THE LAST OF US Episode 9 Side By Side Scene Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 мар 2023
- THE LAST OF US Episode 9 Side by Side Scene Comparison from The Last Of Us Game and TV show. This video includes all the scenes taken almost word for word from the Game into the Live action TV show, The Last Of Us. This includes all the scenes between Ellie and Joel and Marlene and Joel. Including the motorway scene, the hospital scenes with the fireflies and Joel telling Ellie he swears it was all true as they arrive at Jackson, and all of the other comparisons from the Game and TV Show side by side.
#TheLastOfUs #TheLastOfUsEpisode9 #EndingExplained #Episode9 #TrailerBreakdown #TheLastOfUsBreakdown #endingexplained #TLOUEpisode9 #TheLastOfUsEndingExplained #EpisodeBreakdown #HBO #EasterEggs #LastOfUs #Theories #TLOU #Joel #Ellie #Marlene #fireflies #scenecomparison #gamecomparison #sidebysidecomparison
If you enjoyed this video then please subscribe to the channel / @heavyspoilers
If You Want To Help Support The Channel So I Can Make More Videos Like This Please Donate Here:
/ @heavyspoilers
Check out our #shorts channel here HEAVY SPOILERS CLIPS - / @heavyspoilersclips8820
Check out our website at heavyspoilers.com/
Get some awesome Heavy Spoilers show clothes, phonecases and accessories at - shopzeroedition.com/collection...
Check out our BEST new videos below
Bad Batch Season S02E03 Breakdown - • BAD BATCH S2 Episode 3...
Ant-Man And The Wasp Quantumania Trailer Breakdown - • ANT-MAN And THE WASP Q...
The Menu Ending Explained - • THE MENU Ending Explai...
Glass Onion Breakdown - • GLASS ONION: Ending Ex...
Alice In Borderland S2 Ending Explained - • ALICE IN BORDERLAND Se...
Everything Everywhere All At Once Breakdown - • Everything Everywhere ...
Check out our best Shorts videos
The Menu Hidden Twist - • Did You Notice The Hid...
Troll Ending Explained - • TROLL Netflix Ending E...
Mantis Clues Explained - • Why we knew about this...
/* ---- SOCIAL MEDIA ---- */
Follow Us On Social Media At:
Website - heavyspoilers.com/
TikTok - www.tiktok.com/@heavyspoilers...
Twitter - / heavyspoilers
Instagram - / heavyspoilers
Facebook - / deffinitionmc
Follow our team at -
Host Paul - / heavyspoilers
Host Jared - / jaredbuckendahl
Editor Steesh - / steeshhaggie
Editor Matt - / superheronexus
/* ---- VIDEO INFORMATION ---- */ 
Развлечения
Check out our full breakdown here - ruclips.net/video/q2-Egs56y_I/видео.html
Casting Ashley Johnson, the voice of Ellie from the game, as the mother of Ellie in the opening scene of this ep was such a treat!
She actually cried when she got a call from Craig and Neil that she will be ellie mother on last of us tv series
😢
As a child actor she was in Lionheart, a surprisingly decent Jean Claude Van Damme film from the early 90s.
Oh I was so confused, I heard Ellie but it didn't make sense to me why! That's awesome
Yea, when she was grunting it reminded me of playing as ellie in part 2 lol
Man that ending takes me back to when I first finished the game just sitting there in silence thinking “what happens now?” And of course it took years to get that answer. The wait was brutal.
I'm guessing you need to wait a lot longer for the second season.They need bella to grow up to play grownup ellie
@@saadsarwar8123 She won't grow up. She's 19 she won't change now
@@AlexYBITW No way she's staying like this she looks like every other 14/15 year old
@@saadsarwar8123 She's done growing. That's just how Bella Ramsey looks, she looks way younger than her real age and she's won't change now.
@@saadsarwar8123next season will probably be next year the game took 7 years to make part 2
I like how in the show Marlene goes "but Joel what would ELLIE decide" as though she bothered or would have bothered giving her that option to begin with.
True, it's not for Marlene to say that but it's still an important point to consider
This also happens in the game. The dialogue is different but the message is the same.
i was about to give a comment but it would kind of spoil a relatively minor part of the second game so i wanted to know if you've played it before going further. Have you?
The implication in both the show and game is that Ellie would want to make the sacrifice. "Being the cure" was what she believed was her purpose. The show dialogue is a little smarter in that respect in that it asks us to consider Ellie's thoughts in the matter unlike the game, but the answer is still the same.
@@andrewukadike3433 any sane human will save humanity
The way Ellie laughed with the giraffe and how Joel looked at Ellie in the show. Beautiful stuff. I’m so glad we got this adaptation. It’s stuff like this that gives me hope for proper adaptations.
except she's hideous lmao
Oh for sure, this show is definitely a move in the right direction for video game adaptations and I'm really happy it exists but I do think the game is much better. The show skimmed over a lot of Joel & Ellie's bonding and it was harder for me to feel for their relationship in the show vs the game
its not as perfect one but its good as it gets.
@@plaguedoctor4519 as someone whose watching the show but has never played the game (planning to though!) I feel I can see the their bonding beautifully! With how Joel is slowly getting less uptight and ellie becoming more reliant but also less reliant at the same time if that makes sence 💀
@@maygacha4066 that's awesome you were able to buy into it naturally, but I promise once you play the game there are more events, and even during gameplay, that will build onto their bonding much more and I feel like the game really goes out of its way to show it and earn that relationship better if that makes sense. Not saying the show is bad!! This show was a fun ride and as a Last of Us game veteran who has played it multiple times, everything the show ADDS that's not in the game doesn't feel forced but feels like it was added with care and really feels like a fantastic addition that adds more weight to characters and the world that was much needed. But everything the show does when it's adaptating the game, it isn't bad by any means, I just think the game does it a bit better
Bummer they didn't leave in "i'm still waiting for my turn"...such a gut wrenching line that was so powerful in the game.
Ikr
Game is still better
@@hasanraheemdamorkwas5666 Can't deny this is one of the best video game adaptations if not the best though. They really did the game justice.
Her delivery of the "Swear to me" wasn't as stressed either. Unfortunate, i felt like this was some really defining dialogue for her character and the following events.
@@ZarisWhiteFoot No not even close, you have Arcane.
This is the way to adapt a game to a TV show. Stay true to the source material while expanding and adding more concepts.
Yeah. But i feel like they’ll need either two seasons or 12-15 episodes just to adapt Part II.
@@benwasserman8223 Really depends on how they'll pace it. I hope they don't rush it.
Don’t do part 2 please.
@@jareton why not?
The side by side comparison proves that this game didn’t need an adaptation.
I wish the finale was two episodes in length. A lot of it was rushed, but they did nail it.
Forreal. Wish we could have got at least an 1:30.
@@meza7980 we literally did though….
yea, kinda rushed.I was expecting a lot from this episode but to be honest is my least favorite.
@@noxe6413I liked all the episodes but Joel and Ellie escaping the hospital just didn't match the energy 😢
Rushed? There was little to nothing they cut out. They had no reason to make this two episodes in length whatsoever.
It's super interesting seeing how Merle Dandridge's performance is different, much colder and more calculated in the TV show. Amazing.
Who is that?
@@obunkystaindshe plays marlene
@@obunkystaind Marlene's actress on both the game and the show
Oh yeah, she definitely gave off a more cold feel in the show then she did in the game.
Honestly think it's just the changes in the lines. The show took out some nuance in the dialogue.
i love how they did the giraffe scene!!! it was a MUST!
They even kept the same music! Nice touch
Loved it? Is this just a fake comment.
@@Lolp821 Why don't you ki
All Gone (No escape) playing as Joel goes T-800 on the fireflies was amazing. I wanted more of that scene so badly.
Yes!
The bass on that scene was 🤌🏼
Amazing soundtrack
Yes. This show didn't capture the brutality enough. You never see joel use a brick to bash in a soldiers face. And they left two of the nurses alive which i think a lot of the players don't do. So what, he kills all the fireflys but these two nurses are a step too far? They didn't capture his brutality.
@@nathanlee7330 they didn't capture it? Seriously? Lmao
When Ashley Johnson was on in the beginning of the episode, did anyone else mistake her for Ellie simply because her voice is so iconically Ellie? I was like, "what is Ellie doing right now in the brush," had to remind myself that Ashley was someone else on the tv show lol
She needs to play Ellie in Season 2
Fr man I thought this was a grown up Ellie I mean she'd sure as hell fit the looks and voice of an older Ellie
@@soulofsomething6651 how? She's a grown woman
This is EXACTLY what happened to me 😂
I think the actress playing the mother resembles the actress playing Ellie very well (face shape etc). Which made it really believable for it to be her child as she grew up. That was a nice touch, intentional or not.
Notice the difference in how Joel shoots Marlene vs Pedro... Pedro is shooting a blank so he doesn't prepare for the kick, but if you really notice Joel, he leans into it, to control the shot and put her down. It is raw and targeted and intentional. I love it.
Good observation. It's these details that make the game even better than the HBO adaptation
Yeah, made it feel less natural and honestly pulled me out for a quick second
Interesting fact- the mocap giraffe from the game died a few years back, but they used his son for the TV giraffe. He said he was honored and hopes his take on the portrayal of Giraffe 1, while different, stays tue to the source material.
lol
It strikes me how Bella's and Ashley's performances are recognizably different, yet both interesting and compelling in their own unique ways.
Yeah Bella is a bit angrier and she is changing personality nuances far more than Ashley’s Ellie. The result is Ashley’s Ellie feels like more of her actually believes the lie at this point in time while Bella is mostly forcing herself to believe it. Either way - same result and very interesting
Obviously, the game told the overall story much better (it's the source, surprise!). But what the show was able to show in 9 episodes is plenty good enough to warrant it the best video game adaption to date.
I mean the shows not even close to the emotions the game creates, but its ok
@@Hitomankiri yeah the show is better.
@@Hitomankiri Not really the Show does beat the game in some scenes and the game vice versa.
mortal kombat 1995 was better. tomb raider movies. there were good videogame adaptions
that bar isnt that high tho
but yeah
This implies that tv show Joel might be more brutal than game joel cause In the elevator you get shot at on the way but in the tv show Joel killed everyone except for the female doctors he went ballistic on the firefly soldiers no one shot at him when he went to the elevator
They made him more brutal on purpose to better tie into Part II. Part II tries to spin him off as a villain. There's a lot of ambiguity in the original game that gets completely thrown out the window with this adaptation. In the game there are journal/audiologs that definitely states that Ellie isn't the only immune survivor, which sets the stage for Joel knowing that any surgery isn't a sure thing for finding a cure. Likewise in the game he isn't blasting every soul in the hospital. I still think the show is a decent adaptation but I strongly resent Neil's hamfisted writing. The reason for the first game being so great was NOT because of his "genius".
@@RamblingHermit Agreed, Joel justification for killing everyone and "saving" Ellie in the show was kinda lame....
@@RamblingHermit Exactly, it's a shame but well...
There’s just less fireflies in the tv show compared to the game or they just never made it to Joel in time. When Joel gets Ellie out of the room in the game, alarms have gone off and the whole hospital has been alerted including everyone patrolling outside or in other floors, keeping in mind the hospital and surrounding area is massive and this is one of the Fireflies main bases, not to mention the shootout was at night in the game as opposed to daytime in the show. For example Abby and all of her friends (7 people all stationed at the hospital) did not know what happened until like 10 minutes later meaning there probably was a decent amount of people outside and around the hospital
@@RamblingHermit this is very true
Can’t believe it’s already over😢
Same
Get ready for Abby
Yes and knowing where the story goes I most likely won't watch season 2
@@anthonyp9562 yeah I don’t think I can handle the second game again
@@bruhmomentum8302 lmfaoooo
...this just gives me even MORE appreciation for the actors of the game. Both performances are amazing, but the game is next level, still...in 2023. Bravo!
We gotta remember how rare performances like this were in 2013. While there were examples of great voice acting in the late 90s and the 2000s, I believe the Last of Us set the stage for these big-budget storytelling games to come with its combination of more natural performances and motion capture, building on the foundation of the past Uncharted games.
Because it got a remake on PS5, but the 2013 original is still fantastic.
@@RustCohle072 the performances are the same though
I like the show more
@@RustCohle072that’s just graphics and some gameplay stuff
Omg the real VA of marlene doing the scene in a live show its come full circle although i prefer the game way of handling it compared to the show. This show is still the best video game adaptation ever
"You'd just come after her." That was the single most chilling moment of any video game I've ever played. I remember how shook I was at that moment playing the game release week 2013. The show had its flaws but I thought they did the ending some real justice. Seeing that scene in particular again years later had the same effect, even knowing it was coming.
Having played the game and watched the show, I think the show was better. I liked that in the show, Joel was not just some killing machine and that took out every person they saw. Both of their acting was brilliant in the show. I really can't wait for the second season
Pascal delivered this line like a robot. It was horrible in the last episode. His line deliveries were off.
@@TheMrGiannisgr the ability to speak does not make you intelligent. Now get out of here.
@@TheMrGiannisgr It's not off, you're just biased because you know the game by heart. The only few people criticizing the deliveries are people who played the game when everyone else is talking about how Pedro and Bella could win Emmys :v
This episode made me realise that the Fireflies made the mistake of not telling Ellie the truth. Letting Joel speak to her one last time would have been the way to go, Ellie would have wanted to sacrifice herself. Holding him hostile was a big L
Really good point. They know how dangerous Joel is. But I suppose they didn't know how close the two of them got so probably didn't need to anticipate him going all murder hobo.
Joel would have killed them all anyway. Any choice that led to Ellie's death he'd have fought tooth and nail to prevent, whether she wanted it or not.
@@ElPayasoMalo not if he had discussed it with Ellie first... If Ellie told him she wanted to go under the knife despite losing her life, he'd have honoured what she wanted.
Thought the same way 10 yrs ago and again today after finished ps5 version of it.
@@renderpeach Absolutely not. Joel made it clear that he'd always take her away from the Fireflies even if given a chance to redo it and knowing for sure she'd rather him not do it, indicating that he doesn't regret his actions and is unconcerned about how she personally feels about it. Joel did not care what she wanted, which is why he never asked her, and he KNEW she'd have wanted to go through with surgery anyway. Joel doesn't handle loss well, and after losing Sarah and then Tess, he resolved to never feel that way ever again. Joel's choice was ultimately a selfish one.
I liked how the show portrayed how Joel was warming up to Ellie but Ellie was now skeptical. Great stuff
12:27 why’s he delivering this line like a robot?
Ikr it's so bad
@@Pedro_Le_Chef I chuckled when I heard it wtf
I love the dynamic between both actors in both formats. They each got eachother so well
Episode was really good and near shot for shot similar. I had hoped for the drowning scene but all is well. Thank you for hosting. Great vid 👍🏾
Marlene: "How'd you do it?"
Joel: " Well, all this time I felt like I was being controlled by something that allows me to know where people are before they attack me and there were times when I use my hearing, everything turns gray and I could see my enemies through walls. and actually, I think I've been dead before but suddenly I woke up and I felt like I've been in a same situation and then I remember that I've died here, but this time I survived, it feels like a strange dream.
....but yea, It was all her. She fought like hell to get here."
The hearing ability doesn't work on the highest difficult (which I believe it's how it should be played), though, but there rest is pretty accurate. XD
@@NeoZeta yeah listen mode is not available if you play on survivor and grounded mode. Grounded + perma death would be most realistic. But hell naw I’m not good enough a player for that💀
@@riverjame-sv9fo Modesty aside, I can say I'm good enough. I can play grounded easily with no deaths. But you really got to know the game well to reach that point. I used to play competitively online, too. So my combat skill is/was pretty toned, but in grounded you'll have to avoid a lot of combat anyway, if you want to live.
Best comment😆
@@NeoZeta good for you ig
Both ending hospital scenes are so intense
It's amazing how Merle Dandridge has been playing Marlene since the first game. She also did the last of us on stage one night special, the last of us 2 in a flash back scene and now the series ❤️
It's "the look" at the hospital when Joel decides to take Ellie. That is one of the defining moments for the character.
They left the ending just as murky and open to interpretation as the game. Well done!
But it was poorly executed
They rushed the whole hospital part and honestly the whole show was just a low detail story telling.
You get more better story by just watch ing the game’s cutscenes. They left a lot of details that were a big deal in the story.
The photo of Joel and Sarah
the doctor who tells him think about all the lives we’ll saves.
Joel telling Ellie he’s got her while he’s running from the fireflies.
Joel face of fear and guilt when he’s carrying her out of the room.
Joel toured the fireflie to get info to where they have her while has a line that did work in the show cus he just shoots the guy that gave him attitude when he asks in the game the guy refused but Joel shoots him and makes him talk.
The last episode was just weak out of the whole show.
Yeah but I’m betting S2 opens with the perspective if one character who sees Joel’s choice in VERY black and white terms.
@@alexisdealejandro6836 honestly, I agree. The final episode felt rushed, like the show makers just quickly wanted to get over with Season 1 as fast as they can
Hopefully Season 2 will be much better, and they will try to subvert our expectations. Instead of having Joel and Tommy make a stupid decision and have Abby kill everyone and win
@@alexisdealejandro6836 I disagree with u tbh. I liked the fact that Joel in the show just said “fuck it” and killed the fireflies to get to ellie. He aint have time to torture, and he didn’t care about hearing any doctor’s sob story. He said gimme ellie right tf now, and got her. Ending was fire tbh
@@alexisdealejandro6836 Very well said. It wouldn’t have even taken much more time to include those crucial moments, interactions, and emotions in the show that really set the tone for why Joel is doing what he is doing and how its tearing him up inside making those decisions. I feel like even in the games cutscene you can see so much more emotion and so much more uncertainty in the faces of the characters. Even when Joel is leaving the elevator, the face he makes shows that he understands what he is giving up for the sake of his love for Ellie. It’s beautiful and heartbreaking. Love this freaking game.
I loved the scenes they are adding in the show. Ellie looks exactly like her mom. For those who didnt like bella as ellie cause she looks completely different from the game, well heres your answer. Bella nailed it. Pedro nailed it. This season is a 10 for me
NONE of them look like the game. Show is crap
@@HistoryandReviews None, right, tell that to Merle Dandridge, who is the same actress that was both the voice and the character model of Marlene in the videogame lmao
Ithe video game is in every way better With Ellie than THE acting of bella.....
@@HistoryandReviewsseason 2 is gonna be garbage.
Ep 3 ,4 little bit of 5 is piece of shit
Don’t get me wrong I love the TV series and glad there’s a season 2 coming soon but I have to admit that the pacing could’ve have been better. Giving Kathleen and her group two episodes and Bill and Frank an entire 1 hour+ episode (which I loved btw) would’ve been fine if the series had more than 9 episodes but since it doesn’t it made every other story beat and dialogue in later feel incredibly rushed (the effects we see greatest here). It also took away from some of Joel and Ellie’s bonding moments and having so much time spent away from them definitely weakened their relationship compared to the game. It’s a 10/10 show for me but it really could’ve used either longer episodes, 44 minutes? Seriously? Or just more episodes
What bonding momemts are you talking about, besides them just walking around killing infected? But anyways we should get shown more bonding in season 2.
@@thatboysnarly4471 there's a lot of moments of bonding that can be mentioned, like Ellie helping Joel as a sniper, Ellie jumping down the water trusting Joel to help her after Sam/Henry leave them, Ellie running away after she discovers Joel wanted to leave her, Ellie giving Joel Sarah's photo, Joel refusing to stand down to save Ellie as the fire flights get to them after she drowns... I liked the show but I missed some of these moments that made their relationship so strong and so meaningful.
@@thatboysnarly4471 We are not really going to get a lot more bonding in the second season if they follow the story of the second game, apart from the flashbacks. More bonding this season was necessary imo.
i also hated how little infected scenes there were vs the game
agree
One thing I think they missed a trick on in this scene is the way Joel grabs the watch that Sarah gave him when he says you need to find something to live for in the game version.
"I swear."
"...okay."
One of the most powerful ending in any story telling.
It's basically the end of hope for humanity to restore the world in TLOU universe, because joel just killed the only doctor who can make the cure.
BUT, it's the beginning of a new chapter in Joel's life because he have ellie in his life, he found his new purpose.
The ONLY gripes I had with this show is the last line deliveries.
"You'd just come after her" from Pedro felt a little too neutral as opposed to Troy's.
"I swear" was perfect from both ends, but they cut that a little too quickly. In the game, Joel has more time to think for a second if he would actually tell Ellie the trith or lie to her. You can see him seem hesitant as to what he'll say. In the show its a pretty instant response and it felt a little awkward.
At the end of it all though, it's fuckin amazing. Can't wait for Part II to be adapted. The show and the game have their differences and I accept that
just finished watching the show... The line at the end crazy goosebumps...
joel goes full beast mode
Thanks for making this 👍🏾
What parent wouldn't go to these lengths to save their child? This episode tore my heart out. Of course he wasn't going to let another daughter die.
The game made me cry, the show made me sob. Ellie is who I was at 14. Just someone who is confused with their own emotions and needed someone to understand her.
well if u cry in s1, then careful while watching s2 if u can...
@@muhammedenesyavuz9419 **SPOILERS**
oh I played both games I know what’s coming and I’m still not ready :’( the show just brings it alive in such an intense way that it’s almost 10x more heart wrenching. Since you know the second game, that one part that sets the whole plot for the game literally left me silent and sobbing at the same time. I am 1000% not ready to see it in a tv adaptation
@@Deadcops so real I will cry for literal weeks
The ladder scene at 0:45, i almost had a heart attack there, that was scary 😂
Thanks a lot for making this video
Amazing editing skills, very good video!
I still don't get why Bill and Frank's episode, two characters that didn't even interacted with the main story was a 1:30 lenth, but the finale was just 40 minutes.
But for what was there, it's perfect. Joel's suicide attempt is only mentioned briefly in the game, but him actually talking about it was to me the best scene. Indirectly saying how much Ellie means to him makes his choice at the end so much heavier.
And that hospital scene, that psychopath look on Joel's face and the main theme playing on the violin was amazing, it really gave the feel of the monster he can be. Too bad that he sealed his fate by killing that doctor though
come on, you know why
@@tyler-hp7oq "The Message!"
I mean, the show is more focused on drama, world and character building. The last episode was pretty short, in my opinion, because it was pretty much going only off the source material, and didn’t really cut anything out. Bill and Frank I think was needed because of how it shows the peaceful life people can live, even in these apocalyptic settings, almost foreshadowing Jackson.
Cause the whole motif of the story is about how you and the people you care for can be trapped in a continuum cycle of violence, and the way this goes depends on the circumstances and the decisions you make. Bill and Frank's story is an example of a more compassion driven story under better circumstances and the proof that this is still possible in the world they're building, but impossible for the tainted story of Joel and Ellie.
Because the drones who made the show are "those" type of people, and it all entertainment is in the ground now, too interested in garnering critic points instead of making good shows.
Damn yall fast with the clips
Damn here early! Needed a refresher it how the game played out, I saw it so long ago.
I think the actress for Ellie in the show did a great job, but man, Ashley delivers the lines with so much more punch.
12:25/12:28 Joel Miller: You just come after her.
Very bad line delivery by Pedro Pascal.
and Joel dies naturally as an old man.. the End
I actually wrote a fanfic based on that. Inspired by Six Feet Under where he sees a vision of Sarah just before passing away.
@@kjdee140 Link
@@kjdee140 That sounds cool! Link?
Pedro Pascal did a phenomenal job as Joel, it's actually incredible just how well he managed to capture his mannerisms and personality. His performance was every bit as good as Troy's.
Should have been 10 episode but i understand budgets and time restraints
After having a few days to process the whole season, I can say the only disappointing thing was we didn't get enough interactions with the infected. When we had those scenes it was great. Great performances from the actors playing the infected.
Imagine if we had some scenes of the infected, raiders, and Joel and Ellie all trapped in a building. The humans would try to lure the infected towards their opponents.
That would have been great to see, especially in the university.
This episode was great but the game is unbeatable
I think the opposite
I'm with you, the series it's amazing but the game it's simply a masterpiece.
But even so, this is probably the best adaptation of a video game we'll gonna see.
it was an exact copy scene for scene. This one felt more real because its real people lol
They’re both crap lmao mediocre gameplay and mediocre storyline
The live action felt better, mainly because of the subtle face acting which couldn’t really be seen in the game as well, and I think that Pedro’s performance and even Bella’s are probably better than what was in the game, for this sequence at least, which isn’t an insult to the original actors but there’s much more to pick up on when it’s real people instead of voice actors with video game models
Amazing upload time!
Who was waiting on Ellie to give Joel a picture of him and his daughter Sarah ✋
She didn’t have the picture. They changed it.
I can’t believe that they show us those jiraffes but they didn’t show us Joel touching the watch just before he lied on that “i swear”. I loved the show btw
Also wish they had the part where Ellie gave Joel the picture of him and Sarah
This! I was so hoping we’d have a closeup of this due to the symbolism it represents!
They've already set it while climbing. Talking about sarah
@@revampstudios5717 They talk about Sarah while walking on the forest in the game as well, Joel looking at the watch right at the end and the scene where Ellie gives him the picture of him and Sarah and they talk a bit about Sarah’s mother would still have been a nice touch in the show, very little details that make the ending more impactful.
Same like what the hell that was such an important piece to leave out.
That "okay" means "I'm going to hold you to it. If I find out that you lied then...." It also means she NEEDS him to be telling the truth but Ellie is just so damn smart. She knows.
So many layers of meaning contained in a single word. TLOU really is smth else
It's the giraffes! 🦒 Man, they did a great job at adopting many scenes from the game.
The scenes they added in this episode were actually equally good as the game ones, the additions with Ellie's mom and the dialogue between Joel and Ellie about time healing were amazing.
I think the casting is superb. Props to the people that cast these two
And most of the other actors/actresses
I almost wish they had actually shown the actors the game scenes before acting rather than keeping their parts solely them and not watching game footage. I think some of the lines just don't come out simply as powerfully and emotionally setting up the next game (next season) as well as the game. Thats why overall the game is just far better. Yet when youv played the game, coming to the show is like a new easter egg adventure trying to find the connections that they tried very hard to put (which they did great on). I think my main problem with the show is quite literally just script lines delerverance / emotion in them. Idk :)
What I really appreciate is that the scenes are shot identical to the game.
Marlene's actress remembered her lines.
This whole show was SUPER true to the game.
Amazing work. I loved it.
I feel the show lacked a lot of the highly intensive moments that made the game shine and it really lacked infected, the shows not bad by any means but in my opinion it was rushed and is more filler for the game than anything.
More real game actor cameo, this show is amazing.
I enjoyed the show. It didn't blow me away like it has most people but I am a fan of the game first and foremost--the most affecting video game I've ever played (I'm over 50 and have been plying video games since the 1970s).
I only played the game once though but it's stuck with me.
Watching this clip, as much as I was appreciating the acting choices made by Bella Ramsey and Pedro Pascal, in my mind I kept thinking, "Man, the acting in this video game is REALLY good."
I've just finished and this was the most perfect adaptation of anything I've ever seen. Casting original Ellie as the Mum, the original clicker voice actors, showing Dina and foreshadowing Abbie's fathers importance, featuring Left Behind, all the additional backstories for the supporting characters... it was so perfect. I'm sorry I ever doubted this. It really is my favorite game and I was so nervous they'd mess it up, but hats off to everyone involved. Truly phenomenal.
I've never seen or played the game, but watching this makes me want to check it out. My husband loves this show and talks highly about the game. I understand why now.
I'm confused because it was beat-for-beat the same but I still felt like it was rushed.
Because in the game you spend alot of time walking around, and reloading guns, taking damage, dieing, hiding, and stabing.
the game has more gameplay/action so it’s going to seem rushed
Well once again they skipped the infected parts. Could’ve had at least 10 min of that before making it to the hospital
@@thatboysnarly4471no it’s because they don’t convey the emotion well enough in th show
@@thatboysnarly4471 they rushed the dialogue since the tv show has a runtime
The giraffe scene immediately broke me. So well done.
Broke you? Honestly, these comments would break those reading them.
@@Lolp821 Sorry, but I really don't care about your opinion.
The ending conversation felt so rushed as oppose to the game. It was badly paced imo. This is the end. Let the convo be slow, intentional, & let it be the forefront. Game ending is better then the tv show, based off pacing alone
Agreed, strange how they accepted that. It was so rushed. The ending in the game is so much better, acting included
Yea I agree the ending was kind of fast Tbh I really wished it was very slowed down & emotional like the game but it is what it is at the end of it 🥲🤷🏻♀️
I totally agree. It felt like I was watching The ending at x2 speed.
How slow could the ending conversion supposed to be without sounding weird?
@@KimandKamJam it just felt really rushed through tbh the game ending was far way better then this in my opinion .
It was a good show, but it felt so rushed at times. That ending felt super rushed too. You don't have damn gameplay to get back to, slow it down add to it.
I've noticed a certain bit that been cut out but I did thought between game and reality there's a reasonable causes for it that I would accept
They did it. The mad lads did it. They pulled it off. Wish it was longer, the ending and whole hospital bit was only 20 mins but it was still cool. The “you’d just come after her” line was a bit wonky and how Joel shot Jerry was just… it was just too quick, no contemplation. Jerry was also too slow with grabbing the scalpel, there should have been more urgency! But yeah apart from that I’m happy with the ending lol.
I thought killing Jerry quickly worked really well for the show. In the game its the moment where you as the player have to "decide" to pull the trigger and move forward. The preceding fight isn't so out of the ordinary compared to fighting raiders vs in the show Joel already made up his mind and Jerry is just one more firefly in the way.
I agree 100% on the final line. Troy baker delivers it with such spite and disdain and this one is so deadpan. I've read other peoples comments saying that they were going for a "terminator" vibe of Joel being emotionless in that moment butnI just feel that approach is disingenuous to the source material. When i played the final scene in the game i had to use bricks and bottles to bash in the firefly faces and the rage it evokes is so much more telling of the love he has for Ellie. Don't get me wrong. This is the best videogame adaptation ever but when compared to the source i just felt the final scene was their chance to bring more emotion into the violence. Other people have said they're trying to show how 'joel was wrong' but the whole point of the game is that you share Joel's desire to rescue Ellie. Still brilliant though.
@@colinbyrnes1000 yeah, I guess that’s true. You’re right, it does make more sense. That way there’s no focus on Jerry so people won’t think anything is off so they won’t know about the whole Abby thing when watching season 2. If they made a big deal about waiting to kill him and showing him for a longer period of time then some people who haven’t played the games would be like “who is this guy”. I still think he should have lunged to the scalpel tho
@@nathanlee7330 yeah I agree with that. Troy is an amazing actor and he voiced and acted Joel so so well in the games. Nobody can replace him. But I still agree that the show is one of the best game adaptations of all time. They did so much right. They followed the source material closely but also added a lot more depth to certain characters etc. I like the way they did everything and Pedro and Bella are amazing as Joel and Ellie. But to me there’s just two versions of Joel and Ellie now. I see both versions as being good. Neither one or the other is bad.
@@Cazammaf oh definitely, they could’ve kept the lunge and have Jerry’s posture etc match the urgency of keeping Joel from Ellie.
The game did the ending so much better. I’ve loved this show so far but I can’t help but feel like the last episode rushed through the last hour of the game too quick. The dialogue from the game that was used in the show fell flat for me a lot of the time in the finale.
The real draw of this show to me is how they’re able to expand on things from the game while staying true to it. In the last episode it felt like they were just checking off things that happened in the game without fleshing it out more like how they did with Bill and Frank.
I do still like the game's version better, but 3/4 of the last hour is stealthing/combat through the hospital. An hour of that doesn't translate to a show format.
@@Alleggsander I don’t think the shootout should have been any longer. I think the time before they get to the hospital should have been stretched out with one last infected encounter like the game.
One more obstacle before they reach their final destination is necessary for the story in my opinion. I get why they skipped over most of the gameplay segments that’s fine but there should have been more time to spend with Joel and Ellie before the ending. And the dialogue they used from the game just felt a bit lifeless to me.
Episode 8 totally won me over and then 9 completely bolts straight for the ending scene they should have slowed it down a bit. Even adding 20 more minutes to pace it out better would have helped immensely. But this show would have benefited from one or even two more episodes.
All of the original ideas just for the show were great because they added to the source material instead of changing things in a way that hurts the overall story. Any new ideas they had should have gone in before they reached the end. More time to flesh out Joel and Ellie’s journey was needed in my opinion. Still a great adaptation but the ending did not hit as hard as the game.
And the way they just randomly threw around Gustavos music that was made for specific moments was a bit disappointing.
They used the all gone track while Joel’s shooting people but not when he finds Ellie after killing David or when he is carrying her through the hospital. That track is supposed to parallel Sarah’s death it’s what plays when she dies in his arms. The show didn’t focus on that moment of Joel carrying her enough.
But I gotta admit even the hospital shootout felt a bit uninspired and lame. Show us Joel actually being stealthy and playing to his strengths as an old grizzled survivor instead of showing us a montage of him walking out in the open down a hallway mowing down trained soldiers. Even the game felt more grounded in that section.
That scene should have been intense and thrilling to watch but it wasn’t. It shouldn’t have been filmed as a montage it should have played out as an actual scene where people who didn’t play the game might actually think Joel could die but he just strolls through the place like the terminator it’s not as engaging as it could have been. At least in the game you see Joel use tactics to kill everyone.
But all in all the show really needed one more episode like the 3rd or 6th that fleshes the characters out more before the final set piece.
@@Hardrive2677 I feel like an infected encounter would’ve felt unnecessary, how would that develop the characters further or highlight the themes of the episode in a meaningful way? It would’ve just felt like filler, it works in the game because it’s engaging action gameplay, but for the show it would’ve just felt out of place and served no real purpose for the story imo. I would honestly say the show has the better ending just based on the amazing subtle facial acting alone, it added so much that couldn’t have really been achieved through just voice acting and video game models, but that’s just my preference I guess. Obviously the show wouldn’t even exist without the game so that should always be considered, but I definitely do think the show improved on a lot of aspects because the medium of film allowed for that.
@@Hardrive2677 I see where you're coming from.
Personally I was really hoping they'd tie in the 'stepping on a tendril alerts the horde' concept and having that be the cause for them fleeing, nearly drowning, then being found by the Fireflies (similar to how it happens in the game). Having them immediately caught upon entering the city and knocked out by a flashbang did feel a little like something was missing.
One point I'd argue against is that carrying her in his arms is supposed to parallel Sarah's death. I always thought Joel holding Ellie and calling her baby girl after her viciously murdering David was the parallel moment. The last time he uses the term 'baby girl' is while he's losing a daughter, while he uses it in the David moment when gaining one.
@@Alleggsander I think there were two strong parallels to the opening of the game/show. Sarahs death absolutely connects to Joel calling Ellie baby girl. But Joel carrying Ellie through the hospital also parallels when Joel was carrying Sarah after she messed up her leg from the car crash right before she gets shot. It’s just to show Joel being put in another situation where he’s desperately trying to save his daughter.
The version of all gone that we hear while Joel is shooting the fireflies in the show is the same track that plays when Joel is carrying Ellie to the elevator in the game. That moment hits harder in the game for me because of that track being used at the right time.
Crazy accurate episode. Loved it
I wish they kept the music playing over the final scene. Also the scene with Sam and Henry
I think the show added a nice touch when Joel said that the hospital was attacked by raiders so they had to rush out of there
Why are they playing the game at 2 fps?
Those blood-prevention fadeouts added to the video look like scene transitions from Full Throttle.
I really wanted Joel to touch his watch at his last dialogue.
And also Ellie looking at a statue of a deer or something when distracted when Joel was calling her name.
“You’d just come after her.” - the game version just way better 12:23
I feel like I’m the only one who though Pascal was horrible in this scene. Horrible line delivery. He’s talk8mg like a robot.
@@TheMrGiannisgrI thought pascal was pretty good throughout the show but that scene stood out as particularly bad, especially to me since it was my favorite scene in the original game
Ellie dropping the ladder was more clumsy in the show and actually feared Joel would get hurt with that. God I love the show so much
Isn't it weird how people are just so much more satisfied if an adaption actually stays mostly faithful? Who would've thunk.
Yeah it was really dumb when they butchered the whole way Sully and Nate meets in the uncharted movie which was a failure imo
Too bad we already lost Halo :(
Troy Baker and Ashley Johnson wins
Golden Globe winning show. One of the best acted shows I've ever seen. And still I think the game is better. That's proof that it's a masterpiece
watch more TV please the acting was so stiff in this dogshit adaptation
you must not watch many shows/movies
probably the first show you've ever watched huh
@@FernandesRafael1 Why do you think that?
I think the show was decent/good. One of the best acted shows? Masterpiece?? I think that’s quite a stretch.
Ashley Johnson as Ellie's mother was a great surprise!
Goddamn, that final "Okay" gave me the same emotional punch like the one I got when I finished the game the first time
This is by far the best series I've ever seen
That's pretty sad
@@victora.1329 whats the best one for you then?
@@badpiggies4926 idk it's a tough choice between The Wire, Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul, The Sopranos, Barry, Attack on Titan, and GoT (up to season 4)
The final episode was great! It was deep though, which was exciting yet heartbreaking to watch.
I effing love this shit..these actors are doing it
When Joel was walking towards the room, I keep saying "Don't kill the doctor" even though it's destined to happen
I have never played the game....I appreciate the explanation of both! To me the Series is a Brilliant...Superb...from the Actors... to the story line..the emotions.... I believed I was watching a zombie story😉....never felt such intense emotions!! Brilliant!!!
Marlene was so hypocritical throughout this whole thing, she kept saying: "Do you the right thing," but who was she to say what the right thing to do was.
She kept saying its what Ellie would want, but how could she know that when she deliberately denied Eliie the option to make that choice for herself.
It's almost like Marlene had put herself in the place of God, and that in her mind the end justified the means.
Thank you. Ellie had plans AFTER "saving the world" which means she was still expecting herself to live longer. At least Joel had a basis for his decision, however brutal.
@@mcveya6199 still doesn't change the fact that she would've sacrificed herself, proven further by part 2.
One sacrifice to potentially save the whole is worth it. And she gave the option to let Ellie decide at the end
@@maudelhoyo4019 yes, but doesn't she have the right to know what she'd expect first?
@@maudelhoyo4019 she definitely would have, but it definitely right to tell her what’s she’s going into first and let her say her goodbyes
perfect!!
This just makes me realise that the lighting in video games is more beautiful than irl lighting lol. Or maybe the lighting was just more well done in the game? The golden glow during the hopeful scenes is *chef's kiss*
Joels hair moving cause of the wind in the last scene is badass. Pedro and Bella were born to play these roles
I gotta say, they nailed it with the giraffe scene
What did they nail?
3:56 oh my god the way he's voice fades 😭
Great season 1! Do they follow how part 2 of the game goes or do they go in a different direction?
Either way Joe die next season
Didn't expect them to deliver such a splendid ep in just 43min.