Vietnamese, French Veterans Remember Dien Bien Phu 70 Years After Iconic Battle | TaiwanPlus News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- 70 years after the battle of Dien Bien Phu, Vietnamese and French veterans look back at a conflict that shaped the world and their lives.
📹 Reporter(s): Justin Wu/Bryn Thomas
#TaiwanPlus #TaiwanPlusNews #TaiwanNews
-
TaiwanPlus｜www.taiwanplus...
TaiwanPlus presents the country’s unique voice on not only local issues but also world events.
Connect with TaiwanPlus
» Watch shows made by TaiwanPlus / @taiwanplus
» Like us on Facebook: / taiwanplusnews
» Tweet us on Twitter: / taiwanplusnews
» Follow us on Instagram: / taiwanplus
Civil war? So who flies the B52 plane? Who drives the M24 tank. Who flies the F111 plane? Who controls the aircraft carrier? South Vietnamese soldiers were not even allowed to touch those things.
exactly
US is a long lost state of Viet Nam
Vietnam War casualties:
- 🇺🇸: 58,281
- 🇰🇷: 5,099
- 🇹🇼: 25
... And they call it a civil war! 😂😂😂
It is the height of American arrogance to use the name "Vietnam War" instead of "Americo-Vietnamese War" to be distinct from the one before against France and the one after against China.
Greatest comment ever !
US brought it to Vietnam
60% of the tactical air force
50% of strategic air forces
40% of the navy
So who called this a civil war?
With respect for historical truth, the channel must say that France and America invaded Vietnam. This is not a civil war.
Exactly
chính xác đây không phải là cuộc nội chiến
this is not a civil war, it was an invasion. The country democratic republic of Vietnam (north Vietnam) invaded the country Republic of Vietnam (South Vietnam)
Civil war? laugh out loud. America poured trillions of dollars into the Vietnam War. A total of 2.7 million American soldiers fought in Vietnam, reaching 534 thousand troops at its peak. South Korea 325 thousand soldiers, Australia 50 thousand soldiers, Thailand 32 thousand soldiers, New Zealand 3,500 soldiers, Philippines 2,000 soldiers. Vietnam only received weapons and food aid from China and the Soviet Union. Vietnam never agreed to allow Chinese and Soviet soldiers to be present in Vietnam, except for military experts, and they only had a few thousand people on duty to instruct how to use weapons. They never directly participated in combat. China offered to let Chinese soldiers participate in the war, but Vietnam refused and only received weapons and food. Money debt can be paid, but blood debt cannot be paid. Because they can't be revived! Vietnam does not want to owe blood to other countries. Vietnam will gain independence with its own hands. The government of South Vietnam is a puppet government set up by the US to serve US interests when they unilaterally abrogated the 1954 Geneva Agreement. If the US did not intervene in Vietnam. Without unilaterally tearing up the Geneva Agreement, Vietnam was unified through the 1956 General Election. The 17th parallel has never been the official border of the two regions. That boundary was temporary and would be eliminated in 1956 through national elections. Government of South Vietnam = Vichy Government of France.
Pretty sure Soviet pilots in Soviet aircraft flew in Vietnam…
@@Dutch-McLarenJk82- Only 200 North Korean pilots went to Vietnam for training and asked to participate in combat to gain experience. The Soviet Union did not have a single pilot in Vietnam, let alone Soviet pilots who fought in Vietnam. During the Korean War, there were Soviet and Chinese pilots. Not available in Vietnam.
@@Dutch-McLarenJk82- phi công liên xô chỉ làm công tác huấn luyện ở Việt Nam. K tham chiến trực tiếp, có hãy đưa ra bằng chứng, chứ không phải bằng niềm tin :))). Mỹ mà có bằng chứng Liên Xô tham chiến thì họ nêu ra lâu rồi.
No national elections occurred in 1956 in South Vietnam. You read too much communist propaganda. Vietnam today twists the reality of the war, afraid of the truth. No wonder so many Vietnamese are in its prisons because they told the truth. Vietnam government refuses to hear anything that dares criticises its policies and governance.
Check your facts and see the truth.
Ridiculous for that "civil war" narration. Let's face it, Viet Minh defeated the French, and the Americans stepped in to prevent the communist wave as they claimed, which was a bad move since Ho Chi Minh did not pull the ideology that hard and was willing to cooperate with the US in particular, and the international community in general. Just like a line of a popular war song in Vietnam that goes: "Although we love roses, the enemies forced us to pick up the guns".
Dù rằng đời ta thích hoa hồng, Kẻ thù buộc ta ôm cây súng 💪
Bài hát : Hát mãi khúc quân hành ❤
No this not Civil war !!!!!!!!!!
Tôi rất xúc động và tự hào vì là người Việt Nam
The channel must show authentic historical truth, must not distort history, Vietnam did not have a civil war, remember that clearly! When you report on information related to another country, you should report the truth and research carefully before acting.
It was not a civil war. What you said was absolutely wrong. If so, what was the US Army here for? Why did they fight in the front lines? Who piloted B52 and many other kinds of killing machines to bomb VN and kill hundred thousands of innocent Vietnamese residents? What is the meaning of more than 550 thousands of US soldiers died in that war? Was it a civil war?
The Vietnamese army is one of the very best in the world. Bravo!
Mỹ. Pháp Trung Quốc. Nhật Bản và các nước chư hầu bị VN tao đánh cho chạy té đái hết .
Fun fact: when someone sees Vietnam War as a civil war, Vietnamese usually call Americans "unintended tourists".
Vinh quang Việt Nam ! Vinh quang Chiến sỹ Điện Biên, Hồ Chí Minh, Võ Nguyên Giáp...
Civil war my ass!?
So the usa going to Vietnam just for sightseeing !?
The USA was defending South Vietnamese from the Northern Vietnamese invaders.
It was no civil war.
It was North Vietnamese attacking another sovereign country with the help of the USSR and China.
@@FloofyMinari South Vietnam ain't a country, its a puppet government create by the French and American, with all that supports y'all still lost to some farmers with AK, SKILL ISSUES MOMENT
@@FloofyMinari nói gì khi Mỹ thừa nhận chính quyền miền Nam là con rối của Mỹ dựng lên. Sau năm 1973 sao Mỹ không bảo vệ chống cộng sản nữa, hay chống cộng sản chỉ là chiêu bài của Mỹ
@@FloofyMinarimày học lại lịch sử đi
@@UNCLE_NGUYEN 1970's North Vietnam are Communist mate. Dont be butthurted of the truth.
Indeed, Vietnam is a small country located in Southeast Asia. According to historical records, Vietnam has approximately 4000 years of culture. From its early days of nation-building until now, Vietnam has always faced extremely brutal invasions. The Chinese conducted 24 invasions of Vietnam, and the Vietnamese people spent 1000 years liberating their nation. Perhaps there is no other country in the world that has witnessed as much sacrifice and loss as the Vietnamese. During the resistance against the French, it is estimated that around 4 million Vietnamese perished in 80 years of French colonization. Following that, the Japanese caused a famine, resulting in an estimated 4 million civilians dying of starvation. But that was not the worst. The Americans came and bombed this small country into oblivion, destroying everything, even the vegetation. Therefore, the Vietnamese yearn to live in peace like other nations.
cảm ơn bạn. lịch sử của dân tộc Việt Nam chúng tôi là như vậy đó. chúc bạn và gia đình thật nhiều sức khỏe và hạnh phúc nhé
You don’t know anything about Vietnam war? These are not civil war absolutely. All Vietnamese anti invasion and colonialism
Vâng. Mỹ đã mang tổng quân số khoảng 550.000 quân tham chiến trực tiếp ở việt nam.chưa tính quân đồng minh của học nữa.nội chiến gì mà toàn quân nước ngoài vậy ?
Tổng là 6,6 triệu lượt lính. Giai đoạn cao điểm nhất là 500000 lính Mỹ bạn ơi
ý nó là Việt Nam là thằng anh đánh Mỹ là thằng em
I wonder if in 70 years I'll be able to return to my battle grounds in IRQ and AFG and be received with the same dignity the French vets receive from the former adversaries, the Vietnamese? Answer? It's highly unlikely. By the way, it wasn't a civil war. That's a swing and a miss.
Bạn nói đúng! Đó không phải là nội chiến mà đó là cuộc kháng chiến chống đế quốc Mỹ, Mỹ gọi đó là nội chiến để che giấu thất bại của họ mà thôi
THIS WAS NOT A CIVIL WAR, everyone can read all of the other comments to see why!!
Whoever made this video needs to go to school again, to at least learn how to google. "civil war"? Open your eyes and read!!!!
Vietnamese military is not the strongest, but it defeated the strongest military of the world by his bravery. Respect
I'm glad the former enemies became friends
tks for good information about vietnam, although not exactly 100%. I subscribe to this channel because of the authenticity of the information.
Perhaps a surprising similarity to the American Revolutionary battle of Yorktown. Vietnamese = Americans, their Chinese allies = the French, their British enemies = trapped French paratroopers.
The irony is Vietnam revert back to capitalist policy started in 1991.
There is no irony here, the roots of the Viet Minh are nationalism, they fought for the national independence of their country and communism is more like a political tool. Maybe you don't know, Ho Chi Minh was a pro-US until the US supported France in the battle of Dien Bien Phu.
Sao lại trớ trêu ? Chủ nghĩa nào mà giúp việt nam độc lập ,thống nhất thì vn áp dụng !!!😂 còn chủ nghĩa tư bản nó giúp vn thịnh vượng !! Người ta áp dụng vào từng giai đoạn !!
Việt Nam không quan tâm lắm về chủ nghĩa này chủ nghĩa nọ, chúng tôi chỉ vì lợi ích quốc gia và dân tộc.
Không có gì là chớ chêu cả.cộng sản là công cụ giúp chúng tôi giải phóng, thống nhất đất nước. còn tu bản giúp kinh tế phát triển mạnh mẽ. lên nhớ là Hồ Chí Minh muốn theo Mỹ chứ không phải liên xô.chỉ vì hoa kì ủng hộ Pháp lên Việt Nam bắt buộc phải theo cộng sản để giải phóng đất nước
That capitalist policy is just basically Lenin's NEP. You don't know anything about socialism
No state in the Middle East was willing to become North Vietnam 🇻🇳 but the Palestinian Resistance Movement had a Vietcong’s sense of purpose 🇵🇸
Yes they are right , this is a civil war .A civil war between bac ky , nam ky and trung ky against hoa ky . Only true Vietnamese fellas understand what i mean
( 🐧🐧🐧 this is our common joke to counter back when someone say Vietnam war is a civil war )
It wasn't a civil war. It was a war between two countries.
North Vietnam waged war against the sovereign South Vietnam.
South Vietnam defended their homeland from the North Vietnamese invaders.
North Vietnam illegally used "neutral" Laos and Cambodia to bypass the DMZ and attack South Vietnam.
North Vietnam also illegally broke a peace treaty and invaded South Vietnam in 1975.
SOUTH VIETNAM IS NOT A COUNTRY, A PUPPET GOVERNMENT WILL NEVER BE A COUNTRY!
Ở đây không có Bắc Nam, Việt Nam chỉ là 1 nước, không phải 2 nước chỉ có toàn dân Việt Nam chống lại sự xâm lược của Mỹ và chính quyền do mỹ dựng lên tại Sài Gòn, Toàn dân Việt Nam có bộ đội Việt bắc, có biệt động sài gòn, có mặt trận giải phóng Miền Nam Việt Nam là dân Miền Nam và các tĩnh miền tây, có các bà mẹ Việt Nam Anh hùng khắp cả nước... Thế nên bạn câm cái mồm lại và tạo cho não của bạn thêm vài nếp nhăn đi.
Nước Việt nam là một, nhân dân Việt Nam là một. Không ai, không chính thể, tổ chức, thể chế chính trị nào có quyền chia cắt. Đuổi ngoại xâm, thống nhất toàn vẹn đất nước là trách nhiệm thiêng liêng mà mọi người dân Việt Nam đã thực hiện trong 4000 năm lịch sử.
@@Casablanca-dng Nó là cali phọt tranh luận làm ji bạn. Tôi theo dõi nó cãi gân cổ phía trên r. Nói như shit ấy mà.
Que loucura, os soldados que se matavam no campo de batalha perdoando uns aos outros.
E onde estão os mandantes, aqueles que mandam terceiros para a morte defender seus interesses pessoais ?
General Giáp Dominated Dien Bien Phu ~ KHE SANH Was a Different Story; Politics!
i admire vietnamese. they are courageous and patriotic people
Cảm ơn bạn. chúc bạn và đất nước của bạn hạnh phúc và phát triển
BS.....what do the occupiers have to remember ???
💯❤ ☭🇻🇳
why the fuck must the Vietnamese soldiers push the wheelchairs for the frenchy? Did their consulate demand that?
vì những người cựu chiến binh Pháp không tự đi được. giúp đỡ họ là điều bình thường. thể hiện tinh thần Hòa Bình và xoá bỏ hận thù
Corrupt to the core.
Stupid
Im di thang ba que. :)))))
3///
3 /// Republic of Vietnam = Those who sold Vietnam. Corrupt to the bottom, sucking the blood of our compatriots is the Republic of Vietnam.
cay
wecome to peace VietNam ....
TaiwanPlus News🇨🇳😂😂😂
kênh này là đài loan.. lên họ có góc.nhìn và cách nói khác mình khỏi cần quá để ý làm gì..
hay chả quan tâm họ làm gì.
From KMT's dogs to Yankee's dogs