5:31 “if draco were just to get laid one time then he would have never killed dumbledore” damn this seems like a job only Ebony Dark'ness Dementia Raven Way could solve, if only we had her
Harry offered help to the Weasleys several times and they never accepted. The only reason the twins accepted the money for the shop was because Harry told them that they either took the money he won from the triwizard tournament or he was going to toss it all into the lake and the twins lost all their savings to a guy who scammed them after a bet. 🤔
I watched the movies earlier and I clearly remember that in the order of the pehonix or was it goblet of fire book the guy gave them fake Irish gold coins that then disappeared
God forbid he give the winnings to charity or other people who might also need it. JK Rowling is obsessed with the idea that poor people should just be poor and not accept “handouts”, as if scraping by is somehow noble compared to being handed aid.
For the horcrux, I believe the book goes into detail that the object has to be of some kind of value to the person performing the magic. You cannot just use anything. That’s why the objects include things like his personal diary and his pet snake.
The item CAN technically be anything, but Voldemort isn't gonna use a random shoe to put his soul into. He wants the items to have some value; to be "worthy" of his soul or to "corrupt" them with his soul, like the founder items. Not to mention that Horcruxes aren't really a multi-item deal in the first place. The theory is just to split the soul once and the price for that is already high to a normal person.
No it is in fact the case that Voldemore regards himself as so precious that he never would put his own soul in arondom Objekt and it is shown that he really likes to collect things from an early age, like the things he steals from the other orphans and on top of that he saw hogwards as his real home so he wanted to fuse his fate with the center of the British wizarding world as he tried to get one item of each founder, the diary he wrote while he was there and Nagini as his the only thing he ever loved besides himself with in addition was made in misery after the nearly died but was needed to split his soul in 7 parts the most magical of all numbers. Ps he didn't know that Harry although was a horcuxe and the eight part of his soul but to be clear a horcuxe could be anything and like un Harry's case you don't even know that you made one whe your soul is damaged enough.
Can confirm too, it can be anything and there’s even a dialogue about it where dumbledore says something like now you understand the gravity of the situation but harry was thinking of portkeys. As Voldy is egotistical he chose special things.
Ron in the books is drastically different from the movies, Ron in the books is a lot braver, stood up against Harry’s enemies and had a greater friendship with Harry. Hermione was the third wheel in the friend groups. Ron overall got done dirty in Yates movies.
@@cratonorogen9208 I assume its also because Emma Watson is an objectively better actor, and while her performance as a young child wasn't stellar, it was better than Rupert's.
The scenes where Ginny feeds Harry and where she ties his shoelaces are the cringiest scenes in the whole franchise. The way they absolutely ruined an amazing character from the books is beyond me. And I feel bad that Bonnie Wright had to do those scenes, she really liked Ginny and always talked about her boldness, confidence and brilliance which was nowhere to be found in the movies :
Although I agree it is handled a lot worse in the films, I also want to stick my neck out a bit and say that I don't think the Ginny-Harry romance (or any romance for that matter) was THAT well covered in the books either. The Harry Potter franchise in general does not exactly contain the greatest examples ever put to paper in the romance genre
11:10 the detail of Regulus Black getting the horcrux is explained more in the books. Regulus had assistance from his house elf, the only creature with magic who would be able to bypass Voldemort’s spells. The house elf was able to apparate out of the cave with the locket. Regulus actually died there by being dragged into the water by the inferi. The house elf had possession of the locket ever since and could never destroy it, even though he tried.
Harry didn’t help the twins set up their shop with his inherited money, he helped them by giving them his prize money from winning the Triwizard Tournament
@@gnat4999 it was more that he felt guilty for winning the prize money and didn't feel like he deserved it. He was trying to give it away to everyone during the last part of the book. it was way more obvious in the book because it was Cedric that pulled Harry up when he could have gotten to the cup first. and they fought over letting the other person win because they saved each other throughout the tournament. I believe he did try to give it to Molly while in the hospital wing and she refused it. It was just a last second thing when they were getting off the train at the end of the year that he shoved it on the twins saying if they didn't take it he was just going to chuck it out.
To be fair in book Slughorn's disguise was transparent because its mentioned he had very little time to prepare before Dumbledore and Harry arrived and basically was forced to improvise
This video shows how much context was lost in the movies from the books. The movies leave a lot of questions unanswered 🫣 Hermione and Harry had zero chemistry, Harry didn't like hanging out with her alone because she just wanted to study all the time, he preferred having Ron around with them. Love your videos! I already watched the original long video and I'm glad that being re-uploaded in shorter form.
Harry gave Fred and George the money he won from the triwizard tournament - not money from his own bank. Also in the books, draco sees Harry's sneaker slip out of the cloak and fly through the air which is how he knows Harry's there. Also also,the fire used to burn down the weasleys house is fiend fire. Cursed fire that cant be put out. It's also the fire that tears through the room of requirement, rendering it useless.
3:56 Actually in the books, Luna and Ron kinda have really sweet relationship! Like he seems to be the only one who isn't creeped out, but actually Charmed by her quirky tendencies!
I think Ron finds Luna hilarious in the books, so does Luna with Ron because I’m pretty sure the first time they meet Ron says a joke and Luna starts laughing harder than everyone else like it’s the funniest thing she’s ever heard and Ron is almost in awe by that reaction
11:11 Fun fact another thing the movie leaves out from the book Regulus Black didn’t obtain the locket alone he was aided by Kreacher who use to be his elf before Sirius and Harry. Even asked Kreacher to destroy it but he failed
The cave scene and the last part of the movie are some of the most emotional moments in the whole series for me it was painful to watch this grandfather figure in a state like that, also one thing that I love about Harry Potter as a series that is becoming exceedingly rare these days is the finality of death, you know that once a character dies in this series they are not coming back which makes those last scenes that much more impactful.
Yeah, about that, they kinda do come back in portrait form and seem to retain all of their memories, characteristics and they're just always there. Dumbledore is essentially alive, just with no body.
@@dowfreak7 the painting is more like a memory in the book if I remember correctly the painting says something like I don't know that cause I didn't experience that
@@joshuabrien2970Similarly, Nearly Headless Nick also states that there's a difference between a ghost and the person they once were iirc. The ghost isn't really them, just a pale imprint of who they had been that also prevents them from truly moving on, leaving what's left of them in a permanent incomplete state that few would choose. So while a technical form of immortality or life beyond death, there are implied to be downsides so bad even Voldemort didn't choose that option.
3:04 I loved this scene where Malfoy gets a little revenge on Harry. How many times has Harry taken advantage of the cloak to get Malfoy? I wish they had explained perhaps, but it does make sense to me that Malfoy would have figured out some way to spot Harry in the cloak, and turn things around on Harry, just this once...
Harry's sneaker pops out from under the cloak as he hides (in the book). It's explicitly stated that he looked in that direction, too and was just waiting the rest of the ride to bust Harry.
@@dowfreak7 pretty neat! I liked to think though that Malfoy had been tricked by the cloak so many times that he had developed a second sense when it was being used near him. I like that as my head canon explanation :D
The water thing is especially funny because there's a spell in one of the old Harry Potter games where you shoot massive jets of water out of your wand to put out fires lmao
Harry being able to just say a spell name and have it work always bugged me. Like, if a wizard creates a spell does it just get automatically added to a cosmic spell book that every other wizard can use by saying the word, or do all spells already exist in nature and we are just trying to guess what words unlock them?
@@lewischristie2285 Though the wand movements are not even necessary, since we see wandless magic used every so often, it seems just the verbal component and probably imagination, like I assume a Moldyshorts level wizard might just yell Miser (Misery/Miserable in latin) and just use some kind of despair curse.
@@Aeternus75 If you want to make it make sense, you could say that the wand movement is a sort of channel you create, that makes the magic work in the way you want, by almost forcing it down a path. You don't control the magic at that point, you just pour it into a mold and it has no choice but to come out correctly. Non-verbal spells and spells in which your wand access is restricted might be more arcana and naturey, in the sense that you need to really perceive magic well and know the flow of it, so you can form it without the wand movement. Just headcanon, though. Reality is that the magic system just isn't that fleshed out. Not that it's a huge deal, it just kinda breaks down if you think about it too hard. The books do however give some examples of how wand movements and pronunciation are important. There's an instance told of a wizard who tried to cast a spell, mispronounced it and ended up with a bull on his chest.
I always thought Harry was an above average wizard. The films play it down but in the books he’s really good in Defence against the dark arts classes. And it was Snape who created the sectumsempra spell and he was very good at the dark arts. I guess Hermione may be able to create spells but not Harry. 🤷🏾♂️
Ironic how the 'two side characters get together' thing has become so expected nowadays though (see Star Wars for example) + the obviously telegraphed Romione scenes in the movies actually made them the most obvious pairing in the franchise, completely removing the 'subverting expectations' part. Now we're just left with a completely predictable and 'in your face' telegraphed pairing that makes no sense
I thought it was actually because putting them together was some personal parallel to Rowling? And then she went back on it a little while later, which has now become a routine thing for Rowling but… ya know.
if Harry just picked up on the fact that all the spells are mushed up Latin words, he would understand that sectumsempra literally means "cuts that will never heal." ask Hermione for godsake, she'd know
Snape was far from a loser, he was Dumbledore’s right hand man, he managed to fool the world’s greatest evil wizard for 20 years, and he literally created HIS OWN spells and knew better than his textbooks. He could have been anything he wanted in the wizarding world, but he chose to remain a simple Hogwarts tutor to watch over Lily’s son and to help Dumbledore when Voldemort inevitably came back. Snape was a legend
Imagine borderline torturing a 11 year old student because your Dark Master didn't kill his parents and killed your childhood crush instead. And you were the reason he even knew about the prophecy to begin with. Snape is still still an awful person.
Malfoy saw one of the suitcases shift, which led him to believe someone was spying (it was very subtle) - I don’t think he knew it was Harry until the cloak was removed though
Voldi boy was a very proud boy... he wanted the pices of his soul to mean something so he put them in the most magicly important things he could think of
In the book, Harry does feel bad he's wealthy in the wizard world but the Weasleys won't accept charity and Mrs Weasley treats harry like a son and would rather he use it wisely than ask. Fred and George were the only ones willing to take Harry's money, which he got from the end of the fourth movie apart from the trophy the prize was like 5000 dollars that he just gives to the twins because he didn't want it after watching Cedric die
My favorite moment in this movie is Dumbledore taking the magazine on account of his interest in knitting patterns and going to the loo like some mundane elderly man. You'd think he'd have some sort of reason behind his every action that are all part of a larger plan, but nope he just does all that because he's just a guy like all of us deep inside. Come to think of it, this movie shows Dumbledore's human side the most in the series which I appreciated, there's just something wholesome about seeing Dumbledore acting normally like others of his age (Well, he's technically much older but you get the idea)
Just a small note but Malfoy knew Harry was in the carriage because earlier in the scene Draco notices the suitcase moving on its own, giving away that someone was spying on him (and I'm guessing he knows the only person with an invisibility cloak to be Harry)
Funny you mention Draco needing a gf in the Halfblood Prince, because he actually has a really weird relationship with Moaning Myrtle in the book. He spends a lot of time crying with her while she tries to confort him.
in the book, it was Regulas Blacks house elf that replaced the locket with a fake. Something to do with Voldemorts trap spells not recognizing elf life as a threat.
Draco could have piped Pansy Parkinson at any time, worrying about the Dark Lord killing his entire family if this magic box trick in the Room of Requirement didn't work kinda killed the flavor for him. She's all over him in the train scene in the book.
Nah, he definitely piped. He did it out of desperation though and she never spoke to him again. Thankfully he married a girl who had similar views to him about the dark arts being shit. They lived happily ever after.
It doesn’t say that it the books though, Voldemort only makes them with meaningful powerful things because he is full of himself and doesn’t want his soul to be in something that isn’t worth anything
Second-years can't visit Hogsmeade on their own but you expect 12 year old Harry and Ron to take a broom ride to Diagon Alley, grab some money at Gringott's, and go shopping at Ollivander's, a wand maker who likely only does retail sales during a certain time of the year and probably wouldn't have anything on the fly to suit Ron anyways?
the thing about the horcruxes is that I genuinely believed that it was better to use items instead of sand or moon like u said because can you imagine how anyone would want to die after awhile.
Not only that, a horcrux dosen't make you imortal. You are basically stuck in limbo until someone revives you and even then they need the item you stuck a piece of your soul to Gl having 5 deatheaters search the whole atlantis for a grain of sand or use the moon in the revival ritual
I am not 100% sure, since i did not read the books but from the movies what I understood is creating Horcrux does not make you invincible or immortal. It basically works like a 'respawn' button. In order to use the respawn feature you have to do rituals and stuff to extract the soul and then give it a brand new body, that we saw in the ending of goblet of fire. And this procedure requires help from other people, that is why voldemort was so adamant about recruiting followers. if you turn sand grain or moon into a horcrux, i don't think it will be possible. this is why he created horcuxes with items that were related to him and created traps around them so only his followers can get access to it in an event where he died.
Ron always gets really self conscious anytime harry buys him shit in the books, he’d love to give money to the Weasleys but knows they wouldn’t take it it took a lot of convincing just for George and Fred to take his money
What I don’t understand is how it seems like 2 of their children have very successful jobs and Percy later becomes pretty successful. Why tf weren’t they sending money home I mean Percy later has drama with the family but before that every child that was earning money should’ve helped out
I still adore how you used Jeremy Soule's HP game soundtrack for a lot of footage. It's such an iconic, wholesome score and I'll forever love it. Such a shame that HL doesn't have any of those tracks or references for it!
Ron and Hermione's relationship makes so much more sense in the books, they even added several extra scenes to the movies that built up Harry and Hermione together, contradicting the books.
@@Gameprojordan no? i dont think you understood what i said. if i watch it its in 1st person like everyone, but if i remember it my brain constructs a 3rd person pov in order to revisit it
11:25 Kreatur or whatever the name, the black's house elf, he was with regulus, helped him drink and then left him to die there and used elf magic to teleport out of the cave.
I will not stand for this Ron slander, yeah sure maybe not exactly in movies cuz they fucked him up, but in books he is the glue, he and Hermione have much more chemistry than Hermione and Harry - even in the broship way, smh
"it's the school where I've almost died hundreds of times with a geriatric old man that thinks deadly animals are good to have around children. It's so safe." -Harry Potter All Voldemort had to do to protect the horocruxes was put all of them into different muggle banks. No wizard's getting them.
Memories can be stored in 3rd person, tends to occur more often when your traumatized but can pretty much happen whenever. They don't really know why it happens and people have been trying to figure out the reasons behind it since Freud. So IF you don't have at least one memory with a third person/fly on the wall perspective your the weird one.
Not sure if anyone else has mentioned but, (I can't speak for the book because I haven't read it yet) Malfoy knew Harry was up there because there is a literal shot of one of the overhead bags being nudged... Malfoy notices this, and obviously knows something is up... lol. You must've missed that detail.
About the horcruxes grain of sand thing: I think the horcruxes have to be something that is very significant, that the user can passionately, fully split their soil into. I also believe that it takes a lot of power to split your soul that many times
Book readers- was there a chapter in OOTP (or around that area) where Harry tried to give Mrs. Weasley some sort of compensation and she turns him away? I don’t know why something like that is dancing around in my brain…
11:17 I don't remember if the movies say it but he didn't do it by himself. He had Kreacher come with him and told Kreacher to leave without him. And he literally didn't make it out. He died there.
Regulus Black had help from his house elf and so he gave the real locket to the house elf and replaced pretty much straight after the zombie things killed him and Creature the house teleported away
My ranking of the books/films 1) Prisoner of Azkaban/Deathly Hallows Part II 2) Order of the Phoenix/Prisoner of Azkaban 3) Half-Blood Prince/Sorcerer's Stone 4) Deathly Hallows/Order of the Phoenix 5) Goblet of Fire/Half-Blood Prince 6) Sorcerer's Stone/Deathly Hallows Part I 7) Chamber of Secrets/Goblet of Fire *8) Chamber of Secrets
@3:08 Draco works out Harry's there because Harry accidently nudged the suitcase next to him, alerting Draco (I think that's how it is the in the film at least)
I will say that the ron/hermione relationship is better done in the books, it feels rushed in the films. also don’t even get me started on how they ruined harry and ginny as a couple.
Not to mention, how much the movie. Ruins Ron character, didn’t mean him weak character of the trio. Also gave most of his cool moment and character arc to Hermione, because the director or producer liked Hermione so much that. They made her strong female character. While Ron while was a winding bitch or unlike at time. Films version ruined his character, while the books he likeable and smart at time.
They never do anything about rons house burning because it literally never happens in the book. The director i guess just thought it would look cool and then brushes it off lmao
5:31 “if draco were just to get laid one time then he would have never killed dumbledore”
damn this seems like a job only Ebony Dark'ness Dementia Raven Way could solve, if only we had her
If only she was real 😪😔
Legit made me snort-laugh!! 🤣😂
I love this so much
Haha yeah, now list every piece of clothing she's wearing and what color it is though.
😂
Harry offered help to the Weasleys several times and they never accepted. The only reason the twins accepted the money for the shop was because Harry told them that they either took the money he won from the triwizard tournament or he was going to toss it all into the lake and the twins lost all their savings to a guy who scammed them after a bet. 🤔
Yea, how could they possibly say no when he's threatening to toss the money where no one will ever find it.
I watched the movies earlier and I clearly remember that in the order of the pehonix or was it goblet of fire book the guy gave them fake Irish gold coins that then disappeared
God forbid he give the winnings to charity or other people who might also need it. JK Rowling is obsessed with the idea that poor people should just be poor and not accept “handouts”, as if scraping by is somehow noble compared to being handed aid.
@@green7449 more due to the guy taking their money and the fact that Harry would never need it anyway. 🤭
For the horcrux, I believe the book goes into detail that the object has to be of some kind of value to the person performing the magic. You cannot just use anything. That’s why the objects include things like his personal diary and his pet snake.
Also, since Voldemort thought he was so awesome, he specifically wanted special items of power.
The item CAN technically be anything, but Voldemort isn't gonna use a random shoe to put his soul into. He wants the items to have some value; to be "worthy" of his soul or to "corrupt" them with his soul, like the founder items.
Not to mention that Horcruxes aren't really a multi-item deal in the first place. The theory is just to split the soul once and the price for that is already high to a normal person.
No it is in fact the case that Voldemore regards himself as so precious that he never would put his own soul in arondom Objekt and it is shown that he really likes to collect things from an early age, like the things he steals from the other orphans and on top of that he saw hogwards as his real home so he wanted to fuse his fate with the center of the British wizarding world as he tried to get one item of each founder, the diary he wrote while he was there and Nagini as his the only thing he ever loved besides himself with in addition was made in misery after the nearly died but was needed to split his soul in 7 parts the most magical of all numbers.
Ps he didn't know that Harry although was a horcuxe and the eight part of his soul but to be clear a horcuxe could be anything and like un Harry's case you don't even know that you made one whe your soul is damaged enough.
Can confirm too, it can be anything and there’s even a dialogue about it where dumbledore says something like now you understand the gravity of the situation but harry was thinking of portkeys. As Voldy is egotistical he chose special things.
They also established Voldemort's tendency to collect "trophy's" hence why he makes valuable historical objects into horcruxes. It's an ego thing
Ron in the books is drastically different from the movies, Ron in the books is a lot braver, stood up against Harry’s enemies and had a greater friendship with Harry. Hermione was the third wheel in the friend groups. Ron overall got done dirty in Yates movies.
Not just Yates’s films but from the beginning because famously the screenwriter like hermione more
Ron was such a ride or die chad in the books:(
Ron was still a jealous asshole incel in the books
@@cratonorogen9208 I assume its also because Emma Watson is an objectively better actor, and while her performance as a young child wasn't stellar, it was better than Rupert's.
@@NeptuneGuy78 yes she is a decent actress in the later ones but have you seen thunderpants with rupert grint? Better than any harry potter film 😅
The scenes where Ginny feeds Harry and where she ties his shoelaces are the cringiest scenes in the whole franchise. The way they absolutely ruined an amazing character from the books is beyond me. And I feel bad that Bonnie Wright had to do those scenes, she really liked Ginny and always talked about her boldness, confidence and brilliance which was nowhere to be found in the movies :
Although I agree it is handled a lot worse in the films, I also want to stick my neck out a bit and say that I don't think the Ginny-Harry romance (or any romance for that matter) was THAT well covered in the books either. The Harry Potter franchise in general does not exactly contain the greatest examples ever put to paper in the romance genre
@@TheLastCrusader22 it was super out of nowhere. I remember being super confused when Harry suddenly got feelings for her.
Haven't read the books in a while, but in the movies at least Luna Love good has WAY more chemistry with Harry
@@Alex-ve1og tbf I think Luna has chemistry with everyone
@@Alex-ve1ogreportedly Daniel Radcliffe thought Harry would end up with Luna, which he portrayed in his acting
11:10 the detail of Regulus Black getting the horcrux is explained more in the books. Regulus had assistance from his house elf, the only creature with magic who would be able to bypass Voldemort’s spells. The house elf was able to apparate out of the cave with the locket. Regulus actually died there by being dragged into the water by the inferi. The house elf had possession of the locket ever since and could never destroy it, even though he tried.
Harry didn’t help the twins set up their shop with his inherited money, he helped them by giving them his prize money from winning the Triwizard Tournament
so i guess he did just straight up forget hes rich lmao
@@gnat4999 it was more that he felt guilty for winning the prize money and didn't feel like he deserved it. He was trying to give it away to everyone during the last part of the book. it was way more obvious in the book because it was Cedric that pulled Harry up when he could have gotten to the cup first. and they fought over letting the other person win because they saved each other throughout the tournament. I believe he did try to give it to Molly while in the hospital wing and she refused it. It was just a last second thing when they were getting off the train at the end of the year that he shoved it on the twins saying if they didn't take it he was just going to chuck it out.
really makes you think
@@ElvistheAlien the Weasley’s are also too proud to accept actual money from Harry.
@@ElvistheAlien there’s a lot of context missing in the films that are in the books.
To be fair in book Slughorn's disguise was transparent because its mentioned he had very little time to prepare before Dumbledore and Harry arrived and basically was forced to improvise
This video shows how much context was lost in the movies from the books. The movies leave a lot of questions unanswered 🫣
Hermione and Harry had zero chemistry, Harry didn't like hanging out with her alone because she just wanted to study all the time, he preferred having Ron around with them. Love your videos! I already watched the original long video and I'm glad that being re-uploaded in shorter form.
Harry gave Fred and George the money he won from the triwizard tournament - not money from his own bank.
Also in the books, draco sees Harry's sneaker slip out of the cloak and fly through the air which is how he knows Harry's there.
Also also,the fire used to burn down the weasleys house is fiend fire. Cursed fire that cant be put out. It's also the fire that tears through the room of requirement, rendering it useless.
Also also also, that last thing you mentioned was never in the book and never made sense that it was added to the movie.
3:56 Actually in the books, Luna and Ron kinda have really sweet relationship! Like he seems to be the only one who isn't creeped out, but actually Charmed by her quirky tendencies!
I think Ron finds Luna hilarious in the books, so does Luna with Ron because I’m pretty sure the first time they meet Ron says a joke and Luna starts laughing harder than everyone else like it’s the funniest thing she’s ever heard and Ron is almost in awe by that reaction
He finds her amusing rather than weird.
11:11 Fun fact another thing the movie leaves out from the book Regulus Black didn’t obtain the locket alone he was aided by Kreacher who use to be his elf before Sirius and Harry.
Even asked Kreacher to destroy it but he failed
The cave scene and the last part of the movie are some of the most emotional moments in the whole series for me it was painful to watch this grandfather figure in a state like that, also one thing that I love about Harry Potter as a series that is becoming exceedingly rare these days is the finality of death, you know that once a character dies in this series they are not coming back which makes those last scenes that much more impactful.
Yeah, about that, they kinda do come back in portrait form and seem to retain all of their memories, characteristics and they're just always there. Dumbledore is essentially alive, just with no body.
@@dowfreak7 the painting is more like a memory in the book if I remember correctly the painting says something like I don't know that cause I didn't experience that
@@joshuabrien2970Similarly, Nearly Headless Nick also states that there's a difference between a ghost and the person they once were iirc. The ghost isn't really them, just a pale imprint of who they had been that also prevents them from truly moving on, leaving what's left of them in a permanent incomplete state that few would choose. So while a technical form of immortality or life beyond death, there are implied to be downsides so bad even Voldemort didn't choose that option.
Meanwhile Harry cheating death in the last movie.
3:04 I loved this scene where Malfoy gets a little revenge on Harry. How many times has Harry taken advantage of the cloak to get Malfoy? I wish they had explained perhaps, but it does make sense to me that Malfoy would have figured out some way to spot Harry in the cloak, and turn things around on Harry, just this once...
He sees the suitcase move.
Harry's sneaker pops out from under the cloak as he hides (in the book). It's explicitly stated that he looked in that direction, too and was just waiting the rest of the ride to bust Harry.
Luscious Mouthboy
@@dowfreak7 pretty neat! I liked to think though that Malfoy had been tricked by the cloak so many times that he had developed a second sense when it was being used near him. I like that as my head canon explanation :D
The water thing is especially funny because there's a spell in one of the old Harry Potter games where you shoot massive jets of water out of your wand to put out fires lmao
Harry being able to just say a spell name and have it work always bugged me. Like, if a wizard creates a spell does it just get automatically added to a cosmic spell book that every other wizard can use by saying the word, or do all spells already exist in nature and we are just trying to guess what words unlock them?
This magic system is too soft for all that logistical thinking 😂
It's a combo of how you wave your wand and the spell. Also yes, I believe there are spells no-one has figured out the words for yet.
@@lewischristie2285 Though the wand movements are not even necessary, since we see wandless magic used every so often, it seems just the verbal component and probably imagination, like I assume a Moldyshorts level wizard might just yell Miser (Misery/Miserable in latin) and just use some kind of despair curse.
@@Aeternus75 If you want to make it make sense, you could say that the wand movement is a sort of channel you create, that makes the magic work in the way you want, by almost forcing it down a path. You don't control the magic at that point, you just pour it into a mold and it has no choice but to come out correctly.
Non-verbal spells and spells in which your wand access is restricted might be more arcana and naturey, in the sense that you need to really perceive magic well and know the flow of it, so you can form it without the wand movement.
Just headcanon, though. Reality is that the magic system just isn't that fleshed out. Not that it's a huge deal, it just kinda breaks down if you think about it too hard.
The books do however give some examples of how wand movements and pronunciation are important. There's an instance told of a wizard who tried to cast a spell, mispronounced it and ended up with a bull on his chest.
I always thought Harry was an above average wizard. The films play it down but in the books he’s really good in Defence against the dark arts classes.
And it was Snape who created the sectumsempra spell and he was very good at the dark arts.
I guess Hermione may be able to create spells but not Harry. 🤷🏾♂️
I feel like Ron and Hermione only ended up together to subvert expectations.
Ironic how the 'two side characters get together' thing has become so expected nowadays though (see Star Wars for example) + the obviously telegraphed Romione scenes in the movies actually made them the most obvious pairing in the franchise, completely removing the 'subverting expectations' part. Now we're just left with a completely predictable and 'in your face' telegraphed pairing that makes no sense
I thought it was actually because putting them together was some personal parallel to Rowling? And then she went back on it a little while later, which has now become a routine thing for Rowling but… ya know.
if Harry just picked up on the fact that all the spells are mushed up Latin words, he would understand that sectumsempra literally means "cuts that will never heal." ask Hermione for godsake, she'd know
Snape was far from a loser, he was Dumbledore’s right hand man, he managed to fool the world’s greatest evil wizard for 20 years, and he literally created HIS OWN spells and knew better than his textbooks. He could have been anything he wanted in the wizarding world, but he chose to remain a simple Hogwarts tutor to watch over Lily’s son and to help Dumbledore when Voldemort inevitably came back. Snape was a legend
Imagine borderline torturing a 11 year old student because your Dark Master didn't kill his parents and killed your childhood crush instead. And you were the reason he even knew about the prophecy to begin with.
Snape is still still an awful person.
Lord Voldemort? Seriously? Well you haven't seen Ado-
@@phoenixbythefire4555thank you
@@kolossis8283Ado- what HM????
Malfoy saw one of the suitcases shift, which led him to believe someone was spying (it was very subtle) - I don’t think he knew it was Harry until the cloak was removed though
No he knew it was Harry. He says” you know it ain’t nice spy pottah.” Or that your parent should’ve told u not to spy
Voldi boy was a very proud boy... he wanted the pices of his soul to mean something so he put them in the most magicly important things he could think of
In the book, Harry does feel bad he's wealthy in the wizard world but the Weasleys won't accept charity and Mrs Weasley treats harry like a son and would rather he use it wisely than ask.
Fred and George were the only ones willing to take Harry's money, which he got from the end of the fourth movie apart from the trophy the prize was like 5000 dollars that he just gives to the twins because he didn't want it after watching Cedric die
I came just to read the HP nerds push up the glasses on the bride of their nose and "Ahkctually" tf out of this video and it did not disappoint.
At the end, Kreacher the house elf is the one who helps R.A.B. get the real locket. It definitely goes into it in the books and the last movies
My favorite moment in this movie is Dumbledore taking the magazine on account of his interest in knitting patterns and going to the loo like some mundane elderly man. You'd think he'd have some sort of reason behind his every action that are all part of a larger plan, but nope he just does all that because he's just a guy like all of us deep inside. Come to think of it, this movie shows Dumbledore's human side the most in the series which I appreciated, there's just something wholesome about seeing Dumbledore acting normally like others of his age (Well, he's technically much older but you get the idea)
Just a small note but Malfoy knew Harry was in the carriage because earlier in the scene Draco notices the suitcase moving on its own, giving away that someone was spying on him (and I'm guessing he knows the only person with an invisibility cloak to be Harry)
I love Elvis's midmaxing ideas throughout this series.
Elvis probably making bank with these vids. He deserves it. I hope that the videos don't get copyright claimed again
Funny you mention Draco needing a gf in the Halfblood Prince, because he actually has a really weird relationship with Moaning Myrtle in the book. He spends a lot of time crying with her while she tries to confort him.
I FORGOT ABOUT THAT OMFGGGG
in the book, it was Regulas Blacks house elf that replaced the locket with a fake. Something to do with Voldemorts trap spells not recognizing elf life as a threat.
Draco could have piped Pansy Parkinson at any time, worrying about the Dark Lord killing his entire family if this magic box trick in the Room of Requirement didn't work kinda killed the flavor for him. She's all over him in the train scene in the book.
Nah, he definitely piped. He did it out of desperation though and she never spoke to him again. Thankfully he married a girl who had similar views to him about the dark arts being shit. They lived happily ever after.
Tbh Voldemort was born in like...1925...could be the dementia..
The horcrux can be literally anything, but Voldemort has some sort of inflated ego and a sense of greatness.
Dude, I literally NEVER noticed that Slughorn's shoes were in front of the chair in that scene. OH MY GOD.
That "uncut edit' killed me, thank you man, I really looked forward to your videos for a laugh and make my day.
if youve read the books its mentioned you can only make a horcrux out of something meaningful to that person
It mentions that in the films too
"Man, the moon means so much to me. I wish nothing wrong would've happen to it say blowing it up."
It doesn’t say that it the books though, Voldemort only makes them with meaningful powerful things because he is full of himself and doesn’t want his soul to be in something that isn’t worth anything
I remember reading that Daniel was performing whilst drunk at some point in these last films.
I hope “I don’t always lose” becomes his permanent catchphrase at the end of all videos going forward.
Harry really said "Gotta act broke to stay rich"
it’s so nice seeing all of these videos back to back everyday lol enjoying it while it lasts ❤
Second-years can't visit Hogsmeade on their own but you expect 12 year old Harry and Ron to take a broom ride to Diagon Alley, grab some money at Gringott's, and go shopping at Ollivander's, a wand maker who likely only does retail sales during a certain time of the year and probably wouldn't have anything on the fly to suit Ron anyways?
Using water to put out the burrow? Nonsense. That only works in the Lego game
This guy is surfing on the popularity of the new game hard core lol, smart move my man! 😂😏
No he made a big multi hour long video that got demonetized so he's releasing it in parts cause he doesn't know what got him demonetized
In the books Harry explains that the Weasleys will not exept money even though he tried do give them money.
Ralph Fiennes is easily the best part! I've loved your content for years! Keep up the fantastic work!!!
i’m loving these daily uploads
the thing about the horcruxes is that I genuinely believed that it was better to use items instead of sand or moon like u said because can you imagine how anyone would want to die after awhile.
Not only that, a horcrux dosen't make you imortal. You are basically stuck in limbo until someone revives you and even then they need the item you stuck a piece of your soul to
Gl having 5 deatheaters search the whole atlantis for a grain of sand or use the moon in the revival ritual
I am not 100% sure, since i did not read the books but from the movies what I understood is creating Horcrux does not make you invincible or immortal. It basically works like a 'respawn' button.
In order to use the respawn feature you have to do rituals and stuff to extract the soul and then give it a brand new body, that we saw in the ending of goblet of fire.
And this procedure requires help from other people, that is why voldemort was so adamant about recruiting followers.
if you turn sand grain or moon into a horcrux, i don't think it will be possible.
this is why he created horcuxes with items that were related to him and created traps around them so only his followers can get access to it in an event where he died.
Sometimes people remember things in 3rd person. I think it’s a result of growing up watching sitcoms. That’s just my theory though.
Horcruxes have to be made out of something that is important to the maker
Harry should have ended up with Luna, she understood him like nobody else did in the books. I will die on this ship hill.
nice new elvis video
"Maybe he just forgot he was rich" meanwhile I'm sitting here trying to remember why hes rich
No one's destroying the moon dude 😂😂😂😂
Ron always gets really self conscious anytime harry buys him shit in the books, he’d love to give money to the Weasleys but knows they wouldn’t take it it took a lot of convincing just for George and Fred to take his money
What I don’t understand is how it seems like 2 of their children have very successful jobs and Percy later becomes pretty successful. Why tf weren’t they sending money home I mean Percy later has drama with the family but before that every child that was earning money should’ve helped out
I still adore how you used Jeremy Soule's HP game soundtrack for a lot of footage. It's such an iconic, wholesome score and I'll forever love it. Such a shame that HL doesn't have any of those tracks or references for it!
Ron and Hermione's relationship makes so much more sense in the books, they even added several extra scenes to the movies that built up Harry and Hermione together, contradicting the books.
It’s because one of the people who worked on the movies favourite character was Hermione and shipped Harry and Hermione and it’s glaringly obvious
I thought the title was about Snape ☠️
i actually remember everything from a 3rd person perspective, its really weird cause it makes it feel like an out of body experience
Also it’s a movie and we need to watch a SCENE
You watched this movie with an over the shoulder camera view?
@@Gameprojordan no? i dont think you understood what i said. if i watch it its in 1st person like everyone, but if i remember it my brain constructs a 3rd person pov in order to revisit it
@@aaronrivera6732 not just because it’s a movie either, it’s the same thing in the books as well
11:25 Kreatur or whatever the name, the black's house elf, he was with regulus, helped him drink and then left him to die there and used elf magic to teleport out of the cave.
Thanks for the good time, m8.
The Aquafina spell is a step up from the Dasani water spell.
I love how you choose who should hook up with whom.
I will not stand for this Ron slander, yeah sure maybe not exactly in movies cuz they fucked him up, but in books he is the glue, he and Hermione have much more chemistry than Hermione and Harry - even in the broship way, smh
Draco knew Harry was eavesdropping on the train bc he noticed the luggage moving above them. Just had to point that out
11:00 in the book they are supposed to be the corpses of all those who came before trying to get the locket…I think…it’s been awhile lol
5:49 this whack actually hit Tom Felton’s hand, and it gave him a permanent scar. It might not have been the take we see in the movie, but one did.
"it's the school where I've almost died hundreds of times with a geriatric old man that thinks deadly animals are good to have around children. It's so safe."
-Harry Potter
All Voldemort had to do to protect the horocruxes was put all of them into different muggle banks. No wizard's getting them.
I think Ron and Hermione got together because Harry got together with Ginny and this way they all get to be related at the end.
At 9:36 you missed a prime opportunity to say "Riddle me this Tom"
Some ppl do see memories in 3rd person. Like I do. Some ppl see in 1st person in their head, some in 3rd
Also facts on the horcrux in a grain of sand or something as small and just chuck it in the desert
Memories can be stored in 3rd person, tends to occur more often when your traumatized but can pretty much happen whenever.
They don't really know why it happens and people have been trying to figure out the reasons behind it since Freud.
So IF you don't have at least one memory with a third person/fly on the wall perspective your the weird one.
Do all the underworld movies
I choked on 'awkwafina' spell joke
Not sure if anyone else has mentioned but, (I can't speak for the book because I haven't read it yet) Malfoy knew Harry was up there because there is a literal shot of one of the overhead bags being nudged... Malfoy notices this, and obviously knows something is up... lol. You must've missed that detail.
The reason why he didn't put his soul in grains of sand is because he only wanted his soul in important objects to him and the wizarding world.
I would’ve started this series in order but this title absolutely sold me bro. Ain’t had no reason to cook him like that 😂😂
It was the property of the Pensieve, the device which they use to view memories that you would be in 3rd person when viewing
“It’ll be our little secret.” -Tom Riddle.
Malfoy's shoes were chosen pointy by his father as a remider of what a dissapointment he is.
About the horcruxes grain of sand thing: I think the horcruxes have to be something that is very significant, that the user can passionately, fully split their soil into. I also believe that it takes a lot of power to split your soul that many times
Book readers- was there a chapter in OOTP (or around that area) where Harry tried to give Mrs. Weasley some sort of compensation and she turns him away? I don’t know why something like that is dancing around in my brain…
He tries to give her his triwizard money that he won and molly refuses to take it from him if that’s what you mean?
@deepee he tries ti give it to Cedric’s parents and then he tries to give it to Molly
11:17 I don't remember if the movies say it but he didn't do it by himself. He had Kreacher come with him and told Kreacher to leave without him. And he literally didn't make it out. He died there.
Regulus Black had help from his house elf and so he gave the real locket to the house elf and replaced pretty much straight after the zombie things killed him and Creature the house teleported away
My ranking of the books/films
1) Prisoner of Azkaban/Deathly Hallows Part II
2) Order of the Phoenix/Prisoner of Azkaban
3) Half-Blood Prince/Sorcerer's Stone
4) Deathly Hallows/Order of the Phoenix
5) Goblet of Fire/Half-Blood Prince
6) Sorcerer's Stone/Deathly Hallows Part I
7) Chamber of Secrets/Goblet of Fire
*8) Chamber of Secrets
@3:08 Draco works out Harry's there because Harry accidently nudged the suitcase next to him, alerting Draco (I think that's how it is the in the film at least)
I will say that the ron/hermione relationship is better done in the books, it feels rushed in the films. also don’t even get me started on how they ruined harry and ginny as a couple.
Not to mention, how much the movie. Ruins Ron character, didn’t mean him weak character of the trio. Also gave most of his cool moment and character arc to Hermione, because the director or producer liked Hermione so much that.
They made her strong female character. While Ron while was a winding bitch or unlike at time. Films version ruined his character, while the books he likeable and smart at time.
Slughorn had tampered with his memory. To shield it.
"Maybe he just lets his good friend (and his family) live in squalor."
Decent point...
The editing is awesome
I love these daily video things such a good idea gives me summin to watch when I’m high 😂
They never do anything about rons house burning because it literally never happens in the book. The director i guess just thought it would look cool and then brushes it off lmao
The spell Harry used against Malfoy cut Malfoy to ribbons and Draco knew Harry was up above because he saw the suitcase move.
"Nobody's destroying the moon!" Yeah right *laughs in Isaac Clarkes voice*
@11:20 I know you must be getting so many replies on how he did it in the book but I am just having PTSD how F up that scene was in the book.
I love how he does not know Regulus does not exit the cave 😬
Kreacher did on Regulus order.
Everything must be pointy as draco's shoes Elvis my man its villany 101
I'm on pure alcohol, this is all
Malfoy saw the suitcase move , thats why he knew Potter was hiding there