Was Sir Syed Ahmad Khan A Traitor? | Lie Or Truth | Dr Israr Ahmed
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 сен 2024
- In this video, there is a conversation between the program host and Dr Israr Ahmed and Javed Iqbal on Sir Syed Ahmed Khan whether he was a traitor to the country or a patriot
SUBSCRIBE OUR CHANNEL Here You Will Get Videos Of Great Scholars Like Dr Israr Ahmed,Dr Zakir Naik And Mufti Tariq Masood
Dr Israr Ahmad is a great scholar of Islam who speaks in the light of references from Quran and Hadith
Why fatwas were issued on Sir Syed Ahmed Khan !,What was the real purpose of Sir Syed Ahmed Khan?,From the Islamic point of view, which people are fatwas imposed on?,How was the existence of Pakistan possible?
What was the position of Allama Iqbal Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and Quaid e Azam on the existence of Pakistan? Discussion on Islamic debate between program host and Dr Israr Ahmed or Javed Iqbal
#drisrarahmed #islamicvideos #islamic #drzakirnaik #muftitariqmasood #quran #hadees #drisrarahmed #sirsyedahmadkhan #traitor #islamicscholar #newislamicspeech
ALLAH Kareem Dr. Israr Ahmed sahab ke darjaat buland farmaye aur unhain karwat karwat jannat atta farmaye. Ameen Sum Ameen
What a dominating personality Dr. Israr Sahab may ALLAH SUBHAN WA TAALA please with him .
What a personality Dr sahab had. An amazing personality.
❤ ALLAH PAK ❤️ DR Israr Ahmed ko Jannat Ul Firdos Mai Alaw mauqam ata farmayain AMEEN SUMA AMEEN.
(Legend Dr Israr Ahmed)
یا اللہ ، ڈاکٹر اسرار رحمہ اللہ کے درجات بلند فرما۔ آ مین
❤❤❤
آمین ثم آمین
Yes ,I would say he is a traitor ,a supporter of british ,he doesnt deserve any respect.
Thanks for sharing this video clip. Very informative about our history
What was a Great Scholar Ma-Shaa-Allah. He was one of the few Jewels & James of Pakistan's history.
Urdu main likh len ya English par grip kren 🙏
@@adilali5517
Sahi kaha aap nay.
Gems ko james like diya
@@yasmintajuddin3949 thanks for taking it positively
ماشاء اللہ، ڈاکٹر صاحب نے خوب جواب دیا سیکولرازم
ڈاکٹر اسرار صاحب۔❤
Allah Tallah Dr Israr Ahmad ko Jannat Al Firdos main Aala Mukam Atta Farmaya .
ہمارا مذہب اسلام کئی گنا بہتر ہے سیکولرزم سے اسلامی اجازت ہے ہر مذہب کو اپنی رسومات کرنے کی لیکن ہم مسلمانوں کو انہیں تبلیغ کرنے کی ضرورت ہے
You r right Islam allows but today's Muslims don't
This post has really made my day, Dr Asrar Ahmed ne jese Darya ko kozay me band Kar Diya ho, dusray speaker bicharay k expressions dekhnay walay they is doraan.
I would really like to see the full video...
The truth is that perhaps Pakistan is the only country whose people are still so much ignorant of the facts n reasons why their country came into being, because few people have spread so much confusion about it...
ALLAH Dr Sab k darjaat buland kry k ideology of Pakistan ko, Quaid n Iqbal ko jese inho ne samjha aur byaan Kiya us ki misaal dhoonday se nhi Milti...
سرسید پر فتویٰ قدامت پسندی کی وجہ سے نہیں بلکہ اس نے عیسیٰ علیہ السلام کی آمد اور خروج دجال کا انکار کیا تھا اور بھی اسکے نظریات کافی خراب تھے لوگ صرف اسکی لمبی داڑھی دیکھ کر اسکو مسلمانوں کا خیر خواہ سمجھتے ہیں
اس نے صحی کہا تھا۔ کویی عیسی ا نہی انے والا وہ سب بکواس ہے۔
Upload complete recording of this interview... please don't edit.
It's very easy to criticise a great man like dr sir sayyed but very difficult to creat something very great for ummah as,sir sayyed did, these scholar could not stop pak partition ,how can they judge a great man like sir sayyed
💯🎯
He was a traitor.. period!
@@gladiator8192yes he was traitor jahil khabees and british agent
@@gladiator8192he was traitor khabees jahil
@@gladiator8192yes he was traitor jahil and khabees.
Dr israar was right
Excellent topic and debate 👌👍
فتووں کی فیکٹریاں تو اج بھی کافی کھلی ہیں
None of the 3 participants have looked at Dr. ISRAR Ahmed and are continually looking in the opposite direction. This can not be by chance. There are emotions at play for such behaviour.
that's because the host is sitting to the right of them and Dr Israr is at the far end - have you seen how cricket commentators are always looking towards the game in play and not at their co when replying to them
Dr. Israr is a religious person. He sees everything from his understanding of religion. Other 3 people are scholars. They can explain things based on reality.
The greatest reality of this universe is Islam, if you couldn't understand this truth, you don't deserve to be called a scholar.
@@qaiseriqbal3326 So If A Medical Doctor Knows Nothing Of Islam Will Call Him A Non Doctor ? As You Consider No Knowledge Outside Of Islam
Of course! If someone is unacquainted with Islamic teachings, I would call him a non-doctor in a sense that he does not have the spirit of mercy and love that Islam taught and offered to mankind, which has actually been adopted by non-Muslims. Although they are not Muslims but they have Islam, practically and this is the reality of Islam and the universe.
You are implying that religion is far from reality, for your information Dr. Israr RA was MBBS doctor also and one of the greatest Scholar of 20 century.
@@onestate7734
Yes Dr Israr was MBBS but he chose to become preacher. Did you folks not hear what other 3 people said?
Dr israr had same approach as most molvies have that are based on fake stories instead of truth,
Feeling so sad for 3 confused debaters 😢
This is freedom of speech. U have to learn to listen to u're opponents. Pakistan is a democracy
Feeling so sad for your inability to understand an intellectual discourse
Islam allah ke traf se batae gae cheezo se chlta h na ki democracy ya dictatorship se@@Nat-Con
Only people like Sir Syed can save Pakistan.
He was traitor jahil and khabees
What's the name of the programme? I want to see full programme.
یا تو پورا پروگرام اپ لوڈ کیا کریں یا پھر یہ چھوٹے چھوٹے پارٹس بھی مت لگایا کریں
پروگرام مکمل اپلوڈ کر دیا جاتا ہے
جبکہ کچھ لوگوں کے پاس وقت کی قلت ہوتی ہے یہ حصے اُن کیلیے ہیں
2 nation theory is similar to zoinism and there is no such concept in Islam regarding this
alright
true
Dr. Israr came like a tsunami.
کوئی بھی شاعری مکمل دلیل پر مبنی نہیں ہوتی ، چاہیے وہ شاعری اقبال کی ہو۔ شاعری میں ہمیشہ جذبات کا ہی اظہار ہوتا ہے ،
آپ اقبال کو احمد فراز سمجھے بیٹھے ہیں ۔
😂😂😂😂😂😂@@muhammadasadullahsaeed9778
یہ اندازہ، ان ہی کے اپنے سات لیکچرز اور دوسری آراء پڑھ کر بخوبی لگایا جا سکتا ہے۔
I don’t see any single problem in taking Decisions pertaining to nation’s welfare and growth in light of religion BUT just to the basic fact that those decisions are aligned within the framework Allah subhano tala allowed us to maintain. However, going to Ulema to take fatwa on whether to have medium of studies in English or not, is just fundamentally wrong.
Sir syed Ahmed Sir was a Title which was given by Queen of Britian while receiving it man has to bow upon his or her knees and then Served with a title of Sir
Why he was awarded with Sir title by Queen think about it ?
Maulana was member of jamaat islami who opposed creation of pakistan
He was right
Jinnah, Allama iqbal & sir syed these three were secular but teeno change hoye secular mindset se islamic mindset ki tarf
Khoshnassebi hai k hamare pass dr israr jaise log rahe
ہر گز غدار نہیں تھے ،مسلمان نہ قوم بن سکا اور نا ہی امت ،بلکہ ان کا قصور صرف یہ تھا کہ وہ جھوٹی روایات کو نہیں مانتے تھے ،اب ہم مذہب بنوامیہ کو نہیں مانتے بلکہ توحید نبوت اور میعاد کو مانتے ہیں تو کیا ہم کافر ہیں ؟
1929 میں جناح پنجاب مسلم لیگ سے اختلاف کی وجہ سے بدل ھوکے UK چلے لئے تھے
Riyasat e madina was the dream of Qaid e Azam.
PAKISTAN patriotic people's culture '& Association...
جناب اسلام ایک مکمل ضابطہ اخلاق ھے جبکہ ھندوؤں کا اپنے مذھب کے بارے میں ایسا کوئی دعویٰ نہیں ۔ اس لئے مسلمانوں کا اپنے علما سے کسی مسئلہ پر ان سے مشورہ کرنا فطری ھے۔
Pakistan bananay mai USA aur Britain ka be mufad tha.wo communism ke khilaf Afghanistan ke baad second line of defence pakistan ko banana chahtey thei.
..I wish to mourn upon those who had sought for 'fatwa' to learn any language including English. What a narrow - mindedness for a religion that came for whole the universe !
....As to past feelings over learning Science subjects,
is rather much more worth lamenting as we came to
know that famous scholar
& historian " Ibn e Khaldoon
(15 th century) was reluctant to do so ?! ..we astonish--did he not study Holy Qur'an ?!!
ڈاکٹر صاحب نے کمال یہ کیا ہے کہ علامہ اقبال کی زبان سے ہی بتا دیا کہ علامہ کا کیا تصور تھا امت اور احیاے اسلام کے حوالے سے تاکہ کسی کو یہ کہنے کی ہمت ہی نہ ہو کہ نہیں جناب اقبال کا تصور یہ تو نہیں تھا، وہ تو یہ کہتے تھے۔ گویا بحث ہی بند کر دی علامہ اقبال نے اپنا تصور ڈاکٹر صاحب کی زبان سے سنا کر۔
Dr. Mubarak Ali, Dr. Mehdi Hasan and Javed Iqbal all look pedestrians in front of Dr. Israr.
❤❤❤
Quid Azam : was honest muslim - people are confused : western secularism & Islamic secularism- freedom of worship is the part of sharia law..Allama Iqbal & Quid azam were clear about welfare islami state…
where is sir syed in your talks.
کیا آپ نے باتوں پر غور نہیں کیا ؟
Israar is too small a scholar to comment on Sir Syed. He never said a word on him
kaya baat hay dr.israr ki
Very srong arument
Secularists ky perchacy uraa iyay
Alhamdullilla
قائد اعظم تو سچے انسان تھے۔ انہوں نے تو سچ کہا۔ اور کر کے بھی دیکھا دیا۔
اور پھر اسی اسلام کے نام پہ اس قوم کو ۷۰ سالوں جہالت کے انڈھیروں میں ڈبو کے رکھ دیا ہماری افواج بھی یہی نعرے لگا لگا کے ہمارا خون چوستی رہی کہ ہم اللہ رسول اللہ کے مجاہد ہیں۔ ہم مسلمانوں کی فوج ہیں وہ تو آج سمجھ آئی کہ حقیقت میں ہمارے جرنیلوں کا صرف ایک ہی خدا ہے امریکہ۔۔۔۔ 😢
Dr Asrar continuously interrupting while Dr Mubarak Ali is talking.
Dr. Mubarak Ali the real great historian , always logical and rational.
Dr Asrar had zero Tolerance to listen other's point of view.
He was a supporter of Zia ul Haq Kaana Dajjaal and was a member of his Majlis e shoora. Later on resigned when he was kicked out of PTV where he was creating controversies as per his nature.
Just see he is describing his infront of an Encyclopedia of History Dr Mubarak Ali.
Why He was invited infront of these Giants? and allowed to to talk too long which he normally used to do.
He always had a habit of taking up most of the talk time and leave very little time for others to argue in favor of their perspectives.
What is your contribution for Islam and Pakistan it's is very easy criticise some one and point out where he is wrong he is a humen yeah maybe he wrong somewhere but the work he done was praise less
1906 to 19 30......elite club
Assad iqbal.....Hindu not recovered..
Muslim ..... My word gone to do
Urban imperialis
Quran Kay qawal
11 august 1947
46..... Islam 1937....???
Dr Israr lived in some dream land which never existed. No wonder he considered taleban as the main hope for Muslim ummah.
Maulana, is a staunch supporter of Islam and Pakistan, believes in JInnah and 2 nation theory.
Bhai Dr israr & jinnah was correct but country administration part had been failure...overall management is failure.
Right Islamic knowledge was not there in pakistan...all mullah and Maulana r munafiq,that's y all pakistani people r munafiq and country become failure.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ye iqbal jinnah ka program to tha nahi ,title sir syyed ka tha ,un ke thoughts ka koi zikar nahi , Sara bakwas Kar gaye,
achha hoowa . sir sayed ki shaamut nahi aa-ee
Jo Dr Asrar ne byaan Kiya he pehley wo to acquire kr Lein, warna sir Syed pe baat krnay SE kya hasil hona?
NATION PATRIOTIC PEOPLE'S CULTURE HERITEGE & SO SOCIAL ASSOCIATION
Sir Syed was a stooge of East India Company
ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد صاحب نے لبرل کا منہ بند کر دیا
Dr . Israr Ahmed really understand lslam
Sir ye complete series mil skti
Full debate kay naam sy app isi channel pr deakh skty hien
@@hashimimran786 mili ni sir link send kr dain
@@hashimimran786 plz sir
Why Qaid e Pakistan did not charter and implemented ISLAMIC NIZAAM. Dr Asrar to answer?
He died soon after PAk was created. U can't criticize him
True challenging status quo is a Herculean task. Traditionalists hv won strong foundations in our society. When iconic freedom winner Bacha khan challenged fundamentalism , the Mullas and their masters coined him as infidel and anti Pakistan. Today religious beliefs are mostly based on traditional narrations , inspired.by umayyed sponsored Mufassireen. Salat, Hajj ,and many other concepts are wrongly interpreted by traditionalists.
Then why jinnah didn’t apply sharia law in Pakistan as he promised…
Read about Dr Muhammad Asad
He died in 1948
His life was short after partition
Why we called SIR to Sayyed khan was western supporters
Kiyo ka Sir Syed ka dili mission Muslim ko Uplift karna or onka empower karna tha. (2) West ka sath mil kar onhoon na kiya kam kiya.?? Muslim's ka liya College or universities banai tu isma galat kiya hai. Allah swt Sir Syed 👑🫀 ki galatiyon ko maaf kara or onha jannat ata farmai.
Dr. Asrar distorting history and giving speech as usual without realising that he is sitting infront of these 3 Giants , specially Dr Mubarak Ali who is an Encyclopedia of History
He thought they will also swallow his one sided rhetoric like his blind followers.
ہمارا کارواں اب تک تو منزل پر پہنچ جاتا مگر یہ راستے میں پیچ و خم رہبر نے ڈالے ہیں استاد قمر جلالوی
sir syed was an agent
He was jahil khabees
Quaid - iqbal secular
Renessantiob of Islam
In k chehre qabil e deed hayn seculars k🤣🤣🤣
محترم اپ کی ویڈیوز اور کلپس بڑے نایاب ہوتے ہیں اپ اپ کے کلپ بڑے اچھے ہوتے ہیں ایک کلپ کی تلاش میں ہوں میں جس کلپ میں ڈاکٹر شاہد مسعود صاحب ڈاکٹر ذاکر نائیک سے انٹرویو کے دوران ایک سوال پوچھتے ہیں کہ اپ مسلمان کیوں ہیں تو وہ انٹرویو میں تلاش کر رہا ہوں یا کلپ اگر اپ کو ملے تو اپنے چینل پر لگائیے
Lot of Thanks
جی ضرور ❤❤
Ghalat history bata rahai hain yai secular
Sultan Abdul hameed turkey waalai bhi english kai khilaaf thai
Ya kahna kai mullah nai fatwa dia ghalat hai
Yai poora sach nahi bolta
Iqbal actually what he wanted to become couldn't do so
If it's a debate on "how to grow Pakistan economy? " it will be more beneficial to the society.
Too much confusion I would recommend to follow and study Western and European Modernist.
Bus yhi krte rah jana h tum logo ne
Dushman ne Ghaddar Paale Retired IG Asim Munir Mir Jafar Mir sadiq Fattah CC kardoughlaaooo Qamar Jawed Bajwa Babar Nadeem Faisal Nasir Fahim Reza Amir Raashid EJAZ Asif Ghaffoor Ahmed Sharif waqar Ahmad Saher Shamshad Raheel Sharif Parvez Ashfaque Kayani Shafaat Hussain Haqqani Rana Sana Qazi Faez Isaa Serena issa fazlu the diesel Saad Rizvi Nawaz Shahbaz Zardari Ishaque dollar Khwaja Asif
Allah Dr. Asrar r. a. Ki maghferat farmaye. But he has misinterpreted the Iqbal's Allahabad speech.
Iqbal r. a.'s dream was not Pakistan, rather practical Islam. Whereas Pakistan is against Islam.
Pakistan Islam ke naam per ek badnuma daagh hai.
I’m from Lahore, Pakistan ❤✅🇵🇰 I left Islam after reading Quran and listening Zafar Heretics, Adam Seeker, Sahil Bhai and Harris Sultan. I’m happily Ex-Muslim Now….❤🇵🇰✅…
أُولَٰئِكَ الَّذِينَ اشْتَرَوُا الضَّلَالَةَ بِالْهُدَىٰ فَمَا رَبِحَت تِّجَارَتُهُمْ وَمَا كَانُوا مُهْتَدِينَ
أُولَٰئِكَ الَّذِينَ اشْتَرَوُا الضَّلَالَةَ بِالْهُدَىٰ فَمَا رَبِحَت تِّجَارَتُهُمْ وَمَا كَانُوا مُهْتَدِينَ
Can you give a video of yours on RUclips and proof that your in Lahore
Why do you need to announce ?
These are confused guys
Iqbal to Imaam Mehdi k baaray main hudeesain bhe nahi maanta tha, H Easa ki waapsika bhe inkaari tha
Who this guy is secular
اسلام کے نام پر پاکستان بنا تو ہے۔ کیا حال آپ لوگوں نے بنا رکھا ہے۔ AMU سے جتنے مسلمانوں نے تعلیم حاصل کرلی ہے اتنے تو پورے پاکستان میں نہیں ملیں گے۔
آپ لوگ وہاں پر تعلیم کو کتنا فروغ دے رہے ہیں ۔
Pakistab ka mutlub kaya, yay naara QA lugaatay thay??/
Sir Syed Ahmed Khan ka Firqa Nichar tha!
Jiski Buniyad Kamzor thi ki Farishta nahi manta jinnat nahi manta Sirf Allah manta hun yaha Se un k khud ko muslim kehne ki Buniyad toot jati hai 😢
Jobi hoon onka personal belief but Sir Syed 👑🫀 ka mission Muslim's ko uplift or empowered karna tha.
jutka suwaal:: 11 August .1947 ki tuqreer kertay hooway kaya QA upnay huwaas main nahi thay???
Listening to such useless talking is totally Waste of time
Jinnah . Iqbal sialkoti, Sir sayed, Sardar nishtar
Yeh charo Lord mount beton ky Malaashi thy.
Dr. Israr ahmad be like: Bacho main aap ko sahi baat batao😂
Quaid e Azam was a secular. After he became GJ, he founded Paksitan's economy on the basis of interest by inaugurating 'State Bank'. He did not prohibit Wine, night clubs, etc. He never performed Hajj, prayed 5 times etc. He did not know Islam and he did not practice whatever little he knew. He did not fight when the British boundary commission gave Muslim majority states like Gudspur and Juna Garh to India. He just wanted to be a ruler and as a governor general he reported to the Queen of England. Some freedom we got!!!
He was offered premiership of subcontinent by Mr Gandhi himself
Yes that's why as Muslim, Jinnah is not my ideal or anything in good way.
@@habiblangove7910This is the reality. Most of the history we are taught in "study of Pakistan" is fake.
A secular who wanted to create an Islamic state.
yes in those night clubs, your grandmother offer sex to anyone, and that's why how your father is born and then your father marry a girl who sells her body to live that's how you born
Jaheel man
Ye swal hy stupid 😂
Ek Dhele Ki Jaaydad Avenfield Hudaibia Paper Mill Toshah khana BMW Dubai Tower's Manhattan ki property Australia ka Jazeera Belgium ka Farmhouse Kenya and Tanzania ki property Benami accounts ♠️🥃🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖🪖
ڈاکٹر اسرار مخلص جذباتی انسان تھے مگر انہیں علم حدیث اور تاریخ کا علم نہیں تھا نہ کلچر و ثقافت و تمدن کا فہم ۔ مقرر اور خطیب اچھے تھے ۔ سننے والوں کو بھی یہ مدنظر رکھنا چاہیے تاکہ وہ جذبات میں نہ سنیں حقائق کو تاریخ کو سمجھ سکیں
معاف کیجیے گا لیکن میرے خیال سے آپ نے غور نہیں کیا
آپ کون ہیں بھی صاحب؟
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😮@@hashimimran786sahi ❤
Aap kia cheez hn
Poonja Chap, whom we call Qaid e Azam, was an Anglo/Hindu Agent,
Born in a Hindu Family in village Panali Gujrat, Grandfather was called Premji Lal, father Poonja Lal
English tried to pass him off as a ismaili, but imam at Kharadar refused to Grant Poonja family Agha Khani status
Hindu leaders were part of game, they promoted him as great Muslim leader with Muslims around they would not get India
For 800 years, Hindus had no say in running India, with their caste system they were a;lways ruled by Muslims
hence in 1900 it was decided to call him Sunni and name was changed to Mhammad Ali
800 years, together, no one daredlift a finger on any Muslim
Poonja got 1.5 million muslims slaughtered, handed India to Hindus who never had any thing to do with ruling India
Another English agent called Lawrence, divided the Arabs into dozen states
Gutter chapter you seems to be very munafik. After failure of Pakistan apne Qaid E Azam se bhi palla jhad liya.
Having studied his early life and having some knowledge about his daughter, what I can say is He wanted Pakistan to succeed but the baggage of zamidars, nawabs, lawyers including Liaquat Ali and many more from UP and CP (who were basically on the payroll or mercy of Britishers post 1857) were very opportunistic.
These opportunists made a very strong Nexus with local Punjabi, Sindhi Warlords and corrupt army generals in 50s and successfully established a feudal system in the garb of both democracy and Islam.
And as every feudal system has its shelf life as it resist change or democratization of power and ultimately results in economic and moral disaster.
@@SaurabhSingh-pp6ys my dear sadar sahib you prove all jokes correct
Poonja chap CV was built by English with support of 10% Indian who are actually Hindu s and rule, read some history of Great Game
Also latest census of India over 70% called Hindu are Sudhra or Dalits not allowed in Hindu temples
@@kanoongooadmi3308 bhaijaan I am not a sadar of any place. I am aam aadmi and ordinary Indian whose out of 10 good aquaintances 5 are non Hindus due to my work and profession. Among non Hindus 2 of my extremely good friends are from Indian muslim families, one from Sikh, one from Jain and 1 from Christian family. Among Hindus two are from same casts rest from different casts including shudra. So I am not a sadar but a person experiencing and enjoying all indian shades and colours and I really value them.
Great game , I have never heard of nor I read. So I don't know what you are taking about. If you could elaborate it and authenticity of its source.
Yes in India schedule cast schedule tribe population is huge. Also many of the muslim conversation specially in Bengal and Bangladesh and Christian converts in south and west India were from this community. But now all are equally respected and given equal they all can freely go to temples, mosques, churches and gurudwaras. Infact our current president apart from being a woman she is from a very humble schedule tribe family from jharkhand. Previous president was also from a Schedule Cast background. So now all are equal. I think India in only last 75 years has seen people at top posts from non majority class. We have seen non Hindu Prime Minister, Presidents, Defence Chief's,many Chief Ministers, Chief Justice, Chief Election Commissioners, IAS toppers, medical , engineering toppers, board toppers, sports persons, businessmen, doctors, lawyers and what not.
😂😂😂
Even Hindus agree that Jinnah was a British agent. But I didn't know that he was also a Hindu agent as well.