I also love that we only see small, closed-mouth smiles from Darcy up until after his wedding to Elizabeth. There, I can imagine the director saying, "Alright Colin, now you can grin to your heart's content!" He's so happy there. And he really does have a beautiful full-on smile.
Je découvre vos vidéos et analyses sur Orgueil et Préjugés 1995 (la meilleure version du roman!). Je vous remercie pour vos analyses si détaillées et pertinentes. Je trouve tout très bien (votre voix et votre accent, votre calme et bonne humeur et votre générosité de partager votre amour de cette série avec nous). Merci beaucoup et continuez amicalement Almudena
One of the comments to which you referred mentioned Lizzy's "Sharp Tongue." The commenter misspoke. Elizabeth has a sharp wit, but her tongue is quite mild. Austen makes it clear that all her comments are said with such a sweetness that no one can take offense. This is where Keira Knightley's portrayal of Elizabeth completely misses the mark. Her Elizabeth indeed has a sharp tongue and gives offense. She misses Lizzy's charm completely. Ehle is brilliant.
Yes I’ve always thought that the delivery of dialogue in the 2005 was just too quick - which to my eyes showed a sense of not thinking before speaking.
11:00 Perhaps the slight glimmer of a smile in Mr. Darcy's mouth and eyes at seeing Mr. Collins' ineptitude during the dance is because he is thinking: "Aha! No competition for me!" Just one of many possibilities! :)
I believe Darcy is recognizing Lizzie's amazing ability to suffer Mr. Collin's ineptness with as much dignity and grace as possible. In other words he may be feeling sorry for her but also seeing what a good sport she is.
I also think that moment when Lizzy and Darcy are looking at each other when G is playing the piano was special because when G heard them talking about Wickham she messed up and Lizzy protected her by claiming it was her fault because she had forgotten to turn the page for her, Darcy then realized she had protected his sister and her smile let him know she believed him.
Lizzie's protective instincts toward G was what finally validated Darcy's desire, and willingness to throw any concerns about their relative situations out the window and dedicate himself to Lizzie's happiness.
I love Mrs Gardiner's "can you not?". Because the only thing about everything that's happening that surprises/intrigues her, is the fact that apparently Lizzie can't see it.
Mrs. Gardiner is a wonderful character, and I like that the only example we see of a truly happy marriage is that of Mr. and Mrs. Gardiner. They are both so likeable and obviously still very much in love.
In the scene at Pemberley when Caroline makes the Wickham comment, Elizabeth deflects it and immediately returns to Georgiana as if to shield her; I feel that simple sisterly act helps solidify Darcy’s feelings for Lizzie in the way she instinctively protects his sister. It shows she can be trusted with Georgiana and with family secrets. His relief, thanks, and love are right there in his eyes.
There is only one other moment I should like to call out, but it does not show a lighter side of Darcy except to show further that he is human. I feel that many watch the famous first proposal scene and only notice the anger Darcy portrays, and perhaps I could be wrong and others have noticed too, but Firth gives such a beautiful performance in that there are small moments where I believe you can almost visually see Lizzie's words cutting him deeply. I think of these moments as Darcy with his puppy dog eyes. He genuinely seems hurt by what she has said, but it is so subtle, masked by the anger. Yes at one point he faces away and leans against the mantel to easily show his agitation and frustration, but when he faces the camera I believe I can surmise a slight mist in his eyes and for a couple brief moments before he responds to her refusal, he looks as if he may be about to cry. Refusal was the last thing he expected to hear, and I believe you can see the moment where it sinks in, and then again when she explains her reasoning. I believe two things are happening in his mind alongside the anger, one that he has discovered how much he hurt his friend Bingley by misreading Jane's behavior, and secondly that he hurt Elizabeth by extension, and the anger is not only at her refusal but that his own actions are the cause to her denying him. I believe his anger is two-fold, both at hearing no and at himself. At times I re-watch with this in mind, and it affects my viewing so much that I believe you can see a layer deeper into Darcy's actions throughout the rest of the story. An example would be when he is saying "I shall conquer this. I shall." The words take on a double entendre: that he shall conquer his love for Elizabeth and reconcile himself to her refusal, but that he shall conquer his guilt and embarrassment as well. It all leads to those famous lines in the second proposal "...had you behaved in a more gentleman-like manner. You know not how those words have tortured me." I believe this is his true admission of guilt, and not the letter itself, as well as his admission that he has been trying to do better. The truth we all know is that he actually didn't need to change much at all, but simply to be more open and honest and revealing of his true self, most especially to Lizzie. This is why the scenes at Pemberly are so satisfying, because it is the first time we truly see Darcy as he really is through Lizzie's eyes. The fact that the acting in this series was so masterful that here we are so many years later scouring the footage for details and analyzing it to this point is beyond any compliment I could give, it speaks for itself. Yet none of this is possible without the masterpiece that Austen wrote.
@@TudorSmith small point I'm sure but does anyone know why. Bingley, Hurst and Darcy arrive at that very first dance wearing different headgear from the rest of the season? They are like hats for the Navy ? After that scene they only wear those top hats ( and it gets in the way when Darcy finally kisses Elizabeth at the end.
The scene with Georgiana, the hug was not perfunctory. Not a quick hug of her shoulders and a pat but he cradles her head against his shoulder. It was a comforting, loving gesture.
I had no complaints about the other video. Where a thing is not explicitly stated, it’s subject to interpretation. I appreciate both views of Darcy’s look after she confirms that indeed, she walked… but I offer a third. I thought he looked faintly embarrassed. He asks if she came on foot, she responds with a gentle form of “I mean… yeah… obviously… you just saw me walk up,” and for a moment he thinks, “Right. Stupid question…” accompanied by a slightly pained expression. Then he recovers and tries to look a bit more competent. It’s very human and rather humble. I like exploring his gentler nature. I remember this subject coming up when I found out a new friend had enjoyed this version herself. We discussed an article I read in which the author had assumed women fell in love with Colin Firth in this adaptation because of his oh so sexy exit from the pond looking like a drowned rat. I guess the soggy shirt was supposed to have made us swoon. Some might enjoy that but it’s a bit of a red herring. It seems like the cause because of its proximity to the truth. The truth of it was that the scene showed a humbler view of Mr. Darcy. In walking up to the house in this unkempt state and seeing the girl he loved looking at him, his pride could not really cover anything. He was entirely thrown off of his usual stoicism and his feelings were plainly visible. Follow that with him leaping inside to dress and gallop down to catch her before she left, his hair still wet and sloppy and his face bright and eager, and then his frank delight in knowing she liked the house that he hoped to make her mistress of, and there’s really no resisting him. In fact, I hadn’t considered him handsome on first viewing until his expressions made him so. This was the first thing I saw him in and he just seemed stiff and unappealing… until he chose to look otherwise. Honestly, I came away most impressed with Colin Firth’s acting.
It seems to me that Darcy has been talking about Elizabeth to his relatives. When Colonel Fitzwilliam first shows up at Rosings he says to Elizabeth "I get to meet you at last. I've heard much of you..." and then when she first meets Georgiana, Georgiana says "My brother says he has rarely heard anything that gave him more pleasure" (than the singing and playing of Elizabeth). I think this is another insight into his gentle side - he has been talking about her. I iike this side of Darcy. On a totally different thought - has anyone noticed the ring that Darcy wears and is there any significance? He tends to play with it. thanks.
It's a signet ring, which is historically men wore on a pinky finger, which was used to make a wax seal, usually contains a family crest or personal crest. Now I know some people wear the to show what university they attended or as an ornament. This is from Google: "Historically, donning a signet ring was a mark of prestige and authority. It signified familial lineage, social status, and identity in official correspondence".
I always thought the look in the corridor had to do with the memory of the unspoken interaction with Elizabeth in the piano scene, and had nothing to do with Caroline. The piano scene is one of the best love scenes I've ever seen.
I think you are absolutely right when Lizzie comes to see Jane that Mr. Darcy’s greeting of her though he initially was surprised why she would choose to walk. It just improved his opinion of her. She was not trying to impress anyone. She only wanted to come and see Jane. I had always questioned what his feelings were at that moment, but you helped point out that he was suppressing a smile of approval that she did not care about the opinions of others, but she did care very much about her sister and I think he liked that.
I must admit that I always interpreted Mr. Darcy’s little smile as he walked down the hallway as the satisfaction of having silenced Miss Bingley as well. Now I have to concede that it likely had more to do with the fact that he saw a change in the responses of Miss Bennet, but couldn’t it have been in response to the evening as a whole? I picture him thinking, “She seems to be changing her opinion of me, AND I bested Miss Bingley! A most satisfactory evening indeed.”
I noticed tears welling up in his eyes after Elizabeth's affirmative answer. he tried to hide them. I think that's why she started to move on. she was so discreet!
The scene where Darcy is looking at Elizabeth singing is my absolute favorite. My husband looked at me that way on our first date and it was all up with. I can watch this scene over and over.
Oh yes! The look he gives Elizabeth after she rushes back to Georgiana's side after Bingley's sisters try to upset her by mentioning Wickham is a look of love! He was already in love with Elizabeth by then, but when she came to his beloved sister's rescue she scored massive new points with Darcy.
When Darcy and Elizabeth are sparring over the piano at Rosings, and Lady C rudely interrupts. Darcy’s intent and engaged gaze suddenly freezes and his eyes almost imperceptibly roll upward. That is one of my favorite moments.
My favorite moment in this whole drama is at 12:05 (in this video) is when Elizabeth, with a rather competitive smirk, attempts to win the debate by saying self-improvement (practicing piano) is what refines the person and she falls short. But then Darcy softens and complements her on her playing; then that fabulous line, "We -- neither of us -- perform to strangers." In an abstract way, he counters her assertion (as her smirk slowly disappears) by offering that they are alike. Perhaps right for each other?
I have always interpreted the scene where Lizzie dances with Mr Collins at netherfield as an important glimpse into Darcy’s character - at first he smirks at the foolishness and embarrassing behaviour of Mr Collins, but as the scene goes on and follows Darcy as he walks around the room his expression changes and I have always felt that, by the end of the scene he is feeling ashamed and disgusted with himself for enjoying something which clearly caused Lizzie embarrassment- he realised how unkind and ungentlemanly his initial response was towards Lizzie who he admires. And perhaps that was part of his motive in asking her to dance - as recompense for his unkind reaction and perhaps also to help restore Lizzie publicly after the public embarrassment caused to her by Mr Collins’ ineptitude. I also think another beautiful moment which showcases Colin Firth’s talent is the scene after he walked with candle and dogs through the long hall and goes into the music room and is remembering Lizzie at the piano earlier that night - he has a tender look on his face remembering her in his home but then his expression changes to look bitter - I have always felt that was Darcy basically telling himself “you fool, what are you thinking - she has rejected you !!” Hence him racing off to see her the next morning - I think his intention was to try to ask if there was any hope for him. I may be wrong but that’s how I have always felt about it. LOVE your channel
When Lizzy says her feelings are quite the opposite the look on Darcy's face says "Thank you God. She wants me as I want her." He was relieved because he was afraid she might turn him down again, although deep down I think by this point he knew she loved him back, but... he was still clearly a ball of nerves and her admission of love lifted a weight off of him instantly. He breathed a sigh of sweet relief. Darcy is a stoic, masculine man but he's a sweetheart deep down and Lizzy has his heart.
I think my favorite scene in the film is at Netherfield after Darcy emerges from his bath and looks out the window down to see Elizabeth playing with the dog on the lawn (is it his dog or Bingley’s? I’ve always pondered this) The look of pure adoration on Colin’s face is just exquisitely portrayed. His soul is bared, he’s vulnerable and you know at that point he’s lost. I always disliked that they froze the kiss too soon at the end! 😂
I think the kiss is awkward for 2 reasons: Darcy's hat is in the way and they do not embrace. It's hard to give a tender kiss when you are bouncing along in a carriage and you don't hang on to the other person, don't you think?
I love that in the 1995 version, all of the actors played their characters with such perfect nuances that it made each character interesting and complex, even the “annoying” ones. I always thought Darcy was incredibly tender, and playful inside, but restrained it. That’s one of the reasons that he finds Elizabeth so attractive, she has an incredible wit, mixed with a bit of cheeky naughtiness that matches his own sense of humor. I think that this “hidden” side of Darcy is why so many people love his character, and the subtle reveal of it by Firth’s portrayal is the closest to the book. (And more masterful in my opinion.) Thank you for your insights!
Re the dance with Mr Collins, my perception is he is just amused and maybe also subconsciously deciding to dance with her himself to impress her with the contrast that would be entirely in his favour. I’ve never believed the smile to contain any spite or other adverse feelings
5:49-8:40: Yes, I can definitely see how Mr. Darcy is holding in a smile during those scenes. When I first watched this during the Christmas Holiday 2019, as an American University student at Bangor University, for some reason, i could only begin to see Darcy's change of heart only after Elizabeth and the Gardners were talking to Darcy at Pemberley. I'm not sure if this is a cultural thing, as coming from the US, it might take me a bit longer to notice the covert details of Darcy's countenance. Also, upon viewing these scenes again almost five years later, and with your kind help with your take on Darcy's subtle, yet powerful, behaviors, I can definitely see his wise craftiness of expression, like an owl. At 8:35, I think of Darcy stoically straightening his wing feathers before he guides her to Jane. I love owls, too, but that is besides the point of Pride and Prejudice! 🦉
Your 1995 P & P content is all fantastic. The period covered by the novel is a particularly challenging season for Darcy. He has shouldered a lot of loss and adopted massive responsibility at a very young age. He has just gone through extreme distress with his teenage sister. At his age, given that he has already inherited, the subtext is that he has been absolutely besieged by socially/financially ambitious women and their Mamas. Plus, he's trapped in a house with either Caroline Bingley or Lady Catherine for much of the story. He's angry, but his character has an astounding amount of societal pressure to remain composed at all times, and while under perpetual surveillance. He adopts a defensive, mistrustful stance in public. Who could blame him? Enter Colin Firth. I have always been incredibly impressed with this portrayal because he has superhuman control of his eyes. Those eyes vacillate between cold, mistrustful, cynical to vulnerable, amused, impressed or smitten...often within one scene and while barely altering his facial expression. Consider focusing strictly on his remarkable eye acting on your next viewing!
Pride and Prejudice is such a masterpiece. The characters, the dialogues, the way it deals with very serious matters and has such comedic moments, at the same time...I don't think, I'll ever get tired of it. Jane Austen was a great study of human nature. There are no two people, who relate to each other or treat each other in the same way. Every relationship is unique and beautifully fleshed out. I do love, that the friendships between Darcy and Bingley and Elizabeth and Charlotte *are* real relationships. They feel real and serve a point in the development of the story and the characters. The side characters may be side characters, but they are very much not unimportant. And Darcy's 'Mona Lisa' like 'almost a smile' certainly helps to make and keep his character interesting. Colin Firth plays him so well. I don't know if it was intentional, but the fact that he isn't easy to read at times works perfectly. Every viewer can and should interpret his 'smile' the way they want. There is no right or wrong interpretation, necessarily, since we aren't told the story from his point of view. We'll never know, what he thinks about Elizabeth and her muddy hems....but gosh, is it fun to speculate!
It's the subtlety of Colin Firth's acting that makes his portrayal of Darcy so brilliant! I do think he is the best Darcy to have graced any screen, that includes Laurence Olivier's interpretation!!
Thank you for these sharp observations. To me the most pivotal part of the whole series begins with Darcy meeting Elizabeth after his swim in the pond. Both are taken completely aback by the unexpected appearance of the other, Elizabeth especially, by the "not quite so formally attired" Darcy that she looks over in amusement. This scene opens us to Darcy's vulnerable side which is then further amplified by his repeatedly asking Elizabeth about the health of her parents, to which she responds with a chuckle. We also see this vulnerability in the hesitant way he invites Elizabeth to meet Georgiana. Finally, if you look at his facial expression in saying goodbye to Elizabeth and Gardeners and declaring his hope that they will see each other again soon, there is nothing of pride or standoffishness, just a wishful longing that this parting will soon be followed by a subsequent meeting. The whole sequence culminates with Elizabeth looking fondly back at this now vulnerable and yet hopeful man receding from view. From that moment on, we know the tide has turned for both of them.
Yeah, I know this comes from an American but I feel very strongly about the analysis of one scene. The one when Darcy is walking down the corridor. You said he was feeling victorious over Caroline. No! He had set her straight that's for sure, but his return to the music room was to relive the connection with Elizabeth. To feast his eyes on the woman he loves.
One of the purest joys of this version (for me, the ONLY one) of "Pride And Prejudice" is watching, with fascination, the intricate subtleties of Colin Firth's superlative performance as Mr Darcy. You have to pay attention, you have to watch him with care, or you might miss something.....something very important in what's going on, you have to learn to read him, to really see him, to understand him. In the intricate code of behavior in that society, in its time, there is so very much that you have to read, and try to understand, and it amazes me in its subtle complexities. For me, Colin Firth's Darcy is the one, the only, the very best of them all. I just got the fully restored bluray edition of this production, and it is one of the true jewels of my film collection. You have to pay attention in watching it, you have to understand what's happening, you have to come to know these wonderful characters, their time, their culture, their social rules, their ways, and use that framework to truly appreciate and understand these fascinating characters, what's going on. I love the book, I love this production of it. For me, there is no other. Thank you!
@@TudorSmith I read an interesting comment once about Darcy being in such a bad mood because Bingley had -- as usual -- monopolized the prettiest girl in the room and he was frustrated that he never had a chance with women around Bingley. Indeed, Darcy's public rudeness to Elizabeth (in the book he deliberately catches her eye) is necessary for the plot but seems somewhat out of character for the proud, socially rigid gentleman who follows all the rules. The director in fact shows Darcy becoming gradually more irritated at the boisterous manners of the assembly, but I rather like the explanation that he is ticked off at Bingley for always getting the girl.
Also, from what is inferred, he just arrived THAT day, for a shy homebody type to be tired from a journey then forced to attend a social event in a crowded hall with ppl he doesn't know apart from Bingley, who is dancing, and Bingleys sisters, ugh, who wouldn't be a little grumpy.
AT 3:55 you mention that Darch has a playful side. I so agree. One thing that has always bothered me about every adaptation i have watched is that the story always ends with the weddings. I wish some director could please, please find a way to incorporate Lizzie's description of how Darcy came to tolerate her mother, how her father became a regular visitor and there were just some funny insights into how he 'lightened up' a bit with her influence and info about Jane and Charles and Lydia and Wickham. I love the musing at the end.
Having made my video, I can actually see that side of Darcy more. It makes me see such a different side of the character other than a dark brooding man.
PS from Rachel S: men who think women fall for Firth at the swimming scene have a point😄- but for the most part, we fall hard for 1) Darcy’s ability to listen to, and heed, heated criticism from a woman; 2) his innate principles; 3) his empathy; and 4) Firth’s total embodiment of those qualities.
Hi Tudor. Great video! Yes, the revealing of Darcy's true good nature that eventually makes Elizabeth "the happiest creature in the world" has to be subtle. We are borne along the same journey of discovery as Elizabeth. Her prejudice (as third-person omniscient narrator) has to be OUR prejudice. That is why, to me, P&P is such a masterpiece and the balance is so delicate and deft. Elizabeth (and the reader) uncovers what has been there all along. When she speaks to Wickham after her visit with Mrs Collins where she reads the revelations contained in Darcy's letter, Elizabeth tells Wickham that "Mr Darcy improves on acquaintance...that, from knowing him better, his disposition was better understood". Of course, Darcy hasn't yet performed the great act of bringing about Lydia's marriage, but already Elizabeth is softening towards him. Not that Darcy is perfect. The novel is about growth and change, and the good effect that each one has on the other. Have you read Colin Firth's own assessment of Darcy's character in the book "The Making of Pride and Prejudice"? He has great insight, and it was this perception that enabled him to portray Darcy so well, in my opinion. He concludes (best to read it yourself) that Darcy's "failing is foolish, superficial, social snobbery". Paraphrasing here now, but Darcy has had good values instilled in him, but ignorantly believes he will encounter nothing but barbarianism outside his own social circle. When he falls in love with a "barbarian", he realizes "that she is at least his equal, if not his superior, in terms of wit, intellectual agility, and personal dignity." Elizabeth profoundly challenges his old prejudices. I really urge you to read it if you haven't done so already. Firth's description of how he approached the first proposal scene is particularly interesting. Look forward to future videos.
Thank you for that wonderful comment. It must take an actor and extra special skill to be able to "pull out" the depth of a character just from reading text. Colin pulls it of admirably! In fact all the cast really deliver so well and to the point that we the viewers can really believe we like or loathe a character just from the actor's portrayal. One commenter made a point of saying how much they disliked Alison Steadman's Mrs. Bennet. But that's the skill of Alison Steadman I guess!
@@TudorSmith I quite agree about Colin Firth. He tried very hard to understand Darcy and to really inhabit the character. That was so important because Darcy is an enigma until some way through the book, and all that's going on inside him is not apparent from the outside. When we eventually get to know him, we can look back and retrospectively see the clues that were there all along. Firth understood all that, so betrays those "clues" in the subtle ways that your video demonstrates. But Firth couldn't have done that so successfully if he hadn't "got" Darcy's character and inhabited it so well. I greatly admire his portrayal. I love Andrew Davies' writing, but I take issue with him on one thing: he shouldn't have shown Darcy rushing off to London searching for Lydia UNTIL Elizabeth learns of it from Lydia and Mrs Gardiner. This upset the delicate balance that Austen builds into the book. I know there are some scenes where Elizabeth isn't present, and the reader gets special insight, but this isn't one of them. Still, no matter. I know what some critics mean about Alison's Mrs Bennet. She is shrill and over-the-top, but I think this is in keeping with 1995 generally. It went for a more comedic, larger-than-life approach, which I liked. I have enormous sympathy for Mrs Bennet, being a mother. And even a stopped clock is right twice a day! Mr Bennet, on the other hand, whom everybody loves, is quite a culpable character I think. Neglectful, cruel at times, openly mocking his wife and drawing Elizabeth in as an accomplice. But that's another story! Don't get me started! Lol.
I had a thought during your previous video about Darcy's reactions. In the scene where Georgiana is playing the piano and is distracted by Caroline's rude comment, to me all of Darcy's attention is on Georgiana. When Lizzie goes back to help her and shares a look with Darcy, what I see is a shared protectiveness toward Georgiana and perhaps Darcy's realizing that Lizzie believed him about Wickham. I think that's what increases that subtle smile on his face. I think this is where he starts to think he might still have a chance - it's the scene that flashes into his mind later that evening.
Indeed, you are right. I see now that Lizzie acts at that very moment as a protective older sister, which echoes the wish that Georgiana expresses when they get acquainted: "I should have liked to have a sister", and the way she looks at Lizzie saying implicitly "that could be you". This reinforces Mr Darcy's feeling that Lizzie would be the ideal wife for him and at the same time gives him some hope to "conquer" her, as Lizzie herself seems to be naturally fitting with the family and the environment at Pemberley.
I couldn't agree more! Both Darcy and Lizzie have the immediate instinct to protect Georgiana. Then they both realize at the same time that Georgiana is fine and they back down. I think this shows that at this point they have become like minded in their sense of decency and kindness.
I didn't comment on the last video, but it's so nice to be able to have a 'conversation' with the person making the video. It's felt like having a cup of tea with you and discussing our favourite film!
Glad you brought up that unsatisfactory awkward kiss! Every time I see it I imagine a director saying, "Right! Slowly, slowly - remember the whole series has been building up to this moment!" while Ehle and Firth desperately battle the shaking of the carriage. In my opinion, it was a near fail of a scene and definitely could have been better produced.
Каков же должен был быть поцелуй Дарси Элизабет?! Дарси большую часть сериала был неловким в отношениях с людьми. Каков его романтический опыт с женщинами, предположу, что незначительный.Что ожидать в таком случае, конечно, ещё и шляпа, и тряска в карете не могут способствовать. Итог, считаю этот поцелуй вполне соответствовал и характерам героев и месту, где он случился.
Darcy's smile when watching Mr Collins' awkward missteps in the dance is, I think, his recognition that Elizabeth is a lady, in every sense of the word. She does not show annoyance or irritation, doe not act against Mr Collins, but rather smooths over the situation and gracefully gets him back on track--an exemplar of what the mistress of Pemberley would most certainly do, is it not?
I respectfully disagree. To me, Darcy is a little amused at Lizzie being stuck dancing with a man who is obviously a bit of an oaf. And Lizzie does seem to be uncomfortably self-conscious about what she believes Darcy/others must be thinking of the situation, and rather tersely instructs her partner, "Other way, Mr Collins!" The book makes it clear that dancing with Mr Collins was mortifying and distressful for Lizzie: "The two first dances, however, brought a return of distress: they were dances of mortification. Mr. Collins, awkward and solemn, apologizing instead of attending, and often moving wrong without being aware of it, gave her all the shame and misery which a disagreeable partner for a couple of dances can give." I think the movie plays up the irritation and embarrassment, rather than smooths it over.
Ah, love these insights, it's like chatting with a true fan 😊 I've always thought that Darcy is a caring character but socially uncomfortable (as opposed to awkward). It's enjoyable to revisit my favourite adaptation through your eyes.
After making my video, I definitly see that caring side of the character. Maybe it's Colin Firths interpretation and the way he delivers his acting skills that make it so for me.
I agree with your opinion that Darcy directed his speech to Elizabeth in the “turn around the room” scene. Also, he saw that Elizabeth is a good “walker” when she went to Netherfield on foot, so he teased her about waking later, but he also reveals within his tease that he actually thinks Elizabeth looks great while waking, he liked her figure when he saw her arriving at Netherfield, for her “figure appear to be best advantage when walking”.
Yes, I think this scene is great for bringing one of the implicit running gags of the book into sharper relief: that before their big fight at Hunsford, every time she crosses his path, he assumes she's doing it on purpose to try to throw herself at him. Why else would she hike three miles to visit her under-the-weather sister, drop what she was doing to walk in a circle with mean girl Caroline Bingley, or join a couple of Lucases to visit her smarmy cousin at his country parsonage? It's only gradually, over the course of the book, that he understands how genuinely responsive she is to having anyone, especially a loved one, want her company. So she has a bigger stake in the previous night's "if a friend asked you to change plans for them" argument than he initially realizes.
In the scene following the dinner at Pemberley, when he's back in the music room, reflecting on the evening, his expression changes, subtly, from pleasurable reflection to determination to, imo, ride to Lambton the next morning and propose again. He's thwarted only by Jane's distressing letter about Lydia. Thanks for the interesting talks. scene
Really interesting insight of Mr Darcy. If you do one on Elizabeth, it would be interesting if you took a deep dive in how she express so much of her feelings through her eyes. I've only watched the series twice, but noticed already first time how the Elizabeth really speaks with her eyes as well as the rest of the dialog. Like for example when Mr Darcy talks with Mr and Mrs Gardiner after being introduced. You see so well the surprise and confusion in her eyes. Jennifer Ehle does a marvelous job playing Lizzy.
I have a soft spot for the kiss at the end, but I sometimes wish for the final scene to be at Pemberley. Maybe Elizabeth watching her husband riding the grounds so the miniseries comes full circle. Eh, I can only dream. Love this video, I’m hoping for a video dedicated to Jennifer Ehle’s performance. I adore her interpretation of Lizzie. ❤
I’ve always thought that when Darcy watches Fitzwilliam and Lizzy at the piano, he’s feeling jealous because he’s not the one she’s spending time with with
I loved this series and agree it’s the best P&P adaption ever, but what a disappointing final episode! Not only were we robbed of Mrs Bennet’s reaction to Lizzie’s engagement, but also the delicious scenes when Darcy and Bingley have returned to Netherfield and are invited to dinner at Longbourne. After such a delightful feast of a series, I felt seriously cheated at the omission of my favourite scenes from the book!
I have always thought that Elizabeth not telling her father about Darcys involvement in the Lydia/Wickham thing, is out of respect for Darcys "pride" and his position in society.He seems to be an introvert, and Mr Bennett is a good man, but never misses the opportunity to tease and provoke his wife. I think that Elizabeth knows that if she tells her father, he will eventually tell mrs Bennett. Witch will lead mrs Bennett to gossip to everyone and suck up to Darcy, witch he would hate. It would also be a constant reminder of Elizabeths "unfortunate family morals". Best do everything to keep this from Mrs Bennett, and let it be forgotten
Thank you for doing another video! To me this one is all about the brilliance of Colin Firth. The guy moves maybe three facial muscles throughout the entire movie, yet he conveys disdain, astonishment, affection and more. (He never smiles until he's married!) He shows a very intelligent understanding of the book/script, and a truly professional desire to portray the innermost thoughts & feelings of his character. I have a low estimation of the intelligence of many actors, who would not be capable of Firth's subtlety. PS That kiss is a disaster! Since they clearly did not want to show any real kissing (maybe it would not have occurred?), they should have ended just before it.
Lovely videos, thank you so much for making them. Pride & Prejudice is one of my favourite novels, and the 1995 adaptation is, in my eyes, the best by far. About Mr. Darcy's smile at Lizzy's misfortune with Mr. Collins as a dance partner during the ball the Netherfield: I always thought he was comparing himself to Mr. Collins, perhaps thinking "I don't like to dance, but at least I *can* dance". And he knows she enjoys teasing and being witty, so he's enjoying the irony of seeing her stuck in a ridiculous condition from which her wits cannot save her. Moreover, Elizabeth usually chides Mr. Darcy for being proud and uncivil - but now she's showing her exasperation towards Mr. Collins for being an undeserving dance partner and company. Darcy may well be thinking "Who's the proud one now?" Delightful irony of this scene, and a small victory for him. Thank you again for these wonderful analyses, I love revisiting this wonderful story and series.
Excellent insight. I have one interpretation of my own. I interpreted the walking scene of Mr Darcy in hall as his satisfaction. He was satisfied watching how Elizabeth guarded Georgiana from her unpleasant past and how she comforts her. He is satisfied with his choice of perfect wife. And ofcourse he understood the change of behaviour of Lizzy towards him. That's why he got ready early morning and rode to Elizabeth. May be he wanted propose her again or invite her to Pemberley again, but the situation was not in his favour.
That's how I see it. He seems to be pondering her unexpected arrival back in his life and how well everything is going. He's happy to have her at Pemberley. His attention to his appearance the next morning makes me wonder if he was considering asking for her hand in marriage again.
I don't know whether the book says he was going to propose again when he went to see her that day, but I believe he was. That's why I feel extra sorry for him when he gets to the inn only to be foiled by the terrible news of Wickham's "elopement" with Lydia. His first marriage offer went down in flames, and his second never even got off the ground. Thank heavens, the third time was the charm!
Elizabeth is one of the few people that does not constantly busy herself with trying to cheer up Mr. Darcy. I believe it's her negative disposition that allows him to let his gentle side come out. And clearly she is not after his fortune.
Indeed. Elizabeth would marry for love, not money. She would be very happy to take a man who would love her enough to take her for a mere £50 a year. She would be very well pleased! Of course such a man could hardly be sensible and she could never marry a man who was out of his wits 😂
Re. Darcy & Bingley discussing their respective view of the world, you are RIGHT ON TARGET sir! I caught that little smile of Darcy's at the end of his observation of Bingley! What a crafty player Darcy is!
I still find it interesting how Darcy races to change from the swim in order to catch Elizabeth before she leaves and his manner is so sweet to her - surely it is only a few days since she has told him that she would not consider his proposal if he was the last man on earth! He really did take what she said to heart! His pride was exposed and he didn't like what he saw. I find that scene at the carriage and as they walk around the grounds at Pemberley to be the most tender. Thanks for that hint about the thumb rub! It's there for sure. I love it that she turns in the carriage and looks at him as they leave. And then the scene where she sings and plays - she sings a love song, right? So great.
At this point, I have no idea how many times I have watched this BBC series. With each viewing I seem to catch new details that simply add to the experience as a whole. Like many, the series has become somewhat of a comfort watch for me. Seeing someone else catch those subtle glances, details, and minute changes in each facial expression gives me a sense of happiness, as if I am watching with a friend who is paying just as much attention as I am. It is rare that I find anyone willing to watch the 2005 adaptation with me, let alone the full BBC series! It is rarely covered in the grand scheme of reaction and analysis videos on RUclips, so to find someone who loves the series as much as I do, enough to take the time to make videos such as you have, frankly it covers a sorely overlooked section of media and I have very much enjoyed your videos on the subject. Thank you for making these and I hope you continue to do so. Many thanks and well wishes from a fellow Austen and 1995 BBC P&P fan!
Thank you for your videos ! I’m also a big fan of Pride and prejudice (the book) and of course of the 1995 version. I have a comment on Darcy’s behaviour that shows, for me, the acting talent of Firth : when he is uncomfortable with Lizzie (trying to be amiable), he plays with his ring. It happens at least twice : when he comes to discuss with her when she is playing the piano while talking to Fitzgerald, and when he asks if he can introduce his sister to her in the park of Pemberley. I think this detail is important because we can feel that he has to occupy his hands with something because he is so nervous. Ps : I’m sorry if there are mistakes in my post, I’m French and far from being fluent in English ! I have read the book both in French and in English and I like so much the English accent of Firth and Ehle (never watch it in another language!)
In this adaptation we are allowed to see as an audience for the first time a more realistic interpretation of Darcy's character. He is clearly attracted to Elizabeth firstly as a woman but as he spends more time in her company he realizes she has an intellect and humor equal to his own. Colin and also Jennifer can say more with a look and facial expression than words could ever express. The direction and screenplay in this adaptation are nothing short of perfection. A bit of a tangent but there's a clip where Lizzie is out for a walk and she stops to look at some birds flying away from her. For me was put in to suggest to us the audience that she has a longing to leave her home and find another life for herself. It's very cleverly done and I believe a very important little scene in telling of the story and what she's thinking. Again Tudor thanks again for your interesting incites. Keep up the good work.
This interpretation of birds flying is very interesting. Just like when they both walk together at Pemberley and the ribbons on Lizzy's bonnet almost seem to want to hug Mr Darcy. I believe that this movement was intentional, to convey to us that this was also Lizzy's desire at that moment. There are several moments like this that delight us every time we watch an episode of the series, in my opinion.
I absolutely agree that Darcy’s character is not one of severe pomposity. I think that particular prize goes to Mr Collins. Most of Darcy’s true thoughts and feelings are portrayed through his facial expressions & gestures, what he says, I feel, reveals very little about his true character. I love your videos, please keep them coming.
Mr Darcy is a person who most of the time has a serious countenance. However, I see him as a person who is very close to his friends. This can be seen in the relationship he establishes with Mr Bingley, they are quite different but Mr Darcy manages the differences in their behaviour very well. His upbringing doesn't allow him to tell Miss Bingley what he really thinks of her and her sharp comments about Lizzy, for example. I've seen this series many times and re-watched the special scenes a lot, so perhaps I had already noticed almost all of these details about Mr Darcy that this video highlights in such an extraordinary way. I found it very interesting to see the different interpretations that fans like me gave to his smile as he walked through the hall at Pemberley, after having received Lizzy and her aunt and uncle that afternoon. I always thought that the expression on his face simply reflected his happiness at realising that Miss Bennett was more receptive to his presence and conviviality. But it's interesting to realise that there may be other reasons for that mysterious smile. In my opinion, this series is so special which justifies the fact that almost 30 years after it first aired, it still encourages a legion of fans to comment and watch these videos with total enthusiasm. I'm a fan of this channel, I really empathise with the topics and the way they are presented. You can note that it's made by a true fan. Cheers !
This was such a lovely video essay. The more times you watch P&P '95, the more you catch those warm/tender moments of Darcy. The man is not supposed to be easy to read, especially not for Lizzy, so those enigmatic smiles fit perfectly. The other little scene where we see it is when Darcy spots Lizzy playing with his big dog down on the lawn at Netherfield after he comes out of the bath. It's reminiscent of his small smile when he first runs into her when she shows up at Netherfield, windblown and mud-covered. It's been noted that there are 9 instances of Darcy smiling in the book, and almost always it's in response to something Lizzy has said or done. And here's what the book says about her thoughts when she sees his portrait at Pemberly: "...and she beheld a striking resemblance to Mr. Darcy, with such a smile over the face as she remembered to have sometimes seen when he looked at her."
It's been such a long time since I've actually read it that I'd forgotten about any instances of Darcy smiling. I'm definitely going to have to give it a re-read. Maybe also do a video comparing the book to the '95 version. Interesting.....
More amazing P&P content! I am loving this. Colin Firth's subtle brand of acting is perfect for a character who is mostly so reserved. Those little glimmers of smiles feel so well deserved and exciting when they do happen. I would love to see a video on Jennifer Ehle's performance. Her expressions always make me laugh. They are always so relatable!
Whatever else he is, or may be, we know Darcy is a gentle and loving older brother from his treatment of Georgiana. Even Wickham admits to this fact when first talking with Elizabeth. There is already that little hint in the narrative that Darcy may not be what we think him at first. Part of the joy of the novel is discovering the hidden depths of Mr. Darcy. I just love the deep dive into Darcy's character, and Colin Firth's brilliantly subtle portrayal!
@sapphiregamgee. When I was reading this novel at school in Eng.Lit. Class I was baffled by Darcy’s character. So contradictory. I couldn’t believe that a man could change like that - despite his great efforts to save Lydia from her fate. But this dramatisation allowed me to solve the mystery. It was the scenes in and around Pemberly that revealed the truth. The magnificence and responsibilities of his sudden inheritance, at such a very young age aren’t obvious to us modern readers. But so clearly understood by Jane Austen’s own public that there was no need for her to explain. Darcy was first-class marriage bait -and he was so young and lacking in mentors. By the time he turned up in Hertfordshire he would have already been “got at “ by the richest families in the North of England. There would have been shed - loads of flattery and attempts to gain his attention. Enough to sicken him. He saw insincerity everywhere. Add to that his burden of guilt about his failure to see what was happening to his ward, his very young sister - and the last minute rescue. And he was already lonely - grieving for his wonderful father. Much of this we can pick up from the old house-keeper’s conversation with the Gardners on their visit to Pemberley.and the magnificence of the estate. It was Darcy’s love for Elizabeth that began his return to trust and normality. She was so searingly honest - though her candour shocked and hurt him at first.
On re-watching this marvellous series more recently I have also looked for signs that Darcy isn't only the proud and reserved man he appears to be in the first half. It struck me that part of the reason for his behaviour is that Wickham's designs were in the recent past and with Wickham in the vicinity Darcy was reminded of this painful episode. Not something to make him want to be the life and soul of the party!
I love these videos. I believe that scene where he and the dogs are walking down the hall he is thinking he is finally getting somewhere with Lizzie. He knows she actually does like him for the first time but it also is that he basically got rid of the nasty sister to his friend. Kind of what you said AND the fact that things are going his way with Lizzie. Anyway I absolutely love this series. Won't watch any other of Pride and Prejudice this is by far the best and so rewatchable.
The 1995 version is the best. There are more than just one reason why. It is the longest version and because of that they were able to place more scenes into the movie from the book. They really did a great job of reproducing the time period, cloths, dances, food, buildings, accents, etc.. The actors were unknown at the time (at least here in America) so your mind wasnt placing them in any other movie. You could get completely absorbed into the movie. It was well done all the way around and thats why people are still talking about it today. Its a shame that books arent made into movies like this one. They should be made into how ever long it takes without filler. No set time ending. It ends when the story is done. JMO.
One of my favorite Darcy tender moments is during Darcy, Georgiana, and Bingley’s visit to the Inn at Lambton. Lizzy is talking to Bingley and Georgiana steps away to talk to Darcy. The way Darcy tilts his head towards his sister and the tender look on his face tells the beautiful and complete love he has for her.
It’s interesting isn’t it how all those subtle acting parts that are carried out in the background are still so important to telling the story. I tend to watch Mr & Mrs Gardiner whenever they are on screen as they have some wonderfully interacted parts too.
I’ll have to pay attention particularly to the Gardiners next time I watch. I’ve noticed some of their looks and glances before but I’ve never particularly looked out for it. I know some people complain that Mrs. Gardiner is cast too old, but her acting is so superb I still feel like she nails the part.
Thank you, Tudor Smith, for this stellar Darcy video. I find your acute observations both intriguing and entertaining. In a film world replete with miscast Austen characters, Colin Firth's performance as Mr. Darcy is one I think Jane Austen herself would smile upon. And after watching your videos, I'm left with an even greater appreciation for Firth's acting ability and the perfection of his art.
That kiss....I watch programme about the making of PP 1995. Due to filming at locations they filmed it backwards. The first senses filmed were the weddings. They'd been on set a couple of days and new to working together when they film the wedding and have the kiss ❤
Hi! First of all, thank you for your videos! I discovered them only a few days ago and it made me want to watch the 1995 series all over again! Regarding Darcy's gentle and playful behaviour towards Bingley, I always saw it as him acting like an older brother rather than a friend. Darcy enjoys Bingley's happiness and I think there's fondness in the way he smiles at Bingley during the ball scene or when he playfully banters with him later on. From what I remember, Bingley is a few years younger than Darcy and they've been friends for long enough to be comfortable with each other, so Darcy must've known Bingley when he was still young, therefore his affection for Bingley, at least at the beginning, is not the one you share with a friend that you see as an equal, but rather one that you'd have for someone younger that you care for and want to look after. In that regard, the evolution of their relationship makes sense: Darcy gradually learns to see Bingley as a grown man capable of making his own decisions, rather than a child he needs to protect from the world. I'd go further and say this original behaviour towards Bingley could have played a part in Caroline's illusion that she understands Darcy's character. They both tried to keep Bingley from making unwise decisions and reprimanded his naivety, but Caroline failed to realize that, contrary to her, Darcy wasn't doing it solely because he didn't want his party or family to be affiliated with the aftermath of Bingley's poor decisions, but rather because he genuinely thought those decisions could be dangerous for his friend. Caroline didn't care for her brother's happiness, while I think Darcy did, but was blinded by his own vision of what happiness must be. But from Caroline's point of view, she perceived Darcy's action as similar to hers and concluded that they had similar motives. It must have encouraged her affection for him and her hopes that he might like her. Later, when Lizzie literally roasts him alive and he has to reflect on himself, he starts to change the way he sees everything, including his friend Bingley. He realises that Bingley is not the child he met years ago, but a young man who needs and deserve to have his opinions and choices respected. I'm sure Darcy would never cease to look after and advise Bingley, but just like an older sibling learns to do when the younger ones grow up, he would leave more space for Bingley to grow and be his own person. I'd like to add that Darcy was probably comforted in his choice of keeping Bingley and Jane apart because, only a few years back, he saved his own younger sister from ending up in Wickham's claws, and I think in his head it comforted him into thinking he knew how to protect the people he cares for. He failed to realise, however, that the situation was completely different regarding the feelings shared by Bingley and Jane, and that Bingley is not a 15yo girl lol. Well, that's just my opinion! Nice video again, and see ya! =D
I think when Mr. Collin's makes his faux pas Darcy is simply a human being enjoying a few moments of observing absurdity. Mr. Collins is a bit of an oaf. I think Darcy's smile was not so much laughing AT him as simply caught by the moment, an omg smile...and a bit of realization that Lizzie was mortified and i see his smile as also a bit of a twinkle.
In the book, when Lizzie is staying at Netherfield, Darcy is already falling in love with her, but he is very clear that the Bennet's station would prevent the girls making good marriages - that he cannot afford to fall in love with her, and her leaving Netherfield can't come soon enough. I think its also important to keep in mind that Lady Catherine wanted him to marry her daughter, and Bingley's sister wanted to marry him herself and it's implied she wanted Bingley to marry Georgiana, making them one big (probably not very happy) family. I think a lot of the subtlety and surprise about Darcy's reactions and growing gentleness to Lizzie is that they are reluctant - "against my better judgement" I think he says. Part of what I love about Darcy's character development is his transition from his actions being dictated by what "society" would say he should think about the Bennet's and who he should marry (a lady of equal social status) to genuine compassion and understanding for what Lydia's actions were going to mean for all the sisters, that it would literally ruin their entire family, and that he could do something about it because as stupid and foolish as Lydia was, Jane and Elizabeth didn't deserve to suffer from it. It's a transition from head-led actions to heart-led actions on Darcy's part, in my opinion! P.S. I am really enjoying your videos! Just discovered them, and I appreciate how open you are to everyone's feedback! I know I analyze every motion of every scene when I watch this adaptation. And, as an American, I would say that the servant at the inn when Lydia and Kitty meet Lizzie doesn't sound very American to me, the cadence isn't quite what I would expect from an American.... Just my 2 cents on that!
I can't imagine anyone coming to a site dedicated to such a beautiful rendition of Pride and Prejudice and behave with incivility. Quite right to block them. I come here to enjoy the calm, peaceful civility and enjoyable conversations. Now back to Pride and Prejudice. Some of my favorite scenes are when Lizzie meets Georgiana the first few times. I love how welcoming Georgina is to Lizzie compared to Caroline and Mrs. Hurst. It's obvious that Darcy has spoken quite a bit to Georgiana about Lizzie because Georgiana has longed to finally meet her and says that Darcy has praised her skills at the piano forte. Lizzy seems to bond with her instantly, to the point of being upset when Caroline made a crude comment about Mr Wickham which could have been hurtful to Georgiana. Georgiana is perfectly charming. I understand that actress is part of the famous Fox family of actors. I have long enjoyed Laurence Fox in the detective series Lewis.
You can’t please all the people all of the time right? If it’s not for you, just click away. There’s no need to be unkind. I believe Emilia Fox got her first starring role when playing Georgianna (I might be wrong though). She’s the daughter of Joanna David who played Mrs Gardiner. Edward Fox is her father 👍
@@TudorSmith I love Mrs. Gardiner. She so lovely, as is Mr. Gardiner. I had no idea that actress is her real life mother. I learn so much here. Thank you. I've seen Edward Fox in many fine films, as well as other members of the Fox family. Again, thank you.
@@cl6998 I think Georgiana became close to both her sister-in-law Lizzie and her pretty much sister-in-law Jane. Those three women would have gotten along famously.
The ball at Netherfield. Again sir, I believe you've scored another direct hit. If I were Darcy I would have burst out in hoots of laughter! Darcy, more gentlemanly than I, restrains himself admirably with the slightest of smiles.
And when you see Colin Firth deliver that subtle smile and shake of his head, it helps to see the character has amiable right from the offset. It’s almost like you’d be rooting for him right from the start and trying to get all the other characters to understand what you already perceive. I think the next time I rewatch the series that’s what I’ll be doing 🙂
Melting chocolate fire guard”😄.. priceless, Mr. S. This instalment is chock full of goodies, and so many great comments followed. Thoughts: in his response to Collins & Elizabeth dancing, we see him begin to relax in ball settings & enjoy them. His exchange with Bingley, re: the “misanthrope vs. the pushover”shows Darcy’s affectionate banter; if Bingley had seen his expression, I think he’d have taken note and not heard it literally. Your followup on the scene where Elizabeth walks to Pemberly was spot-on.. your use of the term “cheekiness” can apply to all 3 of these scenes. The commenter who laid out all the demands & challenges of his recent past, & present, did a fine job on important factors; I see his light side as returning, not newly sprouted, in the scenes above. Points that you made re: the surprise visit w/the Gardiners are so endearing! Yes to all😊. The piano scene not only shows burgeoning attraction, but Elizabeth’s increasing perception of his facets. Darcy’s “we don’t perform for strangers” has a parallel in Persuasion: Wentworth agreeing with Anne that she “isn’t a card player”. D is openly speaking TO E about herself, without awkwardness. Many American fans may not grasp the full extent of Darcy’s responsibilty FOR Wickham- how that actually works. D would attempt rescue of any girl that W endangered, no matter his own interest or lack thereof. W resents D’s proprietary obligations, yet takes advantage of them, in equal measure. When D hears Jane’s news from E, he’s beside himself on many counts- Firth was magnificent in that scene. The “2nd proposal”: my take is that Darcy is suffused with deep humble happiness for the first time in his life, and Elizabeth is -briefly- a bit too hard on herself, yet essentially radiant with joy. The kiss: yes, the double wedding & departure was unfairly hasty & awkward..😯decidedly odd when more is due to us viewers. We should have seen supporting players at the nuptials, and the newlyweds themselves; and no one can hold a kiss in a moving carriage! The concept of forward motion is lovely, but poorly executed here. Ehle & Firth belong to a set of actors who can perform wonders with their eyes & their hands (Michael Kitchen & Josette Simon, among others); if those talents don’t come naturally, they’re quite a challenge to acquire. Thanks for these exquisite forays into P&P!!😃😍
In the scene where he is needling Bingley a bit I also enjoyed when one of the sisters bantered to Darcey smilingly, "You see, we are not afraid of you." The softening of his face when he says gently "I would not have you so." I really appreciated that.
Yes that scene is another that shows Darcy has kindness in him and is not considered standoffish (if I can use that word) around those who are close to him.
Okay two thoughts from my end: 1) at the Netherfield ball that little smile of Darcy in seeing Lizzy dance with mr Collins seems to me to kind of mirror of that moment Bingley and Darcy had at the Meryton dance. I think we should remember that Darcy is supposed to be totally clueless to Lizzy's animosity towards him. He is used to women fawning over him constantly and even though Elizabeth certainly doesn't fawn, I don't think it actually really enters his head that any woman could actually hate him as much as Lizzy at that point does. When he proposes to Elizabeth the first time he completely expects her to accept his proposal after all. So my take is - and this makes that scene even more funny in a way - that where Elizabeth is completely vexed by mr Collins, then sees mr Darcy and then thinks 'Oh gods and now HE'S here too!' - At the same time I think mr Darcy might actually interpret that look from Elizabeth as the type of embarassment that results from being embarrassed in front of your crush. Or maybe he thinks 'I've been there my girl' - thinking about other awkward partners he's had to stand up with in the past, that made him dislike dancing with strangers so much, maybe? In any case for him it might feel like the same type of 'look of recognition' that he shared with Bingley earlier at the Meryton dance. And soon afterwards he asks her to dance himself, maybe thinking 'I got your sign girl, I'm here to rescue you!' Of course to Lizzy it's totally different! 😂 2) The late night hall walk at Pemberley was always supposed to have been about him thinking of Lizzy. Not for nothing do we hear the tones of the same song she sang at the piano earlier that night. He probably wakes up the next morning with that song in his head 🥰
Maybe that animosity, the strength of character attracted Darcy to Lizzie even more. Whereas it was obvious other women are attracted not just to his power but also his fortune. Here is a woman who was not taking advantage of his wealth. Perfect, he would know she would always be honest but not disingenuous in her feelings for him. He had earned her respect & true love. Jane Austen in all her novels did this in spades. True love always wins. This was her best novel.
Again, wonderful! These tiny calm details make this adaptation so special. The guessing of the thoughts behind each face are making the screen play so interesting. Not like all these movies that reveal every emotion in a huge gestic and expression and shut out.
Don’t you hate it when the characters tell you what they’re about to do, do it, then tell you what they’ve done. C’mon, we’re not simpletons 🤣 It’s so much more intriguing when an actor applies subtleties I think.
![Jack Harlow - Hello Miss Johnson [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Q86_nlRoIGw/mqdefault.jpg)
I also love that we only see small, closed-mouth smiles from Darcy up until after his wedding to Elizabeth. There, I can imagine the director saying, "Alright Colin, now you can grin to your heart's content!" He's so happy there. And he really does have a beautiful full-on smile.
Ha ha you’re so right. Imagine if that was the case!
indeed he does.
Firth and Ehle are both great at mona lisa smiles.. but Darcy also smiled fully when the Gardiners and Elizabeth turn up- not just at the end.
Je découvre vos vidéos et analyses sur Orgueil et Préjugés 1995 (la meilleure version du roman!). Je vous remercie pour vos analyses si détaillées et pertinentes. Je trouve tout très bien (votre voix et votre accent, votre calme et bonne humeur et votre générosité de partager votre amour de cette série avec nous). Merci beaucoup et continuez amicalement Almudena
C'est très gentil de votre part. Merci.
Ugh, fine, you got me, I'll watch 1995 P&P for the 17th time. I just watched it last month, but 🤷♀️
🤣
Oh, is it on RUclips? I don't know where to find it!
LOL! Your sacrifice is great indeed 😂
😂
@@TheWorldisQuietHere3 Such a sorrowful destiny... 😉
One of the comments to which you referred mentioned Lizzy's "Sharp Tongue." The commenter misspoke. Elizabeth has a sharp wit, but her tongue is quite mild. Austen makes it clear that all her comments are said with such a sweetness that no one can take offense. This is where Keira Knightley's portrayal of Elizabeth completely misses the mark. Her Elizabeth indeed has a sharp tongue and gives offense. She misses Lizzy's charm completely. Ehle is brilliant.
Yes I’ve always thought that the delivery of dialogue in the 2005 was just too quick - which to my eyes showed a sense of not thinking before speaking.
11:00 Perhaps the slight glimmer of a smile in Mr. Darcy's mouth and eyes at seeing Mr. Collins' ineptitude during the dance is because he is thinking: "Aha! No competition for me!" Just one of many possibilities! :)
Yes that’s highly possible.
I believe Darcy is recognizing Lizzie's amazing ability to suffer Mr. Collin's ineptness with as much dignity and grace as possible. In other words he may be feeling sorry for her but also seeing what a good sport she is.
I also think that moment when Lizzy and Darcy are looking at each other when G is playing the piano was special because when G heard them talking about Wickham she messed up and Lizzy protected her by claiming it was her fault because she had forgotten to turn the page for her, Darcy then realized she had protected his sister and her smile let him know she believed him.
Lizzie's protective instincts toward G was what finally validated Darcy's desire, and willingness to throw any concerns about their relative situations out the window and dedicate himself to Lizzie's happiness.
I love Mrs Gardiner's "can you not?". Because the only thing about everything that's happening that surprises/intrigues her, is the fact that apparently Lizzie can't see it.
It’s a wonderful moment!
Mrs. Gardiner is a wonderful character, and I like that the only example we see of a truly happy marriage is that of Mr. and Mrs. Gardiner. They are both so likeable and obviously still very much in love.
In the scene at Pemberley when Caroline makes the Wickham comment, Elizabeth deflects it and immediately returns to Georgiana as if to shield her; I feel that simple sisterly act helps solidify
Darcy’s feelings for Lizzie in the way she instinctively protects his sister. It shows she can be trusted with Georgiana and with family secrets. His relief, thanks, and love are right there in his eyes.
The main thing I love about this adaptation is the undercurrent of passion throughout. Wonderful.
The more it’s watched, the more it is observed!
There is only one other moment I should like to call out, but it does not show a lighter side of Darcy except to show further that he is human. I feel that many watch the famous first proposal scene and only notice the anger Darcy portrays, and perhaps I could be wrong and others have noticed too, but Firth gives such a beautiful performance in that there are small moments where I believe you can almost visually see Lizzie's words cutting him deeply. I think of these moments as Darcy with his puppy dog eyes. He genuinely seems hurt by what she has said, but it is so subtle, masked by the anger. Yes at one point he faces away and leans against the mantel to easily show his agitation and frustration, but when he faces the camera I believe I can surmise a slight mist in his eyes and for a couple brief moments before he responds to her refusal, he looks as if he may be about to cry. Refusal was the last thing he expected to hear, and I believe you can see the moment where it sinks in, and then again when she explains her reasoning. I believe two things are happening in his mind alongside the anger, one that he has discovered how much he hurt his friend Bingley by misreading Jane's behavior, and secondly that he hurt Elizabeth by extension, and the anger is not only at her refusal but that his own actions are the cause to her denying him. I believe his anger is two-fold, both at hearing no and at himself. At times I re-watch with this in mind, and it affects my viewing so much that I believe you can see a layer deeper into Darcy's actions throughout the rest of the story. An example would be when he is saying "I shall conquer this. I shall." The words take on a double entendre: that he shall conquer his love for Elizabeth and reconcile himself to her refusal, but that he shall conquer his guilt and embarrassment as well. It all leads to those famous lines in the second proposal "...had you behaved in a more gentleman-like manner. You know not how those words have tortured me." I believe this is his true admission of guilt, and not the letter itself, as well as his admission that he has been trying to do better. The truth we all know is that he actually didn't need to change much at all, but simply to be more open and honest and revealing of his true self, most especially to Lizzie. This is why the scenes at Pemberly are so satisfying, because it is the first time we truly see Darcy as he really is through Lizzie's eyes. The fact that the acting in this series was so masterful that here we are so many years later scouring the footage for details and analyzing it to this point is beyond any compliment I could give, it speaks for itself. Yet none of this is possible without the masterpiece that Austen wrote.
Well put. I hadn’t considered those points but they do make sense to me.
Absolutely agree with this ❤
@@TudorSmith small point I'm sure but does anyone know why. Bingley, Hurst and Darcy arrive at that very first dance wearing different headgear from the rest of the season? They are like hats for the Navy ? After that scene they only wear those top hats ( and it gets in the way when Darcy finally kisses Elizabeth at the end.
🤣he’s such a guy knowing how a female mind functions 🤣most w
Men would not pick up on
The scene with Georgiana, the hug was not perfunctory. Not a quick hug of her shoulders and a pat but he cradles her head against his shoulder. It was a comforting, loving gesture.
For sure! The head touch is *chef’s kiss*
I also enjoy watching Darcy hold Lizzie's hand as he is listening to her explain why she is upset.
A tender moment
I had no complaints about the other video. Where a thing is not explicitly stated, it’s subject to interpretation. I appreciate both views of Darcy’s look after she confirms that indeed, she walked… but I offer a third. I thought he looked faintly embarrassed. He asks if she came on foot, she responds with a gentle form of “I mean… yeah… obviously… you just saw me walk up,” and for a moment he thinks, “Right. Stupid question…” accompanied by a slightly pained expression. Then he recovers and tries to look a bit more competent. It’s very human and rather humble.
I like exploring his gentler nature. I remember this subject coming up when I found out a new friend had enjoyed this version herself. We discussed an article I read in which the author had assumed women fell in love with Colin Firth in this adaptation because of his oh so sexy exit from the pond looking like a drowned rat. I guess the soggy shirt was supposed to have made us swoon. Some might enjoy that but it’s a bit of a red herring. It seems like the cause because of its proximity to the truth.
The truth of it was that the scene showed a humbler view of Mr. Darcy. In walking up to the house in this unkempt state and seeing the girl he loved looking at him, his pride could not really cover anything. He was entirely thrown off of his usual stoicism and his feelings were plainly visible. Follow that with him leaping inside to dress and gallop down to catch her before she left, his hair still wet and sloppy and his face bright and eager, and then his frank delight in knowing she liked the house that he hoped to make her mistress of, and there’s really no resisting him. In fact, I hadn’t considered him handsome on first viewing until his expressions made him so. This was the first thing I saw him in and he just seemed stiff and unappealing… until he chose to look otherwise. Honestly, I came away most impressed with Colin Firth’s acting.
It seems to me that Darcy has been talking about Elizabeth to his relatives. When Colonel Fitzwilliam first shows up at Rosings he says to Elizabeth "I get to meet you at last. I've heard much of you..." and then when she first meets Georgiana, Georgiana says "My brother says he has rarely heard anything that gave him more pleasure" (than the singing and playing of Elizabeth). I think this is another insight into his gentle side - he has been talking about her. I iike this side of Darcy. On a totally different thought - has anyone noticed the ring that Darcy wears and is there any significance? He tends to play with it. thanks.
Now that you mention it, the script does imply that Darcy has at least been talking about Elizabeth to both Colonel Fitzwilliam and Georgiana!
It's a signet ring, which is historically men wore on a pinky finger, which was used to make a wax seal, usually contains a family crest or personal crest. Now I know some people wear the to show what university they attended or as an ornament. This is from Google: "Historically, donning a signet ring was a mark of prestige and authority. It signified familial lineage, social status, and identity in official correspondence".
Yes! He has been telling them about her.
I love the scene where Darcy is comforting Georgiana like the loving brother that he is. It shows his tender side.
I always thought the look in the corridor had to do with the memory of the unspoken interaction with Elizabeth in the piano scene, and had nothing to do with Caroline. The piano scene is one of the best love scenes I've ever seen.
Yes I think you're right. And everyone who's commented agrees too! I may have assumed wrongly in my previous video 👍
Could be the difference between male/female perceptions?
Camera focuses lot on their faces...not wanting to leave them alone...
Caroline always sticks to Darcy..a little aloof with Georgiana around 😅😊😂❤
I think you are absolutely right when Lizzie comes to see Jane that Mr. Darcy’s greeting of her though he initially was surprised why she would choose to walk. It just improved his opinion of her. She was not trying to impress anyone. She only wanted to come and see Jane. I had always questioned what his feelings were at that moment, but you helped point out that he was suppressing a smile of approval that she did not care about the opinions of others, but she did care very much about her sister and I think he liked that.
I must admit that I always interpreted Mr. Darcy’s little smile as he walked down the hallway as the satisfaction of having silenced Miss Bingley as well. Now I have to concede that it likely had more to do with the fact that he saw a change in the responses of Miss Bennet, but couldn’t it have been in response to the evening as a whole? I picture him thinking, “She seems to be changing her opinion of me, AND I bested Miss Bingley! A most satisfactory evening indeed.”
I noticed tears welling up in his eyes after Elizabeth's affirmative answer. he tried to hide them. I think that's why she started to move on. she was so discreet!
Yes you could see he was holding back!
The scene where Darcy is looking at Elizabeth singing is my absolute favorite. My husband looked at me that way on our first date and it was all up with. I can watch this scene over and over.
Oh yes! The look he gives Elizabeth after she rushes back to Georgiana's side after Bingley's sisters try to upset her by mentioning Wickham is a look of love! He was already in love with Elizabeth by then, but when she came to his beloved sister's rescue she scored massive new points with Darcy.
When Darcy and Elizabeth are sparring over the piano at Rosings, and Lady C rudely interrupts. Darcy’s intent and engaged gaze suddenly freezes and his eyes almost imperceptibly roll upward. That is one of my favorite moments.
It is good isnt' it. Lady Catherine isn't even tolerable....that's what I read in his "eye roll" 😂
My favorite moment in this whole drama is at 12:05 (in this video) is when Elizabeth, with a rather competitive smirk, attempts to win the debate by saying self-improvement (practicing piano) is what refines the person and she falls short. But then Darcy softens and complements her on her playing; then that fabulous line, "We -- neither of us -- perform to strangers." In an abstract way, he counters her assertion (as her smirk slowly disappears) by offering that they are alike. Perhaps right for each other?
It is a tender moment between them broken too quickly by Lady Catherine hollering from the other room!
I have always interpreted the scene where Lizzie dances with Mr Collins at netherfield as an important glimpse into Darcy’s character - at first he smirks at the foolishness and embarrassing behaviour of Mr Collins, but as the scene goes on and follows Darcy as he walks around the room his expression changes and I have always felt that, by the end of the scene he is feeling ashamed and disgusted with himself for enjoying something which clearly caused Lizzie embarrassment- he realised how unkind and ungentlemanly his initial response was towards Lizzie who he admires. And perhaps that was part of his motive in asking her to dance - as recompense for his unkind reaction and perhaps also to help restore Lizzie publicly after the public embarrassment caused to her by Mr Collins’ ineptitude.
I also think another beautiful moment which showcases Colin Firth’s talent is the scene after he walked with candle and dogs through the long hall and goes into the music room and is remembering Lizzie at the piano earlier that night - he has a tender look on his face remembering her in his home but then his expression changes to look bitter - I have always felt that was Darcy basically telling himself “you fool, what are you thinking - she has rejected you !!” Hence him racing off to see her the next morning - I think his intention was to try to ask if there was any hope for him. I may be wrong but that’s how I have always felt about it. LOVE your channel
That's how I saw it, too! I love how Colin Firth showcases Darcy's inner world just in a look.
Sim, Darcy( interpretação perfeita do admirável Colin Firth) é especial e envolvente cavalheiro.
In response to any criticism you may have received from your viewers, I LOVE the way you talk!
When Lizzy says her feelings are quite the opposite the look on Darcy's face says "Thank you God. She wants me as I want her." He was relieved because he was afraid she might turn him down again, although deep down I think by this point he knew she loved him back, but... he was still clearly a ball of nerves and her admission of love lifted a weight off of him instantly. He breathed a sigh of sweet relief. Darcy is a stoic, masculine man but he's a sweetheart deep down and Lizzy has his heart.
I think my favorite scene in the film is at Netherfield after Darcy emerges from his bath and looks out the window down to see Elizabeth playing with the dog on the lawn (is it his dog or Bingley’s? I’ve always pondered this) The look of pure adoration on Colin’s face is just exquisitely portrayed. His soul is bared, he’s vulnerable and you know at that point he’s lost.
I always disliked that they froze the kiss too soon at the end! 😂
I think the kiss is awkward for 2 reasons: Darcy's hat is in the way and they do not embrace. It's hard to give a tender kiss when you are bouncing along in a carriage and you don't hang on to the other person, don't you think?
I love that in the 1995 version, all of the actors played their characters with such perfect nuances that it made each character interesting and complex, even the “annoying” ones. I always thought Darcy was incredibly tender, and playful inside, but restrained it. That’s one of the reasons that he finds Elizabeth so attractive, she has an incredible wit, mixed with a bit of cheeky naughtiness that matches his own sense of humor.
I think that this “hidden” side of Darcy is why so many people love his character, and the subtle reveal of it by Firth’s portrayal is the closest to the book. (And more masterful in my opinion.) Thank you for your insights!
Thank you 🙏 The way Colin plays Darcy is a masterclass in acting. And to think he almost turned it down because he felt he’d have little to do!
Re the dance with Mr Collins, my perception is he is just amused and maybe also subconsciously deciding to dance with her himself to impress her with the contrast that would be entirely in his favour. I’ve never believed the smile to contain any spite or other adverse feelings
Oh the contrast. I hadn’t seen that. It’s certainly worth a consideration.
I had never considered that. You could be right.
5:49-8:40: Yes, I can definitely see how Mr. Darcy is holding in a smile during those scenes.
When I first watched this during the Christmas Holiday 2019, as an American University student at Bangor University, for some reason, i could only begin to see Darcy's change of heart only after Elizabeth and the Gardners were talking to Darcy at Pemberley.
I'm not sure if this is a cultural thing, as coming from the US, it might take me a bit longer to notice the covert details of Darcy's countenance. Also, upon viewing these scenes again almost five years later, and with your kind help with your take on Darcy's subtle, yet powerful, behaviors, I can definitely see his wise craftiness of expression, like an owl. At 8:35, I think of Darcy stoically straightening his wing feathers before he guides her to Jane.
I love owls, too, but that is besides the point of Pride and Prejudice! 🦉
Your 1995 P & P content is all fantastic.
The period covered by the novel is a particularly challenging season for Darcy. He has shouldered a lot of loss and adopted massive responsibility at a very young age. He has just gone through extreme distress with his teenage sister. At his age, given that he has already inherited, the subtext is that he has been absolutely besieged by socially/financially ambitious women and their Mamas. Plus, he's trapped in a house with either Caroline Bingley or Lady Catherine for much of the story.
He's angry, but his character has an astounding amount of societal pressure to remain composed at all times, and while under perpetual surveillance. He adopts a defensive, mistrustful stance in public. Who could blame him?
Enter Colin Firth. I have always been incredibly impressed with this portrayal because he has superhuman control of his eyes. Those eyes vacillate between cold, mistrustful, cynical to vulnerable, amused, impressed or smitten...often within one scene and while barely altering his facial expression.
Consider focusing strictly on his remarkable eye acting on your next viewing!
That would make for a great video. I’ll have to get my thinking cap on 👍
Pride and Prejudice is such a masterpiece. The characters, the dialogues, the way it deals with very serious matters and has such comedic moments, at the same time...I don't think, I'll ever get tired of it.
Jane Austen was a great study of human nature. There are no two people, who relate to each other or treat each other in the same way. Every relationship is unique and beautifully fleshed out. I do love, that the friendships between Darcy and Bingley and Elizabeth and Charlotte *are* real relationships. They feel real and serve a point in the development of the story and the characters. The side characters may be side characters, but they are very much not unimportant.
And Darcy's 'Mona Lisa' like 'almost a smile' certainly helps to make and keep his character interesting. Colin Firth plays him so well. I don't know if it was intentional, but the fact that he isn't easy to read at times works perfectly. Every viewer can and should interpret his 'smile' the way they want. There is no right or wrong interpretation, necessarily, since we aren't told the story from his point of view. We'll never know, what he thinks about Elizabeth and her muddy hems....but gosh, is it fun to speculate!
Isn’t it though? I know I can spend hours analysing all the characters and find joy in seeing how they all develop. Masterful writing for sure.
It's the subtlety of Colin Firth's acting that makes his portrayal of Darcy so brilliant! I do think he is the best Darcy to have graced any screen, that includes Laurence Olivier's interpretation!!
And to think he almost wasn’t cast for the role!
@@TudorSmith He wasn't?! That would have been a real shame! Thank you for that information!
Thank you for these sharp observations. To me the most pivotal part of the whole series begins with Darcy meeting Elizabeth after his swim in the pond. Both are taken completely aback by the unexpected appearance of the other, Elizabeth especially, by the "not quite so formally attired" Darcy that she looks over in amusement. This scene opens us to Darcy's vulnerable side which is then further amplified by his repeatedly asking Elizabeth about the health of her parents, to which she responds with a chuckle. We also see this vulnerability in the hesitant way he invites Elizabeth to meet Georgiana. Finally, if you look at his facial expression in saying goodbye to Elizabeth and Gardeners and declaring his hope that they will see each other again soon, there is nothing of pride or standoffishness, just a wishful longing that this parting will soon be followed by a subsequent meeting. The whole sequence culminates with Elizabeth looking fondly back at this now vulnerable and yet hopeful man receding from view. From that moment on, we know the tide has turned for both of them.
Well said. I totally agree 👍
The music is a very powerful element in this particular scene....
Yeah, I know this comes from an American but I feel very strongly about the analysis of one scene. The one when Darcy is walking down the corridor. You said he was feeling victorious over Caroline. No! He had set her straight that's for sure, but his return to the music room was to relive the connection with Elizabeth. To feast his eyes on the woman he loves.
Indeed. I address this in my other video about Darcy’s gentle side 👍
One of the purest joys of this version (for me, the ONLY one) of "Pride And Prejudice" is watching, with fascination, the intricate subtleties of Colin Firth's superlative performance as Mr Darcy. You have to pay attention, you have to watch him with care, or you might miss something.....something very important in what's going on, you have to learn to read him, to really see him, to understand him. In the intricate code of behavior in that society, in its time, there is so very much that you have to read, and try to understand, and it amazes me in its subtle complexities. For me, Colin Firth's Darcy is the one, the only, the very best of them all. I just got the fully restored bluray edition of this production, and it is one of the true jewels of my film collection. You have to pay attention in watching it, you have to understand what's happening, you have to come to know these wonderful characters, their time, their culture, their social rules, their ways, and use that framework to truly appreciate and understand these fascinating characters, what's going on. I love the book, I love this production of it. For me, there is no other. Thank you!
The scene were Darcy claims to find Lizzy tolerable... when she walks by, Darcy looks so shy and a touch wounded..it makes me giggle
It’s almost as if he’s filled immediately with regret!
@@TudorSmith that's exactly what I was trying to say...I get flustered when I see Darcy...lol
@@TudorSmith I read an interesting comment once about Darcy being in such a bad mood because Bingley had -- as usual -- monopolized the prettiest girl in the room and he was frustrated that he never had a chance with women around Bingley. Indeed, Darcy's public rudeness to Elizabeth (in the book he deliberately catches her eye) is necessary for the plot but seems somewhat out of character for the proud, socially rigid gentleman who follows all the rules. The director in fact shows Darcy becoming gradually more irritated at the boisterous manners of the assembly, but I rather like the explanation that he is ticked off at Bingley for always getting the girl.
Also, from what is inferred, he just arrived THAT day, for a shy homebody type to be tired from a journey then forced to attend a social event in a crowded hall with ppl he doesn't know apart from Bingley, who is dancing, and Bingleys sisters, ugh, who wouldn't be a little grumpy.
AT 3:55 you mention that Darch has a playful side. I so agree. One thing that has always bothered me about every adaptation i have watched is that the story always ends with the weddings. I wish some director could please, please find a way to incorporate Lizzie's description of how Darcy came to tolerate her mother, how her father became a regular visitor and there were just some funny insights into how he 'lightened up' a bit with her influence and info about Jane and Charles and Lydia and Wickham. I love the musing at the end.
Having made my video, I can actually see that side of Darcy more. It makes me see such a different side of the character other than a dark brooding man.
PS from Rachel S: men who think women fall for Firth at the swimming scene have a point😄- but for the most part, we fall hard for 1) Darcy’s ability to listen to, and heed, heated criticism from a woman; 2) his innate principles; 3) his empathy; and 4) Firth’s total embodiment of those qualities.
And his intelligence, 'improved by extensive reading'😏
Fifth is so subtle and his performance is so nuanced.
Colin Firth is an amazing actor with incredibly eloquent facial control.
Hi Tudor. Great video! Yes, the revealing of Darcy's true good nature that eventually makes Elizabeth "the happiest creature in the world" has to be subtle. We are borne along the same journey of discovery as Elizabeth. Her prejudice (as third-person omniscient narrator) has to be OUR prejudice. That is why, to me, P&P is such a masterpiece and the balance is so delicate and deft. Elizabeth (and the reader) uncovers what has been there all along. When she speaks to Wickham after her visit with Mrs Collins where she reads the revelations contained in Darcy's letter, Elizabeth tells Wickham that "Mr Darcy improves on acquaintance...that, from knowing him better, his disposition was better understood". Of course, Darcy hasn't yet performed the great act of bringing about Lydia's marriage, but already Elizabeth is softening towards him. Not that Darcy is perfect. The novel is about growth and change, and the good effect that each one has on the other. Have you read Colin Firth's own assessment of Darcy's character in the book "The Making of Pride and Prejudice"? He has great insight, and it was this perception that enabled him to portray Darcy so well, in my opinion. He concludes (best to read it yourself) that Darcy's "failing is foolish, superficial, social snobbery". Paraphrasing here now, but Darcy has had good values instilled in him, but ignorantly believes he will encounter nothing but barbarianism outside his own social circle. When he falls in love with a "barbarian", he realizes "that she is at least his equal, if not his superior, in terms of wit, intellectual agility, and personal dignity." Elizabeth profoundly challenges his old prejudices. I really urge you to read it if you haven't done so already. Firth's description of how he approached the first proposal scene is particularly interesting. Look forward to future videos.
Thank you for that wonderful comment. It must take an actor and extra special skill to be able to "pull out" the depth of a character just from reading text. Colin pulls it of admirably! In fact all the cast really deliver so well and to the point that we the viewers can really believe we like or loathe a character just from the actor's portrayal. One commenter made a point of saying how much they disliked Alison Steadman's Mrs. Bennet. But that's the skill of Alison Steadman I guess!
@@TudorSmith I quite agree about Colin Firth. He tried very hard to understand Darcy and to really inhabit the character. That was so important because Darcy is an enigma until some way through the book, and all that's going on inside him is not apparent from the outside. When we eventually get to know him, we can look back and retrospectively see the clues that were there all along. Firth understood all that, so betrays those "clues" in the subtle ways that your video demonstrates. But Firth couldn't have done that so successfully if he hadn't "got" Darcy's character and inhabited it so well. I greatly admire his portrayal. I love Andrew Davies' writing, but I take issue with him on one thing: he shouldn't have shown Darcy rushing off to London searching for Lydia UNTIL Elizabeth learns of it from Lydia and Mrs Gardiner. This upset the delicate balance that Austen builds into the book. I know there are some scenes where Elizabeth isn't present, and the reader gets special insight, but this isn't one of them. Still, no matter. I know what some critics mean about Alison's Mrs Bennet. She is shrill and over-the-top, but I think this is in keeping with 1995 generally. It went for a more comedic, larger-than-life approach, which I liked. I have enormous sympathy for Mrs Bennet, being a mother. And even a stopped clock is right twice a day! Mr Bennet, on the other hand, whom everybody loves, is quite a culpable character I think. Neglectful, cruel at times, openly mocking his wife and drawing Elizabeth in as an accomplice. But that's another story! Don't get me started! Lol.
Such a comfort to learn others are as obsessed with all this as I am. 😊
Happy thought indeed 🙂
The subtle acting in this movie is superb. 100% my favorite movie ever. Thank you for your videos!
Glad you like them!
I had a thought during your previous video about Darcy's reactions. In the scene where Georgiana is playing the piano and is distracted by Caroline's rude comment, to me all of Darcy's attention is on Georgiana. When Lizzie goes back to help her and shares a look with Darcy, what I see is a shared protectiveness toward Georgiana and perhaps Darcy's realizing that Lizzie believed him about Wickham. I think that's what increases that subtle smile on his face. I think this is where he starts to think he might still have a chance - it's the scene that flashes into his mind later that evening.
Indeed, you are right. I see now that Lizzie acts at that very moment as a protective older sister, which echoes the wish that Georgiana expresses when they get acquainted: "I should have liked to have a sister", and the way she looks at Lizzie saying implicitly "that could be you". This reinforces Mr Darcy's feeling that Lizzie would be the ideal wife for him and at the same time gives him some hope to "conquer" her, as Lizzie herself seems to be naturally fitting with the family and the environment at Pemberley.
I couldn't agree more! Both Darcy and Lizzie have the immediate instinct to protect Georgiana. Then they both realize at the same time that Georgiana is fine and they back down. I think this shows that at this point they have become like minded in their sense of decency and kindness.
I just wish there had been one more movie with this crew,…..it would be SO WONDERFUL!!!!!🤠💋💋💋💋💋💋
I didn't comment on the last video, but it's so nice to be able to have a 'conversation' with the person making the video. It's felt like having a cup of tea with you and discussing our favourite film!
That’s a nice thing to say. Thank you 🙏 I could spend hours talking and analysing this production. 🙂
Glad you brought up that unsatisfactory awkward kiss! Every time I see it I imagine a director saying, "Right! Slowly, slowly - remember the whole series has been building up to this moment!" while Ehle and Firth desperately battle the shaking of the carriage.
In my opinion, it was a near fail of a scene and definitely could have been better produced.
A missed opportunity?
Каков же должен был быть поцелуй Дарси Элизабет?! Дарси большую часть сериала был неловким в отношениях с людьми. Каков его романтический опыт с женщинами, предположу, что незначительный.Что ожидать в таком случае, конечно, ещё и шляпа, и тряска в карете не могут способствовать. Итог, считаю этот поцелуй вполне соответствовал и характерам героев и месту, где он случился.
Firth is such a wonderful Darcy. Fabulous in every way.
I think the scene when she didn’t go to rosings as for “headache”and he went to check on her. How he was genuinely caring
Darcy's smile when watching Mr Collins' awkward missteps in the dance is, I think, his recognition that Elizabeth is a lady, in every sense of the word. She does not show annoyance or irritation, doe not act against Mr Collins, but rather smooths over the situation and gracefully gets him back on track--an exemplar of what the mistress of Pemberley would most certainly do, is it not?
I respectfully disagree. To me, Darcy is a little amused at Lizzie being stuck dancing with a man who is obviously a bit of an oaf. And Lizzie does seem to be uncomfortably self-conscious about what she believes Darcy/others must be thinking of the situation, and rather tersely instructs her partner, "Other way, Mr Collins!"
The book makes it clear that dancing with Mr Collins was mortifying and distressful for Lizzie: "The two first dances, however, brought a return of distress: they were dances of mortification. Mr. Collins, awkward and solemn, apologizing instead of attending, and often moving wrong without being aware of it, gave her all the shame and misery which a disagreeable partner for a couple of dances can give."
I think the movie plays up the irritation and embarrassment, rather than smooths it over.
Ah, love these insights, it's like chatting with a true fan 😊 I've always thought that Darcy is a caring character but socially uncomfortable (as opposed to awkward). It's enjoyable to revisit my favourite adaptation through your eyes.
After making my video, I definitly see that caring side of the character. Maybe it's Colin Firths interpretation and the way he delivers his acting skills that make it so for me.
I agree with your opinion that Darcy directed his speech to Elizabeth in the “turn around the room” scene. Also, he saw that Elizabeth is a good “walker” when she went to Netherfield on foot, so he teased her about waking later, but he also reveals within his tease that he actually thinks Elizabeth looks great while waking, he liked her figure when he saw her arriving at Netherfield, for her “figure appear to be best advantage when walking”.
Yes, I think this scene is great for bringing one of the implicit running gags of the book into sharper relief: that before their big fight at Hunsford, every time she crosses his path, he assumes she's doing it on purpose to try to throw herself at him. Why else would she hike three miles to visit her under-the-weather sister, drop what she was doing to walk in a circle with mean girl Caroline Bingley, or join a couple of Lucases to visit her smarmy cousin at his country parsonage? It's only gradually, over the course of the book, that he understands how genuinely responsive she is to having anyone, especially a loved one, want her company. So she has a bigger stake in the previous night's "if a friend asked you to change plans for them" argument than he initially realizes.
In the scene following the dinner at Pemberley, when he's back in the music room, reflecting on the evening, his expression changes, subtly, from pleasurable reflection to determination to, imo, ride to Lambton the next morning and propose again. He's thwarted only by Jane's distressing letter about Lydia.
Thanks for the interesting talks.
scene
Really interesting insight of Mr Darcy. If you do one on Elizabeth, it would be interesting if you took a deep dive in how she express so much of her feelings through her eyes. I've only watched the series twice, but noticed already first time how the Elizabeth really speaks with her eyes as well as the rest of the dialog. Like for example when Mr Darcy talks with Mr and Mrs Gardiner after being introduced. You see so well the surprise and confusion in her eyes. Jennifer Ehle does a marvelous job playing Lizzy.
I also love Darcy enjoying watching Lizzie dancing with Mr Collins. I think he sees the humor in it.
This adaptation is so beautiful and I love the cast and their interpretations!
I have a soft spot for the kiss at the end, but I sometimes wish for the final scene to be at Pemberley. Maybe Elizabeth watching her husband riding the grounds so the miniseries comes full circle. Eh, I can only dream. Love this video, I’m hoping for a video dedicated to Jennifer Ehle’s performance. I adore her interpretation of Lizzie. ❤
I’ve been thinking about some videos on the individual characters. Some would be more popular than others that’s for sure.
I’ve always thought that when Darcy watches Fitzwilliam and Lizzy at the piano, he’s feeling jealous because he’s not the one she’s spending time with with
He certainly is enjoying seeing Lizzy again.
I've always felt that the colonel liked her. He certainly seems more unhappy at the wedding than Caroline does?
Fitzwilliam seems like a lovey man. He seemed to enjoy Elizabeth's company quite a bit. I wonder if he was interested in her too?
I loved this series and agree it’s the best P&P adaption ever, but what a disappointing final episode! Not only were we robbed of Mrs Bennet’s reaction to Lizzie’s engagement, but also the delicious scenes when Darcy and Bingley have returned to Netherfield and are invited to dinner at Longbourne. After such a delightful feast of a series, I felt seriously cheated at the omission of my favourite scenes from the book!
And ..chapter 60 with that masterpeace brilliant qoat "A man who had felt less, might.". with the voice of Colin Frith. 😢
I have always thought that Elizabeth not telling her father about Darcys involvement in the Lydia/Wickham thing, is out of respect for Darcys "pride" and his position in society.He seems to be an introvert, and Mr Bennett is a good man, but never misses the opportunity to tease and provoke his wife. I think that Elizabeth knows that if she tells her father, he will eventually tell mrs Bennett. Witch will lead mrs Bennett to gossip to everyone and suck up to Darcy, witch he would hate. It would also be a constant reminder of Elizabeths "unfortunate family morals". Best do everything to keep this from Mrs Bennett, and let it be forgotten
I have no idea how many times I have watches this version of P&P, (at least twice a year since 1995), but I notice something new each time.
Thank you for doing another video! To me this one is all about the brilliance of Colin Firth. The guy moves maybe three facial muscles throughout the entire movie, yet he conveys disdain, astonishment, affection and more. (He never smiles until he's married!) He shows a very intelligent understanding of the book/script, and a truly professional desire to portray the innermost thoughts & feelings of his character. I have a low estimation of the intelligence of many actors, who would not be capable of Firth's subtlety. PS That kiss is a disaster! Since they clearly did not want to show any real kissing (maybe it would not have occurred?), they should have ended just before it.
You’re absolutely right on both counts 👍
Lovely videos, thank you so much for making them. Pride & Prejudice is one of my favourite novels, and the 1995 adaptation is, in my eyes, the best by far. About Mr. Darcy's smile at Lizzy's misfortune with Mr. Collins as a dance partner during the ball the Netherfield: I always thought he was comparing himself to Mr. Collins, perhaps thinking "I don't like to dance, but at least I *can* dance". And he knows she enjoys teasing and being witty, so he's enjoying the irony of seeing her stuck in a ridiculous condition from which her wits cannot save her. Moreover, Elizabeth usually chides Mr. Darcy for being proud and uncivil - but now she's showing her exasperation towards Mr. Collins for being an undeserving dance partner and company. Darcy may well be thinking "Who's the proud one now?" Delightful irony of this scene, and a small victory for him.
Thank you again for these wonderful analyses, I love revisiting this wonderful story and series.
I like your analysis. Spot on 👍
💯
Excellent insight. I have one interpretation of my own.
I interpreted the walking scene of Mr Darcy in hall as his satisfaction. He was satisfied watching how Elizabeth guarded Georgiana from her unpleasant past and how she comforts her. He is satisfied with his choice of perfect wife. And ofcourse he understood the change of behaviour of Lizzy towards him. That's why he got ready early morning and rode to Elizabeth. May be he wanted propose her again or invite her to Pemberley again, but the situation was not in his favour.
That's how I see it. He seems to be pondering her unexpected arrival back in his life and how well everything is going. He's happy to have her at Pemberley. His attention to his appearance the next morning makes me wonder if he was considering asking for her hand in marriage again.
I don't know whether the book says he was going to propose again when he went to see her that day, but I believe he was. That's why I feel extra sorry for him when he gets to the inn only to be foiled by the terrible news of Wickham's "elopement" with Lydia. His first marriage offer went down in flames, and his second never even got off the ground. Thank heavens, the third time was the charm!
Elizabeth is one of the few people that does not constantly busy herself with trying to cheer up Mr. Darcy. I believe it's her negative disposition that allows him to let his gentle side come out. And clearly she is not after his fortune.
Indeed. Elizabeth would marry for love, not money. She would be very happy to take a man who would love her enough to take her for a mere £50 a year. She would be very well pleased! Of course such a man could hardly be sensible and she could never marry a man who was out of his wits 😂
Re. Darcy & Bingley discussing their respective view of the world, you are RIGHT ON TARGET sir! I caught that little smile of Darcy's at the end of his observation of Bingley! What a crafty player Darcy is!
I still find it interesting how Darcy races to change from the swim in order to catch Elizabeth before she leaves and his manner is so sweet to her - surely it is only a few days since she has told him that she would not consider his proposal if he was the last man on earth! He really did take what she said to heart! His pride was exposed and he didn't like what he saw. I find that scene at the carriage and as they walk around the grounds at Pemberley to be the most tender. Thanks for that hint about the thumb rub! It's there for sure. I love it that she turns in the carriage and looks at him as they leave. And then the scene where she sings and plays - she sings a love song, right? So great.
it wasn't days, it was months if you read the book I believe
Yes, right.@@LuLeMen
The rush to get back to Elizabeth showed how keen he was to spend time & make a good impression on Elizabeth.
At this point, I have no idea how many times I have watched this BBC series. With each viewing I seem to catch new details that simply add to the experience as a whole. Like many, the series has become somewhat of a comfort watch for me. Seeing someone else catch those subtle glances, details, and minute changes in each facial expression gives me a sense of happiness, as if I am watching with a friend who is paying just as much attention as I am. It is rare that I find anyone willing to watch the 2005 adaptation with me, let alone the full BBC series! It is rarely covered in the grand scheme of reaction and analysis videos on RUclips, so to find someone who loves the series as much as I do, enough to take the time to make videos such as you have, frankly it covers a sorely overlooked section of media and I have very much enjoyed your videos on the subject. Thank you for making these and I hope you continue to do so. Many thanks and well wishes from a fellow Austen and 1995 BBC P&P fan!
Thank you 🙏
I'll rabbit away about P&P till the cows come home, if people will indulge me. 🤣
Each of the characters? Yes please!!
Now there’s a happy thought indeed 🙂
I think the "awkward" kiss is due to the bumpy ride and large brims on their hats.
Thank you for your videos ! I’m also a big fan of Pride and prejudice (the book) and of course of the 1995 version. I have a comment on Darcy’s behaviour that shows, for me, the acting talent of Firth : when he is uncomfortable with Lizzie (trying to be amiable), he plays with his ring. It happens at least twice : when he comes to discuss with her when she is playing the piano while talking to Fitzgerald, and when he asks if he can introduce his sister to her in the park of Pemberley. I think this detail is important because we can feel that he has to occupy his hands with something because he is so nervous.
Ps : I’m sorry if there are mistakes in my post, I’m French and far from being fluent in English ! I have read the book both in French and in English and I like so much the English accent of Firth and Ehle (never watch it in another language!)
Your English is very good. Better than my school boy French 🤣
Yes the ring. He does use it as a soothing security I think.
Interesting that in the recent adaptation of Sanditon Alexander Colbourne also fiddles with his signet ring. An homage to Darcy, perhaps?
In this adaptation we are allowed to see as an audience for the first time a more realistic interpretation of Darcy's character. He is clearly attracted to Elizabeth firstly as a woman but as he spends more time in her company he realizes she has an intellect and humor equal to his own. Colin and also Jennifer can say more with a look and facial expression than words could ever express. The direction and screenplay in this adaptation are nothing short of perfection. A bit of a tangent but there's a clip where Lizzie is out for a walk and she stops to look at some birds flying away from her. For me was put in to suggest to us the audience that she has a longing to leave her home and find another life for herself. It's very cleverly done and I believe a very important little scene in telling of the story and what she's thinking. Again Tudor thanks again for your interesting incites. Keep up the good work.
Oh I missed that clip of Lizzy looking at the birds. It would indeed reveal a side of her character!
This interpretation of birds flying is very interesting. Just like when they both walk together at Pemberley and the ribbons on Lizzy's bonnet almost seem to want to hug Mr Darcy. I believe that this movement was intentional, to convey to us that this was also Lizzy's desire at that moment. There are several moments like this that delight us every time we watch an episode of the series, in my opinion.
I absolutely agree that Darcy’s character is not one of severe pomposity. I think that particular prize goes to Mr Collins. Most of Darcy’s true thoughts and feelings are portrayed through his facial expressions & gestures, what he says, I feel, reveals very little about his true character. I love your videos, please keep them coming.
Ah yes. The pompous Mr Collins. Let’s reserve all pomposity for him 🤣
Thank you Tudor for this. My wife and I love Pride & Prejudice. The acting is awesome.
Yes I agree. I never get tired of this adaptation. Every episode of the six part series is a joy to watch.
Mr Darcy is a person who most of the time has a serious countenance. However, I see him as a person who is very close to his friends. This can be seen in the relationship he establishes with Mr Bingley, they are quite different but Mr Darcy manages the differences in their behaviour very well. His upbringing doesn't allow him to tell Miss Bingley what he really thinks of her and her sharp comments about Lizzy, for example. I've seen this series many times and re-watched the special scenes a lot, so perhaps I had already noticed almost all of these details about Mr Darcy that this video highlights in such an extraordinary way. I found it very interesting to see the different interpretations that fans like me gave to his smile as he walked through the hall at Pemberley, after having received Lizzy and her aunt and uncle that afternoon. I always thought that the expression on his face simply reflected his happiness at realising that Miss Bennett was more receptive to his presence and conviviality. But it's interesting to realise that there may be other reasons for that mysterious smile. In my opinion, this series is so special which justifies the fact that almost 30 years after it first aired, it still encourages a legion of fans to comment and watch these videos with total enthusiasm. I'm a fan of this channel, I really empathise with the topics and the way they are presented. You can note that it's made by a true fan. Cheers !
Ah yes, the "Can you not?"... Mrs Gardiner knew all along 🙂
That’s what I’ve always assumed 👍
Everyone needs an Aunt Gardiner in their lives!
This was such a lovely video essay. The more times you watch P&P '95, the more you catch those warm/tender moments of Darcy. The man is not supposed to be easy to read, especially not for Lizzy, so those enigmatic smiles fit perfectly. The other little scene where we see it is when Darcy spots Lizzy playing with his big dog down on the lawn at Netherfield after he comes out of the bath. It's reminiscent of his small smile when he first runs into her when she shows up at Netherfield, windblown and mud-covered. It's been noted that there are 9 instances of Darcy smiling in the book, and almost always it's in response to something Lizzy has said or done. And here's what the book says about her thoughts when she sees his portrait at Pemberly: "...and she beheld a striking resemblance to Mr. Darcy, with such a smile over the face as she remembered to have sometimes seen when he looked at her."
It's been such a long time since I've actually read it that I'd forgotten about any instances of Darcy smiling. I'm definitely going to have to give it a re-read. Maybe also do a video comparing the book to the '95 version. Interesting.....
More amazing P&P content! I am loving this.
Colin Firth's subtle brand of acting is perfect for a character who is mostly so reserved. Those little glimmers of smiles feel so well deserved and exciting when they do happen.
I would love to see a video on Jennifer Ehle's performance. Her expressions always make me laugh. They are always so relatable!
I’m glad you’re tagging along. A video on Elizabeth (Jennifer Ehle) might be just the ticket 👍
Whatever else he is, or may be, we know Darcy is a gentle and loving older brother from his treatment of Georgiana. Even Wickham admits to this fact when first talking with Elizabeth. There is already that little hint in the narrative that Darcy may not be what we think him at first. Part of the joy of the novel is discovering the hidden depths of Mr. Darcy.
I just love the deep dive into Darcy's character, and Colin Firth's brilliantly subtle portrayal!
@sapphiregamgee. When I was reading this novel at school in Eng.Lit. Class I was baffled by Darcy’s character. So contradictory. I couldn’t believe that a man could change like that - despite his great efforts to save Lydia from her fate. But this dramatisation allowed me to solve the mystery. It was the scenes in and around Pemberly that revealed the truth. The magnificence and responsibilities of his sudden inheritance, at such a very young age aren’t obvious to us modern readers. But so clearly understood by Jane Austen’s own public that there was no need for her to explain. Darcy was first-class marriage bait -and he was so young and lacking in mentors. By the time he turned up in Hertfordshire he would have already been “got at “ by the richest families in the North of England. There would have been shed - loads of flattery and attempts to gain his attention. Enough to sicken him. He saw insincerity everywhere. Add to that his burden of guilt about his failure to see what was happening to his ward, his very young sister - and the last minute rescue. And he was already lonely - grieving for his wonderful father. Much of this we can pick up from the old house-keeper’s conversation with the Gardners on their visit to Pemberley.and the magnificence of the estate. It was Darcy’s love for Elizabeth that began his return to trust and normality. She was so searingly honest - though her candour shocked and hurt him at first.
On re-watching this marvellous series more recently I have also looked for signs that Darcy isn't only the proud and reserved man he appears to be in the first half.
It struck me that part of the reason for his behaviour is that Wickham's designs were in the recent past and with Wickham in the vicinity Darcy was reminded of this painful episode. Not something to make him want to be the life and soul of the party!
I love these videos. I believe that scene where he and the dogs are walking down the hall he is thinking he is finally getting somewhere with Lizzie. He knows she actually does like him for the first time but it also is that he basically got rid of the nasty sister to his friend. Kind of what you said AND the fact that things are going his way with Lizzie. Anyway I absolutely love this series. Won't watch any other of Pride and Prejudice this is by far the best and so rewatchable.
This version seems to me to be the truest adaptation. I may be wrong of course but it brings the story to life for me 👍
I too prefer this adaptation compared to the Keira Knightley movie where I found myself irritated rather than amused by the other sisters@@TudorSmith
The 1995 version is the best. There are more than just one reason why. It is the longest version and because of that they were able to place more scenes into the movie from the book. They really did a great job of reproducing the time period, cloths, dances, food, buildings, accents, etc.. The actors were unknown at the time (at least here in America) so your mind wasnt placing them in any other movie. You could get completely absorbed into the movie. It was well done all the way around and thats why people are still talking about it today. Its a shame that books arent made into movies like this one. They should be made into how ever long it takes without filler. No set time ending. It ends when the story is done. JMO.
Yep, take the time to tell the story, not a summary of a good novel.
One of my favorite Darcy tender moments is during Darcy, Georgiana, and Bingley’s visit to the Inn at Lambton. Lizzy is talking to Bingley and Georgiana steps away to talk to Darcy. The way Darcy tilts his head towards his sister and the tender look on his face tells the beautiful and complete love he has for her.
It’s interesting isn’t it how all those subtle acting parts that are carried out in the background are still so important to telling the story. I tend to watch Mr & Mrs Gardiner whenever they are on screen as they have some wonderfully interacted parts too.
I’ll have to pay attention particularly to the Gardiners next time I watch. I’ve noticed some of their looks and glances before but I’ve never particularly looked out for it. I know some people complain that Mrs. Gardiner is cast too old, but her acting is so superb I still feel like she nails the part.
Thank you, Tudor Smith, for this stellar Darcy video. I find your acute observations both intriguing and entertaining. In a film world replete with miscast Austen characters, Colin Firth's performance as Mr. Darcy is one I think Jane Austen herself would smile upon. And after watching your videos, I'm left with an even greater appreciation for Firth's acting ability and the perfection of his art.
Thank you 🙏
That kiss....I watch programme about the making of PP 1995. Due to filming at locations they filmed it backwards. The first senses filmed were the weddings. They'd been on set a couple of days and new to working together when they film the wedding and have the kiss ❤
Hi! First of all, thank you for your videos! I discovered them only a few days ago and it made me want to watch the 1995 series all over again!
Regarding Darcy's gentle and playful behaviour towards Bingley, I always saw it as him acting like an older brother rather than a friend. Darcy enjoys Bingley's happiness and I think there's fondness in the way he smiles at Bingley during the ball scene or when he playfully banters with him later on. From what I remember, Bingley is a few years younger than Darcy and they've been friends for long enough to be comfortable with each other, so Darcy must've known Bingley when he was still young, therefore his affection for Bingley, at least at the beginning, is not the one you share with a friend that you see as an equal, but rather one that you'd have for someone younger that you care for and want to look after. In that regard, the evolution of their relationship makes sense: Darcy gradually learns to see Bingley as a grown man capable of making his own decisions, rather than a child he needs to protect from the world. I'd go further and say this original behaviour towards Bingley could have played a part in Caroline's illusion that she understands Darcy's character. They both tried to keep Bingley from making unwise decisions and reprimanded his naivety, but Caroline failed to realize that, contrary to her, Darcy wasn't doing it solely because he didn't want his party or family to be affiliated with the aftermath of Bingley's poor decisions, but rather because he genuinely thought those decisions could be dangerous for his friend. Caroline didn't care for her brother's happiness, while I think Darcy did, but was blinded by his own vision of what happiness must be. But from Caroline's point of view, she perceived Darcy's action as similar to hers and concluded that they had similar motives. It must have encouraged her affection for him and her hopes that he might like her.
Later, when Lizzie literally roasts him alive and he has to reflect on himself, he starts to change the way he sees everything, including his friend Bingley. He realises that Bingley is not the child he met years ago, but a young man who needs and deserve to have his opinions and choices respected. I'm sure Darcy would never cease to look after and advise Bingley, but just like an older sibling learns to do when the younger ones grow up, he would leave more space for Bingley to grow and be his own person. I'd like to add that Darcy was probably comforted in his choice of keeping Bingley and Jane apart because, only a few years back, he saved his own younger sister from ending up in Wickham's claws, and I think in his head it comforted him into thinking he knew how to protect the people he cares for. He failed to realise, however, that the situation was completely different regarding the feelings shared by Bingley and Jane, and that Bingley is not a 15yo girl lol.
Well, that's just my opinion! Nice video again, and see ya! =D
What a lovely addition to the comments section. I love your analysis. It’s so spot on and helps me/us to see a clearer motivation for Darcy’s action.
Yes, watching 3 different videos made me bring out my old DVD and even buy an updated film 25-year anniversary DVD.
That’s a very good analysis and something I haven’t thought of before. Thank you.
No man's glance ever goes below a ladie's chin , despite the cut of the dress.
Yes I agree that Darcy is repressing a smile when Elizabeth arrives on foot. Funny!
I think when Mr. Collin's makes his faux pas Darcy is simply a human being enjoying a few moments of observing absurdity. Mr. Collins is a bit of an oaf. I think Darcy's smile was not so much laughing AT him as simply caught by the moment, an omg smile...and a bit of realization that Lizzie was mortified and i see his smile as also a bit of a twinkle.
I reckon you might just be right.
In the book, when Lizzie is staying at Netherfield, Darcy is already falling in love with her, but he is very clear that the Bennet's station would prevent the girls making good marriages - that he cannot afford to fall in love with her, and her leaving Netherfield can't come soon enough. I think its also important to keep in mind that Lady Catherine wanted him to marry her daughter, and Bingley's sister wanted to marry him herself and it's implied she wanted Bingley to marry Georgiana, making them one big (probably not very happy) family. I think a lot of the subtlety and surprise about Darcy's reactions and growing gentleness to Lizzie is that they are reluctant - "against my better judgement" I think he says. Part of what I love about Darcy's character development is his transition from his actions being dictated by what "society" would say he should think about the Bennet's and who he should marry (a lady of equal social status) to genuine compassion and understanding for what Lydia's actions were going to mean for all the sisters, that it would literally ruin their entire family, and that he could do something about it because as stupid and foolish as Lydia was, Jane and Elizabeth didn't deserve to suffer from it. It's a transition from head-led actions to heart-led actions on Darcy's part, in my opinion!
P.S. I am really enjoying your videos! Just discovered them, and I appreciate how open you are to everyone's feedback! I know I analyze every motion of every scene when I watch this adaptation. And, as an American, I would say that the servant at the inn when Lydia and Kitty meet Lizzie doesn't sound very American to me, the cadence isn't quite what I would expect from an American.... Just my 2 cents on that!
Thanks for your wonderful comment. It’s quite insightful. I do my best to get things right but it’s not always spot in.
We also have to wonder how many of the micro smiles from Darcy are actually micro smiles of Colin Firth.
I’m sure there must have been a bit of that.
I’ve got to say, Big Brother, that I really enjoyed this video. Thanks.
Glad you enjoyed it
I can't imagine anyone coming to a site dedicated to such a beautiful rendition of Pride and Prejudice and behave with incivility. Quite right to block them. I come here to enjoy the calm, peaceful civility and enjoyable conversations. Now back to Pride and Prejudice. Some of my favorite scenes are when Lizzie meets Georgiana the first few times. I love how welcoming Georgina is to Lizzie compared to Caroline and Mrs. Hurst. It's obvious that Darcy has spoken quite a bit to Georgiana about Lizzie because Georgiana has longed to finally meet her and says that Darcy has praised her skills at the piano forte. Lizzy seems to bond with her instantly, to the point of being upset when Caroline made a crude comment about Mr Wickham which could have been hurtful to Georgiana. Georgiana is perfectly charming. I understand that actress is part of the famous Fox family of actors. I have long enjoyed Laurence Fox in the detective series Lewis.
You can’t please all the people all of the time right? If it’s not for you, just click away. There’s no need to be unkind.
I believe Emilia Fox got her first starring role when playing Georgianna (I might be wrong though). She’s the daughter of Joanna David who played Mrs Gardiner. Edward Fox is her father 👍
@@TudorSmith I love Mrs. Gardiner. She so lovely, as is Mr. Gardiner. I had no idea that actress is her real life mother. I learn so much here. Thank you. I've seen Edward Fox in many fine films, as well as other members of the Fox family. Again, thank you.
I love when Georgina says “I should have loved to have a sister!” (Wink wink Lizzie, she means you!!)
@@cl6998 I think Georgiana became close to both her sister-in-law Lizzie and her pretty much sister-in-law Jane. Those three women would have gotten along famously.
The ball at Netherfield. Again sir, I believe you've scored another direct hit. If I were Darcy I would have burst out in hoots of laughter! Darcy, more gentlemanly than I, restrains himself admirably with the slightest of smiles.
And when you see Colin Firth deliver that subtle smile and shake of his head, it helps to see the character has amiable right from the offset. It’s almost like you’d be rooting for him right from the start and trying to get all the other characters to understand what you already perceive. I think the next time I rewatch the series that’s what I’ll be doing 🙂
Melting chocolate fire guard”😄.. priceless, Mr. S. This instalment is chock full of goodies, and so many great comments followed.
Thoughts: in his response to Collins & Elizabeth dancing, we see him begin to relax in ball settings & enjoy them. His exchange with Bingley, re: the “misanthrope vs. the pushover”shows Darcy’s affectionate
banter; if Bingley had seen his
expression, I think he’d have taken note and not heard it literally. Your followup on the scene where Elizabeth walks to Pemberly was spot-on.. your use of the term “cheekiness” can apply to all 3 of these scenes. The commenter who laid out all the demands & challenges of his recent past, & present, did a fine job on important factors; I see his light side as returning, not newly sprouted, in the scenes above. Points that you made re: the surprise visit w/the Gardiners are so endearing! Yes to all😊.
The piano scene not only shows burgeoning attraction, but Elizabeth’s increasing perception of his facets. Darcy’s “we don’t perform for strangers” has a parallel in Persuasion: Wentworth agreeing with Anne that she “isn’t a card player”. D is openly speaking TO E about herself, without awkwardness.
Many American fans may not grasp the full extent of Darcy’s responsibilty FOR Wickham- how that actually works. D would attempt rescue of any girl that W endangered, no matter his own interest or lack thereof. W resents D’s proprietary obligations, yet takes advantage of them, in equal measure. When D hears Jane’s news from E, he’s beside himself on many counts- Firth was magnificent in that scene.
The “2nd proposal”: my take is that Darcy is suffused with deep humble happiness for the first time in his life, and Elizabeth is -briefly- a bit too hard on herself, yet essentially radiant with joy.
The kiss: yes, the double wedding & departure was unfairly hasty & awkward..😯decidedly odd when more is due to us viewers. We should have seen supporting players at the nuptials, and the newlyweds themselves; and no one can hold a kiss in a moving carriage! The concept of forward motion is lovely, but poorly executed here.
Ehle & Firth belong to a set of actors who can perform wonders with their eyes & their hands (Michael Kitchen & Josette Simon, among others); if those talents don’t come naturally, they’re quite a challenge to acquire.
Thanks for these exquisite forays into P&P!!😃😍
Thank you for making these series. They're very enjoyable to watch and I love your comments and your clips included😂❤
Glad you like them!
"I might wonder why with so little effort at civility I'm rejected" had me laughing out loud xD
🤣
In the scene where he is needling Bingley a bit I also enjoyed when one of the sisters bantered to Darcey smilingly, "You see, we are not afraid of you."
The softening of his face when he says gently "I would not have you so." I really appreciated that.
Yes that scene is another that shows Darcy has kindness in him and is not considered standoffish (if I can use that word) around those who are close to him.
Okay two thoughts from my end:
1) at the Netherfield ball that little smile of Darcy in seeing Lizzy dance with mr Collins seems to me to kind of mirror of that moment Bingley and Darcy had at the Meryton dance. I think we should remember that Darcy is supposed to be totally clueless to Lizzy's animosity towards him. He is used to women fawning over him constantly and even though Elizabeth certainly doesn't fawn, I don't think it actually really enters his head that any woman could actually hate him as much as Lizzy at that point does. When he proposes to Elizabeth the first time he completely expects her to accept his proposal after all. So my take is - and this makes that scene even more funny in a way - that where Elizabeth is completely vexed by mr Collins, then sees mr Darcy and then thinks 'Oh gods and now HE'S here too!' - At the same time I think mr Darcy might actually interpret that look from Elizabeth as the type of embarassment that results from being embarrassed in front of your crush. Or maybe he thinks 'I've been there my girl' - thinking about other awkward partners he's had to stand up with in the past, that made him dislike dancing with strangers so much, maybe? In any case for him it might feel like the same type of 'look of recognition' that he shared with Bingley earlier at the Meryton dance. And soon afterwards he asks her to dance himself, maybe thinking 'I got your sign girl, I'm here to rescue you!' Of course to Lizzy it's totally different! 😂
2) The late night hall walk at Pemberley was always supposed to have been about him thinking of Lizzy. Not for nothing do we hear the tones of the same song she sang at the piano earlier that night. He probably wakes up the next morning with that song in his head 🥰
Maybe that animosity, the strength of character attracted Darcy to Lizzie even more. Whereas it was obvious other women are attracted not just to his power but also his fortune. Here is a woman who was not taking advantage of his wealth. Perfect, he would know she would always be honest but not disingenuous in her feelings for him. He had earned her respect & true love. Jane Austen in all her novels did this in spades. True love always wins. This was her best novel.
Again, wonderful! These tiny calm details make this adaptation so special. The guessing of the thoughts behind each face are making the screen play so interesting. Not like all these movies that reveal every emotion in a huge gestic and expression and shut out.
Don’t you hate it when the characters tell you what they’re about to do, do it, then tell you what they’ve done. C’mon, we’re not simpletons 🤣
It’s so much more intriguing when an actor applies subtleties I think.