Midnight Mass 1x03 - "I Forgive You, Joe Collie" (1080p)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 сен 2021
- Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended.
Tagged : Action Movies, Action Movies 2018, Shootout Scene, Shootout Scenes, Battle Scenes, Battle Scene, Shooting Scene, all battle scenes, all shootout scenes, Edgar Renton, Lucas Renton, Noptira Renton, Midnight Mass Scene, Midnight Mass Scary Scene, Midnight Mass Death Scene 
Кино
![Roddy Ricch - Survivors Remorse [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/J5IeFzr2GgE/mqdefault.jpg)
![DRAGON BALL: Sparking! ZERO - Fused Warriors Trailer [BUDOKAI TENKAICHI Series]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/84p4Lvyfyes/mqdefault.jpg)
Whoever portrays Joe perfectly depicted a man who tortured himself for his actions and wallowing in regret. That is some great acting.
I love how Flannigan uses the same actors but in different roles. I think this guy was also great in The Haunting of Hill House but such a different role
The actress was the one who was great in this scene. I felt her pain through the screen. Super talented. 🤘🏿
@@dakotab291
Yup. Haunting of Hill House and he was married to the doctor (priest’s daughter) from this show.
Also, this guy Joe was in another movie of Flannigan’s Doctor Sleep. Where he is a member of the True Knot named Barry the Chunk. The guy who says “NUMBER 19!!” To the baseball kid they killed.
Robert Longstreet is the man.
@@TheMikeyIsBack
They both did a good job
"You reached through time, Joe Collie." Damn.
That shit was beyond deep.
Can someone explain this line?
@@everydy04 Not only did he hurt her in the moment, but he took away so many options for her. He changed her future drastically.
@@CursedMarkMedia oh wow thanks for the explanation
That first sound he makes when she forgives him, that sound like she's actually wounded him, it struck me so hard. When we can't forgive ourselves, being forgiven can feel like burning coals. We know we're unworthy of it, and yet we so desperately want it. This is truly a remarkable scene.
EXACTLY!
And best part? He knew it was coming, and still it hit him like a truck...
Hate for doing something evil is logical, it is something we can expect, it i something we deserve, and something we eagerly turn on ourselves... We create armor out of that hate, our personal Hell
And now he has nothing- it all just blew away, like it was made out of paper. Hard not to make a sound, when your world just crumbles to dust, and constant pain, that one learned to ignore, is replaced wtih warm feeling of relief
One time- and i am sorry in advance, if you are not drugs person- i had this moment on LSD when there was only me and my unfiltered mind turning on me. Demons of mine, if you will. Sadness and Anger. and my own mind turned them against itself- there is no feeling, like one, when you cannot escape your own head. I will not bore anybody with details. But i just let it happen, instead of fighting it.
I never knew, that crying for lost loved ones can reach such warm and soft place, that after literal hour of crying, i felt born anew- i liken it to digging into the wound to reach logged object, or squeezing pus out of the wound, only to reach that place of relief after it is done, but on emotional level- i can only somewhat imagine, what he had to go through at that moment, but it does resonate with me- despite i knew, what would happen the moment, she went through that door
Amen
well written.
Sometimes I just think about the sound he makes and my chest crumples in on itself.
This is how you do a scene where you feel for both characters no matter who was at fault.
This scene crushed me.
Yes
He's 100% at fault, there's never even an implication that she was in anyway at fault for being shot. The show just keeps it vague on how intentional it was. My interpretation was he was blacked out drunk and didn't even know what he was doing
That “you reached through time” line gave me goosebumps my goodness
Joe Collie, in a way, was instrumental in Leeza getting out safely at the end. If he hadn't been strong enough to resist the urge to drink and instead go see, and get killed by Monsignor Pruitt, Riley never would've gotten suspicious after hearing the lie that he'd gone to see his deceased sister. This would've had a huge butterfly effect where Monsignor Pruitt doesn't turn Riley after he gets attacked by the demon, Riley doesn't warn Erin by burning himself, Erin doesn't take Sarah and Mildred to church Easter Night, and therefore wouldn't be there to help Leeza, Sheriff Hassan, and Annie and her son escape the massacre and eventually make it to the canoes. By not giving in to temptation and overcoming his demons, Joe inadvertently saved the one person his drinking had harmed the most.
This is so poetic and Biblical. Thank you for this interpretation. Sometimes, it's absolutely how God works.
Damn.
This is just the tip of the iceberg with the brilliant monologues in this show.
I can't fault it.
I love the writing of this show but at times felt like "why are they talking like a Hill House character?" felt unnatural at some points.
Edit: Someone mentioned it feels like watching a play and I have to admit I kinda dig it when I think about it that way.
This monologue and the priest's monologues were the only ones that felt natural. This monologue because it feels like this is a moment the character has been thinking about for a long time, so the words are all ready to just come out. And then the priests monologues, obviously, because preaching is what he does. All of the others were like these massive speedbumps that just ground the show to a halt for me. Doesn't matter how well-written it is if it takes me out of the show. Or the timing is just awkward. Like the sheriff's infodump about his past as the show is gearing up for its climax or the big monologue on death when all I can think about is how she's going to wake up five minutes later as a vampire. So, like, big epiphany for the character and then she wakes up and just awkwardly waits around for the sunrise offscreen?
@@PennyxXxDreadful I definitely agree on sheriff's 9/11 monologue. Great fucking monologue, awful timing. But the others were great overall. She probably died shortly before sunrise and then just burned up before even waking up. But honestly, I dont care either way, it's so unimportant. Same with this one, same with the priest, all the AA meetings, they were all bloody masterful
@finance Yeah, you seem like the type of person that knows a thing or two about expressing their emotions, lmao
The actor who played Joe also played Mr Dudley in The Haunting of Hill House which also made me cry especially the final scene of Mr Dudley carrying his dying wife to the forever house 😭
Omg I still cry so much at that scene!
And then it shows her holding her baby and with Abigail.
He’s also Barry the Chunk from the Doctor Sleep film Mike dod a few years back. A much more sinister role but the man has great range
What an powerful scene. This deserves an Emmy 😥
The writing was unnecessarily long and melodramatic. The actress did a good job tho.
@@alexlazzerly3677 How was this melodramatic? It was raw! Unfiltered and felt real. I’d feel that way if someone deprived me from my ability to walk. I’d want to forgive them but it would be excruciatingly painful to do so. And this scene conveyed these emotions with unwavering authenticity. I’m not entirely sure that people complaining about how boring the dialogue were even invested enough to listen to it
@@AJolie009 maybe melodramatic was the wrong word. But It is too long. Like I understood the point within the first few minutes.
@@alexlazzerly3677 she literally lost her legs, she had every right to bring everything she felt.
@@comedygod522 Lol i'm talking about it from a writing perspective not what the fictional character "had a right" to do. They could have condensed it a bit.
Mike Flanagan himself has a past history of alcoholism and he was raised a catholic (but no longer religious). That’s part reason why this show is so brilliant. Cause the creator truly knows what he’s talking about.
not many people in their life will ever understand what it's like to live with a disability. to know what you want, what you COULD be capable of, if only you weren't disabled. to see what you want to grab hold of, and not being able to reach out for it. that helplessness feeling is so indescribably frustrating. the amount of anger i've felt from my chronic pain over the last ten years has always made me feel like i was being too emotional, too selfish, too whiny. even when i kept it mostly to myself. this whole scene, whether or not someone's disability is caused by another person, speaks to and for everyone with disability. "you reached through time and you stole from me." that feeling of being robbed of your future is unlike anything that any able-bodied person could experience. this show is a masterpiece of beautiful and emotional writing.
His reaction when she says she forgives him is just priceless, perfect, the emotions from the words he longed to hear for so long. I cried rivers. 👌👌👌👌 Well, during the entire monologue. They are incredible.
Leeza and Riley’s mom are the ideal characters of what true Christians are SUPPOSED to be. Understanding that they are not free of sin, and therefore not above others. Their religion heightens them and inspires them to love, forgive, and do better. It gives them wisdom and strength. I’m glad that Mike Flanagan peppered in these good characters with the evil characters who twist the faith and use it for personal gain. Such good writing.
Rileys mom gives a great speech that sums up the wrong kind of religious person. After Bev basically says Riley was a waste of space person, she says "Why does that anger you? That God loves my son as much as he loves you. That he loves everyone as much as he loves you."
The religious thinking God carries more affinity for them than others has led to so much death and destruction throuhout history. It's actually that exact thinking that causes Bev to kill the entire island with her self-righteousness
She better get so many acting gigs! Her acting was amazing!!!
So was his!
As a christian, this series was a marvel, and seeing scenes like this gives so much hope! One because although the series warns about fanatism and overzealous christians, there are scenes in the series that portray christianity in a very human way. Not with charicature or oversimplification of the faith, but with true moments where the christian is shown to be someone who can be angry, and vulnerable... human. I love this scene because it's not cheesy christianity, it isn't cheese forgiveness.
I agree with you strongly. Sometimes we have such an idealistic view and goal of what a Godly life ought to be like that we forget that we are still human. The life of a person trying to live as a Christian/right with the Lord will not be perfect; only God is perfect. The portrayals of what a faithful believer has to deal with in their everyday life are so realistic in this series; they confront challenges, fail, and show they are just trying to do their best. This series’s actors truly receive their due.
As an atheist, this show is the most unbiased take on Christianity I’ve seen
@@Neo2266. That's what I love about it. In the hands of a lesser artist it would have just been a one-sided condemnation of Christianity, but instead it shows that with all religion, it all depends on the person wielding it. We see a wide array of people interact with faith and belief and everyone struggles and falls in their own way but at the end of the day they're all people seeking whatever comfort they can in the face of a world that's both horrifying and beautiful.
Did u guys watch the whole series😂
@@TheUnknown-yx8zc yes, why?
Both actors were amazing. Wow can’t really imagine how you can film a scene like that.
What I loved about this scene is when she first came in and was explaining how much she hated him and when she told him he stole things from her she was in the dark and when she told him she forgives him she stepped into the light.. that got me I love what it represents ❤️
I liked how he's framed at 0:17, makes him look small and pathetic, then, after she forgives him, she starts getting closer at 1:33 and he gets bigger and bigger.
The acting in this show is just incredible.
absolutely.
This show had so many good, creative and powerful speeches/dialogues/monologues. This one was probably the most powerful. Such amazing acting.
The script writers deserve some serious recognition for this show. Unbelievable, powerful speechs.
This is one of the finest scenes in tv history. I love that it relies on the writing and the acting. No big musical swells, no jumping camera. Even the actors barely move. Strong theatre vibes in all of Flannigan’s stuff and I love it!
Mike Flanagan is a master:
He terrifies you
He brings you to tears
He uplifts you
For me, it is just tears. And he is my favourite filmmaker.
her visceral animosity but ensuing forgiveness renders a heartfelt atonement...
Joe got to be forgiven and have some closure before his unfortunate destiny. Robert Longstreet (Joe Collie) and Annarah Cymone (Leeza) killed it
Feels weird to comment on a video that was uploaded so long ago that it feels a little unnecessary, but I always come back to watch this specific scene because it’s beautiful with or without context.
You can watch this scene without even watching Midnight Mass, but the characters, their expressions and their words are all you need to understand the intensity of their emotions and it’s glorious.
And I keep coming back because there is so much to digest, not just from the acting, but the camera work and directing.
Leeza is always shot from the waist up. We see multiple body shots of Joe in this scene, and when we do it’s to showcase how small and uncomfortable he feels. The way he stands and fidgets with his clothes, he is paralyzed with shame and self-loathing. Like a child sitting through a lecture with the full knowledge of what he did wrong. But every shot of Leeza is from the waist up. We know from context clues that she used to be paralyzed, confined only to a chair to do something as basic as moving around. A right taken from her against her will. And here she is very clearly standing with her own legs, legs that by all accounts should not be working because of what Joe did to her. And you would think that would absolve him of his guilt. That it would release him from his shame because the damage that should have been permanent had been undone. But it doesn’t. Because he still sees Leeza in that chair, the one he put her in because of his mistake. A mistake that cost her damn near everything. And that’s something nobody could damn well forget, let alone forgive. This image of her still in that wheelchair, it’s not a perception made from pity, but of accountability. No miracle could erase what he did, could redeem himself in his eyes, and it’s why he sees her now as so powerful and terrifying, but still in that chair, because her wrath is justified. Which is what makes her declaration of forgiveness so painful. He feels he has done nothing to deserve it.
And he’s right, and Leeza knows it too. He may have apologized, but that doesn’t guarantee redemption, change does. And he had done nothing to change, because he feels he deserves to suffer. His drinking only got worse because it was the only coping mechanism he knew. The only thing that did change was he stopped using his guns, for obvious reasons. His alcoholism could only hurt him now. But now, Leeza is actively challenging him to be better. The forgiveness isn’t an out for Joe, it’s a slap to wake him up. He now has to put in the work to make that forgiveness feel earned, or stay miserable knowing full well that it isn’t.
Leeza had every right to never forgive Joe for what he did, miracle or not. But she chose to because she has experienced first had what it felt like to be crippled, and sees now how it can manifest in different ways.
What Joe did to her, it wasn’t done out of malice. It wasn’t a targeted attack. It was an accident, but one that cost her so much, and the hate that she feels is a valid one, because Joe chose to go shooting while drunk. But here she stands in front of him, telling him he has no excuse to not try to be better. If he truly regrets his actions, he would do it for both of their sakes.
“A second chance, now that’s a miracle”
I just KNEW someone would upload this scene!
Flanagan has a talent for getting excellent performances from his actors.
This crazy miniseries about vampires had no reason to be this good. And yet it was. These are truly award winning performances and writing.
This scene. Just beautiful acting from both of them.
"Damn right youre sorry. You stole from me. Not just who I was but who I could’ve been.
You stole from me what I didn’t even have yet. You reached through time, Joe Collie.
All of that is true ….but thats not why I came here today. I came here today... I forgive you. … Im still angry with you but its different. Even now saying it its different"
You reached through time..... The way she conveyed it just amazing
Saw my dad cry during this scene. We've watched a lot of TV together over the years and never once have I ever seen him cry before.
This scene spoke to me a lot. My doctor as a kid diagnosed be 4 years before I nearly died with a preventable illness, yet failed to notify me or my parents. For FOUR years I continued to take medicine that could have killed me at any moment, that nearly killed me and put me through 6 months of absolute hell. I went 4 months without solid food. I went from 135 lbs to less than 70 lbs. I was emaciated and unable to stand due to muscle degradation. I had multiple organs begin to fail, and I only survived because I woke up on Thanksgiving day and could eat for the first time in months. To this day I still hate the man who condemned me to that, who could have said something and spared a 12 year old boy that horror, but chose to keep it to himself. I hate him, and I've dreamt of the worst things happening to him, but I try every day to forgive him. It's been over 14 years since I was sick, and over 8 years since I found out what he did to me, yet I still think about it daily. This scene really hits home for me.
Your family should have sued him for malpractice.
This scene is beautifully written Leeza's words are so powerful, and she speaks with such eloquence. Each time I watch this scene it hurts. The way joe reacts is so fitting for someone who has hated himself for years and him finally getting the punishment and confrontation from her allowed him to finally feel like he's getting what he feels he deserved. Her words hit so hard and pierce through the fourth wall for me and it feels like this isn't just a show but real life. Everyone who has worked on the show has really made it incredible.
I wish everybody who's been a victim of any kind of injustice had a moment like this to wash anger, repentance, and whatever emotion has been stuck in the river of despair.
Both performances are SO, DAMN, GOOD. God, I loved this show.
I didn’t really notice all the monologues in this show until I watched some of the reviews after binging it. Gosh, it is amazing what effects can be brought about by a combination of good writing and good acting. (Not to downplay the myriad of other factors and efforts that go into film- which are also fantastic here, btw -but for a monologue I think writing and acting are the two key pillars to its success)
God!! The moment she said " I Forgive You" My tears 😢 started to flow. The torture two both of them went through or are going through must be unbearable.
Annarah Cymone and Robert Longstreet knocked this scene out of the park. This is the only scene where I remotely cared about any of the teenage characters, though. Otherwise, they were kind of just there the whole season.
This scene is incredible
this scene absolutely floored me
Robert Longstreet is one of Americas finest actors. This scene and the one in the haunting of Hill House where he talks about his daughter are simply brilliant. I hope I get to see him in more roles and I hope he gets an Emmy for this performance.
As a survivor of childhood trauma & abuse, this scene shattered me. I felt every last word Leeza spoke. It really does feel as if your abuser/assailant/whomever caused you trauma had reached through time and stole everything from you. That’s how my experience was, anyways. I could’ve had such a wonderful and happy childhood, but they stole that from me. They stole my future, too, in many ways.
I hope I can one day forgive all of my abusers the same way Leeza did, because right now, I’m just very, very angry (amongst other things).
Kudos to the actress who plays Leeza, and to the writing team/Mike Flanagan for creating such a moving and powerful monologue. 💓
"I can't feel my legs."
Holy damn dude's soul was on the line in this one conversation and he knew it.
Utterly powerful scene! This show should clean up at the Emmys. Best show I’ve seen since Breaking Bad
Completely agree, there was something so entrancing about the whole show. It's time of release is unfortunate during the squid game frenzy as right now it feels like an undiscovered gem, though at the same time if everyone was talking about it it would detract from its raw emotion and power. Sorry that was kinda irrelevant I just felt like saying it, also really hope it does well at the Emmys
Agree 1000%
my favourite scene in the entire show, both of them are such good actors my god
The sound he makes when she forgives him is an absolutely wonderful character choice because it sounds painful and damn it if that isn’t the perfect way to depict forgiveness. It’s like lancing an untreated boil. All that rotten and festering self hatred and self loathing and sorrow being released like that. I’m sure it’s agony initially to be in the dark for so long and suddenly to be put in the light of forgiveness.
This show better get so many Emmy nominations. It was fantastic and beautiful in every way!
“If God can forgive you, then I can forgive you. And if I can forgive you, then anyone can.”
One helluva line, one helluva truth
the acting in this show was phenomenal, loved this scene. actually brought me to tears
This was one of the best depictions of forgiveness ( a main theme of the whole show) I have seen on screen. The acting was superb, the writing was beautiful. "The only thing standing in my way was hate, the only thing standing in your way is you" "you reached through time, Joe Collie" Wow! The power of forgiveness is immense and the lack of it contributes mightily to hatred throughout the history of the human race. What a great scene.
Thanks for uploading this. I was looking for this forever
Wait a minute? This guy’s name is Joe Collie?
But - my name is Joe Collie.
You reached through _TIME_ , Joe Collie.
We forgive you, too, Joe Collie.
@@juliec5151 too soon Julie C too soon :)
Forgiveness is one of the hardest things to do. It's harder than taking revenge.
For a series with so many monologues, it depended heavily on the actors and I cannot find fault in anyone's skills or talent.
This scene alone has some of the best acting I've ever seen in my life, for both of them
On a side note - this scene is the perfect representation of why Flanagan's work are of such high quality. He always allows his actors to shine, no matter if you're in the main or supporting cast. The exchange between Leeza & Joe is just a side story in a larger looming web of plotstrings, but it still gets the attention it deserves and the actors get the opportunity to go all out with their marvelous performances. So many shows I can think of where this scene would've been reduced to one minute, afraid the viewer might distract himself, but not this one. Just brilliant awareness of how genuine stories, performances, themes & substantial monologues in this medium can engage you in ways few other things can.
This show dude... Hits me RIGHT IN THE FEELS man!
Only 50k veiws? This scene was amazing. This series is under rated
I just watched this scene and paused the show to come here. WOW WOW WOW!! What a scene!
This scene absolutely crushed me. It’s beautiful and terrible and so true and raw. I can feel what they’re feeling. This is acting.
The acting from both was just pure master class. Glad the actress was cast in Midnight club as well, she deserves to go places!!
Joe's actor is in "Midnight Club" as well. He's the hospice janitor who cleans up the rooms after a kid passes. Only a couple scenes, but he makes the most of it. His character is a very compassionate and thoughtful guy who's obvious seen a lot of death and it's made him kind of Zen about it all.
This show made me tear up more than jump in fright. Im still stuck on this show
Man, this scene hit me in the gut! Mike Flanagan and the team behind this anthology did a phenomenal job! Props to all of them and props to all of us who got to see it!
This and Sophie Okonedo's monologue in Ratched deserve Emmys hands down.
Both of them are incredible in that scene
I’m doing this scene (myself as Leeza) for my stage debut in about 2 months. Wish me luck folks!
This moment in this show (love everything Flanagan does btw) is beautiful, sad, inspiring. We all should carry ourselves as Leeza does.
Good luck
😊
Such a good scene. Amazing show full of tough emotional scenes like this.
I felt for him and for Riley. First time I saw Riley's vision of the mangled girl, I said out loud "oh, you're gonna torture yourself to death". Joe was just few steps ahead
She handled this situation with such maturity
finally watching this show and this scene.... wow
The craziest thing is, this is probably the third or fourth hardest scene to watch without crying. This show has some of the best writing and acting I have ever seen.
The big ugly monster standing there broken like a child... it was cathartic.
I absolutely love this show, great acting, great deep moments
And this is why I don’t ever drink I’d rather have coca-Cola Pepsi and coffee for the rest of my life😢.
fuck that just dont shoot anyone when your drunk
@@BrookeSkylarShields and dont drink and drive
I've been drinking like an insane pirate since I was 16. Never hurt anyone except perhaps myself in daft accidents.
The last thing I'd ever pick up when I've got a drink in me is a gun or a set of car keys.
Sooo melodramatic, can't see a single tear though, just a ton faux sniffles.
I did some awful things to my ex-fiance when I was a drug and alcohol addict. She called me three years after, and told me she forgave but didn't let me forget what I had done, I had this same reaction. This is such a brilliant scene.
Now imagine this scene without Covid restrictions on set. I loved the show and think it’s one of the best shows of the past decade, which isn’t something I say lightly, but the cinematography was lacking in certain scenes compared to scenes from Hill House or Bly Manor. Still phenomenal performances from both actors.
Covid restrictions lol. People were losing their businesses for having people eating too close while outside while people were right across the street doing stuff for movies while people hung out maskless in the same trailers. At least they could even film this, people not working to make money for big corporations wouldnt have even been allowed this close to work without a mask.
This show was a breath of fresh air and this scene was so cathartic. This was the moment i realized this show wouldn't be about condemnation, but about redemption. This is one of the most Christian shows I've ever seen, but the fact it manages to be a damning indictment of the modern church in America WHILE showing the redemptive Power of God makes it nothing short of a masterpiece.
I keep revisiting this scene and i think i now know why. I wish more shows and movies that tackled themes of faith and -theism could have scenes feel like this. That had actual charecters with motives and depth, not shallow straw men and stand ins for the writer. The problem is most Christian media is handicapped by it's need to sanitize reality to appease fundamentalists, who are the ones most likely to buy christian targeted media. I might actually write an essay on this topic because the thought won't go away.
@@bondfall0072 except that the show is full of straw men and stand ins for the many dumb monologues the show has. You only notice the straw man when it's a theist point view.
@@400thekiller233 i respectfully disagree.
@@400thekiller233 Oh no, not monologues!
@brentdaniels5241 monologues are not inherently a problem, but they are in this show.
beautiful scene
This is brilliant acting! Excellent show!
She will have a bright future to look forward to in Hollywood. The actress.
Holy shit this scene brought out the water works in me. Incredibly powerful acting and scene.
INCREDIBLE ACTING I love this show and scene makes be teary eyed everytime
First tear jerker when I watched this
This scene and the finale haunt me
whoever wrote this party was spectacular. their acting hits deep
Leeza’s monologue gives me chills every time. Baffles me how the actress didn’t win anything for her performance here
my favorite scene in the whole show
Well this scene just came up and bit me in the ass! I was not expecting something so moving and so well done by all involved. Wow!
Another scene that really touch my heart is the scene when joe and riley come home after AA meeting with father paul. They talk and parted their way, before that, they both just awaken their "will to live". But i can't find that scene here on youtube
Both give prize worthy performances.
The hardest forgiveness is against oneself
Ome of the best scenes ever filemed
Wow 🥺
This is the second best scene in the show after Erin's first big monologue (the one on the couch, which is way better than the ending monologue).
Powerful.....goddamn...
I see you now 😭😭😭
This is some kinda scene man
What a fucking incredible scene
Can you change the title so that the punchline isn't spoiled?
HOW DOES IT MAKE YA FEEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
plz post the intro to episode 1