for every new video there is new knowledge. Dan is such a good researcher, always grow up with solid base data. i've seen all your video in YT. Thank you.
His research is based on Islamic literature about the history of Islam and Muhammad, so his research streghten the Muhammad's existence and his basic teaching, only the Qibla is different. We can doubt whether the today's Qur'an is corrupted or not, the Hadith are authentic or not, but the basic story didn't change, which are about war against pagans, about hajj, it's like clicking the puzzle (I'm puzzled with Mecca for so many years, puzzled with some Hadiths and some ayahs in Qur'an and some strange violent Islamic teachings, but his research fix it). Muhammad in my mind was always like he want to follow Abraham's religion, but got fight from pagan worshipper in his town. Now I believe Muhammad's teaching is as simple as that, and those craps maybe added later by some caliphs.
Hello Dan, I miss your videos and your insights on Islam. You inspired me to start comparing the Bible and the Quran, and I have discovered lots of common truths that they both contained. I decided to have a website and share what I have researched with people. I learned so much from you Dan, thank you 😊
A video like this should be getting a million views within 12 hours, satan keeps trying to suppress and oppress but the children of God will prevail. Great work sir, keep on pushing till you meet the Lord! God bless
Been following Dan’s groundbreaking work for a number of years. Always fascinating. The sound guy isn’t experienced. Sound level for the intro was fine, Dan’s radio mic is a little low for comfort!
Dan's work is very interesting, I have been following it for years. For those interested in the early history of Islam, two excellent books that I can recommend are "Early Islam" and "The Hidden Origins of Islam", by Dr. Puin and Dr. Ohlig. They cover many interesting topics. The work on epigraphy by Dr. al-Jallad is also fascinating.
For Hama Great Mosque built in 637, your qibla tool got it wrong! Instead of pointing Hama Great Mosque, the blue balloon is pointing Al-Hassanin Mosque. Too bad because the qibla is different! The Hama Great Mosque is about 3 blocks away, it’s easy to recognize it by its specific characteristics. Now it’s time to find the real qibla of Hama Great Mosque with your GPS apps! You will see it’s not pointing Petra anymore!
I am always excited and very grateful when someone spots an error! Thank you for letting me know. I have now made some changes. The Hama Great Mosque was rebuilt in the 1980s, and has a Between Qibla. It has been rebuilt over the centuries several times, so this adds a bit more of the story. The Hassanin Mosque is also very interesting, as its shape, size, and orientation hints that it may be a much older mosque than Nur AlDin. I suspect he just rebuilt it, based on an earlier mosque. I have not found any architectural or archaeological reports on this mosque yet.
There are other ones who digged into it. Even the Bible says that Mt. Sinai is in Arabia, Midian. Jabal Maqla (Jabal al-Lawz mountain range) in northwestern Saudi Arabia.
Gibson, Damascus is the mother of all cities, the oldest occupied city. The cultural tradition of this city is considered as the center of civilization, being the seat of Syria, Assyria etc. Kuraish had many families living in Damascus who were related to Mohammad. Ezid and Mu'abia were related to the prophet and Mu'abia was the Khalif who defeated the naval force of Rome and is the unsung her who established Islam.
fun-fact about Quibla: 😂 from West Coast BC, Canada … path to Kaaba is almost over the North Pole from here. 2 directions to Kaaba: flat-Earth style … aim East Southeast, as one might travel overland. Globe style … aim around 15-17 degrees East of true North, as one travels by airplane. 😮 Magnetic North is around 15-17 degrees East of true North from here? 🥰 So, just look at a magnetic-Compass, the direction it points uncorrected, is … kinda gonna give a path towards Jersalem, Petra, Mecca or Marib. 😘 at this range … with an over-the-pole angle … they all close! 💜👍
@@xanatax1844 The earth is round so you cannot face one place to another except may be 20-25 miles if they are straight but id they are mountains in between you cannot face them. Period!
If you read Ouran - Surah Al-Fath 48:24 - Prophet Muhammad wanted to perform Umrah in Mecca on the 2nd Hijirah "The peace treaty of Al-Hudaybiyyah." Allah said (and He has restrained the hands of men from you,) meaning, `no harm that your enemies had planned against you, both fighting and warfare, touched you. Allah also restrained the hands of men, whom you left behind close to your families and children, from harming them,' 1. Where was Hudaibiyah? Hudaibiyah is near Mecca. If you study early Islamic Studies you must come across the Treaty of al-Hudaibiyah. If Mecca is Petra, the Treaty of al-Hudaibiyah never happens. 2. Another pre-Islamic event, the Abraha elephants army. The Abyssinian, Christian king of Himyarite marched upon the Ka'bah in Mecca with a large army, which included war elephants, intending to demolish it. Prophet Muhammad's paternal grandfather, Abd al-Muttalib, put the battle in God's hands, realising that he could not take on the forces of Abraha. If you visit Taif - Abrahah's elephant army route is located in the vicinity of Taif and faces the Hijjaz. This area is said to be the route of Abrahah's elephant army and also his cavalry. This path is made of granite stones that are not all the same size. There is also a place that is said to be Abrahah's army camp to rest. The Arabs call this place the Elephant Path. Abrahah's army well is believed to have been dug by Abrahah's army around Mecca before moving to destroy the Kaaba. The wells are believed to be 5 in total. Most likely to accommodate dozens of elephants and horses. Looking at the well, the war and the siege took months. The Abrahah's wells still exist today.
@@phyllis9998 It would be important because were the Qiblas and/or Masjids (the place of prostration - we are assuming HERE that these are Muzlim places of worship) even Izlamic?. I guess that some Masjids (could be of Pagan origins) ie before AH1 and up to 7AH. The Prophet conquers Mecca ~7 AH AND died ~11 AH. Also, I don't think there were that many followers (probably only from Medina) at that time. We know that the Kaaba was a place of pagan worship with many idols. The prophet's father and his tribe were pagan worshippers. Could these early Masjids be places of pagan prostration/worship facing Petra, the Kaaba (the Pagan Kaaba), and/or the temple of Hubal (the moon god). We know that many masjids have a crescent moon and star on the top of their minarets (why? the Muslims can't explain).
Dan gibson eğer bunu okursan kıblenin ne Petra ya ne Mekke'ye bakmadigini söyledin ama ben nereye baktigini buldum. Ve tam işaret ettiğin yerde bir şehir. Ve anlatılan Mekke'ye uyuyor.
As you are informed. I would like to suggest that in your last phrase you admitted to climate change. ( personally I don’t agree) however, would like you consider the possibility that how climate change theory is conceptually applicable. My take is slightly different, the alignment of stars , North Star was not accurate till what Mr. Gevin Menziz in his book 1421, as the Chinese were the only Sea faring power at that time, so what Maps are you referring to? Secondly, Data shown is based on what appeared to you before the GOOGLE MPA invent, so how did you come to the conclusion ? What is the accuracy that you argue of 10 degree. ? To any Mimbar constructed in those times.
There are many errors and suppositions in Gevin Menziz book 1421. See the book review on my channel: nabataea.net/explore/travel_and_trade/book-review-1421-the-year-china-discovered-the-world/
35:25 min. Rekem as Petra.that seems as Raqeem in quran chapter 18:9. ps.Dans mentioned that niche wall near kaaba Petra,is where Ishmael and his mother are buried.yet claims are Ishmael and mum buried at niche wall at Saudi Mecca.
For the Gibson's Kaaba in Petra ... There is no and never existed a Kaaba in Petra. The Gibson’s Kaaba is only an old roman sacrificial altar. This structure is well identified and studied by a French archeologist team from INRAP (Institut national de recherches archéologiques préventives) directed by the archeologist François Renel, who worked 20 years in Petra. Also, the Department of Antiquities of Jordan approved their studies. Gibson never show any paper of this studies. No archeologist approves Gibson’s hypothesis.
The Kaaba was built on a sacrificial altar by Abraham. So their findings do not contradict Gibson's theory, they reinforce it. Thank you for adding more evidence to this rock solid theory.
@@TechkiV Gibson in previous videos shows an altar in Petra which he does attribute as being the base of the Kaaba prior to its demolition and removal.
Excellent presentation. Dan does his research and his analysis stands. Islam was fabricated over centuries and totally depends on the SWORD to "convince" both its followers and its victims.
a few simple questions: 1- Prophet, Abu Bakr, Ali, Osman, Omar, other believers, are they all from Petra? We are not talking about one person. You have to say that everyone has petra and no one knows about it? this is ridiculous. 2- It makes sense to go from Mecca to Medina because there are not many places to go, but it is unreasonable to go from Petra to Medina. There are many places you can go from Petra. Since he migrated to Medina; Isn't Medina in Medina? 3- Are you saying that no one objects to changing the location of Mecca? No one wrote it down, not a single person remembers it, and not a single person told it to their children? Moreover, such an important event! 4- If Becca and Mecca can be confused, why shouldn't those who built the mosques mix them up? 5- Which drug do you use?
1) the grave of Mohamed is under the mosque in Medina not mecca 🤦 2) Medina = Medina, no problem 3) there was civil war at the time of Change, the Hajj stopped for some years and the qibla direction was disputed (as eg reflected by mosque orientations) 4) that question doesn't make sense 5) the level of your questions rather reflects on you than on Dan Gibson 🙄
@@hans471 1) That's not the problem. Going from Petra to Medina, back to petra, and then going back to Medina... this is a problem because nearly 1000km . 2) actually petra != mecca. Because at that time Petra was under the rule of the Roman Empire. Byzantine or Roman sources cannot haven't written that a prophet appeared in their city. Moreover, Petra was conquered in 661, Petra was conquered in 661, Petra was conquered in 661. 30 years after the prophet died 3) civil wars do not erase people's memories. If you suddenly say that the prophet is from Mecca when he was from Petra a few years ago, you cannot silence anyone. It is a great fantasy to say that they were all killed without even one person saying this. The farewell sermon was read on Mount Arafat and there are many more things you don't want to see. 4) To whom is it unreasonable? It makes perfect sense compared to your illogical theory. 5) I wish he had at least one level and kept his nonsense to himself. The only people who think their dreams are real are drunks.
1- It's in Medina 2- Medina is Medina 3- They objected, the first 200 years of Islam are marked with constant civil war. They also built mosques facing different directions. Epigraphy shows that for the first 60 years people had no memory of Muhammad, the figure is brought back on coins by anti-Calif al-Zubayr trying to establish his legitimity. Ibn al-Rawandi in al-Zumurud complained that people claimed Mecca was in the Hijaz whereas it was in the North. The Qarmatians always claimed Mecca was not the original place of the kaaba and black stone. The Roman emperor Elagabalus took the black stone in Petra and made a pilgrimage with it. Armenian historians locate Petra as the birthplace of Muhammad.
@@phyllis9998 Elagabalus 🤦 400 years between them and why there is no record in the Roman records about why a prophet appeared in their city and founded a new religion in a Christian city or declared its independence. Petra was a Roman city. Muslims took Petra 50 years after the death of the Muhammed (S.A.V.). These are written in Byzantine, Roman and Muslim records. Petra was a Roman city. Muslims took Petra 50 years after the death of the prophet. But you still say the prophet was in Petra. this is bullshit.
@@temmuzss at that time he was not prophet; he became prophet in later period to institutionalize Islam. At that time, he was a ruler who lives in Medina.
You can watch their scripts and visit their places and use your scientific knowledge and you will be accurate in your info! Yes people used to think, this world is flat but then comes scientific mind like Galilio who watch the stars in heaven and figure it out that our earth is round And there goes old thoughts of flat earth. God is giving us prograssive knowledge One step at a time.
@@NativeVsColonial first God gave you Brain so use it for until 1950's there was NO science but as the Danile says in his book, "the Knowledge shall increase" This is our time. And to believe in God is with your own experiece and to go against God is learn behaviour. You can hit your head on a concrete wall 100 time by saying "there is NO god" will not make you tree because King David already wrote in the Psalms 53:1 The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God So you are not the first one to say such things Ok?
@@childofgod4862 🔶Earth is Flat: 🔹Proverbs 8:27: “I was there when He established the heavens, when He inscribed a circle on the face of the deep.” 🔹Job 38:13-14: “(13) That it might spread to the ends of the earth and shake the wicked out of it? (14) The earth takes shape like clay under a seal; its hills stand out like the folds of a garment.” 🔹Isaiah 40:22: “He sits enthroned above the circle of the earth; its dwellers are like grasshoppers. He stretches out the heavens like a curtain, and spreads them out like a tent to dwell in.” 🔹Job 26:7: "He stretches out the north over empty space; He hangs the earth upon nothing.” 🔹Revelation 7:1: "After this I saw four angels standing at the four corners of the earth, holding back its four winds so that no wind would blow on land or sea or on any tree." 🔶Earth is Static: 🔹Chronicles 16:30: “Tremble before Him, all the earth. The world is firmly established; it cannot be moved.” 🔹Psalm 93:1: “The LORD reigns! He is robed in majesty; the LORD has clothed and armed Himself with strength. The world indeed is firmly established; it cannot be moved.” 🔹Psalm 96:10: “Declare among the nations: “The LORD reigns!” The world is firmly established; it cannot be moved; He will judge the peoples with equity.” 🔹Psalm 104:5: “He set the earth on its foundations, never to be moved.” 🔶The luminaries are the ones moving, not the Earth: 🔹Joshua 10:12-13: “(12) On the day that the LORD gave the Amorites over to the Israelites, Joshua spoke to the LORD in the presence of Israel: “O sun, stand still over Gibeon, O moon, over the Valley of Aijalon. (13)So the sun stood still and the moon stopped until the nation took vengeance upon its enemies. Is this not written in the Book of Jashar? “So the sun stopped in the middle of the sky and delayed going down about a full day.” 🔹2 Kings 20:8-11 🔹Psalm 19:6: “It rises at one end of the heavens and runs its circuit to the other; nothing is deprived of its warmth.” 🔹Ecclesiastes 1:5: “The sun rises and the sun sets; it hurries back to where it rises.” 🔹Habakkuk 3:11: “Sun and moon stood still in their places at the flash of Your flying arrows, at the brightness of Your shining spear.” 🔶Moon have its own light: 🔹Isaiah 13:10: “For the stars of heaven and their constellations will not give their light. The rising sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light.” 🔹Matthew 24:29” “Immediately after the tribulation of those days: ‘The sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light; the stars will fall from the sky, and the powers of the heavens will be shaken.” 🔹Mark 13:24: “But in those days, after that tribulation: ‘The sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light”
There is no scientific evidence for a globe earth. No matter how hard you look for it, you won't be able to find any evidence for a globe. All they got is fake images. Large bodies of water such as oceans and lakes cannot curve around a ball. All frozen lakes are flat. All empirical evidence demonstrates that the earth is a flat stationary plane. There is no such thing as Space. The sky is a solid dome. The sun and the moon are attached to the dome and are tiny compared to the flat plane of the earth. The Earth is surrounded by the Antarctic ice wall. The pillars of the dome are on the other side of the ice wall that is why no one is allowed to go there. All major governments have signed the Atlantic treaty barring any one from going there without their permission. They are hiding more land and resources beyond the wall
Thank you Mr. Dan, I love your work and your contribution to humankind! 💝
for every new video there is new knowledge. Dan is such a good researcher, always grow up with solid base data. i've seen all your video in YT. Thank you.
Dan Gibson Keep preaching the Truth! God has raised you in right time so you can guide all humanity to the Truth! God bless you and protect you sir!
Thank you, Dan! Very informative, like always.
I really love your works. You are amazing.
Great work. I am an ex Muslim from Pakistan and this teaching made me leave Islam and now I am follower of Jesus Christ. Thank you sir.
How did this make you leave Islam ? You can still be a Muslim and believe in this
His research is based on Islamic literature about the history of Islam and Muhammad, so his research streghten the Muhammad's existence and his basic teaching, only the Qibla is different. We can doubt whether the today's Qur'an is corrupted or not, the Hadith are authentic or not, but the basic story didn't change, which are about war against pagans, about hajj, it's like clicking the puzzle (I'm puzzled with Mecca for so many years, puzzled with some Hadiths and some ayahs in Qur'an and some strange violent Islamic teachings, but his research fix it). Muhammad in my mind was always like he want to follow Abraham's religion, but got fight from pagan worshipper in his town. Now I believe Muhammad's teaching is as simple as that, and those craps maybe added later by some caliphs.
You mean you follow isho
why believe in false nonsense and still be moselim?@@OutlawLu
Do you mean followers of Jesus Christ were not Muslims? His teachings were different?
Hello Dan, I miss your videos and your insights on Islam. You inspired me to start comparing the Bible and the Quran, and I have discovered lots of common truths that they both contained. I decided to have a website and share what I have researched with people. I learned so much from you Dan, thank you 😊
A video like this should be getting a million views within 12 hours, satan keeps trying to suppress and oppress but the children of God will prevail. Great work sir, keep on pushing till you meet the Lord! God bless
Very insightful. Expectations vs Reality. Much to ponder on. Thanks for the video
Been following Dan’s groundbreaking work for a number of years. Always fascinating. The sound guy isn’t experienced. Sound level for the intro was fine, Dan’s radio mic is a little low for comfort!
Respect
Dan's work is very interesting, I have been following it for years. For those interested in the early history of Islam, two excellent books that I can recommend are "Early Islam" and "The Hidden Origins of Islam", by Dr. Puin and Dr. Ohlig. They cover many interesting topics. The work on epigraphy by Dr. al-Jallad is also fascinating.
Hello Mr.Gibson, would you make a video about Salman Parsi?
Great presentation. Would it be possible to make the slides available?
For Hama Great Mosque built in 637, your qibla tool got it wrong!
Instead of pointing Hama Great Mosque, the blue balloon is pointing Al-Hassanin Mosque. Too bad because the qibla is different! The Hama Great Mosque is about 3 blocks away, it’s easy to recognize it by its specific characteristics. Now it’s time to find the real qibla of Hama Great Mosque with your GPS apps! You will see it’s not pointing Petra anymore!
I am always excited and very grateful when someone spots an error! Thank you for letting me know. I have now made some changes. The Hama Great Mosque was rebuilt in the 1980s, and has a Between Qibla. It has been rebuilt over the centuries several times, so this adds a bit more of the story. The Hassanin Mosque is also very interesting, as its shape, size, and orientation hints that it may be a much older mosque than Nur AlDin. I suspect he just rebuilt it, based on an earlier mosque. I have not found any architectural or archaeological reports on this mosque yet.
He came to u .. an your silence speaks volumes😂😂😂😂 like your zum zum water😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅
@@1JohnChapter4 I replied to him on his last video
Q&A not videod?
Did you find any archaeological evidence of exodus from Egypt?
There are other ones who digged into it. Even the Bible says that Mt. Sinai is in Arabia, Midian. Jabal Maqla (Jabal al-Lawz mountain range) in northwestern Saudi Arabia.
Islam is a political system as described in the Hadith. It is very little religion or philosophical ideas.
Gibson, Damascus is the mother of all cities, the oldest occupied city. The cultural tradition of this city is considered as the center of civilization, being the seat of Syria, Assyria etc. Kuraish had many families living in Damascus who were related to Mohammad. Ezid and Mu'abia were related to the prophet and Mu'abia was the Khalif who defeated the naval force of Rome and is the unsung her who established Islam.
Read about Petra. For Nabatean the Petra was the mother of all cities.
Please give me book form Pakistani
At 1.10 this happened after why the bazzentine army left, it was not global warming, it’s CE 537 which moved a lot of places. BBC documentary.
Dan re created history
👋 Hiya from BC! 😅 Wow! You’ve been busy since you left! 💜
fun-fact about Quibla: 😂 from West Coast BC, Canada … path to Kaaba is almost over the North Pole from here.
2 directions to Kaaba: flat-Earth style … aim East Southeast, as one might travel overland.
Globe style … aim around 15-17 degrees East of true North, as one travels by airplane.
😮 Magnetic North is around 15-17 degrees East of true North from here? 🥰 So, just look at a magnetic-Compass, the direction it points uncorrected, is … kinda gonna give a path towards Jersalem, Petra, Mecca or Marib. 😘 at this range … with an over-the-pole angle … they all close! 💜👍
@@xanatax1844 The earth is round so you cannot face one place to another except may be 20-25 miles if they are straight but id they are mountains in between you cannot face them. Period!
Is it better to face the ground and go through the direction of the core of the earth?
If you read Ouran - Surah Al-Fath 48:24 - Prophet Muhammad wanted to perform Umrah in Mecca on the 2nd Hijirah "The peace treaty of Al-Hudaybiyyah." Allah said (and He has restrained the hands of men from you,) meaning, `no harm that your enemies had planned against you, both fighting and warfare, touched you. Allah also restrained the hands of men, whom you left behind close to your families and children, from harming them,'
1. Where was Hudaibiyah? Hudaibiyah is near Mecca. If you study early Islamic Studies you must come across the Treaty of al-Hudaibiyah. If Mecca is Petra, the Treaty of al-Hudaibiyah never happens.
2. Another pre-Islamic event, the Abraha elephants army. The Abyssinian, Christian king of Himyarite marched upon the Ka'bah in Mecca with a large army, which included war elephants, intending to demolish it. Prophet Muhammad's paternal grandfather, Abd al-Muttalib, put the battle in God's hands, realising that he could not take on the forces of Abraha. If you visit Taif - Abrahah's elephant army route is located in the vicinity of Taif and faces the Hijjaz. This area is said to be the route of Abrahah's elephant army and also his cavalry. This path is made of granite stones that are not all the same size. There is also a place that is said to be Abrahah's army camp to rest. The Arabs call this place the Elephant Path.
Abrahah's army well is believed to have been dug by Abrahah's army around Mecca before moving to destroy the Kaaba. The wells are believed to be 5 in total. Most likely to accommodate dozens of elephants and horses. Looking at the well, the war and the siege took months. The Abrahah's wells still exist today.
Kya ise Hindi convert karke bata saktey ho kya please translate in Hindi
Inki documentary Sacred City ki HINDI DUBBING inke channel per hai.
इनकी documentary SACRED CITY की हिंदी DUBBING इनके चैनल पर है
search for "Dan Gibson" channel in yo tu be
One issue I have is changing “BC” and “AD” for the stupid “common era” but leaving the made up dates for Islam
I think you need to speak to Mr.Genvis Menzies. Who wrote 1421 ..
Please read my review of Menziz. nabataea.net/explore/travel_and_trade/book-review-1421-the-year-china-discovered-the-world/
Zülkarneyn de var?
Copied from a popular book into the Quran.
Hi Dan, I think you forgot to include one piece of VERY IMPORTANT information in your time line, ie The birth and Death of the Prophet
How is it important? I don't think it is. Plus there is no historical evidence for these dates.
@@phyllis9998 It would be important because were the Qiblas and/or Masjids (the place of prostration - we are assuming HERE that these are Muzlim places of worship) even Izlamic?. I guess that some Masjids (could be of Pagan origins) ie before AH1 and up to 7AH. The Prophet conquers Mecca ~7 AH AND died ~11 AH. Also, I don't think there were that many followers (probably only from Medina) at that time. We know that the Kaaba was a place of pagan worship with many idols. The prophet's father and his tribe were pagan worshippers. Could these early Masjids be places of pagan prostration/worship facing Petra, the Kaaba (the Pagan Kaaba), and/or the temple of Hubal (the moon god). We know that many masjids have a crescent moon and star on the top of their minarets (why? the Muslims can't explain).
@@Rafa-dh4wh Many of your questions are answered in previous videos posted to the RUclips channel.
Dan gibson eğer bunu okursan kıblenin ne Petra ya ne Mekke'ye bakmadigini söyledin ama ben nereye baktigini buldum. Ve tam işaret ettiğin yerde bir şehir. Ve anlatılan Mekke'ye uyuyor.
Where is this place ?
Prove it.
As you are informed. I would like to suggest that in your last phrase you admitted to climate change. ( personally I don’t agree) however, would like you consider the possibility that how climate change theory is conceptually applicable.
My take is slightly different, the alignment of stars , North Star was not accurate till what Mr. Gevin Menziz in his book 1421, as the Chinese were the only Sea faring power at that time, so what Maps are you referring to?
Secondly, Data shown is based on what appeared to you before the GOOGLE MPA invent, so how did you come to the conclusion ?
What is the accuracy that you argue of 10 degree. ? To any Mimbar constructed in those times.
There are many errors and suppositions in Gevin Menziz book 1421. See the book review on my channel: nabataea.net/explore/travel_and_trade/book-review-1421-the-year-china-discovered-the-world/
35:25 min. Rekem as Petra.that seems as Raqeem in quran chapter 18:9.
ps.Dans mentioned that niche wall near kaaba Petra,is where Ishmael and his mother are buried.yet claims are Ishmael and mum buried at niche wall at Saudi Mecca.
Dr. Gibson authority on Mideast archeology
Truth must come out, whatever the origin of Macca was.
Dan, could "the farthest mosque" maybe nót be Jerusalem, but rather even as far as China?
Wod histrey mane frend
O Arabım demedi?
For the Gibson's Kaaba in Petra ... There is no and never existed a Kaaba in Petra. The Gibson’s Kaaba is only an old roman sacrificial altar. This structure is well identified and studied by a French archeologist team from INRAP (Institut national de recherches archéologiques préventives) directed by the archeologist François Renel, who worked 20 years in Petra. Also, the Department of Antiquities of Jordan approved their studies. Gibson never show any paper of this studies. No archeologist approves Gibson’s hypothesis.
wtf of course there is no Kaaba in Petra. It was completely destroyed. They even said the Doug out the rest of it until nothing was left.
The Kaaba was built on a sacrificial altar by Abraham. So their findings do not contradict Gibson's theory, they reinforce it. Thank you for adding more evidence to this rock solid theory.
@@TechkiV Gibson in previous videos shows an altar in Petra which he does attribute as being the base of the Kaaba prior to its demolition and removal.
Goofy gibson
@@elliotmorin5560nope ?
I miss the blue shirt
No religion, especially the Abrahamic faiths can withstand a dispassionate, critical, reading of their allegedly inspired sacred books.
Christianity still does pretty well.
Seeing “Past” as-is needs total awareness, complete neutrality…
Excellent presentation. Dan does his research and his analysis stands. Islam was fabricated over centuries and totally depends on the SWORD to "convince" both its followers and its victims.
So has NATO, state religion
Muhammed şöyle dedi ben kureşli kuru ekmek yiyen bir kabilenin çocuğuyum?
a few simple questions:
1- Prophet, Abu Bakr, Ali, Osman, Omar, other believers, are they all from Petra? We are not talking about one person. You have to say that everyone has petra and no one knows about it? this is ridiculous.
2- It makes sense to go from Mecca to Medina because there are not many places to go, but it is unreasonable to go from Petra to Medina. There are many places you can go from Petra. Since he migrated to Medina; Isn't Medina in Medina?
3- Are you saying that no one objects to changing the location of Mecca? No one wrote it down, not a single person remembers it, and not a single person told it to their children? Moreover, such an important event!
4- If Becca and Mecca can be confused, why shouldn't those who built the mosques mix them up?
5- Which drug do you use?
1) the grave of Mohamed is under the mosque in Medina not mecca 🤦
2) Medina = Medina, no problem
3) there was civil war at the time of Change, the Hajj stopped for some years and the qibla direction was disputed (as eg reflected by mosque orientations)
4) that question doesn't make sense
5) the level of your questions rather reflects on you than on Dan Gibson 🙄
@@hans471 1) That's not the problem. Going from Petra to Medina, back to petra, and then going back to Medina... this is a problem because nearly 1000km .
2) actually petra != mecca. Because at that time Petra was under the rule of the Roman Empire. Byzantine or Roman sources cannot haven't written that a prophet appeared in their city. Moreover, Petra was conquered in 661, Petra was conquered in 661, Petra was conquered in 661. 30 years after the prophet died
3) civil wars do not erase people's memories. If you suddenly say that the prophet is from Mecca when he was from Petra a few years ago, you cannot silence anyone. It is a great fantasy to say that they were all killed without even one person saying this. The farewell sermon was read on Mount Arafat and there are many more things you don't want to see.
4) To whom is it unreasonable? It makes perfect sense compared to your illogical theory.
5) I wish he had at least one level and kept his nonsense to himself. The only people who think their dreams are real are drunks.
1- It's in Medina
2- Medina is Medina
3- They objected, the first 200 years of Islam are marked with constant civil war. They also built mosques facing different directions. Epigraphy shows that for the first 60 years people had no memory of Muhammad, the figure is brought back on coins by anti-Calif al-Zubayr trying to establish his legitimity. Ibn al-Rawandi in al-Zumurud complained that people claimed Mecca was in the Hijaz whereas it was in the North. The Qarmatians always claimed Mecca was not the original place of the kaaba and black stone. The Roman emperor Elagabalus took the black stone in Petra and made a pilgrimage with it. Armenian historians locate Petra as the birthplace of Muhammad.
@@phyllis9998 Elagabalus 🤦 400 years between them and why there is no record in the Roman records about why a prophet appeared in their city and founded a new religion in a Christian city or declared its independence. Petra was a Roman city. Muslims took Petra 50 years after the death of the Muhammed (S.A.V.). These are written in Byzantine, Roman and Muslim records. Petra was a Roman city. Muslims took Petra 50 years after the death of the prophet. But you still say the prophet was in Petra. this is bullshit.
@@temmuzss at that time he was not prophet; he became prophet in later period to institutionalize Islam. At that time, he was a ruler who lives in Medina.
Also the Earth is supposed to flat as per Bible and Quran, so how come you are expecting them to make their holy sites accurate?
You can watch their scripts and visit their places and use your scientific knowledge and you will be accurate in your info!
Yes people used to think, this world is flat but then comes scientific mind like Galilio who watch the stars in heaven and figure it out that our earth is round And there goes old thoughts of flat earth. God is giving us prograssive knowledge One step at a time.
@@childofgod4862 God gave us cult, Free thinking gave us enlightenment of the science.
@@NativeVsColonial first God gave you Brain so use it for until 1950's there was NO science but as the Danile says in his book, "the Knowledge shall increase" This is our time. And to believe in God is with your own experiece and to go against God is learn behaviour. You can hit your head on a concrete wall 100 time by saying "there is NO god" will not make you tree because King David already wrote in the Psalms 53:1 The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God
So you are not the first one to say such things Ok?
@@childofgod4862
🔶Earth is Flat:
🔹Proverbs 8:27: “I was there when He established the heavens, when He inscribed a circle on the face of the deep.”
🔹Job 38:13-14: “(13) That it might spread to the ends of the earth and shake the wicked out of it? (14) The earth takes shape like clay under a seal; its hills stand out like the folds of a garment.”
🔹Isaiah 40:22: “He sits enthroned above the circle of the earth; its dwellers are like grasshoppers. He stretches out the heavens like a curtain, and spreads them out like a tent to dwell in.”
🔹Job 26:7: "He stretches out the north over empty space; He hangs the earth upon nothing.”
🔹Revelation 7:1: "After this I saw four angels standing at the four corners of the earth, holding back its four winds so that no wind would blow on land or sea or on any tree."
🔶Earth is Static:
🔹Chronicles 16:30: “Tremble before Him, all the earth. The world is firmly established; it cannot be moved.”
🔹Psalm 93:1: “The LORD reigns! He is robed in majesty; the LORD has clothed and armed Himself with strength. The world indeed is firmly established; it cannot be moved.”
🔹Psalm 96:10: “Declare among the nations: “The LORD reigns!” The world is firmly established; it cannot be moved; He will judge the peoples with equity.”
🔹Psalm 104:5: “He set the earth on its foundations, never to be moved.”
🔶The luminaries are the ones moving, not the Earth:
🔹Joshua 10:12-13: “(12) On the day that the LORD gave the Amorites over to the Israelites, Joshua spoke to the LORD in the presence of Israel: “O sun, stand still over Gibeon, O moon, over the Valley of Aijalon. (13)So the sun stood still and the moon stopped until the nation took vengeance upon its enemies. Is this not written in the Book of Jashar? “So the sun stopped in the middle of the sky and delayed going down about a full day.”
🔹2 Kings 20:8-11
🔹Psalm 19:6: “It rises at one end of the heavens and runs its circuit to the other; nothing is deprived of its warmth.”
🔹Ecclesiastes 1:5: “The sun rises and the sun sets; it hurries back to where it rises.”
🔹Habakkuk 3:11: “Sun and moon stood still in their places at the flash of Your flying arrows, at the brightness of Your shining spear.”
🔶Moon have its own light:
🔹Isaiah 13:10: “For the stars of heaven and their constellations will not give their light. The rising sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light.”
🔹Matthew 24:29” “Immediately after the tribulation of those days: ‘The sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light; the stars will fall from the sky, and the powers of the heavens will be shaken.”
🔹Mark 13:24: “But in those days, after that tribulation: ‘The sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give its light”
There is no scientific evidence for a globe earth. No matter how hard you look for it, you won't be able to find any evidence for a globe. All they got is fake images. Large bodies of water such as oceans and lakes cannot curve around a ball. All frozen lakes are flat. All empirical evidence demonstrates that the earth is a flat stationary plane. There is no such thing as Space. The sky is a solid dome. The sun and the moon are attached to the dome and are tiny compared to the flat plane of the earth. The Earth is surrounded by the Antarctic ice wall. The pillars of the dome are on the other side of the ice wall that is why no one is allowed to go there. All major governments have signed the Atlantic treaty barring any one from going there without their permission. They are hiding more land and resources beyond the wall