We have seen BS gaslighting like this before ... look up "Two Jews Infiltrate Anti-Jewish Conference".. the man goes to AIPAC conf and confronts people outside protesting wanting a convo only to say pretty much meaningless crap.. he acts like both sides equally suffer.. again a gaslighting technique many wifebeaters tell themselves... RUdy just wants you to not be so upset as your home is bulldozed and you are thrown out your house and rendered homeless.
@@jimmydean3961 It isn't gaslighting, he is hearing the other side but also talking about his side. Only by understanding both sides can they move forward. You also have to understand that the treatment of the Palestinians by the Israeli government was caused by anti-jew rhetoric caused by the Arabs in the past (the wars and all the anti-jew propaganda based on "The Elders of Zion"), but does it make the current actions of the Israeli gov right? no it does not but it is understandable.
I'm half Palestinian and I do agree with peace I hope there is peace but for us Palestinians it can sometimes be hard to accept after all we've been through, being oppressed for 73 years and getting kicked out of our homes in 1948
@Adam Eliasi yes most ran away. My grandpa didn’t run away but they negotiated with the Jewish army so they can go through the village but not to destroy homes and property. Tira was saved, no home was destroyed. But those who attacked they got their homes destroyed. Only in big cities like Jaffa, Haifa and Akko there were some people who were kicked out of their homes. Why? Cause they lived around Jewish people so they were kicked out. But this is minority around 30% of refugees. Most were from small towns or villages who attacked and their homes were destroyed.
@Adam Eliasi well in these times (today) no one would be expelled from his home for that reason, back then Jews couldn’t trust Arabs so those who lived in Jewish areas of cities like Haifa or Jaffa were kicked out. In bigger towns near the coast there was less fighting. I’m saying around 30% I might be wrong it’s just estimated number don’t take it as a factual, maybe it’s 20% idk. But we agree that most just ran away cause it’s a normal reaction when you see multifront war . Some ran away from the Jews (cause they were afraid just from them), some because they didn’t want to be caught in crossfire. My grandpa didn’t care who will be in control - he didn’t want to leave his home. And I’m glad he stood up. I’m very happy that both sides talk to each other and are open minded people like me. We have to find the things that connect us rather than those which divide us. We are connected by heritage (Semitic people) but religion dividing us. Overall in my opinion religion should be a private matter of the individual, there’s enough land for both of us to live. We are not a population of Bangladesh for example, overall we are less than 20 million . The most difficult matter is Gaza and those who rule it. Those should go away but still people there are even more hateful to Israel - cause they were suffering because of the stupid decisions of Hamas that they put blame on Israel. So Gaza people will need more time to be more open minded unfortunately. We have to be patient, time can slowly heal us but there should be no more rocket attacks, which is the most difficult issue.
As a Jew, I get emotional and hopeful to see Arabs and Jews sitting together in peace, talking and sharing ideas in a civilized way. We need to see much more of this.
Arabs and Jewish people have never hated each other. Christian, Jewish, and Muslim Arabs lived in Palestine for centuries in peace. Arabs condemn Zionists.
@@u.y.3643 Judaism is a religion dude. There are anti-semitic people who are Arab 100%, just like there are Europeans who are anti-semitic. It doesn't mean all arabs/europeans hate Jewish people. Also,...There ARE Jewish Arabs.
While you ARE a Jewish person and you're most probably speaking from experience. and I'm sorry if you've experienced hate. It's wrong to think that all Arabs hate Jewish people because that's simply not true.
They was trying to stop this from happening, but now it's too late. After this war it will take time for people to talk again and to be ready for peace
This is one of the most civil discussion I've ever watched... It is not even a discussion or a debate, it is actually a dialogue. Not only considering it is a palestinian-israeli conversation but in general. No interrupting. They are truly and deeply listening to each other. They all are all inteligent people, not simplistic or too sentimental. They have empathy and respect and they want real answers to this everlasting conflict. 10/10.
Israelis do everything in the world to copy the Palestinians. Their food, music, language (25% of modern Hebrew is Arabic) dance, culture and of course their land.
I’m American and I’m just trying to understand this conflict better. In this discussion, I admire both sides. I wish a peaceful resolution could be found.
@@lynnsmith4 it’s has a lot to do with the Britain and giving land away that wasn’t theirs not Palestine and Israel they are both innocents killing eachother who are basically family.
I’m an American watching this trying to get more educated on these complex issues, and I’m just so impressed with the thought, dialogue, and heart here. I hadn’t heard the perspective on how US aid hurts Israel before, so this was eye opening. I hope you all get the peace and unity that you want. At least there are great people like you fighting for that
You should read the book 'The Israeli lobby and US foreign policy' by John J. Maersheimer and Stephen M. Walt. Very good book to understand the US's perspective on Israel and how it really hurts them in a way.
Duh lol. Devil is in the details. I want to hear the conversation straight from the sources and from both sides not just the narratives of the US, Palestine, or Israel alone. I want to hear it all and make my judgments based on hearing it all.@@JNAMOTORSPORTS
@@uiri The fact is that before 1948 the British ruled the place before the Ottoman and before that the Greeks and before that the Romans and before that was the kingdom of Judah (it is also written in the Qur'an) So where or when exactly was a Palestinian state?? And this means that the Arabs lived there illegally. The funny part is that the Palestinians adopted their flag in 1964 and their anthem in 1988, they did not even have a coin. A state cannot be called a state without all these conditions
As a Jewish Israeli I absolutely loved seeing this! This is our only chance at peace ❤️ By listening to each other and understanding each other’s suffering. Such initiatives MUST happen more.
Zionists are all about EXPANSION greater Israeli project all else is formality nothing to do with peace. go back 75 yrs of Atrocities, war crimes, Apartheid, genocide, ethnic cleansing. does this sound like wanting peace? listen to what Zionist leaders are saying and you will know.
Amazing!! I am a Bangladesh canadian Muslim, and This is what the world needs, you are making incredible differences for the good in this world! Thank you
@@northernlight1000 Bangladesh did not even existed 50 years ago , it’s is a political identity created in 1971 , with the help of India , culturally can you tell me even one thing which is different from India . Even your official and national language is born in ancient India. Think 🤔 again when you say culturally you are not Indian . No offense all subcontinent people have the same DNA politically we may have different passports culturally there none 🙏
@@deepaktabbbbb Our languages are different, Bangladesh is a majority Muslim country India although has many is quite the opposite, we listen to different music, watch different tv, eat similar but different food, I see what you mean as we are similar in some ways but Indians say their Indian and we say we’re Bengali its just rude and without cause to call some one from Bangladesh an Indian knowing very well their not
My name is Shula, and I am Jewish. Thank you very much for this presentation. It confronted me w/a series of ideas about my own believes. I am 81 years old and grandaughter of an Auschwitz victim. It took me a long time to accept German people. Now I do. I hope that this War will end! I know by experience that nobody can change me. I can only change myself. Continue. Best. LOVE to you all!
I am a Pakistani muslim...Now these are the kind of platforms we need to stand a chance against the hate... We need more such interactions... Well done 💐♥️🙏🌹👍
@@r.r6055 I am not gonna go back and forth in the history because historical narrative is different for both sides. Talk about present, why are Israelis building settlement colonies in West Banks?
@@goatboymagic9352 Israel has untempered power and the ability to use it. Their only limitation holding them back? Not Gaza rockets, but the fear of being condemned by the nations of the world. A line they have gotten as close as they can too.
@@andrawusazimi8428 so you wanna commit a genocide just cause they are asking for their land and liberation instead of getting displaced and living under the aggression of an occupier?
@@goatboymagic9352 No, I don't suppose that I do "wanna". In the spirit of goodwill, I will repeat myself in a way you may understand better: 'In order for the damage Israel is doing to be stopped, the Nations of the World must step in and make them. Whether that be the U.N. or their allies.' I will throw in another helpful tip as well, because I am a very charming fellow: 'In order for the damage Israel has done to be reversed, Israelis must be convinced of the need to elect a government that will do so.' I am telling you, you can talk about how the world should be until the stars expire, but it will not change what is true. If the nations of the world don't take action and Israelis keep voting for politicians who take harmful actions; then nothing will change. You want to help Palestinians? Write to your democratically elected officials who are supposed to represent you and persuade them to put pressure on Israel. Open a dialogue with an Israeli and persuade (not insult) them for the need for a responsible, humane government. Even if you fail completely your efforts will still have more impact than whining on RUclips platform.
Incredible chat. Each man held himself with dignity and wisdom. If these guys were in government huge steps would be taken for peace. Thank you for this video!
This conversation is more relevant than ever. We need more people who think like this. It would be great if you guys could write a book together about your perspectives!
@ihateoregonians Satoshi yes we need Palestinians from Gaza Strip to come and talk! Not spoiled Palestinians who suffer from breaking up with their valentines! ruclips.net/video/jbWGm-ARaSk/видео.html
Many have, it doesn’t make much of a difference or improve the lives of Palestinians who suffer under the occupation. I’m sure many israelis are nice ppl, but very rarely would they speak up when it matters
Don't blame it all on Britain. The Palestinians have different religious and ethnic identities and their attempt to define themselves started as a reaction to early 20th century Zionism.
I unsubscribed recently from hostile channels feeling a complete despair and Im so grateful to come across this beautiful conversation that restored my hope in humanity. More of this type of sincere dialogues in good faith is needed.
At about 19:00 the Palestinian Christian guy (I forgot his name) made an important point. He has Israeli friends, so he knows that not all Israelis want Palestinians to suffer. The more these two populations meet, the more likely peace will be.
I think you are correct. It's hard to hate a population when you have friendships within that population. Alienation from each other is the cause of much of these conflicts.
@John Roe let’s call them Palestinians. They may not have agreed to sharing the land with Israelis but they’re a separate people who call Eretz Yisrael home.
@@calich33sehead their Quran states G-D gave the land to the Jews so their claim to the land being theirs is a religious one therefore it contradicts their religion.
@@gamepoint8641 I challenge you to support giving all those Palestinians Israeli citizenship, and thus setting the Arab population to outnumber the Jewish population in Israel over time. Or do you have a better idea?
No one in israel want Palestinians to suffer thats the differantes We just want peace. A lot of Palestinias dont want this, they want israel to wiped out of the map, those the Palestinias we "hate" (more scared and dont trust).
I am european and you guys make me so happy. What your cultures have been through and then the empathic, but also sharp rational attitude towards each others' suffering just blows my mind. I just see the intelligence, the focus on solutions and willingness to understand both sides. It is amazing!
HI! im from Israel and i just love this dialog but what happened in 7.10 was absolute terror i, a person who always wanted peace and i hope we will get this but i must say we CANT not with Hamas-Isis i hope there are still people like them there cus in 10.7 KIDS helped to Hamas-Isis and OLD people I still have fate we can live in peace but for now it cant go on! Hamas-Isis said they will do what happened in 7.10 again and again and we cant let that happened so for now Hamas MOST DIE! if u agree or have something to say please do! let talk!
Blessed are the peacemakers. And I want to send special thanks to Rudy and Loai. I believe you have the understanding of the situation, wisdom and attitude to bring peace to our homeland. Salaam Alaikum and Shalom brothers.
I got quite emotional when the guy said 'I'm willing to compromise on revenge' willing to let go to build a better future. We need more people like this on both sides to move forward and the beginnings of mutual acceptance and peace.
Tbf this is 1000 times better than the selecticely edited garbage they have at jubilee. No one talking over each other. Genuine curiosity and wisdom in this room.
Jubilee brought close minded ppl on purpose to show the west that we hate eachother and that the conflict is not as complicated as it actually is, also trying to show that israelis are insensitive and that there is no solution. I'm sorry but this is better
First off remove every Palestinian and Israeli politician and get some real people. People who are caring and willing to move forward then we can negotiate a peace treaty. I really want to finally be able to visit my stolen land again ;(
Politicians are the reasons for war and divided. I’m still educating me on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict however from an outside perspective and also of what I’m seeing here in the US is this. You have two culture with a history of fighting eachother and have been taught to hate eachother by those in power pulling their strings for political and financial gain. I pray somehow Israelis and Palestinians can find peace. Both are human and capable and can come together and stop being used as pawns. Inshahallah there will be peace between these people.
@@hamoodtatari this land was not stolen... Jewish people are the natives of this land by history that is the main issue what people don't understand or even willing to learn the truth. With all being said I still think we need to sit and talk for our real future because we both are not going anywhere and it is doable in my opinion just need to get rid of the greedy politicians who actually do not care about the people's suffering.
@@noahi829 Zionism is a belief that jews shoudl have a state for jews in the holy land. That is a zionist state. However all 160+ countries that recognise Israel share a zionist view since they recognised it.
I love this conversation. This is one of the best platforms I have seen for this very critical issue. Thank you for this. Sending love from an Afro-American brother in the US.
I was very surprised at the parallels to the plight of the Afro-American, specifically the resulting identity due to a colonized mindset and oppressive environmental factors.
Thank you for this wonderful conversation. As a Syrian, I hope that good and moderate people on all sides prevail and unite to end the suffering that we are inflicting on each other and build a better future for our war-torn region. I have faith that the people of Israel/Palestine will be able to create one just and powerful nation that could be the core around which a new thriving middle east could crystallize.
I don't understand why, I don't even live in Israel, but this video really made me emotional. It shows humanity on both sides. Please one day leave the hate and unite, one day this life will be over for all of us anyway, lets not waste it on hating eachother.
I would love to see more of these types of videos. If possible to get this group together again to discuss 3 years later would be very interesting. Much love to all participants in this video! I hope and pray that they are all still doing well...
In terrible times like these (october 2023) I'm still hopeful we can have more conversations like these and finally reach peace and co-existence. the governments don't represent us!
I want the British and the US to stay OUT of the Israel/Palestine conflict. Let them work it out ✌. They are family and families fight, leave them work it out.
We are both children of Ibrahim, Jews are our cousins by blood fyi. Idk about today's Jews but we lived with alot pf their tribes in some arab countries. Although, their few, they still exist.
@Omry G not really When Arabs conquered they just ruled and sure some tribes did settle there but I’m certainly sure the most Levantine and North African still hold to their roots genetically maybe not so much culturally They even have certain looks
They both descend from Abraham’s children- Isaac, who 1st encountered the religion of Judaism, & Ishmael, who 1st encountered the religion of Islam. In reality, both religions really are more similar than different.
@Omry G Objection! What you are saying is solely based on the idea that the people that would eventually make up the Arab group did not, at all, venture into Israeli lands. This must be false, for humans went all over the world, and Israel didn’t have some ‘anti everyone but people that will become the Jews’ magnet.
Hey man, as a outsider. Thank you guys for giving us a understanding and some context to this story. Love to see this. İ hope that one day, these dialogues will be the tool to the solution.
As someone who has family living on the Israeli side of the Gaza border, this video really touched me. A message to those that attended this...It's people like you that need to move into politics, or positions of influence. The future would look so bright with you guys running the show. Salam/Shalom to all of you.
Looking at the sexist comments here, I ain't surprised women were not picked. Just saying no woman ever told me to kill myself or burn in hell because of my background...
@@jennymironuk6169the sexist comments are really just immature and so pointless. I agree it is about the conflict but perspective is important and representation matters. I think women have an important role in this and should be presented. However, I am going to make this clear. The discussion was amazing to see. Seriously, all do respect to all of these mens courage to engage with each other. It can be super dangerous to do that for some of them. In fact, all of them can be in danger just from this conversation alone. And that's a large problem. I'm not taking away from this conversation at all either. I only suggest this for future discussion. Also this should be called a discussion. Not a debate.
Three on left are Palestinian 3 on right see Israeli. Israel is actually a very diverse country, there are Arabs that come in every shade and Jews who come in every shade
@@Asf-bj4rw "Jews who come in every shade" Dont tell that to any Zionist... ALL their narrative is debunked when you see the different ethnicities of jews. They think they are descendands of the people of Judea. xD
@@MrZxcvbnm22 what? Nothing I’m saying is contrary to Zionism, they are actual decendents of judea we have archeological evidence and DNA evidence to prove it it’s not rly much of a question. But because of the diaspora we have Jews from very light skin Europeans to dark skinned Ethiopians
@@Asf-bj4rw So, Ethiopians are descendants of Judea? People with blue eyes are descendant of Judea? If you say yes then this debate is finished. I only debate with intelligent people.
@@MrZxcvbnm22 wel I believe the Ethiopian Jews had converted in the past but plenty of people with blue eyes are Jewish. But it seems like you’re one of those black hebrew Israelites who like to claim others culture and religion as their own instead of enjoying their own beautiful history
If this was all the media showed for a month I am convinced the problems would disperse quickly...ppl in power have all to gain and all to lose by relinquishing their control through fear
I love this! True and honest conversation without being agressive. We need more people to come together like this. i'm Israeli and i live in the "west Bank" and i had amazing conversations with friends who are arbs , and it was eye's opening for both side's. Its wasen't about changing each other prospective, it was just about knowing more , feeling empathy and find the basic things that are hurting both side's.
I'm an Israeli on the verge of leaving my homeland because of frustration with this conflict. I have been to war over this land, I've lived side by side with Arab Israelis, I've served with fascist and liberal jews alike and have been taught at school by religious Jews and Israeli Arabs and throughout my 25 years of living not a single person around me has expressed this much hope in peace for this land and the people within it like these three at 39:50 - 42:59, I am literally holding back tears . There will be no peace in our land as long as we are divided and are being manipulated by foreign powers trying to keep their influence in our territories. We are all victims of western racism, Jews and Arabs alike, and the first step towards a peaceful life for all of us is recognizing we have more in common with each other than with the US/UK/RS or any other body trying to mine our society for material/intellectual gains. No one is going anywhere and they don't want to help us, we only have each other so we better start working together to benefit whoever is actually living here instead of giving all of our resources to the US in exchange for military aid which only propagates more suffering for us.
This project is a great example of what truly can be a great future Between the Jews and Palestinians cuz no matter how you look at it their Nation would only be stronger if both Palestinians and Jews came together.
@zaxx19 the Arabic language is derived from both Aramaic which was the language spoken in israel-palestine so many years ago as well as Hebrew both Hebrew and Aramaic and a little bit of Farsi makeup the Arabic language.
@zaxx19 another piece of advice I personally as a half Arabic Palestinian on my dad's side and Latino Hispanic on my mom's side and I speak fluent Arabic and fluent Spanish I have no problem in calling the Levant Israel or Palestine the only reason I said israel-palestine is for a little whiny babies like yourself so you could feel included in the name but at the end of the day to fucking name what really needs to happen is that most Palestinians and Israelis do you need to integrate and live together and they can accomplish with the United States is accomplished in the West. In Tel Aviv today you have the second biggest Silicon Valley we're yes there are Palestinians who live in Tel Aviv for your fucking information because I've been there and seen it with my own eyes and guess what the palace things that living Tel Aviv that speak both Arabic and Hebrew are reaping the benefits of a Multicultural Society through secular thinking and science but something tells me you're more of a hardcore Palestinian probably a Muslim at that yeah you're one of those guys that want to only see Palestine as a Muslim Nation I don't understand why so it can be just as shity as every other Muslim country out there the only reason Saudi Arabia and local or even relevant is because they have oil it's not their fucking culture or religion and who gives a shit about Mecca and that shity real estate in the fucking desert at least israel-palestine has beautiful land just like California or you have Forest valleys oceans mountains prairies Etc their land is perfect for all types of fruits vegetables and have always been the Melting Pot of the Middle East in all honesty the religion of Islam has little to nothing to do with the history of israel-palestine in the bigger picture now I'm not personally saying that you can't be Muslim and proud or a Palestine Muslim you could be a Palestinian Muslim just realize that your time can be better spent assimilating into what is today already Israel and maybe have your children reap the benefits of what a Multicultural Society like Israel with all its technology and startups a lot of modern medicine and Technology comes out of Israel that we used today here in America and all of Europe wake the fuck up
I'm still pretty young I'm positive with the right attitude and the fact that I even I know more Palestinians are sick and tired of the fighting the smart Palestinians encourage their kids to go to both Israeli Americanized schools where they can learn both in Hebrew as well as an Arabic and become professional doctors lawyers at a part of a bigger society and community.
I think your problem is that you see is real today as just a small United States in the Middle East where you see the Israelis drinking alcohol smoking weed going to strip clubs all westernized and modern in your point of view about being a Palestinian Muslim is one where those two things can't mix and at the end of the day that's a your problem because most young Palestinians will they be Christians or even Muslims they're not real Muslims they don't really care though have a smoke go have a drink they like to go out and have fun in other words it doesn't matter whether you're Jewish Israeli or Palestinian Christian or Palestine Muslim most of them in the new generation are secular if you're one of those hardcore religious people then you should leave Palestine and go to Mecca that's a better place for you
@zaxx19 just so you know you're an embarrassment to every Palestinian including myself and you are the problem my friend only people like you with your mentality
I am SO proud of you Rudy and your intelligence and hard work at building peace. I commend you all. A great Jewish teacher once said this (referring to people like you and this group): Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God. - Mathew 5:9
This conversation has proved that with having open-minded and brave people on both sides, it is more likely to get rid off biased understandings and polarised stances. To my mind, this is a reasonable approach to tackle the roots of conflicts that politicians on both sides failed to address. I wish all the best to people of Israel 🇮🇱 and Palestine 🇵🇸. Peace and love from Tunisia 🇹🇳
Love this!!! I continually pray for my Israeli and Palestinian friends!!! I also pray for the peace and unity of all who live within Israel and who are suffering oppression!!
After the 7th of october I was so hopeless, I almost gave up on all hope for peace, this video, to some extent re-ignite it, thanks for making this a reallity. Even though this is a harsh time for the region it is really importent for this kind of videos should be spreaded
Towards the end it was getting a bit hot, but when the Palestinian said we agree to disagree but we have to move on and find a working solution that works for the hope and aspirations of all the people, just class. This is no wishay washy ending like a soap opera. This is hardcore realism at its best. This conversation should be aired across Palestine and Israel, and countries taking sides in this war. This should be RUclips algorithms most sold video and reshaped video ever.
I really appreciate discussions like these as they are few and far between. However, what I think would be even more telling and ultimately constructive, is if a group like this could discuss HOW exactly they see a future Israel/Palestine. In detail. Do they see it as complete Israel sovereignty, a joint union of Israel and Palestine, what kind of governing organization, etc...
@@Danny-nn8bo i feel like at this point nobody can see how this can be solved. I feel like we need to stop hating fearing and wanting to kill each other first, only then will we see how this can possibly be solved.
This conversations are so powerful! I on the brink of crying - to feel this love and connection, openness and the will to understand each other. To focus on solving the problems. I think it shows all of as a pattern how to move on from a world system, from world views which is not working anymore toward a new one, where we can have a mature existent - with our self and so with other human and not human beings.
As an Indonesian Muslim, I totally agree with discussions like this, no one is degrading each other. I hope that we as Muslims and Jews can understand each other without having to judge individual preferences.
I enjoyed this. Although, there are many more well educated on the specifics of Palestinian History youth that could’ve been chosen to debate and talk on a perspective coming with much more objective and quantitative facts. You can see the three Palestinians are a bit emotional, but they held their ground well and expressed the points well while also pointing out the problem with the opposition. As a Palestinian I feel like hearing the points Israelis make while watching Israelis hear a Palestinians perspective is very productive dialogue.
Hi Sabrena, hope you're doing well. One of the points raised in the discussion was the futility of the two state solution, and that a one state solution may be better for both groups. I believe the Israeli side mentioned that they would be happy to include those in the West Bank and Gaza as full, equal citizens, and Rudy said that regardless of the name of the state, that it would serve the interests of both groups. Would you accept a plan in which Israel were to annex the West Bank and Gaza Strip, grant each Palestinian equal and full citizenry, and remove checkpoints/IDF patrols from these areas?
I'm Jewish and I'm so very sorry to my Palestinian brothers and sisters. I love you so much and I'm sorry that you are suffering so much from our hurt. We are family and we should love one another.
This was such an interesting conversation, I would really love to hear more like this happening. It would also be great to see this group meet again for a new conversation post 7.10. Rudy and Amir look very similar as though they could be siblings. I feel like the two of them should team up in their activism, they are both very bright young men and I wish this whole group well.
This is beautiful. The world would be such a better place if people could hear and understand each other. Respect for these guys for talking in a respectful manner
Man it makes me cry even I'm a croatian katholic but seeing these two groups doing it the best way and i mean cry of happiness because history shows us a gun brings always the worst results
This is such a good discussion, reasonable, intelligent & informative for an outsider like me. This should be shown to young people. Love & forgiveness is easier said but with prayer & good works comes the “mighty change of heart.” My father was murdered, my sister was raped, I thought I would feel so much hate but I truly believe that the peaceful reassurance that all will be well comes from a greater power. 💕
Oh I know “Israelis” very well and have “Israeli” citizenship, knowing them personally and how they think makes them even more viIe, it’s all ending for you soon, love from occupied Nazareth 😊
Seeing people really trying to listen to each other and seeing the other people’s perspective makes me so emotional. I’m crying. If only we can raise young children with exercises like these… ❤😢
How is this a fair conversation with Jewish intellectuals on one side and average Palestinians on the other... youth speakers like muhammad hijab or Omar Sulieman would of made sense or look fair.
@@ShayPatrickCormacTHEHUNTER I used Muhammad hijab as an intellectual reference, though he’s not Palestinian there people Like him and Omar Sulieman who these guys can have a conversation with. Instead of engaging with laymen Palestinians who clearly cant articulate the nuances of the Palestinians struggle. THAT will be a fair conversation.
@Yasin Osman That's a good point but, the emotional issues are what matter to people at the end of the day.(it's sad but true)And Hijab does not score a point there..
This must go viral... I’m a Filipino and don’t know much about the real history of why there’s so much hatred between Israel and Palestine yet I’m so much into these matter as a human being living in the same world... We must wake up that it’s already 21st century and that hatred must be stop... And I LOVED this video because it shows that people can be open to communication... and I hope that not only we can speak but also can LISTEN TOO... please do more videos like these so others that don’t understand, can learn in general.... And also I would like to ask viewers of a video to be OPEN TO WHAT YOUR WATCHING...
watching this video as a jewish person made me cry; these men are so intelligent and well-spoken, they give me so much hope for a brighter future for all
Im Palestinian and this is sooo motivating soo positive it actually made me feel happy and hopeful i was so angry now i just want peace for both of us
We have seen BS gaslighting like this before ... look up "Two Jews Infiltrate Anti-Jewish Conference".. the man goes to AIPAC conf and confronts people outside protesting wanting a convo only to say pretty much meaningless crap.. he acts like both sides equally suffer.. again a gaslighting technique many wifebeaters tell themselves... RUdy just wants you to not be so upset as your home is bulldozed and you are thrown out your house and rendered homeless.
@@jimmydean3961 It isn't gaslighting, he is hearing the other side but also talking about his side. Only by understanding both sides can they move forward. You also have to understand that the treatment of the Palestinians by the Israeli government was caused by anti-jew rhetoric caused by the Arabs in the past (the wars and all the anti-jew propaganda based on "The Elders of Zion"), but does it make the current actions of the Israeli gov right? no it does not but it is understandable.
I'm half Palestinian and I do agree with peace I hope there is peace but for us Palestinians it can sometimes be hard to accept after all we've been through, being oppressed for 73 years and getting kicked out of our homes in 1948
@Adam Eliasi yes most ran away. My grandpa didn’t run away but they negotiated with the Jewish army so they can go through the village but not to destroy homes and property. Tira was saved, no home was destroyed. But those who attacked they got their homes destroyed. Only in big cities like Jaffa, Haifa and Akko there were some people who were kicked out of their homes. Why? Cause they lived around Jewish people so they were kicked out. But this is minority around 30% of refugees. Most were from small towns or villages who attacked and their homes were destroyed.
@Adam Eliasi well in these times (today) no one would be expelled from his home for that reason, back then Jews couldn’t trust Arabs so those who lived in Jewish areas of cities like Haifa or Jaffa were kicked out. In bigger towns near the coast there was less fighting. I’m saying around 30% I might be wrong it’s just estimated number don’t take it as a factual, maybe it’s 20% idk. But we agree that most just ran away cause it’s a normal reaction when you see multifront war . Some ran away from the Jews (cause they were afraid just from them), some because they didn’t want to be caught in crossfire. My grandpa didn’t care who will be in control - he didn’t want to leave his home. And I’m glad he stood up. I’m very happy that both sides talk to each other and are open minded people like me. We have to find the things that connect us rather than those which divide us. We are connected by heritage (Semitic people) but religion dividing us. Overall in my opinion religion should be a private matter of the individual, there’s enough land for both of us to live. We are not a population of Bangladesh for example, overall we are less than 20 million . The most difficult matter is Gaza and those who rule it. Those should go away but still people there are even more hateful to Israel - cause they were suffering because of the stupid decisions of Hamas that they put blame on Israel. So Gaza people will need more time to be more open minded unfortunately. We have to be patient, time can slowly heal us but there should be no more rocket attacks, which is the most difficult issue.
As a Jew, I get emotional and hopeful to see Arabs and Jews sitting together in peace, talking and sharing ideas in a civilized way. We need to see much more of this.
Arabs and Jewish people have never hated each other. Christian, Jewish, and Muslim Arabs lived in Palestine for centuries in peace. Arabs condemn Zionists.
@@sarayasser2972, that statement is not true at all, and History, in many instances testifies to the contrary.
@@u.y.3643 Judaism is a religion dude. There are anti-semitic people who are Arab 100%, just like there are Europeans who are anti-semitic. It doesn't mean all arabs/europeans hate Jewish people. Also,...There ARE Jewish Arabs.
While you ARE a Jewish person and you're most probably speaking from experience. and I'm sorry if you've experienced hate. It's wrong to think that all Arabs hate Jewish people because that's simply not true.
@@sarayasser2972 “Dude”Sarah; your concepts are all mixed up and flawed.
Today more than ever, the world need this video, and more conversations like this one.
100%
Noooooo
100%!
They was trying to stop this from happening, but now it's too late. After this war it will take time for people to talk again and to be ready for peace
This is one of the most civil discussion I've ever watched... It is not even a discussion or a debate, it is actually a dialogue. Not only considering it is a palestinian-israeli conversation but in general. No interrupting. They are truly and deeply listening to each other. They all are all inteligent people, not simplistic or too sentimental. They have empathy and respect and they want real answers to this everlasting conflict. 10/10.
One thing Palestinians and Israelis agree on is their mutual love for jeans
Must be the genetics
Lol jeans are a must in the middle east! this ain't North Korea habibi lol
Tight jeans
@@Zaabi jeanetics
Israelis do everything in the world to copy the Palestinians. Their food, music, language (25% of modern Hebrew is Arabic) dance, culture and of course their land.
I'm Jewish and love my Palestinian brothers
Ofcourse Jews and Palestinians are the same people both sides converted.
Me too bro me too, we're practically cousins
I'm not palestinian however I am muslim and I love my jewish brothers
I’m American and I’m just trying to understand this conflict better. In this discussion, I admire both sides. I wish a peaceful resolution could be found.
@@lynnsmith4 it’s has a lot to do with the Britain and giving land away that wasn’t theirs not Palestine and Israel they are both innocents killing eachother who are basically family.
May there be world peace
Dude really? Take a break from RUclips. Your obsession is not healthy
This guy is everywhere
Stop pls
@ihab mahdi bro I saw you too in a another video remember?
I hope I don't see you in Porn hub comment section
I’m an American watching this trying to get more educated on these complex issues, and I’m just so impressed with the thought, dialogue, and heart here. I hadn’t heard the perspective on how US aid hurts Israel before, so this was eye opening. I hope you all get the peace and unity that you want. At least there are great people like you fighting for that
You should read the book 'The Israeli lobby and US foreign policy' by John J. Maersheimer and Stephen M. Walt. Very good book to understand the US's perspective on Israel and how it really hurts them in a way.
US fcked many countries in the middle east, Irak and Afghanistan also for example. No wonder many muslim countries disslike USA
@@boshurat6189no it doesn’t hurt us at all
It’s democracy
What do you need to understand? They have religious issues and problems
Duh lol. Devil is in the details. I want to hear the conversation straight from the sources and from both sides not just the narratives of the US, Palestine, or Israel alone. I want to hear it all and make my judgments based on hearing it all.@@JNAMOTORSPORTS
As a Palestinian and this was a great video. Very respectful and intellectual guests.
Dude, you cant call yourself "Palestinian" if there has never been such a state.
but i still like your commant
@RealSeif 47 True. Israel wasnt exist before 1948. but "Palestine" wasnt exist before or today.
@@uribarel my guy says we aren't Palestinian when The word 'Palestine' dates back when the Greek called us phillistens
@@uribarel and BTW the British made the state called Palestine so there really was a state idiot
@@uiri The fact is that before 1948 the British ruled the place before the Ottoman and before that the Greeks and before that the Romans and before that was the kingdom of Judah (it is also written in the Qur'an)
So where or when exactly was a Palestinian state??
And this means that the Arabs lived there illegally.
The funny part is that the Palestinians adopted their flag in 1964 and their anthem in 1988, they did not even have a coin.
A state cannot be called a state without all these conditions
As a Jewish Israeli I absolutely loved seeing this!
This is our only chance at peace ❤️ By listening to each other and understanding each other’s suffering.
Such initiatives MUST happen more.
Thank you for being open minded. I hope peace prevails.
AF
Yeah? Look at today the results of your guys ideas
Zionists are all about EXPANSION greater Israeli project all else is formality nothing to do with peace. go back 75 yrs of Atrocities, war crimes, Apartheid, genocide, ethnic cleansing. does this sound like wanting peace? listen to what Zionist leaders are saying and you will know.
@@david.guez13ah yes, all those leftist peaceniks who have been running Israel for the last few decades...
Amazing!! I am a Bangladesh canadian Muslim, and This is what the world needs, you are making incredible differences for the good in this world! Thank you
Do they teach u about J. f. R. Jacob in school in bangladesh?
More diplomacy, fewer guns.
@manuka no I am not lol, why do you think that
@@northernlight1000 Bangladesh did not even existed 50 years ago , it’s is a political identity created in 1971 , with the help of India , culturally can you tell me even one thing which is different from India . Even your official and national language is born in ancient India. Think 🤔 again when you say culturally you are not Indian . No offense all subcontinent people have the same DNA politically we may have different passports culturally there none 🙏
@@deepaktabbbbb Our languages are different, Bangladesh is a majority Muslim country India although has many is quite the opposite, we listen to different music, watch different tv, eat similar but different food, I see what you mean as we are similar in some ways but Indians say their Indian and we say we’re Bengali its just rude and without cause to call some one from Bangladesh an Indian knowing very well their not
My name is Shula, and I am Jewish. Thank you very much for this presentation. It confronted me w/a series of ideas about my own believes. I am 81 years old and grandaughter of an Auschwitz victim. It took me a long time to accept German people. Now I do. I hope that this War will end! I know by experience that nobody can change me. I can only change myself. Continue. Best. LOVE to you all!
I am a Pakistani muslim...Now these are the kind of platforms we need to stand a chance against the hate... We need more such interactions... Well done 💐♥️🙏🌹👍
Steve Trevor? Nice username for a Pakistani Muslim 😂
@@QaasymZafar Its a necessity... Due to extremist hard liner self proclaimed muftis on social media.... 🙂 Have a lovely day...
Indians and Pakistanis should sit down like this and have a healthy debate.
@@chadd498 I believe it will be 10 times more cordial than this... Almost all Pakistanis barring corrupt elitists do not give a damn about Kashmir
Love and peace from Israel♥
Thats what the most of the Israeli civilians and Palestine civilians want.
TAKE CARE AND STAY SAFE
From all the videos on the web about this subject, this might be the most important and dignified attempt to represent both sides fairly.
u cant justify when UN have already come up with a 2 state solution and Israel still building settlements in west bank.
@@r.r6055 I am not gonna go back and forth in the history because historical narrative is different for both sides. Talk about present, why are Israelis building settlement colonies in West Banks?
@@goatboymagic9352 Israel has untempered power and the ability to use it. Their only limitation holding them back? Not Gaza rockets, but the fear of being condemned by the nations of the world. A line they have gotten as close as they can too.
@@andrawusazimi8428 so you wanna commit a genocide just cause they are asking for their land and liberation instead of getting displaced and living under the aggression of an occupier?
@@goatboymagic9352 No, I don't suppose that I do "wanna". In the spirit of goodwill, I will repeat myself in a way you may understand better:
'In order for the damage Israel is doing to be stopped, the Nations of the World must step in and make them. Whether that be the U.N. or their allies.'
I will throw in another helpful tip as well, because I am a very charming fellow:
'In order for the damage Israel has done to be reversed, Israelis must be convinced of the need to elect a government that will do so.'
I am telling you, you can talk about how the world should be until the stars expire, but it will not change what is true. If the nations of the world don't take action and Israelis keep voting for politicians who take harmful actions; then nothing will change. You want to help Palestinians? Write to your democratically elected officials who are supposed to represent you and persuade them to put pressure on Israel. Open a dialogue with an Israeli and persuade (not insult) them for the need for a responsible, humane government.
Even if you fail completely your efforts will still have more impact than whining on RUclips platform.
Incredible chat. Each man held himself with dignity and wisdom. If these guys were in government huge steps would be taken for peace. Thank you for this video!
This conversation is more relevant than ever. We need more people who think like this. It would be great if you guys could write a book together about your perspectives!
Absolutely fascinating to watch, if only more Israelis and Palestinians could sit down and talk like this...
@ihateoregonians Satoshi yes we need Palestinians from Gaza Strip to come and talk! Not spoiled Palestinians who suffer from breaking up with their valentines! ruclips.net/video/jbWGm-ARaSk/видео.html
Trust me there more :)
Many have, it doesn’t make much of a difference or improve the lives of Palestinians who suffer under the occupation. I’m sure many israelis are nice ppl, but very rarely would they speak up when it matters
Greater israel on the way
M m e
2:58 “…we can live together whenever we forget about our pride.” That’s true of any situation, isn’t it. Powerful and poignant words for today. ❤
The issue is the media wont let anyone forget about anything that causes conflict.
One once said "if 2 fishes are fighting in a lake, then an English had passed by the lake before." XD
😂😂 👍
Best comment 😁😁🙌🙌👍👍
@Aksay Basumatary it’s not Jew vs Muslim, it’s Israel vs Palestine
Don't blame it all on Britain. The Palestinians have different religious and ethnic identities and their attempt to define themselves started as a reaction to early 20th century Zionism.
okay but I laughed at that because it's true
I unsubscribed recently from hostile channels feeling a complete despair and Im so grateful to come across this beautiful conversation that restored my hope in humanity. More of this type of sincere dialogues in good faith is needed.
At about 19:00 the Palestinian Christian guy (I forgot his name) made an important point. He has Israeli friends, so he knows that not all Israelis want Palestinians to suffer. The more these two populations meet, the more likely peace will be.
I think you are correct. It's hard to hate a population when you have friendships within that population. Alienation from each other is the cause of much of these conflicts.
@John Roe let’s call them Palestinians. They may not have agreed to sharing the land with Israelis but they’re a separate people who call Eretz Yisrael home.
@@calich33sehead their Quran states G-D gave the land to the Jews so their claim to the land being theirs is a religious one therefore it contradicts their religion.
@@gamepoint8641 I challenge you to support giving all those Palestinians Israeli citizenship, and thus setting the Arab population to outnumber the Jewish population in Israel over time. Or do you have a better idea?
No one in israel want Palestinians to suffer thats the differantes
We just want peace. A lot of Palestinias dont want this, they want israel to wiped out of the map, those the Palestinias we "hate" (more scared and dont trust).
I hope all these guys and their families are safe it’s so surreal to see such a civil and polite conversation with how things have gone.
Im so proud of all that participated in this gathering.
Sure! The oppressed and the oppressor on the same table.
@@jonsnow4029 jesus bro. Im palestinian but God damn give the israelu PEOPLE not government a chance
@zaxx19 no that's not what he meant. Both of you calm down
@@jonsnow4029 Please change the nerrative. I coould say the Victrious and the Looser. We must put the past behind and move into the Future
@@BoottheHost we are a democracy and our government really isn't that bad as it seems :)
I am european and you guys make me so happy. What your cultures have been through and then the empathic, but also sharp rational attitude towards each others' suffering just blows my mind. I just see the intelligence, the focus on solutions and willingness to understand both sides. It is amazing!
HI! im from Israel and i just love this dialog but what happened in 7.10 was absolute terror i, a person who always wanted peace and i hope we will get this but i must say we CANT not with Hamas-Isis i hope there are still people like them there cus in 10.7 KIDS helped to Hamas-Isis and OLD people I still have fate we can live in peace but for now it cant go on! Hamas-Isis said they will do what happened in 7.10 again and again and we cant let that happened so for now Hamas MOST DIE! if u agree or have something to say please do! let talk!
After 10 years + of studying the Israeli Palestinian, I got to see something new and refreshing. The discussion was very authentic.
Amaaaaazing discussion. This is the kind of work that elevates both of our peoples
Yes man! We need more of this!! We’re friends not enemies!
Yes stop fighting your own family ✌
I said the same thing
Blessed are the peacemakers.
And I want to send special thanks to Rudy and Loai. I believe you have the understanding of the situation, wisdom and attitude to bring peace to our homeland. Salaam Alaikum and Shalom brothers.
Peace starts with accountability and treating Palestinians with justice and dignity! Otherwise, this is just that: talking!
Peace to you is a curse for palestinians, every time you make peace with other nations, palestine doesn't involve
@@milibaz1977 exactly
putin is not one of those peacemakers...
@@milibaz1977 Let me get this straight... because i want peace you assume I'm not Palestinian? Do you realize how that sounds?
I got quite emotional when the guy said 'I'm willing to compromise on revenge' willing to let go to build a better future. We need more people like this on both sides to move forward and the beginnings of mutual acceptance and peace.
Problem is not everyone is at that stage
Looks like someones been watching jubilee
Tbf this is 1000 times better than the selecticely edited garbage they have at jubilee. No one talking over each other. Genuine curiosity and wisdom in this room.
actually I think it's much better
Jubilee's Israeli-Palestinian conversation was kinda terrible. This is much better.
Jubilee brought close minded ppl on purpose to show the west that we hate eachother and that the conflict is not as complicated as it actually is, also trying to show that israelis are insensitive and that there is no solution. I'm sorry but this is better
@@ayosup2239 yes i 100% agree with you but the format is still very clearly inspired by jubilee
i wish the politicians of both side could sit together and talk to each other on this way.. problem solved...
one of the way to start world war 3 lol
@@MiceDevelopment If the humans dont speak to each other...
First off remove every Palestinian and Israeli politician and get some real people. People who are caring and willing to move forward then we can negotiate a peace treaty. I really want to finally be able to visit my stolen land again ;(
Politicians are the reasons for war and divided. I’m still educating me on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict however from an outside perspective and also of what I’m seeing here in the US is this. You have two culture with a history of fighting eachother and have been taught to hate eachother by those in power pulling their strings for political and financial gain. I pray somehow Israelis and Palestinians can find peace. Both are human and capable and can come together and stop being used as pawns. Inshahallah there will be peace between these people.
@@hamoodtatari this land was not stolen... Jewish people are the natives of this land by history that is the main issue what people don't understand or even willing to learn the truth. With all being said I still think we need to sit and talk for our real future because we both are not going anywhere and it is doable in my opinion just need to get rid of the greedy politicians who actually do not care about the people's suffering.
"The parties that we trust to broker peace, are the same parties who make the most money from our conflicts." There it is.
These are the people we need right now. Educated, open minded, and want peace.
It is a shame that this video hasn't reached for more people
It won't be peace with Zionisty Israel... Because it's spreading strife between the countries of the Middle East... So it's like a virus not a friend
@@noahi829 You know zionism isn’t an insult right.By zionist defenition there are currently 160 zionist countries in the world
@@Cmokshofra there's only 1 Zionisty entity which is isreal
@@noahi829 Zionism is a belief that jews shoudl have a state for jews in the holy land. That is a zionist state. However all 160+ countries that recognise Israel share a zionist view since they recognised it.
@@noahi829 you’re just brainwashed. You’re causing more pain to that conflict
i cannot believe how knowledgeable and intelligent you guys are!
That’s because your intelligence is very limited
I love this conversation. This is one of the best platforms I have seen for this very critical issue. Thank you for this. Sending love from an Afro-American brother in the US.
I was very surprised at the parallels to the plight of the Afro-American, specifically the resulting identity due to a colonized mindset and oppressive environmental factors.
Thank you for this wonderful conversation. As a Syrian, I hope that good and moderate people on all sides prevail and unite to end the suffering that we are inflicting on each other and build a better future for our war-torn region. I have faith that the people of Israel/Palestine will be able to create one just and powerful nation that could be the core around which a new thriving middle east could crystallize.
I agree and share your hopes too. Hope you're doing ok in Syria. love from Israel
OMG I GET EMOTIONAL JUST THINKING ABOUT POTENTIAL PEACE BETWEEN PALESTINIANS AND ISRAELIS! One day in sha Allah! ❤️
@Lala Lulu amd because of people like you there isn't yet.
@@ruth078 an eye for an eye
لا تبيعين بلدك طيب هذي البلد حقت الفلسطينيين فقط ومحد له حق يجي ويشارك هذي ارض العرب
Amen 🙏🏽
وعد الله لا يخلف الله وعده. هذه ارض المسلمين. تحياتي الطيبة من مصر.
I don't understand why, I don't even live in Israel, but this video really made me emotional. It shows humanity on both sides. Please one day leave the hate and unite, one day this life will be over for all of us anyway, lets not waste it on hating eachother.
I would love to see more of these types of videos. If possible to get this group together again to discuss 3 years later would be very interesting. Much love to all participants in this video! I hope and pray that they are all still doing well...
In terrible times like these (october 2023) I'm still hopeful we can have more conversations like these and finally reach peace and co-existence. the governments don't represent us!
I want the British and the US to stay OUT of the Israel/Palestine conflict. Let them work it out ✌. They are family and families fight, leave them work it out.
This is a one way oppression. Not a conflict between two equal sides. Let’s get the terminology right!
Jon Snow no there are 2 sides no matter which way you look at it
I agree but the US does need to make deals with Israel no matter what Palestine thinks
It always seems that the west wants to be the world's police, but in reality they just end up making things worse.
Unfortunately Zionists are in control of Israel, USA, NATO, and other powerful Organizations.
He was right Arabs and Jews are both Semites. They came from very simular cultures .They were one people at some stage.
We are both children of Ibrahim, Jews are our cousins by blood fyi. Idk about today's Jews but we lived with alot pf their tribes in some arab countries. Although, their few, they still exist.
@@mbreeze2203 today’s Jews are still largely partially middle eastern. 70% of jews have middle eastern heritage
@Omry G not really
When Arabs conquered they just ruled and sure some tribes did settle there but I’m certainly sure the most Levantine and North African still hold to their roots genetically maybe not so much culturally
They even have certain looks
They both descend from Abraham’s children- Isaac, who 1st encountered the religion of Judaism, & Ishmael, who 1st encountered the religion of Islam. In reality, both religions really are more similar than different.
@Omry G Objection! What you are saying is solely based on the idea that the people that would eventually make up the Arab group did not, at all, venture into Israeli lands. This must be false, for humans went all over the world, and Israel didn’t have some ‘anti everyone but people that will become the Jews’ magnet.
Hey man, as a outsider. Thank you guys for giving us a understanding and some context to this story. Love to see this.
İ hope that one day, these dialogues will be the tool to the solution.
This was 3 years ago
I wonder what would happen if we brought back all these men today
As someone who has family living on the Israeli side of the Gaza border, this video really touched me. A message to those that attended this...It's people like you that need to move into politics, or positions of influence. The future would look so bright with you guys running the show. Salam/Shalom to all of you.
I hope you are ok ❤️
We need to all run the show. Can't wait for someone else to lead us it's not gonna happen
Some women in this conversation is needed. From both sides.
I have seen the women doing the conversations and always their emotions get in the way
women tend to have more extreme views I noticd. Just saying
Looking at the sexist comments here, I ain't surprised women were not picked. Just saying no woman ever told me to kill myself or burn in hell because of my background...
@R S an all women group is a great idea but in the same time this issue got nothing to deal with gender .. It's about the conflict
@@jennymironuk6169the sexist comments are really just immature and so pointless. I agree it is about the conflict but perspective is important and representation matters. I think women have an important role in this and should be presented. However, I am going to make this clear. The discussion was amazing to see. Seriously, all do respect to all of these mens courage to engage with each other. It can be super dangerous to do that for some of them. In fact, all of them can be in danger just from this conversation alone. And that's a large problem. I'm not taking away from this conversation at all either. I only suggest this for future discussion. Also this should be called a discussion. Not a debate.
Except for the guy who's wearing kippah. I honestly cant identify who's israeli and who's palestinian.
Three on left are Palestinian 3 on right see Israeli. Israel is actually a very diverse country, there are Arabs that come in every shade and Jews who come in every shade
@@Asf-bj4rw "Jews who come in every shade" Dont tell that to any Zionist... ALL their narrative is debunked when you see the different ethnicities of jews. They think they are descendands of the people of Judea. xD
@@MrZxcvbnm22 what? Nothing I’m saying is contrary to Zionism, they are actual decendents of judea we have archeological evidence and DNA evidence to prove it it’s not rly much of a question. But because of the diaspora we have Jews from very light skin Europeans to dark skinned Ethiopians
@@Asf-bj4rw So, Ethiopians are descendants of Judea? People with blue eyes are descendant of Judea? If you say yes then this debate is finished. I only debate with intelligent people.
@@MrZxcvbnm22 wel I believe the Ethiopian Jews had converted in the past but plenty of people with blue eyes are Jewish. But it seems like you’re one of those black hebrew Israelites who like to claim others culture and religion as their own instead of enjoying their own beautiful history
I am Jewish and probably the best conversation I’ve seen . Peace for both people 🇮🇱🇵🇸. I hope one day both people live together happy. 💕
I got stressed before watching this video😬 But now I say that this dialogue is necessary for any dispute 💕💜 love both from Iran❤
If this was all the media showed for a month I am convinced the problems would disperse quickly...ppl in power have all to gain and all to lose by relinquishing their control through fear
As an Iraqi I love this
Same
You like that Israel is building illegal settlements? What's wrong with you?
@@ciaronsmith4995 No the talking about peace, ill never support those settlements
@God Syria and Iraq are the best!
@@ciaronsmith4995 Building a room inside your house is illegal?
Where did you get that idea from?
This was the most informative dialogue between Palestinians and Israelis I ever saw. It was done with fairness, dignity, and respect.
I love this! True and honest conversation without being agressive. We need more people to come together like this. i'm Israeli and i live in the "west Bank" and i had amazing conversations with friends who are arbs , and it was eye's opening for both side's. Its wasen't about changing each other prospective, it was just about knowing more , feeling empathy and find the basic things that are hurting both side's.
We need more of this! Thanks for posting this video, especially when almost all hope has become so far-fetched in the region....
PEACE. Yes.
This should be shown all over the world today and on every platform. " We can only find resolution and peace form the ground up."
Im not Jewish or Palestinian and watch this with a tear of optimism... I pray for a end to all hateful suffering.
I am Jewish and I love both Israelis and Palestinians. Wishing that we can end the pain and pray together peacefully.
I'm an Israeli on the verge of leaving my homeland because of frustration with this conflict. I have been to war over this land, I've lived side by side with Arab Israelis, I've served with fascist and liberal jews alike and have been taught at school by religious Jews and Israeli Arabs and throughout my 25 years of living not a single person around me has expressed this much hope in peace for this land and the people within it like these three at 39:50 - 42:59, I am literally holding back tears . There will be no peace in our land as long as we are divided and are being manipulated by foreign powers trying to keep their influence in our territories. We are all victims of western racism, Jews and Arabs alike, and the first step towards a peaceful life for all of us is recognizing we have more in common with each other than with the US/UK/RS or any other body trying to mine our society for material/intellectual gains. No one is going anywhere and they don't want to help us, we only have each other so we better start working together to benefit whoever is actually living here instead of giving all of our resources to the US in exchange for military aid which only propagates more suffering for us.
This project is a great example of what truly can be a great future Between the Jews and Palestinians cuz no matter how you look at it their Nation would only be stronger if both Palestinians and Jews came together.
@zaxx19 the Arabic language is derived from both Aramaic which was the language spoken in israel-palestine so many years ago as well as Hebrew both Hebrew and Aramaic and a little bit of Farsi makeup the Arabic language.
@zaxx19 another piece of advice I personally as a half Arabic Palestinian on my dad's side and Latino Hispanic on my mom's side and I speak fluent Arabic and fluent Spanish I have no problem in calling the Levant Israel or Palestine the only reason I said israel-palestine is for a little whiny babies like yourself so you could feel included in the name but at the end of the day to fucking name what really needs to happen is that most Palestinians and Israelis do you need to integrate and live together and they can accomplish with the United States is accomplished in the West. In Tel Aviv today you have the second biggest Silicon Valley we're yes there are Palestinians who live in Tel Aviv for your fucking information because I've been there and seen it with my own eyes and guess what the palace things that living Tel Aviv that speak both Arabic and Hebrew are reaping the benefits of a Multicultural Society through secular thinking and science but something tells me you're more of a hardcore Palestinian probably a Muslim at that yeah you're one of those guys that want to only see Palestine as a Muslim Nation I don't understand why so it can be just as shity as every other Muslim country out there the only reason Saudi Arabia and local or even relevant is because they have oil it's not their fucking culture or religion and who gives a shit about Mecca and that shity real estate in the fucking desert at least israel-palestine has beautiful land just like California or you have Forest valleys oceans mountains prairies Etc their land is perfect for all types of fruits vegetables and have always been the Melting Pot of the Middle East in all honesty the religion of Islam has little to nothing to do with the history of israel-palestine in the bigger picture now I'm not personally saying that you can't be Muslim and proud or a Palestine Muslim you could be a Palestinian Muslim just realize that your time can be better spent assimilating into what is today already Israel and maybe have your children reap the benefits of what a Multicultural Society like Israel with all its technology and startups a lot of modern medicine and Technology comes out of Israel that we used today here in America and all of Europe wake the fuck up
I'm still pretty young I'm positive with the right attitude and the fact that I even I know more Palestinians are sick and tired of the fighting the smart Palestinians encourage their kids to go to both Israeli Americanized schools where they can learn both in Hebrew as well as an Arabic and become professional doctors lawyers at a part of a bigger society and community.
I think your problem is that you see is real today as just a small United States in the Middle East where you see the Israelis drinking alcohol smoking weed going to strip clubs all westernized and modern in your point of view about being a Palestinian Muslim is one where those two things can't mix and at the end of the day that's a your problem because most young Palestinians will they be Christians or even Muslims they're not real Muslims they don't really care though have a smoke go have a drink they like to go out and have fun in other words it doesn't matter whether you're Jewish Israeli or Palestinian Christian or Palestine Muslim most of them in the new generation are secular if you're one of those hardcore religious people then you should leave Palestine and go to Mecca that's a better place for you
@zaxx19 just so you know you're an embarrassment to every Palestinian including myself and you are the problem my friend only people like you with your mentality
😭 Free Palestinian from Hamas. Glimpse of hope, imagine if all Palestinians and Israelis think like them.
Beautiful please bring this group back together post 10/7. Where is everyone now?
Hey Rudy, you are such a good human being. I love your views and compassion for both sides of the conflict. May god bless you my brother
Watching this video with all that is going on right now is heartbreaking💔
I hope you all can find peace and a solution
Watching this in October 23 is even more heart breaking.
This touches my heart inshallah one day conflicts ends and palestinians live a good life
If only governments could communicate like this. maybe we would actually get somewhere
I am SO proud of you Rudy and your intelligence and hard work at building peace. I commend you all. A great Jewish teacher once said this (referring to people like you and this group):
Blessed are the peacemakers,
for they will be called children of God. - Mathew 5:9
Great discussion 🇵🇸 🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇱🇧🇱🇧
@@libhabib1832 🇮🇱
@@jake4297 🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧
🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
I'm a palestinian Canadian and I'm super grateful for these videos thank you.
Then you aren't pure palestinian.. true palestinian never sees isreal as a friend.. it's like never
I'm an israeli american and I am thankful you can say that
@@noahi829 actually real pasletinians look forward to peace and love
@@noahi829exactly
Damn I loved this.
Thank you for this video! Thank you thank you thank you!!!!!
British empire left lasting impact around the world. Most conflicts today can be traced back to it.
the state of israel is the last trace of the colonialist mindset of british empire
This one can not be. Jews have been under attack since the birth of Islam. The roots of the conflict are not in the actions of the Brits.
@@saraengnoite6766 African countries exists lol
This conversation has proved that with having open-minded and brave people on both sides, it is more likely to get rid off biased understandings and polarised stances. To my mind, this is a reasonable approach to tackle the roots of conflicts that politicians on both sides failed to address. I wish all the best to people of Israel 🇮🇱 and Palestine 🇵🇸.
Peace and love from Tunisia 🇹🇳
Love this!!! I continually pray for my Israeli and Palestinian friends!!! I also pray for the peace and unity of all who live within Israel and who are suffering oppression!!
After the 7th of october I was so hopeless, I almost gave up on all hope for peace, this video, to some extent re-ignite it, thanks for making this a reallity. Even though this is a harsh time for the region it is really importent for this kind of videos should be spreaded
Towards the end it was getting a bit hot, but when the Palestinian said we agree to disagree but we have to move on and find a working solution that works for the hope and aspirations of all the people, just class. This is no wishay washy ending like a soap opera. This is hardcore realism at its best. This conversation should be aired across Palestine and Israel, and countries taking sides in this war. This should be RUclips algorithms most sold video and reshaped video ever.
Thank you Rudy for restoring my faith in humanity!!!
I really appreciate discussions like these as they are few and far between. However, what I think would be even more telling and ultimately constructive, is if a group like this could discuss HOW exactly they see a future Israel/Palestine. In detail. Do they see it as complete Israel sovereignty, a joint union of Israel and Palestine, what kind of governing organization, etc...
its only my opinion and i might be very wrong but i think its too early for that. we have to stop hating fearing and wanting to kill each other first.
@@Danny-nn8bo i feel like at this point nobody can see how this can be solved. I feel like we need to stop hating fearing and wanting to kill each other first, only then will we see how this can possibly be solved.
This conversations are so powerful! I on the brink of crying - to feel this love and connection, openness and the will to understand each other. To focus on solving the problems. I think it shows all of as a pattern how to move on from a world system, from world views which is not working anymore toward a new one, where we can have a mature existent - with our self and so with other human and not human beings.
This is the type of dialogue Palestinians and Israelis need to have without Hamas or the Israeli Government speaking on behalf of civilians.
This is so amazing to see! In these dire times today, I hope this dialogue does not end now. There is hope!
As an Indonesian Muslim, I totally agree with discussions like this, no one is degrading each other. I hope that we as Muslims and Jews can understand each other without having to judge individual preferences.
Many Jews anti Zionism, Israel and Zionism is not religious, it have secular motive
@@tungkarainaina berisik
Much better than the stuff on Jubilee. All the guests utmost well-spoken and respectful. Fantastic video.
I enjoyed this. Although, there are many more well educated on the specifics of Palestinian History youth that could’ve been chosen to debate and talk on a perspective coming with much more objective and quantitative facts. You can see the three Palestinians are a bit emotional, but they held their ground well and expressed the points well while also pointing out the problem with the opposition. As a Palestinian I feel like hearing the points Israelis make while watching Israelis hear a Palestinians perspective is very productive dialogue.
Ofcourse it is, discussions always go great when both sides are actually listening to the other. Godspeed
Hi Sabrena, hope you're doing well. One of the points raised in the discussion was the futility of the two state solution, and that a one state solution may be better for both groups. I believe the Israeli side mentioned that they would be happy to include those in the West Bank and Gaza as full, equal citizens, and Rudy said that regardless of the name of the state, that it would serve the interests of both groups. Would you accept a plan in which Israel were to annex the West Bank and Gaza Strip, grant each Palestinian equal and full citizenry, and remove checkpoints/IDF patrols from these areas?
I'm Jewish and I'm so very sorry to my Palestinian brothers and sisters. I love you so much and I'm sorry that you are suffering so much from our hurt. We are family and we should love one another.
@@theteller393 some of us do. Some of us don't. I don't.
This was such an interesting conversation, I would really love to hear more like this happening. It would also be great to see this group meet again for a new conversation post 7.10. Rudy and Amir look very similar as though they could be siblings. I feel like the two of them should team up in their activism, they are both very bright young men and I wish this whole group well.
I really enjoyed this conversation. The first sensible discussion I have seen in ages. I wish peace for you all.
This is beautiful. The world would be such a better place if people could hear and understand each other. Respect for these guys for talking in a respectful manner
Man it makes me cry even I'm a croatian katholic but seeing these two groups doing it the best way and i mean cry of happiness because history shows us a gun brings always the worst results
This is such a good discussion, reasonable, intelligent & informative for an outsider like me. This should be shown to young people. Love & forgiveness is easier said but with prayer & good works comes the “mighty change of heart.” My father was murdered, my sister was raped, I thought I would feel so much hate but I truly believe that the peaceful reassurance that all will be well comes from a greater power. 💕
I agree with what was said, to start, there needs to be dialog and Israelis and Palestinians need to get to know each other, start with that!.
Oh I know “Israelis” very well and have “Israeli” citizenship, knowing them personally and how they think makes them even more viIe, it’s all ending for you soon, love from occupied Nazareth 😊
A beautiful expression of lovely peoples and 2 civilizations how needs to be freedom together peace from friendly french Jewish ✌💖
Seeing people really trying to listen to each other and seeing the other people’s perspective makes me so emotional. I’m crying. If only we can raise young children with exercises like these… ❤😢
Thank you for that Rudy!
Its important to hear all kind of voices 🇮🇱
Okay, but when can we have justice and peace?
Dude that spoke at the end was awesome! Really open minded and empathetic.. We need more people like you.
How is this a fair conversation with Jewish intellectuals on one side and average Palestinians on the other... youth speakers like muhammad hijab or Omar Sulieman would of made sense or look fair.
Muhammad Hijab is Egyptian though
@Yasin Osman doesn't matter as he doesn't know how it's like being Palestinian...
@@ShayPatrickCormacTHEHUNTER I used Muhammad hijab as an intellectual reference, though he’s not Palestinian there people Like him and Omar Sulieman who these guys can have a conversation with. Instead of engaging with laymen Palestinians who clearly cant articulate the nuances of the Palestinians struggle. THAT will be a fair conversation.
How are they supposed to get hijab all the way from the UK. And tbf both sides are intellectual.
@Yasin Osman That's a good point but, the emotional issues are what matter to people at the end of the day.(it's sad but true)And Hijab does not score a point there..
This is wonderful. But needs Hebrew subtitles too, to reach wider israeli audiences too!!!
Almost all Israeli people know english so no need for Hebrew subtitles really
This must go viral...
I’m a Filipino and don’t know much about the real history of why there’s so much hatred between Israel and Palestine yet I’m so much into these matter as a human being living in the same world...
We must wake up that it’s already 21st century and that hatred must be stop...
And I LOVED this video because it shows that people can be open to communication... and I hope that not only we can speak but also can LISTEN TOO...
please do more videos like these so others that don’t understand, can learn in general....
And also I would like to ask viewers of a video to be OPEN TO WHAT YOUR WATCHING...
Thanks!
watching this video as a jewish person made me cry; these men are so intelligent and well-spoken, they give me so much hope for a brighter future for all