Literally just talked with Indicator lol... His bass is actually the *3rd* Subharmonic of throat bass (2 octaves below the vocalized pitch you are singing when using throat bass. Vibration bass is the 2nd Subharmonic - this is another level below that!). Incredibly hard to do consistently, but he's got it down really well 🔥 Edit: I think he's the first person I've ever heard use the 3rd Subharmonic of throat bass like this before. Big ups to him for pushing the limits of what's humanly possible 🔥😎 Know anyone else that's used the 3rd??
Whaaattttttt I’ve been racking my brain and searching all throughout RUclips comments for an explanation of the mechanics for indicator’s alien bass!! The closest I’ve gotten was Wunknown, who describes it as “harmonizing the vocal fry voice with the false vocal chords” and he did definitely draw a distinction between this bass and vibration bass. But given what you said about vibration bass, how it’s actually the second subharmonic of standard kargyraa throat bass, indicator’s alien bass is the THIRD subharmonic? What interval is harmonizing to create the third subharmonic? And how would you go about about “adjusting” the throat or vibration bass to activate the3rd subharmonic?
@@alkmibeats2133 "harmonizing the vocal fry voice with the false vocal folds" is actually pretty accurate. Honestly... I hate to say this... But techniques like this are almost unteachable without really being in person with someone that can do the technique really well. The best way I can describe "popping" down to different subharmonics is you have to imagine the subharmonic pitch, modify your embouchure appropriately, and allow the lower Subharmonic to *pop* into place. In my opinion, popping down Subharmonic levels in the original "subharmonic bass technique" that I showed using regular folds in the past is much, much easier than doing it with throat bass. This one is super hard 😅 To put Indicator's skill in perspective: Vibration bass (2nd SH) is hard for me and I've practiced it a lot. I've only ever hit the 3rd SH of throat bass a couple times by accident. Indicator has the 3rd SH of throat bass down better than most people have their 1st down. Super impressive! Super difficult!
Indicator himself actually said his bass is a unique bass he cultivated over a few years, combining a mix of vibration bass, subharmonic bass, and chest bass
ayyyyy ❤ im really happy with this review, i think is really important for us to see the technical content of what we do in every art form more deeply, i love ur videos! this made my day, thank u so much!
Just amazing what you can do with a voice. Btw you're videos are extremely motivating for me to learn singing finally. When you talk about voice it feels much more "quantitative" than it does on a lot of singing tutorials/channels. Although everyone says that the vocal cords are muscles like any other muscle your videos get that technical aspect across a lot better.
David, you have one of the best channels I've ever come across. I love your enthusiasm for your niche and you present it in such an approachable yet brainy stimulating way. Also, your sincerity, humbleness, skill, excitement, reactions, and general likability just make you an addictive watch on this topic. You are a rare find.
I enjoy the good things in life, sees "PWAD" clicks instantly. I cant wait to see your reaction! I like your videos and Colaps because you both are great at showing appreciation and discuss things well :)
i love your revision on what you think is going on with the beatboxers. very interesting to see a bass vocalist opinion on this music style. keep it up fam.
Dude I've been following your vids since the beginning (I even watched the bike restoration video) and gotta say there's something about these new vids that are just fucking must-watch. It's the production, the commentary, the music side, vocal technique side... Damn bro you've combined all your talents into some special shit here. Just gotta incorporate restoration into it somehow...
Pls PLEASE react to *Gene Shinozaki,* he’s one of the best beatboxer with insane musicality! Check out his track called *“See You There”,* there’re some best harmonies out there!
Here's a few ideas: Bigman, Gene, Tom Thum. Excellent musicality. Alem, Alexinho, Efaybee - Alem is a bit more on the technical side but all three of them will impress you.
Hi David! If you’re looking for more musical or melodic beatbox, I highly recommend you *“See You There” by Gene Shinozaki.* It’ll definitely be the most chill and beautiful beatboxing you’ve ever heard!
Hey David! Love your videos as someone who was first into singing and kinda fell into beatboxing. I think you'd really appreciate some of the bass techniques in ALEXINHO vs SO-SO | Grand Beatbox 7 TO SMOKE Battle 2019 | Battle 13. At the very beginning So-So uses what I'm pretty sure is a subharmonic/vocal fry bass and alexinho is just always great to watch. Keep up the grind man!
Hi David, I've been really enjoying your recent beatbox videos. Having someone understand and explain what's going on is so much better than the standard 'reaction' video, so thanks!! I would also like to recommend Bigman to you. He has an incredibly smooth throat bass and I think you would really enjoy it! (especially gaslighting)
aaaaa i cant believe warlet is here! i love your content and im friends with her, shes just awesome! a beautiful person and amazing beatboxer, im really happy with this =) also big shoutout to all the other female beatboxers you guys are awesome, looking foward to see more females getting into it ps 13:14 this extra buzz is a front trumpet combined with his vocal bass
Seriously, your face during the first beatbox react and this one was different. You look like you're enjoying beatbox the more you watch. Love your vid
10:32 Piggy-backing onto all the comments that say to check out BIGMAN. This is his specialty, so much that he's also been on Ellen. He's got a throat bass as clean as Codfish's. If you're looking for very clean sounding vocal transitions and techniques, I recommend checking out his song "Confused." If you're looking for a very _full_ sounding beatbox song, I recommend checking out his cover of "Beat It." Some other beatboxers with wacky vocal techniques: SHOW-GO - I see a couple of these in the comments. He's got this "Double Voice" (not to be confused with polyphonic voice), which I believe is basically super good yodeling control. (An aside: If anyone reading this wants to check this out for fun, non-beatboxer Emma Robinson does a cover of Titanium where she does a similar thing which some people call "False Auto-Tune," and it sounds ridiculous.) DJ B3AN - He's got this thing called the "Super Evil Bass," which you can hear in his first round vs Colaps. IMPROVER - I see a lot of this in the comments as well. The most recent Russian Beatbox Champ. Very good vocal bass and control over duck-sound pitch. The groove is insane.
I just discovered you because I really love beatboxing for 5 or 6 years now. You can hear Berywam (group of 4 beatboxers) or some duos (like Uni team, kotcha...) it's really really great, and I give an extra point for berywam because their song seems so real. Btw keep it going! A sub from France :)
He cant appreciate how pwad made special sounds which literally impossible to imagine how. Especially to the extra vibrations he made while doing the vocal bass which makes the crazy alien sound.
He uses a subharmonic accessed thru the throat and another accessed thru the nasal cavity that can both be used separately if you want. Or you can use them in unison to create a 3rd lower register that is alien bass. Those are indicators words himself
You want musicality?! There’s this guy: Stitch from Malaysia so search “I’ll see you tonight” and check it out in the next vid. And also love ur reactions too
13:21 that extra buzz is because he positioned his lip like a forward trumpet so it will be easier to switch between his bass (vocal/uvular bass) and the kicks
The lip buzz isn't really a term most beatboxers use, I think it's more of an a capella thing. There's lip oscillations, where the lips aren't as close to each other and sounds really good when vocalized. Then there's lip BASS (Napom's tutorial was about this one), where the lips vibrate closer and make a more percussive sound, like a strawberry. I really recommend looking into Gene Shinozaki, he has a tutorial on lip oscillations. Also look at his song "Never Give Up", he plays guitar and beatboxes at the same time! A video on that one would be sick. Awesome videos, keep it up man!
You definitely should check out Stitch | ASIA BEATBOX CHAMPIONSHIP 2019 SOLO BATTLE | I'll See You Tonight he's got a very interesting technique at the end, and the whole video is just great.
I can List some *AMAZING* Beatboxers: -Napom (Roll like this like) -Tomazacre (Terremoto, collab w/ Wawad) -Chiwawa (Time is a game) -Dilip -Pwad (It's not the Melodie) -Dharni (my name is dharni ng) -Bigman (Confused/ get Lucky) -D-Low vs. B-art -Improver (pump it up or gbb 2020) -Riddim gods (Hershe remix) I hope you like some of my suggestions! ^^
Loving the beatbox reactions please please! Do codfish vs tomazacre next they both have awesome bass two very different styles though definitely a lot to dissect in that one
Literally just talked with Indicator lol... His bass is actually the *3rd* Subharmonic of throat bass (2 octaves below the vocalized pitch you are singing when using throat bass. Vibration bass is the 2nd Subharmonic - this is another level below that!).
Incredibly hard to do consistently, but he's got it down really well 🔥
Edit: I think he's the first person I've ever heard use the 3rd Subharmonic of throat bass like this before. Big ups to him for pushing the limits of what's humanly possible 🔥😎
Know anyone else that's used the 3rd??
Whaaattttttt I’ve been racking my brain and searching all throughout RUclips comments for an explanation of the mechanics for indicator’s alien bass!! The closest I’ve gotten was Wunknown, who describes it as “harmonizing the vocal fry voice with the false vocal chords” and he did definitely draw a distinction between this bass and vibration bass. But given what you said about vibration bass, how it’s actually the second subharmonic of standard kargyraa throat bass, indicator’s alien bass is the THIRD subharmonic? What interval is harmonizing to create the third subharmonic? And how would you go about about “adjusting” the throat or vibration bass to activate the3rd subharmonic?
Woah!!!!
Check out OneDrain! He has since retired from the BBX community but I believe he is as deep as Indicator, if not deeper.
Have a good day, David! :)
@@alkmibeats2133 "harmonizing the vocal fry voice with the false vocal folds" is actually pretty accurate. Honestly... I hate to say this... But techniques like this are almost unteachable without really being in person with someone that can do the technique really well. The best way I can describe "popping" down to different subharmonics is you have to imagine the subharmonic pitch, modify your embouchure appropriately, and allow the lower Subharmonic to *pop* into place.
In my opinion, popping down Subharmonic levels in the original "subharmonic bass technique" that I showed using regular folds in the past is much, much easier than doing it with throat bass. This one is super hard 😅
To put Indicator's skill in perspective: Vibration bass (2nd SH) is hard for me and I've practiced it a lot. I've only ever hit the 3rd SH of throat bass a couple times by accident. Indicator has the 3rd SH of throat bass down better than most people have their 1st down.
Super impressive! Super difficult!
Yes, he is very good ro use this technique, but I and a lot of other people can do that type of throaght/vibration bass
How to stop beatboxer : tie their hands
thats our only weakness how did you find out
I just started imagine anything after corona virus attack my country...
@@razzaqramadhan1903 where are you from ?
not gonna lie, you had us in the first half
Not Zer0..
Indicator himself actually said his bass is a unique bass he cultivated over a few years, combining a mix of vibration bass, subharmonic bass, and chest bass
aswell its a 4 note chord
Tanis Annicchiarico it’s just a polyphonic..
@@busyval no?
@@busyval a 4 note chord is polyphonic u dip lmao
@@anisnej10 rofl
He looks like footboxg
Plot twist he's Footboxg
ah shit
FootboxG before he was bald
Now that u think about it😂
Not really
I think you haven't checked out Big Ben yet. I recommend "I'm a big boy". He can reach crazy low just with 1 simple bass.
What about "How low can you go?" That video is astonishing.
MixFx has it too. XD
Big ben just isnt what he used to he though :(
It’s called vocalized chest bass, Napom, colaps, and Wunknown use this bass as well as kindo
ayyyyy ❤ im really happy with this review, i think is really important for us to see the technical content of what we do in every art form more deeply, i love ur videos! this made my day, thank u so much!
You are soo amazing ❤️❤️
Immanuel Jijo what is he not allowed to appreciate her ? 😂😂😂
COmo um BR veio parar aq ksksksksksskks ent tá bom
Pwad is doing the starsky bass aka the vocal bass except its "cleaner"
HiBaLaHi he’s doing chest bass but pitch
Starsky bass is not the same as vocal bass. Vocal bass is a higher throat bass and Starsky bass is a uvular oscillation with a head voice
siddharth sanjay it's just the samee
siddharth sanjay starsky is the creator of the sound, and just known as vocal bass
@@elsierazon7255 🤷♂️
I recommend reacting to gene shinozaki's 'remember'. He's one of the most musical Beatboxers out there
and 'Home' my favourite routine from him
or never give up
also mb14, stitch,and a few others
Yes!! This comment.
Don't you remember mb14?
5:40 just appreciating this small edit
lol
Oh I forgot. There’s also this guy: Bigman. Checkout some of his songs pls. I think it’s your type
Can you react to:
Dharni's tutorial on throat bass
High Middle Low
Venom
Alexinho vs Soso
Inertia vs Audical top 4
and/or D-Low vs Colaps
Alexinho vs So-so and Venom are incredible!!
SoSo master of special sounds
You should say dudz too
Trung bao venom 🔥 🔥
@@hydrogenclips4803 they have same style like pwad
I like how David is already practicing saying "shoutout to Swissbeatbox"
Just amazing what you can do with a voice. Btw you're videos are extremely motivating for me to learn singing finally. When you talk about voice it feels much more "quantitative" than it does on a lot of singing tutorials/channels. Although everyone says that the vocal cords are muscles like any other muscle your videos get that technical aspect across a lot better.
I’m sure someone has recommended this already but Bigman “Gaslighting”. Some great vocals with weaved in throat bass! 💪
David, you have one of the best channels I've ever come across. I love your enthusiasm for your niche and you present it in such an approachable yet brainy stimulating way. Also, your sincerity, humbleness, skill, excitement, reactions, and general likability just make you an addictive watch on this topic. You are a rare find.
I have so been looking forward to more of this!!
I enjoy the good things in life, sees "PWAD" clicks instantly. I cant wait to see your reaction! I like your videos and Colaps because you both are great at showing appreciation and discuss things well :)
wrong title.
it should be
"HOW THESE PEOPLE EVEN EXIST"
Because they making music
@Tai Sentry yeah i've corrected it lol
thumbnail*
I love these videos; please keep making more!! I think your perspective is fresh and has given us beatboxers a lot to think about!!
i love your revision on what you think is going on with the beatboxers. very interesting to see a bass vocalist opinion on this music style. keep it up fam.
Im so happy when see your notification 😄. Next please react some Musicality beatboxer i recommend Bigman, Gene shinozaki, mb14, Dudz, D-nice
Id add Gale, and Stitch to that list
If you want to see some amazing singing beatbox, I would recommend Bigman. He is one of the best at combining singing with beatboxing
Also Indicator is pretty nuts
thanks, Will check out!!
Best review yet great artists on display. Thanks David!!!! much love keep it up
Thanks for these great videos!
React to Blackened GBB wildcard 2020. He used some crazy throat techniques.
You should react to show go 👍👍❤
So nice to see you react to Pwad, been a fan of him since the first time I heard his gbb 2020 wildcard.
Love the reactions man :) keep up my man
You should have way more subs! 🔥🔥♥️♥️♥️
13:15 he's doing a spit snare I believe
He's talking about the bass lol not the snare
@@DempseyDaPro lol didn't think of that. well the extra buzz is done by making an O shape with your mouth
Dude I've been following your vids since the beginning (I even watched the bike restoration video) and gotta say there's something about these new vids that are just fucking must-watch. It's the production, the commentary, the music side, vocal technique side... Damn bro you've combined all your talents into some special shit here.
Just gotta incorporate restoration into it somehow...
I really love this channel because he notice a beatboxers❤️ keep it up
Pls PLEASE react to *Gene Shinozaki,* he’s one of the best beatboxer with insane musicality!
Check out his track called *“See You There”,* there’re some best harmonies out there!
Here's a few ideas:
Bigman, Gene, Tom Thum. Excellent musicality.
Alem, Alexinho, Efaybee - Alem is a bit more on the technical side but all three of them will impress you.
When you started watching beatboxing, you already beatboxing and that why I'm still watching u! Love you
Bro it’s so enjoyable watching u talk bout bbx like that😂🔥
Hi David! If you’re looking for more musical or melodic beatbox, I highly recommend you *“See You There” by Gene Shinozaki.* It’ll definitely be the most chill and beautiful beatboxing you’ve ever heard!
Can you react to ‘overtone overload’? It’s absolutely insane and it is super groovy, you’ll love it.
Love these videos
Hey David! Love your videos as someone who was first into singing and kinda fell into beatboxing. I think you'd really appreciate some of the bass techniques in ALEXINHO vs SO-SO | Grand Beatbox 7 TO SMOKE Battle 2019 | Battle 13. At the very beginning So-So uses what I'm pretty sure is a subharmonic/vocal fry bass and alexinho is just always great to watch. Keep up the grind man!
I recommended : Audical - Headbangers
No vocodah
@@gbangerlove i wrote this comment before he changed his name to vocodah :)
@@fjvseverybody6787 who is audical??
Indicator : I'm a alien from the outer space
Pwad :you did a mistake, cause I'm a alien
David I love your beatbox videos you're a real prodigy to the community.
Hi David, I've been really enjoying your recent beatbox videos. Having someone understand and explain what's going on is so much better than the standard 'reaction' video, so thanks!! I would also like to recommend Bigman to you. He has an incredibly smooth throat bass and I think you would really enjoy it! (especially gaslighting)
You should react to the following:
Two-H - So what, i dont give a..
Top 10 unique beatbox sounds
D-Low - HIP-HOP FREESTYLE BEATBOX INSANITY!
Day 4 of trying to get him to watch so what i dont give a
Improver!!! Review him toooo
Love the vid man keep it up👏🙌
aaaaa i cant believe warlet is here! i love your content and im friends with her, shes just awesome! a beautiful person and amazing beatboxer, im really happy with this =)
also big shoutout to all the other female beatboxers you guys are awesome, looking foward to see more females getting into it
ps 13:14 this extra buzz is a front trumpet combined with his vocal bass
Pls watch "Bigman - Gaslighting" or any of his studio releases
My fav beatbox/singer
CHECK OUT CHIWAWA, FIND OUT HOW LOW HER VOICE RANGE CAN GO!!
2 minutes of insane beatbox by d-low is the best
do it more please! beatbox is so special, all beatboxer very creative , smart and free. People needs to know this art!
12:06-Pwad "You did a mistake"
David "Okay ;)"
This guy has to listen to: Confused - Bigman
Confused pigman
@@theseangle 🙂
I don't know why this guy cracks me up so much but i love it
Seriously, your face during the first beatbox react and this one was different. You look like you're enjoying beatbox the more you watch. Love your vid
Hey dude you should check out Improver, specifically the one that says Improver| Russian beatbox champion
It's stuck in my head.
I literally jam to it like with my normal music
Pwads bass is vocal bass or as in starsky bass he has a tutorial on his pwads channel
Keep going you are my best youtuber❤️
You should do more videos of you learning beatbox techniques ! It’s fun to watch !
10:32 Piggy-backing onto all the comments that say to check out BIGMAN. This is his specialty, so much that he's also been on Ellen. He's got a throat bass as clean as Codfish's.
If you're looking for very clean sounding vocal transitions and techniques, I recommend checking out his song "Confused."
If you're looking for a very _full_ sounding beatbox song, I recommend checking out his cover of "Beat It."
Some other beatboxers with wacky vocal techniques:
SHOW-GO - I see a couple of these in the comments. He's got this "Double Voice" (not to be confused with polyphonic voice), which I believe is basically super good yodeling control. (An aside: If anyone reading this wants to check this out for fun, non-beatboxer Emma Robinson does a cover of Titanium where she does a similar thing which some people call "False Auto-Tune," and it sounds ridiculous.)
DJ B3AN - He's got this thing called the "Super Evil Bass," which you can hear in his first round vs Colaps.
IMPROVER - I see a lot of this in the comments as well. The most recent Russian Beatbox Champ. Very good vocal bass and control over duck-sound pitch. The groove is insane.
You need to react to DUDZ his musicality is 🔥
I just discovered you because I really love beatboxing for 5 or 6 years now.
You can hear Berywam (group of 4 beatboxers) or some duos (like Uni team, kotcha...) it's really really great, and I give an extra point for berywam because their song seems so real.
Btw keep it going! A sub from France :)
Hey David, you should try doing inward lip roll sub bass combined with inward falsetto. I figured it out a few days ago and it's SO MUCH FUN to do :)
Pls react to the video "MB14 Saro Reacts"
(Its not really a reaction he's just standing there and its a swissbeatbox video)
You really should watch something from Improver (I would recommend "Pump it up")
He cant appreciate how pwad made special sounds which literally impossible to imagine how. Especially to the extra vibrations he made while doing the vocal bass which makes the crazy alien sound.
He uses a subharmonic accessed thru the throat and another accessed thru the nasal cavity that can both be used separately if you want. Or you can use them in unison to create a 3rd lower register that is alien bass.
Those are indicators words himself
I need to see this man react to Napom
10:41 'But alsO'. Accidental subharmonic or just heavy vocal fry? Either way it's hilarious xD
Accidental subharmonic, awesome
LMAO wow
keep holding this, your content is very good
Your Videos are fun to watch☺️
You want musicality?! There’s this guy: Stitch from Malaysia so search “I’ll see you tonight” and check it out in the next vid. And also love ur reactions too
Damn yo Michael aka stitch is sick
Yo look up Mr Dimple too, he’s got an amazing voice and mad bbx skill
I hâte stitch
Yes! Check out Stitch!!! I was literally about to comment his name because of his musicality. He is someone you are looking for @David!!!
React to blackened gbb 2020 wildcard :D❤
Good wildcard
Yesss!
Daaaamn, that Indicator!!!
Made me tear up!!
13:21 that extra buzz is because he positioned his lip like a forward trumpet so it will be easier to switch between his bass (vocal/uvular bass) and the kicks
Pwad's 'Alien' bass is a voclaized 'growl' in bass singing terms or in beatbox a vocalized chest bass. The vocalization is obviously in falsetto
You need to react to inertia reckless and watch the whole video it’s fully worth it!
He has, but he only watched a couple parts not the whole.
Im sure he would of watched entire clip and useed the highlights for the specific sound or technique used
The lip buzz isn't really a term most beatboxers use, I think it's more of an a capella thing. There's lip oscillations, where the lips aren't as close to each other and sounds really good when vocalized. Then there's lip BASS (Napom's tutorial was about this one), where the lips vibrate closer and make a more percussive sound, like a strawberry. I really recommend looking into Gene Shinozaki, he has a tutorial on lip oscillations. Also look at his song "Never Give Up", he plays guitar and beatboxes at the same time! A video on that one would be sick. Awesome videos, keep it up man!
💜 thank you so much
Anytime bro 🖤
Check out mixfx, he is the creator of the evil that he made in 2012 which is so famous now!
React to d-low “you wanted this” crazy bass
I second this.
ImOleDC I third this
I fourth this
I fifth this
I sixth this
Yes, about time my dude!
Omg i just learned a new beatboxing noise while watching this 😁
If you like musicality more, then go ahead and listen to Gene Shinozaki, Bigman, Dudz, and etc.
React to Show-go and Inertia
Sick big up from Scotland
Two.h has an amazing inward bss sound you should listen to.great vid btw 🔥👍keep up with these kind of videos bro you are great
Review gene shinozaki
Speaking of ducks, check out Improver's latest swissbeatbox video. Its a tad long, but lot's going on
Love the fact that you actually "Review" the Video
You should see if you could do a colab with a bass heavy beatboxer and see how much they could teach you! Love you beatboxing vids btw 👍🏻
Please react to ENEL | Feel My Bass x Bad Boy, thanks 🤟
You definitely should check out
Stitch | ASIA BEATBOX CHAMPIONSHIP 2019 SOLO BATTLE | I'll See You Tonight
he's got a very interesting technique at the end, and the whole video is just great.
IMPROVER when the video came up... I was like WTF😂
PWAD actually made a full video about his vocalized bass
U need more subscribers btw u should have reacted to chiwawa
bet
she'll be in it soon
React : "Bigben, I m a big boy" he is the best throat bass in the world! Loweeeeeer
It's chest bass, not throat bass
@@siddharth4700 nope, it's lower throat bass!
@@kalix3589 nooe its chest bass
No it's PORNHUB HAHA
I can List some *AMAZING* Beatboxers:
-Napom (Roll like this like)
-Tomazacre (Terremoto, collab w/ Wawad)
-Chiwawa (Time is a game)
-Dilip
-Pwad (It's not the Melodie)
-Dharni (my name is dharni ng)
-Bigman (Confused/ get Lucky)
-D-Low vs. B-art
-Improver (pump it up or gbb 2020)
-Riddim gods (Hershe remix)
I hope you like some of my suggestions! ^^
Loving the beatbox reactions please please! Do codfish vs tomazacre next they both have awesome bass two very different styles though definitely a lot to dissect in that one