1. 🎯🚨First Ever Batch for UPSC 2026 By Unacademy IAS Team With Lowest Ever Prices!!! ➡ Now 2 Year & 3 Year UPSC Subscription are at the Lowest Ever Prices! Subscribe Now: unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=IASENGLISH ✅ Complete GS + CSAT + Prelims & Mains Test Series Offer Ends by 27th Nov! UPSC 2026 Subs at just 32,999/- INR. UPSC 2027 Subs at just 42,999/- INR
@@UnacademyIASEnglish is this even a debate, local language and English is all one needs to survive in many parts of the world, just because hindi speaking guys cant learn other languages, a poor street hawker in non Hindi states wont learn Hindi. Hindi speaking kids learn 2 languages but others kids should learn 3 putting them at a disadvantage? Central govt jobs, banking etc has only Hindi and english driving those people to.not learn english and poor people in other states having to learn english? Are non Hindi speaking people second class citizens. We will learn Greek and Latin even just to pi*$ off these arrogant a*$*$ but will never learn Hindi or sanskrit. If you cant fathom this, stay put in your states.
India we already have a link language English which is also connecting the world. Hindi cannot be made a link language as it will be forced anyways for another link language
All Hindu gods orgin from Tamil, 800 years old Hindi language. Modi and Indian archeological department proved that Tamil is the oldest language in the world, check modi speech in youtube. If you respect hindi religion, same you want to respect Tamil also. 800 years old stupid language Hindi.
@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries My brother opened you eyes Isn't that irony
@@vimalrajs4292 english is not our language its a colonial language. We don't use it for our local day to day or we never use it. I am saying this in English only for your understanding
இவனுங்க என்ன பிளான் பண்றாங்கன்னு புரிஞ்சிக்கோங்க சகோ. பாஸ்போர்ட்டிலிருந்து எல்லா அரசு(மாநில) அலுவலகங்களிலும் கூட இந்தியை கொண்டு வர வேண்டும். சீனா, ரஷ்யா போல இந்தியாவிற்கு ஒரே மொழி என்பது தான் இவர்கள் செய்ய நினைப்பது. தமிழக அரசு அலுவலக ஃபார்ம்களிலும் இந்தி வந்துவிடும். நம்ம டாக்குமெண்டஸும் இந்தி வந்துவிடும். நில சொத்து பத்திரங்கள் எல்லாம் இந்தியில் இருக்க வேண்டும் என்று அடுத்த சட்டம் வரும். நம்ம நிலத்தை நம்மிடமே இருந்து ஆட்டைய போடுவானுங்க ஏன்னா நமக்கு இந்தியிலிருக்கும் பத்திரங்கள் படிக்க முடியாது. நிறைய clause சில் அர்த்தங்கள் மறைந்திருக்கும், நமக்கு புரியாது. இவனுங்க இந்தியாவை 4000 வருஷத்துக்கு பின்னால் கொண்டு போக போகிறார்கள்.
இந்தி முழுதாக வர இவனுங்க(பாஜக) வெளிநாட்டு சானல்களை கட் செய்வார்கள், ஆங்கிலத்தை முழுவதும் அழித்துவிட்டு வெளி உலக அறிவே இல்லாமல் செய்துவிடுவார்கள். வடநாட்டானை எந்த காலத்திலும் நம்பாதீர்கள் நண்பர்களே.
I am from Darjeeling in West Bengal. During my entire 4 years of preparation for upsc from Delhi, Laughter of people about my Hindi accent was prevalent, Despite having a decent Hindi accent. I feel the pain of the people who find it even a slight difficulty in communicating in Hindi. And here debate is only about north vs south and their perspective. How about what east and northeast feels about it..?
Brother! The discussion is about Hindi and non Hindi.The problem became bigger when Amit Shah announced Hindi has to be a national language and in Bangalore metro Hindi Sign boards are made mandatory. I don't understand why Hindi is necessary in Bangalore metro stations. Kannada and English is there. Telugu or Tamil or Malayalam makes more sense than Hindi. I can understand your point You don't have to use Hindi, you are better with English.
@@youthindian1593 You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries My brother opened you eyes Isn't that irony
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 then why u can’t you learn Tamil telugu Malayalam Kannada which your brothers and sisters speak in this country, And more over , in what language you are speaking bro in this comment 😂, why you are studying in English medium then, you learning a language of people who looted us ? The thing is very simple bro, people in south can survive with their regional language and English, if they had to go to any place in north India, then they will learn, they have to learn, same way if you come to south, it’s not mandatory to learn South Indian la nguage, but trying to learn help you only, but your getting offended when some South Indian says learn our local language. Same thing you are saying to learn your local language!! It’s what imposition is, keep it simple whenever there is a necessity they ll learn that language, don’t make it mandatory is what we say. South languages are completely different to Hindi bro, North Indian languages are atleast comes from same family, its as difficult as we ask you to learn Tamil or Telugu. So no one is hating other language , I just want to say respect all languages and culture.
There should be a Two Language Policy in Karnataka (Proud moment that TN is the only state that has 2 lan policy). However, KA adopted a Three Language Policy and the infrastructure is only available for Hindi like teachers/funds/education etc. Therefore, you are forced to learn Hindi as your third language bro.
Hindi is the mother tongue or easy to use language for many north Indians and they will start having advantage compared to others and others become 2nd grade citizens in their own country if Hindi is given more importance than other languages. As soon as you consider Hindi as a link language, that's it, that is the imposition. English is the only language in India that is equally away (equidistant) for everyone. So, English should be the link language of India for peach and prosperity of the country.
but I have a reasonable counterargument to your equidistant point! Hindi as the name means, is language of hind which is north western India , birthplace of Indian civilization, it atleast even in modern era retains the Sanskrt-Prakrt words ,English is a very very very fat distant cousin to any of the languages from subcontinent, I personally dont care about hindi, but definitely believe a lingua franca is indeed necessary , which promotes indigenization , a simpler version of Sanskrit it could be
@@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries My brother open you eyes Isn't that irony
@@mahesharaja even historical context, Britishers only united india especially political aspect. Now English is global language, even those who say hindi is national language put their children in english medium schools.
So inconvenience everyone is the argument here? How about instead finding a convenient alternative for everyone - Sanskrit then? All Indian languages have sanskrit vocabulary in it!
Ofcourse, we will, in fact we will learn Greek and Latin but will never learn Hindi or sanskrit just because you cant communicate in English, that is why some states are sh*%$ holes.
@@abby_drafts being Indian is irrelevant as both Hindi and English have to be learnt from start for South Indians unlike North Indians who pick up Hindi even if they don't have it as mother tongue. For South Indians this two language demand is illogical, burden for children and outright discrimination by allowing another Indian language more than equal status to the rest.
When we South Indian people move to North Indian state for work we never complain saying no one speak mother tongue. Only this Hindi speaking people raise this problem.
Yeah north indians think the world revolves around them..a few months back i saw a video where a north indian guy had gone to Japan to work for a long period of time and complaining that Japanese people don't speak english. if u go to a place for long time learn to be like locals😂😂😂.
@@YazhiniS-kn8ziif u go north do u speak Hindi or englush if u speak English even u imposing English on north people. Due to English we already lost everything as telugu state person no one speaking pure telugu except tinglish telugu with mix of English Instead of English hindi why cant we move to samskrith?
U people do not have idea even north people learning south language teaching south languages why we hate hindi no need English in india i hope and i suggest samskrith should be link language
English should be promoted more than Hindi as Secondary Language 1. English is global language. Widely used in business and even in technical languages 2. None of Indian have English as Mother Tongue. So every Indian should put same effort to learn English. It means every Indian is equally treated in terms of learning a secondary language. In India, English should be link language between states and union. Its not about foreign language its about people should equally treated In laymen terms, One general size door is enough to enter into house instead of having seperate doors for fat, tall and short persons,
Regional languages : Tamil- Tamilnadu Malayalam - Kerala Kannada - KA Telugu- AP , Tel Tulu also spoken in KA Rajastani Gujrati Kashmiri Ladhaki Marathi Bengali Odia Assamme Hindi- United province( how many times You can divide keep dividing)also Regional language Link Language = English ✅
We are indians and already united that's more than enough. Respect everyone and all languages. Our mother tongue is the same as my mother. The whole of India was speaking Tamil before 4000 years( oor or pur is a Tamil word, jaipur, udaipur, kanpur, Madura or Madurai) all are Tamil places. can we make Tamil as a common language to create a united province?
@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries My brother opened you eyes Isn't that irony
Oh wait Bengaluru is not developed by North Indians...It's because of visionary thoughts by Kings, Engineers, Policymakers of Karnataka and Kannada people.. Even we can say that North Indian states need South Indian tax money ...if you say Bengaluru is developed by NI , then all NI go to your home state and develop it
So if a person from South India moves to Delhi, he/she should learn Hindi but a person from North comes to South states, the whole state should learn Hindi to be able to communicate to that person?! How is the North Indian can be so privileged?
Yes because in the south there are many languages But Hindi works everywhere Honestly people against Hindi are just pure dumb It gives you access to so much more
@@From004do some research about where sanskrit orginated and hindi originated. Speak with facts. Sanskrit is a indo- EUROPEAN language. There has been enough archeological evidence to suggest that. Hindi is a mix of sanskrit and Urdu.
@@srijagadeeshc3056 Hindi comes out of Sanskrit language and the language you are talking about is Urdu which may sound similar to Hindi for non Hindi speakers but it is very much different than Hindi. In Hindi we say red colour as "Lal" but in Urdu it is "Surkh". So calling Hindi a Persian language is very much coming out of misconception.
@@kiran.h.d then go to USA and UK this is not your father Britain land understand you Christian missionary local languages enough to speak in any states. I'm from Maharashtra I support local languages instead english मला माझ्या मराठीवर प्रेम आहे मी मराठीसाठी मरेन मला इंग्रजी येत नाही गेट हरवलेले ख्रिश्चन वडील.
@@kiran.h.d whatever language working majority speaks at a place at the time, it would be common sense for one to learn that very language instead of imposing one language over others.
@@kiran.h.d yeah some of people think just because 60% Indians speaking Hindi they think like almost everyone speaks and it should be national launguage. They should understand 40% is not small number as it denotes entire South India. So, first of India is not just India. If any foreigner displays a map without pok, then people get mad at them so, why they're excluding South India in this matter by thinking entire India speaks Hindi almost. This is ignorance. So, English is universal language and it should be common since India is very diverse.
@@Vinayyg2000 so suppose I want to communicate with you how can we communicate if we doesn't have common languages. Either I have to learn yours or you learn my language.
From Kolkata saying we will not accept Hindi as national language , never, never,for it agar Civil war bhi karna pade karenge , India is not for North Indians only 😡
When this discussion came in 1948 in the constituent assembly leaders from non hindi speaking asked same question. You want whole India or Hindi India?.Then only they have decided include all the 14 languages in the 8 th scdedule. Now it is 22 languages
That's what we tamilians are also saying.Myself can read, write and speak hindi. Here everyone is liberal to learn anything if they actually want. But imposing is not acceptable at all.
@@prabhayashwanth6271यार भाई इनको हिंदी के लिए कोई फोर्स नहीं करता । इनके यहां राजनीति ही भाषा के आधार पर होती है । 😂😂😂 न्यू एजुकेशन पॉलिसी क्या था । लेकिन फिर भी इन सालों को नफरत है उतर भारत के लोगों से
Hindi as a link language❌️ English as a link language ✅️....learn a language only if u like or want or have a need...as simple as that..forcing a native of a state to learn a language which is alien to them just coz u don't know for eg tamil or English should not be my problem, u come here u learn language...when we go ti north indian or any other state we will learn the local language..as simple as that. If ppl come with lame excuses like hindi is majority or how uneducated ppl will speak English...then how ppl in tamilnadu who are uneducated will speak hindi?...atleast even uneducated tamil person will try to speak in English. So learn english ,state lang and u already know ur mother tongue...so its already 3 languages for many ppl...u come here u learn, when we go we will learn simple❗️
@@Santhosh10KumarYou are ready to learn the language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries My brother opened you eyes Isn't that irony
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 mf giving the same reply to every comment why the f are u commenting in a colonial language. If u are not imposing then just stfu. literally imposing learn english over hindi and saying i am not imposing.
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 The same thing applies to northies also, who are shamelessly living in Blore for many years and not learning even a single word of Kannada. is kannada is not the langauge of india. Enough of slavery in name of nationalism. Stop hindi imposition, we dont need you. You people are no different from the british. Atleast british gave us good infrastructure, but you people are living on our hard earned money and tax and imposing an useless langauge on us. Learn kannada when you are karnataka, and it is as per constitution also
17:52 with all due respect, i humbly disagree with the point being raised here. Bangalore and Hyderabad's development should ve attributed to visionaries such as S.M.Krishna and Chandrababu Naidu. The ecosystem created by the local administration had led to the development and economy. Talent from various parts of the country could come and thrive here.
not just bangalore and Hyderabad every developed city in north and western india like chennai Mumbai Pune is due to the strong and visionary state leadership and a progressive society in these states. Migrants from north just came here to reap the benefits as their state leader are not capable and they as a society have failed with their backwardness.
These northies always try to create a narrative that their panipuri, toilet cleaners created IT industries in hyderabad, bangalore and chennai........ 😂😂😂😂
Just wondering Y North Indian states like UP, Bihar, Jharkhand is still under developed. Before contributing to Southern state's development, they could have developed their own states first.
We are indians and already united that's more than enough. Respect everyone and all languages. Our mother tongue is the same as my mother. The whole of India was speaking Tamil before 4000 years( oor or pur is a Tamil word, jaipur, udaipur, kanpur, Madura or Madurai) all are Tamil places. can we make Tamil as a common language?
In linguistic issue, Tamil Nadu have been handling in good way. Since 1967, TN Follows two language policy meanwhile Rest of the South Indian States follow Tri Language policy. TN people do not want Non-Tamil speakers to speak in Tamil while KA follows Hindi as their third language but want others to speak in Kannada. KA literally don't know how to handle the linguistic issue and Anti Hindi agitation. Teaching Hindi in Schools but Anti Hindi agitation in Public. #Non sense thoughts
@@Vijayakumar_V_Kannan other south indian states are not showing guts to oppose the oppressors of Hindi belt. Karnataka my state is suffering very badly due to Hindi influx. All the government forms, bank forms are either in English or Hindi. Great injustice to my brother village folks who cannot understand both. And my brother Kannadigas are still sleeping while kannada is being erased from the land.
North India also has so called STATES and they are also coming down to south, how many north indian states are teaching Kannada or Tamil???? and South India is far more developed the North Indian states, so the number of people going out of karnataka to north india is far less than people from north coming to karnataka. your point has no logic, Karnataka has 6Crore population, and if only 10 lakh kannadigas going outside, you are teaching the nonsense Hindi to remaining 5.9 crore kannadigas!!! understood your logic? if a shoe or chappel does not fit to your foot, you have to trim the shoe not your own foot~~ Proud Tamilian. (tell me have you ever attended any interview in Hindi when you been to Mumbai or Delhi?)
Just take one aspect about movies, for instance. How the Gujrathi, Bhojpuri, punjab or even marathi movies are struggling to make a footprint due to Hindi and over presence of Bollywood, and on the other hand, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam and Kananda movies are thriving. This is only because we are preserving the language, culture and arts. Once you loose your language you loopse your soul.
NORTH INDIANS ARE FULL OF HINDI SUPERIORITY COMPLEX FOR NO REASON. WHAT IS THE HISTORY OF HINDI VSS SOUTH INDIAN LANGUAGES? FIRST LEARN TO GIVE RESPECT TO STATE LANGUAGES AND REMEMBER STATES WERE CERETAED BASED ON NATIVE LANGUAGE.
Being a person from Tamilnadu, I can say that Tamils try to speak broken native languages of the states that we visit. The only thing we hate is blatant imposition of Hindi upon us.
@@EternalScreams thats ur wish to speak any lang hindi or anything...but for us theres no need sir thats the hard reality..without any use on anywhere in our life why should we learn hindi???
@@EternalScreamsyou speak hindi we don't want to speak hindi we protect our language at any cost it. Our ancestors protected now we will. Tamil world' oldest language🔥💪
If you are going to non hindi speaking places learn their language... If a non hindi speaking guy going to hindi speaking place try to learn hindi...problem is if a hindi guy going to anyplace he is not ready to learn any other language but impose their language on others.. Thats real problem..
once it become link language slowly they make it national language 😮 so many languages loosing their identity because of Hindi 😢 dear north Indians don't competitive with south India but rest of the world 😮
1.)If Hindi people can't read English because English is very different. Same logic Hindi is very different than Tamil . So we also can't read 2.) If we can learn English You can also learn English. English is spoken all over world and is useful in this globalisation era for employment. 3.) In everyone ' s phone we have translators. In next 10 years even one language will be enough to communicate with not only the nation but with entire world.😂😂😂 Maximum 2 languages Minimum 1 language Period ✅
3:08 Hindi Should not be a Nationl language or link language to connect people..Why we need to learn Hindi?? Let India connect with diverse culture language and culture respect each .. Once who come for livelihood or job should learn regional language
Hindi has annihilated dozens of native languages in East Panjab, NWP, CP, BP & various Kingdoms of Great British Raj.Dravidian movement is most inclusive it guided Anna, Karunanidhi & MGR.Reading Periyar & Dr Ambedkar is important to understand Endia.
@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries My brother opened you eyes Isn't that irony
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776if we rewind back some 3500 years back, You will see Aryan Languages invading our homeland. Why did you guys learn these languages?
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 Whether you like it or not, English has become an international language. You can travel all over the world with English including China. At least that is what my experience has been during my recent visit to China. You can also move around in north india with English alone. I am from south, but did all my college education in Chandigarh. I could easily live my life there with English alone. Why do I need to waste my time in learning something I am not interested in? Instead, I spent my time in learning science.
ಭೌಗೋಳಿಕವಾಗಿ ನಾನು ಭಾರತೀಯ.. ಸಂಸ್ಕೃತಿ ಹಾಗು ಸಂಪ್ರದಾಯದ ಭಾಷೆ ಮತ್ತು ನೆಲದಿಂದ ನಾನು ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ ..ನನ್ನ ಭಾಷೆ ಕನ್ನಡ..ನನ್ನ ಧರ್ಮ ಕನ್ನಡ.. ನನ್ನ ಸಂಸ್ಕೃತಿ ಕನ್ನಡ.. ಜೈ ಕನ್ನಡಾಂಬೆ ..ಜೈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ಜೈ ಕನ್ನಡ ನಾಡು .. ಕರ್ಣಾಟ ಬಲಂ ಅಜೇಯಂ..❤️🫶
Those who thinks that English is not our Language and hence learn Hindi. Let me tell you Hindi is also not our language. It’s your language. I don’t want to be a second grade citizen in my own country where Hindi speakers feel superiors to the rest just like how Americans or English 🏴 feel. Now the problem is , you want me to learn Hindi and feel insecure while talking in Hindi as if English alone is not enough. Now coming to India’s economy, IT is the key contributor for India where speaking English plays the key role. Now by learning Hindi, what do you expect out of me ? Let’s be honest. Stop this nonsense of Spreading Hindi.
Tamil is considered one of the oldest living languages in the world:    Age Tamil is estimated to be around 5,000 years old. However, the earliest written account of Tamil is only about 2,500 years old.  Speakers Tamil is spoken by around 78 million people in India, Sri Lanka, Singapore, and Malaysia. It is the official language of Tamil Nadu and is also spoken in Sri Lanka.
@@arunkumarbkoyilandy pls don't comment nonsense our great Tamil language is created by sage agathiya ma munivar by the order of lord Shiva n lord muruga
No need of hindi as national language, telugu is enough. For communication purpose English is enough. Keep the north indian regional language hindi to its place only, dont use and expect in south india.
I'll Only say one thing. 99% of people living in Bangalore who have migrated here and living here for 5 years or more, don't even know even the basic phrases of Kannada, and they feel entitled to not learn Kannada and survive here and live here by knowing Hindi, and so, they expect localities to learn, know and speak Hindi. That's the whole problem of it. I personally have no issues with Hindi per se.. but, it's not just regional chauvinism that's the reason for these conflicts recently. There are deeper issues of migrants taking the welcoming localities for granted and not even trying to assimilate into the society by putting basic efforts into learning local language, if they are settling in that place for long term. Especially because, today I hear more Hindi than Kannada in Bangalore and that's only possible if localities are welcoming and accomodating enough to learn and speak in Hindi to accomodate migrant population. But the reverse that is migrant population who have been staying here for the long term are not even trying to assimilate or at least try to learn basics of local language, and that's the root of the problem... And because of it even the temporary settlers are facing issues because of the locals with extreme views. - My opinion is that no one should force anyone to speak in either hindi or Kannada. It has to be voluntary. Bangalorians in fact have learnt Hindi and have always spoke hindi and are open to speak in hindi, and were welcoming till few years back. But, the migrant people have taken advantage of it and many don't even put efforts in learning basics of it or even are open to learn Kannada. It shows how the migrant people who are even settling in Bangalore are entitled and are reluctant to learn Kannada as a gesture of appreciation and mutual respect, as well as an additional skill that'll help them Navigate situations with ease, by knowing the local language. @15:24 When the auto wala in Bangalore told why speak Hindi, this is Karnataka, speak in Kannada, the person can always say, "I'm here temporarily and it's difficult or impractical to learn"... Instead they became defensive and started saying "why should I learn kannada, you are India and you should learn Hindi". Here, Auto wala forcing the passengers to speak in Kannada is also wrong, and the passengers are also wrong, acting like entitled brats, I'll not learn kannada at all, you only have to speak in hindi. Irrespective of the political games, that politicians play... Mutual respect is the only solution to all of this. - I myself have experienced genuine hindi acceptance organically in Bangalore multiple times, when the Auto driver became happy, acknowledged when I tried to speak in broken kannada with them, and he only switched to hindi to make me comfortable. This is the beauty of MUTUAL RESPECT. @30:52 individually a family came and settled in Bangalore, and they speak a different language in their home,which is fine. But them expecting everyone they encounter outside their home, to speak in hindi with them is also wrong. They have to at least put efforts into learning basics of the local language as a sign of appreciation for local culture, since they are settling there, that shows localities that the mutual respect they are asking for, and localities will also reciprocate with them by speaking in Hindi. That's what is needed. It can't be a one way street. And this is not happening... Of course, localities shouldn't expect the temporary migrants to learn Kannada, BUT THE FACT THAT even the long term settlers are also not open to learn local language and the localities have to adjust and speak in hindi to accomodate the migrants, while migrants being insensitive to local culture and are not even putting any efforts from their side to assimilate with localities... And this issue has come to such a point that some localities are saying enough is enough, everyone should speak in Kannada, which is the other end of toxicity. MUTUAL RESPECT AND NOTHING ELSE.... Can actually help in Hindi acceptance, and the effort has to be put by long term migrant population to show the respect and acknowledgement to localities and local culture, so that localities won't feel threatened or taken for granted for being welcoming to migrants (which has been the case in past 2 decades)... @31:20 Here the assumption of pro-hindi side, that long term settlers are learning the local language is totally false, as that's very very rare... And this is the ground level reality that has caused unrest in locals which the selfish politicians are taking advantage of... By putting fuel in fire. @35:00 this is the accomodating nature of the localities... To accomodate migrants from TN, AP, Kerala and all other parts of the country by knowing those languages to facilitate communication... @ 35:08 is exactly my point!! The willingness... Not even able to learn or speak, or difficulty, logistics, etc... but basic willingness and openness... For long term migrants. That's all there is to it. @35:19 people in south may or may not be more willing to learn languages to accomodate others... But majority of the people from North definitely don't. This is not a generalization. It's an observation from a temporary migrant like me who has learnt basic kannada, staying in Bangalore for 6 years and whose friends, acquaintances, etc are all from North India and almost none of them know even one single word in Kannada even though they're living in Bangalore for more than 5 years. And all these people they don't even see the need or even have a willingness to learn local language, just because they are comfortable here and getting by using Hindi ... ONLY BECAUSE the localites are accomodating and speak in Hindi to facilitate better communication. But it's only one way Street that's the problem here .. at grass root level. Of course another main hurdle is also that there are no good language learning apps that teach Indian languages even in Apps like Duolingo only Hindi so there.. which is very unfortunate. Such apps are missing out on a huge market.
Hema bindu mam speaks my problem. I am from Karnataka and I learned hindi as a 3rd language class 6th to 10th why ? Till date i don't know, why I learned hindi in karnataka. My opinion is that hindi is already imposing and imposed in karnataka, That should be stopped in future.
I'm a Tamilian, personally I believe that learning Hindi as 3rd or additional language during childhood had helped me a lot in career. If you see in workplace, most north indians understadn and speak Hindi. And if you learn Hindi because of your interest or as an additional language, it is very helpful for you.
@@warrior_rana_108 Nobody is telling lie just look at urself when the comment is in English ur replying in Hindi this is enough Mister how u guys imposing Hindi on us if at the same time I reply u in a KANNADA are u able to reply Me so first don't tell lie and don't impose ur language on us if 3 language system imposing on use at the same time 3 language system also to be added on Hindi speaking states also
I think the north India should learn English so that we can exist with one link language for the world instead of one for the country & one for global connect !
States are divided by linguistic diversity why then hindi alone be given prominent. English will be the link language. It will help as link language all over the world.
There r no "both sides" .English is the link language for all Indians ,NOT HINDI My mother is NOT HINDI .. I speak Marathi,Kannada daily and i think in ENGLISH .The mother tongue of Kanandigas,tamilians,malayalis ,telugus,Bengalis,Marathis Assamese,sikkimese,odiyas,himachalis,Punjabis,Goans,Kashmiris ,Manipuris is NOT HINDI
these people say migrants cant speak kannada. but they expect the auto driver, some watchman, hotel waiter, shopkeeper, everyone in the southern state to learn their native language for culture, english for jobs, and then to learn hindi to satisfy these hypocrites
Look at what happened to Cantonese after Mandarin became the official language. You will loose a regional language when one is important than the other. Forcing Hindi to be an official language in India will lead to demise of other regional languages. So, ENGLISH. India will benefit nationally and internationally.
There is already a link language that is english. We can link the whole world. Not just indian languages.Some people from hindi belt are simply entitled they just expect all to serve them and to speek hindi. There are many cases of students that commit suicide due to language bullying who go to the north to study. Many don't feel safe from south to go to north to study they would rather try to find college in the south or go abroad. When they come here and speek hindi we try to understand or communicate in some way but in north they won't even stop and try to listen most of them just walk away even if they understand what u say in broken hindi or english I have personally experienced this. Why should I spend my time learning a language that is not of any use to me day to day in my life . Its so double standard to expect me to spend hours to this cause I will happily do so if in hindi states they have compulsory learning of one of the other indian language other than hindi compulsory too. This way both are spending time in learning a language that they will never use.
English should be made as link language bcz students atleast go to school and learn English,(literacy may increase) If hindi, then no need for going school. Your debate itself is in English.
It's already a link language! English is the only language accepted as a 2nd administrative language from every state of India (after their state's official language), that's why english is everywhere.
North India and South India are very different. Not only linguistically, but also in many other areas. India is a country that was created only through the freedom fight.
U better be scared to conduct this debate in Tamil country. Tamil language is mother for all cultures around India. Tamil must be a national language culturally.
Tamil is oldest language we agree but don't say it's mother of all culture if my mother born before your mother doesn't mean your father born from my father?
Hindi is as a link is unfair for non hindi speaking ppl and an advantage for hindi speakers...we are forced to learn to speak to a guy whose mother tongue is hindi when our language is not...when English is a link language....it is fair for both of us to learn a new language....all sophisticated and well off north indians learn English, go to USA and will not let the underprivileged to grow up by pushing propaganda like English is a colonial hangover bs.
if you feel english is colonial hangover then make Tamil as link language (since majority of Indians understand Hindi so logically they come to a decision of making Hindi as link language. if that logic applies India has majority of Hindus so lets announce Hindu as national religion, and mosquitoes as national bird because there are more mosquitoes than peacocks
If a nation, as complex as India is, need one language. Then the spirit of India is dead and should be split into different countries through referrundum
South Indians are extremely hypocrite when it comes to language. I am a Bengali, I live in Kolkata. I know Bengali, English and Hindi. Punjab, Kashmir, Ladakh, Gujrat, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, You name any north Indian state they have 3 language policies. It's the South Indians who either know two languages i.e English (which they say it's used to travel the world) and the second is their own mother tongue. Why Hindi is being substituted (not imposed) because even the villages in remote North Indian villages know their mother tongue and Hindi. But if you do compare it to a remote south indian villager, they'll only know their mother tongue. They might not be privileged enough to learn English. Both will struggle in different states. Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil and Telegu combine barely make max 30% of speakers however 70% of India can speak Hindi. If you wanna to debate me on this in a civil manner without throwing insults, sure do comment your thoughts and expect a response.
Chetan sir and Abhishek sir both look so alike that I always thought they are same person. I have been following the Hindu analysis session for last 3 months. They both are just amazing. Got to learn so much!
In telugu we have saying పళ్ళు ఊడగొట్టుకోవడానికి ఏ రాయి అయితే ఏంటి even through English we already lost telugu we closed all telugu medium schools are we preserving language?
You don't need to carve out a small Dog door in a Big door, the Big door is enough for lot of things. We have English in school no matter where you are in India. So why 3 language policy for few state and 1 language policy for few states? Just keep 2 language policy like Tamilnadu. State language + English language is much more enough.
Well said, indirectly that making Hindi because of most number of people understand that language in north. is just like announcing DOG as national animal since there are more dogs than tigers in India.!~!
I am frm Tamil Nadu we not against hindi language and I myself worked in Mumbai, Delhi, hyderabad, Kolkata as bank manager I have learned hindi within 3 months and hence if need we will learn and communicate. Don't make it as a policy every govt communications should be written in hindi only that we don't accept Dr that u should understand & U should give space to other linguistic languages Dr and respect Dr.
Linguistic Nationalism and Linguistic Chauvinism are both equally berserk concepts! Respecting each other's culture and accepting diversity are the features that made India the melting pot of civilisations. We must never let go of these fundamental features of Indian society by falling into the trap of political entities!
Sir really i am very happy because when i heard chethan sir form Karnataka ❤😍 and i never saw such a top notch teacher in International relations Hat's off you sir 🙏
Hindi is not even a classical language but some wants to be is as a national language. Q: But Hindi is the most spoken language in India so it should be National Language Right? SIMPLE LOGIC : Okay. Let's make crow and dogs as our National bird and animal because we have more of it. 😂
Language is an emotion and it's culture lives in it. Respecting the culture with humility and respect is a much needed aspect from everyone. Touching that emotion for political play is one of the worst thing that a politician can do, and those who does must def be an incompetent one, who lacks knowledge and wisdom to lead a country or a State for that matter.
Marathis Bengalis Gujarathis Punjabis never opposed Hindi imposition and made Hindi imposition easy for hindians Bhojpuris Awadhis Mewadis Rajasthanis Gardhwali Maithilis Haryanvis Himachalis don’t even know that Hindi has grossly weakened their languages and culture Tamils Kannadigas are right in negating Hindi as so called link language
All South Indians learning Hindi when they move north for opportunities or government jobs to run their lives. But South Indian should learn Hindi to accommodate you to be comfortable when you move to south for opportunities or jobs ? What is this ?
37:47 the way Samad sir asking is amazing. Great work Unacademy. Don’t call the word Bimaru just because of poor and unstable govt. these states are behind southern part of India.
Why do always people who initiate the first attack and atrocious claim have to dictate the nature of the conflict?. Why should there be a war considering we are talking about assigning national language to a country like India which is not a nation in first place?. It's a union formed by mutual agreement between various other smaller nations like EU. *Imagine French want to dictate that every other nation inside EU should use french has their national language. And label the rejection from rest of union member as a act of war.* The audacity of the person to use this title.
I just want to put my thoughts 1. If there is a aspect of mini languages like Tulu, Coorgi diminishing in the shadow of Kannada, same is the case with other languages diminishing under the umbrella Hindi. 2. For a certain section of hindi speaking migrants people coming into southern Indian states, learning hindi by all itself is disparity. And it's imposition. 3. Hindi as a link language lags very much in academic terms like scientific terms but English serves this purpose. In this regard it would be difficult to learn for southern states people to learn Hindi as a link language, English as a academic language. 4. Imagine a student(from southern state) failing in Hindi and scoring well in core subjects still held back in terms of marks and promoting to next class. We are already having this case. 5. Southern states still lacks in political representation just because population is the only criteria for the delimitation process. We need more criteria like progress, contribution to development, historical significance etc in delimitation process.
youre talking about about whats wrong with hindi, and I agree, but hindi must not be discarded I believe that will be actually a strategic mistake, hindi can be purified and developed into a more sanskritized form , and you can just using the roots develop new words for scientific terminology ,like how European researchers did with Latin and Greek in 15-19th century, that can also become a link language and most people I believe then will be comfortable, obviously retaining each regional language, Northeasterners will have to come to a compromise unfortunately ,anyways they cannot communicate with other tribes because of diff language, they had to develop nagamese for such, so a new such language should help that too, thats my 2 cents
@@sharanvknd Tulu, Kodava not at all developed their language academically since ages . TULU and kodava people forget their language in kerala , but in karnataka they feel like diminshing . Without karnataka tulu and kodava would have been dimnished .
point one, if a language is similar then it happens.(such as bhojpuri is a subset of Hindi) the major one will swallo the minors. but Hindi can never swallo kannada.
1. 🎯🚨First Ever Batch for UPSC 2026 By Unacademy IAS Team With Lowest Ever Prices!!!
➡ Now 2 Year & 3 Year UPSC Subscription are at the Lowest Ever Prices!
Subscribe Now: unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=IASENGLISH
✅ Complete GS + CSAT + Prelims & Mains Test Series
Offer Ends by 27th Nov!
UPSC 2026 Subs at just 32,999/- INR.
UPSC 2027 Subs at just 42,999/- INR
@@UnacademyIASEnglish is this even a debate, local language and English is all one needs to survive in many parts of the world, just because hindi speaking guys cant learn other languages, a poor street hawker in non Hindi states wont learn Hindi. Hindi speaking kids learn 2 languages but others kids should learn 3 putting them at a disadvantage? Central govt jobs, banking etc has only Hindi and english driving those people to.not learn english and poor people in other states having to learn english? Are non Hindi speaking people second class citizens. We will learn Greek and Latin even just to pi*$ off these arrogant a*$*$ but will never learn Hindi or sanskrit. If you cant fathom this, stay put in your states.
India we already have a link language English which is also connecting the world. Hindi cannot be made a link language as it will be forced anyways for another link language
All Hindu gods orgin from Tamil, 800 years old Hindi language. Modi and Indian archeological department proved that Tamil is the oldest language in the world, check modi speech in youtube. If you respect hindi religion, same you want to respect Tamil also. 800 years old stupid language Hindi.
No need Hindi, English is enough for a link language
Yes
@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history
I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi
That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries
My brother opened you eyes
Isn't that irony
why english not chinese?
@@vimalrajs4292 english is not our language its a colonial language. We don't use it for our local day to day or we never use it. I am saying this in English only for your understanding
@@vimalrajs4292 ❤️❤️❤️
அனைவரும் அவர்களின் தாய் மொழியை பயன்படுத்தும் உரிமை உண்டு. அவர்களின் தேவைக்கேற்ப மற்ற மொழிகளை கற்றுக்கொள்ளட்டும் ❤
@@200rupeesUpisoliga VERY true 👍 brother or sister,
What an awesome translation by google!
இவனுங்க என்ன பிளான் பண்றாங்கன்னு புரிஞ்சிக்கோங்க சகோ. பாஸ்போர்ட்டிலிருந்து எல்லா அரசு(மாநில) அலுவலகங்களிலும் கூட இந்தியை கொண்டு வர வேண்டும். சீனா, ரஷ்யா போல இந்தியாவிற்கு ஒரே மொழி என்பது தான் இவர்கள் செய்ய நினைப்பது. தமிழக அரசு அலுவலக ஃபார்ம்களிலும் இந்தி வந்துவிடும். நம்ம டாக்குமெண்டஸும் இந்தி வந்துவிடும். நில சொத்து பத்திரங்கள் எல்லாம் இந்தியில் இருக்க வேண்டும் என்று அடுத்த சட்டம் வரும். நம்ம நிலத்தை நம்மிடமே இருந்து ஆட்டைய போடுவானுங்க ஏன்னா நமக்கு இந்தியிலிருக்கும் பத்திரங்கள் படிக்க முடியாது. நிறைய clause சில் அர்த்தங்கள் மறைந்திருக்கும், நமக்கு புரியாது. இவனுங்க இந்தியாவை 4000 வருஷத்துக்கு பின்னால் கொண்டு போக போகிறார்கள்.
இந்தியை Full -லா இறக்கிவிட்டு, இந்தி கார்ன் எல்லாம் இங்கே வந்துவிடுவார்கள்.
இந்தி முழுதாக வர இவனுங்க(பாஜக) வெளிநாட்டு சானல்களை கட் செய்வார்கள், ஆங்கிலத்தை முழுவதும் அழித்துவிட்டு வெளி உலக அறிவே இல்லாமல் செய்துவிடுவார்கள். வடநாட்டானை எந்த காலத்திலும் நம்பாதீர்கள் நண்பர்களே.
I am from Darjeeling in West Bengal. During my entire 4 years of preparation for upsc from Delhi, Laughter of people about my Hindi accent was prevalent, Despite having a decent Hindi accent. I feel the pain of the people who find it even a slight difficulty in communicating in Hindi. And here debate is only about north vs south and their perspective. How about what east and northeast feels about it..?
@@GravitasKG that's exactly the point. Why should we speak Hindi when our accent is made fun of? No, thank you very much.
because south India is more vocal about it (karnataka and tamil nadu not andhra telangangana and kerala )
Come and join the club, it's ur battle too,so come forward.
Problem is east and north east don't voice out their problems in this regard as much as south.
Brother! The discussion is about Hindi and non Hindi.The problem became bigger when Amit Shah announced Hindi has to be a national language and in Bangalore metro Hindi Sign boards are made mandatory. I don't understand why Hindi is necessary in Bangalore metro stations. Kannada and English is there. Telugu or Tamil or Malayalam makes more sense than Hindi. I can understand your point You don't have to use Hindi, you are better with English.
Tamil ❤ever, Hindi never 😂😂 வாழ்க தமிழ் ❤❤
Being a Bengali, I support your thought
😂😂😂😂
👏
semma, final judgement Tamil ♥︎
Being a hindi speaker i support your thought
No need of 3 language policy,,,
Every state must applied two language policy
1) State language
2)English
@@youthindian1593 You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history
I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi
That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries
My brother opened you eyes
Isn't that irony
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 then why u can’t you learn Tamil telugu Malayalam Kannada which your brothers and sisters speak in this country, And more over , in what language you are speaking bro in this comment 😂, why you are studying in English medium then, you learning a language of people who looted us ?
The thing is very simple bro, people in south can survive with their regional language and English, if they had to go to any place in north India, then they will learn, they have to learn, same way if you come to south, it’s not mandatory to learn South Indian la nguage, but trying to learn help you only, but your getting offended when some South Indian says learn our local language. Same thing you are saying to learn your local language!! It’s what imposition is, keep it simple whenever there is a necessity they ll learn that language, don’t make it mandatory is what we say. South languages are completely different to Hindi bro, North Indian languages are atleast comes from same family, its as difficult as we ask you to learn Tamil or Telugu. So no one is hating other language , I just want to say respect all languages and culture.
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 then why u learned English??? If u have problems with English then tell ur state to stop teaching English in ur state
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 exactly 💯
@@CHRS-ri5mf what exactly he is wrong
only kannada and english, no need hindi for us
true bro
im a tamil guy if i vist ur state ill try to speak kannada basic words only not try to impose my tamil words
There should be a Two Language Policy in Karnataka (Proud moment that TN is the only state that has 2 lan policy). However, KA adopted a Three Language Policy and the infrastructure is only available for Hindi like teachers/funds/education etc. Therefore, you are forced to learn Hindi as your third language bro.
Boycott Hindi, ಹಿಂದಿ ಭಾಷೆಯನ್ನು ತೊಲಗಿಸಿ. ಸಿರಿಗನ್ನಡಂ ಗೆಲ್ಗೆ ಸಿರಿಗನ್ನಡಂ ಬಾಳ್ಗೆ.
No kannada No English OnLy Russian😂😂😂
Hindi is the mother tongue or easy to use language for many north Indians and they will start having advantage compared to others and others become 2nd grade citizens in their own country if Hindi is given more importance than other languages. As soon as you consider Hindi as a link language, that's it, that is the imposition. English is the only language in India that is equally away (equidistant) for everyone. So, English should be the link language of India for peach and prosperity of the country.
but I have a reasonable counterargument to your equidistant point! Hindi as the name means, is language of hind which is north western India , birthplace of Indian civilization, it atleast even in modern era retains the Sanskrt-Prakrt words ,English is a very very very fat distant cousin to any of the languages from subcontinent, I personally dont care about hindi, but definitely believe a lingua franca is indeed necessary , which promotes indigenization , a simpler version of Sanskrit it could be
@@mahesharaja
Very true
@@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history
I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi
That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries
My brother open you eyes
Isn't that irony
@@mahesharaja even historical context, Britishers only united india especially political aspect.
Now English is global language, even those who say hindi is national language put their children in english medium schools.
So inconvenience everyone is the argument here? How about instead finding a convenient alternative for everyone - Sanskrit then? All Indian languages have sanskrit vocabulary in it!
Yeah all south indian will fight with eachother for many things but for language or hindi imposition all will become United.
Not something to be proud of, it's an Indian language too after all.
Ofcourse, we will, in fact we will learn Greek and Latin but will never learn Hindi or sanskrit just because you cant communicate in English, that is why some states are sh*%$ holes.
Lmao more and more teens now Know hindi sooner or later whole nation will know it, but the quality of that hindi will be dog shit.
@@abby_drafts being Indian is irrelevant as both Hindi and English have to be learnt from start for South Indians unlike North Indians who pick up Hindi even if they don't have it as mother tongue. For South Indians this two language demand is illogical, burden for children and outright discrimination by allowing another Indian language more than equal status to the rest.
@@ShivanshThakur-sh8ub which Hindi is
When we South Indian people move to North Indian state for work we never complain saying no one speak mother tongue. Only this Hindi speaking people raise this problem.
yes bro
Yeah north indians think the world revolves around them..a few months back i saw a video where a north indian guy had gone to Japan to work for a long period of time and complaining that Japanese people don't speak english. if u go to a place for long time learn to be like locals😂😂😂.
👏
@@YazhiniS-kn8ziif u go north do u speak Hindi or englush if u speak English even u imposing English on north people.
Due to English we already lost everything as telugu state person no one speaking pure telugu except tinglish telugu with mix of English
Instead of English hindi why cant we move to samskrith?
U people do not have idea even north people learning south language teaching south languages why we hate hindi no need English in india i hope and i suggest samskrith should be link language
English should be promoted more than Hindi as Secondary Language
1. English is global language. Widely used in business and even in technical languages
2. None of Indian have English as Mother Tongue. So every Indian should put same effort to learn English. It means every Indian is equally treated in terms of learning a secondary language.
In India, English should be link language between states and union. Its not about foreign language its about people should equally treated
In laymen terms, One general size door is enough to enter into house instead of having seperate doors for fat, tall and short persons,
yes
Sensible opinion
Anna durai lives in your comment. This should be pinned.
english is the language we use in offices or official purpose not the language to be used in public
Regional languages :
Tamil- Tamilnadu
Malayalam - Kerala
Kannada - KA
Telugu- AP , Tel
Tulu also spoken in KA
Rajastani
Gujrati
Kashmiri
Ladhaki
Marathi
Bengali
Odia
Assamme
Hindi- United province( how many times You can divide keep dividing)also Regional language
Link Language = English ✅
We are indians and already united that's more than enough.
Respect everyone and all languages. Our mother tongue is the same as my mother.
The whole of India was speaking Tamil before 4000 years( oor or pur is a Tamil word, jaipur, udaipur, kanpur, Madura or Madurai) all are Tamil places. can we make Tamil as a common language to create a united province?
@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history
I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi
That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries
My brother opened you eyes
Isn't that irony
Daii lusus😂Its Hyderabadis urdu nawas land...telgus go out
Even Malayalam kannadam Hindi spoken in Tamil Nadu so also add this
@@KumarVelu-i3u வாழ்க
Oh wait Bengaluru is not developed by North Indians...It's because of visionary thoughts by Kings, Engineers, Policymakers of Karnataka and Kannada people..
Even we can say that North Indian states need South Indian tax money ...if you say Bengaluru is developed by NI , then all NI go to your home state and develop it
Well said 🎉
@@rvPravasi ❤️ super bro
Example of development is UP - the shithole of India
Well said 🎉🎉
They are beggars can't able to develop thier states 😅 first and they are saying they developed bengaluru 😅
Kannada is the heart & soul of Bengaluru.
@@Albetroz1415 🤣🤣🤣 not banglore
Needless to say
isn't Kannada is the heart & sole of KA (instead of Blor alone ) hahahah ??? - ur already making discrimination by separating Blor from KA
@@moorthy001no man Bengaluru means Karnataka, Karnataka means all its districts and capital city....😅
@@cartoonbaby5711
Get lost beggar😅
Go to u r shit shates😅😅😅
So if a person from South India moves to Delhi, he/she should learn Hindi but a person from North comes to South states, the whole state should learn Hindi to be able to communicate to that person?!
How is the North Indian can be so privileged?
Yes because in the south there are many languages
But Hindi works everywhere
Honestly people against Hindi are just pure dumb
It gives you access to so much more
Many languages = One country
One language = Many countries
😂 very true 🔥
😂 amachuputta thalaiva...
Hindi is from Persian language family. Then how it can be called national language of India!!🤔
@@Shyamkumar-e7z9i who say it's Persian????? It's indian and mother of all languages is Sanskrit
@@From004 then let's learn samskrutham and tamil...
It's Persian family language only not even indian.
@@From004do some research about where sanskrit orginated and hindi originated. Speak with facts. Sanskrit is a indo- EUROPEAN language. There has been enough archeological evidence to suggest that. Hindi is a mix of sanskrit and Urdu.
@@srijagadeeshc3056 Hindi comes out of Sanskrit language and the language you are talking about is Urdu which may sound similar to Hindi for non Hindi speakers but it is very much different than Hindi. In Hindi we say red colour as "Lal" but in Urdu it is "Surkh". So calling Hindi a Persian language is very much coming out of misconception.
@@keshavkumar-bl6im sanskrit is itself an outsider language...
If anybody wants a national language, then ENGLISH solves the problem.
Instead of learning HINDI, English is a better choice.
@@kiran.h.d then go to USA and UK this is not your father Britain land understand you Christian missionary local languages enough to speak in any states. I'm from Maharashtra I support local languages instead english
मला माझ्या मराठीवर प्रेम आहे मी मराठीसाठी मरेन मला इंग्रजी येत नाही गेट हरवलेले ख्रिश्चन वडील.
@@kiran.h.d whatever language working majority speaks at a place at the time, it would be common sense for one to learn that very language instead of imposing one language over others.
no foreign lang as national understood
why english not japany or spanish?
@@kiran.h.d yeah some of people think just because 60% Indians speaking Hindi they think like almost everyone speaks and it should be national launguage. They should understand 40% is not small number as it denotes entire South India. So, first of India is not just India. If any foreigner displays a map without pok, then people get mad at them so, why they're excluding South India in this matter by thinking entire India speaks Hindi almost. This is ignorance. So, English is universal language and it should be common since India is very diverse.
ಹಿಂದಿ ನೆ ಏಕೆ ಲಿಂಕ್ ಲ್ಯಾಂಗ್ವೇಜ್ ಆಗಬೇಕು ಪ್ರಾದೇಶಿಕ ಭಾಷೆಗಳು ಕೂಡ ಲಿಂಕ್ ಲ್ಯಾಂಗ್ವೇಜ್ ಆಗಬಹುದಲ್ಲ. ಹಾಗಾಗಿ ನಮ್ಮ ಭಾಷೆ ನಮ್ಮ ಹೆಮ್ಮೆ
@@Vinayyg2000 so suppose I want to communicate with you how can we communicate if we doesn't have common languages.
Either I have to learn yours or you learn my language.
@@Deads0ul999 ENGLISH is there. That's enough.
@@Deads0ul999 u actually given the solution simple learning either parties language will put a full stop for the debate and english
@@Deads0ul999learn a neutral language which is used all over the world-English not Hindi or Sanskrit.
@@Deads0ul999 Learn English so that you can communicate all over the world.
From Kolkata saying we will not accept Hindi as national language , never, never,for it agar Civil war bhi karna pade karenge , India is not for North Indians only 😡
@@LAMdia7 hello who pressuring you to speak Hindi , your mouth your choice what you speak
You also hindi is not your mother language. @@AdityaRaj-pu1ox
wow 1st time hearing a north indian friend against hindi😂 nice bro
When this discussion came in 1948 in the constituent assembly leaders from non hindi speaking asked same
question. You want whole India or Hindi India?.Then only they have decided include all the 14 languages in the 8 th scdedule. Now it is 22 languages
Your comments deliver your mentality 😂😂 get well soon
தமிழ் சுமார் 5,000 ஆண்டுகள் பழமையானது என மதிப்பிடப்பட்டுள்ளது. இருப்பினும், தமிழின் ஆரம்பகால எழுத்துக் கணக்கு சுமார் 2,500 ஆண்டுகள் பழமையானது.
When I moved to TN for a job, I learned Tamil. Now I can read the above comment, I am self taught.
That's what we tamilians are also saying.Myself can read, write and speak hindi. Here everyone is liberal to learn anything if they actually want. But imposing is not acceptable at all.
संस्कृत 10000 साल पुराना है ।परन्तु लिखित विवरण 3000 साल पूर्ण है ।
और वैसे भी तमिल अफ्रीका की भाषा है । 😂😂😂😂
@@prabhayashwanth6271यार भाई इनको हिंदी के लिए कोई फोर्स नहीं करता । इनके यहां राजनीति ही भाषा के आधार पर होती है । 😂😂😂
न्यू एजुकेशन पॉलिसी क्या था । लेकिन फिर भी इन सालों को नफरत है उतर भारत के लोगों से
Hindi as a link language❌️ English as a link language ✅️....learn a language only if u like or want or have a need...as simple as that..forcing a native of a state to learn a language which is alien to them just coz u don't know for eg tamil or English should not be my problem, u come here u learn language...when we go ti north indian or any other state we will learn the local language..as simple as that.
If ppl come with lame excuses like hindi is majority or how uneducated ppl will speak English...then how ppl in tamilnadu who are uneducated will speak hindi?...atleast even uneducated tamil person will try to speak in English. So learn english ,state lang and u already know ur mother tongue...so its already 3 languages for many ppl...u come here u learn, when we go we will learn simple❗️
@@Santhosh10KumarYou are ready to learn the language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history
I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi
That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries
My brother opened you eyes
Isn't that irony
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 lol English is the link language no wonder you are typing in that.
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 mf giving the same reply to every comment why the f are u commenting in a colonial language. If u are not imposing then just stfu. literally imposing learn english over hindi and saying i am not imposing.
😂@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 ya it's an irony that u wrote it in english...and 90% of the comments r in english
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 The same thing applies to northies also, who are shamelessly living in Blore for many years and not learning even a single word of Kannada. is kannada is not the langauge of india. Enough of slavery in name of nationalism. Stop hindi imposition, we dont need you. You people are no different from the british. Atleast british gave us good infrastructure, but you people are living on our hard earned money and tax and imposing an useless langauge on us. Learn kannada when you are karnataka, and it is as per constitution also
Bangalore is developed because of Mysore King's,Kempegowda and other good British. The IT domain took advantage of it to grow.
Exactly 👍
@@kiran.h.d absolutely, it was developed before IT revolution, northies couldn’t do shit in their place and keep migrating to our place
💯 % ✅️
Disagree. Just find out how much tax and revenue the IT industry has brought to Karnataka.
100% true bro
"Don't speak kannada,that is totally ok,but,but,do not ask us to speak in Hindi in Karnataka........"
Love your stand!😍
Don't speak and use hindi in South, use in your north just simple.
True
17:52 with all due respect, i humbly disagree with the point being raised here.
Bangalore and Hyderabad's development should ve attributed to visionaries such as S.M.Krishna and Chandrababu Naidu. The ecosystem created by the local administration had led to the development and economy. Talent from various parts of the country could come and thrive here.
S m Krishna is a legend
not just bangalore and Hyderabad every developed city in north and western india like chennai Mumbai Pune is due to the strong and visionary state leadership and a progressive society in these states. Migrants from north just came here to reap the benefits as their state leader are not capable and they as a society have failed with their backwardness.
These northies always try to create a narrative that their panipuri, toilet cleaners created IT industries in hyderabad, bangalore and chennai........ 😂😂😂😂
Just wondering Y North Indian states like UP, Bihar, Jharkhand is still under developed. Before contributing to Southern state's development, they could have developed their own states first.
It's mutual benefit. Without policymakers there's no infrastructure. But without talent there's no use or revenue from the infrastructure.
We are indians and already united that's more than enough.
Respect everyone and all languages. Our mother tongue is the same as my mother.
The whole of India was speaking Tamil before 4000 years( oor or pur is a Tamil word, jaipur, udaipur, kanpur, Madura or Madurai) all are Tamil places. can we make Tamil as a common language?
That's just ur fantasy.
@@gpremkumar2015 bro there is no evidence for your claim.
@@Vivek9052qw Ramayana and Mahabharata are also Mythology 😂😂
@@ShivanshThakur-sh8ub that is true ...Jali kya
@@Vivek9052qw because you don't know the real history and Tamil language 😊
ಚೇತನ್ ಸರ್ ಮಾತುಗಳು ತುಂಬಾ ಅರ್ಥಪೂರ್ಣ ಹಾಗು ಹೃದ್ಧಯದಿಂದ ಬಂಡವಾಗಿತ್ತು❤😊
In linguistic issue, Tamil Nadu have been handling in good way. Since 1967, TN Follows two language policy meanwhile Rest of the South Indian States follow Tri Language policy. TN people do not want Non-Tamil speakers to speak in Tamil while KA follows Hindi as their third language but want others to speak in Kannada. KA literally don't know how to handle the linguistic issue and Anti Hindi agitation. Teaching Hindi in Schools but Anti Hindi agitation in Public. #Non sense thoughts
I think tri lang is better for every states to follow so that they can not face any difficulty if they go in other states
@@Vijayakumar_V_Kannan other south indian states are not showing guts to oppose the oppressors of Hindi belt. Karnataka my state is suffering very badly due to Hindi influx. All the government forms, bank forms are either in English or Hindi. Great injustice to my brother village folks who cannot understand both. And my brother Kannadigas are still sleeping while kannada is being erased from the land.
Great 👏👏
@jawan451 That's non sense. English for the universal connect. Mathematics/science need english. Mother tongue is enough. If u want learn at home.
North India also has so called STATES and they are also coming down to south, how many north indian states are teaching Kannada or Tamil???? and South India is far more developed the North Indian states, so the number of people going out of karnataka to north india is far less than people from north coming to karnataka. your point has no logic, Karnataka has 6Crore population, and if only 10 lakh kannadigas going outside, you are teaching the nonsense Hindi to remaining 5.9 crore kannadigas!!! understood your logic? if a shoe or chappel does not fit to your foot, you have to trim the shoe not your own foot~~ Proud Tamilian. (tell me have you ever attended any interview in Hindi when you been to Mumbai or Delhi?)
Just take one aspect about movies, for instance. How the Gujrathi, Bhojpuri, punjab or even marathi movies are struggling to make a footprint due to Hindi and over presence of Bollywood, and on the other hand, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam and Kananda movies are thriving. This is only because we are preserving the language, culture and arts. Once you loose your language you loopse your soul.
Agreed, as being Marathi
Good ,the same view I given my comments in so many debates .
@@sandipmore814marathi gujarathi oriya punjabi...films loosing their identity bcos bollywood.swallowed completely
NORTH INDIANS ARE FULL OF HINDI SUPERIORITY COMPLEX FOR NO REASON. WHAT IS THE HISTORY OF HINDI VSS SOUTH INDIAN LANGUAGES? FIRST LEARN TO GIVE RESPECT TO STATE LANGUAGES AND REMEMBER STATES WERE CERETAED BASED ON NATIVE LANGUAGE.
Being a person from Tamilnadu, I can say that Tamils try to speak broken native languages of the states that we visit.
The only thing we hate is blatant imposition of Hindi upon us.
Stalinite 😂😂😂
You Don't only have culture But We have our Own Mother Tongue like Bhojpuri, Maithili, Angika but We can Speak Hindi or English
@@EternalScreams thats ur wish to speak any lang hindi or anything...but for us theres no need sir thats the hard reality..without any use on anywhere in our life why should we learn hindi???
@@AkshatSingh0501 cow dung belt 😂
@@EternalScreamsyou speak hindi we don't want to speak hindi we protect our language at any cost it. Our ancestors protected now we will. Tamil world' oldest language🔥💪
I like Chetan sir's argument and take...
Proud to be Indian 🇮🇳
Rooted by Kannadiga...💛❤️
@@SangameshGadadavar-f4o ಏನ್ ಬದನೇಕಾಯಿ ಹೇಳಿದ? ಇಂಡಿಯನ್ ಆದ್ರೆ ನಮ್ ಮೇಲೆ ಈಗ ಇರೋ ಹೇರಿಕೆ ತಪ್ಪಿ ಹೋಯ್ತಾ?
Am ready to give up my nationality for my identity.
@@sarcasticman666. Me Too
@@sarcasticman666. ನಿಜ 💛❤️
So separate kannada country okay na?
hindi might be official language, bring tamil has national language which is oldest and mother of all indian languages . can u accept this
they wont bro but ok atleast engkish is fine in south but not hindi
Samskrith is the mother of all languages in India
If you are going to non hindi speaking places learn their language... If a non hindi speaking guy going to hindi speaking place try to learn hindi...problem is if a hindi guy going to anyplace he is not ready to learn any other language but impose their language on others.. Thats real problem..
In India, Tamil is a completely Indian-origin language. Sanskrit, hindi ect not origin from indian land.
U r Just a fool 😂😂commenting without knowledge
Sanskrit is indian origin due to Christian missionaries English became imposed language in south
True
Well said.Sankrit is not native Indian language.It has european influence. Every Indian should learn Tamil.
Only Kannada for Karnataka. No Hindi in Karnataka please.
once it become link language slowly they make it national language 😮 so many languages loosing their identity because of Hindi 😢 dear north Indians don't competitive with south India but rest of the world 😮
1.)If Hindi people can't read English because English is very different. Same logic Hindi is very different than Tamil . So we also can't read
2.) If we can learn English
You can also learn English.
English is spoken all over world and is useful in this globalisation era for employment.
3.) In everyone ' s phone we have translators. In next 10 years even one language will be enough to communicate with not only the nation but with entire world.😂😂😂
Maximum 2 languages
Minimum 1 language
Period ✅
True
Even in north india Hindi is killing other languages hindi imposition is also in North India
Atleast south languages name known to everyone but not single north language known to everyone 😢
3:08 Hindi Should not be a Nationl language or link language to connect people..Why we need to learn Hindi??
Let India connect with diverse culture language and culture respect each ..
Once who come for livelihood or job should learn regional language
Hindi has annihilated dozens of native languages in East Panjab, NWP, CP, BP & various Kingdoms of Great British Raj.Dravidian movement is most inclusive it guided Anna, Karunanidhi & MGR.Reading Periyar & Dr Ambedkar is important to understand Endia.
@@Mubashirhassan-mf3qk
Great British Raj
🤣🤣
@mahesharaja You shall learn language of those who have exploited us and looted our mother country and but you can't learn the language that the millions of our brothers and sisters speak from history
I am not saying that you should not learn our regional language but you should learn both regional and Hindi
That is not imposing instead british imposed English on all colonial countries
My brother opened you eyes
Isn't that irony
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776if we rewind back some 3500 years back, You will see Aryan Languages invading our homeland. Why did you guys learn these languages?
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776 Whether you like it or not, English has become an international language. You can travel all over the world with English including China. At least that is what my experience has been during my recent visit to China. You can also move around in north india with English alone. I am from south, but did all my college education in Chandigarh. I could easily live my life there with English alone. Why do I need to waste my time in learning something I am not interested in? Instead, I spent my time in learning science.
@@philomath-mohitgupta4776bitching about English in English 🤡😂 LOL
ಭೌಗೋಳಿಕವಾಗಿ ನಾನು ಭಾರತೀಯ.. ಸಂಸ್ಕೃತಿ ಹಾಗು ಸಂಪ್ರದಾಯದ ಭಾಷೆ ಮತ್ತು ನೆಲದಿಂದ ನಾನು ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ ..ನನ್ನ ಭಾಷೆ ಕನ್ನಡ..ನನ್ನ ಧರ್ಮ ಕನ್ನಡ.. ನನ್ನ ಸಂಸ್ಕೃತಿ ಕನ್ನಡ..
ಜೈ ಕನ್ನಡಾಂಬೆ ..ಜೈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ಜೈ ಕನ್ನಡ ನಾಡು ..
ಕರ್ಣಾಟ ಬಲಂ ಅಜೇಯಂ..❤️🫶
Tamil is indigenous to India. And all Dravid languages. Sanskrit is an indo european language.
@@ParisBaguetteChannel-y1dஅந்த தேவிடிய பசங்களுக்கு தெரியாது
No man Sanskrit is Indian origin
These five teachers are like five Pandavas💪 watching them together is a pleasure for us
We need these kind of debates on serious issues from time and time again, these are really fascinating and worth watching ❤
I think let's learn English and advice to everyone to learn English. It will be a better way and due to this our country will be an educated country .
mean learning English will make I educated
@@jawan451 engineering, doctors, CA and so many reputed jobs are in English. So English is a must 🤦
Those who thinks that English is not our Language and hence learn Hindi. Let me tell you Hindi is also not our language. It’s your language. I don’t want to be a second grade citizen in my own country where Hindi speakers feel superiors to the rest just like how Americans or English 🏴 feel. Now the problem is , you want me to learn Hindi and feel insecure while talking in Hindi as if English alone is not enough. Now coming to India’s economy, IT is the key contributor for India where speaking English plays the key role. Now by learning Hindi, what do you expect out of me ? Let’s be honest. Stop this nonsense of Spreading Hindi.
We ,the people of west bengal don't want this hindi imposing.
Tamil is considered one of the oldest living languages in the world:



Age
Tamil is estimated to be around 5,000 years old. However, the earliest written account of Tamil is only about 2,500 years old.

Speakers
Tamil is spoken by around 78 million people in India, Sri Lanka, Singapore, and Malaysia. It is the official language of Tamil Nadu and is also spoken in Sri Lanka.
@@sureshkumarc
Tamil isn't the oldest language. Tamil was derived from a proto Dravidian language as all other south Indian languages.
@@sureshkumarc tamil♥️♥️
@@arunkumarbkoyilandy Sanskrit is not an old language derived bro pro ariyan language 💩🤣
Tamil 😂...just a tatti
@@arunkumarbkoyilandy pls don't comment nonsense our great Tamil language is created by sage agathiya ma munivar by the order of lord Shiva n lord muruga
English should be the National language
Any South Indian says we are South Indians the phrase given by North Indians in every matter
in Tamil Nadu we say, any north indian as Pani puri language speaker.
No need of hindi as national language, telugu is enough. For communication purpose English is enough.
Keep the north indian regional language hindi to its place only, dont use and expect in south india.
I'll Only say one thing. 99% of people living in Bangalore who have migrated here and living here for 5 years or more, don't even know even the basic phrases of Kannada, and they feel entitled to not learn Kannada and survive here and live here by knowing Hindi, and so, they expect localities to learn, know and speak Hindi. That's the whole problem of it.
I personally have no issues with Hindi per se.. but, it's not just regional chauvinism that's the reason for these conflicts recently. There are deeper issues of migrants taking the welcoming localities for granted and not even trying to assimilate into the society by putting basic efforts into learning local language, if they are settling in that place for long term.
Especially because, today I hear more Hindi than Kannada in Bangalore and that's only possible if localities are welcoming and accomodating enough to learn and speak in Hindi to accomodate migrant population. But the reverse that is migrant population who have been staying here for the long term are not even trying to assimilate or at least try to learn basics of local language, and that's the root of the problem... And because of it even the temporary settlers are facing issues because of the locals with extreme views.
- My opinion is that no one should force anyone to speak in either hindi or Kannada. It has to be voluntary. Bangalorians in fact have learnt Hindi and have always spoke hindi and are open to speak in hindi, and were welcoming till few years back. But, the migrant people have taken advantage of it and many don't even put efforts in learning basics of it or even are open to learn Kannada. It shows how the migrant people who are even settling in Bangalore are entitled and are reluctant to learn Kannada as a gesture of appreciation and mutual respect, as well as an additional skill that'll help them Navigate situations with ease, by knowing the local language.
@15:24 When the auto wala in Bangalore told why speak Hindi, this is Karnataka, speak in Kannada, the person can always say, "I'm here temporarily and it's difficult or impractical to learn"... Instead they became defensive and started saying "why should I learn kannada, you are India and you should learn Hindi". Here, Auto wala forcing the passengers to speak in Kannada is also wrong, and the passengers are also wrong, acting like entitled brats, I'll not learn kannada at all, you only have to speak in hindi.
Irrespective of the political games, that politicians play...
Mutual respect is the only solution to all of this.
- I myself have experienced genuine hindi acceptance organically in Bangalore multiple times, when the Auto driver became happy, acknowledged when I tried to speak in broken kannada with them, and he only switched to hindi to make me comfortable. This is the beauty of MUTUAL RESPECT.
@30:52 individually a family came and settled in Bangalore, and they speak a different language in their home,which is fine. But them expecting everyone they encounter outside their home, to speak in hindi with them is also wrong. They have to at least put efforts into learning basics of the local language as a sign of appreciation for local culture, since they are settling there, that shows localities that the mutual respect they are asking for, and localities will also reciprocate with them by speaking in Hindi. That's what is needed. It can't be a one way street. And this is not happening...
Of course, localities shouldn't expect the temporary migrants to learn Kannada, BUT THE FACT THAT even the long term settlers are also not open to learn local language and the localities have to adjust and speak in hindi to accomodate the migrants, while migrants being insensitive to local culture and are not even putting any efforts from their side to assimilate with localities... And this issue has come to such a point that some localities are saying enough is enough, everyone should speak in Kannada, which is the other end of toxicity.
MUTUAL RESPECT AND NOTHING ELSE.... Can actually help in Hindi acceptance, and the effort has to be put by long term migrant population to show the respect and acknowledgement to localities and local culture, so that localities won't feel threatened or taken for granted for being welcoming to migrants (which has been the case in past 2 decades)...
@31:20 Here the assumption of pro-hindi side, that long term settlers are learning the local language is totally false, as that's very very rare... And this is the ground level reality that has caused unrest in locals which the selfish politicians are taking advantage of... By putting fuel in fire.
@35:00 this is the accomodating nature of the localities... To accomodate migrants from TN, AP, Kerala and all other parts of the country by knowing those languages to facilitate communication...
@ 35:08 is exactly my point!! The willingness...
Not even able to learn or speak, or difficulty, logistics, etc... but basic willingness and openness... For long term migrants. That's all there is to it.
@35:19 people in south may or may not be more willing to learn languages to accomodate others... But majority of the people from North definitely don't. This is not a generalization.
It's an observation from a temporary migrant like me who has learnt basic kannada, staying in Bangalore for 6 years and whose friends, acquaintances, etc are all from North India and almost none of them know even one single word in Kannada even though they're living in Bangalore for more than 5 years. And all these people they don't even see the need or even have a willingness to learn local language, just because they are comfortable here and getting by using Hindi ... ONLY BECAUSE the localites are accomodating and speak in Hindi to facilitate better communication. But it's only one way Street that's the problem here .. at grass root level.
Of course another main hurdle is also that there are no good language learning apps that teach Indian languages even in Apps like Duolingo only Hindi so there.. which is very unfortunate. Such apps are missing out on a huge market.
Hema bindu mam speaks my problem.
I am from Karnataka and I learned hindi as a 3rd language class 6th to 10th why ?
Till date i don't know, why I learned hindi in karnataka.
My opinion is that hindi is already imposing and imposed in karnataka, That should be stopped in future.
I'm a Tamilian, personally I believe that learning Hindi as 3rd or additional language during childhood had helped me a lot in career.
If you see in workplace, most north indians understadn and speak Hindi. And if you learn Hindi because of your interest or as an additional language, it is very helpful for you.
यार भाई जरा ये बताना तुम्हे हिंदी के लिए कैसे फोर्स किया जाता है । जो तुमलोग इतने झूठ बोलते हो 😂😂
@@warrior_rana_108 Nobody is telling lie just look at urself when the comment is in English ur replying in Hindi this is enough Mister how u guys imposing Hindi on us if at the same time I reply u in a KANNADA are u able to reply Me so first don't tell lie and don't impose ur language on us if 3 language system imposing on use at the same time 3 language system also to be added on Hindi speaking states also
Level of this amazing debate is unbeatable
It's a wow moment ..
I think the north India should learn English so that we can exist with one link language for the world instead of one for the country & one for global connect !
States are divided by linguistic diversity why then hindi alone be given prominent. English will be the link language. It will help as link language all over the world.
There r no "both sides" .English is the link language for all Indians ,NOT HINDI My mother is NOT HINDI .. I speak Marathi,Kannada daily and i think in ENGLISH .The mother tongue of Kanandigas,tamilians,malayalis ,telugus,Bengalis,Marathis Assamese,sikkimese,odiyas,himachalis,Punjabis,Goans,Kashmiris ,Manipuris is NOT HINDI
these people say migrants cant speak kannada. but they expect the auto driver, some watchman, hotel waiter, shopkeeper, everyone in the southern state to learn their native language for culture, english for jobs, and then to learn hindi to satisfy these hypocrites
height of hooliganism. nonsense north indians. We should speak only kannada in karnataka.
Look at what happened to Cantonese after Mandarin became the official language. You will loose a regional language when one is important than the other. Forcing Hindi to be an official language in India will lead to demise of other regional languages. So, ENGLISH. India will benefit nationally and internationally.
How many POLITICIANS who wants to make Hindi as National language, Are their sons/daughter are studying in HINDI MEDIUM ??
There is already a link language that is english. We can link the whole world. Not just indian languages.Some people from hindi belt are simply entitled they just expect all to serve them and to speek hindi. There are many cases of students that commit suicide due to language bullying who go to the north to study. Many don't feel safe from south to go to north to study they would rather try to find college in the south or go abroad. When they come here and speek hindi we try to understand or communicate in some way but in north they won't even stop and try to listen most of them just walk away even if they understand what u say in broken hindi or english I have personally experienced this. Why should I spend my time learning a language that is not of any use to me day to day in my life . Its so double standard to expect me to spend hours to this cause I will happily do so if in hindi states they have compulsory learning of one of the other indian language other than hindi compulsory too. This way both are spending time in learning a language that they will never use.
Are you talking about karnakata just replace hindi with kannada. Then you will see what is happening in Bengaluru.... Ek din ganda wala faso
Hindi already suppressed mati, bhojpuri, Rajasthan, marathi in this 75years of imposition
@@ramesha840 add Punjabi, Bengali, Oriya, Telugu in Hyderabad, and North East languages
Yes the bjp government wantedly naming all central government schemes in Hindi. Naturally the southern states feel letdown.
Also those who from north like to communicate only in hindi. This hurts the locals like autowalas, tea shop etc, So they respond in local language.
English should be made as link language bcz students atleast go to school and learn English,(literacy may increase) If hindi, then no need for going school. Your debate itself is in English.
It's already a link language! English is the only language accepted as a 2nd administrative language from every state of India (after their state's official language), that's why english is everywhere.
North India and South India are very different. Not only linguistically, but also in many other areas. India is a country that was created only through the freedom fight.
South indians don;t belong to the north indian race . We are different.
U better be scared to conduct this debate in Tamil country. Tamil language is mother for all cultures around India. Tamil must be a national language culturally.
Tamil is oldest language we agree but don't say it's mother of all culture if my mother born before your mother doesn't mean your father born from my father?
As a North Indian citizen: Simple answer "NO".
I enjoyed this session ❤ ಚೇತನ್ ಸರ್ ನಿಲುವು ❤
When south indian moves to north they never cries that people are speaking in thier mother tongue
This is the level of debate you have when knowledgeable persons interact. So much constructive and intriguing.
You have forgotten to mention here that Tamil was the mother language of Telugu, kannada, Malayalam, tulu, coorgi etc, for that matter.
We should give preference to ENGLISH than any other languages. It will help India and Indians to elevate to better level
Happy to see our awesome educators in single frame... 🙏 Loved it..
தமிழ் தேசியம். தமிழ் மொழி.
Learning hindi or any language is not a.problem, but forcing hindi should learn compulsory which is given highest priority this is not accepted by us.
Hindi is as a link is unfair for non hindi speaking ppl and an advantage for hindi speakers...we are forced to learn to speak to a guy whose mother tongue is hindi when our language is not...when English is a link language....it is fair for both of us to learn a new language....all sophisticated and well off north indians learn English, go to USA and will not let the underprivileged to grow up by pushing propaganda like English is a colonial hangover bs.
if you feel english is colonial hangover then make Tamil as link language (since majority of Indians understand Hindi so logically they come to a decision of making Hindi as link language. if that logic applies India has majority of Hindus so lets announce Hindu as national religion, and mosquitoes as national bird because there are more mosquitoes than peacocks
Bro understand my comment properly...we on same side😂
If a nation, as complex as India is, need one language. Then the spirit of India is dead and should be split into different countries through referrundum
Make Tamil the language of India .Oldest living language in the world !
I love the way chethan sir talking
South Indians are extremely hypocrite when it comes to language. I am a Bengali, I live in Kolkata. I know Bengali, English and Hindi. Punjab, Kashmir, Ladakh, Gujrat, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, You name any north Indian state they have 3 language policies.
It's the South Indians who either know two languages i.e English (which they say it's used to travel the world) and the second is their own mother tongue.
Why Hindi is being substituted (not imposed) because even the villages in remote North Indian villages know their mother tongue and Hindi. But if you do compare it to a remote south indian villager, they'll only know their mother tongue. They might not be privileged enough to learn English. Both will struggle in different states.
Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil and Telegu combine barely make max 30% of speakers however 70% of India can speak Hindi. If you wanna to debate me on this in a civil manner without throwing insults, sure do comment your thoughts and expect a response.
Chetan sir and Abhishek sir both look so alike that I always thought they are same person. I have been following the Hindu analysis session for last 3 months.
They both are just amazing. Got to learn so much!
Tamil and english ❤ telugu and english ❤ malayalam and english ❤ Kannada and English ❤ accepted in southern languages
EXCELLENT !!!
Then u killing all south languages through English
No one speak pure telugu in telugu states due to English if we speak English what about telugu
In telugu we have saying పళ్ళు ఊడగొట్టుకోవడానికి ఏ రాయి అయితే ఏంటి even through English we already lost telugu we closed all telugu medium schools are we preserving language?
You don't need to carve out a small Dog door in a Big door, the Big door is enough for lot of things. We have English in school no matter where you are in India. So why 3 language policy for few state and 1 language policy for few states? Just keep 2 language policy like Tamilnadu. State language + English language is much more enough.
Well said, indirectly that making Hindi because of most number of people understand that language in north. is just like announcing DOG as national animal since there are more dogs than tigers in India.!~!
I am frm Tamil Nadu we not against hindi language and I myself worked in Mumbai, Delhi, hyderabad, Kolkata as bank manager I have learned hindi within 3 months and hence if need we will learn and communicate. Don't make it as a policy every govt communications should be written in hindi only that we don't accept Dr that u should understand & U should give space to other linguistic languages Dr and respect Dr.
How maturity should be resembled, just look at Mukesh Sir...The best podium ever with regards to other 4 pillars...❤Blessed to have you all...
hes biased to hindi speakers
Let's have link language as English, we all should start from same point
Linguistic Nationalism and Linguistic Chauvinism are both equally berserk concepts! Respecting each other's culture and accepting diversity are the features that made India the melting pot of civilisations. We must never let go of these fundamental features of Indian society by falling into the trap of political entities!
Sir really i am very happy because when i heard chethan sir form Karnataka ❤😍 and i never saw such a top notch teacher in International relations Hat's off you sir 🙏
ನಮ್ಮ ಭಾಷೆ ನಮ್ಮ ಹೆಮ್ಮೆ💛❤️💛❤️
There is no need to impose one language as national language. Excellent dabate sir/mam
Hindi is not even a classical language but some wants to be is as a national language.
Q: But Hindi is the most spoken language in India so it should be National Language Right?
SIMPLE LOGIC : Okay. Let's make crow and dogs as our National bird and animal because we have more of it. 😂
We don't want Hindi, force Hindi and u see divided India.
Language is an emotion and it's culture lives in it. Respecting the culture with humility and respect is a much needed aspect from everyone. Touching that emotion for political play is one of the worst thing that a politician can do, and those who does must def be an incompetent one, who lacks knowledge and wisdom to lead a country or a State for that matter.
Marathis Bengalis Gujarathis Punjabis never opposed Hindi imposition and made Hindi imposition easy for hindians
Bhojpuris Awadhis Mewadis Rajasthanis Gardhwali Maithilis Haryanvis Himachalis don’t even know that Hindi has grossly weakened their languages and culture
Tamils Kannadigas are right in negating Hindi as so called link language
All South Indians learning Hindi when they move north for opportunities or government jobs to run their lives. But South Indian should learn Hindi to accommodate you to be comfortable when you move to south for opportunities or jobs ? What is this ?
37:47 the way Samad sir asking is amazing. Great work Unacademy.
Don’t call the word Bimaru just because of poor and unstable govt. these states are behind southern part of India.
Why do always people who initiate the first attack and atrocious claim have to dictate the nature of the conflict?. Why should there be a war considering we are talking about assigning national language to a country like India which is not a nation in first place?. It's a union formed by mutual agreement between various other smaller nations like EU.
*Imagine French want to dictate that every other nation inside EU should use french has their national language. And label the rejection from rest of union member as a act of war.*
The audacity of the person to use this title.
I just want to put my thoughts
1. If there is a aspect of mini languages like Tulu, Coorgi diminishing in the shadow of Kannada, same is the case with other languages diminishing under the umbrella Hindi.
2. For a certain section of hindi speaking migrants people coming into southern Indian states, learning hindi by all itself is disparity. And it's imposition.
3. Hindi as a link language lags very much in academic terms like scientific terms but English serves this purpose. In this regard it would be difficult to learn for southern states people to learn Hindi as a link language, English as a academic language.
4. Imagine a student(from southern state) failing in Hindi and scoring well in core subjects still held back in terms of marks and promoting to next class. We are already having this case.
5. Southern states still lacks in political representation just because population is the only criteria for the delimitation process. We need more criteria like progress, contribution to development, historical significance etc in delimitation process.
youre talking about about whats wrong with hindi, and I agree, but hindi must not be discarded I believe that will be actually a strategic mistake, hindi can be purified and developed into a more sanskritized form , and you can just using the roots develop new words for scientific terminology ,like how European researchers did with Latin and Greek in 15-19th century, that can also become a link language and most people I believe then will be comfortable, obviously retaining each regional language, Northeasterners will have to come to a compromise unfortunately ,anyways they cannot communicate with other tribes because of diff language, they had to develop nagamese for such, so a new such language should help that too, thats my 2 cents
@@sharanvknd Tulu, Kodava not at all developed their language academically since ages .
TULU and kodava people forget their language in kerala , but in karnataka they feel like diminshing .
Without karnataka tulu and kodava would have been dimnished .
point one, if a language is similar then it happens.(such as bhojpuri is a subset of Hindi) the major one will swallo the minors. but Hindi can never swallo kannada.
Best thing should be the topmost one. Then Tamil is the oldest language and every one should learn
U have to choose best thing by quality and not by quantity
I knew that the chethan sir is from Karnataka ❤😊😊😊