당시 걸 스피릿을 본방으로 챙겨봤었는데 오늘 우연찮게 알고리즘에 브걸 왕눈좌 캠퍼스영상이 떠서 보다가 반가운 얼굴이 보이길래 당시 민재씨가 부른 이 노래에 감동을 받았던게 기억이나서 찾아왔네요. "절대로 약해지면 안 된다는 말 대신 지금 이 순간 끝이 아니라, 나의 길을 가고 있다고" 민재씨가 부른 노래처럼 민재씨나 소나무 멤버들도 언젠가는 꼭 본인들이 가고 있는 길에서 빛을 보는 날이 왔으면 좋겠어요.
i watched it live but there are some site who upload the video about the episode www.reddit.com/r/kpop/comments/4up0zh/jtbc_girl_spirit_episode_2_performances_160726/
I am here after Daehyun tweeted about her. AND I AM GLAD I FOUND HER. OMAYGHAAD. SHE DESERVE THE FIRST PLACE. I am a Kei fan, yet I understand why she won :D
tbh minjae's perf also was good too just like what other says. but in my opinion i personally kei's perf. was memorable mostly thats why she got no.2 afterall. i'd like to say that kei overshadowed minjae. but both are good. its just like other kei's group's main vocalist nor lead vocalist members (babysoul/jin/sujeong) are overshadowed by her. but again both's performance minjae and kei was good. thats why they're top 2. congratz!!
+긴다 kpop if you listen to practically any well trained singer (Luna, ailee, hyorin, eunji) you will see that breathing can be accomplished very quietly, no matter how demanding a song. It's a skill that can be learned. That said, minjae did perform very well and she won so I'm happy for her.
+Stiles Hale considering ailee is a soloist and gets all the vocals she heavely puts emphasis on her voice and how to conrol it. luna after debut started taking vocal lessons to improve her vocals. hyolin and eunji are just natural worked talent. Minjae as she hasn't gotten as much as eperience as the others can't really be compared to vocals of that caliber
achacha7894 i think i interpreted your initial comment differently than you meant it. I wasn't saying she should be as good as those other idols already. you said "can it be helped?" and i was pointing out idols that prove that with practice and training it can, indeed, be helped. She has lots of time to improve, and will eventually get it under control if she practices.
she did great breathing is not a bad thing, it's just something that can be fixed through time however she's super talented and not even the 1st main vocal of her group the emotions (if you guys know the lyrics) she was able to give with her beautiful voice are the main reasons she won first place and it was well deserved. I cried when i heard her singing this song with this much involvement and emotion.
Since SONAMOO debuted, the song Deja Vu already caught my eye!! I watch several their performance. I'm impressed by the rappers and the girl who always sings with smile(I recognize Minjae but I don't know her name before). It was the first time I saw a singer showing her impression so well meanwhile singing~ I watch Girl Spirit because I saw the news one SONAMOO member will join then I know the name of the girl Minjae💙. In the Kpop groups, there are so many singers good at singing with skills. However, what I desire to listen to is songs song by the singers with their emotion. I'm glad that Minjae show me the emotion of this song and I can kidda feel her eager. I sometimes fear SONAMOO will disappear in this huge and competitive Kpop industry, but now I'm happy that SONAMOO become better and better and Minjae did well😢😌!!!
and hope she could fix her breathing bc i can hear clearly when she try to take a breath(?) yeah i hope she could fix it for a better performance :) minjae fighting!
@@Flopped69 High D and Minjae are both main vocalists! :) I guess High D would be considered the "first main vocalist" since she gets more of the high notes/belts but technically I believe both are main vocals!
Wow, so many amateur vocal coaches in the comments. Well I don't know shit about singing and I'm not going claim I know anything. I thought she did great and I'm hoping she and Sonamoo can gain more recognition from this show. Same for the other contestants as well.
So freaking true.lmfao!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This performance was 100/100 for me. I always get goosebumps from her especially in Sonamoo's Deeply Love.....
Wow ~ I think minjae's voice really suitable for OST. Idk why but watching this makes me emo ~ Im in tears... Good job minjae!!! Minjae fighting! Sonamoo fighting!
Not bad. The gasp breathing is really distracting, though. Don't understand how any vocal coach can let that go. And, YES, it does need to be corrected.
Since they posted this video, I will always go back here every time I feel down and then after that I will feel better and ready to face again the reality. Thank you Minjae for singing passionately, I hope Sonamoo will be successful soon.
yes. eunji loves this song because it helped her get back on the road to follow her dreams. she sang it 5 years ago on a variety show and again earlier this year on 'healing camp' to a student who was about to give up on going to university.
What’s really the bad part of the singing is after big notes you can hear her going “huuu” when she breaths in, it sounds like she is struggling, still a great voice
dont sleep on her, dont sleep on sonamoo, dont sleep on talent
소나무 꼭 잘됐으면 좋겠다 너무 아까워...
당시 걸 스피릿을 본방으로 챙겨봤었는데
오늘 우연찮게 알고리즘에 브걸 왕눈좌 캠퍼스영상이 떠서 보다가
반가운 얼굴이 보이길래 당시 민재씨가 부른 이 노래에 감동을 받았던게
기억이나서 찾아왔네요.
"절대로 약해지면 안 된다는 말 대신
지금 이 순간 끝이 아니라, 나의 길을 가고 있다고"
민재씨가 부른 노래처럼 민재씨나 소나무 멤버들도 언젠가는
꼭 본인들이 가고 있는 길에서 빛을 보는 날이 왔으면 좋겠어요.
왕눈좌와 함께 수업듣던 소나무의 민재 맞나요 실력있는 보컬이네요~! 응원합니다^^
This is now my second most favorite cover of this song after Eunji's. Minjae's emotions really got through. She totally deserved first place.
이때 본방으로 봤었는데..한참 힘들때라 이노래가 너무 와닿았다 민재 잘되라
걸스피릿 다시 했으몀 좋겠어요ㅠ 민재님 나를외치다 노래 현장에서 듣고싶네요
롤린 -> 은지 캠퍼스 -> 소나무 민재 보고 여기까지 왔습니다.
은지 친구 민재~
she is the one who scored the best 43 to 90 she is also in first place now glad for her
how do you know this? what site please
i watched it live but there are some site who upload the video about the episode www.reddit.com/r/kpop/comments/4up0zh/jtbc_girl_spirit_episode_2_performances_160726/
+Kiken did she perform 'I' by taeyeon too?
yeah but not is this episode you can watch her performance and the recent videos upload in this channel just look for her
You deserve to be on #1 spot. Hands down
안녕 내 청춘의 영웅..
minjae you really did well
우리 민쟁이 잘했다
I am here after Daehyun tweeted about her. AND I AM GLAD I FOUND HER. OMAYGHAAD. SHE DESERVE THE FIRST PLACE. I am a Kei fan, yet I understand why she won :D
Wooooow!!! . I was a pine cone since the debut and I didn't know that minjae's voice is that good . ❤️ proude of her . Best contestant
IM HAPPY THAT MINJAE GOT FIRST!!!
No wrong info
This is right
1) SONAMOO’s Minjae 90 Votes
2) Lovelyz’s Kei 88 Votes
3) OH MY GIRL’s Seunghee 87 Votes
4) Cosmic Girls’ Dawon 83 Votes
5) Pledis Girlz’s Sungyeon 81 Votes
6) CLC’s Seunghee 65 Votes
tbh minjae's perf also was good too just like what other says. but in
my opinion i personally kei's perf. was memorable mostly thats why she
got no.2 afterall.
i'd like to say that kei overshadowed minjae. but both are good. its just like other kei's group's main vocalist nor lead vocalist members (babysoul/jin/sujeong) are overshadowed by her. but again both's performance minjae and kei was good. thats why they're top 2. congratz!!
나를 외치다 소나무처럼 자기색 강하고 강한 이미지. 소나무의 무대 응원합니다
minjae you did great. stan sonamoo
민재 ~♡
the breathing.... she needs to get that under control... a good singer should never audibly gasp before or after a note.
that's a pretty common new idol issue. seunghee does that a lot too. i'm sure they'll improve
+Stiles Hale CLC Seunghee voice is sometimes kinda annoyed when she sings because of her breathe
+긴다 kpop if you listen to practically any well trained singer (Luna, ailee, hyorin, eunji) you will see that breathing can be accomplished very quietly, no matter how demanding a song. It's a skill that can be learned. That said, minjae did perform very well and she won so I'm happy for her.
+Stiles Hale considering ailee is a soloist and gets all the vocals she heavely puts emphasis on her voice and how to conrol it. luna after debut started taking vocal lessons to improve her vocals. hyolin and eunji are just natural worked talent. Minjae as she hasn't gotten as much as eperience as the others can't really be compared to vocals of that caliber
achacha7894 i think i interpreted your initial comment differently than you meant it. I wasn't saying she should be as good as those other idols already. you said "can it be helped?" and i was pointing out idols that prove that with practice and training it can, indeed, be helped. She has lots of time to improve, and will eventually get it under control if she practices.
Minjae, you the best!!!
awww....Minjae you did well..sonamoo Hwaiting...Minjae Hwaiting..1st place well deserved
she did great
breathing is not a bad thing, it's just something that can be fixed through time
however she's super talented and not even the 1st main vocal of her group
the emotions (if you guys know the lyrics) she was able to give with her beautiful voice are the main reasons she won first place and it was well deserved. I cried when i heard her singing this song with this much involvement and emotion.
She is the main vocal though.
@@nazaricooke838 minjae is the 2nd main vocal. High D is the 1st main vocal
minjae fighting...sonamoo finghting
청춘의 시림이... 그 젊음의 뭉클함이 느껴진다... ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Cant stop repeating.......
waaa im so proud of minjaee!!!!
Since SONAMOO debuted, the song Deja Vu already caught my eye!! I watch several their performance. I'm impressed by the rappers and the girl who always sings with smile(I recognize Minjae but I don't know her name before). It was the first time I saw a singer showing her impression so well meanwhile singing~ I watch Girl Spirit because I saw the news one SONAMOO member will join then I know the name of the girl Minjae💙. In the Kpop groups, there are so many singers good at singing with skills. However, what I desire to listen to is songs song by the singers with their emotion. I'm glad that Minjae show me the emotion of this song and I can kidda feel her eager. I sometimes fear SONAMOO will disappear in this huge and competitive Kpop industry, but now I'm happy that SONAMOO become better and better and Minjae did well😢😌!!!
that's actually why she won first place in the episode
and she's not even known so people can't even say they are biased
she deserved first place
민재 1위 congratulation
CONGRATULATION MINJAE!CONGRATULATION SONAMOO
and hope she could fix her breathing bc i can hear clearly when she try to take a breath(?) yeah i hope she could fix it for a better performance :) minjae fighting!
congratulation Minjae..
And she's not even the main vocalist. I'm proud of you Minjae!!!!
She is the main vocalist
she is the main vocalist lol
@@pinklemonaze9982 isn't it High.D
@@Flopped69 High D and Minjae are both main vocalists! :) I guess High D would be considered the "first main vocalist" since she gets more of the high notes/belts but technically I believe both are main vocals!
은지 수업친구 민재씨도 잘되기를..
멋진곡에 멋진공연!! 재능 & 체계적배움 = art!!!
재능이 잇을수록 제대로 배워 세상을 더욱 밝게~~ best case!! 짝짝^^
the best! minjae fighting!!💜💖
대박!!!
Minjae was awesome! Solid performance. Very strong and emotional. Loved it! :D
the best.. Minjae Jjang 👍
Fighting Minjae Fighting SONAMOO!! ❤❤❤
Wow, so many amateur vocal coaches in the comments. Well I don't know shit about singing and I'm not going claim I know anything. I thought she did great and I'm hoping she and Sonamoo can gain more recognition from this show. Same for the other contestants as well.
So freaking true.lmfao!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This performance was 100/100 for me. I always get goosebumps from her especially in Sonamoo's Deeply Love.....
I'm about to cry ..
한편의 뮤지컬~~~
Proud
Proud of you 😢😍
her voice sounds like Apink Eunji one of my best female vocal..
*Happy tear* so proud of you minjae!!
WAAAAAAAAH IM SO PROUD OF YOU BABY MINJAEEEE 😭😭 IM CRYINGGG THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL 😭😭😭
Minjae fighting ~ SONAMOO fighting ♡♡♡♡♡
Wow good
minjae give her all...
Wow ~ I think minjae's voice really suitable for OST. Idk why but watching this makes me emo ~ Im in tears... Good job minjae!!! Minjae fighting! Sonamoo fighting!
minjae!!!
so proud of you
All this beautiful talented ladies are giving us their talent,let us rejoice in it and be positive,민재 ♥감사합니다.
민쟁이 잘했어~
omo, im crying 😭😭😭 she gave me a goosebumps when i heard it from the beginning .congratsss minjae .🙌🙌 im so proud of u 😆
love this performance so much, such an inspirational song💓
ah I recognize this song cause Eunji sang it before! Minjae (?) was astounding!!
WOOOO YESS people need to see this!!
Minjae ı love you :D
I love this show! I love how I and other fans are discovering how talented these ladies are.
my tears almost drop when i watching this...
Congrats!! I love Minjae 😍👍👏👏
Minjae and Dohee talent just got wasted, really
goose bumps. minaje myloves 😍😍😘😘
I hate tsent for hiding these beautiful talented girls behind their silly songs...sonamoo needs to be known!
Wow just Wow
so proud of you minjae!!
QUEEN
daebak! rise sonamoo :)
beautiful voice!!!!
Fighting ! SONAMOO
👏 goodluck fighting👏
Such a good voice 💕
good job Minjae!!!
so proud of you
I don't really know about singing technique.
She's good, but I think she must control her breath
Not bad. The gasp breathing is really distracting, though. Don't understand how any vocal coach can let that go. And, YES, it does need to be corrected.
minj ❤️
pround of you,, minjae fighting 😇😇😇
良い
wow! her voice so good fighting minjae!!!!!!!
Since they posted this video, I will always go back here every time I feel down and then after that I will feel better and ready to face again the reality. Thank you Minjae for singing passionately, I hope Sonamoo will be successful soon.
wow.goosebumps
this is just minjae.. imagine if high.d join this singing show too..
Wow it sound nice i like minjae's cover👌🏼
Really god job Olaf
Did Eunji Apink use to sing this song? I think that because it sounds so similar to me....
yes. eunji loves this song because it helped her get back on the road to follow her dreams. she sang it 5 years ago on a variety show and again earlier this year on 'healing camp' to a student who was about to give up on going to university.
+PINK PANDA thank u. I've heard Eunji sings this song for 4-5 times so I can remember that she used to sing this song.
+PINK PANDA what's the name of the song?
Melissa KPOP 'Shout Myself' by Maya
i heard euijin cover it on show
Dis they have to add that sonamoo clip? Now I feel so sad ;((
this songs so touching ever😭😭😭😭😭 💞💞💞
What’s really the bad part of the singing is after big notes you can hear her going “huuu” when she breaths in, it sounds like she is struggling, still a great voice
wow! Minjae!! hwaiting! Sonamoo!!! I love you!
nice one minjae, i really like your voice, it makes me cry
왕눈좌 캠퍼스 영상 보다가 오겟지?
왔습니다!
love her since ep1
Woooo...
♥♥♥♥♥
Even I don't know the translate this song make me into tears
이 노래 원곡 10000만 이상 들어본 사람 입장에서 봤고 많은 분들의 커버 버전을 많이 들어봤는데
음색은 정말 정말 매력적이고 고음도 안정적이라서 참 듣기 좋은데 넘 아쉬운건 중간 중간 들숨소리가 너무 크게 들려서
감상에 방해가 되네요 ㅠ 매우 아쉽습니다.
Jinsol when from 35 to 88
Minjae's difference is 45 when jinsol's is 53 she has improved more
Really??? Spoiler
But this is Minjae's video. That's not what's important. They both improved a lot and that's what's important not who improved more.