What a solid performance! You could tell she wasn’t feel her best, but she still came out and delivered a solid performance. And America voted her into the next round.
I love her voice and any song she sings automatically she makes it her own by the tone of her voice however I really would have loved to have heard this with just her on the piano that would have been so signature❤
In order to win, she needs to cover instantly recognizable standards like she did with "The Story", or "Both Sides Now". Blue Eyes Cryin' In the Rain, I Fall To Pieces, Blue Bayou, The Sound of Silence, The First Time Ever..., and so on are perfect for Mckenna's voice. Idol producers give great songs to choose from to those they hope will win. Great singers, Mckenna, is a great singer, don't get quite the choice of others. But a couple others (not to be named), seem to be who producers want in the final 3.
She was sick and everyone gave her grace but she was not good. The judges tell everyone they are great. Zero criticism for all. Simon is missed. Time for some new judges.
I like her but didn’t like this song choice. This performance was disappointing and clearly impacted by her illness. Hopefully she’ll have a solid comeback performance next week.
They all don't make it because of having a "famous" relative. Lionel didn't put Aretha Franklin's granddaughter thru in 2022. Plus, what about the ones that have had contracts, records, etc... in the past or tried out on previous/similar shows. Should they also not be allowed?
The "star" is her . She is the One who not only sound great but the looks is the idol itself , not even tryin❤ finale it is
She could sing I don't wanna miss a thing. It would be perfect on her voice.
I was gonna say!!! Who's her dad. Aerosmith?? They look so similar 😍
Not an easy song to sing even made in a key of your tone... She rocked it 🎉🎉🎉
Wrong song choice. Ruined the song, should sing a Bonnie Tyler song.
@@jmit3491 A Bonnie Tyler song...great idea. This was okay, but not her best performance.
What a solid performance! You could tell she wasn’t feel her best, but she still came out and delivered a solid performance. And America voted her into the next round.
She's very pretty. And her tone, just hauntingly beautiful.
She should be the winner 🏆💿♥️
I’d love to see her get a chance to re- sing this one. Being sick, def shows but she still did fantastic. If she was 💯- it would be a game changer.
She did an wonderful job after being under the weather.
I have no idea who’s gonna win! I think it’s gonna be one of the girls cause they are just all fantastic!
Yeah, she's making the Top 10.
the true star!!! Love you McKenna! My winner!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My Idol!!!
OMG fricking unique voice
She has a whole future ahead of her! She is moving to LA
Hauntingly beautiful voice
Just wow. Chicago and let alone Peter Cetera are very difficult songs to tackle. She did an amazing job. I felt every word and didn't want it to end.
Wow! She is so talented! ❤❤❤
Go Girl Sick Voice & All You Were A Powerhouse & You Did Well
McKenna sings beautiful! ❤ Love her voice 🎤🎶🎵🥰
Great singer
Amazing performance
She did amazing being under the weather. Love this song choice .
Wow, she is awesome, love her tone , and song choice, yes keep it up,
I love her voice and any song she sings automatically she makes it her own by the tone of her voice however I really would have loved to have heard this with just her on the piano that would have been so signature❤
You nailed it again McKenna
Beautiful voice love her
Love her voice
Love her ❤❤
My winner!!
I want Mckenna to win ❤
I only wish it was the whole song. I would listen to her rendition for days on end. This was soooo good!!!!!!
I love her , in all aspects she is a STAR! An Icon....
Amazing 🤩
Everything about this is IT!!! She sang this 🤩
Original voice ❤❤❤❤❤
The American Idol 2024 🎉 love you McKenna
Very good job ❤
❤❤❤❤McKenna ❤❤❤❤beautiful 🎉🎉
Love this song,
In order to win, she needs to cover instantly recognizable standards like she did with "The Story", or "Both Sides Now". Blue Eyes Cryin' In the Rain, I Fall To Pieces, Blue Bayou, The Sound of Silence, The First Time Ever..., and so on are perfect for Mckenna's voice. Idol producers give great songs to choose from to those they hope will win. Great singers, Mckenna, is a great singer, don't get quite the choice of others. But a couple others (not to be named), seem to be who producers want in the final 3.
I feel like she can sing "A Case of You" perfectly.
One of my favourites!
Hands down the best! Hope she wins
Yes 🎉🎉🎉❤ !
I love her she has the package. She can say she looks like a singer and she can’t perform oh boy can she perform.🥰🐾
Love her
McKenna I hope makes it to the top 5. Sorry she is under the weather.
Mckenna is amazing!
WOW!1. 🌀🌀💛🤗👍
She should win.
yeah mackeiyea mackenna road to finals
She's my favorite along with abi julia and jayna
🎉🎉❤
Wow
She looks like Julia Roberts to me and she was awesome ❤
❤❤❤❤
Top 5
From the start i've predicted top 3 will be Abi, Will, and Tristan. I think Mckenna might just sneak in there though.
She is like the female version of Aerosmith.
Please do “What was I made for” by Billie Eilish. I KNOW you will do good with that song!
She has the whole package
The Julia Robert’s of AI !!
I like that little bit of smokiness in her voice. Seems like a bit of struggle in spots, may of been her illness affecting her voice.
She is amazing! Such a soulful voice!
Stylist needs firing. She's gorgeous and theyre making her look old fashioned
Can they give her piano back ? Or a guitar. I think she will be in her best confidence when she holding an instrument.
Gene Simmons looks like Howard Stern. 😀
☝🏽
Maybe she could sing a Bryan Adams song.
Her voice is sooooooo sexy. And she is stunningly beautiful. OMG
Do a Lana Del Rey song please. ❤
Sing with Carrie Underwood
She was sick and everyone gave her grace but she was not good. The judges tell everyone they are great. Zero criticism for all. Simon is missed. Time for some new judges.
Jack my most fav in this voice.
This is NOT Jacks Video BYE
Sori yea McKenna for finals
Wrong key ?
Someone screwed up !
Sorry Charlie !
She doesn't have much of a range. She should try some Cher songs.
Not good song choice for her vocal..
Mckenna, Jayna and NYA For the finale
A Joke right😂😂😂😂
@@efrenmoreno3 Now it’s a joke :( Nya didn’t make it
KB & maybe Emmy? 🙂
@@cjdlaron Not having Abi in the top 3 is CRAZY
@@efrenmoreno3 So crazy!!! Well now she can be added to that list!
Didn't like this song for her. It's a bit of a karaoke sounding. But I love her voice so much. Oh she was sick.
Ouch, NOT a great song choice for this great singer. Good luck McKenna.
Not her best performance.
Had some minor pitch issues, overall she did a great job!
Wrong song
I thought the music overpowered her voice. I doubt think it was a good song choice.
Poor McKenna. Her voice is not 100%. She did great though.
A bit off for me 😊
Not a great song choice ….
Bad song choice which sucks because she's my favorite. She needs to sit down at the piano that's when she's at her best
Too much song for her voice
Not 100%
None were 100%
She was great.
It sounds really off to me
Nya should have made it she did better than her
She should pick Carly Simon song such as nobody does it better or youre so vain...
This performance full of out of tune....
I like her but didn’t like this song choice. This performance was disappointing and clearly impacted by her illness. Hopefully she’ll have a solid comeback performance next week.
Shoot! Terrible shame she's sick---draining her voice and energy. Hope she bounces back up for next performances.
very bad
Like Emily, shes another person on here because of who her mother was. She should've been gone also
They all don't make it because of having a "famous" relative. Lionel didn't put Aretha Franklin's granddaughter thru in 2022. Plus, what about the ones that have had contracts, records, etc... in the past or tried out on previous/similar shows. Should they also not be allowed?
Emily grandmother Loretta Lynn
@@gerrih5857 I said those 2 if u can eead
Her parents weren’t famous at all
@bernifitzsimmons176 not as famous as Emmys grandmother, but they had a following & story that a lot of people knew about