Do High Flow Nozzles MIX Dual Color Filament?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 июл 2024
- I recently showed you this really fancy-looking, two-color filament that comes out of the nozzle with the same pattern as it was fed and creates some mesmerizing effects on your parts. However, the question so many of you had was, what happens if you feed this material through one of the high flow nozzles that split the filament up. Will they mix the material and remove the effect? This is the question I’ll answer today by printing parts with Bondtechs CHT nozzle, my simple mesh nozzle, and finally, this overkill Hedgehog Volcano nozzle where I solder six pieces of wire in which we’ll, of course, also test for its flow capability! Let’s find out more!
Check out the Dual Color Filament (Affiliate):
Redline Filament (GERMANY): tidd.ly/3nZafag
3DJake (EUROPE): geni.us/My3w8NW
Matterhackers (USA): www.matterhackers.com/store/l...
Website article: www.cnckitchen.com/blog/do-hi...
💚 Support me 💚
Patreon: / cnckitchen
Join as a RUclips member!
CNC Kitchen Threaded Inserts: geni.us/CNCKInsertsChoice
Merch: teespring.com/stores/cnckitchen
Buy an Original Prusa i3 printer: geni.us/CNCKPrusa
PayPal: www.paypal.me/CNCKitchen
Shop at Matterhackers(US): www.matterhackers.com/?aff=7479
Shop at 3DJake(EU): geni.us/zHvnB
Shop at E3D: geni.us/CNCK_E3D
🎙Check out The Meltzone Podcast: / @themeltzone
🛒 Equipment used in this video:
CHT Nozzle - V6 Compatible (Affiliate in DE/UK): geni.us/U6M8s1K
CHT Nozzle - Mk8 for Ender 3 and similar (Affiliate in DE/UK): geni.us/OevmhbU
E3D Toolchanger (Affiliate): geni.us/E3DToolchanger
E3D Hemera Extruder (Affiliate): geni.us/CNCK_E3DHemera
Flir One Thermal Camera (Affiliate): geni.us/BUaN
Mekanika EVO CNC Router: cnc.mekanika.io/
🖨 Printed models:
Mini Stefan: www.prusaprinters.org/prints/...
Chromatic Vase: www.myminifactory.com/object/...
Christmas Tree: www.thingiverse.com/thing:191...
🎥 Related videos:
DIY Dual Color Filament: • 3D-Print Your Own Fila...
CHT Nozzle: • Does This make Volcano...
DIY High-Flow nozzle: • My High Flow Nozzle is...
Mixing Hotend: • Add dual extrusion wit...
Belt Extruder: • This 3D PRINTABLE Extr...
📖 Further Links & References:
Core Heating Patent: worldwide.espacenet.com/paten...
⚙ My gear (Affiliate Links):
🎥 CAMERAS & LENSES
Panasonic GH5 - Professional 4k60 camera: geni.us/LMN0CmS
Panasonic GX80/GX85 - Great value system camera: geni.us/M2Sm
30mm f2.8 macro - Great Macro Lens (80% of my videos): geni.us/vEwqD
10-25mm f1.7 - Awesome Lens: geni.us/ZTBH
12-35mm f2.6 - Great Allround Lens: geni.us/S9GOsr
14-140mm f3.5-5.6 - My go-to travel Lens: geni.us/fSAyKo
25mm f1.4 - Nice prime for photography: geni.us/mqWM
🎙AUDIO
Rode Video Mic Pro - Shotgun mic: geni.us/6JFRdJ
Rode Film Maker Kit - Wireless mic: geni.us/XMD2N
Rode NT-USB - Studio Mic: geni.us/YVONvy
🔴 LIVE STREAMING
Elgatoo Stream Deck: geni.us/ppIiAL
Elgatoo HDMI USB Capture Card: geni.us/imhD
Logitech C920 - Overhead camera: geni.us/ViVgB
Follow me on Twitter: / cnc_kitchen
Follow me on Instagram: / cnckitchenyt
Chapters
00:00 Introduction
0:52 Co-Extrusion Filaments
1:37 High Flow Nozzles
3:46 Über Volcano Nozzle
8:37 Flow Test
9:46 Summary
#3Dprinting #diy #nozzles 
Наука
Could mixing nozzles be useful?
Could you bypass the patent by having the nozzle two part? lets call it a heat zone instead, seperate it from the nozzle itself and bingo. Patent avoided, this is how patents lead to innovation. Lets do this. Having a heatzone with internal heating "fins" or wires is here by free for all. Refer to this post as prior art in relation to any potential lawsuits!
@@ET_AYY_LMAO This is actually a really good idea!
@@ET_AYY_LMAO Isn't this what Stefan did in one of the last videos? ruclips.net/video/TdndOILeaIo/видео.html
Could be very interesting for designers. But as well for functional gradient materials with variable stiffness.
Man, full CMYK coloring would be something to behold.
hey stefan, i think the melting performance of the über-volcano would be even better if you wouldn't have milled the sides down. the milled down surfaces reduce the contact area with the heater block thus reducing heat transmission.
just add more solder before re-cutting threads. Need to find some silver solder that can handle higher temperatures.
I agree. And to create a flat spot to start the drill, screw the nozzle in a M6 nut. Then drill through the nut and the nozzle, and remove the nut afterwards.
True although it does help start the drill. My suggestion though would be to plunge the end mill only in the locations you plan on drilling the holes and use an end mill only a little bit over the size that you plan to use for the drill bit.that way the solder completely fills the hole and you get full contact. I also wonder if you can get a steel Volcano nozzle. That way you could install steel wires and braze them or weld them in rather than using solder that has a melting point so close to the plastic. This would also allow you to increase the temperature and or use higher temperature plastic.
Interrupted threads don't appear to be a problem, but might be better served with just a 1mm slot on each side compared to a full reduction, yes. Which incidentally... might allow affixing the wires in a different way: don't drill through but stick it into the other side, then bend up the wire into the channel before soldering it in.
Depends. As long as the heat transfer into the nozzle is >= the heat going into the filament then it doesn't matter. Think of the nozzle as a bucket with a hole in it. And the heat flowing into the nozzle as a hose filling the bucket with water. You can restrict the hose as much as you want as long as it flows at least as much water as the hole in the bucket then the bucket will never empty.
As long as you can fill the bucket as fast as the hole can drain it then the bucket will stay full. He only needs as much heat transfer into the nozzle as the nozzle transfers into the filament. If this happens then the temperature of the nozzle won't drop.
If you want to keep the bit from wandering, make an M6 nut with 3 sides, and tighten the nozzle inside. Then you can use the flats of the nut as your drill point without having to sacrifice the threads on the side of the nozzle.
It's essentially just making a drill bush, but for a radial drilling direction instead of an axial direction.
You could just drill a hole in a normal nut and rotate into position, drill and rotate it again, repeat till you have all the holes drilled.
@@samthenerf both are really smart ideas
@@samthenerf Good idea. Better still, a square nut (maybe a long one, made from a bit of brass bar) with a longitudinal split right through one side, and the guide hole drilled opposite the split. Then when you tighten the vice it'll flex and clamp the nozzle threads. Jig and fixture all in one! Bonus marks if one side is rounded so that the flexure of the jig doesn't affect the grip of the vice jaws.
Could also just spotface each hole with a small center cutting end mill and a slow feedrate. Or even just use a chunky center drill barely enough to get past the threads.
Smart Idea - I think this is how it would work just fine....
A standard M6 nut is just fine though - not even something to make.
FYI US patent laws place no restrictions on personal experimentation with patented ideas. Only if you started selling something would it matter. The whole purpose of the patent system is to encourage inventors to disclose their ideas in exchange for patent protections so that other people can understand and improve on the idea.
I’ve seen a lot of misconception about this in the 3D printing community (that said, I know nothing about German law).
Excellent job as always and very informative video!
Just seperate nozzle and heatzone. make special heatzone, then use bog standard nozzles in the end, boom patent avoided, and hereby declared public domain!
The ultimate nozzle soldering would be to braze the wires in place. The brazing temperature is around 450 °C
Or even better yet use a press fit connection and superheat the nozzle before placing it.
I wouldn't want to braze brass, ie, it's a pain if the filler and parent metal melt at the same temp because the whole nozzle can melt. Sliver solder would be better, or even 99% high tin solder.
I personally would just peen the wire ends to seal them, or centre punch the ends so they expand.
@@SidneyCritic good point. I just looked it up and brass melts at around double the temperature of brazing solder. Brazing copper tubing and brass fittings is common in HVAC applications
@@nrdesign1991 It's more a thermology thing. Like some people classify silver soldering brazing because some SS is brass coloured. Where as I classify brazing as welding with brass, ie, the same material. When you weld cast iron with high grade brass rods, the weld can be so hard that when it cools/shrinks it can crack the base metal.
You are perfectly correct in saying there is fillers that will melt at a higher temp than solder, but not as high as the parent metal.
@@SidneyCritic you could just hit it with a TIG torch and tack it real quick and that'd be good enough if the hole was not loose around the wire
Your Über Volcano nozzle looks sooooooooo tempting to try out! Wonder what the flow rate would be at 0.6 and 0.8 nozzle diameter, getting close to the supervolcano but much less mass? Exciting!
Or do this with a super volcano nozzle. Could get some truly insane volumetric flow rates
Hey Stefan! I'm unsure if it's already been commented, but one idea I have for increasing turbulence in the flow is to offset the copper wires from the center of the flow path by a little. This would cause uneven resistances down each side path, leading to slight travel time differences of the split fillament, and when compounded with the 120° rotations might work well enough to cause some sorts of mixing. Varying the amount of offset for each wire would likely work even better as it'll introduce some chaos to the paths the filament needs to flow down. Just a thought! Good luck with the CMYK mixer idea!
Wow, that Uber Volcano looked insane.
You could probably make a solderless wire insert by drilling out the holes to exactly the same size or slightly less than the wire being added then freezing the wire (to shrink it) so it fits. As the wire heats back up to room temperature it will create a very good metal-metal contact. Essentially the same thing you would do with fitting bearings or bushings.
The biggest issue I could see with that is that brass (ie the nozzle) has a slightly higher thermal expansion than copper, so might loosen the wire at printing temperatures.
Aluminium has a slightly higher coefficient than brass, but of course has lower thermal conductivity than copper.
Just food for thought regarding the manufacture of home made CHT-esque nozzles
When we are trying to get good mixing in our pellet extruders we choose our dual 20mm extruder with about 10 stages of mixing sections. These are very extreme mixing sections, they look like aggressive toothed sections, and we introduce our fillers at different stages.
So you're saying that having something more like teeth in the flow path will create more mixing/turbulence?
@@infernaldaedra I think it would help with turbulence at least since the rounded wire acts more as a speed bump and just slows down the flow a bit instead of causing a lot of mixing/turbulence. Something more chaotic, a bladed shaped obstruction could be used to push the flow from side to side thus causing more turbulence instead of just a speed bump effect of the rounded wire.
Thanks for the interesting video! To drill holes in the uber volcano nozzle, you can take an aluminum hex jig, inside which you make a threaded hole for the nozzle, and drill holes perpendicular to the centerline that will guide you when drilling the nozzle.
Have you thought about using your router to mill slots in the threaded section of the nozzle? you could insert copper "blades" with sharpened edges to reduce resistance and increase surface area for heat transfer.
I was thinking he could possibly just file the wire down a little bit before inserting it
working with microfluidic devices for a while as well as trying to make my own microfluidics mixers, I truly feel home with your video. Thank you like always for your quality content, friendly delivery and top notch video quality
The answer is simple, stick copper wires through your bread roles
Love these experiments!!! This why it's my favorite channel
You could have made the holes entering obliquely instead of vertically to further increase surface area whilst maintaining a shorter piece
Good point, it looks like that is what they do in the patent too.
The CMYK extruder idea sounds like a fun (but potentially frustrating) project! I wonder if it’s been done before, if not it certainly should be :)
it has been done many years ago. It's called the Diamond Hotend, and there's 3 and 5 color ones. See my post further up for my experiences with it! ;-)
Man I love this concept, let's crank up that flow! Thanks for the shout out :D
Thanks for your great design!
Loving these videos about not only the dual color filament but also these home made nozzles! Keep it up! Really interesting thought experiments and results!
Wow, really surprising results! Great work on testing this concept to the extreme. Love your videos!
AWESOME! As always :) Keep up the great work, Stefan - I really appreciate it...
This is an amazing channel, keep up the outstanding work!!!
Awesome and thorough work as always!!
GREAT video of the highest quality ‼️
Your explaining skills are superb! 👍
Along with great use of visual aids! 😊
(Loved your Rundstück example!) 🥰
This channel always amazes me
That is such a cool looking filament!!!
Fascinating! Thank you, as always! :-D
Truly, you are doing some fascinating work and education materials for everyone to watch, which I am truly glad that you are here with us, stay safe and be healthy, my dear friend. ❤
1. Use silver plumbing solder, goes a lil hotter and is stronger. It also conducts more heat.
2. Use a torch to get the whole thing hot, the just let the solder wick in.
3. This is great. I'll post some of my custom nozzles once I get my printer working again.
4. Patent laws don't apply until you sell it. Experiment away!
Patent laws often still apply if you mod a nozzle and then start selling things made with that printer.
First time commenting on your channel. The Uber Volcano looked fantastic. Thank you for all of your efforts and videos. They are a great inspiration for 3D printing and building in general. Keep up the good work.
Awesome! Thank you!
I appreciate the sacrifice of a roll to demonstrate your point.
Well done Stefan!
This video has insane production quality!
that mosaic blur intro made me giggle because I am a child. incredible stuff as always
You present the topic as a mature experimental physicist. You have attracted outstanding comments from your viewers which are a treat - no crappy comments. Well done, Stephan.
Wow! Just awesome!
In US and Canada, you can build prototypes out of any patent. You just can't sell products made from patents.
Pretty cool that I made it into the video. I actually found out on my own when I bought some green/white quantum for Christmas prints. If you have a large flat surface and use a octagram spiral for a top or bottom pattern it looks amazing.
Happy to include you 😉
That was super-interesting! 😊👍
Nice! I did a similar test with a 2mm nozzle from 3D Solex and had the same results! Great video!
LOL - Burnt Rolls! Love your work !!!
Contenu tout mignon, merci Stefan ❤️
I wonder about if you were to put slots in the walls of the nozzle threading and put a DE safety razor as what would split the filament rather than the soldered copper wire @CNC Kitchen? I also think putting flat sides on the Uber volcano would have a negative effect on "even" heat transfer.
1. If you want to drill holes in surfaces that are not perpendicular to the drill, consider using a center drill.
2. You could tap the cross holes and use threaded stock instead of round wire. This would increase contact with nozzle and filament.
3. In the US, as long as you don't sell (in this case) the nozzle you can build and use whatever you want.
Finally, your videos are uniformly excellent. Thank you.
very good job!
Hi Stefan.
Great video. I did my thesis on the topic of static mixing nozzles in college and thought I’d share my findings.
We tested the three-way Diamond hotend extruder you showed(10:12), the Zmorph dual filament head, the M3D Quad Crane nozzle, and finally a custom metal 3D printed nozzle with a static mixing design similar to epoxy mixing nozzles you showed(4:25).
Although the Dimond hotend, Zmorph and M3D Quad Crane fed several colored filaments into a single chamber, they didn’t add any turbulence or mixing agent to mitigate the “toothpaste effect” where colors were only visible at certain angles.
The 3D printed metal nozzle with epoxy mixing design by far had the best results. Would be happy to share images but can’t post pics on RUclips comment.
The ultimate pitfall that kept from continuous printing was leakage due to significant back pressure from from forcing the two filament through the mixing chamber. We never tested a dual-colored filament like the one you tested. Feeding this single filament could reduce back pressure and allow for continuous printing, just an idea.
Best,
Noah
P.S. I’ve been a big fan of your channel for years, thank you for your contributions to the 3D community.
Diamond hotend tutorial is something what im waiting for! I couldn't find full guide anywhere.
I'm sure I am not the first to think of this. But I have not seen it mentioned, and I have watched 8,000 videos about 3d printing.
The idea is that as you print layers (arbitrary for example) 9, 10 and 11, you leave holes or slots in strategic places. Then on layer 12, you pump those holes full of hot filament and you have effectively created a rivet that securely connects layers 9-12 and improves layer adhesion.
You have run across this idea before? Willing to test it?????
Thanks for another great episode.
What a cool idea. Maybe send this idea to CURA so they can test it and maybe implement the idea into their software.
@@andreaspoulsen8017 I'm hoping Stefan spots it and goes on to test it. He has plenty of expertise to do it. If it works I would approach Cura at that time.
Great, thanks!
When drilling holes, use a M6 nut predrilled as a guide. Works like a charm
It would seem that removing the material from the nozzle would reduce contact surface area thereby reducing the amount of heat transfer. I wonder how much heat transfer is lost on the flat surface areas and if the flow would be much better with less material being removed?
I Love the experiments. You can learn so much from doing them.
Nice! I asked for this! I am glad you did it. EDIT: really surprised by the outcome.
Gotta love engineers: the only type of crazy people to film bread heating with a thermal camera.
Proud to be of that species.
Also that censored print at the start is very suggestive, love it.
Looks great! Now to get a bit of filament ....
This is awesome, I look forward to messing around with this. So glad your always pushing the industry further and testing with great accuracy. Could you talk about or look into wether or not keeping consistent volumetric flow rate close on all areas or none of them (ex: I find it is good to keep the volumetric flow rate close to equal from infill to walls, which even though sensors show not much change in temp I feel the nozzle it self would still loose some temp if only a micro second, but that micro second can be the difference between good and exquisite walls and start lines) learned some information about this from the channel Pro3D.
Another cool video. Can I ask where the video is on the prusament pc blend carbon is? Very curious on this filament, especially after your great standard pc blend video.
I would love to see how profiling the copper wire would do for the flowability and heat performance. Something like a tear drop or hydrofoil since the CHT nozzle has sharp ingress dividers.
What if the wires are slanted along the flow direction?
This is quite fascinating, and that Uber Volcano is something you'd expect to see in nightmares.
This gonna be good
Did E3D actually send you a Revo beta to test? Would be curious to see its volumetric flow against all other nozzles you tested so far.
Any thoughts on a nozzle system which would allow end users to create their own dual color filament. Rather than feeding in one filament that is already dual color the nozzle would take two filaments and line them up next to each other.
Basically a kind of a Diamond nozzle which he shows at the end could probably create this effect. There are also dual nozzles around.
Won't such wide (why so wide?) flat sides reduce the thermal conductivity (of the heat block to the nozzle)?
What if you used a Tesla-valve in reverse? It'd obviously result in a lot of resistance and thus slow flowrate, but I would expect it to cause turbulance.
Hi, have considered using heatsinks and fans on the stepper motors for any of your FDM/FFM 3D printers?
You can use a spot drill to start the hole, and/or mill a tiny flat spot with a small end mill and drill into that. You have the cnc capability to that would be easy to do!
How does the copper dimetallic heatbreak compare to a conventional (steel?) heatbreak in these tests? Is it closer to a volcano nozzle or is it about the same as a standard heatbreak?
Hi Stefan! I have some advice for your frozen bread rolls from some tests that I conducted a few months ago. Based on my findings, going for a lower temperature and a longer time will usually always improve bread quality, however, the temp-time ratio often is dependent to the volume of the bread since a bigger volume will need a longer time for the heat to reach the middle. That's all. great vid as always hope my advice helps!
So, to get a faster printing, we should use thinner filaments!
I think it's great that you show the mistakes as well.
Milling down the sides of the über volcano nozzle probably reduced the heat conduction into the nozzle somewhat. If you can figure out how to drill holes without milling the sides down, maybe your nozzle would perform even better.
Also the wire arrangements and the shal of the wire could be significantly improved :) I think this could actually be a very practical concept.
@@infernaldaedra I'm not clear what "shal" means, but I think if the wire was made to have an elliptical or even rectangular cross section, even more heat could be transferred into the filament by the wires, due to the increased surface area.
Could you take 3 of your modified volcano hotends mounted to a center feeding modified volcano with a very large tip. But mount the 3 so that they are not injecting straight in but at an angle to induce a vortex. Would this cause the dual color filament to wrap around the center feeding filament or mix it all together?
Is there a way to make a blade of copper than can be press inserted into the interior of a nozzle to achieve filament melt performance ?
Hi Stefan, I got some Dichromatic filament a while back and I am interested to know if you ever had a case where the lines of color change during the print i.e. colors being where they shouldnt be. would be great to hear from you
The mosaic censor in the intro caught me off guard for a second... 😳
Super! Why not cut screw thread only near holes?
The dual color filament combined with 3d printing layer lines is actually a pretty convincing illusion of an anisotropic material.
Not specifically anything like iridiscence or pearlescence or brushed metal but something vaguely in that realm.
You touched on it briefly, when you mentioned the 'smooth' copper wire, but one of the features of the static melt mixers that you show at 4:38 are sharp corners. The corners provide places for eddies to form from.
At 6:25 you can see one of the copper wires wasn't soldered at all.
When I saw the title I was like the flow is going to remain laminar. Then watched the video and was yeah exactly as expected.
Just seen a video on how strong Phrozen Nylon resin is. Could you do a video of that in the future?
Would be really keen to see the 3-in-1-out nozzle performance for color changing and perhaps for color mixing.
Over the holiday break, I printed some roses in Matterhackers Quantum dual-color filament. With the silk effect they look stunning. So much so, that I had to order another color so I could have half a dozen in a vase with different color variations (raspberry/gold and raspberry/silver). Nearly every color was out of stock until Feb, maybe indicating how popular this filament type is right now. It's a good thing that these high flow nozzles don't mix the colors.
I'd like to find a way to print with bands at different height having alternating perimeter print direction, so that an color stripe effect can be achieved, but I can't find a slicer that provides control over this. Anyone got any ideas?
There is some really interesting physics going on here, it's awesome
Thanks alot for this...saved me alot of work trying to get mixing from my Geeetech a10m...I guess the higher viscosity of filaments makes it pretty much undoable...
Would threading the ID of the nozzle help?
Interesting video
Have you heard of the Cetus2 from tiertime, which can coextrude on its own and do these effects without special filament, and if so, whats your opinion?
Very very cool
Would be interesting to try multi color printing by rotating the y table or the nozzle itself around the z axis.
Do you think crimping the 0.8mm wire in the nozzle, with like a pair of tweezers, would do any different? You'd be making the wire into more of a tear drop shape, so it might cut down on resistance. (barring that the flowing plastic doesn't crush the tear drop into something worse.)
Your machining is pretty good. Id like to see you try skipping the soldering an use press fit pins, that wouldn’t need to go all the way through. Copper might be too soft though.
I’m curious if you could cut a v shape into the copper wire and solder it in facing up so it has an easier time cutting the filament?
what CNC do u use? Can I ask for the brand and model?
I saw the pun you threw in there. Nice work.
I tried making a diy CHT nozzle by just cutting a piece of copper sheet metal the width of the nozzle inlet and sticking it in there, theoretically splitting the flow in two. It seemed to work, I was printing pretty fast and thick in petg with no issues. That was actually the reason I went with this method - petg temps are too close to solder melting temps for my comfort.
Just to clarify, you can build anything patented that you want, you just can’t legally sell it.
What if you print multiple strands of rainbow silk pla at once with a nozzle that accepts multiple strands?
Silk is pretty weak it would probably look awesome but have poor adhesion.
Hey Stefan i have a question i cant find the answer to but you may know it! Do you know what size tap i need for an ender 3 v2 heater block?
What Layer hight are you using?
You got any place to buy a cht nozzle in the 🇺🇸?
What solder do you use? Would like to have to a go at your diy nozzle.
i wonder how much carbon/glass/and glow filled filament will last before destroying a cht? or will it???
You could spot mill circles in the nozzle and drill a tight hole, then just centre-punch the wire ends to expand them and seal the holes.