What does Indian Air Force's new doctrine contain
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2023
- #Defencescope
The #IAF has come out with a new doctrine. ThePrint’s Deputy Editor Snehesh Alex Philip speaks to Air Marshal Diptendu Choudhury (Retd), a key architect of the new doctrine to understand what it is all about.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Snehesh Alex Philip's article here : theprint.in/defence/what-does...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Can you fix the audio please. It doesn't feel like it is easy on ears, it echoes.
Yes, it marred an otherwise excellent interview.
Nicely explained by the AM Diptendu. We may like to understand that all three services fight to attain the political objective by fighting respective tactical and strategic battles. He has clearly explained how at some point times political masters have restrained the freedom of total employment of power. But ultimate military victory depends on occupation of enemy land which is primarily done by the Army. So at some point of time entire effort of other two services have to be pointed towards assisting the Army attaining the same.
1. Thanks Snehesh for this interview with AVM!. 2. As regards the national security doctrine, it ought to be in place first before we into the theaterization ; however, such doctrine need not be put in public domain first as long as it is well understood and absorbed by all the three forces! So no Chief of any Armed Forces need to convey his wisdom to the larger public! The earlier this is sorted out, the better it is for the country. Hope Rajnath Singh will act fast and get it done before 2024!! 3. BTW, Nehru in 1962 appears to be like Zelensky of today as both approached USA for air power support!!
Since the war is in Europe, Zelensky might actually get support as blonde haired, blue eyed fair skinned people are at risk
The history lesson from the officer is fascinating- thank you
Wow! So much new info about the role played by our Air Force in past wars. Very nice interview.
IAF = Indian accident force. Which can do accident of modern aircrafts like Mirage & Su30 & C130 Hercules as well to do stunts. It can hit it's own helicopter with own spider missile as accident. 🤷♂️🥴 It couldn't fly at night in 1965 war to longewala post. 🤷♂️
iaf has not planes what can it do with new doctrines it uses ancient planes and cnt buy new ones most of its planes are ones designed in the 80s and 90s and here talking about space what a joke iaf should take a lesson from the navy and fix itself
If I am not mistaken,DChow was flying Mig29 during Kargil. I hope you ask him to do a interview of the events during Kargil. His experience and his experience of being the first batch of Su30mki pilots who went to Russia for training.Some experience of Red Flag will be amazing.
Excellent insight into IAF roles and doctrine
was a big big fan of Diptendu Choudhury ever since he was a young MiG 29 pilot in the late 80s.
A doctrine also clarifies to the members of the organisation as to what their role is. It prevents the tail from wagging the dog.
Sound quality sucks. Please sort out these technical issues next. Nevertheless great interview with quality questions and ofcourse equally fitting answers.
Why does the soun cut off at 1:24?
Airforce should understand that only a unified force could wage a modern war. There's no need for three separate arms which competes with each other instead of working together for a common goal. Israel defence forces should be the model we should try to replicate. See how they've successfully out fought all their neighbors simultaneously in multiple wars. This was only possible because of the deep integration of all the arms of the military. The threat of a two front war is very real.
IAF as org is a burden on Indian taxpayers. Best is to dissolve it & strengthen the Army air wing & Navy Air wing with IAF assests, for the minimum works IAF does as dropping bombs & transport pilots.
@@surojeetchatterjee this is the stupidest idea I have ever heard
There is a huge misconception roaming around that our forces are not well integrated and cannot communicate with each other. Well, I wouldn’t blame you. It has been propagated by 'some' defence experts for some time now. People tend to forget we have Successfully conducted an operation which liberated a country, an achievement IDF cannot claim. So comparing two forces is meaningless.
@@surajbiradar9827 We don't need Airforce as separate org for transport aircraft pilots & minor bomb drop. Drones & Coast guard, Army Navy Air wing can do that. IAF doesn't have a single air to air missiles kill shot in its history. 🤷♂️🤣
@@arijitpalit2756 IDF captured whole Sinai peninsula from Egypt in war then returned it back with treaty. 🤷♂️🤣
When summarizing the wars, we clearly understand that there is a Airforce restraint and separate service mindset. Also it has clearly reinforced my understanding that a theatrical formation would have won several wars. However, if I understood correct, there is an US Airforce and they have a subset that is theaterized..
I thought IAF has been merged with the home guards after loosing their last two jets in one day. Seems they were able to salvage some museum pieces.
Wonderful interview.
Good interview. But felt pity at the place where the Air Marshall (retd), was struggling to defend the opposition to theaterisation. His argument that the Airforce is very different from other two due to territorial limitations, isn't a good one. Did the airforce/airpower of other world powers become less effective after theaterisation ? We are taking comfort in status quo. But we will be soon left far behind and will find ourselves fighting for survival in this fast changing world. Unless we embrace the changes required to face the challenges
I skimmed through the doc. It’s very light on the future roadmap (page 87 onwards), there’s no roadmap about its future requirements. Just bullet points about that they want to do R&D on PPP and shift to capabilities. Roadmap is supposed to at least talk about how you address issues mentioned in your doctrine.
As usual timepass... nothing concrete. 🤮🤮
@@azingo2313 It feels like it was a Post Grad thesis paper written by a National Defence University candidate. I hope the classified one isn't as barebones as the public document.
Poor audio. Please fix it
Missile/Rockets focussed arm needs to be constituted forthwith
Battle readiness of Indian Air Force exposed twice in the past. .. during kargil war and after Balakot attack. In my opinion…. real war situation ..IAF will struggle again if they don’t prepare properly.
You are not an expert
@@dpfrmhell What's the need to be an “ expert ” here ? Everyone saw what happened in and post balakote. But if bhakts wanna count their papa Modi's failures as success then it's like bhens ke aage been bajaana. 🤣
@@kingmaker393 Lol...'Unprovoked Liberandu Combustion' alert
Audio needs to be improved.
Good interview - but Snehesh - please ask short, simple questions and don't repeat yourself - let the expert talk. Perhaps - what are core elements of new doctrine, what does air force need to change, how will this impact inter-services co-operation, what capabilities need to be acquired. How does this compare to our adversaries, etc.
The Americans have tested a sixth generation aircraft whereas we still use junks from the last century . Our squadrons are depleting rapidly when there is a possibility for our enemies attacking us together from both the west and the east.
Video games is not real life
@@rohitkashyap1051 As real as your own existence boss.
ruclips.net/video/lMr7thd7qh0/видео.html&feature=shares
@@subyjerrin5837
My comment was about being attacked from both sides.....
All 3 nations are nuclear nations....a full scale conventional war is unlikely....unless ofcourse in a video game....
As far as indegenization is concerned, it comes down to cost to benefit. The cost to compete woth US like tech is too high for India which has other challenges.
👌🙏
Let me guess. How to fight a war without any jets since you lost all of them during peace time ?
officers of iaf are sick with their superiority and British officershahi mentality.
Or theatrisation se inke promotion or officershahi ko khatra h isliye dikkat h .
Baaki world ki best defence forces theatrisation follow kr rhi h ,inko bas apni power paise or pbor ko dabane ki padi h .
IAF as an organization is a burden on Indian taxpayers.
😎they are ray ban chasma fauj.which they are issued for free and when it is time to deposit it back to the store they buy 100 rupees imitation roy-ban from revdi and give it.
@@surojeetchatterjee they must dismantle all air Forces all over the world.
IAF was exposed during balakot operation, it's high time that it improves their performance... somewhere something is not good... They shot their own helicopter, could not properly defend downing of F16,
i agree
1/India : should be the AIrcraft Manufactruing Factory of the world.
Especially:
manufacturing the Powerful:
Clean Engines.
2/Designs..
Suite all purposes.
Fully TECHNOLGY Integrated..
Multitasking:
Stealth:..invisible.
I think navy published its unclas maritime doctrine first, sometimes imm after Kargil…
Sad to say but one needs to have some decent aircrafts and some decent quantity of those for a strategy to work.India doesn't have great fighter aircrafts nor the quantity. Government is sleeping. MMRCA2.0 is needed urgently but Government is sleeping. SO
sad and pathetic.
Govt is not sleeping, IAF babus are sleeping. They did not spent their allocation for years, then dithered and delayed AoN for MRCA and are still bickering about which aircraft they want. They don't even have their requirements set straight.
Which modern air force operates 7 different types of Fighter aircrafts... Indian Airforce is a joke... its ridiculous how much money is wasted on the peripherals of maintaining the support systems of all the different types of aircrafts.. on top of that they won't let helicopters(including attack helicopters) being operated by army...
"Paagal banaa rahe hai sabko..."
When you are dependent on foreign fighters, you have 2 options depending on geopolitics
1) have a uniform platform composition if you are part of any military alliance with strong superpowers providing you with all the equipment, because your goals and strategy matches that with your alllies. For eg. NATO countries
2) If you don't have any military alliance then you can't have 'one' reliable supplier
So you are left with 2 options
1) build your own equipment or
2) diversify your fleet as to insure against any one supplier blocking support.
We are in the middle of this fuss where our indigenous ecosystem is not fully developed so we have to diversify or sign a military pact with US
@@surajbiradar9827 True, but the way IAF maintains its inventory of non fighter aircraft & helicopters is a Joke as well. IAF Officials & political party leaders vested interests comes in the way for selecting aircraft rather than the clause u mentioned.
@@surajbiradar9827 also the upgrade programs are also joke of IAF, just like 2011 Mirage upgrade with 3 billion without AESA Radar. 🤷♂️🤣 only IAF upgrades 1 decade old technology spending public money without planning.
This is a major issue which many are not aware. Costs go skyrocketing to maintain these different types of aircraft and needs further cost to make them communicate with each other.
Agree 💯.
Indian airforce is a joke now.
Wasted more than a decade to decide and purchase MRFA..... timepass is still going on.
The vision statement in IAF's new doctrine is a negative statement, the vision statement should always be positive imo.
They r known as Indian accident force & cowards non warriors transport aircraft pilots, so they will have negativity it's normal thing.
Skipped the interview from 6th minute..
Poor audio
The good Air Marshall is obfuscating on purpose. We know EXACTLY what the army chief meant by that rather callous statement.
It's not news to anyone that Indian military's war weaponry & tactics are still mostly of soviet/russian origin. old habits die hard.
Big Timepass 🤭🤮
Wasting time.....took 10 years to decide one fighter aircraft 😆😆😆
Without IAF country can't win anything army officers are old age era people
This is a very crude comment reveals lack of knowledge about military science
War room mein rajnitik baten super secrisi mein hoti Hain aapko Air force ke doctoron ka kaise pata lag Gaya
#05#05#05
IAF has one and only one doctrine....waste time.
Waste decades after decades in taking one decision l.
Such a shame 😂😂😂😂😂.
No respect for IAF....sorry.. 🙏🏻🙏🏻
India has no capacity because no system and technology owned by India. Very poor number of all system and lack of fire power. Technologywise we are way behind. We are capable to fight with Pak only. Real aero space power usa Russia and others are fractional power
Rice bag for host
harhahahaaaa...lolol🤣
IAF is the weakest link in India’s armed forces in my opinion , it’s training standards are abysmal , and it shows in a spate of regular crashes of SU30, Mirage 2000, Mig21, Choppers , fratricide post Balakot etc….the best way forward is to break the IAF assets up into Army Aviation Corp, Naval aviation and just leave Transport duties to IAF.
Transport duty should also go to coast guard & NDRF. There is no need for IAF as seperate org with this performance.
Agree. IAF is very very weak...abd useless also
IAF has truly earned it's moniker "Incompetent Air Force".
Good.that u realize it's your opinion.....
They play with the tools that they have been given...
Crashes have to be compared vis a vis flying time.....in simple words...how much do we fly....
Nepal Airforce ,if they have one ,may not have any crashes....
i fully agree😎
36 Rafael's are the only 4.5 generation aircraft in the IAF. The rest of them are dated... Tejas MK2 and AMCA projects need to be handed over to Tata Aerospace or some other private player. HAL is pathetic.
Tatas will foldup their aerospace division and close shop. IAF does not order in bulk and keeps delaying beyond the point of no return where you have no other option except purchase foreign aircraft. You need consistent funding and TLC for your domestic industry. If you keep giving piecemeal orders, you get a piecemeal product.
IAF doctrine. 🤣🤣🤣 Never had a kill shot with air to air missiles in its existence. 🤷♂️🥴
Paki Spotted 😂😂😂🇵🇰
Agree. IAF is just a time wasting entity 🤭🤭🤭
So called F16 kill after Balakot is not validated on the ground , not a single sign of debris , some AWACS signature is being touted …all propaganda
@@ghungroogangatesh3549 F-16 smashed part is been recovered by IAF
@@User-ce4zu no not a trace of debris, all images are fake news
3.30 - host trying hard not to sleep
10.30- gone to sleep for 2 seconds
23.03- tries hard to supress yawning
26.19- finally gets bored and starts checking wattsapp and tiktok
34.16- is releived the torture is finally over and wakes up.
This unkempt scamp on this show is a disgrace.