An excellent insight iin to the current economic , social and political scenario! Yes! We need to debate and discuss! Thank you for your valuable thoughts!
Very pertinent questions raised here. We need to see more such discussions which when viewed by the current govt, and positively acted upon, should result in all-round change for the better. On a personal note, missing Parakala's Mid Week Matters.
Nice to see you back with MG ! Missed this talk because YT alogaritham did not pop it up ! Midweek does matter to all os here and therefore let's have Deccan Discussion at the weekends and the Midweek on Wednesdays ! Hopefully your travels were liberating and refreshing ! Please keep up the stellar job !
It gives some sort of positivity when we listen to such learned people otherwise the present scenario is really very very disturbing.I could listen to Mr Prabhakar after a long break.Anyways always would love to know his point of view
What an enlightening discussion between two eminent economists. We are certainly on the path to a majoritarian society, where other communities could be reduced to second-hand citizens. The thought of one religion, one language is worrisome for several people. Our opposition parties, alas, are groping in the dark, can't find a common minimum programme to agree on or a leader amongst themselves. In that scenario, if the current dispensation decides on 'Parties Todo' to form Governments in non-BJP ruled States, there is not even a weak cry from amongst our opposition. After Maharashtra, Goa is the latest example. Of course, in the latter case, Goa was already under the BJP but with a wafer-thin majority. So, the move to buy out Congress legislators. And the sad truth is that this is all considered legal! Obviously, it doesn't suit the Government to amend the existing law, to make it water-tight right now. Later, perhaps, when most of the "elected" legislators will belong to the current dispensation. 😥
This is the way to retain power by any means. Never mind the cost ti country n it's people. The people too unfortunately feel that we are on the right path.
"A nation of equals" well said Mr.Guruswamy. But, can it happen? In view of the fact that certain political parties have a vested interest in creating divisions and inequalities..
Hats off to Mr. Prabhakar. Only question Sir,can you peacefully stay together at home with your wife? If so both of you are probably the best couple alive.
Valid points expressed. One language, one religion imposition to divide Indian people instead of binding except for political advantages. Freebees given to States which are not contributing as much as they received and suppression of some States corporates and benefiting only few corporates of some States only also because of partisans politics. Discussions need to bring the truth out to open eyes of politicians and their supporters or some hypocrites of States ready to praise power
Thankyou for this insightful , thought provoking discussion. Where do go from here. How do we get out of this trap, where only 1 percent of the population is benefitting
Central government and the double engine states reflect the deterioration of federalism when the States heads and chief ministers are changed and ministers installed at the whims and fancies of the center, though the state legislature is independently elected body and the state people should decide who should be what. It was a trickle pre 2014, now it's midnight moves in a flood and from print media next day do we realize an event has happened.
What is the economic impact on the southern states after the merger of State Bank of Hyderabad, State Bank of Travancore, State Bank of Mysore, State Bank of Maharashtra etc. with the State Bank of India.
One language? That's what split Pakistan. The West Pakistan wanted to impose Urdu on the Bengali speaking East Pakistan. What is the BJP planning for Bharat?
Interesting but fake theory by leftist historians. If that was the reason & the love for Bangla language was so strong, then why did East Pakistan split from Bengal province in 1947 in the first place? Why didn't the language of Bangla unite the two halves of Bengal?
Also a farmer is charged 12% interest on his loans whereas a car loan is charges 7/8% Is not the farmer subsidising the car owners at 7 or 8 percent interest? That's for banks to declare.
india will be best when Tamil Nadu/Kerala the south are Independent Countries. As will reunion of Greater Bangla. West and Bangladesh. NE. Kashmir/Khalistan. As well the cow belt for rss and hindutva.. Germany/France/Italy/Spain/Greece.......separate countries part of of a union. UK can leave no conflict.
Current geographical and political boundaries of Sub Continent are not reasonable. South India, North India and East India are three separate entities, we have been saying that religion is not the only binding factor, so current India is basically three countries with so many inequalities.
Gentlemen a union is by choice never forced. GST is going to destroy the union. It should have been a state tax. Only income tax should be a tax of the centre. This would have resulted in more employment because the center has incentive.
....and also the moot point ...who got the most of the pie of that eight lakh crore?... while getting loans from banks written off and those who got those assets at throwaway prices.
India needs transparency in currency distribution by implementing digital currency no cash. And salaries should be regualed. Even unemployed old age pension and universal basic minimum income and free health care and free education should be implemented. Everything should be done through digital.
The whole thing has been more talk rather than any positive suggestion. Can the two summarize in specific well articulated itemized points how things are now and what they want them to be instead talking in generalities, it looked more like the articulation of the views of Sonia-Rahu lINC
The only suggestion from South for the development of North is that 1.stop all defense expenditure apporx 4 to 5 lacs crores. 2. Send 20 thousand brahmin priest to each side of border ie., pak and china border 3. So that they will become 4 to 5 priest per km of border. 4. So that they will perform shanti pooja and all types of poojas as specified in vedas, so that they can change the mindset of pak and china army and politicians as the change wrong signals of raasi's which are no of light years away from earth. 5. Use that budget for the development of north, mostly hindi belt. 6. As a hindu i have full confidence on our vedas, brahmins priest they can achieve anything based on vedas
2 self proclaimed intellectual fools exhibiting their not so hidden prejudices. Sowing seeds of disruption and exhibiting their Modi hatred in couched terms. These are the nincompoop types that have ruled India for 60 years and the results are there for all to see. It was not perfect before and it is not perfect now. In trying to create a North South divide, these two have failed to explain why Tamil Nadu's devolution has actually increased even though it is smack in the South. Stop this nonsense.
Not one word out of place or extra but to the point and rich in analysis ! His wife maybe FM, but it's clear that Modi did not have access to a brilliant pair like this nor does he have the capacity to understand or recognise such resources unlike a,RajivG, PVNR, MMS or SoniaG ! Ticked all boxes on a subject that needs the closest attention ! Well done !
Tamilnadu's Devolution 😂. Have you checked on GDP, GST, HDI, Mortality rate and several other factors of the states of India. They have been and are in the Top 3 in all the parameters. May be it's time for people to watch anything other than Navika Nair, Rahul, Shivshankar and Arnab 😁
Sir, admire ur stands in the present political and economic situations. 🙏🙏🌹🌹
We are missing your scathing but factual insights and commentary on the country's politics Mr Parakala. Please don't delay too long!
Agree with you and appreciate your concerns.
Dr Prabhakar, missing your midweek videos. Look forward to hearing your views on the developments in the country.
Indeed. Discrimination against d hardworking Southern States in India is legendary. This must not be allowed to continue.
Missed your valuable and insightful mid-week matters.
Very interesting Sir's
Missing mid week matters Sir ....ps resume......and soon....👍🙏
change needed in 2024 to save democracy.
An excellent insight iin to the current economic , social and political scenario! Yes! We need to debate and discuss! Thank you for your valuable thoughts!
Sir, waiting for your Midweek matters ...
Midweek M maybe stopped for reason known to them.
It was good to hear though.
Very pertinent questions raised here. We need to see more such discussions which when viewed by the current govt, and positively acted upon, should result in all-round change for the better.
On a personal note, missing Parakala's Mid Week Matters.
.
A nice platform
At last
Thank you
Waiting for Midweek Matters...
The south has been discriminated in every field and it's industrial groups suppressed
Nice to see you back with MG !
Missed this talk because YT alogaritham did not pop it up !
Midweek does matter to all os here and therefore let's have Deccan Discussion at the weekends and the Midweek on Wednesdays !
Hopefully your travels were liberating and refreshing ! Please keep up the stellar job !
Discussion is democracy - well said!
It gives some sort of positivity when we listen to such learned people otherwise the present scenario is really very very disturbing.I could listen to Mr Prabhakar after a long break.Anyways always would love to know his point of view
What an enlightening discussion between two eminent economists.
We are certainly on the path to a majoritarian society, where other communities could be reduced to second-hand citizens.
The thought of one religion, one language is worrisome for several people.
Our opposition parties, alas, are groping in the dark, can't find a common minimum programme to agree on or a leader amongst themselves. In that scenario, if the current dispensation decides on 'Parties Todo' to form Governments in non-BJP ruled States, there is not even a weak cry from amongst our opposition. After Maharashtra, Goa is the latest example. Of course, in the latter case, Goa was already under the BJP but with a wafer-thin majority. So, the move to buy out Congress legislators.
And the sad truth is that this is all considered legal! Obviously, it doesn't suit the Government to amend the existing law, to make it water-tight right now. Later, perhaps, when most of the "elected" legislators will belong to the current dispensation. 😥
Waiting for mid week matters Mr. Parakala Prabhakar .
A great debate by intellectuals of stature.
We need more discussion ,debates and participation in people's movement.So that ideas can be assimilated to the needs of common people.
We are missing Mid-week matters. Why have you stopped? Please resume
This is the way to retain power by any means. Never mind the cost ti country n it's people. The people too unfortunately feel that we are on the right path.
A very timely awakening call. People are ignorant.
A great video..
"A nation of equals" well said Mr.Guruswamy.
But, can it happen?
In view of the fact that certain political parties have a vested interest in creating divisions and inequalities..
Hats off to Mr. Prabhakar. Only question Sir,can you peacefully stay together at home with your wife? If so both of you are probably the best couple alive.
Eagerly waiting for your mid week matters
Mid Week ...matters most of us. Revive..
Valid points expressed. One language, one religion imposition to divide Indian people instead of binding except for political advantages. Freebees given to States which are not contributing as much as they received and suppression of some States corporates and benefiting only few corporates of some States only also because of partisans politics. Discussions need to bring the truth out to open eyes of politicians and their supporters or some hypocrites of States ready to praise power
What a tragedy 8000 views out of 1.4 billion, here lies the answer.
Thankyou for this insightful , thought provoking discussion. Where do go from here. How do we get out of this trap, where only 1 percent of the population is benefitting
Central government and the double engine states reflect the deterioration of federalism when the States heads and chief ministers are changed and ministers installed at the whims and fancies of the center, though the state legislature is independently elected body and the state people should decide who should be what. It was a trickle pre 2014, now it's midnight moves in a flood and from print media next day do we realize an event has happened.
What is the economic impact on the southern states after the merger of State Bank of Hyderabad, State Bank of Travancore, State Bank of Mysore, State Bank of Maharashtra etc. with the State Bank of India.
Yes a matter worthy to be discussed
I keep waiting for the midweek matters.Has it been discontinued .
Parakala Sir, when do you start mid week matters?
Same here waiting for too long
Me too 🙂
Me too
One language? That's what split Pakistan. The West Pakistan wanted to impose Urdu on the Bengali speaking East Pakistan. What is the BJP planning for Bharat?
Interesting but fake theory by leftist historians. If that was the reason & the love for Bangla language was so strong, then why did East Pakistan split from Bengal province in 1947 in the first place? Why didn't the language of Bangla unite the two halves of Bengal?
Good evening sir,
👏👏👏👍💙
Also a farmer is charged 12% interest on his loans whereas a car loan is charges 7/8% Is not the farmer subsidising the car owners at 7 or 8 percent interest? That's for banks to declare.
Respected Sir
Have you stopped your Midweek matters series?
india will be best when Tamil Nadu/Kerala the south are Independent Countries. As will reunion of Greater Bangla. West and Bangladesh. NE. Kashmir/Khalistan. As well the cow belt for rss and hindutva.. Germany/France/Italy/Spain/Greece.......separate countries part of of a union. UK can leave no conflict.
@Sivasubramanian Iyer are you having nightmares?
Mr Prabhakar
Where were you.. all these months?
What happened to Midweek Matters?
Are you safe?
South needs to get away from the north
Am wondering how Mr Parakala Prabakar and Finance minister Mrs Nirmala Seetharaman living together northpol and south pol😂
Education/Health/ justice /Freedom of religion no caste system nonsense.for progressive states. Is the answer
Do start mid week matters
Current geographical and political boundaries of Sub Continent are not reasonable. South India, North India and East India are three separate entities, we have been saying that religion is not the only binding factor, so current India is basically three countries with so many inequalities.
INDIA needs to be united.
@@pinakisinharay8411 I wish, but it is not possible.
Gentlemen a union is by choice never forced. GST is going to destroy the union. It should have been a state tax. Only income tax should be a tax of the centre. This would have resulted in more employment because the center has incentive.
Audio to be improved.
9:12 Intellectuals eating Fevicol about TG and AP partition.
just loan out money to common people. Indian people are so hardworking they don't waste that money.
....and also the moot point ...who got the most of the pie of that eight lakh crore?... while getting loans from banks written off and those who got those assets at throwaway prices.
How Prabhakar's wife is on opposite view "All is Well"?
Yes. Really surprising.
India needs transparency in currency distribution by implementing digital currency no cash. And salaries should be regualed. Even unemployed old age pension and universal basic minimum income and free health care and free education should be implemented. Everything should be done through digital.
The whole thing has been more talk rather than any positive suggestion. Can the two summarize in specific well articulated itemized points how things are now and what they want them to be instead talking in generalities, it looked more like the articulation of the views of Sonia-Rahu lINC
Glad at least u think Sonia and Rahul have positive ideas...
The only suggestion from South for the development of North is that
1.stop all defense expenditure apporx 4 to 5 lacs crores.
2. Send 20 thousand brahmin priest to each side of border ie., pak and china border
3. So that they will become 4 to 5 priest per km of border.
4. So that they will perform shanti pooja and all types of poojas as specified in vedas, so that they can change the mindset of pak and china army and politicians as the change wrong signals of raasi's which are no of light years away from earth.
5. Use that budget for the development of north, mostly hindi belt.
6. As a hindu i have full confidence on our vedas, brahmins priest they can achieve anything based on vedas
CWKYSNAH (CHAI WALE KO YE SAMAJH NAHIN AATAA HAI)
Suggest solutions if you want the country to prosper. Mere Analysis leads to Paralysis 😂
Let Parakala Prabhakar enlighten his own wife she is taking some bullshit in the house...
He is covert of TDP
2 self proclaimed intellectual fools exhibiting their not so hidden prejudices. Sowing seeds of disruption and exhibiting their Modi hatred in couched terms. These are the nincompoop types that have ruled India for 60 years and the results are there for all to see. It was not perfect before and it is not perfect now. In trying to create a North South divide, these two have failed to explain why Tamil Nadu's devolution has actually increased even though it is smack in the South. Stop this nonsense.
Not one word out of place or extra but to the point and rich in analysis ! His wife maybe FM, but it's clear that Modi did not have access to a brilliant pair like this nor does he have the capacity to understand or recognise such resources unlike a,RajivG, PVNR, MMS or SoniaG !
Ticked all boxes on a subject that needs the closest attention ! Well done !
Tamilnadu's Devolution 😂. Have you checked on GDP, GST, HDI, Mortality rate and several other factors of the states of India. They have been and are in the Top 3 in all the parameters. May be it's time for people to watch anything other than Navika Nair, Rahul, Shivshankar and Arnab 😁
Mr Tbund get educated and don't screech from your backside.
Can you put down your credentials that you have the temerity to comment on intellects of such calibre!