I'm kinda confused what kinda popularity votes are going on here... This performance was amazing. How did she get such a low rank? I'm lowkey pissed rn.
Because Taeyeon, In korea, is loved for her singing abilities, everybody knows her songs. so anyone been compared to her is going to lose because people expect to hear the same incredibles lows and highs controlled tones that sung by Taeyeon looks so easy but when you try to cover them is so hard to do. Billboard journalists think than not even Taylor Swift can pull off Taeyeon's vocal range: >
Billboard journalists even attempting to compare Taylor Swift to Taeyeon is kind of an insult to Taeyeon's skills...that's like comparing Selena Gomez to Beyoncé...
I'm a Taeyeon fan and I absolutely love this version/cover, she add her own colors here and this is what makes the song perfect!!!! Thank you Minjae, I think I'll download this ver. :D
she slayed she deserved more she was able to control her breath completely this week, nothing was off and also the negging squad coming within the first second this video was released, lmao i see you edit: also i think the arrangement could have been done better to keep the hype (even with the rap parts), cause it felt really "calm" and after seeing the ep with eng subs i side with what the judges said
infected89 lmao? i have actually pretty high standards, and i think she did great with her own version considering how hard the song is and how it can't be compared to the original (as every cover tbh) and no, not a "she-deserves-first-place great", if u thought that's what i meant
+Shinebinnie OMG did she really cover it? I really like them😊 I found them cuz I'm a baby haha. They are really talented and TS is sort of wasting their talent with cute concepts😅 I mean I liked their new song it was literally addicting but TS needs to give them their own color😉 I literally LOVEF deja vu and cushion but It didnt felt like it was "their" concept😙 I hope TS will keep them and give them songs that they actually choose to perform and shows all their talents😘😘
+Duygu Acar They said they will comeback soon but We don't know if is a new song or a follow up. TS is really good on finding good artists. I love when TS let their artists wrote their own lyrics. I hope Sonamoo will comeback with their own style and coquear the world bcs they deserve it. ♡
Of course she didn't sing better then the original. Because who can? An original is an original. BUT that doesn't mean she didn't do a great job. Everyone has their own style, and it's good that you don't sound like someone else because then you'll just be known as "insert name here" She did good
only 65?? The judges should try singing this song before giving out the score tbh. this song is legit hard and not everyone call pull off that song this good
lmao the whole "if you don't sing don't judge" argument is bullshit. You don't need to sing to be able to know a good/bad performance. The slow parts were good but she started cracking on the high notes.
why anyone who try to cover this song always sounds the same and have similar singing way ? seulgi, juniel , and now this girl. original by taeyeon is the only sounds different
cause they sound safe. taeyeon sounds like some awesome rocker girl. I personally think instead of steady vocal someone like aoa Choa can pull off a cover. choa is more suited for indie/rock
This is areally hard song and she was able to control her breath and runs so well. She just need a little more power when she sang the I's and the ad-lib.
yes it really suits her voice but the whole performance is just like a normal stage of common music show, if you compare with the stage of dawon and OMG's seunghee
I am so proud with Minjae, she really great for choosing songs, first even thought its not great 'take care of me' showing how minjae introduce herself, then' 'shout to myself' expressing how she would do great even though she will fall and fall again, and now 'I'i.. all songs are great, showing she was no joking choosing all her songs
She sang great, but her emotions are missing. I can feel her admiration for Taeyeon in the song (it says that Taeyeon is her role model), but it feels like she is misinterpreting the emotions she's supposed to convey in the lyrics. Taeyeon wrote those lyrics about her loneliness and hardships in her long years of celebrity life. I don't feel the yearn and the refreshing emotion in her voice. She's still young and I have a lot of hopes for her😁 Awesome notes and vocals!
that why many people dislike it :/ i am a SONE and i think that her vocal is good, not too much strong but stable. He looks beautiful as well. she and her group "Sonammo" deserve more attention (Sonammo's songs also are good choice, check them out)
She's really good! What I really love in her performances are that verses treated with much care and emotion as choruses. Her high notes are not shabby either. Her low votes might to due to Taeyeon comparison but she should had more votes really.
Damn, i really thought kei and minjae would've topped this episode, but i guess the other contestants got more votes because their songs were more popular and much more of a 'hit' ? It's a shame :/
"I" is like the biggest hit of them all though. It might be that it would be very hard for almost any of the contestants on this show to live up to the standards Taeyeon has set. She's also hard to hear over her instrumentation.
i liked this actually it was a risky choice of song but tbh not even taeyeon herself can nail the same power and emotion from her own studio version on a 100% rate in live performances so i think minjae did pretty great and comparing, as always in covers, is pointless and stupid it's cute that taeyeon inspires minjae :)
Shinebinnie But Dohee does all the high notes and hard parts so yeah she's still considered as the lead vocalist although on TS' site, it says she's a main vocalist too
+Secret Bigstar DGNA BIG Spica Rania Stellar Baekpo No. Minjae is the main vocal not the lead. minjae have hited high notes in sonamoo songs with Dohee and Euijin is the lead vocalist.
Minjae did great ❤❤ Fighting minjae! ❤ ps. i like her performance here but i still prepare dohee's cover of I 👌 But both are amazing. Sonamoo fighting! Main Vocal line fighting! Minjae Fighting!
I think she should have tried changing the arrangement a bit more and she might have gotten more points. The instrumentation was also louder than her sometimes which kind of doesn't work.
My fav song, sing by my fav girlgroup member. She slay it! Taeyeon's song its difficult, but she can do well.. Its a shame that Sonamoo are underrated. They' re full of talent..Same like Oh My Girl and CLC
SONAMOO Minjae sing very well, but the overall crowd isn't high, I thought she will choose 'Why' by Taeyeon ~ 'I' is very hard to sing ~ Minjae, well done !
She has certain kinks in her voice that would totally take this song to a more "independent artist" sound......but because she's a trained "idol", she gives the song the typical pop treatment. She seems to have a bit more unique voice, so I was hoping to hear a more alternative spin on this song. I wish fans would let these girls just cut loose and actually use their voices in many ways instead of the cookie-cutter holding ling notes and hitting not-even-close-to-high high notes and thinking that makes a good singer.
She did good, but I can see why she didn't score high. Like with Ohmom (CLC's Seunghee), there was some issues towards the end & it began to sound forced. Her voice is really good, but there's always room for improvement.
![[Review]Girl Spirit Ep.5: So-jung from LADIES'CODE sings 'I Don't Love You'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ee91jjiZA9M/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Review]Girl Spirit Ep.5: So-jung from LADIES'CODE sings 'I Don't Love You'](/img/tr.png)
It's not simple to handle a Taeyeon song and to follow her but she did AWESOME. That was amazing.
I was really surprised that she could pull it off that well, I mean taeyeon's songs are not easy to sing and she totally did a great job!
Kevin she sings quite good
But lack of emotional🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
everyone call her "this girl" "this girl" "this girl". okay her name is minjae she from sonamoo. the most talented group
I'm kinda confused what kinda popularity votes are going on here...
This performance was amazing.
How did she get such a low rank?
I'm lowkey pissed rn.
I feel you..
Because Taeyeon, In korea, is loved for her singing abilities, everybody knows her songs. so anyone been compared to her is going to lose because people expect to hear the same incredibles lows and highs controlled tones that sung by Taeyeon looks so easy but when you try to cover them is so hard to do. Billboard journalists think than not even Taylor Swift can pull off Taeyeon's vocal range: >
just review and hear again how she sing...it was _______
Billboard journalists even attempting to compare Taylor Swift to Taeyeon is kind of an insult to Taeyeon's skills...that's like comparing Selena Gomez to Beyoncé...
+Kae Wow, why would they do that?! Don't they know that might start a fan war? 😠😤
I'm a Taeyeon fan and I absolutely love this version/cover, she add her own colors here and this is what makes the song perfect!!!! Thank you Minjae, I think I'll download this ver. :D
Support Minjae and Sonamoo 💚.
she slayed she deserved more
she was able to control her breath completely this week, nothing was off
and also the negging squad coming within the first second this video was released, lmao i see you
edit: also i think the arrangement could have been done better to keep the hype (even with the rap parts), cause it felt really "calm" and after seeing the ep with eng subs i side with what the judges said
You've got low standards if this was "slaying"...
infected89 lmao? i have actually pretty high standards, and i think she did great with her own version considering how hard the song is and how it can't be compared to the original (as every cover tbh)
and no, not a "she-deserves-first-place great", if u thought that's what i meant
So you use "slay"' for every random attempt at singing a good song that goes somewhat decent and you think you've got high standards... oh dear.
infected89 just a bad choice of words i guess, deary
chill lmao and i stand by what i said
Her breathing support was not very good here tho
LET'S TREND THIS AND MAKE TAEYEON WATCH THIS.
YES she should make a reaction to it omg 💕 I love Taeyeon's songs and she did a great job with this💋
+Duygu Acar You should listen to Minjae's cover to Ur. ♡
Sonamoo is really a talented group. stan them. ♡
+Shinebinnie OMG did she really cover it? I really like them😊 I found them cuz I'm a baby haha. They are really talented and TS is sort of wasting their talent with cute concepts😅 I mean I liked their new song it was literally addicting but TS needs to give them their own color😉 I literally LOVEF deja vu and cushion but It didnt felt like it was "their" concept😙 I hope TS will keep them and give them songs that they actually choose to perform and shows all their talents😘😘
+Duygu Acar They said they will comeback soon but We don't know if is a new song or a follow up.
TS is really good on finding good artists.
I love when TS let their artists wrote their own lyrics.
I hope Sonamoo will comeback with their own style and coquear the world bcs they deserve it. ♡
Shinebinnie yess
Hey that's Sleepy from Untouchable. Minjae's labelmate
Yess TS Familyy
Of course. TS artists always do these kinds of collaboration when performing.
This girl deserves to be in the top with kei
Honestly I liked both of them the most today
PREACH THIS.
it's minjae from sonamoo
Her voice suited this so beautifully. She deserves so much more
Of course she didn't sing better then the original. Because who can? An original is an original. BUT that doesn't mean she didn't do a great job. Everyone has their own style, and it's good that you don't sound like someone else because then you'll just be known as "insert name here"
She did good
only 65?? The judges should try singing this song before giving out the score tbh. this song is legit hard and not everyone call pull off that song this good
judges are not the only one who vote there are 100 selected audience mainly majors in music who votes too . and yeah 65 is too low for her
lmao the whole "if you don't sing don't judge" argument is bullshit. You don't need to sing to be able to know a good/bad performance. The slow parts were good but she started cracking on the high notes.
did you not hear that strained mess at the end of the song?
why anyone who try to cover this song always sounds the same and have similar singing way ? seulgi, juniel , and now this girl. original by taeyeon is the only sounds different
"the only one sounds different. maybe because TY vocal tone/color is indeed one of a kind
cause they sound safe. taeyeon sounds like some awesome rocker girl. I personally think instead of steady vocal someone like aoa Choa can pull off a cover. choa is more suited for indie/rock
Taeyeon tone is higher then most people that covers it the ones I seen they drop the tone of the first verse lower than when Taeyeon sings it
jungin's cover sounds different
Manami bsn she is a rocker , so she sang it like a rocker and arrangement the music to suit her
i love sleepy
This is areally hard song and she was able to control her breath and runs so well. She just need a little more power when she sang the I's and the ad-lib.
each singer has its own characteristics in terms of sound, her voice is unique and nice :D
she did greatly awesome, she improved too, esp her breathing
i think her sweet voice suits the song really well! how many points she got for this?
only 65 :(
seriously??
+Dina Sari Handayani yeah.
yes it really suits her voice but the whole performance is just like a normal stage of common music show, if you compare with the stage of dawon and OMG's seunghee
I am so proud with Minjae, she really great for choosing songs, first even thought its not great 'take care of me' showing how minjae introduce herself, then' 'shout to myself' expressing how she would do great even though she will fall and fall again, and now 'I'i.. all songs are great, showing she was no joking choosing all her songs
She deserves 100pts. Taeyeon should watch this 😊
Let's trend this and Taeyeon will watch this. 😚
I'M CRYING! YOU DID IT SO WELL, LITTLE MINJAE!
She sang great, but her emotions are missing. I can feel her admiration for Taeyeon in the song (it says that Taeyeon is her role model), but it feels like she is misinterpreting the emotions she's supposed to convey in the lyrics. Taeyeon wrote those lyrics about her loneliness and hardships in her long years of celebrity life. I don't feel the yearn and the refreshing emotion in her voice. She's still young and I have a lot of hopes for her😁 Awesome notes and vocals!
You should her other perfomance. ♥
You have to see her singing Chilgapsan!! Her emotions are in her singing!
This is really good!
Wow this is quite amazing. It's not easy to sing taeyeon's song. Kudos to this girl. BTW what show is this?
Girls Spirit
that why many people dislike it :/ i am a SONE and i think that her vocal is good, not too much strong but stable. He looks beautiful as well. she and her group "Sonammo" deserve more attention (Sonammo's songs also are good choice, check them out)
that high note was fabulous tbh
thank you
She's really good! What I really love in her performances are that verses treated with much care and emotion as choruses. Her high notes are not shabby either. Her low votes might to due to Taeyeon comparison but she should had more votes really.
beautiful performance of beautiful song of taeyeon
소나무 흥하자!!
She honestly suprised me, it was better than I expected
Damn, i really thought kei and minjae would've topped this episode, but i guess the other contestants got more votes because their songs were more popular and much more of a 'hit' ? It's a shame :/
"I" is a huge hit, I and Bang Bang Bang are the most popular for now,
"I" is like the biggest hit of them all though. It might be that it would be very hard for almost any of the contestants on this show to live up to the standards Taeyeon has set. She's also hard to hear over her instrumentation.
I is a very difficult song
I disagree on "I" being the biggest hit lol. Cheer Up and Wild Flower were pretty huge in Korea.
why blame the song, it shud be the singer smh -.-
민재도 흥해라~
Lol at those Sones commenting and treating Taeyeon like she's 'untouchable' XD
Nice Try. (From Taeyeon's fan)
GO MinJae You Can Do It, I Love You, Fighting MinJae
i liked this actually
it was a risky choice of song but tbh not even taeyeon herself can nail the same power and emotion from her own studio version on a 100% rate in live performances so i think minjae did pretty great
and comparing, as always in covers, is pointless and stupid
it's cute that taeyeon inspires minjae :)
GREAT MINJAE !!!
TS family💚
cant believe this performance got only 65 points... poor Minjae... Keep fighting and do your BEST :)
hmm her voice is nice but its not strong enough to handle this song to its full potential
Yeah because she's just a lead vocalist.
+Secret Bigstar DGNA BIG Spica Rania Stellar Baekpo NOOOOO. Minjae is main vocal with HighD.
Shinebinnie But Dohee does all the high notes and hard parts so yeah she's still considered as the lead vocalist although on TS' site, it says she's a main vocalist too
+Secret Bigstar DGNA BIG Spica Rania Stellar Baekpo No. Minjae is the main vocal not the lead.
minjae have hited high notes in sonamoo songs with Dohee and Euijin is the lead vocalist.
Shinebinnie I KNOW. READ MY COMMENT AGAIN
she deserves 100
Seo In Young being more lively feels great.. good to see her smiling and dancing along.Good job Minjae.
Minjae did great ❤❤ Fighting minjae! ❤
ps. i like her performance here but i still prepare dohee's cover of I 👌 But both are amazing. Sonamoo fighting! Main Vocal line fighting! Minjae Fighting!
I think she should have tried changing the arrangement a bit more and she might have gotten more points. The instrumentation was also louder than her sometimes which kind of doesn't work.
minjae and sleepy~TS family~
Her voice is amazing. Sounds almost like Taeyeon.
she's so awesome
she did incredible
his voice is so sweet :33
This one is also good!
Why........she deserve more than that??
good performance, definitely a hard song to cover. need more Minjae, she is such a great singer with a beautiful voice ♥♥♥
So Wonderful ❤
She did a great job but I think to sing this song, it needs more power.
My fav song, sing by my fav girlgroup member. She slay it! Taeyeon's song its difficult, but she can do well.. Its a shame that Sonamoo are underrated. They' re full of talent..Same like Oh My Girl and CLC
she has such a sweet voice i love it
she's wrecking my bias list in sonamoo😠😍
MY GIRL DESERVES MORE !!!!
How many points did this angel get
65 but she deserve more than.
wowwwww Her voice is amazing
where is she from? her group?
SonAmoo
sonamoo
sonamoo
She from group name 'SONAMOO' same company with Untouchable, Secret and B.A.P
Thanks ^^
Is it just me or at some parts did she sound like Taeyeon? not the whole thing just at some.
I love minjae 😍
I think the song is too high for her but she has a great voice :)
It actually isn't, she's a soprano too just like Taeyeon, she just can't reach the notes because her technique is improper :)
I Love This Song "I" of Taeyeon and she's sing this song 😍
"I" is a really difficult song that need a powerful vocals. I think Minjae is better with solemn songs that will fit her sweet voice
fck the votes she deserved a better outcome..still Minjae you did well Gurl..sleepy doe..sonamoo minjae Hwaiting..😢
SONAMOO Minjae sing very well, but the overall crowd isn't high, I thought she will choose 'Why' by Taeyeon ~ 'I' is very hard to sing ~ Minjae, well done !
She has certain kinks in her voice that would totally take this song to a more "independent artist" sound......but because she's a trained "idol", she gives the song the typical pop treatment. She seems to have a bit more unique voice, so I was hoping to hear a more alternative spin on this song. I wish fans would let these girls just cut loose and actually use their voices in many ways instead of the cookie-cutter holding ling notes and hitting not-even-close-to-high high notes and thinking that makes a good singer.
Wow
Your voice is a beautyyyyyyyy!
so sweet
minjae fighting!!!
That's amazing I thought Sonamoo's main vocal is High.D but Minjae has amazing voice too
Sonamoo has two main vocals. ♥
she has guts, it's nice btw
민재도 뜨자
slayyyy minjae
65 is too low I don't understand??
She did great except for that last part :(
I think she should sing Why by Taeyeon or U R by Taeyeon
Taeyeon's voice is very unique and beautiful. I think 'I' is bad choice coz it's too difficult for minjae.
tag yourself, I'm Sungyeon at 0:29
Me in school
Oh goood she's so gorgeous, i love u minjaeee 😍😍😍😘😘😘
I really like the 2:47 part
fighting!!! I'm taeyeon fan 😂
god job baby 😭
what show is this?
sleepy is the number 1 solbangul
what's the name of pogrom
Girl Spirit
❤❤❤
TaeYeon-I ❤
her name plis?
Minjae from Sonamoo. ♥
She did good, but I can see why she didn't score high. Like with Ohmom (CLC's Seunghee), there was some issues towards the end & it began to sound forced. Her voice is really good, but there's always room for improvement.
who's the guy ? btw, Minjae (?) did well
Yuri singing Taeyeon's song. jk 😂
I like Minjae's vocals. Her performance was lovely. ^^ Her score was wayyyyy too low tho.
daaaaaaaaaamn minjae!!!
for Me the best is kei
the girl from Sonamoo?
Yes, her name is Minjae.
Name show?
Girl Spirit
난 소나무 좋아해 보고싶다
minjae >< jangggg ~!!!!