UN's top court orders Israel to halt military operations in Rafah | BBC News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 май 2024
- The International Court of Justice has ruled that Israel must halt its military offensive in Rafah in southern Gaza.
South Africa had asked the ICJ to order it as an emergency measure, saying Israel’s actions in Rafah amount to a “genocidal” operation and threaten the survival of the Palestinian people.
The ICJ is the top UN court and can make legally binding rulings in disputes between countries, but has little way of enforcing its orders.
Israel has previously called South Africa's case "wholly unfounded", saying the Rafah offensive is key to defeating Hamas following the 7 October attacks, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 252 were taken to Gaza as hostages.
At least 35,800 Palestinians have been killed in the war since then, according to Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry.
Subscribe here: bit.ly/1rbfUog
For more news, analysis and features visit: www.bbc.com/news
#Israel #Gaza #BBCNews
Free USA from AIPAC!!!!
- 450 Palestinian villages were destroyed by the Colonialist Zio’nists to setup Isriael, 70 years ago.
- For last 70 years the criminal settlers kept pushing Palestinian people out till half of them left and the remaining half were pushed into congested areas like Gaza.
- Hundreds of civilians killed by Isriael every year.
- 30 children killed by Isriael in 2022.
- 200 civilians killed by Isriael in 2023, before the current conflict.
Why should Israel not be called as a mad colonialist occupier?
Then free the USA from any other committees as well, you antisemite!
Why does anyone think Hamas would stop its ambitions of destroying Israel? Why does anyone believe there are 35,000 casualties - the UN had to admit it does not have the names/bodies of 12,000 casualties, so it had to revise down its total causality numbers of woman and children by 50%.
Do they not understand the Islamic “Taqiyya appears in Sura 3:28:" ?
“Let not the believers take the unbelievers for friends; and whoever does this, shall have nothing to do with Allâh in any matter; unless you do this to protect yourselves from the unbelievers. Thus Allâh cautions you to have reverence only for him. To Allâh is destiny.”
in other words, in a time of war its encouraged to lie;
Regarding 3:28, Ibn Kathir writes, “… believers who in some areas or times fear for their safety from the disbelievers… are allowed to show friendship to the disbelievers outwardly, but never inwardly.” Ibn Kafthir quotes Muhammad‘s companion, Abu Ad-Darda’, who said “we smile in the face of some people although our hearts curse them"
@@SadaK-tr6dmIt belonged to the Hebrews for over 3000 years. Look at the map Israel is a dot on it compared to what the Muslims have. If the UN wants to get involved let them go clean out the terror group HAMAS.
Evil Hamas the devil's advocates need to go.
free the world from Aipac
This is the most useless court ever,
It is the only court in the world that has some possibility to give justice to an occupied people. Who else can bring Israel to justice when the USA backs an occupation power to protect them from justice every time ?
No, it's not. It's a place for where nations can discuss instead of every country resorting directly to conflict. The UN is not the world police, and it shouldn't be.
@@phonephonersononly when you don't get your way
A tennis court has more authority and is much more meaningful.
South Africa's hypocrisy stinks to high heavens. It's laughable seeing an African country spearheading such move in the ICJ, whereas hundreds of biafrans are being massacred daily by Nigerian soldiers. How about the atrocities being committed in congo, South Sudan, the jihad in North Nigeria. fulani herdsmen menace. South Africa should look inward, if actually they want to be taken serious in the world stage
Justice for Hind Rajab,her family and those 2 paramedics💯
Lad reporting from Israel seems like someone talking from Israel's war cabinet ..
He probably is
Why they're not arresting Putin for war crimes
That's like telling a bully to stop beating up the kid once the victim has been buried!! A bit, Fekin late!!
It's like telling an army to stop destroying a terrorist organisation
What peaceful negotiating party should Israel speak to in Gaza precisely?
It's like humus say civilians don't exist only opposition and Palestinians 😮
Should Israel negotiate with Hezbollah? Hamas? PA which pays terrorists salaries (higher than average that doctors are paid in Gaza, go figure), PIJ? Lions Den? Fatah? Which group that represents the Palestinians should Israel speak to? Also, since we are on the subject, which group should all the Arab nations which don't allow Palestinians inside speak to? Same group?
Ok so Israel would stop the war in Rafah and who will make sure Hamas won't rearmed. This court is a joke! Israel is going to destroy Hamas in any price! It is a consensus in all parts of the Israeli sosciaty. On october 7th Hamas opend case with the Israeli public themselves.
UN useless
Hasbulla agent
Its not useless, its controlled by the US and its minion the UK. So anything to do with peace or stability is veto'd and many countries and the UN itself is scared of sanctions if they go against them.
Actually doing its job instead of being a USA mouthpiece
@@yungerK9It'll be vetoed/sanctioned into oblivion unfortunately.
Humus Just like them then komrade 😂
That is about as effective as a loud fart.
lol
It actually isn't. The next step is to have an arrest warrant for Bibi which means he can't set foot in any civilized country under the threat of arrest.
Sadly you are right 👍
I must have missed the part where the court ordered Hamas to release all hostages, make restitution to the families who lost their members to Hamas and to the State of Israel, and the part where the court demands Hamas make formal representation to the court explaining why they use civilian Palestinian Arabs as cover for their war and terrorism activities against Israel, after explaining why they constantly terrorise Israel.
Well my farts get a lot of attention! Will keep on trying to change the world
Now who is going to enforce this?
Nobody, the ICC is a joke
It's not enforceable
The countries that back the icj? That's like half the world + a lot of the countries not in the icj don't support isreal and might want to tighten relationships with Arab nations and still arrest them
@Gigi-irish What other ICC court rulings have ever affected politics inside those countries?
@@lb9029 If nothing else it has opened the eyes of many in both Western and non-West countries. Fewer brainwashed people can only be a good thing.
To some extent it piles pressure on the US as they like to spread their idiotic mantra of "freedom and democracy" as they go about bombing places. It might make that a bit harder for them
Isreal never border or adhered to any order by world body.....
Israel is isolated dude. That's serious 😅
@@aungaisum8654oh no surprise Israel were called to isolated long ago ,God called Abraham to isolated from the evil , to be the light of the world !
@@user-ty8zq6pc5e what drugs are you on, Israel and Zionism is pure evil. True orthodox Jews do support Israel or Zionism. Where is God commanding Jews to return to that land. I can guarantee the majority of Jews are secular in Israel and don't even adhere to God's laws because if they did they wouldn't be supporting or allowing the alphabet community to do sin.
And you will learn to love it.
I’m glad Israel will ignore them. They have the right to defend them selves.
The UN never stopped USA or Russia
Luckily, Israel is neither of them. Especially in terms of power and influence.
@@Erebos931Isreal has a major influence in the Middle East. Along with influence they have military capabilities far superior than most in that region thanks to US military hardware.
@@Erebos931Where do you get your information? Hindustan times?
STOPPING USA MEANS STOPPING ISRAEL ...
@ibitefingers3380 I always thought they had the most influence but after the last 7 months it's changing. Thank God 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽 thank you the courts have spoken.
They be throwing that anti semitic to everything they disagree with. At some point it will have no meaning , just a meme phrase 😊
Is hamas that have that speech!!!
Terrorist Organization Hamas: 👀
An extremely important point.
Israeli politicians and too many citizens have been using the anti-Semitic excuse to justify anything and everything Israel does or doesn't do for Israel's benefit. That and the excuse of referring to the Holocaust.
Therefore Israel has the right to trigger wars with Palestinians, colonize what's left of Palestinian lands, attack and kill to colonize ...
Israel's 'Manifest Destiny' of Palestine.
Just like America's Manifest Destiny with Native peoples.
Both used since the Zionist (Jewish Nationalism) displacement and murder of 800,000+ Palestinians in 1948 to create the state of Israel.
Yeah. Just like the term "Islamophobic".
It already has no meaning
Will be ignored by the champions of human rights and democracy
Does the British government believe in Law and Order specifically International Law and International rules based order? Are we seriously going to carry on licensing weapons to this scene of death and destruction.?
@@eliqfor1bull
@@eliqfor1 They are planing villas in Gaza, is this "defense" too?
Yes uk and us recognize the international law when it convenient to them. They are shameless and heartless 😊
@@eliqfor1 The only party responsible for this more than plausible genocide is Is ra hell. The illusion of self defence evaporated months ago. In international law those subject to a brutal illegal occupation have the right to resist that illegal brutal occupation.
@@eliqfor1 Blah blah. NAtional ZIonism on full display.
Reporter emphasize on the number of delivered food-truck, but the food has to be bought. 😂🤣 So what's the point. They are vandalising all types of aid. But bragging about commercial food.
Its common for the abused to become abuser
45 states in the united states of america have child marriage laws
Zionist Jews abuse the Orthodox Jews.. so in that context, you are right.
Is it , and is it here ?
@@gpac8147 Jews will turn on each other one day.. just wait!
@@gpac8147 yes and yes
South Africa: the victim has become the defender
Israel: the victim has become the abuser
No abuse only lies
@@JamesCzerwinski-zk4qudeluded is what you are
South Africa about to hold 'elections' 😂
SA is no victim, they are overseeing a genocide of their own. Only someone from there would now....
@@Stevemcqueen808every democratic nation hold elections.
Just stop the Dam war 🙌 🙌 🙌 😍
Not war … it’s gencoide by Isreal .. thousands of kids murdered in Gaza by Isreal
Agree war is ugly
Hamas doesn’t want to unfortunately
@@MrMustang13 Israel can leave Gaza at any time.
THEY SAID STOP THE WAR NOT END THE WAR ...
This is the most useless court ever,.
Intervention would do the trick, but yeah, purely symbolic lmao
Kangaroo court
"Hundres and hundres of COMMERCIAL trucks went in but people can't afford the food" What in the name of god is wrong with you?!
An Israeli joke of course.
Israeli protestors have been stopping trucks and vandalizing them. Stealing the food and aid.
IDF looted people of their valuables in check points when they urged people to go south. Wonder why they can't afford food.
Yes, Israel is feeding the very people who supported Hamas. They have also provided shelter and a safe place for nearly a million Palestinian's, the very people who helped create Hamas. This free food is not being distributed for free, it's being sold via merchant's to the Palestinian population via Hamas and the UN's own agency UNRWA. Palestinians who have no money are only receiving one meal a day and little water and it is they who ironically the UN are using to claim that starvation is rampant, the Western legacy press do the rest to prop up the lie. It's a true reflection of just how corrupt and morally bankrupt the UN and Hamas actually are and the only reason they are getting away with it is credited to the press core. Absolutely disgraceful.
US should support the ICC
Always on the wrong side
(US should support the ICC) US is not a signatory to the ICC. They are smarter than you.
@@MikeAhern-199 Wow, what can I say to such an intelligent retort? You really showed me...what I just said. Read better, man.
@@MikeAhern-199 free 🇺🇲 USA 🇺🇲 from AIPAC Z10gs like u
So they ruled
What’s confusing about this whole situation is that it’s possible to both condemn the Hamas attacks _and_ think Israel has been more than heavy-handed in its response to October 7th. It’s possible to support Palestinian freedom from Israeli state oppression without being antisemitic just as it’s possible to support Israel against Islamist aggression without being anti-Muslim. These 2 things are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Too many folk are either one thing or t’other in this conflict when it’s possible to be both/and.
Indeed. But sadly this is too complicated for many, many people in the black & white world they wish to inhabit.
I agree and I don't find this confusing at all. I'd take it one step further and say we can be against the Israeli government without being against Israelis, and so on. Like any country, the government doesn't necessarily represent what the population wants, and we know in this case that many Israelis are against Netanyahu.
Unfortunately, a lot of people have a hard time walking and chewing gum at the same time, are ignorant of the situation, or profoundly indoctrinated.
Bump all that nuance and critical thinking you just applied...
You anti Semitic.
Argument won
I couldn't agree more. And it especially baffles me when people claim they're good at critical thinking, yet clearly choose only one side in this conflict. I'd especially expect more from students, when it comes to that trait. I'm quietly hoping that the silent majority is actually capable of criticizing both, but I'm not sure it's true. Maybe they just don't care.
@@lb9029 students that criticise hamas or Palestine get cancelled by their peers and have to stay silent out of fear. Mob rule is a reality. The most vocal people are usually also the most extreme & it seems like most moderates simply don't want to speak for fear of being cancelled by one side
Have they insisted that all hostages be released ?
Yes, it’s in the report…
They have no power over Hamas Either
Stop the genocide
Stop the lies. There is no genocide. It's war. Innocent people get killed in wars. Was Hiroshima genocide? NO.
Hamas can surrender and leave.
Learn what a genocide is. Then come back and repost cause u a sheep fool. And for the record. Tik tok is not a factual textbook. You may actually have to read and form on opinion. Are u capable of doing that without mommy and daddy helping?
@jameshazel1495Israeli citizens and police destroying aid trucks from Jordan is of course not genocide it is Nazism.
River to sea
All is
ISRAELI
🇮🇱
Islamic Criminal court chief Karem Khan, Islamic Court of Justice chief Nawaf Salam. You think Israel will halt with those names? Why Europe create such chiefs?
Europe is moron. Very disgusting continent under terrorist.
The Court has made their decision, now let them enforce it
I dont think the Israeli leader would agree with this UN or United Nothing, they have the total right to defend itself from all evil that tries to destroy them..
Here are the current members of the UN Human Rights Council, most of which are countries that abuse human rights: • Iraq • Cuba • China • Qatar • Angola • Burundi • Pakistan • Venezuela • DR Congo • Afghanistan • Saudi Arabia • United Arab Emirates
Well said!
sure lets now move to discredit the court because we don't agree with it. classic! and expected
I think this is the president speaking and he's from Lebanon, you're 100% correct, how on earth can you trust a "united nations" when it's basically run by the League of Arab Nations 😂 this very event in ordering Israel to stop their mission is about to show us where the actual power lies.
@@niageo876the court has discredited itself in aligning itself in favour allowing terrorists to continue to reign in Gaza, the biggest violation in human rights in the entire situation is hamas and their charter that every citizen is a valid martyr.
@@niageo876 UN has lost their credibility long time ago... Now they are only showing us their True colors! And I am grateful for that...Only reassures what I suspected!
Only the Israeli army can release the hostages.
Not a ridiculous court order.
You didn't see thos kind of coverage and condemnation durjng the Syrian war. Why was the murder of 600,000 Muslims less important? Im genuinely curious.....
In Syria, the president Assad was killing his own people. Purely domestic conflict with outside influence.
What a complete waste of time and energy, it’s going to be really embarrassing for the court when the Israelis tell them to get lost and there’s nothing they can do
Then where is human rights for thousands of children in Gaza that became amputees as a result of the Israeli brutal airstrikes? 🤷🏻♀️ Those children are in bad condition forever and they can't have their organs back again, those children became disabled forever
Hamas and its supporters are 100% to blame
can you go join them and stop complaining?
noisy insect.
@@jerrymiller9039not Israel for launching the missiles? Lol ok jew.
@@user-mw4eq5mq4bIsrael has a right to defend itself against kids with rockets. The age of the finger pulling the trigger doesnt affect its potency
@@jaymadre5996 yeah? Starting to sound like a real fascist.
Rubbish.
I don't know South Africa and the ICJ cares this much about humanity with Russia killing civilians everyday in Ukraine without any provocation. Why didn't the ICJ give a timeline for the release of Hostages? A clear portray of double standard.
I feel bad when I see the death of innocent Palestinian civilians. After all, why does this oppression not end? The only desire of the people and children there is to live. They have the right to live. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Whole world is wrong. Only innocent Boys are US UK and Israel according to BBC😂
Arabs are not the whole world, although they spreaded in Europe and became very loud and noisy
Great Decision, now make sure its implementation
Where was the UN court and their rulings when Hamas attacked Israel
Israel: we don't care.😂
Israeli gov is pure evil.
Israel: That's very anti-Semitic of you. How dare you!
YES they don't care... But who created Israel? the UN!
If they want to destroy the very institution that forced the creation of their state... is up to them.
The Levant history changed hundred times since the Pharaohs, Greeks, Persians, Romans ... They take for granted 75 years of government in the area and now think they can destroy what validate their state haha
@@shlomoalSouth Africa🇿🇦 is teaching the Nazis a lesson.
STOP the GENOCIDE #FreePalestineNow 🇵🇸
@@flavio1243
Shut up....
You are to be blamed committing Holocaust Against Jews.
Forgot about that??
Now you people are pretending to be innocent 😐😐
It’s pretty clear at this point that these men with napkins in their shirts don’t have any real authority
Bunch of arrogant pussies
That's absolutely ridiculous
The hair on the judges from south Africa tho...
@patrickodea6500 They can't personally implement their ruling, the majority of the world's countries will be obligated to support the ruling, which means there will be a lot more pressure on Israel. Which means that if Israel doesn't stop, they will be a pariah state. No one will want to do business with them
It's clear they are idiots
You can't order others to do anything without an army or money. Or both.
"Israel, you are allowed to fight and defeat Hamas but don't go to Rafah🤡" 🙄
Why....what do every one hide in Rafah...what skeletons are hide there.. it MUST BE GO TO THE OPEN.....
Are we still pretending that Israel cares about the hostages?
Are you still a dumbass?
The UN is not a Nation. It is chartered as a UNITED NATION. And so for the ICC to be a court of the UN or not is anomalous.
You shouldn’t be telling the people that making an obscenity out of themselves by supporting the messaging and banner of terrorists is a good thing
Israël is undefendable on this one.
We all knew their revenge would go too far.
And affect innocent civilians.
Who will now be tomorrow's "terrorists" (Quote marks because Israël is creating them, so it is a tragedy)
fighting back occupation isnt terrorism
Yet all amarican politicians don't seem to see how ridiculous they look still trying to defend it
@@endlesspera8808 how come Muslim Arabs in Israel have more rights than Muslim Arabs in any of the 20+ Arab nations?
Nothing more dangerous than radical Judaeic terrorism financed and given impunity by the US
Bollox 🤡🤡
First off the UN top court likewise all other UN top courts has no teeth
I guess you are too young to remember when they arrested, tried, and hanged Slobodan Milosevic, president of Serbia.
@@samsmith2635 because the USA and UK supported them
They has no hard Power, but Soft Power.
Why the Biden administrations is desperate to sanction ICC if they don't have any power?
YES, they have... The Hague institutions and the UN, validate the Western World Order, more than the Global South it's the interest of the West to protect these institutions, because without it, there's NO Basic International Law.
If the West want to dissolve the current International Law to support a Genocide in Gaza, is up to them.
@samsmith2635 At the order of America and the West. For Israel, that will not gonna happen, America, and the Brits will oppose anything that will compromise the security of Israel.
REMEMBER: ICC, ICJ, UN don't has teeth... BUT.
They has no hard Power, but Soft Power.
Why the Biden administrations is desperate to sanction ICC if they don't have any power?
YES, they have... The Hague institutions and the UN validate the Western World Order. More than the Global South it's the interest of the West to protect these institutions, because without it, there's NO Basic International Law.
If the West want to dissolve the current International Law to support a Genocide in Gaza, is up to them.
Chronological. War started at which date. Date of complaint? Filing, collecting data? Date of Court ICJ?
There is no war in South Africa. But it is collapsing. The ICJ should ask South Africa to clear the sewer going past people's front door.
SS still lives comfortably ?
🫡
Nein!
They helped create NATO.
Look up the organisers of operation Gladio.
@@codswallop164 O`pss !
In humus
Not falling for it Schlomo. Get off your propoganda department PC and fight your own war.
If everybody that critics your actions are anti semetic, or liars you should start considering that you are a liar yourself.
SA ANC GAV IS A DISGRACE TO ALL THE PEOPLE AF SA
Only israel can decide when its end...thats the only reality
- 450 Palestinian villages were destroyed by the Colonialist Zio’nists to setup Isriael, 70 years ago.
- For last 70 years the criminal settlers kept pushing Palestinian people out till half of them left and the remaining half were pushed into congested areas like Gaza.
- Hundreds of civilians killed by Isriael every year.
- 30 children killed by Isriael in 2022.
- 200 civilians killed by Isriael in 2023, before the current conflict.
Why should Israel not be called as a mad colonialist occupier?
Were the children throwing stones at them?
@@janetnyamongo Why are the European Colonialist settlers there in the Palestine in the first place?
What for Palestinians to vote then back in and for it all happen again let Israel sort their own problems out, Israel needs to do what’s best for them and their families and futures
Order all you want, not going to stop them
Objection your honor, if you have never been in a combat zone, you don’t know what you are talking about.
Thank goodness they are just people around the world who care about humanity and human rights.
Why is that BBC journalist acting as an Israeli government spokesman? Disgraceful
I was thinking the same thing
Paul Adams. Shame on you
I thought the same 😅
Absolute joke
Saying netanyahu is not a war criminal is like saying there are no nazis in the British parliament.
can the ICJ even enforce these orders? or are they just a formality
Why no ruling in Syria , soudan , ukraine , iran , egypt ....
There’s a arrest warrant for Putin… why the hypocrisy from yourself
Because Israel is getting armed by the "free" world against civilians. Your examples are in totally different circumstances.
You forgot Afghanistan, Iraq and Yemen. Why are Bush and Blair not behind bars? That was your question, right?
It's all a bunch of b.s
Exactly funny world
The judges have clarified that this doesn’t mean they have to halt their operations in Rafah, read the wording.
That's the israeli reading... not the world reading....
International Court of Injustice
These pinguins are so funny, they have eaten so many fish. Are they stupid? I don't know.
😂😂😂😂
"The Palestinian struggle is not just a cry for justice. It’s a blistering battle for the most fundamental human rights that every living soul on this planet should inherit by birthright. It’s an unyielding resistance against the oppressive, suffocating grip of occupation and the callous denial of the most basic human dignity ... The battle for justice in Palestine is not merely a political struggle. It's an elemental moral battle ... If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. I implore every person of conscience, regardless of their origins or beliefs, to stand steadfast with the Palestinian people in their unwavering quest for justice."
- attributed to Malcolm X
complete bull
@@juliam235 I agree. This person clearly isn't in reality. It's sad to hear the same rhetoric preached by "well-meaning basement activist" with no real knowledge.
I stand with Israel 💙
This actually made me laugh.
Palestinians and human rights?!
Where exactly go these "human rights" when Palestinians kill and torture innocent Israelis and other people who simply happen to be visiting Israel?
If Palestinians are oppressed then the word changed its meaning..
How DARE Israel take the guns and tunnels away from the POOR PALESTINIANS! Every person has a fundamental human right for a HOBBY!
You call the hamas/Palestinians moral..what was Oct. 7...your delusional. STRENGTH & BLESSINGS TO ISRAEL 🇮🇱 🙏 ❤️
The court didn't stop the British or the Americans going after Isis or Al-Qaeda. They haven't gone after Ukraine for fighting back when they were attacked by Russia. Isn't this double standards?
Yes, but only in regards to America and Britain. To them Israel is a puppet state anyway, and they can't stop Putin.
This is for those who ever support the Zionist Israel
Why don't you talk about the illegal settlements built on Palestinian Lands in West Bank? Why don't you talk about how they humiliate Palestinians on Israeli checkpoints? Why don't you talk about the United Nation resolutions that Israel don't comply with such as 1947 resolution 181 (II), partitioning Palestine into two States - one Arab and one Jewish - the independence of the Palestinian Arab State continued to be unjustly obstructed and the rights of Palestinians “flagrantly denied”. resolution 194 on Nov. 1948 The right of return of Palestinian refugees to Palestine? Resolution 242 in 1967 the illegal occupation of Israel to Palestinian Lands in West Bank? Resolution 904 in 1994 Protecting the Palestinians in the occupied territories from the Israelis after the Ibrahimic Mosque massacre? Why you are not talking about Dec 30 2022 United Nation Resolution against Israel at ICJ. 87 Country votes in favor including China and Russia against the illegal settlement and illegal occupation of Palestinian Lands and the Holy City of Jerusalem.
Why don’t you talk about The UN Security Council, for its part, responded to the Israeli decision to annex East Jerusalem, by issuing Resolution No. 478 on August 29, 1980, which included non-recognition of Israeli law regarding Jerusalem, and called on countries to withdraw their diplomatic missions from the city. Also Resolution No. 15/36 on October 28, 1981, declaring that any changes in the Jerusalem area are illegal and against international law, and that such actions are an obstacle to achieving just and comprehensive peace. UN Resolution 2334 issued on December 23, 2016, confirms that Israel’s establishment of settlements in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967 - including East Jerusalem - has no legal legitimacy, and demands that Israel immediately stop all settlement activities and not recognize any changes to the June 4 borders. /June 1967. UN Resolution in 1974 says in point #5 The Palestinian people have the right to regain their rights by all means in accordance with the United Nations Charter. It affirms the right of the Palestinian people to independence and sovereignty and the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination and the right to return to Palestine.
since the inception of the security council USA used the vote the vito 88 times and they vote 56 times out of 88 times in order to protect Israel from the vito. The superpower of the world in the past over 50 years used more than 65% of the votes to protect Israel and support them killing daily innocent Palestinian civilians.
After signing the Oslo Accords on September 13, 1993, the Palestinians promised by Israel , USA, EU, Russian and UN that the eastern part of Jerusalem would be their future capital, and the Palestinian leadership confirmed its firm position many times by saying, “There is no Palestinian state without East Jerusalem as its capital in accordance with the resolutions of international legitimacy and the peace initiative.” Arabic". Even the official American position supported the international position on occupied Jerusalem, which appeared in an American message of reassurances to the Palestinians in October 1991, in which it stated, “We do not recognize Israel’s annexation of East Jerusalem or its expansion of its municipal borders.”
Russia confirms that it recognizes West Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and East Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine, which was reconfirmed by a source in the Russian Foreign Ministry in December 2017.
However, the US Congress reversed the international position on October 23, 1995, when it issued a law stipulating the transfer of the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem and the necessity of recognizing “Jerusalem as the capital of the State of Israel.” The Two state solution is been shut and dead a long time ago. Benyamin Netanyahu bragged about how he has spoiled the Oslo accord.
I wonder Why are you playing the victim role? Israel always victimize itself?
I'm Palestinian and Israeli are killing us since 1947 and we never heard you talking about it and condemn Israel for killing innocent Palestinians. Why you speak about the reaction of the innocent Palestinians tortured daily by Zionist Israeli but never speak about the action of Israeli illegal occupation of Palestine that bring such reaction? Please come to Palestine and see for yourself how they treat Palestinians and tortured them. Please we invite you all to come and see the truth by yourself.
why can't UN stop Israeli Zionist killing innocent Palestinian Civilian mostly Children and women for 75 years? Why UN can't punish Israeli Zionist for violating more than 70 UN Resolution but destroyed Iraq for violating couple of UN Resolution? UN should ask the west why you consider Ukrainian defending their lands against Russian as freedom fighter but you consider Palestinian defending their Land against Israeli as Terrorist?
Do the Palestinian have the right to defend themselves because you always say Israel has the right to defend itself? Do the Palestinian have the right to defend themselves when Land was taken from them Homes were destroyed when daily innocent civilian Palestinian children’s and women were killed Palestinian homes were confiscated and demolished by Israeli and when UN Resolutions on Torture on ethnic cleansing against the Palestinian in Israel failed and so many other UN Resolution against Israel failed. did the Palestinian have the right to defend themselves when Israel Turn on and off Electricity stop the water stop food stop fuel stop medical Aid put Gaza on the biggest open-Air Prison for 16 years long long before October 7 attack by Hamas? You can’t say open Air Prison because you go to prison if you did something wrong. It is the biggest open concentration camp in the world.
if you claim Israel has a "right to self-defense" then shouldn't you also acknowledge Palestine's right to armed struggle against the occupying power? Armed resistance against the occupying power is a fact that is acknowledged by international humanitarian law conventions.
You are so ignorant about the facts on the ground. People in Gaza are living in subhuman conditions because of Zionist Israel.
Hamas was created in 1987 and Zionist Israel been killing innocent Palestinian Civilian since 1947. Palestinian since 1947 were crying to the world shouting to people like you to UN, EU, USA, Russia, China, .... etc. to help them and to stop the massacre of Palestinian by Israel Zionist to stop the catastrophe that started on 1947. Where were you from 1947 until 1987 when Israel Zionist killed innocent Palestinian and still killing them until today? No one helped the Palestinian or listened to them. Nobody cares about them for 75 years. Palestinian decided to stand up and defend themselves and on 1987 after they lost hope from the entire world to save them Hamas was born as REACTION to the ACTION of the Israeli Zionist against innocent Palestinian. Hamas is REACTION for the illegal ACTION of the Zionist Israel. What Hamas did in OCT 7 is happening to the Palestinians daily since 1947 for 75 years. Where were you and why you didn't condemn the killing of those innocent Palestinian for 75 years? What Hamas did is REACTION of the illegal ACTION of Zionist Israel. The ACTION is the illegal Occupation of Palestine by Israeli Zionist and the violation of more than 70 UN Resolution by Israel Zionist. End up the illegal ACTION of Zionist Israel they will be no REACTION. The Problem with the western Media you do condemn the REACTION of the Palestinian and forget about the illegal ACTION of Zionist Israel. Do you condemn the Nakba in 1947 the Ethnicity Genocide of Palestinian by Israeli?
“They used to say Palestinians fight like heroes, now they say heroes fight like Palestinians.”-Norman Finkelstein
What about the bedrock rule of international Law, no taking Land by Force? No nation no power is allowed to take neighbors territory by force? When Russia does it, we are pretty clear but when Israel does it specially in the West Bank taking Palestinian lands by force the western world became Blind and forget about the bedrock rule of international Law?
Haifa Massacre 1937 2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937 3. Haifa Massacre 1938. 4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939 5. Haifa Massacre 1939 6. Haifa Massacre 1947 7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947 8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947 9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947 10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947 11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947 12. Tantura Massacre 1948 13. Jaffa Massacre 1948 14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956 15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967 16. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982 17. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990 18. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994 19. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002 20. Gaza Massacre 2008-09 21. Gaza Massacre 2012 22. Gaza Massacre 2014 23. Gaza Massacre 2018-19 24. Gaza Massacre 2021 25. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing.
Question for the Christian. As Christian do you have the right to make Bethlehem as your territory , because 2000 years ago that was the origin of your religion?
If Palestinian land belongs to Israel from 3000 years ago I hope Italians won't want to restore the Roman Empire !!!!
DONT LET ANYONE CONVINCE YOU THAT IT STARTED ON OCTOBER 7th PLEASE REPOST
Russia and Ukraine are both states in traditional War
Israel is attacking Population... There's no Army vs Army
Ham@s is not the government of Palestinians, but the Palestinian Authority that is cooperating with the west.
So you are trying to say that isr*el should keep attacking innocent civilians,strave more people and cause more death. Double Standard is when ukraine fight back its patriotism but when palastinian fight back against occupiers its terrorism
What one of them countries used starvation as a weapon?
Fantastic timing with the court order-only missed the 1948 Nakba by a bit!
It's time to end this war once and for all. Far too many innocent people have died on both sides. As an Irish person who lived through "the troubles" I'm ashamed to say I hated those on the opposite side to me but that's how I was brought up by my family and local community, just as they were brought up to hate me and mine. The Irish conflict dated back hundreds of years and so we had little or no hope for a resolution - but then came the Good Friday Agreement. The grace shown by both sides, whose beliefs were entrenched, eventually resulted in acceptance, peace and security for all. I'm so happy and thankful for their bravery, especially as my most loved friends and relatives are those who I would have once hated and damned. We are one people before a one God and I wish the same for the Israeli and Palestinian people.
Didn't the SS disappear from the EU?
What's your point ?
How ironic to have Judge Nawaf Salam deliver this ruling🔴⚪🟢⚪🔴
And God seated in heaven He laughs at His enemies, there’s no wisdom neither counsel against the Most High of Israel. He’s the chief commander of Armies of Israel, the mighty man of war!
Do these people even know what genocide is ..... pff the whole united nation freak show is child-play
has ICJ arrested Putin?
Or zelensky..
@@hollytalbot6695russian propaganda bots are not welcome here lol
Ot Bush, Blair, etc...
@@hollytalbot6695 Why would they arrest Zelensky? He isn't invading other countries, nor annexing parts of other countries, nor committing genocide, nor threatening nuclear war every few days. Putin on the other hand...
@@fantasypvp Nor are people who support a man who forces people with down syndrome to go to the frontline...
BRAVO israel!!!!!!! You have a right to defend yourself! South Africa has nothing to say about it. They need to stop Boko Haram and stop terror in their own Country.
Eh, what does Boko Haram have to do with South Africa?
Boko Haram operates in Nigeria and environs, genius.
Ridiculous
Serious question, from a legal perspective, how can the UN tell Israel they are not allowed to attack Rafah if they are firing missiles at civilians within Israel from Rafah?
Can they actually tell a country that they are not allowed to protect its civilians?
Any nation not supporting the UNs top court needs to leave the UN. You won't be missed & the world will celebrate your departure
Accountability is anti-Semitic
Accountability? Fake crimes against humanity? Fake starvation in Gaza? Name me any other army on Earth who takes more measures to attempt to avoid civilian casualties during battle than the IDF does. You got anything at all?
It is so amazing that the same international bodies that evolved from the event of holocaust is being used against the very people at the receiving end in the past!!
That's because the Genocide Convention applies to genocides in general, not only genocide on Jewish people. Or did you think it did?
Yeah. The Apartheid state of Israel is run by Nazis. The tables have turned.
@@harriemeeuwis978 Absolutely, what I mean to imply is that the then victim is causing genocide on another community. Thank is what amazes me!!
@@be-easeHistory is full of cruel human behaviour. It's very difficult to develop virtues, certainly if you can get away with the opposite behaviour. Israël clearly thought and thinks wrongly it has an inexhaustible moral credit.
So Israel can’t find back.
What a joke
So have thousands of people have already died and now suddenly there is an "immediate risk" absolute bunch of jokers!
I must have missed the part where the court ordered Hamas to release all hostages, make restitution to the families who lost their members to Hamas and to the State of Israel, and the part where the court demands Hamas make formal representation to the court explaining why they use civilian Palestinian Arabs as cover for their war and terrorism activities against Israel, after explaining why they constantly terrorise Israel.
Shame on USA and UK for complicity!!!
You're not making any sense.
@@cmf7475He’s making perfect sense
Shame on Putlers vegetables they came out small and oddly shaped for the championship show of cabbages 😮
Why the court didn't order Hamas to come to court and explained why they attack Israel on Oct 7th?
Bezelbub Smotrich is the Finance Minister, not Shitamar Ben-Gvir.
Why should they
Israel will Just Ignore the other ICJ like it always does. No one is going to Enforce the ICJ Decision on Israel. Free Palestine 🍉🇵🇸🇺🇸.
Incompetence and intolerance - United Nations core competencies.
Then what are they going to do to Gaza? Do you think hamas is going to release the hostages?
We saw the judges of darkness in you tube .ICJ is the house of darkness.
So that the ICC and now the ICJ. At what point does the UK gov and fellow western gov stop to think 'are we complicit in Israel actions and will we be prosecuted'?
Unassailable truth is the path to victory and peace while falsehood and duplicity lead surely to ruin and decay.
Not that Israel listens to anyone explaining morality to them, but it's nice that the court finally came around.
A chair at ICJ is also antisemitic😂😂😂😂
what about the hostages israel has
They would be freed of course. Including the ones Isreal has been holding for years.
No such hostages
@@adrianchase1190
This is for those who ever support the Zionist Israel
Why don't you talk about the illegal settlements built on Palestinian Lands in West Bank? Why don't you talk about how they humiliate Palestinians on Israeli checkpoints? Why don't you talk about the United Nation resolutions that Israel don't comply with such as 1947 resolution 181 (II), partitioning Palestine into two States - one Arab and one Jewish - the independence of the Palestinian Arab State continued to be unjustly obstructed and the rights of Palestinians “flagrantly denied”. resolution 194 on Nov. 1948 The right of return of Palestinian refugees to Palestine? Resolution 242 in 1967 the illegal occupation of Israel to Palestinian Lands in West Bank? Resolution 904 in 1994 Protecting the Palestinians in the occupied territories from the Israelis after the Ibrahimic Mosque massacre? Why you are not talking about Dec 30 2022 United Nation Resolution against Israel at ICJ. 87 Country votes in favor including China and Russia against the illegal settlement and illegal occupation of Palestinian Lands and the Holy City of Jerusalem.
Why don’t you talk about The UN Security Council, for its part, responded to the Israeli decision to annex East Jerusalem, by issuing Resolution No. 478 on August 29, 1980, which included non-recognition of Israeli law regarding Jerusalem, and called on countries to withdraw their diplomatic missions from the city. Also Resolution No. 15/36 on October 28, 1981, declaring that any changes in the Jerusalem area are illegal and against international law, and that such actions are an obstacle to achieving just and comprehensive peace. UN Resolution 2334 issued on December 23, 2016, confirms that Israel’s establishment of settlements in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967 - including East Jerusalem - has no legal legitimacy, and demands that Israel immediately stop all settlement activities and not recognize any changes to the June 4 borders. /June 1967. UN Resolution in 1974 says in point #5 The Palestinian people have the right to regain their rights by all means in accordance with the United Nations Charter. It affirms the right of the Palestinian people to independence and sovereignty and the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination and the right to return to Palestine.
since the inception of the security council USA used the vote the vito 88 times and they vote 56 times out of 88 times in order to protect Israel from the vito. The superpower of the world in the past over 50 years used more than 65% of the votes to protect Israel and support them killing daily innocent Palestinian civilians.
After signing the Oslo Accords on September 13, 1993, the Palestinians promised by Israel , USA, EU, Russian and UN that the eastern part of Jerusalem would be their future capital, and the Palestinian leadership confirmed its firm position many times by saying, “There is no Palestinian state without East Jerusalem as its capital in accordance with the resolutions of international legitimacy and the peace initiative.” Arabic". Even the official American position supported the international position on occupied Jerusalem, which appeared in an American message of reassurances to the Palestinians in October 1991, in which it stated, “We do not recognize Israel’s annexation of East Jerusalem or its expansion of its municipal borders.”
Russia confirms that it recognizes West Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and East Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine, which was reconfirmed by a source in the Russian Foreign Ministry in December 2017.
However, the US Congress reversed the international position on October 23, 1995, when it issued a law stipulating the transfer of the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem and the necessity of recognizing “Jerusalem as the capital of the State of Israel.” The Two state solution is been shut and dead a long time ago. Benyamin Netanyahu bragged about how he has spoiled the Oslo accord.
I wonder Why are you playing the victim role? Israel always victimize itself?
I'm Palestinian and Israeli are killing us since 1947 and we never heard you talking about it and condemn Israel for killing innocent Palestinians. Why you speak about the reaction of the innocent Palestinians tortured daily by Zionist Israeli but never speak about the action of Israeli illegal occupation of Palestine that bring such reaction? Please come to Palestine and see for yourself how they treat Palestinians and tortured them. Please we invite you all to come and see the truth by yourself.
why can't UN stop Israeli Zionist killing innocent Palestinian Civilian mostly Children and women for 75 years? Why UN can't punish Israeli Zionist for violating more than 70 UN Resolution but destroyed Iraq for violating couple of UN Resolution? UN should ask the west why you consider Ukrainian defending their lands against Russian as freedom fighter but you consider Palestinian defending their Land against Israeli as Terrorist?
Do the Palestinian have the right to defend themselves because you always say Israel has the right to defend itself? Do the Palestinian have the right to defend themselves when Land was taken from them Homes were destroyed when daily innocent civilian Palestinian children’s and women were killed Palestinian homes were confiscated and demolished by Israeli and when UN Resolutions on Torture on ethnic cleansing against the Palestinian in Israel failed and so many other UN Resolution against Israel failed. did the Palestinian have the right to defend themselves when Israel Turn on and off Electricity stop the water stop food stop fuel stop medical Aid put Gaza on the biggest open-Air Prison for 16 years long long before October 7 attack by Hamas? You can’t say open Air Prison because you go to prison if you did something wrong. It is the biggest open concentration camp in the world.
if you claim Israel has a "right to self-defense" then shouldn't you also acknowledge Palestine's right to armed struggle against the occupying power? Armed resistance against the occupying power is a fact that is acknowledged by international humanitarian law conventions.
You are so ignorant about the facts on the ground. People in Gaza are living in subhuman conditions because of Zionist Israel.
Hamas was created in 1987 and Zionist Israel been killing innocent Palestinian Civilian since 1947. Palestinian since 1947 were crying to the world shouting to people like you to UN, EU, USA, Russia, China, .... etc. to help them and to stop the massacre of Palestinian by Israel Zionist to stop the catastrophe that started on 1947. Where were you from 1947 until 1987 when Israel Zionist killed innocent Palestinian and still killing them until today? No one helped the Palestinian or listened to them. Nobody cares about them for 75 years. Palestinian decided to stand up and defend themselves and on 1987 after they lost hope from the entire world to save them Hamas was born as REACTION to the ACTION of the Israeli Zionist against innocent Palestinian. Hamas is REACTION for the illegal ACTION of the Zionist Israel. What Hamas did in OCT 7 is happening to the Palestinians daily since 1947 for 75 years. Where were you and why you didn't condemn the killing of those innocent Palestinian for 75 years? What Hamas did is REACTION of the illegal ACTION of Zionist Israel. The ACTION is the illegal Occupation of Palestine by Israeli Zionist and the violation of more than 70 UN Resolution by Israel Zionist. End up the illegal ACTION of Zionist Israel they will be no REACTION. The Problem with the western Media you do condemn the REACTION of the Palestinian and forget about the illegal ACTION of Zionist Israel. Do you condemn the Nakba in 1947 the Ethnicity Genocide of Palestinian by Israeli?
“They used to say Palestinians fight like heroes, now they say heroes fight like Palestinians.”-Norman Finkelstein
What about the bedrock rule of international Law, no taking Land by Force? No nation no power is allowed to take neighbors territory by force? When Russia does it, we are pretty clear but when Israel does it specially in the West Bank taking Palestinian lands by force the western world became Blind and forget about the bedrock rule of international Law?
Haifa Massacre 1937 2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937 3. Haifa Massacre 1938. 4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939 5. Haifa Massacre 1939 6. Haifa Massacre 1947 7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947 8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947 9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947 10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947 11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947 12. Tantura Massacre 1948 13. Jaffa Massacre 1948 14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956 15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967 16. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982 17. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990 18. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994 19. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002 20. Gaza Massacre 2008-09 21. Gaza Massacre 2012 22. Gaza Massacre 2014 23. Gaza Massacre 2018-19 24. Gaza Massacre 2021 25. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing.
Question for the Christian. As Christian do you have the right to make Bethlehem as your territory , because 2000 years ago that was the origin of your religion?
If Palestinian land belongs to Israel from 3000 years ago I hope Italians won't want to restore the Roman Empire !!!!
DONT LET ANYONE CONVINCE YOU THAT IT STARTED ON OCTOBER 7th PLEASE REPOST
ISRAEL HAS PALESTINIAN HOSTAGES SINCE 75 YEARS BUT MAJORITY ARE BLIND...
What about Palestinians hostages in Israeli Jails?
To those calling the ruling useless or the UN useless. Go do something about the Gaza situation yourself instead of being a keyboard warrior. At least the UN has been giving humanitarian aid. What have you done besides punching your keyboards.
It's not a line darling. It's a fact.
no ceasefire
"No kidnapped, No ceasefire whether they like it or not."
---- < A biased ruling. The transfer of weapons and equipment to Hamas goes through Rafah in tunnels that run underneath the border with Egypt. Israel is actually trying to avoid civilian causalities. Hamas could have surrendered but they chose to use civilians as shields instead.
The ICC issued a warrant against Putin for kidnapping Ukrainian children but not for killing civilian populations, even though there was no justification for his invasion of Ukraine, and, even though, he confessed to paying the Wagner Group to commit war crimes in Ukraine and continues attacks on the civilian population.
Russia paid $1 billion to Wagner group in one year, says Putin /watch?v=tb9Nljhfj2E