Sony Fx30 vs RED Komodo | Which one is better?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 ноя 2023
- Fx30 Course - riley-fx30.thinkific.com/cour...
__
Affiliate links:
Sony Fx30: amzn.to/3VK2CTF
Sony a7siii: amzn.to/3tiXJ4J
Atomos Ninja V: amzn.to/33k3q7G
Ninja V with SSD: amzn.to/3teVPlH
Rode Video Micro: amzn.to/2QWsqzo
Black Pro Mist Filter: amzn.to/2TmJCPA
Sony 24-70 GM: amzn.to/3vuSMYu
Sony 70-300 G: amzn.to/3fTOdjE
Hosa stereo break out cable: amzn.to/3nMtmT0
Saramonic Smart rig: amzn.to/2SqMudM
Favorite Gimbal: amzn.to/3bVsQgD
__
Here are a few of my other projects you might enjoy:
The Welder | Guinea-Bissau Documentary: • The Welder | Guinea-Bi...
Portrait of Guinea-Bissau: • Portrait of Guinea-Bis...
The Clinic | Congo Documentary: • The Clinic | Congo Doc...
What I learned in the Congo: • What I learned in the ...
* I receive a small commission at no extra charge to you for purchases made through the affiliate links 
Кино
I need a little help. I put my fx30 in video mode and I can't leave the iso in automatic. what am I wrong?
With your skill set bro, it doesn’t make a difference what you shoot with. Your passion for what you do will always translate to the screen. 🫡🎥
I appreciate that!! Thank you!
Great video Riley!
Thanks Nick!!
after owing the Komodo for 3 years I sold it for two FX30's, for me it was an amazing switch, but its not the same situation for everyone
Interesting! I bet having a 2nd matching camera made a difference!
@@RileyEndicotthow easy(?) to match RED or maybe you shoot the other way match RED to Sony? You said you use RED A cam, Sony B cam... do you find yourself jumping through hoops? Slog is so particular to expose for...
I love that you put komodo footage in this one, love it! I would love to see shaky cam to see the global shutter in its glory
Thanks!! I don’t shoot a ton of high action/super shaky content but when I do you’ll be the first to know 😁
@@RileyEndicott thank you so much💖
Great job! Thanks
Thank you!
Good vlog and I notice that your red video got lots of noise because of low lights?
What are your thoughts on the FX30 ProRes RAW vs the Komodo R3D RAW? I was kind of dissapointed that the FX30 has no extra recoverable DR compared to Log and no way to change WB in ProRes RAW.
Yeah. R3D is also 16 bit vs PRR is 12 bit. The Fx30’s raw also comes with a 4.7k windowing of the 6k sensor and introduces a fair amount of noise (the fx30 has good built in noise reduction). I personally won’t be using the external raw options on the fx30 much and almost exclusively shoot in R3D on my Komodo. It’s nice to have on the fx30 but i don’t think it creates a ton of advantages.
With new versions of davinci resolve and using x intra on sony, you can modify wb and ISO as if it was RED Raw 👌
Always fun to see Tacoma :)
I think the FX 30 can hold its’ own against the Red in terms of dynamic range - the global shutter is great on the Red for those who need it, but global shutters do decrease dynamic range for current sensor technology …
Great video! I would suggest either side chaining your vocals to the music, or to lower the music levels because it can overpower your voice.
quite annoying first 2 min of the video.
Agreed
How much horsepower is the Komodo tho👀
I am currently owning the Canon R7 and the OG Red Komodo, I am tempting to sell them both and get the R3 instead! Tempting to go with Sony but just not convinced with the color and the fact that they pump new camera every year (or almost!)
Yeah. Sony is quick to release new cameras on their consumer level but the their “pro” video cameras like the fx3 and fx6 have been out for a few years and don’t look like they are going anywhere. But it also sounds like you have a pretty good set up already! 🙂
Good work
Thank you!!
10/10 title. You got me to click!
16 bit raw vs 10 bit… you can match them if you expose everything correctly on set. Otherwise they are not even close
Most people can't tell the difference between 10 bit and higher. Unless you're filming for a movie theater release or intend on releasing a 4k bluray of your film then the end result between the Sony and Red will be very similar as compression from RUclips or other streaming platforms like Netflix, Hulu, etc tend to zap out the quality and dynamic range right out of your video. I find it funny when RUclips content creators invest in expensive Red or Blackmagic gear when far cheaper cameras would get the job done.
You’re definitely right. The red footage is so much more flexible!
@@03chrisvthe recording in higher bit depths is purely for post production
@@03chrisvthat’s because their realities begin and end in a cell phone screen
Dci and xavc-s are not pro res equivalents. Yes with the new davinci update and some transcoding in catalyst you can get a psuedo raw file but yea that's still not pro res
XAVCS-I is a 422 10 bit intra-frame codec the same as pro res is. Pro res is different from pro res raw :)
@@RileyEndicott ah ok thanks for clarifying that
Of course!
Sony is/was the most cursed camera for it's colour science, but to my eyes fx30 has far far better colour science than RED.
Red looks like smartphones' videos with extra sharpness and contrast.
Sony is looking organic like film rather than digital.
Sony’s color science has improved significantly but to say that red’s is like a smartphone is just silly 😂 Everyone has their own preferences but red is definitely my favorite color science
👍 Red Komodo A FX30 B cam set up.. Any projects with cuts to share ?
@@RileyEndicott I have to respect your choice 🙏🤣
stop drinking and smoking dude. you are the only person in the world to ever say that!
@@bmefilms6879 Never ever have tried any 🍷 or 🚬
Monstro is losing to Venice and Komodo is losing to FX Series, this the fact.
Comparison is the thief of joy just create
Indeed it is
Nice comparison. I like the C70 as a compliment to the Komodo. Probably should consider a Nikon Z8 😅
Yeah I bet that’s an awesome combo! Haha yeah that might be the move eventually 😎
If I had $10k just lying around...
The only time I felt the necessity of 4k when I saw the 'Secret life of Walter Mitty' skate boarding scene on 55' tv.
For new filmmakers Fx30 is the gift from God. Cause they are not going to film outdoor High resolution drone shots or high budget action sequences.
From this video id have to say Komodo cinema look all the way over the FX30 footage.
i was more impressed using Fuji Xh2s and new xs20 . That sensor was rly good and close to cinema cameras
Not agreeing with you on the Pro Res internal comment about each camera. What is imposter syndrome or any other syndrome that you mention?
Well the Komodo shoots pro res internally and the fx30 shoots XAVCS-I which is an intra-frame 10 bit 422 codec (exactly what pro res is). So they both shoot a pro res equivalent codec internally :)
The biggest weakness of the Sony codec is that internally they are 10bit - a bit less flexible in post- using an external recorder you can get 12 bit out of the FX 30.
@@RileyEndicott Well you don't lower the codec used in the Fx3 to compare the two cameras. Internally the Komodo records red raw and the FX3 doesn't come close to that internally.
@@RileyEndicott I get your point but no need to knock down what one camera can do to make the other look the same.
I’m not knocking one down. I’m pointing out that they both share a useful feature. ProRes is one of the few codecs that doesn’t require transcoding for broadcast work. It means the Komodo can get used on a lot of productions that don’t have the post budget to deal with R3D raw. Both cameras can fit into those work flows. It’s a good similarity for them both to have :)
ok please stop!
😂
😂😂😂😂😂
wow, great gear shilling!
Nice video. video quality is superb. but you have to work on Audio. your voice is boxy and thin. simply it's not good. it sounds like Diety or Boya Microphone.
Great video brotha , I’m definitely on the verge of grabbing a red Komodo and also have a fully rigged fx 30 so I’m definitely not going to sale and use them as a team thanks to you 🫡 lol
Happy to help! I’m definitely happy to have both! 😁
The only time I felt the necessity of 4k when I saw the 'Secret life of Walter Mitty' skate boarding scene on 55' tv.
For new filmmakers Fx30 is the gift from God. Cause they are not going to film outdoor High resolution drone shots or high budget action sequences.