Jewish Soldier Goes To Battle In Nazi Germany | Memoirs Of WWII #18
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2019
- American Jewish soldier Robert “Bud” Sabetay recalls his many experiences in the Battle of the Bulge, and what it was like to face antisemitism in the heart of Nazi Germany.
Purchase Bud’s autobiography “Memoirs of an American Jewish Soldier”
sabetaypublishing.com/sabetay_...
Memoirs of WWII Website: bit.ly/2w60kGM
Patreon: bit.ly/2HIebIN
Instagram: bit.ly/2FBGBhv
Facebook: bit.ly/2w5Lhgf
Twitter: bit.ly/2jlcp1A
Written and Directed by Joshua Scott
Filmed by Christian McLean
Edited by Joshua Scott and Christian McLean
Post Audio by Lane Tarr
Illustrations by Anne Jordan
Archive Footage Sources:
www.archives.gov/
U.S. Department of Defense
Archive Photograph Sources:
Republic of Poland
United States Library of Congress
Musical Score Source:
artlist.io/
Artlist Songs and Composers:
“Breathe In” by Yehezkel Raz
“Beyond the Horizon” by Borrtex
“Empty Room” by Max Herve
“Empty Seats” by Roland Bingaman
“The Depths” by Ben Winwood
“Memoirs Of WWII Theme” written by Joshua Scott
performed by Jonathan Hadinger and Joshua Scott
Sadly last week I lost my Great uncle aged 94. He was badly injured in D-day but returned to the ETO some months later & survived the war. 2 months ago he received the French legion medal for helping liberate France, given to him by the French nation. It’s SO important we remember & capture their stories as it’s becoming to late. Thank you for your efforts.
Sorry for your loss.
RolIinStoner420 Thank you. He was a brave man.
@@Andyb2379 At least he got his medal in the end. At least you can known he went to peace knowing that- To someone out there- Maybe a whole nation, maybe a city, maybe just one man- He was more then just a man. He was a hero- And that medal is proof that his valor will never be forgotten.
KaaCroy Thank you. To me he was a hero, they are all hero’s for answering the call.
I'm so sorry about your loss.
"I knew about anti-semitism but I thought, i'll judge them on my own."
This is what a fantastic human being looks like.
"We defeated the wrong enemy" - General Patton 1945 (assassinated)
Agreed, although a bit sad that this is noteworthy. If it wasn’t, that would mean more people were like this.
My grandfather who served in Asia, ( after the war, he lost his job to the sane country as American companies were buying from them)
He never said a bad word in front of me about a nation which he had many issues with.
I’m thankful for that. As hate & judgement is often passed down from elders to the young.
@@Sbreslin59-js2zz Umm, he was speaking of the Soviets....
@@Sbreslin59-js2zzsounds like he was a bitch and so are the Nazis who jerk him off.
I wanted to make this same post...I wish America was still like this...what an incredible man
It's hard to listen to these and not feel humbled. Another great video.
The FBI hey I have seen your comments on other videos, cool to see I have similar interests with The FBI.
@The FBI {{{FBI}}}
@@austinjeffris38 same LOL
The FBI OPEN UP 2:40
Humbled and inspired
This guy actually gave I speech at my school in Germany, it was so interesting
Teichbukkanier - That’s awesome. I’d give a lot for the chance to meet him and shake his hand.
Könntest du sagen wo ??
@@Igvoz The fuck is your problem?
@@kyle-xc8pq let him be...angry arab
@@Igvoz We learned about WW2 and about the horrors oft that war you can't accus us today for actions that happened 80 years ago.
This guy has seen it all. Can't even imagine the hell he's been through. And there is many, many stories like this that are buried 6ft below. Never forget the sacrifices made by these men, no matter which side they fought for.
Very true and there are less and less of these soldiers alive to tell the story
My grandad fought in a battle it's just gross I don't have the will to go hunting and what they have done just unbelievable
My Grandpa never spoke much of the war. I just remember him telling me they zig zagged over the Atlantic. He never touched a gun again that I know of. He was the greatest man I’ve known.
Totally but its rather depressing that these hero’s that sacrificed everything for us only get 1 day of appreciation while the pride gets a whole month i wonder if they would have fought on had they known about that.
@@parsa6526 We live in this weird time, where everyone tends to seek out the easiest way to quick satisfaction and the governments and media feed those ideologies to people. These acts and things are signs that the civilization is coming to an end. We have seen this throughout the history of mankind.
"Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it."
Which is exactly why there are Americans and other people in first world countries who think they want Socialism.
Fax
"We defeated the wrong enemy" - General Patton 1945 (assassinated)
your guys channel should have millions of views. this is the best damn channel on YT. may we never forget where we came from and what we have nowadays!
10:50 - This, then, is bravery. To look into the eyes and hearts of the 'enemy' and see the humanity and goodness within them. To withhold judgement in the face of hatred.
I'm sure it must have taken real spirit of character.
Thank you for sharing your story and thank you Memoirs of WWII for capturing and conveying it so jarringly.
My family migrated from Germany after the first war. My grandfather went on to fight in the second as an American GI. After that my mother was born in 49 and went on to serve for 34 years. The beginning of a proud American family
Damn thats awesome
@@GuhbsBeats Her high school graduation present was luggage. As Grandpa explained "Guess what, your going in the army". He sure had a way with words. She then transferred to the USAF after her contract :p but yeah I admire them a ton. They are a different breed of leaders
To all who served and to all in service now, thank you. To my 4 great uncles and both of my grandfathers I cannot thank you enough.
nobody fucking asked
@@Latesthunder That's a real piece of shit thing to say, but it did make me laugh.
You guys should do another channel for Vietnam my grandfather has amazing stories about his time in Vietnam
Or korean war
Korean war x2
Colton Thompson I’m almost certain they will talk about Vietnam and other wars on this channel but they’re focusing on wwii vets because they will be gone really soon
I agree,I want Vietnam stories too
Phuocyy i agree my grate grandpa passed a few years ago he got kick out of the army bc he stole a Jeep to drive General paten into war when they told paten that they didn’t want him to go in
Chilling to hear his story and a good reminder to be gratefull for what we have.
This guy is one of my favorites! Super humble and honest. I sent Memoirs of WWII an email about a 97 year old guy in Salem Oregon who fought in D-Day. I hope they interview him...
An old man in his latter years telling his story of his late teens early twenties, about the horrors of war, does not deserve any dislikes.
Not bitter or angry..a true hero..
Eye opening. Stuff you were never taught in school or reported by the media.
God has blessed you Bud.
Thank you.
Jeff Kwas this was taught in school...
God the stories about him tackling his friend and the grenade not working really make you think
I read alot of war memoirs. I've read accounts of this "disembodied voice" phenomenon on a creepily high number of occasions. Not just limited to warnings of impending danger but also terrible shit, like a pilot hearing "look down there" and spotting enemy in the open, etc. Don't know what to make of it.
Really
Dave I like to think of it as a way of god communicating to us or a deceased relative that’s looking over you and everyone else it’s crazy to hear these stories many people to think of it as a sixth sense too but there’s no way science can explain this phenomenon
@@FitFreakCentral really....
@@FitFreakCentral these story got me tough the heart everytime. Im gonna miss this generation and my great grand ma who told me lot of story of ww2 she did pass away ...about my great grand pa who goes too ww2 from here in canada too juno beach. God bless all the soldier who died for politiciens
Please, please never stop posting these videos. Considering what these men have went through, and reflecting on my own life always gives me the strange feeling I'm missing something. These guys have experienced an existential deepness, have lived through so much, that I consider myself a weakling. These videos only make that feeling stronger, and give so ample opportunity to reflect upon my own life. Please don't stop
The look of remembrance in his eyes when he tells his story almost 75 years later, tells me that the things he saw were engrained forever. My great-grandpa has the same look in his eyes when he told me about his time in the Army Air Corps. I’ll never forget it or what he told me for the rest of my life.
7:00 was the hardest part for me. I mean to dream that you got killed and for it to actually happen is just crazy and sad.
R.I.P. James 😞
Hamster Life 101 and it’s not like he got shot in the head and taken out quickly. He had enough time to acknowledge he was hit and was horrified and most likely screamed out “I’m dying” and no one could save him
@@dongambino5308 how bad do you think he's feeling to have seen this and just wasn't able to help his mate. I mean im german(15) and im feeling so bad for the people that left their lives during WWII, but that part of the video literally got me thinkin about the fact that these are people who die in war wich had a normal life with kids, wife and parents.
I came to the comments looking for something acknowledging james. I feel terrible that this man had to hear him say i had a drem that i died and actually see it happen and plus james having time to say he was dying.
There is always a glass of wine in my home for people like him. Respekt and a salute from Germany
It's always unbelievable to hear what these men went thru. I'm thankful to those who stepped up and answered the call. My thanks also goes out to you for sharing their stories. Great job as always.
What an amazing story these soldiers have to tell. So glad to be able to hear his.
What an amazing attitude. I wish many others who have been thrust into such a difficult situation would be as moral, and objective, as this man. Not only did it save the lives of others, but it probably saved his life. He also came away from the war with a much clearer conscious.
I had five uncles in the war, including The Bulge. All returned unscathed, but the stress killed my grandparents too young. I still feel the presence of that great conflict.
Your grandparents served in the war too?
@@roderickstockdale1678 They were on the home front trying to keep the family business afloat. War kills not just with direct weapons.
@@terraflow__bryanburdo4547 what kind of business was it?
@@roderickstockdale1678 Hardware store
When he couldn't pull the pin on the incendiary grenade no matter how hard he tried. I have to believe that was divine intervention. For him to have experienced real antisemitism and still had the courage to not pre-judge, is amazing. What a great human being. If only nowadays...
Capn Pete for sure.
Really! A real hero
If you were to show me this channel and ask me how many subscribers I think it has I would undoubtedly say about 10 million. The production quality and matching a story to a video is amazing. Thanks for everything you do.
Amazing man. Another great war story! Keep them coming
At 9 minutes, 45 seconds to 10 minutes....wow! What a hero! 🇺🇸❤️🇺🇸💙🇺🇸 Thank you and God Bless to all of our past & present servicemen and women.
My grandfather was a son to polish Jewish immigrants, from Brooklyn. An American GI apart of the 44th infantry division, in the 71st infantry regiment. From 1940-1945, and was honorable discharge at the rank of staff sergeant.
Another good one. Please continue your great work in saving this memories! We live in times that make it even more important to share that information. We should never forget what happened so this will never repeat.
Greetings from Germany
My dad was a US medic that was at that same battle at Metz. He was very humble about his service.
My great granddad was a ww2 soldier who died a few years ago i only ever seen him like three times but he never wanted to talk about the war he was serving for new zealand
Thank you for you service everyone who is or has served.
What a good hearted man... and a war story so well told. Thank you.
Wow, just couldn't pull the pin. Devine intervention for sure.
@Edmund Halling sure I can relate to that, I can believe there are some coincidences, maybe the pin in the grenade was damaged or was faulty, would have been better if later he tried to pull the pin and it came right out.
Lets all take a few seconds each day and appreciate our freedom that we have due to these brave soldiers.
ivy and roses What freedom?
OY Vey freedom to not live in a German or Japanese speaking fascist world, freedom to be alive and outside of internment camps if you’re a member of a race that these abhorrent regimes consider “undesirable”...do I need to list any more for you or is that enough? Your entire way of life today is thanks to these people.
@@oyvey304 you know EXACTLY what freedom sop pretending!
Germany did the same thing as the US. And thats genocide european Americans killed the natives like animals. Stalin was worse than Hitler but nobody speaks about his crimes
Amazing video, as always. Keep up the good work 😁
Another great video Josh! Keep it up!
Thanks for putting these videos all together Josh. They bring a very strong feel and message for war and why we need to stop conflict of all sorts. plus im sure it helps other WW2 veterans decide to finally tell there stories publicly. All this means so much
Thank you for this Project man😢
Always enjoy listening to the interviews of the brave veterans who are quickly fading away.
By far this is my favorite video, he is so humble he didn't judge Germans, he didnt say they were bad like most people say today, he said both sides did bad things, Some Germans actually helped jews and were kind but he also didnt forget to say not Germans acted the same, All i hear in society Germans bad, US good, all Germans are Nazis, when you listen to his story he tells us it wasnt like that at all it was the opposite with the citizens, I can tell God really was watching over him in the war it makes me emotional just listening.
I absolutely LOVE what you do. Thank you so much for doing it and sharing it. God Bless You and your crew.
Amazing!
I just wish the interviews could be longer. I really enjoy learning and hearing the stories as sad as they all are .!
Thanks for another great video, looking forward to the next.
Most chills ive ever gotten from one of these videos.
Bud is the quintessential American man, all of us should strive to be more like him.
He's of a different era. We don't compare to them. Too much luxury now.
American Republic Take the time to work hard, vote for what you believe will do you and your country good. Treat others the way you wish to be treated and don’t back down from a fight.
@@Coldfront15 That's good advice. You should be a gym teacher and straighten up the youth.
The Bear Jew has lived through hell to tell his story
I was thinking that even before I saw your comment.
GET THE BAT!
@@indianheadlogan search up bear jew on youtube this will be the 2nd video you see
So few bear Jews.
These are all amazing, but this one was beautifully told. Thank you Bud
8:56 “ on both sides I’ve seen stuff like that” & “ some of our guys weren’t so good.”
Super important line. In every mass group of people there will be good & bad. It’s up to the good to hold their own group accountable.
He doesn’t care which side was worse, he understands that the Wehrmacht was made up of individual people, just as our side was. It’s very important to treat each individual soldier with nuance, instead of lumping them all into the same group. An extremely important and powerful message, especially coming from him.
Thank you for interviewing Bud. And thanks to Bud for his incredible strength of character.
My grandpa was a lil kid when war raged in Germany and he told me some stories how he saw the war, damn this war wasn't fun for anyone F for every one, soldier and civilian who lived in this time
Honestly cannot get enough of this channel. EVERY. SINGLE. STORY is entertaining! 👏👏
Going through all these videos i just want to hug these guys and let them know how grateful i am.. multiple generations seperate us but the sacrafice he (and all soldiers) give for our country deserves the respect of EVERYONE. Thank you sir.
“Some of our guys weren’t so good.” Good and bad people on all sides of a war on a scale like this. Thank you for your courage and service. Families of peace loving humans around the world are proof of you and your friend’s sacrifices.
Sadly, even America had a few bad apples (for example see the Biscari Massacre of Axis prisoners by several bitter GIs). War does terrible things to men and women involved in it. It's why keeping your moral conscience strong is critical.
This is a very powerful memoir. Thank you 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
Great video!!!
My heart is happy whenever I get the notification that you posted a new video. I absolutely love this series, and hope that once it is over, you will move into Vietnam veterans
And he says, " Oh my God I'm Dying." 😢😟😞
We are so blessed to have so much because of his bravery and humility and from the millions like him. These stories are so important in our history. Thank you for sharing
My orthodox Jewish father upped his draft and went to war in 1944. He was killed in France soon after. He didn't complain that he wouldn't be able to eat the food. He felt he could not stay home even if they weren't drafting men with children.
Please keep making these videos. This is a great thing you are doing.
this channel is amazing i want to do stuff like this for a living. preserving history that would otherwise be completely forgotten
How in the world does this channel not have at least a million subscribers? I mean really the videos are very well put together interesting stories..
Bulletsponge thank you!
I love your work! Another great Video!
Youre doing such a amazing Job guys. So important
best channel for these videos thx much
I hope one day a visit to Australia would be on the cards, our vets are one of a kind
Imagine going thru what he and his buddies went thru at 18-19 years old. War is such a crazy thing. RIP to all soldiers and vets of WW2
*Gone but never forgotten*
I have been binge watching these videos all week. I have depression anxiety and ptsd. I battled with suicide since I was 13. These stories are helping me greatly and giving me a different perspective on life. I had 7 great grandfather's all brothers whom were in WW2. I really wish I could hear their stories from a indigenous perspective. None the less. Thank you all. May the world not only hear your stories but learn from your stories. ❤
I Absolutely love this channel! WWII is my favorite thing to learn about and I hope to make a career out of it!
Such great videos. I love hearing their stories so much
Thanks for sharing your story Bud .. very touching memories
My uncle fought in the bulge as a bridge engineer, so they went in first. The things he saw, had no words to describe them
This is one of the most important channels on youtube
Thank you for your service. My heart, thoughts and prayers are with you all.
The part of the grenade and the basement killed my heart it's so awesome how sometimes bad thoughts lead to good things
In such great shape, society is lucky to still have people like him around to tell the stories of the greatest generation.
This upsets me thinking what these people went through for our freedom, i thank each and every one of them. What a terrible thing war is.
@Sea Skimmer What freedom? Freedom to genocide white people?
www(dot)bitchute(dot)com/video/cTykEjkGNRzB
@@oyvey304 sigh, when you grow up a bit your get what i mean.
@Sea Skimmer So you have no comeback so you resort to insults. How do you define “Grow up” because in reality we are all “children” compared to our ancestors. Or do you mean work consume sleep and repeat? How would “growing up” help me see that we have freedom. I bet you did not watch the video? Whites are being genocided yet we have freedom?
Much love - Oy Vey
@@oyvey304 I didn't mean grow up as an insult i meant when you "grow up" in mind and body you will see we have freedom where you said "what freedom?" You are free compared to how your would be under Nazi rule if that makes it easier for you to understand. The worlds not perfect (never will be) but some things are better than they might have been. (Hey i could be wrong, who knows what a Germany dominated world would be like?)
@Sea Skimmer Hi*lers Germany did not want to dominate the world yet communism has dominated the world and whites are being gen*cided.
Love every vid man
Amazing video!!
Thanks for sharing
This was really touching
I could listen to Bud all day/ awesome video ty
Keep them coming!!!👍😁
I love this Chanel thank you ..❤️
Great Video
I love these videos a raw history lesson just like both of my grandfather's I loved hearing their stories about it even the horrible ones they told .
Thank you.... it doesn’t seem like just a thank you even touches a deep part of my heart ❤️ God Bless you and keep you❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Wonderful to watch. Thank you
Thank you for this beautiful momoir
This was amazing
I'm binge watching these videos with tear drops on my shirt.
Very well done thank you and all the military
Wow this was a beautiful video. Divine intervention took place with that PIN
I could listen all day
you need to start putting out a video every week!
Bolt-action2186 how we wish we could, our team is 3 people all with full times jobs on the side. We only have enough Patreon support to travel once a month to capture these amazing stories. Believing that some day some we will have financial support to do this full time. Thank you for your enthusiasm and for watching!
what a great video
thank you for documenting this while these heroes are still on this Earth
I will make the best of my day after hearing of this.
Pleases keep this up it will save lives. It saved mine.