some 2.6kg tolerance. She was about 53kg competing in 50kg wight class
Right.
I love Vantage who shows and most importantly Explains from scratch. And it covers all the issues that a person needs to know. Whenever i wanna know abt a topic, I search for Palki's explanations. Thanks a lot
People should praise her efforts. Pray for her come back with ❤ from PK
If she was above the specified weight limit, she could not be given an exemption. That rule applies to everyone. It is silly to expect and ask for an exemption. Play fair!
Glad to see one sensible comment 👍
But don't she deserve silver because she won other ganes fair?
@@aravindhdeivag111 What does your query have to do with the weight exemption?
@@mohasat01anbbhakt chamche are very happy and giving gyann 😂
@@mohasat01 no she competed fairly till finals. So se should be disqualified from finals not from the entire event
Bold and the beautiful
We all Indians are proud of u....
What ever the Decision is u are the star and inspiration to all Women in India keep smiling keep smiling keep your heart strong we respect you heard work u win or u loose still ur heart wins
Abk
Hyderabad
very heartbreaking
Seriously insane rules..salute to you Vinesh Phogat. Fellow Indians, she deserve great applause and respect for all the efforts for rebouncing when fate has hit her hard every time since early stages 🙏 she is truly an inspiration and a gem❤🎉
Why is she talking like this. Why most of your anchors talk like this ? It’s so irritating to watch her. Ca she read the script without these unnecessary pauses. Just tell me the news not the Mellow drama.
Watch in 2x will be more tolerable
Go watch Arnab Goswamy's news show. He doesn't know how to pause, so you may like him :D
Stop acting like a child, it's that we people talk we make pauses
Exactly!!! she think she is a. hero or sumthng
You don't like her don't watch. We like it because she talks like this. ❤
I watch you from Jouston tx im mexican american but love how you explain things and love ke the word news thru your eues or perspective. I watch you before i watch isa news
Same scales and same rules for every competitor. If you’re over the limit then you’re over the limit. Sad but simple, and fair.
What your rules says about Algierian male beating womens ? What your rules says about child r@pist to perform in front of billion watching from around the world even kids. What does your rules say about Kenyan runner getting her medal even after being disqualified?
@@NEO-v7ryou are being emotional. It’s simple make the weight class if you want to compete. Every contact sports in all events from wrestling, ufc, boxing knows this. All this attention is unnecessary. She should have never competed in that weight class then
@@niyimakinde3176 ufc is sport? 🤦
@@NEO-v7r that’s all you took from the reply?…got you
@@niyimakinde3176 It is a common practice in wrestling to perform below your normal weight with a weight cut. Even the wrestler from the USA who won the Gold was a big weight cutter. And Vinesh's normal category is 53 kg, so her performing in 50 kg is just fine.
Now, how she was overweight by 100gms raises a lot of questions on her dietician and physio. But I personally feel, just for 100gms they should have considered giving her some more time to shed weight than just 15 minutes, as the fight was anyways more than 12 hours later.
All eyes on the olympics 🌚
Nope
Conspiracy to keep India from the medals podium. Phogat was supposed to wrestle a US wrestler in the finals and there was a very good chance she would have won. This disqualification is to save US face and ensure US wins the Gold. If situation was reversed , 100 gms minute infraction would be overlooked to appease the US. Shameful to play the technical card to guarantee a US gold medal !!
This is fair, as extreme weight loss gave her an advantage in previous competitions, while not being able to maintain her weight was a risk she had to bear.
That's bullshit that's not fair to disqualify
The weight loss wasn't an advantage when other athletes were more experienced
When its under 50kg then its under 50kg not 50.1kg it was fair to disqualify her
@AkilaVidushan-vn1vf it's fair to disqualify but not fair to say she had advantage of weight when most athletes don't play in their weight
i think this comment is by bjp paid media - look at the id.
Question for ex wrestlers or domain experts- why she can’t fight in 56-57kg class, her natural weight?
Of course, that is the question.
Very disrespectful to Indians 😢
How? Puri batein na Jano bako she was fit for 53 lg after political drama from OUR INDIA then she took 50kg which she was not unfit she said i would loose weight metabolism is a thing.
Olympic authority verfied thier consent all ohk he reduced to 49.5kg but then it increases to 51.5 kg Maybe metabolism or hormone who knows.
Rules you gave consent.
It's not first time happened to country happened 2-3 times before 2008 , 2012 etc nothing new . It's not like it only happens to india
They are unbiased. Rules are for everybody and ones must respect those.
Its very unfortunate. Felt sad for her.
Should they allow 80kg Indian women to beat up 49kg women from other countries and win gold to "respect" India?
If not, then they are just following the rules to ensure fair fight in a similar weight class.
India should have put her in a 53kg weight class for a fair fight instead of 50kg.
It’s really heartbreaking 😢, she won the medal - no courtesy by the organizers- she is the winner and a tigress hats off to
That cuban player should show some sportiness....she should refuse to play final for gold....as vinesh already defeated her in previous match...cuban player should refuse to play because vinesh deserved the final match....
Are you kidding?It's not a gully match kiddo,it's the Olympics! Showing sportiness and mutualrespect are two different things,lol what a joke😂
@@sharatk4511exactly..
@@sharatk4511 yess this is olympic and cuban player is already defeated by vinesh clean and clear..with 5-0
@@XyzZyx-c7e5h yeah!If that cuban player get's an another chance she should take it, everyone works hard these dumb people will never get it.
This is not chakde india movie
True that! India has gained a champion - Vinesh Phogat.
Feeling so sad
I heard somewhere that in world championships or some tournaments wrestlers are allowed 50-100gms overweight. Also they are given some window of time to re-check the weight if failed in first attempt. But seems olympics is bit tight on rules. Wish someone can shed some true light on this.
WhatsApp forwards are not to be trusted.
Some tolerance must be there.
So this is person that beat Yui Sasaki Japan's flag bearer 3 years ago!!!!!??!! But my goodness DISQUALIFIED on such a crude technicality is so cruel and heartbreaking especially for a country that had a solid chance at a gold medal 😢😢
Wonderful rules 😢 as my German perception says... sie hat betrogen. Punkt. Germany with EU exerts heavy power making rules.
Probably you are new to wrestling. It is a common practice in wrestling to perform below your normal weight with a weight cut. All the competitors in the category are weight cutters (i.e. their natural weight is beyond 50kg and they cut weight before the tournament/match). Even the wrestler from the USA who won the Gold was a big weight cutter. Vinesh's normal category is 53 kg, so her performance in 50 kg is just fine.
Now, how she was overweight by 100gms raises a lot of questions on her dietician and physio. But I personally feel, just for 100gms they should have considered giving her some more time to shed weight than just 15 minutes, as the fight was anyways more than 12 hours later.
Also, not giving her even the silver medal is not a correct decision. She qualified in all her weigh-ins till the semi-final (with 49kg) and won the semi-final match fair and square. So why not give the silver medal at least?
she is a Fighter.....not quieter.more power To her ,proud of you vinesh
I cried ❤ I love her god bless !!
This is simply ridiculous. Is Olympic Event for Participants or Participants for Olympic?
This is like an unqualified lab tech telling me that because i had mutton the previous night my cholestrol numbers were skyrocketing...😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
विनेश बहन का इस तरह ओलंपिक् गोल्ड मेडल मैच फाइनल से अयोग्य हो बाहर हो जाना इस देश का दुर्भाग्य है। जिसकी भरपाई कभी नहीं हो पाएगी एक खिलाडी जो बर्षों दिन रात जिस सपने को पूरा करने के लिए इतनी मेहनत करता है उसका इस तरह टूट जाना बहुत दुखदाई है। विनेश बहन हमें आप पर बहुत गर्व है जिस तरह आपने पेरिस ओलंपिक में खेला और हम सब भारतवासियों का सर गर्व से ऊंचा किया आप हमारी नज़रों में ओलंपिक गोल्ड मेडल विन्नर हो और रहोगे। यही कामना है की भगवान भारत देश पर भविष्य में दया करे और आप जिस सम्मान के हकदार हैं वो आपको मिले। जय हिंद जय भारत।
why didnt she claim injury if she was not going to make it below the weight limit, it appears she was misinformed about her weight and nudged towards disqualification
It was not possible to claim injury, unless that injury occurred during the earlier bout..
Love u Vinesh. You are an inspiration. Keep playing and keep shining ❤
52 kg hours before the finals is unfair for the 50 kg category. They did their best to cut her weight but short of 100g excess. It is justice served to her opponents (quarter/semis) as they fought a 52 kg wrestler in 50 kg category.
palki is playing dumb. it ain't india, it is on the olympic.
No wrestler plays in their natural weight
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 That's why you give them the 2.6kg overweight limit for her 50KG...Vinesh was over 2.6KG plus the deck of card weight (100grams)...The girl was competing at 53kg in her last 2 world championships with 2 silvers...she can't beat out another indian girl at the 53kg class...
@ninersnation3298 well nope it's 50 kg weight for the event wrestlers would have to weigh 50 kg on the day of the weighing but during the match they go back to the normal weight vinesh phogat was 100g over 50kg not 100 g over 52.6 kg
What are you saying? Till the semi-final her weight was 49kg, and she passed all the weigh-ins and beat the opponents fair and square. Then how is this justice?
They aren’t giving the real picture….she was 2.7 kg over the 50 kg and after the whole overnight weight reduction measures she managed to reduce to 2.6 kg hence 100gm excess….,if it was only 100 gm excess it wasn’t a big task for her to reduce over night….
lanat hey k aik achi athlete ko 100 grm overweight honey pey disqualify kardiya. i know the pain, better luck in the future..love from pak.
She already taken retirement 😖
We r all proud of her HARD WORK n COURAGE. Any way BEST OF LUCK for ur future endeavors. JA HIND.🙏🤝🇮🇳
She proved she is a real hindustani warrior
No need to carry medals ❤
Typical Cheat culture.... 😂😂😂....
hard reality, she did not win.
@@arunagarwal3426 Vinesh cheated in that class.... Fair play, leave your cheating culture..
The same goes for typical fake degrees in India... 😁
How? She cannot even control her weight.
yeah, that’s what losers say to themselves😂😂
REALLY STUPID RULES..ABSURD AND UNREALISTIC.
She was disqualified because of a small weight increased but A BIOLOGICAL MAN can compete in women's game and win.
Humanity had lost the wisdom to know what is right and wrong.
What about a child r@@pist?
India should have had a man competing in that women's class. The Olympics allows that.
Indian man? Lol. They should use Indian women for ALL events. Better chance of winning something.
Ask your dad for that Partizipation...
I doubt it would change anything for the Indian medal ranking. But sexual assault incidents in the female locker rooms would skyrocket.
@@electromega3077 That's Porkistan.
@@VoltarStarman-m6r You didn't get the sarcasm.
Superb, India won plenty of Olympic medals this time, showing the world her true super power 😊
Its very shameful for us indians ,,
Why Disqualification ?? Or Left Opposition Played too much politics with her Olympic session?? Karma always give Back to you
Which opposition?
Disqualification because of being overweight.
How can men masquerading as women get a pass while a wrestler who has 1kg over gets eliminated?
Not even 1kg only 100 grams
Heart break for the entire nation not for Vinesh alone.
May be who wanted her to fall may be happy.
Thousands of reasons cannot justify irresponsible actions of support staff and they are answerable to the entire nation.
How can you say the staff was irresponsible ? It could be that they try hard, it is easy to miss the hard work you put when you are working in the background.
She should be awarded atleast Silver. She won the matches to reach the final.
Don't heart break.its game .life matter .plz take another way to reduce wait .we r with u n for us u r fighter n winner. God bless u.
The Kenyan athlete Kipyegon was also disqualified from 5,000 metres race but she and her Kenyan team protested and she got Silver medal.
So why Indian team didn't do same as the Kenyan team did ?
There is no comparision btw the indian n kenyan cases . First of all, athlete running events dont have weight categories that sports like boxing , judo, wrestling n weightlifting have.
@@nanyanguo1There is no weight categories in running race but rules are same in every sporting events, if a participant is disqualified the participant will not receive a medal.
If the Kenyan athlete could get medal, why can't she ?
@@serlongengti8634 when you breached the weight limit, there is no room for argument . Its clearcut disqualification.
Dont know what the kenyan was disqualified for . It must be something arguable or else she couldnt succeed in her appeal to be given the benefit of the doubt. by IOC .
@@nanyanguo1Kenyan Athlete was found obstructing which is why she was disqualified according to the Olympics commiitee 🙃
@@serlongengti8634 then she must have been given the benefit of doubt it was not intentional for her to be able to be let off by the review cttee.
“100g was her invisibility Gold 🥇”❤️🔥💙🧡🤍💚
It’s so disappointing!! .1 difference.. She should stand up again.. hoping her recovery from this loss 🤞🏻
Boycott this game
😀😀😀😀😀 u r great.
It is already a fking game.. there is no russians, so majority of great atheltes are not attending.
Only40-50 countries attenindg, unfortunately the great athelets are in remaining parts😂.
So this is a fcking western shit
The Olympics!!?
1.4 billion people, and just 3 Bronze medals. North Korea with all its sanctions and trade restrictions imposed on it, has been able to win 2 Silver and 3 Bronze medals. Olympics would still be the same without India's participation.
@@ShauryaSingh-qq6lz why not… it is just a western shit. If it is a world game, regardless of politics atleast every country can attend the game.. this is just few countries competing themselves..you ve to cone here and see, much anticipated highprofile sex game.. just an arena for hook up and open sex
Very Unfortunate!!! Very Well Perfomed, better luck next time...GOD BLESS
Indian Government should lodge a strong complaint. Thats it. Get her back into the bout.
A "strong" complaint? For what, to bend rules just for indian fighters and give them an advantage?
Is India going to send 60kg fighters in the 50kg weight class and file a "strong" complaint in the next Olympics too?
This is heart break for every Indian😢😢
even if she is overweight what the problem its just 100 gms , where the sports spirit . afterall she was fine in all the matches , what I feel is that this could have been overlooked
Bro rules is rules. She can participate in 55 but not 50 even if it's 100 0r 50
@@innocentkasho954 then the rules should be a bit liberal because weight is never constant , one day I am 62 then 62.5 the next day....also where's the BMI index , I don't think she is should be near 50kg at all , given her height and how muscular she is.....well guess what no point in bickering over it cause rules are rules
Bro Olympics is not in India. India has the "chalta hai" attitude. But rule are rules everywhere else.
So called superpower with no gold medal.This lady is not blaming China for taking the bulk of the gold medals away from India.Bravo!
Respect ❤
Will u reduce ur weight to compete with low weight guys or choose to fight with ur natural weight segment?
@@zz-ly4qd In human body the things you can't change are for example skin colour etc. (except surgery). The body weight is something you have a control over, choice and right to control. The Olympics have standard rules with considering all the factors. Every player gets checked before every match if they fit in rules. She was eligible for around 3 rounds and in the next she was 100 grams more than 50 kg hence disqualified.
@@Shreds1016 as per toi it is 52.7 kg. Is dt just for 50kg segment? If ur body has low fat, weight loss after a point is not right. Wrong is wrong. Rules r nutral .
@@zz-ly4qd She was weighing 49 kg in previous matches of Olympics which was right according to Olympic's guidelines. Later she gained that 52.7 kg weight. She tried to maintain it by exercise etc. Then she managed to come from 52.7 kg to 50.1 kg.
@@Shreds1016 wrong info
according to toi news paper.
If a limit is not respected by one, then it won't be respected by anyone.
Incompetent support coaching staff
Hey ! Vinesh it’s me from Montana I do so very much you get this message, no worries , maybe just maybe this is the turning point in your life, you did more in your young life than anyone I have ever known ,including myself, take care of you mow, remember you have always been number one , no need for a piece of metal, nor clapping from people whom you will never meet, time for yOU to see yourself, love and happiness from Montana,USA. If you are ever here in America , look me up!
The olympics rules are very strict . I saw lots of disqualification in this olympics.
Yeah she beat those other opponents because she is heavier than they expected.
That's just bullshit, weight measurement are done before each match day. So take your European agenda away
Unlike a WOMEN beat her opponents and reach the final. Right?
"We caught your athlete doping red-handed"
"But you said it was her weight?"
"Oh yea she was 100 GRAMS heavier than before! This is intolerable! She's disqualified!"
"And you only mentioned this after THREE straight matches?"
"The decision has been made"
Not only phogat but others also Lakshay sen lost medal by 1 set ,, Maheswari anand lost medal by 1 point ,,Arjun babuta lost by 1.4 point ,, Dhiraj & Ankita lost medal by 2 set.....
Who said modi?
Modi didn’t do shit for sports. Only thing Indians care to watch is cricket. When cricket team fails, everyone be appreciating them. But when it comes to Olympic and international competitors, no one cares. Instead of supporting, yall criticize them. Shame on you
So by your understanding, Modi does not want India to win the medels ?
Senseless comment
@@SXHIB10some ppl in comment section.
Very very strange that they couldn't manage her weight right before the finals
Incompetent management team
@NEO-v7r I agree it is the management team, but find it difficult to believe that it was plain incompetence at the level of an Olympics management team
@@archiem9926 what do you think it could be? Vinesh has taken retirement from wrestling. Only she can tell what happened now.
Still sounds like she was cheating, its like saying someone only had a few grams of a banned substance so we should overlook it. Ridiculous
Tell me you are d@mb without telling me you are.
How is that cheating? Do you even follow wrestling? Please refrain from talking about things you know nothing about.
@@koko64124 keep your knowledge for somewhere needed. There are many playschool you might find your competition there.
2021 Almaty Asian Championship gold medal she won in 53 kgs
2022 Birmingham Commonwealth Games gold she won in 53 kgs
2023 Belgrade World Championships she won bronze in 53 kgs
She should have fought in 53 kgs category but was forced to fight in 50 kgs. Federation is to be blamed.
The rules are clear, so you can wait after the gold medal match before you feast, so you can not blame anyone
Ironic how they only cared about this fact in final
@@SXHIB10they cared about it throughout
@@kc5466 and just disqualified by 100 gram margin?
@@SXHIB10 yeah. That’s how it goes. That is proof that they cared. Because they disqualified her
@@flygonc3717 for the 50kg class, they have a 2.6kg overweight limit beyond the 50Kg. Your girl Vinesh went over the 2.6 Kg and another 100 gram (weight of a deck of card). Justice has been served on that girl.
Still.she is a winner. Congratulations 🎊. God Bless and kept strong.
Rules are rules
How did she gain 1.1 kg? ……
Yes, rules r made for right reasons. A 56 kg person is playing at 49 kg segment is also not right.
Of course right. How can allow a wrestler with 100 GRAMS of overweight. It's totally not comparable to A WOMEN boxers winning her matches fair&square.
This years Olympics is an absolute Circus. A circus that makes you sad & grim instead of laugh & entertain
140 crore people of India Today heart' 💔 broken
If 140 crore ppl depend on one medal. Then it’s tragedy of the nation. Grow up and move on.
@@bodhisattva6308move on what? This government never cared about sports. All our golden medals were won in 1960s. Since then, what we have achieved?
@@SXHIB10 india and sports are far off. I mean move to creat a healthy society. Competitive sports is not for Indians.
@@bodhisattva6308 💀
@@bodhisattva6308 bro what?
Greed is what played out whoever decided as to which weight division the player should to compete. I don't see any injustice here. That's why there is a rule in every game to avoid unfair advantage over other players. "Dura lex sed lex".