You have to ask how much durability you really need. I have a 60L sack in 1000D Cordura that I bought in the 1970s. I used it for multiple seasons as a technical climbing sack, mostly on abrasive granite, before relegating it to day sack duties. It has been used for literally thousands of days in the hills, and is still going strong with little visible wear. It will see me out. So clearly unless you are involved in a highly abrasive activity like canyoneering the 500D will do you just fine. Though having said that, a typical lightweight pack only uses 1.5 sq meters of fabric, so you will only be saving 200g or so. As for damaging your clothes, any well designed pack should surely be using something smoother like an Oxford for the back and the straps? These are low abrasion areas where heavy Cordura would be overkill. That's what my old pack uses and it has lasted fine.
I’ve been looking at some rifle bags. Most say they are made out of 600D. I’ve bought 3 of them off Amazon. 2 reputable brands, 1 an Amazon brand. The two reputable are 600D PVC, and 600D polyester. The polyester feels considerably tougher/stronger/more heavy duty, yet the PVC version is “supposed” to be “better”. The Amazon brand one is marketed as 500D Cordura, but feels like absolute trash. So my question is how do you even verify what the product is actually made out of, because clearly things can be marketed as whatever they want and not actually be said material…..
This is all true. Hard to tell. Best course of action I’d say is to email customer service to verify but that might not yield any better info. The reputable brands will know for sure.
Thanks JB great video - have you thought about a 1000D with a 'sacrificial anode' of a 210 stitched on the back, plus a matching shirt pair to avoid unnecessary movement or chafing?
Bomb proof!! No issues. My 26L GR2 shows no wear. My 34L shooter has been abused, no problems. My Rucker 4.0 was used during an event this weekend and it also is showing no signs. All are 500D 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@@JBOutside1 How intense are these events? I am new to all this Goruck stuff and quite honestly never spent more than $30 on a bag before this. Didn't realise how big of a communtiy there was surrounding rucks and backpacks.
@@JustFluxz the Rucker was thrown around, carried a 20lb plate (normally 30lb) and dragged around. This wasn’t the most intense event I’ve done but I’m confident the 500D is just as capable for anything I plan to do. It’s my preferred fabric currently.
Without any experience it is difficult to describe. Best advice I have is to research or ask the company website where you bought it to see what they used in the design. Otherwise, someone with both fabrics in a bag design should be able to tell you by feel. Hope this helps.
@@JBOutside1 I'll do my best, I bought it from Amazon claiming its 1000D cordura, but the weave noticeably much larger compared to 1000d I've seen on pictures online. Is the weave supposed to be larger or smaller on 1000d compared to 500? Or is it that an inaccurate way of differentiating?
@@RIVERAEDGE not an expert, but I believe the number corresponds most directly to the thickness of the individual fibers - which translates inversely to the density of the weave. So 1000d = thick, more robust fibers = wider weave / more rugged hand; at the other end of the spectrum, something like 210d (as demonstrated in the video) = finer fibers = smoother, denser weave (yet more susceptible to wear over time). Hope that helps; I’m learning all this for the first time myself.
I have a GR2 with 1000D exterior with 210D back and straps. Perfect combo. Soft to carry. Will last a lifetime otherwise. It's flawless and durable as all hell. It's a be all end all bag that I plan on having forever. I use it for everything. EDC, hiking, deployments, overnight travel, you name it, it goes.
one of my only issues with my GR1 is that wearing it with a tank or w/o a shirt can chafe you pretty quickly, especially on the straps to your shoulders.
@@JBOutside1 Im searching for bag to use for a gym bag / multi purpose but i want it to be durable. Some of what Im looking at is 600D polyester and another is 1000d Nylon …just didn’t know if there was a big difference. Not sure what X-pac or VX is…
@@jawbonelive3813 gotcha. It will really come down to feel in my opinion. Both are water resistant and durable. More about who is making the bag and the level of detail in manufacturing.
Excellent video, this question of material is asked too often and the video explains it well enough. I do wonder, I too just ordered the GR2 34L in black Multicam, I’m sure it’s just a matter of time before the 1000D/500D start coming with the same back and strap denier as the Rucker 3.0. It honestly is very durable for the time I’ve had my 3.0, and would be even slicker for the edc/travel based rucks.
That's a good point. If I know anything about GORUCK they don't often change things rapidly. I suppose that's a possibility that they'll start using 210D on straps in all the rucks. But then again it does change the aesthetic of the bag so I doubt it.
@@JBOutside1 there’s just nothing like a 1000D broken in GR. Excited to receive my 500D 26L, if it feels as close to a broken in 1000D it saved me 8 months of breaking in haha
@@JBOutside1 yup. I’ve owned the 1000d GR1 and the new Bullet 15 with the 500/210. My ideal bag would be the Bullet… just larger (I don’t want the laptop compartment of the GR1).
I always thought of higher denier like higher thread count material. I have some 1600D stuff and it's actually a smoother face due to the higher thread count textile. Anything with a higher/denser thread count will be more durable. Even the poly non woven stuff in a higher denier is thicker, not necessarily more abrasive.
Do you recommend the white cordura fabric for backdrop shoot? Like they said less wrinkles if the fabric is thicker and heavier. Im confused now if I should buy. The 3 yard of cordura fabric.
@@JBOutside1 i have under armour UA UNDENIABLE storm 3 Its 30l It fit laptop 17inch , keyboard , laptop fan and cloth But now i need bigger to take more cloths I cant find same style top loader but 40-45L Any suggestion or how to search ?
@@JBOutside1 nice one, thank you, I got my first goruck today (gr2 26l 500D) and went for my first ruck, I just put a 22lb barbell weight in the elastic pouch, it carried alright but would you reccomend a ruck plate instead? Have you had any issue rucking with the 500D one? I thought it would be substantial for rucking as well as using for EDC and travel but now I'm doubting myself!
@@Chivalrousdrake before the Rucker was introduced I rucked with standard bricks from Home Depot (lots of rucking 101 info in my other video). The Rucker is really the best solution if you’re going to do a lot of rucking. That said, the GR2 will work and a plate will be a good solution. The plate for the GR1 is what fits your ruck the best. The bad news is that the Rucker takes a separate plate. You can use the Rucker plate in the GR2 but it won’t be as secure. Check out my “Rucking 101” and “Rucker” videos for some more detail.
The answer is yes. How much, I’m not sure. Since these bags are slightly different designs it would not have been completely fair to directly compare. I think in the larger bags like the GR2s going with the 500d is the way to go because of all the layers of fabric in the bag design.
There is a very slight difference in weight. The more material, the more weight savings. I think in a bag like any of the GR2s the savings of having 500D is noticeable, but not dramatically. I haven't weighed bags to compare but if I had to guess it would be well under 1 lb difference. The feel of 500D is better also for the more layered bags like the GR2.
@@makcz944 Dang, you’re good. I weighed both. 25% savings. While not an exact match weighing the SK21 (2.4 lbs) and GR1 (3.2 lbs) I did see a significant difference.
I’m not a fabric expert but I’m 99% sure it’s not in this application. It looks like that’s a separate coating that is specifically added to certain types of fabric.
![Eminem - Temporary (feat. Skylar Grey) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZaK9Wi5ho0o/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for taking the time to do this. A lot of companies are moving away from 100d!
You bet! I am seeing a lot of other fabrics which is a shame the 1000D is a tank!
You have to ask how much durability you really need. I have a 60L sack in 1000D Cordura that I bought in the 1970s. I used it for multiple seasons as a technical climbing sack, mostly on abrasive granite, before relegating it to day sack duties. It has been used for literally thousands of days in the hills, and is still going strong with little visible wear. It will see me out. So clearly unless you are involved in a highly abrasive activity like canyoneering the 500D will do you just fine.
Though having said that, a typical lightweight pack only uses 1.5 sq meters of fabric, so you will only be saving 200g or so.
As for damaging your clothes, any well designed pack should surely be using something smoother like an Oxford for the back and the straps? These are low abrasion areas where heavy Cordura would be overkill. That's what my old pack uses and it has lasted fine.
Good stuff
I’ve been looking at some rifle bags. Most say they are made out of 600D. I’ve bought 3 of them off Amazon. 2 reputable brands, 1 an Amazon brand. The two reputable are 600D PVC, and 600D polyester. The polyester feels considerably tougher/stronger/more heavy duty, yet the PVC version is “supposed” to be “better”. The Amazon brand one is marketed as 500D Cordura, but feels like absolute trash. So my question is how do you even verify what the product is actually made out of, because clearly things can be marketed as whatever they want and not actually be said material…..
This is all true. Hard to tell. Best course of action I’d say is to email customer service to verify but that might not yield any better info. The reputable brands will know for sure.
Sad
This guy's bag collection is similar to my shoe collection, great vid!
Thanks for watching! Yeah, it's a problem 😜
Excellent review, exactly what I was looking for. 👏🤜🤛💪
greetings from Argentina 👋
Awesome, thank you! Hola!
Nicely done and said, thanks. Looking forward to the Kaidan review too.
Thanks! Me too!
Thanks JB great video - have you thought about a 1000D with a 'sacrificial anode' of a 210 stitched on the back, plus a matching shirt pair to avoid unnecessary movement or chafing?
Great idea
Looking forward to sew a custom jacket and judging fabric weight thru a screen makes things hard lol, the video was very useful though
Thanks! Haha
What a lineup!🤩, man that Mc Rucker 1.0 and that gr0 👍👍killer
I think I’m finally ready to sell the 1.0 if you’re interested. Finally time to thin the heard a bit.
How is the 500D holding up? I am interested in the 26L GR2 but I'd like to hope this bag would last most of my life considering the price lol.
Bomb proof!! No issues. My 26L GR2 shows no wear. My 34L shooter has been abused, no problems. My Rucker 4.0 was used during an event this weekend and it also is showing no signs. All are 500D 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@@JBOutside1 How intense are these events? I am new to all this Goruck stuff and quite honestly never spent more than $30 on a bag before this. Didn't realise how big of a communtiy there was surrounding rucks and backpacks.
@@JustFluxz the Rucker was thrown around, carried a 20lb plate (normally 30lb) and dragged around. This wasn’t the most intense event I’ve done but I’m confident the 500D is just as capable for anything I plan to do. It’s my preferred fabric currently.
Thanks JB!
No problem!
How can you tell the difference between 1000 and 500 Denier? I have a jacket in cordura and I am unsure on the denier level
Without any experience it is difficult to describe. Best advice I have is to research or ask the company website where you bought it to see what they used in the design. Otherwise, someone with both fabrics in a bag design should be able to tell you by feel. Hope this helps.
@@JBOutside1 I'll do my best, I bought it from Amazon claiming its 1000D cordura, but the weave noticeably much larger compared to 1000d I've seen on pictures online. Is the weave supposed to be larger or smaller on 1000d compared to 500? Or is it that an inaccurate way of differentiating?
@@RIVERAEDGE not an expert, but I believe the number corresponds most directly to the thickness of the individual fibers - which translates inversely to the density of the weave. So 1000d = thick, more robust fibers = wider weave / more rugged hand; at the other end of the spectrum, something like 210d (as demonstrated in the video) = finer fibers = smoother, denser weave (yet more susceptible to wear over time). Hope that helps; I’m learning all this for the first time myself.
I have a GR2 with 1000D exterior with 210D back and straps. Perfect combo. Soft to carry. Will last a lifetime otherwise. It's flawless and durable as all hell. It's a be all end all bag that I plan on having forever. I use it for everything. EDC, hiking, deployments, overnight travel, you name it, it goes.
Right on! 👊🏻
one of my only issues with my GR1 is that wearing it with a tank or w/o a shirt can chafe you pretty quickly, especially on the straps to your shoulders.
I can see that.
Super informative
Glad you liked it
Is there a big difference in bags made with polyester vs nylon? What’s your take on that?
Are you asking about X-pac/VX type stuff vs the Cordura type?
@@JBOutside1 Im searching for bag to use for a gym bag / multi purpose but i want it to be durable. Some of what Im looking at is 600D polyester and another is 1000d Nylon …just didn’t know if there was a big difference. Not sure what X-pac or VX is…
@@jawbonelive3813 gotcha. It will really come down to feel in my opinion. Both are water resistant and durable. More about who is making the bag and the level of detail in manufacturing.
Excellent video, this question of material is asked too often and the video explains it well enough. I do wonder, I too just ordered the GR2 34L in black Multicam, I’m sure it’s just a matter of time before the 1000D/500D start coming with the same back and strap denier as the Rucker 3.0. It honestly is very durable for the time I’ve had my 3.0, and would be even slicker for the edc/travel based rucks.
That's a good point. If I know anything about GORUCK they don't often change things rapidly. I suppose that's a possibility that they'll start using 210D on straps in all the rucks. But then again it does change the aesthetic of the bag so I doubt it.
@@JBOutside1 there’s just nothing like a 1000D broken in GR. Excited to receive my 500D 26L, if it feels as close to a broken in 1000D it saved me 8 months of breaking in haha
How do both handle water? More specifically rain? Thanks! For context my 1000D has had no issues even in a deluge
@@Chambros703 haha, yeah I think it’s about the same. Lived in feel from free, 500D
@@Chambros703 I haven’t had the 500D bag soaked yet but I wouldn’t expect much of a difference. Especially new.
I’d like to see a slick 26L GR1 with the 210 back panel. At that point the 500 vs 1000 discussion doesn’t matter.
Yeah maybe, the feel of the bag is dramatic all-around with these two materials.
@@JBOutside1 yup. I’ve owned the 1000d GR1 and the new Bullet 15 with the 500/210. My ideal bag would be the Bullet… just larger (I don’t want the laptop compartment of the GR1).
is 600D CORDURA® Eco polyester and 600d recycled polyester are same?
which one is most robust?
I’m not familiar with the 600s
I always thought of higher denier like higher thread count material. I have some 1600D stuff and it's actually a smoother face due to the higher thread count textile. Anything with a higher/denser thread count will be more durable. Even the poly non woven stuff in a higher denier is thicker, not necessarily more abrasive.
Cool! Thanks!
1000 d is needed for plate carriers
I would agree
Thanks!
No problem!
why i can't find information about 700d? i only have pouches and backpacks in 700d
Not sure. I don't have any experience with 700D
@@JBOutside1 only info i can find from the manufacurer: it combines the strengh of 1000D and the lightweight of 500D
@@ravingbadger Seems obvious by the number...haha. But how does it feel to compare? What specifically have you found out of 700D?
@@JBOutside1 it is highly abrasive resistent and tear resistent - i can't compare it cause i have no experience with other cordura materials
What about 700D v. 1000D?
The possibilities are endless
How to tell visually when buying online new or used if it’s the 500d or the 1000d version, is there any indication or label tags on the pack??
No. You can try to find out when it was purchased. That might narrow it down. The color and when it was bought could tell you.
@@JBOutside1 Okay when was the 500d version first released for their packs, and are they discontinued the 1000d version??
@@freecanadaland 500D wasn't available until like a year ago.
@@JBOutside1 Is there a big difference in price between the 500d and the 1000d?
@@freecanadaland they were sold at the same price.
Is the Rucker 3.0 1000d also ?
Yes
Do you recommend the white cordura fabric for backdrop shoot? Like they said less wrinkles if the fabric is thicker and heavier.
Im confused now if I should buy. The 3 yard of cordura fabric.
that sounds right, I don’t have any experience with backdrops though
Is this mean a polyester ?
No. Nylon
@@JBOutside1 i have under armour UA UNDENIABLE storm 3
Its 30l
It fit laptop 17inch , keyboard , laptop fan and cloth
But now i need bigger to take more cloths
I cant find same style top loader but 40-45L
Any suggestion or how to search ?
@@purplefurture6960 Sorry I don't have a recommendation
Is 500d or 1000d more waterproof ?
I would say negligible difference.
You said in the video not to use cotton t shirts which shirts are best?
Any tech shirt is what I’d recommend. I’ve found that if I double up some lightweight tech shirts I have no problems. No specific brand.
@@JBOutside1 nice one, thank you, I got my first goruck today (gr2 26l 500D) and went for my first ruck, I just put a 22lb barbell weight in the elastic pouch, it carried alright but would you reccomend a ruck plate instead? Have you had any issue rucking with the 500D one? I thought it would be substantial for rucking as well as using for EDC and travel but now I'm doubting myself!
@@Chivalrousdrake before the Rucker was introduced I rucked with standard bricks from Home Depot (lots of rucking 101 info in my other video). The Rucker is really the best solution if you’re going to do a lot of rucking. That said, the GR2 will work and a plate will be a good solution. The plate for the GR1 is what fits your ruck the best. The bad news is that the Rucker takes a separate plate. You can use the Rucker plate in the GR2 but it won’t be as secure. Check out my “Rucking 101” and “Rucker” videos for some more detail.
The 500D will be just fine for rucking if your question was about the material. I love the 500D GR2.
no sandpiper backpacks?
I haven’t used any yet
Is there a weight difference?
The answer is yes. How much, I’m not sure. Since these bags are slightly different designs it would not have been completely fair to directly compare. I think in the larger bags like the GR2s going with the 500d is the way to go because of all the layers of fabric in the bag design.
Describe please about weight differences
There is a very slight difference in weight. The more material, the more weight savings. I think in a bag like any of the GR2s the savings of having 500D is noticeable, but not dramatically. I haven't weighed bags to compare but if I had to guess it would be well under 1 lb difference. The feel of 500D is better also for the more layered bags like the GR2.
@@JBOutside1 I think difference about 20-30%. Can you weigh both bags?
@@makcz944 Dang, you’re good. I weighed both. 25% savings. While not an exact match weighing the SK21 (2.4 lbs) and GR1 (3.2 lbs) I did see a significant difference.
I see you to have a bag problem. Im not judging, I completely understand
Haha, yeah it could be considered a problem. But if it brings you joy? 🤷🏼♂️
Nice
Thanks
I got a 750 D pack 😅
😎😁
Is Cordura IRR treated?
I’m not a fabric expert but I’m 99% sure it’s not in this application. It looks like that’s a separate coating that is specifically added to certain types of fabric.
What a waste of time
Thanks for watching!!