I prefer the remake acting here in this scene.....Angela is supposed to be 18, which she sounds in that version. And you can actually see her facial expressions.
Both versions convey Angela's suffering and mental state. In the original, the focus is on the face (her gaze changes when she returns to "reason", it is an instant, but it is enough to understand it). In the remake, the movements of her body are so expressive (Angela collapses on the stairs showing that she is no longer expecting anything). I admire the work of the creators, everything in this game is so meticulous and studied, it more than deserves the title of masterpiece.
I like the VOICE ACTING from the original one. But the remake one stay true to its characteristics and many argue that that is how an 18-19 y.o. should act!!! Boy times changed!!!!
@@noone-pg4lr some are remixed very dimmed versions of the original, and some removed at all 😕 or doesn't kick in until the end of the cutscenes. This scene in particular with Angela stair fire has the best music in the original.but you can barely hear it here .
I’ve liked every single CS in the remake better, by a long shot. All except this one. Now if we can meld Angela’s performance in the original with James in the remake it’d be perfect. Oh and keep the original score.
Bro the new voice actress is not the same... I dont want to be mean but it sucks. The original was so much better... Hope someone can mod the voices back in.
You’re pretty much saying “it’s bad because It’s different”, bro like of course it’d be different It’s a remake. But about the tone of this specific scene, picturing angela’s tragic fate, Bloober team by no means ruined the scene they just directed it in a more cinematographic tone, and some deliveries are as impactful as the OG. The thing is, the OG it’s a truly unique masterpiece too perfect to be mimetized or overcomed, but you can keep the essence and weight of the scene and this they defenitely nailed. Take aside the saudosism my man, the game might not be perfect but It’s not that bad as you are saying.
@@samuelico06 it's not the same feeling at all. The OG was much more natural, specially Mary and Maria. The actor that plays James on the remake is very good though, he's great.
The comment who said “she can get it.” I genuinely hope you bite the curb,
She needs it
@@pcprincipal7755 not very PC principal of you
@@pcprincipal7755 long walk, short pier
She sounds so much sadder in the remake 😭😭
The second one when she says “mama” is literally heart breaking 💔
I prefer the remake acting here in this scene.....Angela is supposed to be 18, which she sounds in that version. And you can actually see her facial expressions.
Both versions convey Angela's suffering and mental state. In the original, the focus is on the face (her gaze changes when she returns to "reason", it is an instant, but it is enough to understand it). In the remake, the movements of her body are so expressive (Angela collapses on the stairs showing that she is no longer expecting anything). I admire the work of the creators, everything in this game is so meticulous and studied, it more than deserves the title of masterpiece.
I like the VOICE ACTING from the original one. But the remake one stay true to its characteristics and many argue that that is how an 18-19 y.o. should act!!! Boy times changed!!!!
On part from this moment and silent hill 4 .. I knew it was different for everyone... she can only see fire and James can see monsters
Theme of Laura (Reprise)
It sounds similar to Lisa Dies from the first Silent Hill.
I've teared up at both not gana lie :/
The original is the best 4 me. Love the remake graphics but the acting in this scene is meh....
If you want game play the remake is better, but if you want the cutscenes and music the original is far superior.
The remake did a fine job in this scene the voice acting was good
@@noone-pg4lr i think the music was underwhelming in the remake .
@@hayderneamah1323 but is it not the same music
@@noone-pg4lr some are remixed very dimmed versions of the original, and some removed at all 😕 or doesn't kick in until the end of the cutscenes.
This scene in particular with Angela stair fire has the best music in the original.but you can barely hear it here .
Oh my 😮
❤❤❤❤
I’ve liked every single CS in the remake better, by a long shot. All except this one. Now if we can meld Angela’s performance in the original with James in the remake it’d be perfect. Oh and keep the original score.
They did keep the original score.
@@DHM91 I was just talking about the voice acting. But I’m pretty sure it’s not 100% the original song. There seems to be some tonal differences.
The original voice actor makes me laugh instead of appreciating the tonal differences in the OG ...@@chrisvgt2010
James is not Angela's mama ,but he can be a papa of her :)
LOL
How did that play out the first time? 💀
Mama james
💀
You probably don't want to be seen as her Papa, given her backstory.
.......you do realize that Angela is a victim of r@pe from her own dad right?
Bro the new voice actress is not the same... I dont want to be mean but it sucks. The original was so much better... Hope someone can mod the voices back in.
Elaborate?
Hard disagree
I don’t particularly like Angela in either version, but the new one has way more nuance in her vocal performance
You’re pretty much saying “it’s bad because It’s different”, bro like of course it’d be different It’s a remake. But about the tone of this specific scene, picturing angela’s tragic fate, Bloober team by no means ruined the scene they just directed it in a more cinematographic tone, and some deliveries are as impactful as the OG. The thing is, the OG it’s a truly unique masterpiece too perfect to be mimetized or overcomed, but you can keep the essence and weight of the scene and this they defenitely nailed. Take aside the saudosism my man, the game might not be perfect but It’s not that bad as you are saying.
@@samuelico06 it's not the same feeling at all. The OG was much more natural, specially Mary and Maria. The actor that plays James on the remake is very good though, he's great.
@@GrosserAndrew5000og is unnatural and horrible lol
The remake failed with the music and the acting....smh ....how can this happen! I enjoyed the game but i will never support another blooper project.
you gotta be joking lol
Bro you clearly don't know how to interpret a scene of this magnitude.
@@DaturaPlaysmfs be crying i swear 😂😂😂 humans can never be satisfied
You gotta be kidding or something , or you just have a bad taste
It’s bloober
She can get it
Wtf who can get it
@@JohnNiskala first girl can get it
@@nathandangerfield575dude ??? Get a life. You’re so weird.
U mean the original first voice actress is better? That she gets the scene better?
@@GrosserAndrew5000 noooo, nooooo, noooo. The og can get it not the voice actor.