Rosewood VS Mahogany. Which tone do you prefer?

Hey folks,
I did a quick tone comparison between a 2023 Gibson Songwriter and a 2024 Martin D-18.
I'm a rosewood guy!
Which do you prefer?
Should I switch to Mahogany?
Let me know what you think!
Thanks for watching.
Al
#thecanadianflatpicker #musicpractice #bluegrass #canada #leadguitar #martinguitar #guitar #guitarlesson #gibson

[@zororosario]

Sounds real nice , both guitars the Gibson in particular is very focused 😊. I'm considering a songwriter mahogany from L&M, can't find a sound comparison. This video gives me a fair idea of what it maybe like in a different tone wood for the back and sides. Thanks

[@thecanadianflatpicker]

Thanks so much. I work at lnm so if a mahogany SR comes through, I'll be sure to demo it.

[@alicankarakaya2770]

D-18 has such an iconic sound. Songwriter doesn't get the love it deserves though.

[@thecanadianflatpicker]

I couldn't agree more

[@jamiemacdonald4994]

I like rose wood because the strings are broken in

[@thecanadianflatpicker]

Me too

[@jamiemacdonald4994]

But if the d 18 strings were broken in it would be a tie

[@thecanadianflatpicker]

Heck yes

[@dennispedicone5125]

Martin D18 all the way

[@thecanadianflatpicker]

Yes the d18 is just a tone monster

[@Nour01]

Gibson ❤

[@thecanadianflatpicker]

Yes !!!!