Can someone PLEASE explain this to me: I know Leafpool had the vision about Brambleclaw defending the Clan, but why did StarClan choose HIM instead of Brackenfur? If Brackenfur became leader, the Clan wouldn't be chaos with Bramblestar being possessed and all. And maybe, just perhaps, Ashfur wouldn't bother to possess Bramblestar at all..
LIGHTNING TAILL!!!!! he always knew what do to, and he was wise in his ages. he was trusted by Thunder, and he always expected Lightning tail to be leader.
@@red-catsareliquid lightning tail does die from dogs before he is named leader, and i think he dies in thunderstars echo as the leader after thunderstar was owlstar (owl eyes)
BrightHeart: Definitely deserved to be leader, the poor thing got screwed by the Erins SwiftPaw: I honestly don’t think he should be leader. He definitely deserved to live, but he wasn’t around long enough to show any good leadership qualities MudClaw: I’m a little bit torn on this case. He fair and square served his deputyship, but TallStar was right. He would’ve led WindClan into unneeded battles, and he was to arrogant and controlling. But honestly OneStar didn’t do much better. MudClaw would’ve deserved to be leader if he changed his attitude HollyLeaf: Man I love her, and I would’ve liked to see HollyStar. But saying this, she wouldn’t be that good of a leader. She ran off when things got hard and she murdered in cold blood, and attempted to murder her own mother. I think she deserved the role of deputy- and then she could improve, and then maybe become leader CloudPelt: Idk anything abt this dude 😅 Remember this is just my opinion! Feel free to disagree, but stay respectful
Cloudpelt was the deputy after Foxheart had died under RaggedStar. But more of what he could be more recognizable is that he was the kit that Yellowfang helped when she was opened to the opportunity to be a medicine cat by her powers. Later, they save Cloudpelts life again, having them both share a strong bond. But sadly, Cloudpelt dies of blood lost. He really was a great character who deserved more attention. He's in Yellowfangs Secret. He definitely deserved to have been a leader. He had such a kind heart. He told yellowfang that he wishes to some day have a mate and kits of his own! But that never happened..
I LITTERALLY cried when holly leaf ran into the tunnels she only thought she did the right thing it would’ve killed me to I so agree with her being ✨Hollystar✨
LIGHTNING TAIL!! idk if u know abt him, but he is in the 'Dawn of the Clans' and the following, and he would have been a noble leader after Thunderstar
If you make a part 4 of this, can you put in jayfeather I think he is wise and a well developed character although, many people think he is a ruthless, cruel character because of the ay he acts. But in my opinion I think he is a great choice for a leader and he shows that you don’t need eyes to see the good in someone. Quotes: “I forgave her eventually. Even though I could never love her as a mother after what she’d done, I respected her as a medicine cat and loves her as a clan mate.” “This will not be the end of the clans As long as I have breath in my body the clans will be safe.” “Sometimes mistakes can never be undone But you just have to learn to live with them.”
(Spoilers) Why I think Mudclaw didn’t deserve to be leader; He was too aggressive and short tempered. This lead to him quite often threatening cats of other clans- whether they deserved it or not. Tallstar wanted Windclan to be friendly of other clans, and knew that wouldn’t be the case if Mudclaw became leader. Onewhisker was a loyal, trustworthy and kind cat, and he had good leadership skills. He assisted Fireheart and Greystripe on the journey back to Windclan camp (after Shadowclan drove them out) and was very helpful. Tallstar knew that Onewhisker would keep the ‘alliances’ with the other clans, specifically Thunderclan, after he passed. He knew that Firestar and Onewhisker were friends, but he also knew that their loyalty to their clans would make everything right. If Mudclaw had been leader, their friendship’ with other clans would have been- well- terrible 😂
But when Onestar became leader he started to act distant from Firestar, and started to act more agressive towards others. he betrayed his mate and son 'Darktail' and it seemed that he stuggled with the leadership role, like Clear Sky.
@@CreatureCreations- before she had a half clan relationship, she was described to be a brave, compassionate and loyal warrior who was kind to other cats. And even other cats thought she might be deputy, but she likely got so angry due to the fact we was exiled
I get that swift paw died but before that he still managed to fight of four dogs and he was only an apprentice. Meanwhile all of the clans (that’s at least 70 cats) running away when one dog runs a them😂😢
Swiftpaw - he wasn't a warrior when he died, he died cause of own stupidity, and Brightheart got hurt cause of him. Hollyleaf - she was very impulsive, was acting on emotions, and, like Swiftpaw, wasn't showing any leadership qualities at all. (Sorry, bad english)
@@XMoonlightXMidnightX Yeah! I love Tallstar tho, he was just a little old when he decided to switch those two! Onestar really is a bad leader, one of my most hated! I loved Tallstar tho, just that little mistake that he chose Onewhisker, otherwise he is fine!
No hate against Swiftpaw, because he was a very brave cat and had a very unfortunate death saving Brightheart. But on the other hand, he was kind of rude to Cloudtail and Firestar.
(my opinion) I think that Swiftpaw didn’t even close deserve to be a leader, but I agree that Brightheart or Cloudtail would have made great leaders. Especially Deadfoot, Lionheart and Stonefur.
IF I SEE RUSSETFUR IN ANY OF THESE IMMA CRY She literally watched Berrykit almost bleed to death and her excuse was “he’s not clanborn!” Like ma’am neither are tou
I wouldn't say mudclaw should have been leader. He was ambitious and acted somewhat like tigerstar -- I feel like windclan would be in danger with him as leader.
Someone need to do something in the orange by zach brians for ashfur! The orange could be the fire! And the lines to you im just a man to me ur all i am where the hell am i supposed to go, poisened my slef again something in the orange tells me u arent coming home fits so well!
Why is no one in the comments talking about mudclaw? If they are, theyre saying bad things about them? Tbh, he served as windclan's deputy for so long, and for tallstar to just change the deputy while he wasnt even there to witness it was kindave sad for him. He put so much work into caring for his clan, and yes, he was technically a villain, but can you blame him, hes just like how everyone likes mapleshade as a villain character because she went through something hard, and overcomed it with revenge. Mudclaw was similar, although Mapleshades backstory was worse, we arent getting into her. Mudclaw gathered up a group of cats from different clans to ambush onewhisker, and windclan so that he could be leader and there would be no onestar. Onestar was a horrible cat in the books after becoming leader. He literally left kits and his mate to die. Personally, Mudclaw was stronger, and more commanding, with good speaking skills. He deserved to be leader of windclan
i’m sorry but i saw cloudpelt and realized i haven’t heard of cloudtail in the books in so long and i searched up how he died SINCE WHEN DID HE DIE SO EARLY????? IM ON THE THIRD SERIES AND I DIDNT EVEN REALIZE HE WAS DEAD BC I DIDNT READ FIRESTARS QUEST
IN MY OPINION: I think all of these wouldn’t make good leaders except for Mudclaw. He really deserved leader not Tallstar. But I really do respect you’re opinion
I'd say whitestorm and graystripe also did. Yes I know graystripe did, but he was it temporarily, not permanently. This is just my opinion so dont come after me-
I just watched all your vids and subbed. Pin?
Sure😁
Still no pin buddy
"If i die as a apprentice, ill die fighting like a warrior" -swiftpaw
Edit:WOAH TYSM GUYS
Edit2:
OML TWINS-
Same pfp,both fox therians(I’m also a cat and in ur bio it says ur questioning one!)
@@3sillykitty WOAHHHH!
"Time to change my pfp again" -Zer0-0n-paws
@@ToastAndBread2i think I saw you in Warrior cats ultimate edition
@@GloryWoFDragon rlly? What did I look like?
I think that Gray Wing should have become leader. He was so wise and open to other’s opinions.
He actually had the choice to, it was right there, but he really didn't want to
@@EnbyniniI know!!!
THANK YOU FINALLY
He did for a little while but then due to his breathing problems he had to retire plus he didn't really want to be one
He is better than Skysh*t
Just imagine-
✨SwiftStar✨
That sounds like a paper towel brand ☠️
@@AveRagePerSonnnn NOOOOO!
@@myuorinz but it sounds like it
what have I started
I JUST READ A GRAPHIC NOVEL MUD CLAW DESERVED TO BE LEADER LIKE IF YOU AGREE
Can someone PLEASE explain this to me:
I know Leafpool had the vision about Brambleclaw defending the Clan, but why did StarClan choose HIM instead of Brackenfur? If Brackenfur became leader, the Clan wouldn't be chaos with Bramblestar being possessed and all. And maybe, just perhaps, Ashfur wouldn't bother to possess Bramblestar at all..
bEcAUse bRaMBle bOi iS sUper CUte
@@KittensRule xD
Because Bramble is the main character.
I think Brackenfur would've made a hell of a lot better leader than Brambleclaw did.
@@Lu13s Maybe, but bRambLE bOi'S rEign wIlL neVEr eNd
I like that you chose Brightheart, i think she actually had been better than Bramblestar.
I agree
Also, the name Brightstar is amazing
No one is better than my babie boi Bramble
fr
@@Nanook32fr
Finally, someone that agrees that Cloudpelt deserved to be leader!
I think stonefur should be in the list ❤
LIGHTNING TAILL!!!!! he always knew what do to, and he was wise in his ages. he was trusted by Thunder, and he always expected Lightning tail to be leader.
i thought lightning tail did become leader it just wasn’t in the books bc thunder said if something happened to him then lightning tail would lead
@@red-catsareliquid lightning tail does die from dogs before he is named leader, and i think he dies in thunderstars echo
as the leader after thunderstar was owlstar (owl eyes)
@@iwillfindegg owl eyes becomes leader??? Omg
@@red-catsareliquid yea lol i think thunderstar named one of his kits lightning stripe for lightning tail
BrightHeart: Definitely deserved to be leader, the poor thing got screwed by the Erins
SwiftPaw: I honestly don’t think he should be leader. He definitely deserved to live, but he wasn’t around long enough to show any good leadership qualities
MudClaw: I’m a little bit torn on this case. He fair and square served his deputyship, but TallStar was right. He would’ve led WindClan into unneeded battles, and he was to arrogant and controlling. But honestly OneStar didn’t do much better. MudClaw would’ve deserved to be leader if he changed his attitude
HollyLeaf: Man I love her, and I would’ve liked to see HollyStar. But saying this, she wouldn’t be that good of a leader. She ran off when things got hard and she murdered in cold blood, and attempted to murder her own mother. I think she deserved the role of deputy- and then she could improve, and then maybe become leader
CloudPelt: Idk anything abt this dude 😅
Remember this is just my opinion! Feel free to disagree, but stay respectful
Idk who Cloudpelt is either 💀
Im pretty sure Cloupelt was the Shadowclan deputy before Brokentail and after Foxheart but i could be wrong. Im sure that its on the Warriors wiki.
Cloudpelt was the deputy after Foxheart had died under RaggedStar. But more of what he could be more recognizable is that he was the kit that Yellowfang helped when she was opened to the opportunity to be a medicine cat by her powers. Later, they save Cloudpelts life again, having them both share a strong bond. But sadly, Cloudpelt dies of blood lost. He really was a great character who deserved more attention. He's in Yellowfangs Secret.
He definitely deserved to have been a leader. He had such a kind heart. He told yellowfang that he wishes to some day have a mate and kits of his own! But that never happened..
I was waiting sooo long for someone to FINALY say BeightHeart and HollyLeaf should be leaders ❤🔥
Me
I LITTERALLY cried when holly leaf ran into the tunnels she only thought she did the right thing it would’ve killed me to I so agree with her being ✨Hollystar✨
"If i die a apprentice I'll go down a warrior!" -swiftpaw
I wouldn’t say swiftpaw deserved to be leader, but he did deserve to live
Yes...
Yes😢
YES
May fav thing about this short is that it’s not just deputy’s who died
Greystripe, Russetfur, Whitestorm, lionheart
And bristle frost!
WHITESTORM MY BABY 🛐🛐🛐🛐
Whitestorm and Greystripe 🙏✨
Greystripe❤❤❤
Want part 4? Comment who you think should be next!
(Please consider watching parts 1 and 2 first)
LionBlaze! he would become a great and strong leader! What do you think? His name would be LionStar! Plzzz do part 4!
LIGHTNING TAIL!! idk if u know abt him, but he is in the 'Dawn of the Clans' and the following, and he would have been a noble leader after Thunderstar
Bristlefrost, Gray Wing, and Reedwhisker
@@TropicalLaser10 fr
Always lostface never brightheart..... Until this video ♡
Wait did she become dep?
@@Poppywcue4075no she’s just an elder that gets mentioned sometimes now
No, it's Brightheart!
She was named Lostface under Bluestar's reign then it got changed later to Brightheart by (i believe) Firestar
@@Lu13s yes Fireheart (star) changed her name to brightheart
Swift paw would have been such a great leader, honestly-
SO TRUE ❤❤❤❤❤❤
If you make a part 4 of this, can you put in jayfeather I think he is wise and a well developed character although, many people think he is a ruthless, cruel character because of the ay he acts. But in my opinion I think he is a great choice for a leader and he shows that you don’t need eyes to see the good in someone.
Quotes:
“I forgave her eventually. Even though I could never love her as a mother after what she’d done, I respected her as a medicine cat and loves her as a clan mate.”
“This will not be the end of the clans As long as I have breath in my body the clans will be safe.”
“Sometimes mistakes can never be undone But you just have to learn to live with them.”
I think a HollyStar would be cool, sad we never got one :'3
(Spoilers) Why I think Mudclaw didn’t deserve to be leader;
He was too aggressive and short tempered. This lead to him quite often threatening cats of other clans- whether they deserved it or not. Tallstar wanted Windclan to be friendly of other clans, and knew that wouldn’t be the case if Mudclaw became leader.
Onewhisker was a loyal, trustworthy and kind cat, and he had good leadership skills. He assisted Fireheart and Greystripe on the journey back to Windclan camp (after Shadowclan drove them out) and was very helpful.
Tallstar knew that Onewhisker would keep the ‘alliances’ with the other clans, specifically Thunderclan, after he passed. He knew that Firestar and Onewhisker were friends, but he also knew that their loyalty to their clans would make everything right.
If Mudclaw had been leader, their friendship’ with other clans would have been- well- terrible 😂
yes, I agree. Also why do I think he should a shadow clan leader? idk lol
@@ilovewarriorcatsss idk I guess that shadowclan always had the evil leaders lol 😂
But when Onestar became leader he started to act distant from Firestar, and started to act more agressive towards others. he betrayed his mate and son 'Darktail' and it seemed that he stuggled with the leadership role, like Clear Sky.
@@iwillfindegg yeah I’m only on the power of three but that’s just why I thought Mudclaw didn’t deserve it etc
@@SophieBaileyandRaven OPS UR ON THE POWER OF THREE SOZ FOR SPOILERS
Holly leaf is my favourite character
We need more sss warrior cats in edits
YES CLOUDPELT YES!! HE IS SO UNDERRATED I LOVE HIM
Cool ❤😢🎉
Totally agree w/ Brightheart, and not just because she’s one of my favs
But not mudclaw
Yessss! Mud’claw should’ve been leader! ❤
Brightheart is my favorite character
Same
You should add Mapleshade if you haven’t, before she went insane she was a loyal and dedicated warrior
Didn't she have a half clan relationship? That doesn't sound very loyal. Plus, Mapleshade was way too easily angered.
@@CreatureCreations- before she had a half clan relationship, she was described to be a brave, compassionate and loyal warrior who was kind to other cats. And even other cats thought she might be deputy, but she likely got so angry due to the fact we was exiled
I agree! I also think Brackenfur even tho he isnt on this list deserved it too!
I agree with all of these and especially Hollyleaf. But also bristlefrost
Let’s go swiftpaw my fav!
(I literally had a bday party about swiftpaw
Especially since as a kit hollyleaf wanted to be leader so bad 😢
i %100 agree with bright heart
I like that you chose Hollyleaf, but I do think a medicinal cat is a more suitable job. But you're right. She deserved more than she got.
Yes! So many missed opportunities with brightheart bc she lost her eye 💯
i love swiftpaw he deserved so much more
Personally, I disagree with Mudclaw being a leader, but I fully agree with Brightheart!
Love theee video (quick question is that a German shepherd or African wild dog therian pfp?)
It's an African Wild Dog ❤️
Honestly, i wish Whitestorm would have been able to be leader, ik he was old but still
Stonefur joins the Chat. My man wasn't even Leader and sacrificed it all, and himself, for the Riverclan 👑
I luv Hollyleaf honestly 😅 she is my fav
i think nightheart would’ve been a good leader :D
Not sure cloudtail wouldve even been picked as deputy, since he didnt believe in starclan and didn't care about the warrior code.
yess bright heart would be the best leader
I get that swift paw died but before that he still managed to fight of four dogs and he was only an apprentice. Meanwhile all of the clans (that’s at least 70 cats) running away when one dog runs a them😂😢
Swiftpaw - he wasn't a warrior when he died, he died cause of own stupidity, and Brightheart got hurt cause of him.
Hollyleaf - she was very impulsive, was acting on emotions, and, like Swiftpaw, wasn't showing any leadership qualities at all.
(Sorry, bad english)
brightheart was a great cat until she died (which didn't already happen, she lives as a elder) so I think she deserved to
i don't like swiftpaw because of that reason... and whitepaw (later wing) had to wait forever for her warrior name.
@@ilovewarriorcatsss who's whitewing
I AGREE ON SWIFTPAW FINALLY SOMEONE WHO AGREES WITH ME AND WHO STUPID HE WAS AND GETTING BRIGHTHEART INJURED
@Enbynini Brightheart and Cloudtail's daughter mother of Ivypool and Dovewing
I had a cat just like hollyleaf and no i dont watch the show!i miss her😢
Have u done white’storm yet? Bc if u haven’t then do it white’storm would have been a great leader of thunder clan
Mudclaw was a bit aggressive in his book, but he would have been a amazing leader
what about curlfeather? cause in sky, frostpaw thought that his mom would have been the prefect leader.
yes my queen holly
You do realize that holly leaf is a villain😂
I swear my morphs deserve to ve leaders
You chose ivypool that's great
I also think Brackenfur would be a great leader I’m sad he wasn’t chosen
“Maybe cloud will be leader one day!”
~ Princess
I think she was talking about cloudtail, pretty sure cloudpelt was a shadowclan deputy
I think Ivypool would be a good leader 😁
mudclaw most certainly does NOT deserve to be leader- he literally tried to murder onestar, and his ambitions led to his death
if idiotic tallsatr didnt choose onewhisker to be leader mudclaw would have been a fine leader
@@XMoonlightXMidnightX Yeah! I love Tallstar tho, he was just a little old when he decided to switch those two! Onestar really is a bad leader, one of my most hated! I loved Tallstar tho, just that little mistake that he chose Onewhisker, otherwise he is fine!
Holly leaf my beloved :]
BRIGHTSTARRRRR
Y'all did you put Longtail on this? He really should have
No hate against Swiftpaw, because he was a very brave cat and had a very unfortunate death saving Brightheart. But on the other hand, he was kind of rude to Cloudtail and Firestar.
HOLLYLEAF YASS❤
(my opinion) I think that Swiftpaw didn’t even close deserve to be a leader, but I agree that Brightheart or Cloudtail would have made great leaders. Especially Deadfoot, Lionheart and Stonefur.
Me still waiting for tawnypelt😢
Redtail (Thunderclan)
Whitestorm (Thunderclan)
Shellheart (Riverclan)
Whiteclaw (Riverclan)
Cloudpelt (Shadowclan)
Russetfur (Shadowclan)
Deadfoot (Windclan)
The list is endless.
Greystripe deserved to be leader aswell
Whitestorm deserved to be leader more than all of them-
I personally don’t think Swiftpaw or Hollyleaf should have been leader but I agree with the rest :)
same, especially hollyleaf
Holly leaf ❤️❤️❤️❤️
IF I SEE RUSSETFUR IN ANY OF THESE IMMA CRY
She literally watched Berrykit almost bleed to death and her excuse was “he’s not clanborn!” Like ma’am neither are tou
I wouldn't say mudclaw should have been leader. He was ambitious and acted somewhat like tigerstar -- I feel like windclan would be in danger with him as leader.
Hollyleaf team
👇
I think BrackenFur would’ve been the best leader. Bro has done nothing wrong that I know of.
I think maple shade deserved to be leader
Someone need to do something in the orange by zach brians for ashfur! The orange could be the fire! And the lines
to you im just a man to me ur all i am where the hell am i supposed to go, poisened my slef again something in the orange tells me u arent coming home fits so well!
Stonefur
Feathertail
Mapleshade
Gorsepaw
Morningflower
Oakheart
Redtail
I feel like bristlefrost might have been a good leader
I think bright heart would be better deputy
BrightStar
SwiftStar
MudStar
HollyStar
CloudStar
I think Ivypool deserved it too
I kinda say no to Mudclaw and I agree with Tallstar's words
Soo true, except for swiftpaw
Brackenfur would be great too
COOL 💯💯❤
I would say RussetFur should have been leader !
I think Whitestorm should’ve been leader
Please if he dose don’t spoil it by commenting
Why is no one in the comments talking about mudclaw? If they are, theyre saying bad things about them?
Tbh, he served as windclan's deputy for so long, and for tallstar to just change the deputy while he wasnt even there to witness it was kindave sad for him. He put so much work into caring for his clan, and yes, he was technically a villain, but can you blame him, hes just like how everyone likes mapleshade as a villain character because she went through something hard, and overcomed it with revenge. Mudclaw was similar, although Mapleshades backstory was worse, we arent getting into her. Mudclaw gathered up a group of cats from different clans to ambush onewhisker, and windclan so that he could be leader and there would be no onestar. Onestar was a horrible cat in the books after becoming leader. He literally left kits and his mate to die. Personally, Mudclaw was stronger, and more commanding, with good speaking skills. He deserved to be leader of windclan
Swiftpaw I disagree, but I do think he should've been a Warrior
The last two I’m not sure of, because Hollyleaf was very…..well…..yeah….before she died
My list
Brackenfur
Shrewpaw
Bristlefrost
Ivypool
&
Cloudtail
I feel like Swiftpaw would be a horrible leader. He’s impulsive, and his death was because he never thought his plan through
i’m sorry but i saw cloudpelt and realized i haven’t heard of cloudtail in the books in so long and i searched up how he died SINCE WHEN DID HE DIE SO EARLY????? IM ON THE THIRD SERIES AND I DIDNT EVEN REALIZE HE WAS DEAD BC I DIDNT READ FIRESTARS QUEST
HOLLYLEAF FR DID
IN MY OPINION: I think all of these wouldn’t make good leaders except for Mudclaw. He really deserved leader not Tallstar. But I really do respect you’re opinion
I'd say whitestorm and graystripe also did. Yes I know graystripe did, but he was it temporarily, not permanently. This is just my opinion so dont come after me-
mud claw attackt hi clan 😢 but he did not know what whold happen so I agree