I also like the way his mouth fell open around 2:39, and the way he talked so nicely about the roles of the vocalists and their growth, and even their roles in the vocal unit.
whoa you didn't watch it twice lol. I personally think that 'Thanks' is the most powerful song done by Seventeen music wise and lyrics wise. Being Carats since Predebut era makes me really notice that Seventeen is growing up a lot these days. Boi, I even teared up when I watched Thanks for the first time because it is THAT powerful and touching at the same time. I had the same reaction as you when I heard Jeonghan's part in Thanks lol because I kind of don't expect that from Yoon Jeonghan. AND ABOUT MINGHAO MY BOI, Seventeen gave him center part because of his lack of presence in Clap era😭 I really like that even though there's 13 of them, they split everything in a fair amount for next comeback like what you just mentioned the lack of main vocal in the last 2 comebacks, and suddenly Seventeen drop a vocal-heavy song. I really like this comeback!
_5 days has passed since the comeback_ _Still no signs of a new reaction video..._ _All hope that we have left - starting to fade..._ _All faith begins to diminish as well..._ _”Maybe I should just give up”_ _”At this point, it will never come...”_ _I watch more reaction videos to distract myself from the truth_ _Until..._ _”Okay, Pai, just one more LAST time”_ _(Haha... thats funny because I said the same thing an hour ago)_ _Either way, I swipe down to refresh the subscription page_ _...Nothing._ . . . . . . . . *_Wai-wait a second..._* *HE JUST FUCKING UPLOADED IT 23 MINUTES AGO WJINWOIHWIHOWH* *MIRANDAAAAAAA GET IN HERE AND STOP EXPOSING ME ONLINE* _An ambulance can be heard in the distance_ _-FIN-_
yesss josh & jeonghan were just okay vocalists when seventeen debuted but they've improved so much. i mean josh is now the Legendary Starter of Seventeen Songs and booooiiiiiiii i was not prepared for jeonghan's vocals in this comeback, i almost fell out of my chair (not joking) bc his vocal game was too strong lmao. i'm so happy that they've figured out what suits each member's talents best & using them to the team's advantage (except for jun. they figured it out in lillili yabbay but none of their songs ever since have used that beautiful-ass falsetto again. get on it, woozi + bumzu)
yesss i guess it's all about finding that correct range of vocals that each of them sound great in. Personally I find josh sounding GREAT in that Aju Nice acoustic version and Rocket. Time to bloom those talents ;)
Honestly I agree. Minghao doesn't get lines but as time has progressed - he spends more time centre stage than any other member and you can almost always see him somewhere.
my bias is minghao because of Hot but now that i’m lookin back at their older songs I can almost never see him which is very different to their newer ones
Well, I think they gave Minghao a center position because he was missing from so many performances due to health issues. Just likes they did for Wonwoo in Boom Boom. They really look out for each other!!
i agree so much about the repackaged album title tracks upstaging the original title tracks. pretty u was a great song, but nothing could've prepared us for the epicness of aju nice lmao. same w/ clap & thanks. what i love is the consistency in quality w/ the repackaged b-side songs, they don't just add 2 or 3 mediocre songs & call it a day, they always add songs almost as good as the title track
Am I the only carat who prefers pretty u to aju nice? 😂😂😂 Pretty U is the song that gets me into 17. Even mansae had no impact. It wasnt until I got into them that I appreciate mansae.
Something I find interesting is that seventeen is starting to rotate the “center” members. By that I mean early on vernon, mingyu, woozi, and maybe seungkwan were really pushed to the front the most. Now mingyu didn’t even get a close up shot in the music video and the four I just mentioned don’t get nearly as much screen time or lines as they used to. If I had to pick the “center” members that I think seventeen is promoting the most now I’d say it’s Joshua, Jun, and Jeonghan (before I feel like most people just soloed him out for his hair which is a damn shame and I’m glad he’s getting a lot more love now). Scoups, Wonwoo, Hoshi, and DK have also been really eye catching and I know many people who have gotten into seventeen because they stand out a lot. I think Dino and Minghao (even tho minghao has been getting a lot better screen/center/line distribution) are the ones who need to get some spotlight maybe through a solo project or reality show appearance soon. Dino can literally do anything - rap sing dance and is really funny while minghao’s sass and sense of humor plays out really well on variety shows, he’s a fantastic dancer, and while his voice isn’t the strongest it still has a unique tone, as proven with My I. It’s just really interesting to me as a long time fan to see how the focus has shifted, because I remember when people only knew seventeen because of vernon.
I think this choreo feels almost more powerful than Clap because of its abundance of emotion? The feelings that are portrayed through the choreography- their struggles, their hard work, their thankfulness - make me feel overwhelmed and proud whenever I watch it. ^^
Seventeen title tracks never really resonated with me (was always a B side track guy for seventeen) until 'Don't Wanna Cry', and Clap wasn't to my taste at all but then they hit me with this I feel attacked it's so good it's been on replay since release lmao
rofl exactly the same with me. never really cared for seventeen. but then don't wanna cry stood out to me, but then thanks was damn... it hooked me so hard into it. been going on a kpop reactions binge to this song
I agree with you about Manse. :) For me its one of their best comebacks. The music, the melody, the electric guitar, the dance and the wow oh wow vocals of DK and Seungkwan. If Manse was released today with the fandom being bigger than it was 2 yrs ago, it will probably be all the hype Right now Love your reaction
I am so glad to hear what you said about Aju Nice and public reaction to it because the centre for that era was Seokmin. Also recently I have heard about some nasty things people said about Seokmin and how he "failed" in that era. For me it was the best era because the song is great, the dance is amazing and Seokmin shines in aju nice era!
Honestly, this is the first video I’ve properly watched of yours and it was great to see how you pointed out all of those things I’d maybe never even consider. Just, does it have a good tone. I enjoy how you pointed out Seungkwan and DK, and how much Joshua has grown. How Minghao, even if he doesn’t get a lot of lines he has a huge stage presence. And the rappers, how the beat changed during their parts. It all makes me appreciate the song so much more than I already did.
i am FED! but also i liked what you said about the choreography differences between clap and thanks. like you said, clap has a very powerful swagger feel to it while i feel like thanks is powerful in terms of how emotional it is. this is a present to the fans and i think a lot of us were expecting another smile flower type song, but we got something that is, at least to me, a lot better. this song and choreo is just so raw and captivating and the meaning behind it all just adds to the effect. i literally cried the first time I watched the mv, which is weird considering the genre and all that, but the amount of emotion that shines through is what makes it so good. it's their personal message to us, the fans, and that connection we get with them in this is so pure. thank you pd and thank you seventeen. lol that was longer than i thought it would be
For some reason I felt like the choreography was.. Nostalgic? It felt like a 'thank you' but also like a look back to the opportunities they have been able to have. I haven't been a carat for very long but I still felt like I could cry while watching. I can't even imagine what long time fans noticed. Overall the song was a bit dubsteppy for me but it brought across all the feeling above and the song was obviously perfected a lot. The song will most likely grow on me over time, this is just my first impression of the song itself.
OH YES FINALLY!! Also I love Thanks *a lot* The choreo, MV, wardrobe, vocals, rapping, EVERYTHING about this is exactly what I was hoping for and even more. I get this great feeling while listening to it (i can't explain it with words honestly), which I haven't gotten before from their title tracks. A big fat *yes* from me!
I have to giggle whenever I watch this & PD talks about Aju Nice being bigger than Pretty U for SEVENTEEN. The boys did an interview where Woozi said Aju Nice was their first choice for title track but Pledis turned it down & he had to put together Pretty U.
from all of their songs, this song means a lot to me and for their choreography, before this song is released, i love their choreography in don't want to cry and clap but now, thanks is the best choreography i've ever seen oh yeah and i agree with you about Joshua. He is way better now and i think with this new song, Joshua gathers a lot of attention from people..I think you should watch the dance version music video or the video when they performed at show champion, Scoups really made an awesome wave
As much as I loved the other choreographies, the choreography here really tells a story. Instead of a swag and chill dance it is expressive and powerful. It is quite different and I don't see it very often. Don't let me get started on the song itself! I was probably more hype in this song than I was for clap. I also like how after the raps the pre chorus is less upbeat and more light. Tbh the pre choruses in seventeen's songs are always my favourite part.
So obviously this is up there as one of my favorite SVT songs and MV. It is honestly amazing. Okay real words. I thought it was amazing how Joshua gets to start songs. He has come so very far from even Healing to now. I agree Woozi and Jeonghan don't get as many lines but this one seemed to be a perfect setting for both of their voices. A chance for them to shine. Honestly I think the only ones who didn't get a chance yo shine vocally is Dino. Made up for his dance Cameo. And Minghao my bobo. I love his dancing as well.
I think that every song they make it is more and more mature. You can see this with the choreography and lyrics and compare it to the debut songs and in my opinion it is going to pay off for them really heavily. Keep it up boiiiz
You’re honestly my favorite reactor and youtuber on this platform because not only do you love seventeen you also break down the mv and everyone’s lines and just talk about it so beautifully. I appreciate that a lot, thank you PD-nim💞
The first time I watch the mv, it definitely made me emotional. It has the same vibe with DWC but definitely more intense, both in terms of song and dance.. I love their fun, youthful song like Mansae, but this one really took my love for Seventeen to the next level ♥
Since I've discovered your channel two months ago thanks to jae's vlogs you've instantly became my favorite reactor. I'm not into reaction videos because they're all so repetitive and more and more boring these days, but since I've discovered your channel I watched all of your videos because your reactions are really SO interesting !! Really you're not giving us just some screams as reactions but you observe and see so many details that i didn't see the first time I watched the MV, really you're amazing !! 🙏🏼
Seventeen, even with a constant changing or evolving of music styles/genres, have never put out a song that I don't like. For me I connect with music emotionally. Which one thing Seventeen are amazing at is portraying emotion through their songs, lyrics and choreos. Them being self-producing idols is probably what helps in creating and portraying emotions so well.
THAT INTRO WAS SO FREAKING COOL 😎 well damn I have to say that your channel is just getting better and better, I was a casual watcher before, but now I'm excited every time you guys post! 😍
Idk why im very into their new song this Thanks.. im freakin obsess.. very obsess particularly watching vernon the8 an scoup got eveyoneeeeee argh.. i think i havent heard or watch such complete mv it bring sentimental its hypee it slow its bring every emotion... im very proud of what they have achieved and their transcending from adore to thanks is huge but they have not lose their essence god im subscribing anyone who have uploaded thanks and give me 1 hour youtube ad im gonna wait patiently for the mv to start and im gonna listen to it till my ears bleed....
You're the first youtuber I go to whenever Seventeen releases anything. With this song, I really enjoyed the texture of the instruments. I liked how for me this track was unpredictable. Every time I think they're about to have a beat drop, Woozi comes in with the soft prechorus and it gets me every damn time. I agree with you about Jeonghan, yes he's not the strongest vocalist but man his falsetto notes are beautiful and soft and alluring. Joshua opening the song and getting the chorus made me super happy because his voice is very under appreciated. This song as a whole was made beautifully and I'm so damn happy to stan a group with this much talent and great music quality.
Ok, we were all waiting for this, but can i just say: I LOOOOOVE THAT INTRO!!! I looooove how it makes Seventeen comeback SUPER DUPER PRECIOUS! And, i think this MV is really super clever as you said. My favorite part being the last chorus/dance where they switch shots of different members performing, and location and everything, it gives so much more punch to the choreo (as if it was needed) and is a great final!!! I love the b-side songs of the repackaged album too, i'll wait until sunday like a good girl for the listenning party!
*I swear, if thanks, or any seventeen song for that matter ends up getting played in public, I'm gonna end up as hyped as Seungmin when they played Day6*
i always wait extremely excited for ur reactions on seventeens songs and album cause it makes me see things that i may not see by myself and its always amazingly well reacted and commented as well. i feel like thanks is such a powerful and emotional song, especially for carats and we are all amazed by how seventeen cant disappoint us and always surprise their beloved fans with perfect songs + choreograph ♡ this is a thing that im thankful for. ps.: sometimes i felt like the coreo was inspired by the movements of "the oa" an original serie fr netflix. but not the careo itself but in the way that that it has been made... when they are dancing in a circle, for example. its amazing.
this is probably my favorite EDM song done by Seventeen so far! also the lyrics just hitting my heartstrings! as usual your critque making me re listen to the song to go look into what you just talked about
your reactions and critiquing are just amazing to listen to. the way you pick apart the music as much as the video is great to watch. love watching your reactions.
I really want him to react to VAV ;-; If he could do that album analysis it would be great, since VAV's album was like an repackage of their 2017 title tracks releases. It is such a good content!
I absolutely LOVE your channel. You are the ONLY youtuber whose reaction I am happy to watch all the way through, not just the reaction :) your love for svt is also SO relatable. I'm glad to be a sub 💜
I’m so glad you reacted to this!!! I was waiting for this moment and it was perfection!!! I love this come back, the way it was filmed! Was just great with how the actual song is and the dancing so AMAZING!!!
You’re the only person that I trust to judge SEVENTEEN because you’re the only one who cares about them and take your time to describe not only their voices and stage presence, but also their personalities. Thank you.
![BabyChiefDoit - Wonderful Time (Official Music Video) [Shot By @Rxllo]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_Bfqt3zV2KE/mqdefault.jpg)
The way his eyes shine everytime he sees Jeonghan... relatable
I also like the way his mouth fell open around 2:39, and the way he talked so nicely about the roles of the vocalists and their growth, and even their roles in the vocal unit.
Lizelle Matthews so true, that's why I love his reactions so much
Lara Conde I totally agree with you
Cause forreals... SAME 😍
He is such a mood tbh ahahah
what cracks me up every time is the framed picture of Jeonghan in the back
I was just about to ask who the person in the framed picture was LOL
OMG! I don't realize that's Jeonghan until I see your comment. Have to scroll up to check it, and then ... LOL
Lol that's the best thing in his set I love it
whoa you didn't watch it twice lol. I personally think that 'Thanks' is the most powerful song done by Seventeen music wise and lyrics wise. Being Carats since Predebut era makes me really notice that Seventeen is growing up a lot these days. Boi, I even teared up when I watched Thanks for the first time because it is THAT powerful and touching at the same time. I had the same reaction as you when I heard Jeonghan's part in Thanks lol because I kind of don't expect that from Yoon Jeonghan. AND ABOUT MINGHAO MY BOI, Seventeen gave him center part because of his lack of presence in Clap era😭 I really like that even though there's 13 of them, they split everything in a fair amount for next comeback like what you just mentioned the lack of main vocal in the last 2 comebacks, and suddenly Seventeen drop a vocal-heavy song. I really like this comeback!
He looked so attacked when Jeonghan started singing lmao
_5 days has passed since the comeback_
_Still no signs of a new reaction video..._
_All hope that we have left - starting to fade..._
_All faith begins to diminish as well..._
_”Maybe I should just give up”_
_”At this point, it will never come...”_
_I watch more reaction videos to distract myself from the truth_
_Until..._
_”Okay, Pai, just one more LAST time”_
_(Haha... thats funny because I said the same thing an hour ago)_
_Either way, I swipe down to refresh the subscription page_
_...Nothing._
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
*_Wai-wait a second..._*
*HE JUST FUCKING UPLOADED IT 23 MINUTES AGO WJINWOIHWIHOWH*
*MIRANDAAAAAAA GET IN HERE AND STOP EXPOSING ME ONLINE*
_An ambulance can be heard in the distance_
_-FIN-_
+ 😂😂😂
This comment is pure gold made me laugh so much
that was me
Lol
*"STOP EXPOSING ME ONLINE"*
ASDFGHJKL THIS PART KILLED ME
Seventeen's comeback is not complete wothout PD's reaction
True.....
HONESTLY!!!!
PREACH
Lololol
no joke, i've been checking on the channel since february 5 for this and now FUCK YES IT'S FINALLY HERE HOLD ME 😂😂😂
spazzuke same by me
same gurl same 😂
exactly same reaction when Jeonghan hit that high note ......BLESSED
yesss josh & jeonghan were just okay vocalists when seventeen debuted but they've improved so much. i mean josh is now the Legendary Starter of Seventeen Songs and booooiiiiiiii i was not prepared for jeonghan's vocals in this comeback, i almost fell out of my chair (not joking) bc his vocal game was too strong lmao. i'm so happy that they've figured out what suits each member's talents best & using them to the team's advantage (except for jun. they figured it out in lillili yabbay but none of their songs ever since have used that beautiful-ass falsetto again. get on it, woozi + bumzu)
yesss i guess it's all about finding that correct range of vocals that each of them sound great in. Personally I find josh sounding GREAT in that Aju Nice acoustic version and Rocket. Time to bloom those talents ;)
At this point u know it's a good song if Josh starts the song (although every svt song is good)👌👌
Honestly I agree. Minghao doesn't get lines but as time has progressed - he spends more time centre stage than any other member and you can almost always see him somewhere.
my bias is minghao because of Hot but now that i’m lookin back at their older songs I can almost never see him which is very different to their newer ones
@@angelic_xinyu oh god 5 years 😭 i haven’t watched many of the newer mvs but i have listened. i’m glad he gets more screen time finally 😭
Well, I think they gave Minghao a center position because he was missing from so many performances due to health issues. Just likes they did for Wonwoo in Boom Boom. They really look out for each other!!
i agree so much about the repackaged album title tracks upstaging the original title tracks. pretty u was a great song, but nothing could've prepared us for the epicness of aju nice lmao. same w/ clap & thanks. what i love is the consistency in quality w/ the repackaged b-side songs, they don't just add 2 or 3 mediocre songs & call it a day, they always add songs almost as good as the title track
spazzuke Yes, yes, yes!!! 👏
+Whisperoftheart 😊😊😊
Am I the only carat who prefers pretty u to aju nice? 😂😂😂 Pretty U is the song that gets me into 17. Even mansae had no impact. It wasnt until I got into them that I appreciate mansae.
WATCH THE CHOREOGRAPHY VERSION!!! 😍🔥👌👌 it’s amazing
10/10
yes!!
He is talking about Minghao 😭😭😭 Thank you so much 😭😭😭
Something I find interesting is that seventeen is starting to rotate the “center” members. By that I mean early on vernon, mingyu, woozi, and maybe seungkwan were really pushed to the front the most. Now mingyu didn’t even get a close up shot in the music video and the four I just mentioned don’t get nearly as much screen time or lines as they used to. If I had to pick the “center” members that I think seventeen is promoting the most now I’d say it’s Joshua, Jun, and Jeonghan (before I feel like most people just soloed him out for his hair which is a damn shame and I’m glad he’s getting a lot more love now). Scoups, Wonwoo, Hoshi, and DK have also been really eye catching and I know many people who have gotten into seventeen because they stand out a lot. I think Dino and Minghao (even tho minghao has been getting a lot better screen/center/line distribution) are the ones who need to get some spotlight maybe through a solo project or reality show appearance soon. Dino can literally do anything - rap sing dance and is really funny while minghao’s sass and sense of humor plays out really well on variety shows, he’s a fantastic dancer, and while his voice isn’t the strongest it still has a unique tone, as proven with My I. It’s just really interesting to me as a long time fan to see how the focus has shifted, because I remember when people only knew seventeen because of vernon.
g17558 and right know cz of mingyu n seungkwan who always in variety show. I hope another member have experiences in variety too.
I think this choreo feels almost more powerful than Clap because of its abundance of emotion? The feelings that are portrayed through the choreography- their struggles, their hard work, their thankfulness - make me feel overwhelmed and proud whenever I watch it. ^^
i feel like carats don't get shook by the fake drop before the pre-chorus (or fake drops in general) bc of without you??? lmao
spazzuke *R E L I A T A B L E*
+ Airi [CARAT] eyyyy high five!
spazzuke 🤣👋
Airi [CARAT] 'RELIATABLE'
Is this a typo or...? 😂
Suzy292002 sarcasm LOL 😂
Can't wait for your Jeonghan & Joshua duet reaction!!
Seventeen title tracks never really resonated with me (was always a B side track guy for seventeen) until 'Don't Wanna Cry', and Clap wasn't to my taste at all but then they hit me with this I feel attacked it's so good it's been on replay since release lmao
Hahaha I'm the opposite I agree their b sides are more my style but I didn't really dig DWC but clap was more my style
Johnny Nguyen
yes?
rofl exactly the same with me. never really cared for seventeen. but then don't wanna cry stood out to me, but then thanks was damn... it hooked me so hard into it. been going on a kpop reactions binge to this song
Johnny Nguyen laloaka
Honestly I'm glad China line is getting more love recently like since I joined during 아주 Nice they've definitely gotten a fair bit more screen time
Jeonghan really Provide improved a lot I got heart atake when i hear him from the start I wasn’t ready for that
I'm glad DK got more lines again where he's shown. Alibs are nice but if he's in the back no one notices
3:19 "I thought this would be a very chill song."
When are SEVENTEEN title tracks ever chill? TT ^ TT
i dont usually buy kpop songs besides day6 & exo, but this repackage, all the new songs were great! and yes i bought it ;)
Rue Dodoro thank yoooouuu, as a carat im happy seeing this comment.
bless youuuuu 💎💎
i dont think seventeen has ever made a bad song
"i feel like i see jun on the ground a lot" flashback to "okay now why are they getting on the ground"
I agree with you about Manse. :)
For me its one of their best comebacks. The music, the melody, the electric guitar, the dance and the wow oh wow vocals of DK and Seungkwan.
If Manse was released today with the fandom being bigger than it was 2 yrs ago, it will probably be all the hype Right now
Love your reaction
Seventeen's comeback is complete, the Producer reacted to the mv already!!!
“i feel like i see jun on the ground a lot”
iM-
I am so glad to hear what you said about Aju Nice and public reaction to it because the centre for that era was Seokmin. Also recently I have heard about some nasty things people said about Seokmin and how he "failed" in that era. For me it was the best era because the song is great, the dance is amazing and Seokmin shines in aju nice era!
Honestly, this is the first video I’ve properly watched of yours and it was great to see how you pointed out all of those things I’d maybe never even consider. Just, does it have a good tone. I enjoy how you pointed out Seungkwan and DK, and how much Joshua has grown. How Minghao, even if he doesn’t get a lot of lines he has a huge stage presence. And the rappers, how the beat changed during their parts. It all makes me appreciate the song so much more than I already did.
i am FED!
but also i liked what you said about the choreography differences between clap and thanks. like you said, clap has a very powerful swagger feel to it while i feel like thanks is powerful in terms of how emotional it is. this is a present to the fans and i think a lot of us were expecting another smile flower type song, but we got something that is, at least to me, a lot better. this song and choreo is just so raw and captivating and the meaning behind it all just adds to the effect. i literally cried the first time I watched the mv, which is weird considering the genre and all that, but the amount of emotion that shines through is what makes it so good. it's their personal message to us, the fans, and that connection we get with them in this is so pure. thank you pd and thank you seventeen.
lol that was longer than i thought it would be
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION SINCE THIS MV DROPPED. Please watch the performance version so aesthetically pleasing
Isa Ashley I agree! The performance video is one of the most powerfully moving choreography I’ve seen! Just beautiful!
that transition at 0:24 thoooough
i can finally rest in peace knowing pd has reacted to this.
For some reason I felt like the choreography was.. Nostalgic? It felt like a 'thank you' but also like a look back to the opportunities they have been able to have. I haven't been a carat for very long but I still felt like I could cry while watching. I can't even imagine what long time fans noticed. Overall the song was a bit dubsteppy for me but it brought across all the feeling above and the song was obviously perfected a lot. The song will most likely grow on me over time, this is just my first impression of the song itself.
2:39 aka the moment PD turns into a .jpg for jeonghan 😂😂😂😂
OH YES FINALLY!! Also I love Thanks *a lot*
The choreo, MV, wardrobe, vocals, rapping, EVERYTHING about this is exactly what I was hoping for and even more. I get this great feeling while listening to it (i can't explain it with words honestly), which I haven't gotten before from their title tracks. A big fat *yes* from me!
VernonAndJinInfiresMe ToDrinkWaterNotAlcohol I love your profile pic 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Amanda Manchester Thanks haha ^_^
"I feel like Jun's on the ground A LOT"
*UM YEAH BC THAT'S HOW WE LIKE IT ;)*
never clicked so fast in my life, I have been waiting for your reaction 😍
I have to giggle whenever I watch this & PD talks about Aju Nice being bigger than Pretty U for SEVENTEEN. The boys did an interview where Woozi said Aju Nice was their first choice for title track but Pledis turned it down & he had to put together Pretty U.
Pd, do you plan on reacting to the dance practice for this song? Or have you already watched it?
BeBobBlueBob He's gonna react to the live stage soooooo I think that the live version is better, even tho the dance practice was pretty as well.
Hoshi, thanks! I watched the weekly schedule vid after I watched this. 👌
I’m so exited for 1 in 10000 !!!
from all of their songs, this song means a lot to me
and for their choreography, before this song is released, i love their choreography in don't want to cry and clap
but now, thanks is the best choreography i've ever seen
oh yeah and i agree with you about Joshua. He is way better now and i think with this new song, Joshua gathers a lot of attention from people..I think you should watch the dance version music video or the video when they performed at show champion, Scoups really made an awesome wave
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
the way you love and support seventeen, especially jeonghan... it’s beautiful and i cry
As much as I loved the other choreographies, the choreography here really tells a story. Instead of a swag and chill dance it is expressive and powerful. It is quite different and I don't see it very often.
Don't let me get started on the song itself! I was probably more hype in this song than I was for clap. I also like how after the raps the pre chorus is less upbeat and more light. Tbh the pre choruses in seventeen's songs are always my favourite part.
So obviously this is up there as one of my favorite SVT songs and MV. It is honestly amazing. Okay real words. I thought it was amazing how Joshua gets to start songs. He has come so very far from even Healing to now. I agree Woozi and Jeonghan don't get as many lines but this one seemed to be a perfect setting for both of their voices. A chance for them to shine. Honestly I think the only ones who didn't get a chance yo shine vocally is Dino. Made up for his dance Cameo. And Minghao my bobo. I love his dancing as well.
I think that every song they make it is more and more mature. You can see this with the choreography and lyrics and compare it to the debut songs and in my opinion it is going to pay off for them really heavily. Keep it up boiiiz
I get chills listening to this song more than others, especially listening with headphones oh my god it sounds so good!
You’re honestly my favorite reactor and youtuber on this platform because not only do you love seventeen you also break down the mv and everyone’s lines and just talk about it so beautifully. I appreciate that a lot, thank you PD-nim💞
The first time I watch the mv, it definitely made me emotional. It has the same vibe with DWC but definitely more intense, both in terms of song and dance.. I love their fun, youthful song like Mansae, but this one really took my love for Seventeen to the next level ♥
Since I've discovered your channel two months ago thanks to jae's vlogs you've instantly became my favorite reactor. I'm not into reaction videos because they're all so repetitive and more and more boring these days, but since I've discovered your channel I watched all of your videos because your reactions are really SO interesting !! Really you're not giving us just some screams as reactions but you observe and see so many details that i didn't see the first time I watched the MV, really you're amazing !! 🙏🏼
Actually waited on my pc for the notification to come up bruh
i find it so adorable how you just awe in jeonghans beauty, its so cute.
Seventeen, even with a constant changing or evolving of music styles/genres, have never put out a song that I don't like. For me I connect with music emotionally. Which one thing Seventeen are amazing at is portraying emotion through their songs, lyrics and choreos. Them being self-producing idols is probably what helps in creating and portraying emotions so well.
I like how PD describes it very well. He notices even the tiniest detail. Love this reaction.
Finalllllyyy, I was waiting for you to react
WAITED FOR THIS THE WHOLE WEEK
THAT INTRO WAS SO FREAKING COOL 😎
well damn I have to say that your channel is just getting better and better, I was a casual watcher before, but now I'm excited every time you guys post! 😍
this literally gives me goosebumps until now. 'Thanks' is such a nice song!!!!
Idk why im very into their new song this Thanks.. im freakin obsess.. very obsess particularly watching vernon the8 an scoup got eveyoneeeeee argh.. i think i havent heard or watch such complete mv it bring sentimental its hypee it slow its bring every emotion... im very proud of what they have achieved and their transcending from adore to thanks is huge but they have not lose their essence god im subscribing anyone who have uploaded thanks and give me 1 hour youtube ad im gonna wait patiently for the mv to start and im gonna listen to it till my ears bleed....
You're the first youtuber I go to whenever Seventeen releases anything.
With this song, I really enjoyed the texture of the instruments. I liked how for me this track was unpredictable. Every time I think they're about to have a beat drop, Woozi comes in with the soft prechorus and it gets me every damn time. I agree with you about Jeonghan, yes he's not the strongest vocalist but man his falsetto notes are beautiful and soft and alluring. Joshua opening the song and getting the chorus made me super happy because his voice is very under appreciated. This song as a whole was made beautifully and I'm so damn happy to stan a group with this much talent and great music quality.
Ok, we were all waiting for this, but can i just say: I LOOOOOVE THAT INTRO!!! I looooove how it makes Seventeen comeback SUPER DUPER PRECIOUS! And, i think this MV is really super clever as you said. My favorite part being the last chorus/dance where they switch shots of different members performing, and location and everything, it gives so much more punch to the choreo (as if it was needed) and is a great final!!! I love the b-side songs of the repackaged album too, i'll wait until sunday like a good girl for the listenning party!
*I swear, if thanks, or any seventeen song for that matter ends up getting played in public, I'm gonna end up as hyped as Seungmin when they played Day6*
2:37 And, it was at this moment, the moment that we all know.
This MV is like half of what goes on behind the scenes IRL, and the finished product after shooting all of the scenes for an MV
i always wait extremely excited for ur reactions on seventeens songs and album cause it makes me see things that i may not see by myself and its always amazingly well reacted and commented as well. i feel like thanks is such a powerful and emotional song, especially for carats and we are all amazed by how seventeen cant disappoint us and always surprise their beloved fans with perfect songs + choreograph ♡ this is a thing that im thankful for.
ps.: sometimes i felt like the coreo was inspired by the movements of "the oa" an original serie fr netflix. but not the careo itself but in the way that that it has been made... when they are dancing in a circle, for example. its amazing.
This is the first time I've seen your videos and your love for jeonghan is the biggest mood? The framed picture? Iconic. bless your reactions
THANK YOU!!!!! I WAS waiting for your reaction and i love it as always thanks !!
I love your SVT reacts so much and THANKS is so so sooooo beautiful. It makes me emotional every time
“ jeonghan’s falsettos are piercing “ Agrreed!
hearing the passion in your voice whenever you talk about seventeen and how much they've improved seriously makes me happy ♡
this is probably my favorite EDM song done by Seventeen so far! also the lyrics just hitting my heartstrings! as usual your critque making me re listen to the song to go look into what you just talked about
PD-NIM! I waited for this. Everytime seventeen have comeback I always check on your channel. I so love your reactions to them :)
your reactions and critiquing are just amazing to listen to. the way you pick apart the music as much as the video is great to watch. love watching your reactions.
Yes, Im waiting for this.
I love more the thinkin' about you than thanks. Don't know why. Excited to your reaction for the rest of the songs.
react to gorgeous by vav!!
omg yeah! or spotlight!
I really want him to react to VAV ;-; If he could do that album analysis it would be great, since VAV's album was like an repackage of their 2017 title tracks releases. It is such a good content!
YES YES YES YSEBSYEBSYE SYE S JUST VAV IN GENERAL OMG
YESSS!!!!! He needs to react to VAV. Their songs are such bops! It's just so sad how underrated they are.
I KNOW OMG I WOULD KILL FOR A SPOTLIGHT REACTION
I've been waiting for your THANKS reaction for days... Thanks for this.
I absolutely LOVE your channel. You are the ONLY youtuber whose reaction I am happy to watch all the way through, not just the reaction :) your love for svt is also SO relatable. I'm glad to be a sub 💜
i’ve heard like two(2) seventeen songs; one which i like but the other which i can’t remember at all but dAMN THIS IS SUCHA. GOOD SONG IM SHREECHING
SVT's comeback will never be complete without your reaction..
I'm gonna go ahead and say it again, this song is such a jam. I always come here after I find music I like and see if you said anything about it
Ur videos are the only “reaction videos” I watch and I can’t tell why but I enjoy this
I was literally waiting for this and I visit youtube everyday to check if you dropped it already and now is the time!!!!
i love going back to your old videos. though it makes me feel older but you know i feel this deep connection and I just love the feeling of it ☺️
I was SO excited to see your reaction to thanks bUT THEN YOU SHOWED THE 1 in 10000 TEASER!! AND I'M JUST!!! SO EXCITED FOR IT!!!!!
OMG I have been waiting for your reaction, finally I’m watching 😭
I’m so glad you reacted to this!!! I was waiting for this moment and it was perfection!!! I love this come back, the way it was filmed! Was just great with how the actual song is and the dancing so AMAZING!!!
Your commentary is always the best. I hope you'll do a short listening party for the new songs! Keep up the good work!
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS REACTION!
All the rap was written by jihoon this time.
You’re the only person that I trust to judge SEVENTEEN because you’re the only one who cares about them and take your time to describe not only their voices and stage presence, but also their personalities. Thank you.
My life wan't complete without your reactions PD-nim
yes i’m so happy you finally did a reaction! :)
Tbh I like the choreography video more than the actual mv just bc it’s mesmerising to watch them dance
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS SINCE THE MV DROPPED!! THANK YOU ❤😃
PD WHERE ARE YOU?? WERE WAITING FOR YOURE REACTIONS... WE MISS YOU!!
Clap made me wan to dance and scream, this song made me clutch my heart and cry, it made me so emotional and I dont even know why 😭😭😭
IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIIIIIS, THANKYOU