What’s your view on Rahul’s Kerala speech. He is taking advantage of religious composition there but blaming Modi for dividing India. He is making same mistake again and again but expects different result. Isn’t it foolish and self destructive?
Manish Tiwari's statement were true. Hindus were persecuted under foreign rule for 800 years and brahmins had to pay a heavy price for it. We faced ethnic cleansing in our homeland. We have been subjected to worst crimes in history.
@@drvdn8550 try being a proud Hindu! Which is Hindi word for India! Hindu is not a religion! Kindly stop missionary educated mind of yours influence others!
@HIMANSHU SINGH Instead of trying to call other people 2nd hand, mr Arya why don't you stop having a second homeland in India and talk to us about your real homeland, Persia as taught by yoru Vedas?
This edition should have been extended to 25 minutes and should have covered when this elitism really first started going back as long as possible.....
This is because of lack of education in the Nehru/Gandhi family where none after Nehru had formal education. Added to this the class cult of royals ex civil servants and ever competing law professionals.
Good evening Sirji...Pro poor pro Country statement is made from heart to be effective. Leaders like Modi ji will decimate such leaders who has no knowledge about Indian culture and psyche.
Sad truth of Indian politics- As they say in India Congress is communal as per its convenience while BJP is always communal as per compulsion. Hopefully we have brighter more inclusive next-gen leaders coming soon.
What is wrong with commununal politics? 🤔 Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism, jainism are indigenous to this land. So it's duty of the constitution and all political parties to protect and promote indigenous religion.
Thanks for this cut the clutter views on elitism very balanced view Mr. Shekhar now I am frequently visiter on your page to see the.view on between the line.Keep balanced view and keep country above every thing. Jai hind
I actually agree with Manish Tiwari and disagree with Shekhar on this... Yes communities who are labelled brahmins may not have reached the point that Jewish people had to go thru BUT the rhetoric that is coming from the 'so called liberals' about 'brahminism' is very similar to the rhetoric that the middle class germans made about 'Jews'... They justified their xenophobia using arguments like 'they are an insular community'... They are a 'small rich powerful entitled community' that overpowers the 'oppressed germans'... It is not childish to observe the xenophobia coming from the left in India.. And along with it the vocab like 'smash this' , 'destroy that' evokes violence and we are just waiting for our 'gas chambers' or 'funeral pyres' in the future...
sr modi was once unable to pronounce the name of "Mohandas karam chandra gandhi " and in parliament on the laugh of M's chaudhary he said i have seen such thing after suparnkha. so with this i think that one who has bad days in any field not only this politics all thing start matter for him but not for winner.
भगवान बुद्ध और भगवान कृष्ण दोनों ही मानते थे कि घृणा, ईष्र्या, वैमनस्य, क्रोध और वैर आदि का निवारण 'सिर्फ और सिर्फ' प्रेम, सद्भावना, करुणा, सत्य और अहिंसा से ही किया जा सकता है। क्या यही उनके प्रवचनों का सार नही है? हालांकि बतौर मनुष्य हमें भुल करने और उनसे सीखने के लिए हमेशा तैयार रहना चाहिए। 💐🙏
Even the otherwise rational Ramachandra Guha paints Nehru as 100% have done a great job and not made any mistakes. Nehru has, by and large, laid the not only foundation but nurtured democracy and secularism in India. But he made blunders on foreign and Defence policies. Neither Taroor or Guha will talk of it. Selective amnesia?
It do agree with you on Nehru. But, to be fair, it is India's luck that Nehru didn't make mistakes in our Constitution/federal structure or go on a dictatorial path and got our foreign policy right. This is the better choice.
Dear Shekhar Sir, The Print Please make a video on British Politics, Party System and their factions and their current state Just like you did for Israeli Politics ...Please Eagerly waiting for it DIXIT
Great Video. Does explain the strange behaviour of the Congress Party since its independence. From the corruption tolerating Nodi to the communal promoting Rajeev(Shah Bano/Ram mandir idol). The Congress is lost its moral fibre and that explains the rise of Modi and BJP. I hope thought whoever forms the next government, will focus on the economy and not on religion/Caste. we are all Indians first.
If any tiwari and joshi can speak for brahmins then I am just as eligible and I say that religion does not lie with only brahmins that only brahmins can talk about it Modi and Uma have just as much if not more because of their political position to love and speak for our religion Having said that, I also believe Brahmins are far too much demonised today(not comparing to Jews but still). Brahmins are expected to be apologetic for being born one. It is almost a law of politics that if you champion causes of sc st you must abuse Brahmins first and attack them, all else comes later. Anything done by any upper caste anywhere in India, is immediately attributed to Brahmins. If you can't call all muslims terrorist for being born a muslim or because someone from their religion became an extremist why call all Brahmins castiest? Why persecute all Brahmins?
Its not OK to tell them what to say, what not. The first time statement is the one which is in his mind. Just because BJP's communal politics seems bad one should not ignore that the congress is same as BJP a elite club just a bit secular. Our democracy was always in this elites hand however sometimes some good elite understand our problem,
Now what gupta ji is saying for congress is if you wanted vote you should have stick with demonising Brahmins with the illogical facts were mostly untrue and discriminating against Brahmins and division between societies are just fine till you are getting vote from tha....for gupta g its all fine waah gupta g waah...🐷🐷😂
All the issues are debatable but not in abusive language. Thia is not the way of civilised people at least. The behaviour of congressmen show their desperation. All sects of Indian society have contributed to the very causes of the nation be it Brahmins, Vaishya, Kshtriya or Shudras. In fact all equally respectable. But here in case of Congress elitism, it is to show others mean and their sole moto is power be it at the cost of Indian society or the nation. Respect all to get the replica.
Tharoor's remark is not at all objectionable. What he meant was it is because of Nehru democracy took roots in India and enabled people from poor background could reach high offices. It is not elitist to say so.
Brahmins have not been abolished in Constitution, just their unjust privileges have been taken away. By the way Dalits have been suffering for centuries. Though their present leaders may be coarse and abrasive, their plight is still not resolved. Until that point in time at least, you brahmins have to stop complaining. All higher and middle castes have no locus standi until then. Till then, please bottle your grievances.
Mr Gupta, Is it really childish to compare the state of Brahmins (like Kashmiri Pandits) to Jewish holocaust? Consider how an abode of Brahmins (Kashmir), where they were in Majority a few hundred years back, was made 97% muslim thru the power of sword and guns. Why can't you compare what Hitler did with Sikandar Butshikan's Brahmin Massacre or Aurangzeb's Brahmin Massacre? Aurangzeb went to the extent of killing a Sikh Guru,because he gave shelter to Kashmiri Pandits... Post 1947, Kashmiri Pandits were cleansed out of POK and J&K systematically. If all this is not Victimization what is?
And just what is wrong with Tharoors statement about Nehru ensuring a system wherein a chaiwala could become a PM. Because it's true and that is it! It's thanks to him & other stalwarts like Ambedkar, that we have such a good constitution. Can one imagine what we would have got if there were mediocres like Modi or brokers like Amit Shah in the assembly then? That document would have probably been an elitist spawning one 😏
No it was not Nehru but Mahatma Gandhi..he made congress a public limited organization, so that anybody can join and provided the talent, determination and honesty can climb up the ladder. Stalwarts like Sardar patel, Kamaraj, Rajaji, Lal bahadur shastri came to politics because of him
@@vijayshankar4645 He is talking about the nation building tasks that Nehru undertook as a Prime Minister such as strengthening democratic institutions, and the provisions he introduced in the Constitution through the constituent assembly.
That system existed during British period also. Nehru ruled like a democratic dictator without any opposition. Did Nehru has any other choice, the answer is NO. Nehru cannot be given a credit for the things that he didnt do or claimed to be. There is some major differences between Ambedkar Constitution and Nehruvian constitution. What so great about Indian constitution, it is just a copy of existing constitution in other countries? We would have a better constitution if Modi and Amit Shah had been there, it is a fact. You can compare them with Sardar Patel. You hate Modi because he is OBC and you hate Amit Shah because of him being a Jain Minority.
In communication, the sender sends and the receiver receives. Unfortunately, when we make unnecessary mistakes in pronunciation, we cause a disturbance in the communication. The receiver instead of getting our message gets distracted by the mispronunciation. It is a low cost/no cost exercise to simply address the issue of mispronunciation, especially when you are a highly visible person. Rajiv Gandhi's carelessness is rude and inconsiderate. It is akin to the British deliberately or carelessly mispronouncing Indian names including the names of towns and cities. I don't think Mani Shankar Aiyer was wrong in his description of Modi a neech. By immediately pouncing on the words and twisting it to "low caste", Modi actually proved Aiyers point right. I totally support Shashi Tharoor's statement that it is our Constitution given to us by our founding fathers that enables even a chaiwala to become a Prime Minister. Trust Modi to twist that statement around to paint himself and his doubtful chaiwala origins as victims of Shashi's elitism. I wouldn't blame Shashi. No matter what you say about Modi, he will twist and turns it around to suit his purpose. Remember, he did say something to the effect of "I want people to attack me. When people attack me I benefit". Its the old "when people throw bricks at you, build a house with the bricks". I do agree with the gist of Shekhar's argument. In the field of romance and attraction, you may be wearing the best brands and driving an expensive car and living in a posh section of town, but if you don't get rid of those nostril hairs, you might just keep striking out with the girls and wondering why?
Now actually two jobs are aspired in our India Netaji based on casteism religions And rejoinal. Guruji also based on above basics. Ur capacity to raise Passions and earlier the better position u occupy
This video was made before the elections. Elites in congress destroyed its chances both in 2014 and 2019. Then, it was Chaiwala jebe. In 2019 it was Chowkidar Chot Hai, not to speak of Sam Pitroda’s “Hua to hua”. Modi brilliantly turned these jibes against congress. Hopefully congress will com out with similar faux pas starting with alphabet C in 2024 also to help Modi! Some people never learn.
Mr Shekar guptha , This episode of clutter, by u, is really not woth apreciating. Because you feel that brahmins should not have voices which are legitimate
It seems that Rahul G has no independent vision on key issues. He has to build a narrative that is not about modi or modis mistakes alone but around the hopes of common people. This has never been seen. In other words what the Congress narrative?
But shashi tharoor said nehru created institution not becoming decorator himself,see in china people of humble background cannot aspire to become pm because they doesn't have strong institution to support it...
Just by whipping party members to say something in public, won't change their mindset. By the way, for the first time, Manish Tiwary had used some brain
MORE THAN elitism, IT IS WITH THE BACGROUND OF APPEASEMENT OF HINDU VOTES WHICH IS LIKED BY RAHUL. YOU SEE RAHUL VISITED MORE TEMPLES. THIS IS ONE OF THE REASONS OF SUCH STATEMENTS. I FEEL.GUCCHI, MOCHIIS elitism
Tharoor belongs to a high caste Nair family and this caste looks down on the lower castes. He is s pseudo secular. All Congres leaders ared big pseudos without any intelligence
Gupta ji.. With due respect.... Dont you think Brahmin community also contain Poor, Downtrodden... etc.. yet they are living with self respect .. they are the most abused community today...
Shekhar we are all Indians first..leave this hi ndu bIT aside ..we zoroastrians are a minority and have never asked for reservation...indias industrial greatness is tatas.godrej.and many more..we have the greatest brains in law medicine. Engineering..show Me what these fellas have done...NOTHING...U GET ME SHEKHAR
as a brahmin born i was made to be sorry since childhood because of ancestors and am still finding hard to live because of continuous generation by generation and constitutionally valid discrimination by others simply because of my birth in a brahmin family. No i am not rich and am never going to be in India. So if you don't stop berating brahmins all the time we will het fed up. And frankly speaking we are barely keeping ourselves together in this time of constitutional discrimination and social persecution. Mark my words, we brahmins are extremely frustrated and sadly when that frustration leaks it results in some incidents against others fueling more persecution and then more frustration. This has to stop!
The print's gameplan sounds like make such a video to grab bjp supporters attention and then once the channel gets added to your RUclips feed, start showing biased anti bjp videos to change your opinion
Shekher looks like you are childish & naive. Many Brahmins have lost their livelihood, careers, status due to caste/religion based reservations at colleges , government jobs, public sector, police, judiciary etc. you don’t feel the pain, family / relative insult, social / society shaming etc Better to die permanently than die every day. Shame on you that you are out of touch with social reality. BJP got some extra votes due to their forthright support to 10% reservations for EWS .
The starting few lines abt Congress siding with the down trodden is OK but how much can one listen If repeatedly a narrative showing ones caste or religion in bad light is made just because they are the upper caste or majority religion in the society....
Shekharji, say what you may but none can do away with Brahmanism and manuwad Even an illiterate Brahman gets natural respect in our society while the lower castes including the Guptas must stand on a lower rung till eternity in India.
What are you doing????Is it journalism?.Dis you ever ask any tough question to congress leaders ???Answer is no.You asked Sonia Gandi does she cook or not.Wow what a question??Please stop batting for congress or any party.Please follow the besic principals of journalism.Because now days people are loosing their fath in media.As a student of journalism it seares me a lot...
Well.31 crore Bank Accounts for Poor 5 lakh ruoees health insurance Startup India and Mudra loan not for Herald house but for youth 1.5 cr toilets you are having a problem with this then I am sorry for your so called solution
Sir, paradoxical . How does elitism matters ??? Modi maybe be an OBC but has taken the country a decade back in terms of growth .... So wats ur point ??
Well Tharoor did make a valid point. Nehru did create a system where any Indian can become the PM. Modi or shastri or zail singh are all good examples. The constitution was written under Nehru's watch. I don't understand what's wrong in this observation.
Completely agree Thoughtflux...our country would have definitely gone the Pakistan way if RSS / BJP took over the reigns in 1947. No law and order, self appointed goons deciding who should marry whom, what to eat, science text books talking about Hanuman's gotra and Ganesha's plastic surgery. No IIT, no IIMs, no BARC, no ISRO ...so completely agree with Tharoor's point - Pandit Nehru could have easily taken India the dictatroship way as he had overwhelming support from people but he chose the democratic path for our country. And surprising to see comments talking about Ambedkar being ignored by Nehru - this is a well laid conspiracy by the BJP. Sure Ambedkar, Patel and Nehru had their differences like any democractic party would have but essentially they were all Congressmen who shared similar values and ethics. There is not a single article in history that talks about any kind of animosity between these great Congress leaders.
Now only Fake gandhi family has a right.Panwala & chaya walla has no right on this unless they r congress men.How many congi chayawallas & panwallas can speak on valid points.Under congi rule our sisters & mothers had to relieve themselves on open ground for decades fm Nehru' s time.
Kabhi kabhi koi topic nahi milta to kuch bhi video bana le , har kahi baat ke bich mein itna time period ka difference hain aur yehi woh baat hain jo disha aur desha decide karti hain , kya bakwass hai , kuch bhi.
Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
Really didn't expect this from Shashi Tharoor. He's slowly becoming the epitome of Liberal Elitism
What’s your view on Rahul’s Kerala speech. He is taking advantage of religious composition there but blaming Modi for dividing India.
He is making same mistake again and again but expects different result. Isn’t it foolish and self destructive?
He's a Buffon and no one takes him seriously
Thanks to him Congress will slowly suffer the same fate as Janta dal ,if changes are not made sooner
That is called hitting the nail on the head.
Manish Tiwari's statement were true. Hindus were persecuted under foreign rule for 800 years and brahmins had to pay a heavy price for it. We faced ethnic cleansing in our homeland. We have been subjected to worst crimes in history.
True... Best example is Kashmiri pandits
Congress speak of secularism but doesn't practice real secularism...
Didn't expect this from Shashi Tharoor. Today a chaiwala has redefined the whole nation and inspired a whole lot to say that we r all proud Hindus.
Try being a proud Indian?
@@drvdn8550 try being a proud Hindu! Which is Hindi word for India! Hindu is not a religion! Kindly stop missionary educated mind of yours influence others!
@HIMANSHU SINGH Instead of trying to call other people 2nd hand, mr Arya why don't you stop having a second homeland in India and talk to us about your real homeland, Persia as taught by yoru Vedas?
@HIMANSHU SINGH Well now that you know ( Rig Veda Book X, Hymn 14, Verse 1,2) then maybe you will be more careful when you open your mouth
From when have you became truthful and unbiased..
After realising RaGa is not becoming prime minister!
Shekarji has just made a compelling argument for the dissolution of all political dynasties in India. I agree with him completely.
This edition should have been extended to 25 minutes and should have covered when this elitism really first started going back as long as possible.....
Wonderful analysis to bring out the link between dynastic politics and elitism.
Nice observation. Congress being so attached to elitism should make all the downtrodden elite and have their time without inhibition
congress is a dynasty party...
hardly anyone is there who has worked on the ground ....most of them are there because of their surname
This is because of lack of education in the Nehru/Gandhi family where none after Nehru had formal education. Added to this the class cult of royals ex civil servants and ever competing law professionals.
As per Subramanya swamy, even Jawaharlal was not really formally educated. And his dad ,Motilal was a Brit Stooge.
Good evening Sirji...Pro poor pro Country statement is made from heart to be effective. Leaders like Modi ji will decimate such leaders who has no knowledge about Indian culture and psyche.
Sharp, crisp and a veteran journalist like!
what a joke, sir
Shekar gupta is talking about the clan he belongs to.
Sad truth of Indian politics- As they say in India Congress is communal as per its convenience while BJP is always communal as per compulsion. Hopefully we have brighter more inclusive next-gen leaders coming soon.
What is wrong with commununal politics? 🤔 Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism, jainism are indigenous to this land. So it's duty of the constitution and all political parties to protect and promote indigenous religion.
What is problem with being Communal? No one country has this issue, why we only feel like that.
Thumbs up to Shekhar Ji !!!!!!!
Shashi Tharoor -who is not a Tharoor - also came from mundane beginnings. I hail from his home district
Thanks for this cut the clutter views on elitism very balanced view Mr. Shekhar now I am frequently visiter on your page to see the.view on between the line.Keep balanced view and keep country above every thing. Jai hind
From the starting Gandhi, Nehru are English educated elites became top level of the party...
I actually agree with Manish Tiwari and disagree with Shekhar on this... Yes communities who are labelled brahmins may not have reached the point that Jewish people had to go thru BUT the rhetoric that is coming from the 'so called liberals' about 'brahminism' is very similar to the rhetoric that the middle class germans made about 'Jews'... They justified their xenophobia using arguments like 'they are an insular community'... They are a 'small rich powerful entitled community' that overpowers the 'oppressed germans'... It is not childish to observe the xenophobia coming from the left in India.. And along with it the vocab like 'smash this' , 'destroy that' evokes violence and we are just waiting for our 'gas chambers' or 'funeral pyres' in the future...
ANand superbly said!
This is a reality of the country, across party line caste prevails. We need to understands this reality to fight caste and bigotry.
Excellent Mr Shekar Gupta Sir
Very interesting! This is a rare treat, must have more as I’m tired of hearing bjp + hindutva.
Congress party should be thankful to Shekhar who has shown them mirror of their unexpected expressions out of fear of what?
Constructive criticism 👍👍👍
Since when Shekhar Gupta became neutral news giver. That's a good change. Still doing a soft criticism on congress though
What about the Hindu holocausts in their own motherland in every few years since 1000 A.D. till 1947? During the Islamic & European conguests?
सही हैं, आपकी निष्पक्षता बहुत जरूरी हैं।
Ms Priyanka Vadra asking, "Smriti Irani? Who?". Its Smriti Irani, M.P. from Amethi. :D
Bang on!!
Indira was elitist too. She was India itself.
sr modi was once unable to pronounce the name of "Mohandas karam chandra gandhi " and in parliament on the laugh of M's chaudhary he said i have seen such thing after suparnkha.
so with this i think that one who has bad days in any field not only this politics all thing start matter for him but not for winner.
U r just awesome shekhar sir🙏
भगवान बुद्ध और भगवान कृष्ण दोनों ही मानते थे कि घृणा, ईष्र्या, वैमनस्य, क्रोध और वैर आदि का निवारण 'सिर्फ और सिर्फ' प्रेम, सद्भावना, करुणा, सत्य और अहिंसा से ही किया जा सकता है। क्या यही उनके प्रवचनों का सार नही है? हालांकि बतौर मनुष्य हमें भुल करने और उनसे सीखने के लिए हमेशा तैयार रहना चाहिए। 💐🙏
Superb analysis.
Ha ! Ha! Manish Tiwari did
Not give you the money you wanted?
I like your programme SEKHAR. Congrats
Even the otherwise rational Ramachandra Guha paints Nehru as 100% have done a great job and not made any mistakes. Nehru has, by and large, laid the not only foundation but nurtured democracy and secularism in India.
But he made blunders on foreign and Defence policies. Neither Taroor or Guha will talk of it. Selective amnesia?
It do agree with you on Nehru. But, to be fair, it is India's luck that Nehru didn't make mistakes in our Constitution/federal structure or go on a dictatorial path and got our foreign policy right. This is the better choice.
Shekar Gupta for the first time is attacking the Congress with a curtailed diplomatic kid gloves!
this one is brilliant
good one. But still not understanding RSS is BJP
Dear Shekhar Sir, The Print
Please make a video on British Politics, Party System and their factions and their current state
Just like you did for Israeli Politics ...Please
Eagerly waiting for it
DIXIT
Great Video. Does explain the strange behaviour of the Congress Party since its independence. From the corruption tolerating Nodi to the communal promoting Rajeev(Shah Bano/Ram mandir idol).
The Congress is lost its moral fibre and that explains the rise of Modi and BJP.
I hope thought whoever forms the next government, will focus on the economy and not on religion/Caste. we are all Indians first.
If social media was during rajiv era he must have be trolled very badly
If any tiwari and joshi can speak for brahmins then I am just as eligible
and I say that religion does not lie with only brahmins that only brahmins can talk about it
Modi and Uma have just as much if not more because of their political position to love and speak for our religion
Having said that, I also believe Brahmins are far too much demonised today(not comparing to Jews but still). Brahmins are expected to be apologetic for being born one. It is almost a law of politics that if you champion causes of sc st you must abuse Brahmins first and attack them, all else comes later.
Anything done by any upper caste anywhere in India, is immediately attributed to Brahmins.
If you can't call all muslims terrorist for being born a muslim or because someone from their religion became an extremist why call all Brahmins castiest? Why persecute all Brahmins?
Now that you are not serving the family as much, start going to gym. Those arms are so thin.
LOL I didn't paid attention, but now I can't un-see it 😂
Its not OK to tell them what to say, what not. The first time statement is the one which is in his mind. Just because BJP's communal politics seems bad one should not ignore that the congress is same as BJP a elite club just a bit secular. Our democracy was always in this elites hand however sometimes some good elite understand our problem,
Now what gupta ji is saying for congress is if you wanted vote you should have stick with demonising Brahmins with the illogical facts were mostly untrue and discriminating against Brahmins and division between societies are just fine till you are getting vote from tha....for gupta g its all fine waah gupta g waah...🐷🐷😂
Lot of comments suggest that people like this video because it is critical of the Congress
Love makes life worth living, not American Congress.
All the issues are debatable but not in abusive language. Thia is not the way of civilised people at least. The behaviour of congressmen show their desperation. All sects of Indian society have contributed to the very causes of the nation be it Brahmins, Vaishya, Kshtriya or Shudras. In fact all equally respectable. But here in case of Congress elitism, it is to show others mean and their sole moto is power be it at the cost of Indian society or the nation. Respect all to get the replica.
Naresh Gaur And I suppose “Nana/Nani” are also to be respected??
@@sdverma001 well if that's how you look then i guess not 😂😂
Tharoor's remark is not at all objectionable. What he meant was it is because of Nehru democracy took roots in India and enabled people from poor background could reach high offices. It is not elitist to say so.
@print , how long after the abolishment in the constitution, will the brahmins have to carry the weight of their ancestors' mistakes?
and what about the christian mistakes in goa with the doctrine of discovery and the violence of the muslim invasions? Are they being held responsible
Brahmins have not been abolished in Constitution, just their unjust privileges have been taken away. By the way Dalits have been suffering for centuries. Though their present leaders may be coarse and abrasive, their plight is still not resolved. Until that point in time at least, you brahmins have to stop complaining. All higher and middle castes have no locus standi until then. Till then, please bottle your grievances.
excellent
Mr Gupta, Is it really childish to compare the state of Brahmins (like Kashmiri Pandits) to Jewish holocaust? Consider how an abode of Brahmins (Kashmir), where they were in Majority a few hundred years back, was made 97% muslim thru the power of sword and guns. Why can't you compare what Hitler did with Sikandar Butshikan's Brahmin Massacre or Aurangzeb's Brahmin Massacre? Aurangzeb went to the extent of killing a Sikh Guru,because he gave shelter to Kashmiri Pandits... Post 1947, Kashmiri Pandits were cleansed out of POK and J&K systematically.
If all this is not Victimization what is?
Don't forget Tipu sultan "ji" and Aurangzeb
I LIKE VERY MUCH THE 5 CARD S THEORY. WELDONE.
Ideological confusion, thy name is INC!
Secrets of 'Janeo' - Pappu's Failed Strategy.
And just what is wrong with Tharoors statement about Nehru ensuring a system wherein a chaiwala could become a PM. Because it's true and that is it! It's thanks to him & other stalwarts like Ambedkar, that we have such a good constitution.
Can one imagine what we would have got if there were mediocres like Modi or brokers like Amit Shah in the assembly then? That document would have probably been an elitist spawning one 😏
No it was not Nehru but Mahatma Gandhi..he made congress a public limited organization, so that anybody can join and provided the talent, determination and honesty can climb up the ladder. Stalwarts like Sardar patel, Kamaraj, Rajaji, Lal bahadur shastri came to politics because of him
@@vijayshankar4645 He is talking about the nation building tasks that Nehru undertook as a Prime Minister such as strengthening democratic institutions, and the provisions he introduced in the Constitution through the constituent assembly.
@@musharrafaamir6861 That was done by Ambedkar not Nehru. Nehru opposed Uniform Civil Code and congress still does.
That system existed during British period also. Nehru ruled like a democratic dictator without any opposition. Did Nehru has any other choice, the answer is NO. Nehru cannot be given a credit for the things that he didnt do or claimed to be. There is some major differences between Ambedkar Constitution and Nehruvian constitution. What so great about Indian constitution, it is just a copy of existing constitution in other countries?
We would have a better constitution if Modi and Amit Shah had been there, it is a fact. You can compare them with Sardar Patel. You hate Modi because he is OBC and you hate Amit Shah because of him being a Jain Minority.
In communication, the sender sends and the receiver receives. Unfortunately, when we make unnecessary mistakes in pronunciation, we cause a disturbance in the communication. The receiver instead of getting our message gets distracted by the mispronunciation.
It is a low cost/no cost exercise to simply address the issue of mispronunciation, especially when you are a highly visible person.
Rajiv Gandhi's carelessness is rude and inconsiderate. It is akin to the British deliberately or carelessly mispronouncing Indian names including the names of towns and cities.
I don't think Mani Shankar Aiyer was wrong in his description of Modi a neech. By immediately pouncing on the words and twisting it to "low caste", Modi actually proved Aiyers point right.
I totally support Shashi Tharoor's statement that it is our Constitution given to us by our founding fathers that enables even a chaiwala to become a Prime Minister. Trust Modi to twist that statement around to paint himself and his doubtful chaiwala origins as victims of Shashi's elitism.
I wouldn't blame Shashi. No matter what you say about Modi, he will twist and turns it around to suit his purpose. Remember, he did say something to the effect of "I want people to attack me. When people attack me I benefit". Its the old "when people throw bricks at you, build a house with the bricks".
I do agree with the gist of Shekhar's argument. In the field of romance and attraction, you may be wearing the best brands and driving an expensive car and living in a posh section of town, but if you don't get rid of those nostril hairs, you might just keep striking out with the girls and wondering why?
Now actually two jobs are aspired in our India
Netaji based on casteism religions
And rejoinal.
Guruji also based on above basics.
Ur capacity to raise Passions and earlier the better position u occupy
Please do an episode on the Doklam issue
This video was made before the elections. Elites in congress destroyed its chances both in 2014 and 2019. Then, it was Chaiwala jebe. In 2019 it was Chowkidar Chot Hai, not to speak of Sam Pitroda’s “Hua to hua”. Modi brilliantly turned these jibes against congress. Hopefully congress will com out with similar faux pas starting with alphabet C in 2024 also to help Modi! Some people never learn.
Mr Shekar guptha ,
This episode of clutter, by u, is really not woth apreciating. Because you feel that brahmins should not have voices which are legitimate
Actually i like Rajivji ...but then longowal = longewal ..now we know from where raga has picked up these traits 😂😂😂
Shekhar Gupta can't even imagine a Congress without it's elitists.
It seems that Rahul G has no independent vision on key issues. He has to build a narrative that is not about modi or modis mistakes alone but around the hopes of common people. This has never been seen. In other words what the Congress narrative?
But shashi tharoor said nehru created institution not becoming decorator himself,see in china people of humble background cannot aspire to become pm because they doesn't have strong institution to support it...
Please make a series about prime ministers of India and their legacy. I bet Rajeev Gandhi will be worst.
why is long e wala insulting?? :)
Just by whipping party members to say something in public, won't change their mindset.
By the way, for the first time, Manish Tiwary had used some brain
MORE THAN elitism, IT IS WITH THE BACGROUND OF APPEASEMENT OF HINDU VOTES WHICH IS LIKED BY RAHUL. YOU SEE RAHUL VISITED MORE TEMPLES. THIS IS ONE OF THE REASONS OF SUCH STATEMENTS. I FEEL.GUCCHI, MOCHIIS elitism
You will just ask tough questions to bjp but u will ask sonia gandhi if she knows how to cook pasta . Sold out media
Tharoor belongs to a high caste Nair family and this caste looks down on the lower castes. He is s pseudo secular. All Congres leaders ared big pseudos without any intelligence
Guptaji seems like well-wishers of Gandhi family. You should become adviser to your boss family
Jignesh Kumar Patel the line to being adviser aka chamcha to gundhi family is quite long my friend.
Clear the Clutter. It is not eiitism but Vested interests ruin the old creed lest one good custom should corrupt the world.
Elitism is a disease inherited by the kongress from British
Apne yeh gyan un logon ko Pehle dena tha .Ab toh chidiya chug gayi khet
Gupta ji.. With due respect.... Dont you think Brahmin community also contain Poor, Downtrodden... etc.. yet they are living with self respect ..
they are the most abused community today...
Shekhar we are all Indians first..leave this hi ndu bIT aside ..we zoroastrians are a minority and have never asked for reservation...indias industrial greatness is tatas.godrej.and many more..we have the greatest brains in law medicine. Engineering..show Me what these fellas have done...NOTHING...U GET ME SHEKHAR
Hmm, Are you trying to keep balance between bjp bias and Congress bias?? Don’t you feel ashamed
as a brahmin born i was made to be sorry since childhood because of ancestors and am still finding hard to live because of continuous generation by generation and constitutionally valid discrimination by others simply because of my birth in a brahmin family. No i am not rich and am never going to be in India. So if you don't stop berating brahmins all the time we will het fed up. And frankly speaking we are barely keeping ourselves together in this time of constitutional discrimination and social persecution. Mark my words, we brahmins are extremely frustrated and sadly when that frustration leaks it results in some incidents against others fueling more persecution and then more frustration. This has to stop!
Couptaji cheque nahi mila Tuglak Road se?
The print's gameplan sounds like make such a video to grab bjp supporters attention and then once the channel gets added to your RUclips feed, start showing biased anti bjp videos to change your opinion
That is how liberal leftist filth works.
Shekher looks like you are childish & naive. Many Brahmins have lost their livelihood, careers, status due to caste/religion based reservations at colleges , government jobs, public sector, police, judiciary etc. you don’t feel the pain, family / relative insult, social / society shaming etc Better to die permanently than die every day. Shame on you that you are out of touch with social reality. BJP got some extra votes due to their forthright support to 10% reservations for EWS .
The starting few lines abt Congress siding with the down trodden is OK but how much can one listen If repeatedly a narrative showing ones caste or religion in bad light is made just because they are the upper caste or majority religion in the society....
Shekharji, say what you may but none can do away with Brahmanism and manuwad Even an illiterate Brahman gets natural respect in our society while the lower castes including the Guptas must stand on a lower rung till eternity in India.
What are you doing????Is it journalism?.Dis you ever ask any tough question to congress leaders ???Answer is no.You asked Sonia Gandi does she cook or not.Wow what a question??Please stop batting for congress or any party.Please follow the besic principals of journalism.Because now days people are loosing their fath in media.As a student of journalism it seares me a lot...
सीखने के लिये सभी को, सभी से, हर समय तैयार रहना चाहिए, और ये ईर्ष्या भी हो सकती हैं। 🤗🙏
Rajiv Rahul, both duds!
It appears as you are an advisor to Rahul
You adviser or bhakt of modi.
@@yeshsingh5005 There is simply a hostility to problem than an approach towards solution
@@rishitmayank4458 modi is not the solution. Modi is problem for India and problem for 1.2 billion people of India.
Well.31 crore Bank Accounts for Poor 5 lakh ruoees health insurance Startup India and Mudra loan not for Herald house but for youth 1.5 cr toilets you are having a problem with this then I am sorry for your so called solution
sir, it is other backward classes nd not castes. much of your knowledge about many things is limited. so cut the clutter forever, i mean the show
Congress ka dalla
Sir, paradoxical . How does elitism matters ??? Modi maybe be an OBC but has taken the country a decade back in terms of growth ....
So wats ur point ??
modi is a baniya .
Total Fingerpick 10 years back? 🤔 I won’t comment on it!
Well Tharoor did make a valid point. Nehru did create a system where any Indian can become the PM. Modi or shastri or zail singh are all good examples. The constitution was written under Nehru's watch. I don't understand what's wrong in this observation.
Please read about a certain person called BR Ambedkar. Thank you
Completely agree Thoughtflux...our country would have definitely gone the Pakistan way if RSS / BJP took over the reigns in 1947. No law and order, self appointed goons deciding who should marry whom, what to eat, science text books talking about Hanuman's gotra and Ganesha's plastic surgery.
No IIT, no IIMs, no BARC, no ISRO ...so completely agree with Tharoor's point - Pandit Nehru could have easily taken India the dictatroship way as he had overwhelming support from people but he chose the democratic path for our country.
And surprising to see comments talking about Ambedkar being ignored by Nehru - this is a well laid conspiracy by the BJP. Sure Ambedkar, Patel and Nehru had their differences like any democractic party would have but essentially they were all Congressmen who shared similar values and ethics. There is not a single article in history that talks about any kind of animosity between these great Congress leaders.
Now only Fake gandhi family has a right.Panwala & chaya walla has no right on this unless they r congress men.How many congi chayawallas & panwallas can speak on valid points.Under congi rule our sisters & mothers had to relieve themselves on open ground for decades fm Nehru' s time.
@@kumarapuramsathyamoorthy4730 we are talking about India and its constitution and not any political party. Lol read before you type.
@@savitashankar8575 Bro/Sis...I understand it..But little fact correction..Ambedkar was not a part of Congress party ..He was not a Congressmen.
Kabhi kabhi koi topic nahi milta to kuch bhi video bana le , har kahi baat ke bich mein itna time period ka difference hain aur yehi woh baat hain jo disha aur desha decide karti hain , kya bakwass hai , kuch bhi.
Ohh shekhar u r very cute. How u r just exonerating by telling they dont have any malice😅😅😅😅
Sonia pappu vadra mahachor hai..Lol lol
Sir remember visveswaraiya of Rahul Gandhi