Surveil, hunt & probably eliminate: What India’s deal for MQ-9B drones means for Navy, Army, IAF
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 июн 2023
- The age of drones is upon us, but like all procurement of Western weapon systems, deal involving MQ-9B Predator B drones has run into controversy. In episode 1260 of #CutTheClutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta looks at how India will use MQ-9B drones & how they differ from earlier Predator versions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@CoorgWildernessResort
More here - www.coorgwildernessresort.in/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Navy Chief Admiral R Hari Kumar's full video in #ThePrintUncut here : • 'Will give a capabilit...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
Please make show on IAF's depleting Squadrons strength and how IAF calculated that it requires 42 Squadron why not more than 42 or less than 42 what is logic behind 42 Squadron
China LAC per hamari baja raha hai or Shivji China may Kailash perbat per birajman hain😢
The Congres's statement on this was ridiculous. They said that DRDO could deliver such high-quality drones at 20% of the cost, and that too in a short time. The drafter of this statement must have been on some "high-quality" stuff. The other part was the price. The US Govt foots the R&D bill of companies like Lockheed Martin, Boeing, and General Atomics. They also get grants & incentives. Hence, the prices quoted to the US and other countries are different. For, e.g., F35s were sold to Canada and German for $450 million and 240 million, resp, but the US airforce got them for 100 million. Customization also adds to costs.
Some people have this white man syndrom. they think anything the white guys makes is better. We need to come out of this mindset first
Right 👍
Scamgress salty that they aint getting a cut😂
Add infrastructure build up to this.
Politically I am not inclined to the BJP or congress or any other political parties , but when it comes to security of our nation it is imperative that we get the latest weapon system and the purchase of these drones are of at most importance, We can grow our own industries of drones and weapon systems simultaneously that doesn't mean that we should not get these from outside , this will give our developers more insight into the working of world class drones and this can be used to tinker our own systems
He really cuts the clutter, unbiasedly reports. A mature journalist in deed amongst a lot of nonsense passing off as journalism. More strength to him.
Ignorance is bliss!
But the audio guy does a very poor job 😕
@bubulmallick846
That is the pakistan 🇵🇰 model of development. Beggars can not be choosers.
When you're used to getting alms, your economy tanks and ATMs go dry. Lack of basic food such as Aata, and then people turn to loot and blackmail as is happening even for the sacrificial Goats on Bakra Eid.
We're happy to pay for everything we buy as we know how money is earned and value it. So we use it wisely for our country's development.
@bubulmallick846
Like Pakistan 🇵🇰 we don't allow our land or resources to be used for wars by others.
we don't fight wars for others, we fight our own wars.
Of course every beggar feels someone is generous till they are getting alms, like 🇵🇰 is felt USA 🇺🇸 was generous when they gave you $and weapons all these years. Now China 🇨🇳 is generous. Pakistan 🇵🇰 will always remain a beggar country. You'll always be spreading your 🤲 from whereever you can get alms. Right now China is doing it. Tomorrow when Chinese stop giving you'll go elsewhere. Begging is in your DNA.
@@bubulmallick846bhikari mulk katorastan every thing free beggar country pappistan
Once upon a time Mr Nehru told that India does not need Army so we lost 1962 war... Now the great grand child is also talking we did not want drone we want PM chair and help Swiss bank to open new accounts... Another thing yesterday china moked India for buying this drones Today some Swiss bank employee did press conference regarding high price of this drones...
Who cares what China thinks, when do they ever say anything honest or that isn't meant as an insult. The CCP is salty the CH-4 copies of the Predator/reaper were not wanted, and those that bought them sold them soon aftern due to poor quality.
fuddu nehru used to say hindi -chini bhai bhai and hhindu-mooslim bhai -chara where mmossllim mmosslim bhai bhai an hhindu being chara.... he used to say iindia donot need army, police is enough.... man such were the leaders choosen by the iindian. no doubt iindia was sslave for nearly 700 yrs.
It is NOT predator MQ9B is the reaper. Congress has conveniently compared the price of the MQ1 predator with that MQ9B reaper. This is by far the best drone available. US airforce is now replacing F16 squadrons with this drone.
Congress party knows how to get kickbacks from such deals. This is why they think others will also get kickbacks. Only thing Congress party does not know is that the present government is totally patriotic and transparent in such deals.
Very true. Congress looks for making money in every activity ..
At 11:30, Shekarji is worried about Services fragmentation due to the drone deal. I believe that's misplaced. With the new Theatre command implementation, the Army and Air force will share their facilities and maintenance. So we should not be that worried about giving 8 to Army and 8 to Air force. I'd rather push for faster jointness and cohesiveness between the two services instead.
There was already a report of establishing a unified drone command.
Drones cannot be used as offencive against pak and china
Also In War Scenarios Army on ground , Navy in Water & Airforce in Air have independent role to play . And has to be sharp focused on their targets & objectives!
Probably the reason for distributing small quantities of such sofisticated armaments amongst the three services must be to sensetize them to their operating requirements. So that at a later date if volumes become available, operating people are savy .
I agree, as similar DRONE is being tested by DRDO. But their is time to production.
Exactly.........and once war theater established, the full force of drones can be integrated and optimized in udage for operation and objectives.
Nope. The Armed forces in India are suffering from same old mentality of turf war and petty positioning. Not just Apache or MQ-9B, take a look at Chinook. Chinook is a troop carrier helicopter which ideally should be operated by Army Aviation Wing since Army has the troops but IAF did not allow that due to petty internal turf war.
@@animesh_tiwary
Why diverting from buying latest drons to defend us to blah blah blah.........
@@souravchakraborty8861 ? DRDO has nothing close to Predator forget this. Ghatak and all are yet to even fly with electronics yet.
We are a "Jugaad" country. Many seasoned defence experts have repeatedly flagged the "some here, some there" strategy alongside our insanely high number of suppliers. Jugaad works until it doesn't. Some "Babu" might have made tall claims of how we could use the same drone for multiple purposes (which even the creators of the drones won't have imagined), leading to Govt thinking of extracting a value of 300 billion out of 3 billion spendings. Hence, the 15 to the Navy, 8 to whoever breakup.
Looking at the cabal of ministers it shouldn't be a surprise - it's a jugaad cabinet without qualifications!
MQ-9B capability is best in world.
It's also the costliest drone in the world.
@@tytxlx6503 do a google search , read about its sensors and avionics
@@tytxlx6503USA use same drone to kill Iranian military commander in Iran in 2020. With same drone they did many operations.
Please share this video to congressi to understand predator drone importance ...
Why would someone need a video to understand the importance of drones? Drone is the most effective way to locate and hunt any enemy. Russia and Ukraine war is a proof of that.
Congress is the opposition party, they will oppose every decision of the running government. As a Bangladeshi who reads every news about India, I think India is on the right way.
It is very important that this very sensitive contract be given to Adani so that he can recoup some of the humongous losses he has incurred . After all Rafale contract was given to bankrupt Ambani and oil contract to elder Ambani. All the PM'S oligarchs minting while the citizens struggle . LAGE RAHO .
@@jkardez4794 What?, Adani kah aaya bheech main, Matlab kuch bhi. Rafales came from france, This drones are coming from U.S.
Matlab Rahul Gandhi samze ho ka?
@@jkardez4794 not only this. General atomic is a company owned by Adanis brother. It’s all family business. ModiZ is putting 3 billion in Adanis pocket. Modi jis son and modis brother is also employed by Adani and are on adanis payroll living in big bungalows
along with P-8is, these drones can be a great help for Indian Navy in countering chinese subs inside Indian Ocean. Not to forget other missions on LAC and LOC. Great assets.
It's excellent research done by Guptaji. Also the manner of his explaining in layman's language are all amazing. Thank you
@@bubulmallick846 Who better than paxtan to demand something for free? 😂
Coupta it's not only Bofors legacy, it's the legacy of Durbari journalists like you as well who during Congress times use to do hit jobs on army
Now you have Adani to do hit jobs ; sadly he's Licking his wounds 😑 😕
Very good analysis from Shekhar sir.. 😊
Educative , Thank you. I look forward to more such videos
Khangress wants to help our Islamist and communist neighbours. They have done the same with Rafael, by putting pressure on Indian Government they want to know the sensitive Tech included in the deal ....we have complete faith in GOI and Indian Army...Ignore papu and gang ...
Morocco - US definitely deserves a completely separate episode on Cut The Clutter
As an aviation enthusiast though not an expert I would like to add the following:
The higher powered engine of the Reaper / Sky Guardian has been correctly mentioned by SG. However, that is only a part of the entire aircraft. The old Predator has a gross weight of one ton where the Reaper has a weight of nearly 5 tons. The payload itself is 1.7 tons which is more than weight that of the Predator! Simply put it is several times bigger.
Now the question whether they will survive has been wrongly approached. These are not "inside the combat" a/c like fighters or bombers but more like ISTAR and AW&CS. Now, if a Reaper is vulnerable then these are too. And if so why are these considered as force multipliers and so important in modern warfare? The answer is obvious.
These carry any anti-sub sensors but not anti-sub weapons. They do carry Hellfire missiles and bombs that can be used against surface targets.
Have you read the deal, wow this rebooting not just your defensive industry this a comprehensive deal that strengthen your economy. I have always said that this war not just military it's economic.
Didn't they use this to kill a terrorist in Afghan recently
I don’t understand these so called security experts…if according to them these drones are of minimal use, then why do Pakistan and China keep on adding to their drone stockpile. Some people will criticize no matter what…even if it’s a question of national security
You are ill informed and the defense experts are right.
These drones are insanely expensive - they cost as much as a fighter jet with associated costs etc. E.g. Taiwan bought 4 reapers for $600 million - you could have fielded something like 15 additional Tejas Mk1As for that cost, or 40 extra Tejas Mk1As if you only want to account for the forex cost (after all, GoI can always print more rupees). The Indian govt is rumored to be buying 31 drones for $3.2 billion - again - a cost that could buy 75 additional Tejas Mk1As at nameplate value and a whopping 213 extra Tejas Mk1As if you only include the forex cost - because again - the rupee part of the purchases just ends up recirculating within the Indian economy.
The drones that Pakistan, Turkey and China are buying are much cheaper - Bayraktars are $5m each or around $20M each with the full package. Ultimately Pakistan will end up flooding India with hundreds of drones for a couple of billion dollars while India will just be operating less than two dozen across army and airfare - despite spending multiple times as much as them. Reapers are designed for an expeditionary army taking down targets in places that don't have any air defense not a defensive army facing down two modern armies on its land borders.
The Reaper might make sense for naval operations for reconnaissance during peacetime and submarine hunting during wartime but it makes zero sense for either the air force or army. The airforce needs more Tejas and Rafale with better radars and anti-stealth missiles, the army needs swarms of cheaper drones of Bayraktar class that can actually be used in a conflict.
@AKumar-co7oe hey dolt... the MQ-9B is meant for 24×365 continous surveillance of land and maritime borders which are very vast
Compare the cost of keeping a tejas airborne for 30 hours & a Mq-9b for same time... also the max endurance of Tejas is no more than 4.5 hours at a time
@@iHarsh918 That's what he said. Read before you comment, smartass.
@@AKumar-co7oe If enemy manage to shoot down one of both. in Tejas apart from the equipment lose we will lose one life. that is a major problem if one values human life. and buying these drones doesn't mean that we cannot get other cheap drones, we are designing drones in our country and manufacturing them too.
@@manut1349 except that it's not equally easy to shoot down either - a tejas can dodge and fight air to air with radar missiles, a reaper can only bomb helpless wedding parties in afghanistan - it is totally defenceless against fighter jets and other air defense - it isn't capable of dodging
If you want to protect pilots, support the CATS warrior program for networked drone warfare
Very nice explanatory video. Thanks Print.
Beautifully explained shekharji
❤❤
Thanks for the book recommendation Shekhar- the way of the knife. Added to my list.
Always a pleasures to listen to SG , when he talks about defense technology . He swims like a big fish in deep water.
Excellent analysis ❤
Well researched article.
Congress is unhappy cause they can't make money on defense deals now... shekarji ur party 8snnever coming to power do what ever...haah
i will never vote for congress again do u know why???? because i came to know that in 46' election mmosslim voted for paakistan ( more than 90%) but this kaamchor librandu congress party did not do popul. xchange..
Excellent
When Shekarji decides .. it always comes great... but little bit late... ok no problems.. better late than never.. we love the authentic journalism..
That was a complete post mortem of MQ-9B by Shekhar ji.
Pappu wants to know their sensors for the Chinese. That's what he was trying for Rafale aircraft
Thanks for simplifying the purchase of DRONES
India doesn't have any drone program in MQ9B category. In fact no other drone in the World comes near this drone.
Yes, these will be expensive (even though the price negotiations is yet to happen), but these will be a force multiplier - especially for the Navy. Gupta is right on this - Navy is happy with these birds.
Ignore the exfarts. China is unhappy with this deal for a reason.
Forget about drones, India cannot make a mobile or even a simple automobile . What we have is a moron brigade which chants along with a pied piper . Wonder what Jaishankar has to say about the deal regarding independence after lecturing the Americans and Europeans .
We must leave it to our armed forces to decide which wepons to buy from where . Be it from India or abroad. Civilians job is to give total budget for defence . Withing that budget armed forces must decide what is best for indias securiety. For price etc the entire process of du diligence is in place . We saw that during Rafael hoopla congress creates eventuly to be snubbed very badly in their face by supream court .
Nothing is going to come out of congresses hoopla again . One thing us good is that this goverment without caring much about opp drama is fully going ahead with modernising armed forces. These drones are one of the most deadly wepons world has seen in the last decade and we sourendee with enemies and poures borders need this kind of weapon to search and destroy terroriest and drug smuglers coming in from all sides of India.
That's because you're a Desi andhbhakht you don't read the French media which had the guts to show how a bankrupt Ambani was given the contract. Typical Andhbhakht !
Dancing Mama Shekhar ❤
There are 8 ex-Indian navy personnel under house arrest for last 1 year in Qatr. Looking forward to an episode to #ctc
What is there to make an episode?
Qatar says they were spying for India & Israel.The case is in courts now.
Last week a Turkish guy got arrested in North East for spying, it's part of the game
can you do an episode on "kaveri" engine?. May be be this will provide more insight into the current situation.
Shekhar gupta is a better defence analyst than other journalists...
It’s a shame that we haven’t allowed private companies to develop drones. Currently turkey produces indigenous drones which are nearly as good but are dirt cheap.
India's tapas is better than bayraktar-Tb2(turkey)...
Sir please do a CTC on the laser weapon Kaali
Thanks!
Dear viewer,
Thank you for supporting ThePrint's journalism.
We need Rustam with BSF regarding drug smuggling from punjab and bangladesh
It can be used to surveillance the land and water borders very effectively.
Great
“ India should be producing intelligent properties and patents rather than just consuming. For this India needs to recognize that it needs all the protections and legal apparatus that allows that. ” - Fareed Zakaria
An uninformed statement by an uninformed person. Development takes time, and innovation is the last step of this journey. Unless you the master product, you can't produce its next iteration. All developing countries began their journey by imitating, aka reversing engineering, over time, mastered the skill and then became the beacon of innovation - Japan, South Korea, and China are examples. India's started its journey in the 90s (post-liberalization). It is the second fastest-growing economy of the last 3 decades. It's doing pretty well. It will innovate when the time is right.
@@sankalp6872
For last 10 years time was not right for innovation? But time was right to do Hindu Muslim all over the Nation?😅
@@sankalp6872 Fareed is right on this one. Our Intellectual Property Laws need serious reforms and updates. Our Judiciary is absent when it comes to IP and copyright enforcement. We don't need the same laws as the US but we need good laws and a responsive Judiciary none the less.
@@libshastra Laws are not the problem. Enforcement is the issue. Our courts are already swamped with so many cases that IPR and Copyrights go for a toss. Judiciary needs a fix and expansion.
@@mg.f.9023 Nope. Muslim radicalism was a national security problem. It had to be neutralized.
Please make a cut the clutter episode on Opposition to unified theatre commands by Armed forces mainly Airforce
Waiting for cuttheclutter on UCC from Shekhar ji.
21:46 *The Way Of The Knife* Mark Mazzetti
I am reminded of establishment of Radar research centres at the five IITs in early 70s and were given Rs. one crore each. UOR also pitched for it and got Rs. 20 lakhs.
At that time we didn't have expertise even for one centre.
So it is old habit of spreading the resources too thin.
Good half baked truth.
If we want surveillance in both sea and land at low operation cost this is the best. Along LOC with night vision with attack capability will support the army for surveillance.
Sekhar Gupta Ji, I have immense respect for you as a journalist. Your observations on splitting Drones among army and Airforce are well taken . As a journalist, you should have researched how other countries with these assets are managing. If your logic of splitting assets is extended, why have Army,Navy and Airforce and split assets? I think each Arm of defence has a different requirement and different outlook for managing their assets. People, who have laid down their lives in the defence of the country, with hands on experience of 30 years, should know how to manage. India already has a thinking of having CDS to coordinate between Army, Navy and Airforce. I have put in my thoughts,so you may consider them also.
I think its more of a package deal... The way it was announced along with GEF414 engine. Prior to this they were not willing for tech transfers. Suddenly they are enabling 80% transfer. Speaks for itself. For India, which has long tried unsuccessfully to develop indegenous engines, perhaps this might be the calling. And for India, 3.2bill Usd is a small price to keep US engaged in the game. I mean after all you need market access for your goods, FDI's and what not.
Why no episode on titan submarine incident yet
Sg works on politics ONLY. No such incentive in it
there is no clutter there. someone made a terrible business deal of paying 250K USD to purchase death. what is there to discuss in it?
none of iindia business.....
Sg, without theaterisation each arm maintain separate strategic assets. Fusion of these assets form after theatre commands
Are this better then reaper drone
This is the reaper.
😂😂😂.... Waah
SG, please upload daily ctc bit early. By 11pm is fine but its getting late on a daily basis, we just cannot lose sleep waiting for it.
There will always be some kind of money exchange and few people near to power getting benefit.
However if the product is good, if the deal is beneficial for the country, it is good for the country
It can help Army surveil the LoC and LAC and detect any troop/terrorist build up close to the border better than satellites can.
It's more important for navy .... for IOR
@@sidthesailor3483 India does not have any disputed naval borders, but we do have a disputed, active and hot LoC and LAC. So while Navy can use these cover a larger area, the army and air force need these equally if not more at present.
If the congress has its way - Indian troops will be armed with slingshots and Diwali mela dhanush baand. I still remember the decade or so of damage done by the congress’ AK Antony who refused to buy anything in order to keep his image “clean”.
I guess no episode on joint statement about science and technology part. Anyone Please help if it’s come or request SG sir to do it
Its there.
Plz chk
MQ-9B will be operated by the Tri-services command, nah? One based out of North and one based out of South?
First time watching just after 2-3 minutes of video released
Only criticism. No discussion on Drones.
We should engage our private engineering firms to manufacture this in bulk, Tata Technologies, LT, Mahindra etc. The parent company in the USA is also headed by an Indian now, Vivek Lal
Whoever works outside is nullified as a indian
Given its drawbacks the drone would be deployed after air domination has been established and enemy's air defence suppressed. Any addition to defence assets is welcome given the prevailing global situation
100 million per piece? Arent drones supposed to be cheap? Isn't rafale priced nearly same?
👍
Maybe we should have a Missle force, and another Drone & Surveillance Force.
Bofors was a scam but Bofors played an important role in Kargil war...
Same, MQ-9B Reaper will be an unnecessarily expensive deal but it will be a good deal....
it is not unnecessary. Reaper Drone is best in world. USA use same drone to kill Iranian commander in Iran in 2020.
It’s expensive because we are demanding customization. NAVIC integration, MRO facilities, local subcomponent manufacturing, integration with our communications infrastructure all add to the cost of the procurement. You are not just buying 31 drones.
Why can't we have separate division of drones and helicopters? They can work wherever needed
Sir iska Hindi version bhe laye
Dronacharya was the original inventory of drones. Now we buy drones from foreign countries.
If Congress is opposing this, please be assured this is good for country 😂
This is basically for surveillance. Sir how many wars have you seen in last 20 yrs.
Correction: we are buying more of sea guardian not reaper
Thank u Sir, it is very informative 🙏🙏
Sir you are right, same thing i am thinking, ghatak drone is only solution. Why they are buying for army, these drones are no match to mordern fighters and defence missiles
IMHO, these drones were pushed by the US as a package with the GE 414 engines, the GE 414 engine partial TOT was what were really required, yes the navy would find some utility in regards to using these drones in non contested airspace but as far as combat capability is concerned, there is no such capability to engage submarines or even track them when they are submerged.. at best these drones are designed to drop ordinance in uncontested airspace over the heads of rifle armed insurgents or keep an eye on surface vessels in the IOR nothing more.. even in lightly contested airspace within low intensity conflict zones these would be brought down like flies through hard or soft kill capabilities as seen in the middle east, Persian gulf etc.
They are primarily for the Navy to supplement Posiden PI8 for the anti-submarine role, comparatively, they are cheaper for PI8 aircraft and can stay in the sky longer than Pi8, with less maintenance and work with less crew, in fact, they can communicate with PI8, when in air. China is increasing its submarine numbers and also building 8 more for Pakistan, our submarine numbers are nowhere near them, this will help the Navy till we beef up our submarines to monitor the Indian Ocean and Arabian Sea. To sum it up, they are only for surveillance, and that's the reason the army is only investing primarily in loitering munition for attack roles, not drones
Editor could have done a better job by excluding the ending nod signal
Yeah, probably Congress needs to know the details so that they can supply the information to China.
Give it to a bankrupt Ambani ...
Excellent journalist. But still waiting to accept the mistakes pointed out in his show by Dr. Salvatore Babones.
Necessarily share Indian air bases with American personnel in order to optimally utilize the drones.
The need for such drones by the Navy and Army is understandable. They have to conduct ISR missions over vast expanse of territory. But the need for it by the IAF is confusing. For offensive actions armed drones would be useless.
It is most unfortunate that questions are raised for political gains over kickbacks even before the system has been bought. As has been reported it is going to be a government to government deal and this nonsense should be nipped in the bud. Need of the hour is to get means to deter potential enemies across the boarders. As always Mr.Gupta has explained everything very well for a layman to understand.
Need of the hour is to enrich bankrupt businessmen and give them sensitive contracts like the Rafale .
Indegenous Rustom should be produced in a big number.
No machine is infalliable but it does not stop from purchasing it because it is important.
Sometime distribution of assets is because of availability of funds from different wings of arm forces.
Forvany thing in world there are so called experts for and against but one thing need to understand they are expert of old age and I believe that present working persons know the needs of today and future.
The cost of Chinese stealth J20 5th Generation fighter jet is $120 million
The Indian drone is only $100 million it is a bargain, 👍
Air Force does not need these drones as well as Apaches. Air force is there to keep air space clear. Not to perform the functions of Army and Navy. They better stick to that.
KEEP UR HANDS DOWN TIE IT TO THE CHAIR NOW NEED TO GESTURE SO MUCH
these days small cheap drones that pack a punch seems more relevant. The ones that cost less and destroys valuable equipment or draws expensive interceptors. The drones of this durability are probably quite useful in maritime surveillance. main attractiveness of these drones is that they are expensive and percentages of commission makes them attractive to the buyer.
Why can't people just leave the decision making part to the real military experts? Can see so many people here fighting from both sides , as if they know all its capabilities. And NO, Google search won't reveal its real potential. You are not comparing smartphones here by just looking at its spec!
This is the platform where one can air their views anonymously and fight with other anonymous people. Is it not fun. RUclips and video creators benefit from the comments making more money for them, that is fun too. The algorithm is set for that.
@@manut1349. Good comment
why do u think these so called real military experts cant be question..
At 11:14 you are expressing doubts about the concept of dividing the assets . Are you a better expert on the subject ?
GlobalEconomy Innovation Index 2022:
India ranks No. 40
South Korea No.6
Singapore No. 7
China No. 11
Japan No. 13
@tytxlx6503
Per Capita of GDP 2022 :
India: 2,301 $
Bangladesh: 2,687 $
Singapore: 82,794 $
China is no 1 when it comes to stealing IP
@conquerorlalitaditya6550
Congrats 🎉
Atack Helicopters are always under the Army control in most western countries, why is it that India never adop this system
Guptaji, well crafted analysis......making sure that getting these important equipment from USA, No credit given toModi or his govt!!!!!!!!
Why not giving credit where its due????? Well, all knows the real reasons..........
When has the army and the Airforce defense acquisition ever make sense out of the three arm force the Navy has been and has shown is the only arm force in our county that actually knows what it needs and what it wants and how to utilize it assents . Except for the sub and AIRCRAFT carrier debate thats is where its beijg constraint by our defense budget as for the othet two nothing ever make sense sijce they them self dont even know what they want what they need.
It's mainly to counter akinci drones purchased by Pakistan from turkey
The US use very young women as drone pilots, some 19-20 years, for their agility and nimbleness.
Like a video games
Why you want to know what kind of features the drones have? So that the enemy knows it?
This may be very useful weapons for forces but it is nothing for india. The latest tech is RQ180 this tech is already withdrawn from advanced countries
may be enough for Pakistan surveillances. Other than China no other advanced countries in our neighborhood.
If we have Boeing P8i then why do we need MQ-9 drones ? .... Or maybe we could have purchased 15 of these only for the navy ! .... In that case we could have saved a lot of money and also controversy ! ....
Per hour cost of flying p8i aircraft would be 20 times more than this drone, and maintanence of p8i is huge it's a commercial Boeing plane