Part One: Thomas Kinkade: the Evil-est Painter | BEHIND THE BASTARDS

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 янв 2025

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @wuggle420
    @wuggle420 4 месяца назад +604

    My ex-mother-in-law once called a Thomas Kincade painting a "Kinky" and I may never recover

    • @NeiZaMo
      @NeiZaMo 4 месяца назад

      Some people just need that kink aid to get off

    • @jannettb7930
      @jannettb7930 4 месяца назад +16

      Totally stealing this lmao 😂

    • @mercerblackwell
      @mercerblackwell 4 месяца назад +13

      That's what they call 'em in the fan club 😂

    • @jannettb7930
      @jannettb7930 4 месяца назад +12

      @@mercerblackwell there's a fan club?? Seriously??

    • @bryncheeze8970
      @bryncheeze8970 4 месяца назад +7

      I don't think anyone who knows this will recover either

  • @jrobson100
    @jrobson100 4 месяца назад +902

    OK, let me preface this by saying that I love Randy's work. I had never seen an image of him before and my first reaction was "We have Alan Moore at home." I apologize in advance if Randy sees this.

    • @daniexists6
      @daniexists6 4 месяца назад +157

      Hey, that's not fair. He's been trying to get into a Rasputin lookalike contest for years.
      For the record, this is a joke. Sorry, Randy.

    • @bergec0
      @bergec0 4 месяца назад +48

      @@daniexists6 No, no. Robert is Rasputin.

    • @TheNaldiin
      @TheNaldiin 4 месяца назад +39

      Randy seems mostly surprised he still exists.

    • @janschleicher5276
      @janschleicher5276 4 месяца назад +17

      ​@@bergec0they can go as young and old Rasputin 😂

    • @sp00kums
      @sp00kums 4 месяца назад +67

      Gotta hit that “Artists that look like ancient and powerful wizards” demographic somehow!

  • @Aogami20
    @Aogami20 4 месяца назад +365

    Andy Warhol - "The production line commodification of art is bad"
    Thomas Kinkade - "You had me at the production line commodification of art."

    • @e32b61
      @e32b61 4 месяца назад

      Except Warhol didn’t say that. He thought it was good because Andy cared about money above all things. And in fact, Warhol’s works are at the center of much that is wrong with the art world today. From the Mugrabi collection to the Warhol Foundation, power is brokered via auction houses, high-end galleries, and NGO’s like the Pew Charitable Trusts that control public museums, to engage in a cyclical scam of releasing a few works for “tours” of major institutions to increase visibility, then selling those or similar works by the artist for record-breaking (and tax deductible) profits and money laundering. Enough for an episode of this podcast to say the least.

    • @MissOhio1980
      @MissOhio1980 4 месяца назад +18

      which is funny.... Andy Warhal is some of the most commercial art.

    • @Aogami20
      @Aogami20 4 месяца назад +12

      @@MissOhio1980 That's kind of the point.

    • @MistaZULE
      @MistaZULE 4 месяца назад +11

      @KimberlyBishh just like the other person said, that's literally why he got famous. Pop art was a big middle finger to the commodification of art andy warhol was seeing infect his profession.

  • @wrexvincent
    @wrexvincent 4 месяца назад +623

    I used to speculate that Thomas Kincade was a serial arsonist who would paint the houses he set fire to because there is no way houses should glow like that unless there is an uncontrolled fire inside

    • @kilgoreplumbus1360
      @kilgoreplumbus1360 4 месяца назад +18

      coating a house in unevaporated paint would go up well I imagine, I think I have arson tendencies but do not seek to harm others so do not indulge. Watching stuff burn is hypnotising to me idk.

    • @spoofbaby
      @spoofbaby 4 месяца назад +25

      Rene Magritte had some paintings with daylight skies over nighttime buildings but it was supposed to be unsettling

    • @zorantaylor3190
      @zorantaylor3190 4 месяца назад +18

      In the example they show here of a late-afternoon winter scene, it looks like when people inside a house have just put new wiring in and are testing it by turning on as many lights and appliances at one time as possible, while one person in the basement waits by the fuse box with a flashlight in case any of the circuits break. It feels like that's the only plausible reason an interior would ever be that bright. It looks absolutely unbearable.

    • @goodun2974
      @goodun2974 4 месяца назад +6

      Art that is idealized is art ideologized. (Autocorrect wanted to change this to "idiologized", which works as well).

    • @MissOhio1980
      @MissOhio1980 4 месяца назад +4

      ​@kilgoreplumbus1360 everyone is hypnotized by fire...im glad you dont wanna hurt people tho

  • @IshibashiPandora
    @IshibashiPandora 4 месяца назад +285

    Thomas Kinkade - bringing untold comfort to a generation that tells everyone else to pull themselves up by the bootstraps.

    • @jeffhidalgo8457
      @jeffhidalgo8457 4 месяца назад +4

      So apt.

    • @roadlesstraveled34
      @roadlesstraveled34 4 месяца назад +4

      This is the realest comment about my parents ever

    • @jeffhidalgo8457
      @jeffhidalgo8457 4 месяца назад

      @@roadlesstraveled34
      I guess complaining about the boomer's "f'ed" up ethos is a zero sum gain. We must bootstrap ourselves and not spoil our kids like our grandparents did.
      Cheers Jeff

  • @plcthelegacy4131
    @plcthelegacy4131 4 месяца назад +365

    To me, Kinkade art is like the Polar Express movie. There's a warmness to it but there's also something profoundly creepy and uncanny.

    • @MissfitJoy
      @MissfitJoy 4 месяца назад +20

      Omg! This! My MIL will go on and on about his work and my husband feels the same way (bc he generally adopts whatever she likes) and I just feel the inexplicable need to go take a shower.

    • @goodun2974
      @goodun2974 4 месяца назад +21

      Art that is idealized is also ideologized, and perhaps sanitized "for your protection". Kincaid would have hated Picasso's "Guernica", which is precisely why Guernica matters and Kincade does not. Now let's try to imagine what America would be like if 1 in 4 American homes had a print of Guernica on the wall..... By the way, I saw a triptych on display in a modern art museum in Barcelona that was sort of a combination of Guernica and a Dante-inspired, Hieronymus Bosch style, "7 levels of hell" painting. It was staggering, terrifying, and enormously powerful.

    • @chadanding8692
      @chadanding8692 4 месяца назад

      ​@@goodun2974wow I'm gonna look that up

    • @Foghorn-tr1je
      @Foghorn-tr1je 4 месяца назад +3

      @@goodun2974 Picasso was also an ass.

    • @goodun2974
      @goodun2974 4 месяца назад +9

      @@Foghorn-tr1je , this is true: sometimes the ever-popular "tortured artist" theme or meme turns out to be a not-so-popular *torturer-as-artist* or "artist as torturer" upon closer study or, ugh, personal experience and physical contact. I will say, however, that the Picasso museum in Barcelona is worth visiting, as is the Gaudi museum. Picasso's earliest work look nothing like his later cubist works.

  • @miguelvelez7221
    @miguelvelez7221 4 месяца назад +623

    This is EXACTLY what the person in charge of Popeye The Sailor should look like.

    • @snorpenbass4196
      @snorpenbass4196 4 месяца назад +38

      He looks like he was in the cast of the Popeye movie, doing a repetitive sight gag in the background while Robin Williams is singing. I mean this as an absolute compliment, I love that movie.😄

    • @jannettb7930
      @jannettb7930 4 месяца назад +11

      Bluto is in charge of Popeye! That's awesome

    • @annhier1713
      @annhier1713 4 месяца назад +13

      Yes! Love his DuckTales shirt, too.

    • @MissOhio1980
      @MissOhio1980 4 месяца назад +1

      the sailor MAN...get it right.😅

    • @TheRunningLeopard
      @TheRunningLeopard 3 месяца назад

      Omg, I recognize his voice from the set of episodes that got me into Behind the Bastards.

  • @nephthys0xa499
    @nephthys0xa499 4 месяца назад +371

    My mom bought a piece of this dreck. She told me over and over how I need to keep it as an investment and only sell it if I had it appraised so I would get a good price. I stopped trying to tell her that it would never hang on my walls and it wasn't worth what she thought it was because it started to feel mean. She mentioned it again while she was in hospice and I promised to take good care of it. I hate that guy. I hate him even more that he's a part of my memories of my mom's passing.

    • @michellemausicohen2505
      @michellemausicohen2505 4 месяца назад +30

      Oh, what a sad, nightmarish thing to go through!

    • @cc1k435
      @cc1k435 4 месяца назад +6

      Hope you got her money back. 😂😢

    • @VelcroPoodle
      @VelcroPoodle 4 месяца назад +36

      If it's worth it... maybe try to think of it as she genuinely thought it would be helpful for you, and was trying to help you.
      But fuck Kincaid.

    • @hurdygurdyguy1
      @hurdygurdyguy1 4 месяца назад +25

      The only thing Kinkade art is worth is taking them and painting over them with images from other genres, such as Star Wars, Bosch, Disney, orgies etc 🤣🤣🤣

    • @cydkriletich6538
      @cydkriletich6538 4 месяца назад +7

      Oh, your comment runs parallel with one of mine. And I, too, felt bad not being able to show the same enthusiasm for my mom’s $800 Kincade piece.

  • @IshibashiPandora
    @IshibashiPandora 4 месяца назад +233

    Professional illustrator just dropping some insights on the industry:D Selling art to the middle class has actually been a big business for over a century, indeed in the early 20th century illustration was incredibly lucrative. In 1910 when the average American pay was $438 annually and average home price $2000, Maxfield Parrish raked in $100,000, making him one of the wealthiest individuals on Earth. (He was also an objectively better painter than Kinkade - freakishly so, as he painted his images in separate layers of red, blue, and yellow glazed, a technical marvel.) His painting "Daybreak" continues to outsell the Last Supper, and is estimated to be contained in 1 of 4 American homes. Other examples are Norman Rockwell, Margaret Keane, and J.C. Leyendecker. For my own part selling prints is essentially all I do, and I'll go on record emphatically that regular non-billionaire humans are by far the best customers:)

    • @ShinyAvalon
      @ShinyAvalon 4 месяца назад +46

      Norman Rockwell is one of the finest _storytellers_ in the world. I don't generally like what people consider his "genre" (wholesome small-town American life), but for him, I make an exception. Every detail, every _line_ in his paintings contributes to what Edgar Allen Poe called "the unity of the whole." I learned _sooo_ much about picture composition from just from looking at Rockwell paintings, it's unreal.
      Maxfield Parrish's work is stunning, too. It's my dream to see some of his stuff in person; apparently, no print can really capture the power of the originals.

    • @cactusshadow9840
      @cactusshadow9840 4 месяца назад

      emus pedaling bicycles...global solidarity time a new method of time keeping that places both hemispheres spheres of globe Side by side counter rotating next to one another divided into twelve color coded sections subdivided into sixty numerical minutes...eliminating the need for inter national date line and daylight savings time saving an enormous amount of energy being spent correcting mistake that are made by clerks trying to understand why for several hours every day it is three different days on the same planet.

    • @frumiousbandersnatch
      @frumiousbandersnatch 4 месяца назад +25

      Everyone thinks of Norman Rockwell's work as kitschy Americana but later in his career he turned out some insightful stuff, like "The Problem We All Live With" and the Goya-esque "Murder in Mississippi."
      Rockwell is a fascinating guy - I looked at Wikipedia to jog my memory and there was some stuff I forgot.
      Maxifield Parrish is legitimately technically wonderful. Seeing his work in person is kind of mindblowing from a technical standpoint alone. Now those paintings are luminous - the layers are so, SO fine.

    • @yesthisisshi
      @yesthisisshi 4 месяца назад +9

      Parrish's work is so beautiful.

    • @piggywiggie3922
      @piggywiggie3922 4 месяца назад +7

      I hope you don't mind this question, do you have a recommendation for a place where you can have quality prints made? I've tried to have prints made in the past but the details didn't transfer well.

  • @thecactusman17
    @thecactusman17 4 месяца назад +256

    I'm not trying to discredit BTB here, but i think we can all agree that the evilest painter was rejected from an Austrian art college and had some pretty disturbing thoughts about certain ethnic minorities.

    • @TheoRae8289
      @TheoRae8289 4 месяца назад +1

      I thought it was a French college?

    • @cattymajiv
      @cattymajiv 4 месяца назад +1

      Whatever. Delusions of artistic talent are common among megalomaniacs like Hitler and Putin. I'm sure that Trump thinks he's a great painter too.

    • @blurryeyes316
      @blurryeyes316 4 месяца назад +3

      I was thinking the same

    • @sleepyburr
      @sleepyburr 4 месяца назад +12

      I was just thinking that one of the similarities between the two is that Kinkade also rarely put people in his paintings. I think that contributes to the eerie vibe they give off; suspiciously lifeless and somehow vaguely post-apocalyptic, like you don't know who or what is really lurking in that cabin.

    • @brennenderopa
      @brennenderopa 4 месяца назад +1

      Idk that is like calling Michael Schumacher a ski athlete.

  • @patg2109
    @patg2109 4 месяца назад +112

    My aunt was the venerated artist of her small rural community. She generated income from her classes in "Thomas Kincade painting." Her "students" were all SNL-style church ladies. I remember her telling me that they weren't allowed to sign their paintings without the added phrase "in the style of Thomas Kincade." It's sad that she was actually quite talented on the rare occasions she would paint local landscapes, but she was a TK machine. I was astounded to learn he was born in 1958. I figured he was her era (pre-boomer).

    • @CatMinionUS
      @CatMinionUS 4 месяца назад +13

      There's an entire industry around "paint like Bob Ross". No joke. The owners of the Ross IP have certification courses teachers have to take. Then they book the certified teachers all over the country. I live in a major market, we have 6 certified teachers here.

    • @Ladytasya
      @Ladytasya 4 месяца назад +4

      ​@@CatMinionUS I am part of the problem because I am now googling Bob Ross painting class

    • @natewilson111
      @natewilson111 3 месяца назад

      ​@@Ladytasya I don't want to paint Bob Ross 🤷

    • @AliceBowie
      @AliceBowie 2 месяца назад

      ​@@CatMinionUSJust like those "photographed in the style of Mapplethorpe" classes that church ladies used to go to in the 80s.

  • @BabaCorva
    @BabaCorva 4 месяца назад +144

    Getting to see Sophie deal with Robert in real time is my favorite thing. Sophie, you are truly producer goals!

    • @SgtKaneGunlock
      @SgtKaneGunlock 4 месяца назад +26

      sophie putting up with roberts shinanagins is 30% of why i listen

    • @FemmeFatalleMuse
      @FemmeFatalleMuse 4 месяца назад +16

      @@SgtKaneGunlock As a long time listener, having Sophie speak in the episodes definitely made the show better. Getting to see her facial reactions to Robert's shenanigans ups the content even more.

    • @davidgallagher6096
      @davidgallagher6096 4 месяца назад +10

      its too bad they were not filming during the bagel throwing days.

  • @bearVshark100
    @bearVshark100 4 месяца назад +208

    Randy looks like an unhinged and yet slightly more hinged version of Cody Johnston. Like his beard is a bigger mess but his soul seems more at peace.

    • @asherjackson
      @asherjackson 4 месяца назад +25

      the sentiment that cody johnson is defined by his soul being at odds with peace is such a fun summary i hope he never reads.

    • @misslayer999
      @misslayer999 4 месяца назад +1

      Excellent call

    • @ash_sunday
      @ash_sunday 4 месяца назад +23

      he’s like Cody and Big Joel did the fusion dance

    • @rogue-taxidermy_griffin
      @rogue-taxidermy_griffin 4 месяца назад +2

      ​@@ash_sunday OH GOD

    • @ms.bunniesarecute2287
      @ms.bunniesarecute2287 2 месяца назад +1

      Apologize to warmbo before the boars open a portal to your immediate location

  • @catsonmeth1
    @catsonmeth1 4 месяца назад +101

    Thomas Kinkade was an artificially intelligent human trained to generate trapper-keeper covers for 80-year-old middle schoolers.

    • @phoenixdavida8987
      @phoenixdavida8987 4 месяца назад +2

      Genius!

    • @stewieismyhomeboy
      @stewieismyhomeboy 4 месяца назад +4

      That reminds me, I wonder if there will be a Behind the Bastards for Lisa Frank

  • @_mycotroph
    @_mycotroph 4 месяца назад +189

    I think Kincaid paintings perfectly (and accidentally?)capture the feeling of uncanny valley. Like, they resembles real landscapes, but something about them is so fantastical that it feels fake. The closest I can muster, is that his paintings feel like hallucinations. They look like the world does while tripping on mushrooms, but.... more distant. Disconnected.
    As a rural californian, the resemblance to almost real things and places really drive the feeling home

    • @SuperStella1111
      @SuperStella1111 4 месяца назад +25

      They are bloody dark paintings - they have profound psychological dark. Artificial, twee environments that literally (this has been studied) grow to depress those who look at these paintings too long (even when they like them). It's putrid garbage.

    • @ValerieEnriquez
      @ValerieEnriquez 4 месяца назад +34

      Kincaid paintings look like genAI art before that was a thing. If you told me that Midjourney shat that out, I'd believe it.

    • @AnkhAnanku
      @AnkhAnanku 4 месяца назад +17

      @@ValerieEnriquez1000% what I was thinking. All soft focus vibes with too many glow effects and really bad perspective. Exactly like something that AI shits out.

    • @WlatPziupp
      @WlatPziupp 4 месяца назад +18

      It's like a beauty filter turned one notch too high.
      Like a song with just a bit too much autotune.
      A bunch of making single parts prettier over and over again until they no longer fit together

    • @ValerieEnriquez
      @ValerieEnriquez 4 месяца назад +16

      @@AnkhAnanku I commented before hearing the part about how AI was probably fed a lot of Kincaid and that's why your aunt's/bot posts on Facebook look Like That and it just makes so much sense. Everyone's aunt post their Kincaids online, genAI scrapes and "learns" from it and eventually the AI gets trained on the stuff the prior AI made and now we're in the gray goo version of the internet. It's happening with large language models now.

  • @Para2normal
    @Para2normal 4 месяца назад +97

    My late Dad, a fairly talented amateur painter, would have described Kincaids work as "Chocolate Box Lid", it wasn't meant as a complement

    • @sottosopravoce
      @sottosopravoce 4 месяца назад

      A talented painter of words, too.

    • @cutecupcakebunnies
      @cutecupcakebunnies 3 месяца назад +4

      My sewing kit is an old cookie tin with a Kincaid print on the lid.

    • @WarriorKalia
      @WarriorKalia 3 месяца назад +4

      Vapid, tactless, and a poor attempt at evoking nostalgia?
      At least the chocolate box lid smells good.

    • @dreamsofturtles1828
      @dreamsofturtles1828 3 месяца назад +2

      Yup, that kind of says it.

    • @thedarkmasterthedarkmaster
      @thedarkmasterthedarkmaster Месяц назад

      To counter that do you think choclate box lids shouldn't have art

  • @ScaryClownProduction
    @ScaryClownProduction 4 месяца назад +207

    I grew up in the same town as Thomas Kinkade. He was widely considered to be a drunken asshole, who turned his back on the town, his brother (who is also considered to be one of the Town drunks), his gallery was considered to be an eyesore, and it was generally accepted that the only reason I had money was because he did work for Disney because he was too much of an asshole, that if Disney hadn't gotten him, he won't be anybody

    • @ScaryClownProduction
      @ScaryClownProduction 4 месяца назад +51

      And to put it in perspective: this town made national headlines a few years ago for protesting the fact that they couldn't call themselves Hangtown, and Kincaid was considered to be an asshole even to them

    • @Baribrotzer
      @Baribrotzer 4 месяца назад +14

      @@ScaryClownProduction Well, I can kinda see that.
      If you're going for Wild West tourism dollars, Hangtown is a MUCH cooler name than Placerville. And I suppose that the Placervillian Chamber of Commerce gets seriously annoyed by the huge traffic jam at the Rt 49/US 50 light every weekend - of people who don't stop and give them no business, but just get themselves to Lake Tahoe as fast as they can.

    • @RedBrite
      @RedBrite 4 месяца назад +2

      ​@@ScaryClownProduction I was at those protests!!!

    • @ScaryClownProduction
      @ScaryClownProduction 4 месяца назад

      @@Baribrotzer no it's because it's a right wing place and they got all upset because there are people who get upset by the idea of a noose (I'm not joking, there were quite a few quotes about snowflakes)

    • @serrenadesinge3160
      @serrenadesinge3160 4 месяца назад +6

      Can confirm this is all true: I'm from the same town. Remember him selling his stuff in front of Raley's when I was a teenager

  • @btk2034
    @btk2034 4 месяца назад +280

    I did not expect Randy to look like a Viking but here we are.

    • @tamarabrugara
      @tamarabrugara 4 месяца назад +43

      He looks like marx and Engels had a baby

    • @drunkenfarmerjohn42
      @drunkenfarmerjohn42 4 месяца назад +25

      Yer a wizard, Randy!

    • @mortomes7063
      @mortomes7063 4 месяца назад +8

      He's Trevor Phillips from GTA5

    • @LightHalcyon
      @LightHalcyon 4 месяца назад +7

      I’ve always pictured him as his character in his comics circa 2005

    • @willhennessy864
      @willhennessy864 4 месяца назад +8

      A viking in a DuckTales shirt, no less.

  • @HyenaDandy
    @HyenaDandy 4 месяца назад +95

    I see why Kincaid and Rockwell get compared. But honestly, when I look at even the more happy Rockwell paintings, I feel drawn in. It feels like he wants me to be part of the world he creates. While with Kinkade, it feels like he wants me to see it, to enjoy it, but that I'm not invited into it.
    I really admire an artist who is willing to say "I just want people to be happy." I write erotica and my Twitter bio is literally "I write things that make people feel good." I'm proud of that.
    But I think that a key difference is that Rockwell believes that making people feel good is just as valid of a goal for an artist as anything else, while Kinkeid seems to think that's the only purpose of art. And the result is him being worse at making people feel good, because he isn't really thinking about what to avoid, and what makes people not feel good. The lights in the houses are there because glowing is happy. It doesn't really account for the fact that sometimes glowing is off-putting. Or that two different things can make me smile, but for different reasons. He just puts things in a pile of "Happy" and "Not Happy" and jams as much happy as he can in.
    When Rockwell wants you to smile, he approaches it with a question of "How do I bring out this feeling in the viewer?"
    When Kinkayd does it, he comes at it with an approach of "What can I put in here that people will like?"

    • @bluester7177
      @bluester7177 4 месяца назад +19

      Because Rockwell is actually technically competent, there is thought put into it, he knew how to compose an image to tell a story, he is very good at visual storytelling.
      Kinkaid is more shallow, he is just painting something that looks superficially pleasant.

    • @stannieholt8766
      @stannieholt8766 4 месяца назад +24

      Rockwell was also interested in using his art for social criticism, such as “The Problem We All Live With.” It shows a small Black girl (inspired by Ruby Bridges) being protected by federal marshals against segregationist protesters as she walks to kindergarten.
      The scene is as carefully and symmetrically composed as any Renaissance Nativity, and the little girl’s appearance is detailed as warmly as any of his Saturday Evening Post covers… but the wall behind her shows racist slogans and smears from thrown tomatoes, reflecting actual reactions.
      So Rockwell was not only the greater craftsman, but the far greater artist in terms of making a statement with his work.

    • @amaravazquez8591
      @amaravazquez8591 4 месяца назад +14

      Rockwell's art has humanity, both in a literal and figurative sense. Worts and all. Kincaid's is completely devoid all of that.

    • @HyenaDandy
      @HyenaDandy 4 месяца назад +5

      @@stannieholt8766 oh absolutely. I was specifically making the comparison purely within the context of the works that aren't trying to say something, because my point was about the fact that respecting the power of art enables you to accomplish the goal of making something light and happy.

    • @shadesofgray5476
      @shadesofgray5476 4 месяца назад +8

      If you see Rockwell's work in person, there's just no comparison. The colors, the strokes, the craftsmanship...

  • @amandastraw6965
    @amandastraw6965 4 месяца назад +72

    I am delighted that I get to tell this story.
    I used to go to a small fan-run Supernatural con for fanfic writers. The first year I went, they played a Thomas Kinkade’s Christmas Cottage drinking game. The rules were simple: the person who resisted drinking the longest-i.e., the last person to take their first drink-won.
    I did not win.

    • @amandastraw6965
      @amandastraw6965 4 месяца назад +19

      Also, are you guys aware that Supernatural fanfic writers invented the Omegaverse?

    • @BiBye
      @BiBye 4 месяца назад +4

      ​@amandastraw6965 i unfortunately am but i have no clue if these fine folks are

    • @poutinedream5066
      @poutinedream5066 3 месяца назад

      ​@@amandastraw6965 🤷🏽‍♀️ Me- what's the omegaverse?

    • @AliceBowie
      @AliceBowie 2 месяца назад

      ​@@poutinedream5066Romance novels that have the word 'knot' on every page.

    • @themostbigsisterenergyyouv752
      @themostbigsisterenergyyouv752 Месяц назад +1

      I feel like Robert knows too much about SPN fandom I’m so curious as to why

  • @MikeFlu73
    @MikeFlu73 4 месяца назад +76

    The best thing about video podcasts? The guests' cats!

    • @brucywarren
      @brucywarren 4 месяца назад +5

      And Robert's bathrobe

    • @MikeFlu73
      @MikeFlu73 4 месяца назад +5

      @@brucywarren That’s a kimono.

  • @zorantaylor3190
    @zorantaylor3190 4 месяца назад +83

    There's an appearance of "Grunkle" Stan Pines from Gravity Falls on a podcast the name of which I forget (It's Alex Hirsch just improvising in character) where he praises his favorite artist, who he refers to as "Thomas Kinkelly, Painter of Clowns". It's such a deep cut, but I think a lot about how much that single offhand joke really punches way above its weight for a non-canon quote from an animated Disney TV character. It's shockingly layered for what it is. Here's a stupendously corrupt, periodically actually criminal old man who runs a tourist trap filled with forged cryptid ephemera and merchandise casually conflating all this 20th Century American mega-kitsch in a way that somehow feels both very wrong and very believable at the same time. I remember actually googling "Thomas Kinkade clowns" as I was listening, because I knew he had the name wrong, but I also had this instinctive knowledge that came from somewhere I couldn't identify that what he was referring to appealed to the same AUDIENCE as Kinkade's paintings. And "Kinkelly" is such a perfect slice of "Old American guy who was always a POS but has now even started to get worse at just being a bullshit artist as senility slowly sets in" pie. Alex's delivery and how he elaborates on the subject just makes it even better, too - The way he uses that gruff, bourbon-soaked hector to wax nostalgic about how "Thomas Kinkelly" painted "Only the SADDEST of clowns!" perfectly captures that feeling of listening to someone whose very existence seems to erase that fine line between pure bullshit and the most guileless kind of sincerity, who fundamentally doesn't know the difference, in artistic terms, between being uncompromising and just being really, REALLY aggressively performative. That guy on tiktok with a "passion for acting" who only does out-of-context (save for the captions) scenes of people who are being broken up with or who just watched their own child die or something horrific screaming and crying and kicking things and falling on the ground comes to mind, and arguably that's the other side of the Kinkade coin, just using agony as a cheap signifier of artistic value instead of tranquilized nostalgia. As the types of AI images discussed in this podcast demonstrate, the two often go hand in hand. It's all about that performatively protective and concerned but actually completely emotionally and intellectually stunted type of middle-aged middle-American person that watches TLC, the Hallmark channel and nothing else whenever they're not on Facebook sharing MAGA memes and images of AI Jesuses that glow like halogen lamps kissing starving African babies until they're healthy again and can suddenly fly or whatever. It bears repeating: MILLIONS of people unironically consume this shit ALL DAY now.

    • @ShinyAvalon
      @ShinyAvalon 4 месяца назад +16

      This is...quite possibly the most entertaining short essay on pop culture I've read in years. Bravo.

    • @zorantaylor3190
      @zorantaylor3190 4 месяца назад +9

      @@ShinyAvalon Thanks, now I'm too pleased with myself to sleep....

    • @zorantaylor3190
      @zorantaylor3190 4 месяца назад +9

      Update: I was out for like maybe an hour, but that was it. You made my night. Thank you again.

    • @RedKincaid
      @RedKincaid 4 месяца назад +5

      If you recall the podcast ylease let me know, I'm both a big fan of Gravity Falls and a big hater of Thomas Kincaid (Not just for having the same name lol)

    • @Silburific
      @Silburific 4 месяца назад +9

      Holy crap, this was a fascinating read. I only wish it had even a single line break to make it easier on the eyes, but damn if I wouldn't listen to more rants like this in video essay form.

  • @RedKincaid
    @RedKincaid 4 месяца назад +48

    As someone who grew up around these, I apreciate the internet retroactively justifying my seemingly irrational hatred of these paintings.

    • @cactusshadow9840
      @cactusshadow9840 4 месяца назад +1

      stethoscope...stethophone...intellectual decay. global solidarity time, a new method of time notation that places both hemispheres of globe side by side counter rotating divided into twelve color coded sections subdivided into sixty minutes eliminating the need for both international dateline and daylight savings time. preventing multitudinous clerical errors, as petty government clerks attempt to understand why for several hours every day it is three different days at the same time

    • @RedKincaid
      @RedKincaid 4 месяца назад

      @@cactusshadow9840 Gene Ray taking on daylight savings time?

    • @MiyukiFan
      @MiyukiFan 4 месяца назад +2

      Ironic choice of username

    • @RedKincaid
      @RedKincaid 4 месяца назад +2

      @@MiyukiFan I'm fully aware lol, I've thought it was a funny coincidence for a long time

    • @alisonmercer5946
      @alisonmercer5946 3 месяца назад

      I hated them too

  • @michaeldougherty6036
    @michaeldougherty6036 4 месяца назад +36

    The funny thing about Kinkade's "highlighting" method of mass production, is that it's actually the inverse of how many old masters did it. Many Renaissance painters has an entire studii of "understudies" who would paint almost the entire portrait, often before a client had even been found. And the master would just come in and do the face, once the client showed up.
    Artists have been figuring out ways to mass produce their stuff for ages. It's really only with the advent of lithography, photography and other industrial-scale reproduction methods, that fine-artists (and more specifically, their rich ass collectors) hit upon the notion that exclusivity is the key to art's worth. Much as I despise Warhol, I appreciate that he helped burst that notion.

  • @shmehfleh3115
    @shmehfleh3115 4 месяца назад +82

    Good lord, Kinkade invented AI art and NFTs! He really is history's greatest monster!

    • @roboticzamat
      @roboticzamat 4 месяца назад +2

      Thank you! The moment I sae AI art, I instantly knew it was as Kinkaide as Ive ever seen! 😂😂😂😂

    • @Caelinus
      @Caelinus День назад

      The "Paint a tiny extra tree on the print and now it is an investment " thing is just 100% NFTs. Say what you will about him, this asshole was a pioneer to grifters.

  • @jamesdeananderson
    @jamesdeananderson 4 месяца назад +160

    Thomas Kincaid is Lisa Frank for grandmas

    • @lytlechamberlain761
      @lytlechamberlain761 4 месяца назад +24

      Or doomsday cultists. Can't forget about them.

    • @frumiousbandersnatch
      @frumiousbandersnatch 4 месяца назад +45

      I regret to inform you that, thanks to the inexorable and stupid march of time, that Lisa Frank is Lisa Frank for grandmas.

    • @cc1k435
      @cc1k435 4 месяца назад +3

      ​@@frumiousbandersnatch😂

    • @natewilson111
      @natewilson111 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@frumiousbandersnatch #elderlygenx

    • @peyote2thumbs
      @peyote2thumbs Месяц назад +1

      My god that is the best description ever!!! 😅

  • @juliakrystosek8003
    @juliakrystosek8003 4 месяца назад +26

    I've already listened to the audio version on Spotify, but here I am--I came to see the pictures of the paintings, I stayed to follow the every movement of Randy's cat.

  • @omegafilming
    @omegafilming 4 месяца назад +90

    I've probably listened to all the episodes that Randy had been on, and finally matching the face to the voice is *jarring.*

    • @lytlechamberlain761
      @lytlechamberlain761 4 месяца назад +7

      At this point it's been like 20 years since I started reading Something Positive, but I never understood why he drew himself like that until just now.

    • @Puddlef1sh
      @Puddlef1sh 4 месяца назад +5

      Same, I'm blown away. Popeye is in good hands.

  • @Summalogicae
    @Summalogicae 4 месяца назад +108

    Here I am being up my own bum:
    Kinkade, The Painter of Light, because no one has heard of Rembrandt before.

    • @henryglennon3864
      @henryglennon3864 4 месяца назад +20

      It's the equivalent of a musician claiming to be the "composer of sound".

    • @snowmonster42
      @snowmonster42 4 месяца назад +10

      My thoughts were more along the lines of Monet, but yes! That trademarked moniker that he gave himself has always chapped my ass. My kids have derived quite a bit of amusement from people who have asked me to admire their Kincaide prints.

    • @marocat4749
      @marocat4749 4 месяца назад +2

      rem-brand-t even has burn and fire related in the name :P

    • @AnthonyFlack
      @AnthonyFlack 4 месяца назад +9

      @@henryglennon3864 - it's the equivalent of Joe Rogan calling himself the thinking person's intellectual.

    • @bluester7177
      @bluester7177 4 месяца назад +2

      Even among his contemporaries he would not fit the moniker, but dude was good at marketing.

  • @cassie6422
    @cassie6422 4 месяца назад +75

    As someone who used to work for a Thomas Kinkade adjacent gallery….i have a unique hatred for his work. Mainly because of the clientele it would attract. I’ve got stories. It’s truly amazing what sort of absolute homophobic, racist, sexist bullshit old white people feel comfortable sharing with a complete stranger as they stare at the absurdly religious work. Meanwhile I just stood there listening like…..ok so you wanna buy it or…..????? lol i was there far too long and I’m happy to say I am a full time freelance artist now and my mental health has never been better

  • @jcalexandrewrites
    @jcalexandrewrites 4 месяца назад +26

    I’m going to be honest: I’m fascinated by Thomas Kinkade discourse. Because, for the life of me, I don’t know why people hate his paintings so much. They are the most inoffensive art pieces ever created, and yet people react with absolute revulsion to them. And I can’t wrap my head around the reason why. I can understand being offended by art meant to be offensive, but to be offended by something that’s otherwise mid and inoffensive…again, that fascinates me. Why are people so offended over things that are not offensive?

    • @Summalogicae
      @Summalogicae 4 месяца назад +27

      Because art never occurs in a vacuum; it is the cultural aspect of it that fuels its offensiveness.
      That someone sells kitsch is cringy but it’s offensive when it explodes and is treated as if it’s qualitative equal to, say, Andrew Wyeth. It doesn’t help that it became associated with an odious group of religious people-Evangelicals-which is offensive to many.

    • @missblackwood
      @missblackwood 4 месяца назад +1

      ⁠@@SummalogicaeImagine saying that about Muslims or Jews. Are they odious and offensive too? Bigotry is ugly no matter who you direct it at.

    • @referencetosomething4187
      @referencetosomething4187 4 месяца назад +16

      I think it has to do with the hypocrisy of it all. The paintings try SO hard to seem inoffensive, while also representing politically charged ideas that have brought so much suffering into the world. Every piece screams the ~American Dream~ but to anyone who knows their history, there's this inescapable feeling that in each picturesque cabin, a fire is burning and buried underneath it is a field of indigenous bones. They look so peaceful and yet the taste of blood fills your mouth if you look at one too long

    • @boy_girl_cat_party1824
      @boy_girl_cat_party1824 3 месяца назад +2

      Baby did you watch this whole thing on mute?

  • @yvonnepeltier9815
    @yvonnepeltier9815 4 месяца назад +19

    I always heard the title, "Painter of Light", and thought how Lucifer means "Bearer of Light". So Thomas Kinkaide was comparing himself to Lucifer

  • @NoadiArt
    @NoadiArt 4 месяца назад +120

    What I find hilarious, is that Kincaide styled himself as the "painter of light" but it's James Gurney who is considered by artists to be incredible at painting light. He even has an incredibly well regarded book for artists called Color and Light.

    • @cavebearstudio6517
      @cavebearstudio6517 4 месяца назад +6

      I always think of artists like Dan Flavin, James Turrell and others as being “painters of light” personally. I mean they’re painting with light. All actual painters are just painting with sticky mud.

    • @AnthonyFlack
      @AnthonyFlack 4 месяца назад +13

      I mean, Monet... let's not even compare, it's insulting.

    • @bluester7177
      @bluester7177 4 месяца назад +10

      Kinkaids real talent seem to be knowing how to market himself.

    • @PanEtRosa
      @PanEtRosa 4 месяца назад +8

      Albert Bierstadt is the painter I most associate with light. I think he's literally the painter Kinkade wants to be, and can't reach because Kinkade is unwilling to try different things and is therefore incapable of making a creative decision.

    • @KINGBublepop
      @KINGBublepop 4 месяца назад +13

      I can think of many artists with excellent use of light. I wouldn't say James Gurney is "the one" I think he just made the best books on colour and light out there. (Also he's a super friendly dude! He painted me as a detail in one of his paintings heheh).
      I've only ever heard Kincade being brought up in the context of marketing.

  • @theoldbear4213
    @theoldbear4213 4 месяца назад +35

    One time someone donated a ton of "collectable" plates to my job. In the boxes, I found a letter from some New York auction company or something, to who I presume was the mother or grandmother of the folks who donated the stuff. The letter was explaining to the woman that the plates were an investment, and she would be able to both retire and put her grandkids through college off the sale of them after only a few decades of waiting.... Considering her grandkids gave the things away, I think that was a scam...

    • @PanEtRosa
      @PanEtRosa 4 месяца назад +8

      I remember things like that having tear-out cards in Oriental Express, and you mailed them in with a check to order. christ, I knew when I was *8* those promos were full of shit. it's baffling that anyone ever believed this mass-produced junk with invisible "artists" would increase in value.

    • @MistaZULE
      @MistaZULE 4 месяца назад +6

      This is actually upsetting me. What truly despicable practices

  • @tithund
    @tithund 4 месяца назад +32

    I love that you have that Logitech submarine controller in your layout.

  • @superpheemy
    @superpheemy 4 месяца назад +36

    When Ralph Bakshi gets mentioned I'm all in on this episode. Hopping into the backseat with a loaded pistol, sunglasses and a lit cigarello. "Let's roll!"

    • @superpheemy
      @superpheemy 4 месяца назад

      Of Bakshi, Dan Olsen (of Folding Ideas) said "Let me tell you the story of a coked-out pervert from New Jersey and his dream to make a movie."

    • @yesthisisshi
      @yesthisisshi 4 месяца назад

      yeah, that was a fun surprise

  • @muninns760
    @muninns760 4 месяца назад +47

    "I was doing a Supernatural fandom joke." I feel seen, Robert. Thank you.

  • @blazingliger2246
    @blazingliger2246 4 месяца назад +31

    I've hated Kincade ever since my high school art class. I'm feeling really justified in despising him now.

  • @bizzaremannequin
    @bizzaremannequin 4 месяца назад +24

    I am so excited for this one. I was raised by my very religious grandparents and my grandma was a HUGE Kinkade stan. She had so many of his prints and for one of our family vacations we visited Carmel just to look at the architecture.

    • @ostrich67
      @ostrich67 4 месяца назад

      What happened to it all?

    • @bizzaremannequin
      @bizzaremannequin 4 месяца назад +1

      @@ostrich67 She probably still has everything, sadly I had to go low contact with them.

  • @whoopsydaisy6389
    @whoopsydaisy6389 4 месяца назад +21

    I told a woman working in a gallery in Monterey who was excitedly telling me about his work having hidden crosses, that I found his art creepy and disturbing. I said it felt like it sucked the light from a room.
    She got so upset with me that I thought she was going to start crying.
    I've never met a T.K. fan who wasn't a bit rabid about it.

    • @TheoRae8289
      @TheoRae8289 4 месяца назад +1

      At one point is was hidden N's for Nanette

  • @Reid-mv4ll
    @Reid-mv4ll 4 месяца назад +44

    I've enjoyed hearing from Randy's perspective on the pod ever since the Scott Adams episodes. Great guest on a great podcast.

  • @SaintJoi
    @SaintJoi 4 месяца назад +36

    I hate, HATE the title "painter of light." His sense of light was crap. The light in his paintings makes no sense.

    • @TheoRae8289
      @TheoRae8289 4 месяца назад +3

      You were supposed to be able to shine whatever light on them and "affect the time of day depicted" according to whoever worked in that galleria I encountered in 2001.

    • @sidilicious11
      @sidilicious11 3 месяца назад

      When I got into doing jigsaw puzzles I put together a few of Kincade’s Disney painting puzzles. I never took him seriously before but after staring at a few of his paintings in detail, as one does when doing puzzles, I grew to admire his technique. I am a professional artist and craftsperson myself.

  • @manateesandmermaids
    @manateesandmermaids 4 месяца назад +22

    I first learned about Thomas Kinkade in a Southern Baptist Sunday School class. Our lessons were...loosely inspired by a devotional-type book chock full of Thomas Kinkade paintings. I say loosely inspired because no matter where we started, the lesson always ended with "and that's why communism is evil and Jesus is a Republican."
    I took a long-suffering boyfriend with me to one class. Afterwards, all I remember him saying was, "Thomas Kinkade is a very weird choice for a bible study book. He was not a nice man." (He graciously did not mention the 600 additional weird choices made during the class, which I think was very polite of him.)

  • @mathildepateau1741
    @mathildepateau1741 4 месяца назад +43

    There is one artist who has modeled himself after Kinkade rather successfully, and that is Wyland. I worked at one of his galleries and hated every second of lying to people about the “collectible value” of a shitty print reproduced by the thousands. He is also equally a terrible human being masquerading as an environmentalist and I have a theory about him using a ghost painter who has since died. I am convinced that I am right and tell everyone who will listen. The only genuine thing about Wyland is that he is a hack.

    • @jernfuglen
      @jernfuglen 4 месяца назад +3

      I had to look him up. His art seems like something made for postcards or jigsaw puzzles

    • @georginatoland
      @georginatoland 4 месяца назад +1

      WYLAND!!!! **primal scream** He had a gallery next door to the bookshop I worked at during the early 90s. He was a stuckup asshole and his art was garbage. I don’t know how he persuaded the City of Long Beach to deface our Civics Center downtown, but he did. Inaccurate mural of sea creatures. If kids in Long Beach have a faulty understanding of oceanography, Wyland is to blame.

    • @claudiameier666
      @claudiameier666 4 месяца назад

      yes its pretty good but nothing spectacular.

    • @claudiameier666
      @claudiameier666 4 месяца назад +1

      the perspective in the first picture seems off. the cottage seems too close and the red truck seems to tiny

    • @Usapropaganda-t7h
      @Usapropaganda-t7h 4 месяца назад

      Looked it up …looks like children’s stickers. It’s actually terrible.

  • @ocularpatdown
    @ocularpatdown 4 месяца назад +24

    If only the failed Austrian painter had gone down this path. It still a dark road, but nowhere near as dark as what happened in our timeline.

  • @superpops97
    @superpops97 4 месяца назад +10

    I have them listen to BTB for years and this is my first time seeing any of these people. This must have been what it felt like to see a radio host on TV for the first time. Wild

  • @cmfort2696
    @cmfort2696 4 месяца назад +27

    It's funny this popped up in my feed, recently I was thinking about getting old paintings like this and then painting strange somewhat apocalyptic scenes on them.

    • @zorantaylor3190
      @zorantaylor3190 4 месяца назад +1

      He reminds me of Big/Little Joel.

    • @GillfigGarstang
      @GillfigGarstang 4 месяца назад +2

      They already kind of feel eerie and purgatorial; what with the serine depopulated snowy landscapes dotted with twee cottages who’s windows reveal interiors being consumed by eternal raging infernos.

  • @jamiefrontiera1671
    @jamiefrontiera1671 4 месяца назад +22

    As an artist whose medium is wood carving, I get hit up with wood carving ai. And there is this kinkade shine to the ai that just isn't the same with wood (yes even with a glossy coat of lacquer it just not the same) and the wood grains just don't match up. It's never ending and I hate it. And someone was fooled and shared an ai photo to a wood carving group wood carving illustrated magazine
    Although on another wood carving group, a chip carver took one of those ai photos and decided to see how she would actually chip carve the image. Hers is more real and just beautiful. It highlights why these ai artists bots destroy the attention of what real artists should get

  • @BrooksMoses
    @BrooksMoses 4 месяца назад +6

    I think one interesting thing about Kinkade's art comes up in the juxtaposition of his goal "to make people feel good" while, as you mention about 44:30, the only emotion that he tries to put in to do that is "comfort". I'm looking around my dining room as I'm watching this, and on my walls I have three photographs and a pencil drawing that IMO are reasonably good art, and all of them are there mostly just make me feel good. But they have a range of emotions behind that feeling, and only a little of that is comfort.
    It kind of comes off like Kincade is ... well, to allude to a Princess Bride quote, it comes off like he's selling something, and not just in the literal sense of selling the art. By forcefully denying that life contains other things besides absence-of-pain, his art is selling something that can be a lot the "be quiet and don't worry and everything is okay" sort of emotional direction that tempting fairy-tale villains use to seduce the heroes into their traps. I expect this is why it goes so well with the Chthuloid horrors and the Star Wars militaria.

  • @Plexerexis
    @Plexerexis 4 месяца назад +37

    Why does Sophie keep defending Jamie Loftus, the Grand Rapids hammer assassin? What is she hiding from us? And why isn't Anderson on camera?

    • @lytlechamberlain761
      @lytlechamberlain761 4 месяца назад +11

      *Alleged* hammer assassin. The case never went to trial because of, y'know... what happened to all of those Assistant District Attorneys.

  • @Daedalussi
    @Daedalussi 4 месяца назад +145

    damn randy is transition goals

    • @Thelma7361
      @Thelma7361 4 месяца назад +9

      I LOVE this comment xx

    • @ferlessleedr
      @ferlessleedr 4 месяца назад +29

      If you wanna transition into a cabin in the most remote parts of Montana, I suppose.

    • @liesalllies
      @liesalllies 4 месяца назад +5

      BIG AGREE lolol

    • @Daedalussi
      @Daedalussi 4 месяца назад +20

      @@ferlessleedr precisely

    • @Patrick-it8nk
      @Patrick-it8nk 4 месяца назад +4

      Hell yeah getcha goals live your best life

  • @phostetlerart
    @phostetlerart 4 месяца назад +7

    I love the discussion about "pleasant" art. It's not really a surprise that Kinkade ended up essentially running an assembly line factory, because that "pleasant" is really just the absence of any sort of feeling, like joy or sadness. Kinkade's paintings are like a dull morphine haze. At some point, an actual human artist might insert a point of view or an emotion into the painting, but that might be controversial or confusing, and therefore harder to sell.

  • @Summalogicae
    @Summalogicae 4 месяца назад +82

    Cant enter an Evangelical’s home without spotting at least one Kinkade print, if not in the dining room, then a small one in bathroom

    • @UntoTheBreach24
      @UntoTheBreach24 4 месяца назад +15

      Of course. As servants of the Gnostic Archon, Evangelicals are naturally drawn to these vortices of evil energy

    • @jawsbert
      @jawsbert 4 месяца назад +7

      In my family it was jigsaw puzzles of his paintings that had been framed after they were completed

    • @Summalogicae
      @Summalogicae 4 месяца назад +6

      @@jawsbert
      Wow, that’s even more cringe 😬

    • @meemurthelemur4811
      @meemurthelemur4811 4 месяца назад

      ​@@jawsbert Or paint by numbers.

    • @dawnreneegmail
      @dawnreneegmail 4 месяца назад

      Bathroom, perfect placement

  • @sophia-helenemeesdetricht1957
    @sophia-helenemeesdetricht1957 4 месяца назад +14

    I've always described Thomas Kinkaide's art as "if a lich or some ither soulless creature hit their mid unlife crisis and became an art forger who specializes in knocking off Manet and Rockwell and oftwn gets them mixed up in his cephalion.

  • @Radignostic
    @Radignostic 4 месяца назад +18

    kinkade is to luminism what rowling is to fantasy

  • @Hughes81
    @Hughes81 4 месяца назад +32

    I worked illegally at age 13 at a Kinade store in my local mall for Christmas. Got paid in cash every dsy I worked. Thry tried to short me, but my mom and I threatened to expose them using under age labour.

  • @Erisblackstone
    @Erisblackstone 4 месяца назад +110

    Randy's got the "THE END IS NIGH" look on

    • @jeremyr722
      @jeremyr722 4 месяца назад +5

      Lol 😂

    • @lytlechamberlain761
      @lytlechamberlain761 4 месяца назад +6

      You can get some really good rewards from Randy's side quests, too, but you can only start the quest chain if he's coming up on a deadline.

  • @SaintLoser314
    @SaintLoser314 4 месяца назад +13

    Welp, today I learned I grew up with a Kincade painting in my childhood home in the living room. I can’t unlearn that, thanks Robert

  • @JM-gd3hr
    @JM-gd3hr 4 месяца назад +10

    Real talk the sailing thing is the same as my dad. He bought a sailboat and wanted to sail across lake eerie and down the mississippi for 6 months. He had to be rescued on day 2.

  • @manuel-manufs-sambs
    @manuel-manufs-sambs 4 месяца назад +10

    I have been reading Randy's webcomic for *ages* and I never looked him up. He looks exactly how I mentally pictured him, though. And I cannot overstate how much I love it.

  • @idontwantahandlethough
    @idontwantahandlethough 4 месяца назад +26

    the more I watch this podcast, the more I realize that Sophie's job is literally just Robert Wrangler. She wrangles Roberts, and she's damn good at it too!

  • @sgraham4533
    @sgraham4533 4 месяца назад +7

    I met one of TK’s artists at a neighbor’s party and she said he was the worst boss ever. So when I saw this video pop up, I decided to tune in to see why she made that claim because she was too scared to say anything or give details since she still worked for him

  • @RecRoomPlays
    @RecRoomPlays 4 месяца назад +13

    this has very little to do directly with the content of the episode, but "Thomas Kinkade" sounds like the sort of name I'd expect a villain in Bioshock to have

  • @mycroft_moriarty
    @mycroft_moriarty 4 месяца назад +13

    Really appreciate Robert's occasional (along with certain guests) nods to roleplaying games, even if many of them are (justifiably) disdainful. I feel represented.

  • @edwardarkwright7116
    @edwardarkwright7116 4 месяца назад +43

    Thomas Kinkade looks closer to 2024 Steven Seagal than 2007 Jared Padalecki

    • @theautisticguitarist7560
      @theautisticguitarist7560 4 месяца назад +7

      Dude a Thomas Kincade biopic starring Steven Segal would be amazing. Especially if he wrote and directed it.

    • @edwardarkwright7116
      @edwardarkwright7116 4 месяца назад +4

      @@theautisticguitarist7560 hilarious. A con artist writing and starring as a con artist

  • @filthymcnasty7960
    @filthymcnasty7960 5 дней назад +2

    I know it's not the first time in history that America has talked about annexing Greenland, but the fact that the "Greenland has had it way too good for too long" gag was somehow prescient has me reeling

  • @racheldolfi6533
    @racheldolfi6533 4 месяца назад +9

    I’m loving the video pods! It’s so crazy to see the people in my ears on screen. Fabulous, y’all.

  • @Aogami20
    @Aogami20 4 месяца назад +14

    The discussion about what makes good art is always very interesting. For me, good art should evoke a reaction in the viewer. Whether you want to make people happy, or angry or horny or depressed, it all serves a purpose. Art is a form of communication, and that communication can be as subtle as enhancing the ambiance of a hospital waiting room or as loud and devastating as war journalist photography.

  • @DefendYoungstown
    @DefendYoungstown 4 месяца назад +9

    I remember commercials for those "Kinkade Galleries" prints. The thing that made me really remember it was the term "master highlighters". I think there was another marketeers doing this called "The Hommel Mint" and a third place using the same marketing pitches and even the same narrator was selling mail order Precious Moments figurines.

  • @capitalistraven
    @capitalistraven 4 месяца назад +8

    Suggestion: while you're discussing something visual can you keep it up on screen? Was frustrated while watching because I wanted to look at the image and instead I got to watch a talking head describing it.
    Love your podcast by the way, thanks!

  • @thesir9912
    @thesir9912 4 месяца назад +10

    Best part of this format is seeing the Lagavulin on Robert's shelf.

  • @samuellightwing5467
    @samuellightwing5467 4 месяца назад +5

    I volunteered for a long time at a charity shop in London UK, and SO many Kinkade 500 piece jigsaw puzzles passed through...

  • @daniexists6
    @daniexists6 4 месяца назад +21

    Okay, but I would genuinely wanna see you guys do John K of Ren and Stimpy, 'cause holy shit.

    • @AnthonyFlack
      @AnthonyFlack 4 месяца назад

      Sad alcoholic control freak with daddy issues grooms teenage girls, burns friendships

    • @makeart5070
      @makeart5070 4 месяца назад

      That would be a great episode. Total train wreck of a human being

  • @yensid4294
    @yensid4294 4 месяца назад +14

    Ugh, my Aunt had a Kincaide. It was a Xmas gift from her daughter & it had actual lights O_o
    A couple of my college art teachers in the 90s had gone to school with Kincaide. They didn't really think much of his art but they admired his success. If you wanted a job at Disney/Pixar/Hallmark/WB etc you went to Academy of Art SF or to Art Center Pasadena. I didn't know Kincaide was from Placerville until I watched that Jared Padalecki Hallmark movie lol.

  • @waywardscythe3358
    @waywardscythe3358 4 месяца назад +27

    As an amateur artist who's also a mechanical engineer with an interest in rocketry, i can only hope to strive to be a good future subject for BtB.

    • @MajorHickE
      @MajorHickE 4 месяца назад +5

      So deny you entry to art school and then vote you into office

    • @SaintLoser314
      @SaintLoser314 4 месяца назад +3

      With some hard work you can get there eventually buddy. Don’t give up!

    • @kereymckenna4611
      @kereymckenna4611 4 месяца назад +3

      Maybe a Failure to Launch crossover with BtB

    • @mgkleym
      @mgkleym 4 месяца назад +1

      You should strive to be a future subject of magpie's show.

  • @ParableOfSower
    @ParableOfSower 4 месяца назад +6

    Now that I have established my bonafides with my knowledge about the great Supernatural fandom (I was a Cas fan), I can confess that my mom owns 2 Kincaids. I bought them for her 😬. I knew it was scammy but she loved his work, and I love her.

  • @SilverDragonJay
    @SilverDragonJay 4 месяца назад +4

    I will admit, it took me a long time to realize that Thomas Kinkade art was actual prints that you were supposed to hang on your wall and not just jigsaw puzzles.

  • @RumTumTaver
    @RumTumTaver 4 месяца назад +11

    Proud owner of a Randy Milholland print. Medusa and a blindfolded bird. It is my retirement fund.

  • @carlamarlene2927
    @carlamarlene2927 4 месяца назад +2

    Oh MY GOD!!! I can't believe it. I LOVE listening to y'all, my twin boys turned me on to you guys. They started listening their first year of college. They've learned so much as have I. I've always wanted to thank you. Even though sometimes it can get too much dark, we always go back.
    And my husband and I LO O OVE when Sophie truly laughs. It's so infectious!
    Keep up the good work, the world needs it.
    Some of my fave episodes are part 5 of Henry Kissinger, and the whole RFK jr series!

  • @leebone1
    @leebone1 4 месяца назад +23

    “ROBERT!!!”
    -Sophie, usually

  • @HereBeDragonsYT
    @HereBeDragonsYT 4 месяца назад +4

    Art isn't supposed to make people feel good. Art is supposed to make you FEEL. Some of the best art ever made evokes emotions that aren't happiness.

  • @jamesphelps1958
    @jamesphelps1958 4 месяца назад +9

    I want Jamie loftus to have to do her own 16th minute podcast on the Grand Rapids murders. We need to make it happen!

  • @pr0t34n
    @pr0t34n 4 месяца назад +13

    41:31 if I ever have a band, the name of the first album is going to be "Enraged at an Early Age"

    • @zorantaylor3190
      @zorantaylor3190 4 месяца назад

      AN ANIMAL ENRAGED AT AN EARLY AGE
      'CAUSE HOW THE FUCK YOU S'POSED TO GROW UP WHEN YOU WEREN'T RAISED?
      SO AS I GOT OLD AND I GOT A LOT TALLER
      MY DICK GOT SMALLER BUT MY BALLS GOT LARGER
      I DRINK MORE LIQUOR TO F

  • @alexcarter8807
    @alexcarter8807 4 месяца назад +4

    There are biographies of Rockwell and they're good reading. A major difference was, Rockwell was doing his art about times he lived through. Kinkade wasn't born until 1958. Rockwell was always very humble about his art, and thought of himself as an illustrator rather than a fine artist - illustrators were a big deal through most of the 20th century and while Rockwell was one of the very top guys, there were a lot of other illustrators with big followings. Rockwell was a wholesome guy, there's no other way to describe him, without a mean bone in his body. Kinkade was a cynical hack.

  • @jiyugaokamax
    @jiyugaokamax 4 месяца назад +2

    this was such a treat to have a vod along with the pod and 3 things that stood out :
    1) Sophie looking fabulous, both her makeup and her crisp video and sound 💯💮✨
    2) Randy's all-around fun uncle energy to match his warm voice 💐
    3) Robert's lighting pulsing randomly despite being in his underground bunker 🤷

  • @robs4900
    @robs4900 4 месяца назад +3

    More Randy please ! I've been reading SP for 15-20 years and somehow he is as sweet as I would have expected the creator of Rippy the Razor to be. Lots of love to you from France, hope your move to California went well.

  • @J3nJ3nl0llip0p
    @J3nJ3nl0llip0p 4 месяца назад +8

    This podcast was shouted out on another podcast! Josh from reddit on wiki talked about this as one of the best out there. I agree! Been listening for about a year or so now❤❤❤❤. I feel like I'm kickin' it with my friends back in the jr high/hs days when I listen to you.

  • @chaueter1041
    @chaueter1041 4 месяца назад +39

    So who else out there has a relative that upon discovering they collected Kincaid paintings, proudly displayed in their home... your respect level for them, which was never high in the first place, plummeted to the bottom.

    • @SaintLoser314
      @SaintLoser314 4 месяца назад +4

      Yup, the house I grew up in. My parents were super religious

    • @BobDacat-py6so
      @BobDacat-py6so 4 месяца назад

      My mother in law. To be honest my opinion of her couldn't have been lower. Every book in her house (all 23 of them) I counted them twice. Except for one Bible the rest were all goofy woo self help books. Tony Robbins to Deepak. Even her religion is surface level and full of bigotry.

    • @hurdygurdyguy1
      @hurdygurdyguy1 4 месяца назад

      Well, for my mom it wasn't Kinkade (thank God!) but the Precious Moments figures 🤮 She had a large display case for her collection ... Precious Moments $h1t is such a scam!

    • @dieSchreckschraube
      @dieSchreckschraube 4 месяца назад +1

      They probably only counted professional painters, and a certain someone never quite made it to that stage. Hence his "other job".

    • @claudiameier666
      @claudiameier666 4 месяца назад

      ok and you are so much better.... maybe your relatives 5hought the same about you. to me lots of self help stuff is a sign of searching for direction and peace.

  • @Kutulhu
    @Kutulhu 4 месяца назад +9

    I haven't listen to the whole thing, so I don't know if this comes up, or if it is even known, but one of his daughters while in art school (in San Fran?) absolutely stole designs from online sellers on Etsy and pawned them off on her own site. She was called out and did the perfunctory mea culpas to not be expelled.

  • @WolfHreda
    @WolfHreda 4 месяца назад +17

    Kinkade believing that art can only be valid if it makes you feel good illuminates a lot about his character. He definitely wouldn't have appreciated something like the game Pathologic, which encapsulates pain and misery beautifully as you attempt to thwart a burgeoning epidemic whilst navigating the strange and esoteric governing processes of the town around you.

  • @dawnthegoblin
    @dawnthegoblin 3 месяца назад +2

    My grandfather used to work for Thomas Kincaid. Worked really hard for him, bought his cigars for him, etc. Family "invested" in so many of his paintings and then when the housing market crashed Grandpa was "let go" and couldn't get a decent job and then when he died and all the paintings became worthless they were stuck with them.
    I used to like his art due to exposure but like at some point I realized "Oh he knows how to paint like 3 things, he's boring and creepy"
    So I'm excited to get into this vid. 😊

  • @marquitaarmstrong399
    @marquitaarmstrong399 4 месяца назад +3

    I have subscribed to your channel although totally devastated by your content in this episode. Used to love Kincade houses. Pictures etc. Was 22 or so. Am 76 now. Don't know whether to thank you or thank you. Guess both. It's better to know than not know so..Thanks!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤

  • @MissMeganBeckett
    @MissMeganBeckett 4 месяца назад +2

    I sort of liked his paintings of cottages or houses in the woods near some sort of water like a river or lake that he painted like it was near sunset or sunrise when the sun comes in underneath the clouds, but I have no information on him as a person at all, so this is going to be an interesting watch, I have plenty of time because I’m watching this with my breakfast so I can probably watch the whole thing in one go. The paintings always reminded me of the times when I was little that my extended family would all get together and pool enough resources to rent a lake cottage for a week in the summer and we’d carpool up there together and have so much fun being there together away from the city smog and every day having barbecues or campfires in the evening after playing on the beach all day and swimming and canoeing and sunbathing or sitting or laying in the shade reading a book or napping or playing lawn games and going into the water again if we got too hot in the sun and playing board games and card games in the evenings after dinner with my grandparents and uncles and aunts and my siblings, it was really fun, and it was so easy to fall asleep after having such a big day outside every day and my insomnia would go away for a while for the time being and I would be able to sleep well with the clean air and the cool lake breeze and the calls of the loons in the distance, I really liked going to the cottage.

  • @kanders7391
    @kanders7391 4 месяца назад +4

    Actually Maxfield Parish back in the 1920s & 30s made most of his money from selling to middle class & working class people. He was the first fine artist painter to sell out and sell his works to corporations for calendar art. It ended up as prints on a lot of commercial media as well. To this day, depression era prints of Parish paintings can be found in antique stores. In frames that originally housed 1800s & early 1900s photos of peoples families, and some of the old photos are still in the frames behind the Parish prints. Most of these prints were cut from the original calendars. Partly they used to frame the calendar art because they were either poor in the depression or because they lived in a small town which back in even the 1930s some parts of the country had never been exposed to fine art which mainly occurred in the big cities which also had the only art museums. So when they got in the feed & farm equipment catalogue and it came with a calendar suddenly with all this art work added in on the back of each sheet flipped to the top, they were moved by it, impressed even though his earlier works maybe weren’t the greatest. The early 20s paintings were a little excessively pseudo ancient greek/arabian Mediterranean style with robed figures & figures in sort of arabian Aladdin style clothes lounging at picnics with grapes & wine or carrying urns. His art was the only paintings most of these people had ever seen. His later works were great American nature landscapes. Often painted in the national parks. He eventually developed a layered color style that mimicked the rgb or cmyk style of color photography that made his later paintings almost look three dimensional. Parish was quoted as saying that if you study the color of things closely in the natural world. Rocks, trees, river/sea, sky etc, you will find elements of several colors in each, because its based on the prismatic spectrum. What you see is reflected light. He said, “There is actually a lot of red in a tree.” Its not just brown trunk & green leaves. Parish’s decision to sell to the calendars caused a national art awakening.

  • @Ceruleansquid-lo3iv
    @Ceruleansquid-lo3iv 4 месяца назад +12

    if anyone wants some truly cursed knowledge... there might be furry supernatural art, but omegaverse also came from the fandom. It was actually RPF about the main actors. I was not expecting to share this, but I also wasn't expecting Robert to name drop supernatural

    • @neauxway
      @neauxway 4 месяца назад +4

      Maybe I'm remembering a fever dream but I swear Robert has made reference to mpreg in the past

    • @themostbigsisterenergyyouv752
      @themostbigsisterenergyyouv752 Месяц назад +1

      Robert knows too much to (k)not have an AO3 ;)

    • @madisonluna5190
      @madisonluna5190 Месяц назад

      Thank you i wanted to comment about this so i'm glad someone else already did

  • @floraposteschild4184
    @floraposteschild4184 4 месяца назад +9

    I call him the hobbit on 'shrooms painter. 8:24 Not to many electrical lampposts are located by the side of a stream. Guess that gets flooded out every spring. 9:28 The river winds slowly uphill to the sea.

  • @SesshyLover777
    @SesshyLover777 4 месяца назад +3

    Randy. You're an AMAZING specimin of man. Never change. Couldn't be more pleased with your beard, shirt, or kitties👍

  • @frankmacdonald5827
    @frankmacdonald5827 4 месяца назад +5

    24:48 as somebody who has watched both Supernatural and Gilmore Girls I agree with both Robert and Sophie here.

  • @Lulu_Catnaps
    @Lulu_Catnaps 4 месяца назад +9

    Insanely excited for this. All i know about kinkade is the book with Mr. Gurney and hes a huge inspiration of mine. He hardly talks about kinkade it seems...

    • @henryglennon3864
      @henryglennon3864 4 месяца назад +7

      Have you seen James Gurney's RUclips channel? It's great, and he seems like a wonderful person.

    • @Lulu_Catnaps
      @Lulu_Catnaps 4 месяца назад +3

      @henryglennon3864 yes! I've been following his channel and blog for a long time and they're both wonderful

  • @RusselCS
    @RusselCS 4 месяца назад +5

    been listening to this podcast for years and honestly video versions are worth it if only for the pet guest appearances