FINAL FANTASY II - Series Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
- / ludiscere
/ ludiscere
and a link to my Final Fantasy I video: • FINAL FANTASY I - Seri...
hello everyone! this is the second video in a series in which i will be going through every main series Final Fantasy game (and some others too probably) in order to give them a wee bit of in-depth analysis, and figure out what makes each individual FF game tick. i'll be focusing on various things like development history, gameplay analysis, and musical analysis, but i'll also be drawing from outside sources like linguistics and mythology to try and understand as much as possible why these games are the way they are, and why people love them so much.
if you got to the bit around 32 minutes in and decided it wasn't for you, i totally understand - here's the timestamp to get you past direct discussion about that part: 34:21
i refer to a few articles and ideas throughout the video. i'll link some stuff here in case you want to do some supplementary reading:
FF ranking list 1: www.digitalspy...
FF ranking list 2: www.digitaltre...
FF ranking list 3: whatculture.co...
FF ranking list 4: www.redbull.co...
interesting article on Nazi eugenics: www.bbvaopenmi...
some info about children in the Holocaust: encyclopedia.u...
Auschwitz Memorial Museum twitter: / auschwitzmuseum
fascinating info on how Darwin's work was misappropriated to be used politically: www.bl.uk/roma...
wikipedia article on child euthanasia in Nazi Germany: en.wikipedia.o...
wikipedia article on 'Lebensunwertes Leben': en.wikipedia.o...
info on the rhotic /r/ sound: en.wikipedia.o...
info on West Country accent and dialect specifically:
www.theocelot....
www.encycloped...
and if you'd like to hear it (you could also just watch Hot Fuzz for this):
• West Country Yap
if you're interested, the songs used in this video are:
Prelude (PSP) - 0:01
Main Theme (PSP) - 1:30
Ancient Castle (PSP) - 4:09
Battle Theme 1 (PSP) - 5:23
Battle Theme 2 (PSP) - 7:54
Main Theme (FFIV [SNES]) - 10:34
Cid's Theme (FFIX) - 13:19
Breaking Boundaries (FFXIV:BM) - 15:34
Procedamus in Pace (FFXIV:SB) - 17:24
Town (PSP) - 19:42
The Rebel Army (PSP) - 22:29
Chocobo Theme (NES) - 26:23
Aloha de Chocobo (FFIX) - 27:16
Dungeon (NES) - 28:56
Wandering (FFX) - 31:28
Theme of Suspicion (FFIV [DS]) - 35:56
Gau's Theme (FFVI) - 39:47
Prismelody: Pirates Ahoy (World of FF) - 41:32
Infiltrating Enemy Territory (Bravely Default) - 42:59
Find Your Way (FFVIII) - 44:33
Tower of the Magi (PSP) - 46:29
Castle Pandaemonium (PSP) - 46:54
The Red Wings (FFIV [SNES]) - 48:29
Battle Theme 2 (PSP) - 50:35
Finale (PSP) - 52:25
FF Main Theme (London Philharmonic Orchestra) - 55:39
ideally, i would rather only use music from the game in question, but it just wasn't possible in a video of this length. FFII's soundtrack is really good, but i definitely had to nick some other songs for the sake of having music that fit what i was talking about.
footage used throughout the video:
FFX sphere grid: • Kryllyk Plays FFX - Sp...
Takeshi's Castle: • Takeshi's Castle - Kno...
the rest of the footage was captured by me. but please check out the above videos and their creators!
finally, a huge thanks to my best pal Joe, without whom this channel would be much worse off. Joe has done all the art for my channel from its inception, from the old logo to the new black mage logo, the old intro and all the outros, and most recently the incredible art for my Patreon tiers! he is an immensely talented artist and an absolute legend so check him out:
/ steakjoe
/ steakjoeart
thank you all so much for reading this far and i sincerely hope you enjoyed the video!
alastair x 
Игры
Ludiscere is a wonderful content creator. A shame he isn't that big. However using as much objectivity as possible he's earned his spot at the top of my list of favorite youtubers.
Check out Mr. Gentlemen if you like criminally under subscribed content creators.
Also Alleyway Jack has good FF content too
There's no such thing as objectivity, but yeah these videos are very interesting.
Coming from the guy who wrote the ranking you cited at 00:23, this is a really good video 😊 I'm glad people have a soft spot for II, and I think the music and bones of the story are solid. If Square ever did a 3D remake (even up to graphical standards of something like Opera Omnia) I think they could really unlock the potential.
Looking forward to your other FF videos!
you deserve more subs! your content is really well presented and objective. finally, someone who appreciates ff2 ❤️
you're too kind, thank you!
@@Ludiscere us black mages need to stick together ;)
for real though, your editing is top notch and your content is great! thank you for your hard work, and I'm eagerly looking forward to your ff3 vid.
@@maybepolly_ Lol
Ludiscere for me your series analyses are now what I consider mandatory retrospectives to digest the game I had just played. Thank you very much for your work
Agreed!
I honestly love FF2 despite the flaws it has. its main theme is one of the most beautiful, somber pieces that i hold within my heart.
what i find the most interesting about the emperor is how he takes over both heaven and hell, and the fact he essentially won't die unless both halves were destroyed simultaneously. this was actually pretty intriguing.
i also found deumion's story in the arcane labyrinth interesting as it.. expands upon FF2's world lore with it having probably one of.. the most destructive magics in the series via the destroy tome, and one of the strongest white magics in revive
Oh fuck yes finally some appreciation for FF2, I'm gonna enjoy this
You’re definitely one of my favorite content creators!! I am always so excited to be able to watch any new videos you come out with, especially the Final Fantasy ones.
you're too kind. thank you :)
FF1 and FF2 are so darn epic. Love 'em both 🙂
I’ve played FF2 multiple times on the NES and this entry always fascinates me, that many people despise this game because of the gameplay, but they rarely pointed out other stuff, such as the themes, story, setting, characters, and how very well done it was for a game made back in 1988.
And I definitely agree that far too many rely on click bait, and that it centers around negativity.
I honestly much prever stuff that is well thought out and has a good balance between Positive and Negative aspects such as this game.
Sure I definitely agree that it’s not perfect, and that feel that having 16 levels is far to high, but people seem to forget that this is the 2nd entry, and there was no set formula for this game when it was made, which was why they were experimenting to see what will fit.
And there where many aspects of this game that I really enjoyed such as the Overworld, Music, Setting, the side characters, the new monsters, the new spells and items, and I was surprised by how very dark the story was that it made it very memorable.
Very glad to see someone who had the same appreciation as I had when playing this game. And I really enjoyed this video.
It's because it's too grindy. If the game wasn't so grindy it would've been a lot more enjoyable to play. I think the system, in and of itself, is fine, but they simply went too far with the grindiness.
40:33 - Funny thing is that there was a discarded idea about Guy's parents. When the group tries to enter the emperor's castle they have no way to access the place without being undetected, then a scene unfolds where some beasts are going to attack the group, only for Guy to recognize them as the family that took care of him when he was a baby. After this they help the group to enter the castle. Found this information in "Final Fantasy Ultimania Archive" Vol. 1
It would've been nice for him to have had a moment other than "Guy speak beaver".
I agree 100% with your text screenshot at 54:55. FFII Is shaping up to be a favorite FF of mine and I actually LOVE taking advantage of the grindy battle system! I went into II thinking it was bottom tier but that just doesn’t suit my tastes now that I’ve sunk my teeth into it. My all time favorite FF is VIII, again I loved taking full advantage of the “broken” system. It’s what’s most fun to me. I likes what I likes and I’m very pro FFII.
Such a great series of FF videos. I search RUclips for FF content all the time and finally tripped over them. Thank You
I absolutely love the level of detail and research you put into your videos. I’m only halfway through but I can tell already that this vid deserves more views. I’ve always heard from people that FF II has an interesting story but that part of the conversation always gets drowned out when people discuss its gameplay mechanics.
It's locke in your pfp!
Never forget how RABtoons adapted Scott's death: "Scott said he didn't love you, then he died."
Along with FF1, FF2 is my favorite in the series. I enjoy it too much in the PSP and i love the new art style that they give it to both remakes :D
I think out of all the Final Fantasy games 2 is one of the ones I most want to see a remake of. The fact that it has so many good ideas that don't come together right means that it could be something terrific if they gave it another shot.
I'm glad I found your channel as these FF analysis videos are very in depth and entertaining. Can't wait to check out some of your other videos and hope to see the FF III analysis someday :D
I'm rewatching these, after starting FF9 And 6, and while obviously the fantastic analysis is brilliant I can't get past the fact you actually did proper subtitles it helps my HOH self easily understand and I want to thank you.
31:45 That line right there is what made me fall in love with this game's plot. More than any of the named character deaths, that one guy talking about his dead daughter cut me deep.
Really refreshing review! I just beat FF2 for the first time, and I really enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would. Granted, I was playing the PSP version.
I never did much grinding, except with Ultima and Flare, and I never grinded by hitting myself. Anytime a new party member joined, their HP was around the same as my other members, so I figured I was on track with what the developers expected. It's not my favorite FF, but I'd say I enjoyed it about the same as FF1.
Same. Only I beat gba version.
So underrated, FF2 is a great, if tragic, tale. The leveling system is definitely where most hate comes from, that grind is no joke.
Edit: the cast and each of their stories are so wonderful and empathetic.
it's probably worthwhile to situate the final fantasy series' focus on fighting against evil empires with Japan's own empirical history.
I never played the game, but now I have to. This retrospective really made me see the value of FFII, great work!
It’s a proto SaGa game. It’s great.
This is a great video. I recently played the NES version of FFII for the first time and struggled to express what specifically I thought was good about it, but I think this video does a good job of explaining what makes this game so special.
This was definitely worth the wait.
I actually sort of want to try the game now. It may be tedious but those smaller character narratives you mentioned sound quite interesting. Thank you.
Currently playing the Gameboy Advance version on a retropi--it's very good.
The level up system isn't that bad, especially if you do all the fights. It requires a level of decision making early on, as in don't smother yourself with too many options. Carve a role for each character in terms of weapons and magic where each is unique to the others, and fight all the fights, and you will grow appropriately.
The high encounter rate is fine considering that's the whole point of the game.
It's very good, one of the games I have enjoyed most as of late.
Time for an actually good take on FF2 for once
Oh hell yeah lads this is gonna be a good evening
FF2 is a great game, it's definitely weaker that other FF games but still an important and extremly enjoyable jrpg ❤
Well, i prefer FF2 over the others.
to be fair, it did come out in 1988. Story wasn't a huge thing back then. It wasn't till 1989's Dragon Slayer VI: The Legend of Heroes and 1991's Final Fantasy IV that story started to become the main focus.
"Extremely fun", i like the game but i disagree its not that enjoyable. Its not terrible but i think it has a OK gameplay
It's only enjoyable if you like grinding a lot - the SaGa series (FF Legend 1,2,3) played a way better role in refining the system so that it didn't feel like you actually had to grind a lot just to beat the game. A lot of people often confuse the enjoyment of this game with Final Fantasy 4 because of the mis-numbering of the series in the 90s - FF4 is a LOT more important than FF2 because it was one of the first storyline based Final Fantasies released in the USA, and was groundbreaking for being easily one of the first JRPGs in the series to feature unique characters and classes tied to them.
FF2 does NOT have that - you have to basically make the characters proficient in whatever you choose them to wield, whereas with FF4, these character's abilities such as Rosa being a white mage actually played a role outside battle when she heals Edge, and of course, my favorite character of all time, Rydia, who conquers her fear of fire and then learns Fire1. You don't have that type of interaction in FF2. Instead all we have is "Guy Speak Beaver" and he doesn't even use this in combat to charm enemies like a beast master or something.
@@RydiasRevenge pretty much This final fantasy 2 is very grindy yes even the PSP and GBA version,if you don't grind you Will start Falling behind because your MP, defense and HP Will Be too low
Never played the OG NES version, but hearing about its issues I can understand why people don't like it too much. With that said I really enjoy the psp and origins rerelease, I'd say PSP over origins cause your weapon affinity increases faster, lightens the grind lol.
Fantastic video. I really loved FF2 as a kid and this video really makes me glad I did.
the post game is cool the idea that you can use the old party is awesome. the level system ehh that's where the charm makes it or breaks it but outside that the story was cool
What an amazing analysis, thank you so much for all your work, I really enjoyed it.
I could see where this game would be terrible to play sitting in front of a television, but I have loved playing it on my phone. I enjoy grinding to begin with. It's great to be able to kill some time waiting in line or for an appointment grinding some spells or weapon levels out. If you take your time grinding when you can and advancing the story when you feel ready it is a great game to play on the side. Great in depth review and a very fair take.
I really enjoyed the times I’ve played through this game. Exactly once per version released in English. I am also a huge SaGa fan so that might have something to do with it.
Spot on use of wandering flame. Good video dude
thought for a pretty long time about the most appropriate song for that bit - glad you noticed it!
your channel deserves so much more attention. wonderful video
Its finally here! I can assume the the editing was quite a journey for you. Great video. I enjoyed every minute of it.
That bit about Leon and why they became the Dark Knight is strange now that you mention it, granted it's been over a decade over since the last time I played FFII. That bit about him possibly being under some form of unmentioned mind control made me think of Kain from FFIV, perhaps a bit of Leon was also part of the blueprint for them along with Richard.
They definitely borrowed a lot from this story for FF IV
I'm glad there are more and more people giving FFII a chance. It's not an exceptional game mechanically but I always found the story very interesting and while the man party is very one note, the world building and themes do an amazing job making it fascinating (especially for an RPG of it's time).
Great video, you did an amazing job can't wait for the other FF videos :)
Your channel and final fantasy 2 is toooo underrated :(
This video deserves more views
Hey 👋 love these FF analysis videos. I've been watching them in preparation for the new pixel remasters. Thanks for the content. You got a new subscriber
hey! thanks man, that's really kind of you. i actually came across your channel the other day, i saw the tidus/raldo video and thought it was super interesting (despite the lack of a result) - that kind of stuff has always been fascinating to me, so thank you for making that content :)
@@Ludiscere thank you
yeah, it has basically meant that i've had to rewrite the video from scratch so i can include both the 3D remake and the new pixel remaster! before it was just going to focus on the 3D version, because it was the only licensed/official english version of the game. not anymore though!
Loved your focus on the depressing nature of the narrative. Played through this for the first time last year and I honestly loved every minute. More than III or IV actually.
I recently started it and it's DOWNRIGHT INCREDIBLE! One of the most perfect JRPG's I've played.
What fantastic and thoughtful take on my favourite game from the series
This video is incredible. I just finished FF2 for the first time and came looking for what people have to say about it. This is super well done and informative, interesting, and thoughtful. Also the way you transition from one topic to the next is so seamless, half an hour passed by and I didn't even notice lol. Excellent work! I'll come back and watch you FF3 video after I play that one.
The Emperor is far and away my all time favorite FF villain
Funny thing is I love this game to death, and I really like the leveling system as it allows me to create a party to my liking for an example: I could have guy be the mage that sits in the back and heals and deals mage damage and Maria be a duel wilding axe user and firion beating the shit out of anyone with just his fist and Leon be in the back and use a bow
Love how good status effect spells are in this one
Congrats on getting this video out!
Speaking of Nausicaa, the whole thing about a princess ruling in her sick father's stead reminded me of her when you mentioned it.
I get more Star Wars vibes, tbh.
Fun fact
I just just started playing Final Fantasy 2 Pixel Remaster for switch when I found this video. I've never played the old Final Fantasy's, so I'm going through them now.
I find it really interesting that the second games in a series tend to be black sheep within larger franchises.
Earth and Beyond did it best when the Jenquai Warrior class attacked the Progen school bus during the starting quests. They explained that it was necessary because they were weapons of the future.
Final Fantasy II is one of my favourites of the series. Love the music, the theme, the story, and what they tried to do.
This video is so *clean*, glad I'm finally getting around to your channel.
In terms of dungeon design and getting lost, I’ve noticed that at least for the first 4 games (the pattern breaks a bit in 5) the closest door to the entrance is usually optional, and the furthers door from the entrance is usually correct to progress.
Really enjoyed your analysis of I and II. Looking forward to III.
This has been a fantastic analysis of Final Fantasy 2, thank you :)
Before watching this, I want to say: I love FF 2!
Just finnished this game as the pixel remaster and absolutely loved it. I missed 1 chest and it's time to play again completely differently!
I'm glad to finally see someone point out how the Elder Scrolls games have a similar leveling system to FF II.
Wow you did it! You tied video games to real life history. I genuinely agree with your analysis on the need to tie games with reality
I’m 2 years late to your video but I really did enjoy playing this game. I played this on my PlayStation after playing the other final fantasy games that came out prior. I still have my original PlayStation and play it regularly. I liked the plot, and though the leveling up was different I enjoyed the challenge. I also played it using the hacks on how to level up MP and HP and I still had fun.
My first FF game. Fell in love instantly. 💖
I'm a huge fan of ffxiv and I have played all these games and it's enjoyable to see them insert all the little parts of other ff games into its story Endwalker focuses really heavy on 2 3 and 4
Subbed cause of the final fantasy 1 video, glad I stayed for the gravity rush vid and what im sure is to be another great one
Great video! As much as I know they'd almost never consider doing a remake of this game (I mean, look how long it took them to do FF7!) I think this game would benefit the most out of any game in the series of being given a proper second chance. The story is pretty good and could be great with a couple of tweaks, but the rest of the game around it could be so much better if they tried again nowadays. Wishful thinking, but maybe one day!
It's called ff12, i'm not joking, is basically ff2 but good
I decided to play FFII because I really wanted something like Grandia I that wasn't Grandia I.
And honestly, I was sleeping on this game because of how much people seemed to hate it, saying that it was the worst of the series and how wrong and broken the leveling system is... but actually this might be my new favorite from the NES trilogy!
Happy to have found another option to scratch that Grandia itch :)
I loved FF2. I’m glad I found someone who understands it.
Well researched and thought out script, great editing, nice voice that's easy to listen to, I can tell this video took a while to make. Lots of love and care put into it.
Though you probably already know this. Don't let negative comments get to you.
much appreciated mate, thank you so much!
unsurprisingly, i watched your video on the game when i was researching, and i thought it was comfortably the best piece of discourse surrounding FFII on this website - very refreshing to see someone diverge from what everyone else says, and say it well. the way your video starts is absolutely perfect, with all the clips of people bashing it and saying the same shit. sums it all up really.
but yeah, thanks man. means a lot :)
Love your videos. I played ff2 a long time ago in the gba collection. I'm actually not a ff fan, mostly cause I'm not a native English speaker and there wasn't a version in my language at the time. And because rpg in general need a lot of text and reading to make progress, it actually made me despise this kind of game.
Now I know a bunch of english, and there is a lot of games in my language, and even though I'm a avid rpg player (just the most known ones like mother or pokemon) I still can't play FF... Tried 8, 10, 1, 2 and 3. And the 2 one was the only one I played through till the end.
Hope the comment helps with the algorithm, your videos truly deserve it!
This was great as always, I'm playing through FF2 right now and it's really great. Having more fun than with 1 somehow even though I loved 1.
I'm trying to picture what the game could have been, this whold story of rebels against a crushing empire feels so relevant these days.
Also the "arabian" settings really gives it a distinct feel. I love the character design and the combat system isn't so bad if you're not against grinding.
I just gotta finish it now but I'm having a lot of fun.
My DnD character was from Cornelia but he's retired now after 3 long years of IRL game. My new character might hail from Altair, who knows!
Came here from awesome IV video, and the more I watch the video, and Dissidia making me like Dio-like emperor, I feel I would like FF II. Thank you for these. :D
Loved this video! The PSP version has also the best bonus dungeon too. Quite surprised you didn't mention the actual main theme, which is sad and beautiful. The symphonic version, and its arrangement into song form in Final Fantasy Pray show how amazing the theme is.
i do briefly discuss the main theme at the end of the Final Fantasy III video!
Yeah, noticed that after watching it. :P I'm loving your review on IV, btw.
While good gameplay can often end up feeling dated just as a consequence of technology and tastes changing over time, a good story is timeless. I think story matters a lot more, generally speaking.
Having said that, I find it easier to put up with a bad story than with bad gameplay. I don't mean "mediocre" gameplay there, mind, I mean genuinely bad. Fortunately, Let's Plays exist for the games that suffer from those and have a story worth telling.
Love your long form final fantasy reviews. I've listened to them driving to work and falling asleep to them at night. Not a bad thing! One more sub from me! I hope to see more rpgs in the future. Anything from old to new games would be great to see.
I’ve only just gotten into the FF series thanks to the newest remasters, and although I’ve found FF2 to be…frustrating, I really appreciate finding someone who puts my thoughts on it into words.
Speaking of, if you’ve had the chance to play the new remasters yet, what do you think of them?
Idk, it's wonky but it reminds me of skyrims leveling system a bit. I definitely remember in skyrim leveling up my blocking by letting weak mobs hit me when shielding or going back and forth while sneaking on an unaware npc
The road to Hell leads to a Frozen landscape, that is a clear reference to Dante's Devine Comedy.
That must be why when the Emperor that is dressed like Davey Bowie becomes the ruler of Heaven and Hell because he has decided that Earth isn't enough.
A huge flaw in this game is something most players don't even know (mainly because it's not explained in the game as far as I know). A lot of equipment actually reduces the amount of damage your spells do. Spells can actually deal a decent amount of damage at higher levels. Although most of the time just focusing on physical damage is still king.
starting maria off with a bow was probably one of the more unfortunate decision this game made, especially if you dont know about this system (Of course the game doesnt tell you about it -_-)
"After he died, the Emperor went to hell and took over!" is such a simple yet memorable plot point, its just so over the top and silly when you think about it: Man was so ambitious and evil he overthrew Satan
I'm surprised Star Wars wasn't mentioned in this, this game was beginning of FF drawing constant inspiration from Star Wars.
Great video! If any viewers are interested in Final Fantasy IIs ideas and would like to see them better executed I'd highly recommend the SaGa series. Akitoshi Kawazu, the man who is in a lot of ways behind Final Fantasy IIs uniqueness, rarely touched the mainline Final Fantasy series after II, but he went on to create the SaGa series, which carries forward a lot of its ideas like the lack of a traditional leveling system and rotating guest party members and introduces a lot of new interesting ideas as the series goes on.
FF2 is one of my favorite FF games of all time. I ADORE this game!!!!
Since I'm not well acquainted with Final Fantasy analysis, I haven't been 'tainted' by the negative FF2 discourse. So this is kind of my first real introduction to the game, and well... this video makes me want to try playing it! (Though I doubt I can get a copy on my hands for the GBA..) I really appreciate your fair assessment of the game and that you tackle so many different aspects. I always learn something new from your videos! :) Looking forward to the next one!
FF2 played normally is a chore....but when you have a speed toggle and can do 4x speed in battles...man it's a different experience.
54:55 me too thats why final fantasy series is my favourite
Oh, and I watched your video about the first game and I'll continue listening to your analysis' while level grinding. Even though I haven't gone through this video yet I'll just say thank you for your awesome job on the first one and I hope you are able to keep it up. Subbed.
Being the second in the series, it's one of my favorites.
Great video! For me personally I still think FF2 is my least favourite but replaying it recently I found the motivating factor was mostly the story, because it sure as hell wasn't the dungeon design lol as you said, it's a great story hindered somewhat by the era it was made in.
I love this game and love your content keep up the great work
I played FF2 for the first time recently, I had no previous knowledge about the game either positive or negative, I don't engage much on game reviews specially for old games.
I enjoyed the game a lot, and I was surprised by your video that such a negative perception of the game exists. As I said and went in completely blind for a game play, no expectations. And I was happily surprised by the game.
Great review.
A real eye opening review that shows how one can be objective.
I think the higher encounter rate is appropriate considering the system for improving your characters
Fun fact. The father of fascism, Benito Mussolini was married to a Jew and there were ten thousand Jews who were members of the Fascist Party in Italy. The only reason Mussolini became racist towards Jews wasn't because he had a change of mind about them, it was because he was pressured by the German National Socialists to do so to strengthen his position and The Axis. My point here is that National Socialists and fascists had different philosophies and agendas. If this is the case then why do Fascists get labelled with the crimes of National Socialists? Perhaps the same reason the Chinese Communist Party can accuse the United States of racism and fascism while at the same time be a totalitarian superpower who's genociding and organ harvesting the Uighurs. It's amazing what money and a well orchestrated propaganda machine can do. I'm not trying to defend fascism here, just putting a spotlight on just how powerful the propaganda is to save the face of socialism (even though fascism is national syndicalism i.e. trade unionism which is always hard left).
@Tom Ffrench If the Nazi's hated socialism then why have socialism in the name. These kind of things matter if you're regime is about totalitarianism and absolute information control. Socialists never consider that they have socialist factions at war with each other, like Protestants and Catholics, Sunni's and Shiites, it's always the "no true Scotsman" fallacy when the dirty laundry is hung out, and what's funnier is that the atrocities of Stalin and Mao get left out of the discussion when they have done more murder and oppression over a longer period of time than Hitler. When you cut through the propaganda and see the positions people take, you realize that the world is built on narratives, and the narrative that National Socialists are not socialists is one of them. If all socialist factions have the same goal but have different means of getting there, who is to say which is the real socialism. Also, socialism is supposed to be a stepping stone to communism, and even in Engels' and Marx's communist manifesto, they call for the dictatorship of the proletariat, and by having dictators you have subjects, thus a hierarchy of the managerial class. The state will never wither away and true socialism will never be achieved, it's always more centralization and thus more tyranny and oppression.
@Tom Ffrench Ethnic cleansing happens all the time, it's just that the west only focuses on Hitler. Xi Jinping of the CCP is ethnic cleansing the Uighurs right now and the west only cares about what happened from a time and a place I'm not from, nor do I think you're from. If you brought up this question of "Why should we care what happened nearly 100 years ago" you would get the usual "So it doesn't happen again", you reply with "Well shouldn't we do something about the CCP genocide of the Uighurs" which will result in a far less call for action and even denial that the CCP is doing exactly what the Nazi's are doing. It's nothing new for the communists of China either, they did the same to the Tibetans decades ago under Mao's regime.
I misheard you say Joseph is a “Punchy ball man” and went ,,wow wow, too soon man! My heart can’t take it!
The design philosophy for protagonists at the time is that they are supposed to be extension of the player as they are what you want them to be through your imagination. That is also why the main character is often silent, so you identify with him/her better. Some might say it is lazy writing, but using your imagination to role-play is an important part of the original DnD style which is often lost with heavily narratively oriented games nowadays. I really appreciate FF2's simplicity and effectiveness in telling an engaging story despite the limitation of its medium.
wonderful and very complete review. I never had a chance to play this installment when it was released on PS1. I ll try to find an alternative to play it again, probably emulator.
I beat the game today (Soul of Rebirth included) and your opinion is exactly the same as mine, even the comparison with Zelda II and Simon's Quest was in my mind. Great video, man.
Really good video. I honestly really love this game, despite his problems with the battle system, dungeons and high enemies encounters. Right now I'm just replaying III, but 100% I'm going to play II again.
Unfortunally you didn't talked Soul of Rebirth.
(Sorry for any mistake)
Final Fantasy 2 is similar to the Skyrim of Final Fantasy except the enemies don't level with you.
I played the Final Fantasy 2 Pixel Remaster (you can see the playthrough on my channel under live streaming) and the only flaw that FF2 really had was how overly grindy it was.
It does require a lot of meta knowledge to do well, for example, like always equipping shields to keep your agility increase which determines turn order.
That said, because of the meta knowledge required versus kill enemies, get exp, I can understand why people didn't like it. Plus the scaling inn costs.
EDIT: In regards to the empty rooms, those were also present in the original Final Fantasy. The poison cave, for example. They were entirely a trap to increase the difficulty of the dungeon by forcing harder encounters. Especially in Final Fantasy I where magic and the ability to heal your party was more limited. I firmly believe the dungeons were designed for you to delve, retreat, delve because doing them all in one sweep, before getting the heal staff, would be too draining on your ability to recover.
Leon's entire redemption arc is based on the fact that he's Maria's brother and that's mostly it. I do feel like while it wasn't elaborated on that it was some form of mind control ala Kain, but it isn't explicitly mentioned; however, when you compare the narrative in FF2 vs FF1, I can easily give that a pass because it went from a generic hero story, to a story with actual characters.