The funny thing is that she watch back to back episodes so her intro for the next one wasn't as happy as this one. She did a side by side of her intros on her ig story a few days ago haha
13:15 Magy: "This is such a nice wedding. This is such a nice episode." Ramsay Bolton, 3 episodes ago: "If you think this has a happy ending, you haven't been paying attention."
Thank you for being so vulnerable. This episode was devistating when I first watched it. I almost stopped watching the show. But I'm glad I continued. There are more tragic deaths, but there are no scenes as brutal as this one. You've made it through the worst.
Guys I'm not saying people didn't react to videos beforehand. Reacting to things is NOT a new concept. They had game shows built around that concept back in the 80's. There were plenty of viral videos that people reacted to before. But there were no reaction channels, and people were not reacting to tv series and movies. That was 100% the Red Wedding that sparked it.
None of the show luckily was spoiled for me. I just finished it a few weeks ago. I watched this episode on the way to a job site and cried in front of my coworkers...I work in construction. Most awkward day ever.
@@brandynkoogler4500 dont you people realize even these kind of comments spoil future episodes and plot lines. Jeez, and you just said you were lucky nothing was spoiled for you.
@@akubuckbee7242 zero spoilers actually, except the names of the battles. If you've never seen the show, that tells you absolutely nothing about what happens other than a battle which is pretty normal for Game of Thrones. Big whoop. I didn't spoil anything with regards to the story. So calm down it will be okay.
Aw the Red Wedding 😔 Shout out to my fellow Song of Ice and Fire book readers who knew about the Red Wedding for 13 years and didn't spoil it for fans the TV show 🤘
The hardest thing was my co-workers all knew I read the book and I had to pretend that nothing was coming. A female coworker loved Rob Stark's character and thought he was going to be the main character for that season. I had to play along. She called in sick that Monday because she was so upset. I do have to say, that Friday before the Red Wedding was interesting. They had no idea what was coming.
@@TheKukulkan it was almost the same for me! i had coworkers who were fans of the show but hadn't read the books, so when season 3 rolled around I had to really play coy/quiet about the big spoilers. A lot of them were Robb Stark fans too, so it was almost painful watching them glow about him and knowing his fate. That monday after the red wedding episode they all went up to me crushed like "YOU KNEW ABOUT THIS?!?!"
@@roboj After that episode, almost all my coworkers bought the books. This one episode made all of them readers or RR Martin's work. Like you everyone at work was upset that I sat on this information. They later thanked me because I did not spoil it for them. One co worker loved the show/books so much she called her daughter Arya. The entire office was into this show and I could not be the one that spoiled even the smallest hint of what's to come.
I was all in with this episode. This one pulled me in. Anything can happen - that's a great thing in a TV show. The way they ended the whole thing is what ruined it for me.
@@christopherrousseau1173 There were only two people in the world the night it aired. Those who read the books and those who didn't. And those who read it were waiting to watch the reactions of those that didn't. Even more so then the show.
15:50 was the entire fandom when that aired. Book readers were gleefully watching everyone’s souls get crushed and show watchers universally declared they would quit the series.
Neither my gf nor I had read the books. When this episode aired, she had a very Magy-like reaction (with a lot more hiding behind pillows though). I just watched with wide eyes and mouth open, thinking, "This is crazy but it's brilliant!" I love storytelling, including all the ups and downs, and the severe, unexpected turn in this episode made me even more of a fan than I already was. It didn't crush my soul because, although I was sad to see the characters go, it was artistically an amazing choice and I loved it. Definitely one of my favorite episodes of the series.
@@johnplaysgames3120 Find a way to read the scene in the book. Even the writing of it was amazing. "10 angry ravens raked at her face..." It was in Catlyn's POV, and she lost her mind and scratched up her face right before she FELT the blade at her throat,,and the chapter,ended on that cliffhanger. We didn't get confirmation that she was actually CUT in the throat until several chapters later, through dialogue, rumors, and a really awesome dream-turned-warging scene. There's also something super duper fuggin awesome that follows this specific storyline, and they didnt. Put it. In. The show. I wanted to punch them. It would have been so badass. And satisfying, after this scene.
I can’t be the only exception though? Despite being a history buff and know a lot of real life situation in history where scenes of “red wedding” actually happened, my friends thought I would enjoy Game of Thrones, but in reality, I couldn’t even root for Robb, his father’s death was normal, there are many instances what Ned did, did actually happened in RL, like 80% got beheaded or burned or killed, 10% got tortured and 10% rot in jail until died of diseases or old age. What Robb was doing was extremely foolish, how many Kings were killed by a clan? In game of thrones there was only 2 players. Based how the series was going until season 5, I stopped, it was clear to me who will be the last two to grab the title, but both of them are not the players, wasn’t interested in both of them. People could say a lot of people were playing the game but, honestly, most of them are tools or trading cards, have power, but not playing the game, if you realised, the one player that was on defensive was removed before the second player realise he was on offensive. So it was a game that nobody played against each other, anyone who have both of the players would win the game, but no one gave a shit.
@@MagicMagy Were you interested of GOT before and late in watching it due to your age? I wonder at your age do you appreciate the entertainment value or intrigue with this series? After all GOT is a global phenomenon compared to some other American shows.
14:17 This song is the Rains of Castamere. This is the reason why Catelyn was worried, because it's the song of House Lannister. You might heard this song after the Battle Of Blackwater episode during the credits. Furthermore, when that song was played it signals the Frey and Bolton to turned on the Starks and Tully army outside the Twins.
"and who are you, the proud lord said, that I must bow so low? But only a cat of a different coat is all the truth I know, with coat of GOLD🔶 AND A COAT OF RED 🔴 THE LION 🦁 STILL HAS CLAWS, AND MINE ARE LOND AND SHARP MY LORD IS ALL THE TRUTH I KNOW..... AND SO HE SPOKE AND SO HE SPOKE THAT LORD OF CASTAMERE AND NOW THE RAINS WE PORE HIS HALLS WITH NONE A SOUL TO HEAR....
Catelyn was always smart and understood the political nuances of _Game_ of _Thrones_ ...I wasn't surprised that she knew something was wrong before it happened. It's too bad that Ned Stark didn't listen to his wife or he would have still be alive.
@@luminatrixfanfiction Cat also made some serious errors, like arresting Tyrion, which was cause enough for Jaime to lance Ned and kill his guard, and arrest him......and we all know how that ended up.
Finally got to the episode that changed everything. The Red Wedding. This does the book justice. The horror just keeps going and going. I had to watch this episode with my friends because I already knew what was coming. This actually made one of my friends break his phone (on accident). He was more upset about this episode than his phone. This feeling you have....it stays with you for almost the entire series and just makes you hate the Lannisters more and more you think about it.
@starlord the best guardian The thing is in the book Rob Stark married a Lannister Cousin. She was "kidnapped" moments before the wedding. These changes from the book made the show interesting for those who read the book. The killing of the pregnant wife was a kick in the gut for us book readers. After this we waited for Lady Stoneheart but she never showed. I am happy that they did the book justice, but it was tough. I cried and I knew it was coming.
@@TheKukulkan I remember when I read the books I somewhat suspected him meeting this cousin was all a setup by the Lannisters to put a rift between the Starks and Freys. I don't think they knew it'd pay off this well though. In the show that's all pretty neatly avoided though.
@@TheKukulkan "The thing is in the book Rob Stark married a Lannister Cousin." Jeyne Westerling is not a Lannister cousin "She was "kidnapped" moments before the wedding." She wasn't there at all, Robb wanted her to stay at Riverrun with the Blackfish
Even though it made us all feel like shit after, this has to be the most brilliant episode in television history. Literally caught the whole audience by surprise.
@@Mycernius That was your silly mistake. One should never read the books. 😃 But in all seriousness. For me it's better to read the books afterwards, to fill in the details missed by the show. I'm visual so books do nothing for me other than provide rote information. I can't get excited or emotional or even visualize the action from a book.
Well, now you know to expect it. George RR Martin who wrote the books said in an interview "You know you watch something like Spiderman and you see him backed up in a corner against 20 thugs and he beats them all up with ease. You are never scared for him, but in Game Of Thrones no matter if you are the main character or not if its unrealistic for you to survive then you wont."
Of course, that's all utter nonsense, because who lives or dies has nothing to do with realism and everything with what GRRM wants to happen. If realism was an issue, Tywin Lannister would have thanked the Freys, then have them hung, drawn and quartered and sent their bits and pieces to all the seven kingdoms as an illustration as to what happens to people who break their oath of fealty. You don't reward people who put the axe to the foundations of the social compact and scoff at the very foundation of your own agency and power. The "inspirations" GRRM has cited in the past for the Red Wedding have precious little in common - both with each other and the Red Wedding - other than people being surprisingly killed.
@@victormanteca7395 Oh my sweet summer child. You still believe that they introduced wholly original ideas. They may have rushed the ending, but I can guarantee you that what the narrative was based on GRRM's notes. Of course, given the "speed" at which he progresses, he has every opportunity to disavow his own words and change his concept in order to distance himself from the outcry. That is, if he ever bothers to finish the stuff instead of raking in HBO cash for prequels.
@@ohauss George RR Martin has repeatedly changed his story outline. I wouldn't put it out of question that he changed it again after seeing the backlash to the last season. Could be a reason for why it takes him so long to get winds out.
Magy: "I'm so done with Game of Thrones!" Me: "Don't worry Magy...the North remembers!" Without a doubt, one of the most heartbreaking episodes of the entire series. I'm a grown man and literally had the same reaction as you when it first aired.
@@ben1ben2ben1ow? Jon Snow and Sansa literally avenged one half of the Red Wedding by ending the Boltons, and Arya avenged the other half by killing the Freys. The third half was avenged by Tyrion when he murdered his own father. How was "The North Remembers" butchered? It may not be as good as it was in the books, where grand conspiracies are coming, but it was still good
Fun fact from one of the biggest GoT fans ever: This was my introduction to the series. First episode I watched. I had a friend that had read the books and thought this would happen in episode 10, so he said it would be fine for me to watch with them and get a feel for the series. I watched this the morning after it aired and immediately bought all of the books and began watching the series. He apologized profusely, but having this bandaid ripped off before I had a chance to love Robb was such a blessing.
Omg, I had a similar experience. I saw a gifset of the red wedding deaths in Tumblr and I thought, "this looks very intense and impressive, I'll start watching" so I knew all along looool. I usually don't mind being spoiled but I kinda regret it being this one thing.
To this day i still remember reading this scene, about 20 years ago when this book came out. I got to the scene, i read it and turned the page to the next chapter and i just sat there for a solid 30 minutes thinking about what i just read. I put the book down and i didnt finish reading it for almost a year. I know your reaction well, the TV series really did this scene justice, even with the changes they made.
I remember reading this in the books before Season 3 aired, and was heart broken. But now I knew to expect my favorite characters to get whacked, after they killed Robert and Ned off. I also remember a Dave and Dan interview where this was the episode they were looking forward to filming and showing the most. Game of Thrones, never a happy ending.
A trivia about the Red Wedding. Everyone who planned the Red Wedding ended up dead in the same way. Roose Bolton got stabbed by Ramsay ( He killed Robb by stabbing) Walder Frey got his throat slit by Arya (His soldier slit Catelyn's throat) House Frey were poisoned by Arya (Robb's army were tricked into drinking by Lannister and Frey soldier) Tywin Lannister was shot with a crossbow by Tyrion ( Catelyn and Robb were injured by crossbow shots)
I like how everyone is so kind and they don't try and give Magy spoilers, may that continue so that she can enjoy the series like we all did. Of course we were all waiting for your reaction to this episode 😀
Well you knew Magy would react poorly to this episode, so that makes you a sadist for making THIS the episode you waited for and wanted to see her react to.
@@jeffburnham6611 It’s literally a reaction channel. Everyone who ever watched this show went through this. Go outside, talk to a real girl, stop simping for a RUclipsr.
@@jeffburnham6611 get it right, it's called emotional vampire, and that's what we, excluding you of course, are. But then, we're not here trying to suck, no pun intended, well maybe a little intended, up to anyone. Our GoT family own what we are.
How wonderful is it, that something as simple as a story, written and performed can evoke such pure emotion from people. It goes a long way to say how well a thing is made
It's not their anthem. It's a song that was written after the Lannisters utterly destroyed another House. Basically a small house rebelled against the Lannisters and Tywin wiped them all out. He literally had every man, woman and child of the smaller house killed. It's a very infamous song in Westeros and when Catelyn hears it she instantly knows what is going to happen but it's too late.
@@Riggswolfe I know. But I said that it was their "anthem" because it would be too long to explain. Don't forget that I talked to a person who doesn't know everything about the universe of Game of Thrones.
@@Riggswolfe So it's actually the opposite! The Lannisters used to be a much smaller house but one of their ancestors (Lann The Clever) tricked the Casterly's out of their castle and destroyed the entire family to take their place. That's why their home is still called Casterly Rock.
@@EmeraldDreams7 But that's not what the song is about. This song is about how Tywin annihilated house Reyne of Castamere, a vassal house that got too big for their boots. The song is basically a boast: stand up to house Lannister, and all that will be left is broken stone and ghosts.
I'm late to the party but I felt the same way. It was so sad. I had no idea what was going to happen. Was so excited for Rob his queen and all the starks. I cried to. Love your reactions!
Lol it was easy to tell which part of the video the red wedding was in, just scrolling through the thumbnail I can see Magy with a big glowing grin on her face all the time up until a certain point in the video where the grin is completely gone.
Jon Snow didn't take Ygrette with him because the Night's Watch would kill her. He knew she would be safer with the Wildlings as long as she didn't kill any. That is why he stopped her from defending him. Great reaction to the emotional "Red Wedding" episode, poor Magy..
In the books, The Red Wedding is from Catelyn's POV. She went mad after Robb gets killed and started scratching her face before her throat was slit and was thinking don't cut her hair..Ned loves her hair 🥺🥺
Uh, bless her sweet heart! I have never seen anyone react so 2 things: 1. truthfully to the whole episode, scene by scene 2. so happy to the 1st part, which was half decent at best Uh, just bless her sweet little heart!
(From the third A Song of Ice and Fire book "A Storm of Swords") Tywin: The blood is on Walder Frey's hands, not mine. Tyrion: Walder Frey is a peevish old man who lives to fondle his young wife and brood over all the slights he's suffered. I have no doubt he hatched this ugly chicken, but he would never have dared such a thing without a promise of protection. Tywin: I suppose you would have spared the boy and told Lord Frey you had no need of his allegiance? That would have driven the old fool right back into Stark's arms and won you another year of war. Explain to me why it is more noble to kill ten thousand men in battle than a dozen at dinner.
I remember watching this with my friends, and when the episode ended we were all just silent form what felt like an hour. I think this episode has rightfully earned its spot as one of the most heart breaking episodes of any show made.
One of the best reactions I've seen... takes me back to the first time I watched this with friends who read the books and just waited for our shock and breakdown... don't worry Magy the North remembers.
Everyone who has seen game of thrones was eagerly waiting for your reaction to this episode...you didn't disappoint Magy. I think many fans of the show needed therapy after watching this episode.
The joy and happiness Maggy has early in the wedding...and even being annoyed at Kat's nervousness when the Rains of Castamere is being played. Me: 🥺 Oh this will be shatter her heart 💔
An episode "9" reaction? Ooh. Clicks on link. Starts video. Aah, there's her smile, so giddy, so welcome. Notices the title of video, re-reads the title... SEASON 3... episode 9... :/ Look back at video... SUCH a big happy smile on her face. I can't do this. I can't start the weekend like this. I can't watch this. --- I shall return :/
@@paulfeist Not all of us.We book readers knew what was coming because we already had been traumatized by the books years before. Though the show upped the ante somewhat because Rob was so much younger in the books (I think he's 15 in the books or close to it) and they added his genuine relationship with his wife (in the books he married a Westerosi noble man's daughter he had sex with when he was recovering from a battle against her father's forces, who were allied with the Lannisters. She wasn't present at the wedding and her family had ensured that she didn't become pregnant). We were all expecting betrayal from Talisa at some point, so seeing her get stabbed in the belly by Lothar Frey was even shocking to us.
@@YouHaventSeenMeRight I started the books after starting the show. I tried to stay "behind" in the books as I watched. It was like getting the "cliff notes" before reading the book. I wasn't to the Red Wedding yet when it happened in the show. It was brutal. Masterfully filmed!
This is the turning point of the show. Once you’ve reached this point, it’s almost like reaching the halfway point to the summit of Mt. Everest. You’re committed now, no turning back. But the road ahead looks so bleak after what you’ve just been through. Man, this show was good. Hands down the most shocking, brutal, mind blowing bit of storytelling I’ve ever witnessed. Truly a master stroke.
Thank you, Magy, for one of the best reactions in GOT history. I wish I could click the like button a hundred times for you. I need to download this to watch over and over. 😍😍😍😍😍
I haven’t started the RUclips video yet, but oh dear god I already know when I see Magy crying that I’m gonna start crying with her! Edit: yup I’m balling just as much her 🥺😭😭 I know how you feel watching your favorite characters die like that it was hard for me to watch to I started screaming at my laptop and slammed it shut afterwards and cried too, but hang in there, girl!
One of the last things Catelyn Stark (Rob Starks Mother) thought of before she died was "Make it stop hurting Ned". Broke my heart when I read that in the books 😥
It is sad but just think, how good a show must be, to get reactions like that. It's beautiful really. No character is safe at any moment and not many other shows are like that, it makes it very special. A masterpiece. To make you feel these feelings, it must be.
I have to say first, that i too LOVE this show. I have seen many different crowd reactions, and MAGY, BY FAR, YOU HAVE THE BEST REACTION THAT MIRRORED MINE THAT I HAVE SEEN THUS FAR!! THE SADNESS, ANGER, AND JOY, IS INDICATIVE OF WHAT A MASTERPIECE THIS SHOW HAS BECOME. THANK YOU!!
😭 this episode was a huge shock to everyone 💔... I wish I could give you a big hug Magy 😢.... This is one of the hardest episodes of the series and it always hurts to lose your favorite characters. But I hope you continue to watch, because there is amazing moments to come in later seasons.
This is THE EPISODE! Definitely the best episode of the series imo. This episode changed everything. This changed the game completely. It revolutionized this show and pulled off one of the best twists ever.
They stabbed Charlie Chaplin’s granddaughter right in the baby. Talk about holding malice, haha. The reactions to this great show are so entertaining to watch.
"I'm so done w GOT" We all said this several times during the series Magy. You have to get through some dark stuff to reach the other side. Great reaction as always!
What an honest and beautiful reaction, knowing what would come I was totally at a loss of words when u said "This is such a nice wedding" with that huge smile all over ur face, then those tears in the end broke my heart :(
Poor child was so happy. By the end of the video her mascara was all over her face and the way she said thankyou for watching and see you in next episode, made her sound dejected of life. Poor soul!
I almost couldn't bear watching this one. Magy was so HAPPY watching the wedding. And all the while, I knew what was coming, and I couldn't warn her. I couldn't warn Magy, I couldn't warn Robb. I couldn't warn any of them. I remember the day this episode came out. I remember the next day when you instantly knew who was a GoT fan or not.... we were all very sad that day. The Stark motto is "Winter is Coming".... Now you know what "winter" looks like. (big hug from a GoT fan who knows how you feel!)
I remember I was watching this when I was in the hospital and when this happened, I accidentally screamed ” nooooo!" so loud that 2 nurses ran into my room
Yeah the North remembers....and I also remember the first time I saw this episode.. I never wanted to watch GoT again, and that's kinda the best about it. Because I did.
Such a gut wrenching episode - probably the most shocking and heartbreaking in the entire series. Your reaction broke my heart again - cheers to you Magy for powering through!
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
13:20 Magy: "this is such a nice wedding, this is such a nice episode!"
Me: oh, my poor child...
Oh for real!
oh my sweet summer child
Me: is it though???
*You stole my comment.*
IDK, I kinda liked it! Very successful wedding by Dothraki standards. 😎
"They're so happy. This is such a nice wedding" Oh man.....my heart sunk when she said that
Love your Karl icon. Haven't seen it in years. "So, a knob a night, is it."
Don't buy it, seemed overacted.
Mine too. Honestly I was dreading the chain mail moment watching this reaction.
sank*
Seeing her so happy and excited at the start of the episode is just going to make this even harder to watch.
@@Mr.Ekshin LMAO!
Oh no
The funny thing is that she watch back to back episodes so her intro for the next one wasn't as happy as this one. She did a side by side of her intros on her ig story a few days ago haha
Salt to the wound
Ikr? I was like, "oh no, this won't end well."
13:15
Magy: "This is such a nice wedding. This is such a nice episode."
Ramsay Bolton, 3 episodes ago: "If you think this has a happy ending, you haven't been paying attention."
Maggy at the beginning: "that was easy."
Me: "oh girl, you are in for a world of pain"
Magy: "What a nice wedding! They look so happy!"
Me: "Oh you sweet summer child.."
Poor Magy. She didn't realize how dark this show really is.
really dark show
15:06-16:06 -- The series of reactions in precise order of every GoT viewer. :)
The saddest part was the excitement she had when the video started lol. Hope ure feeling better :)
Ramsey from future: Well, about that-
Sweet summer child
The most famous lines from the Game of Thrones:
#1 "Winter is Coming"
#2 "I'm so Done with Game of Thrones!"
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
yesss😂the second one
Yo Know nothing Magy¡¡
Thank you for being so vulnerable. This episode was devistating when I first watched it. I almost stopped watching the show. But I'm glad I continued. There are more tragic deaths, but there are no scenes as brutal as this one. You've made it through the worst.
"Im so done with GOT" was the line I muttered to myself most during Season 8.
The messiest reaction I have ever seen..........I'm so done with GOT.................
Fun fact. This episode pretty much started the modern trend of reaction videos on RUclips.
Well not quite, it was a thing long before then. But it and some other viral reaction videos made it a fad.
I think skybound was doing walking dead reactions before but I’m too lazy to fact check
2girls1cup - 2007
Red wedding - 2013
Thats not true.
Guys I'm not saying people didn't react to videos beforehand. Reacting to things is NOT a new concept. They had game shows built around that concept back in the 80's. There were plenty of viral videos that people reacted to before. But there were no reaction channels, and people were not reacting to tv series and movies. That was 100% the Red Wedding that sparked it.
It's pretty incredible you didn't have this spoiled for you. This is a difficult episode to watch, especially by yourself.
None of the show luckily was spoiled for me. I just finished it a few weeks ago. I watched this episode on the way to a job site and cried in front of my coworkers...I work in construction. Most awkward day ever.
But not the most difficult...
Spoiler alert!!! The most stressful was probably Battle of the bastards. The most emotional was easily IMO the great war at winterfel
@@brandynkoogler4500 dont you people realize even these kind of comments spoil future episodes and plot lines. Jeez, and you just said you were lucky nothing was spoiled for you.
@@akubuckbee7242 zero spoilers actually, except the names of the battles. If you've never seen the show, that tells you absolutely nothing about what happens other than a battle which is pretty normal for Game of Thrones. Big whoop. I didn't spoil anything with regards to the story. So calm down it will be okay.
Magy: "Such a nice wedding, look at how happy they are"
The rest of us: My sweet summer child...
Well girl, you're no longer a little summer child... welcome to the winter childs
Not until hardhome
@@seancarroll5803 shhhh
*children
@@seancarroll5803 Or hodor
@callmecatalyst chill out Karen, I was just making a comment, no need to slit my throat over it 😉
This is how many sadists smiles while people are in pain.....the black tear running down the cheek tho. i feel bad for magy
Aw the Red Wedding 😔
Shout out to my fellow Song of Ice and Fire book readers who knew about the Red Wedding for 13 years and didn't spoil it for fans the TV show 🤘
It was hard not to. But, we wanted it to be as shocking for them as it was for us.
That is how the whole react thing started lol people filming their friends and families reaction knowing what was coming
The hardest thing was my co-workers all knew I read the book and I had to pretend that nothing was coming. A female coworker loved Rob Stark's character and thought he was going to be the main character for that season. I had to play along. She called in sick that Monday because she was so upset. I do have to say, that Friday before the Red Wedding was interesting. They had no idea what was coming.
@@TheKukulkan it was almost the same for me! i had coworkers who were fans of the show but hadn't read the books, so when season 3 rolled around I had to really play coy/quiet about the big spoilers. A lot of them were Robb Stark fans too, so it was almost painful watching them glow about him and knowing his fate. That monday after the red wedding episode they all went up to me crushed like "YOU KNEW ABOUT THIS?!?!"
@@roboj After that episode, almost all my coworkers bought the books. This one episode made all of them readers or RR Martin's work. Like you everyone at work was upset that I sat on this information. They later thanked me because I did not spoil it for them. One co worker loved the show/books so much she called her daughter Arya. The entire office was into this show and I could not be the one that spoiled even the smallest hint of what's to come.
Her: "this is such a nice wedding"
Everyone: "ohhhh dear"
When she said I'm so done with Game of Thrones I can't tell you how much we all felt the same
I was all in with this episode. This one pulled me in. Anything can happen - that's a great thing in a TV show. The way they ended the whole thing is what ruined it for me.
It wasn't hard for me. I had read the book and was looking forward to it.
"I'm so done with Game of Thrones."
It's soooooo not the last time you will say this, dear. Cry it out, Chin up, and buckle yourself in.
@@christopherrousseau1173 There were only two people in the world the night it aired. Those who read the books and those who didn't. And those who read it were waiting to watch the reactions of those that didn't. Even more so then the show.
@@DarthTach and that basically starten the whole reaction culture.
Actually adorable how Magy stands up in a rage and doesn’t look any taller than when she was sitting. 😂
Sorry Magy. This was hard for all of us. Things will get better! And you don't have to wait an entire year for Season 4.
Things will get better?? Setting the poor girl up for heartbreak...
@@shawn7257 Yeah, "get better" is not something that sounds very accurate to me. Think about all the things they are still going to do... LOL
yes, things will get better, but they won't stay better.
@@shawn7257 i mean in upcoming 2-3 episode a certain someone will FINALLY die.. so THAT'S a good thing 🤷♀️
@@rishikagupta6061 No need for spoilers mate
15:50 was the entire fandom when that aired. Book readers were gleefully watching everyone’s souls get crushed and show watchers universally declared they would quit the series.
Neither my gf nor I had read the books. When this episode aired, she had a very Magy-like reaction (with a lot more hiding behind pillows though). I just watched with wide eyes and mouth open, thinking, "This is crazy but it's brilliant!" I love storytelling, including all the ups and downs, and the severe, unexpected turn in this episode made me even more of a fan than I already was. It didn't crush my soul because, although I was sad to see the characters go, it was artistically an amazing choice and I loved it. Definitely one of my favorite episodes of the series.
@@johnplaysgames3120
Find a way to read the scene in the book. Even the writing of it was amazing. "10 angry ravens raked at her face..." It was in Catlyn's POV, and she lost her mind and scratched up her face right before she FELT the blade at her throat,,and the chapter,ended on that cliffhanger. We didn't get confirmation that she was actually CUT in the throat until several chapters later, through dialogue, rumors, and a really awesome dream-turned-warging scene.
There's also something super duper fuggin awesome that follows this specific storyline, and they didnt. Put it. In. The show. I wanted to punch them. It would have been so badass. And satisfying, after this scene.
I can’t be the only exception though? Despite being a history buff and know a lot of real life situation in history where scenes of “red wedding” actually happened, my friends thought I would enjoy Game of Thrones, but in reality, I couldn’t even root for Robb, his father’s death was normal, there are many instances what Ned did, did actually happened in RL, like 80% got beheaded or burned or killed, 10% got tortured and 10% rot in jail until died of diseases or old age. What Robb was doing was extremely foolish, how many Kings were killed by a clan? In game of thrones there was only 2 players. Based how the series was going until season 5, I stopped, it was clear to me who will be the last two to grab the title, but both of them are not the players, wasn’t interested in both of them. People could say a lot of people were playing the game but, honestly, most of them are tools or trading cards, have power, but not playing the game, if you realised, the one player that was on defensive was removed before the second player realise he was on offensive. So it was a game that nobody played against each other, anyone who have both of the players would win the game, but no one gave a shit.
She: "This is a nice episode!"
So soon to say it my darling ... so soon
well that made it look so good and at the end😞
@@MagicMagy Were you interested of GOT before and late in watching it due to your age? I wonder at your age do you appreciate the entertainment value or intrigue with this series? After all GOT is a global phenomenon compared to some other American shows.
“This is such a nice wedding!”
10 photos taken right before disaster
14:17
This song is the Rains of Castamere. This is the reason why Catelyn was worried, because it's the song of House Lannister.
You might heard this song after the Battle Of Blackwater episode during the credits.
Furthermore, when that song was played it signals the Frey and Bolton to turned on the Starks and Tully army outside the Twins.
"and who are you, the proud lord said, that I must bow so low? But only a cat of a different coat is all the truth I know, with coat of GOLD🔶 AND A COAT OF RED 🔴 THE LION 🦁 STILL HAS CLAWS, AND MINE ARE LOND AND SHARP MY LORD IS ALL THE TRUTH I KNOW..... AND SO HE SPOKE AND SO HE SPOKE THAT LORD OF CASTAMERE AND NOW THE RAINS WE PORE HIS HALLS WITH NONE A SOUL TO HEAR....
Catelyn was always smart and understood the political nuances of _Game_ of _Thrones_ ...I wasn't surprised that she knew something was wrong before it happened. It's too bad that Ned Stark didn't listen to his wife or he would have still be alive.
@@luminatrixfanfiction Cat also made some serious errors, like arresting Tyrion, which was cause enough for Jaime to lance Ned and kill his guard, and arrest him......and we all know how that ended up.
"Aww, they're so, so happy." That's called foreshadowing in The Game of Thrones.
Finally got to the episode that changed everything. The Red Wedding. This does the book justice. The horror just keeps going and going. I had to watch this episode with my friends because I already knew what was coming. This actually made one of my friends break his phone (on accident). He was more upset about this episode than his phone. This feeling you have....it stays with you for almost the entire series and just makes you hate the Lannisters more and more you think about it.
If I had the Tanos ganlet with all the stone I would snap for Game Of Thrones showrunner 😣
@starlord the best guardian The thing is in the book Rob Stark married a Lannister Cousin. She was "kidnapped" moments before the wedding. These changes from the book made the show interesting
for those who read the book. The killing of the pregnant wife was a kick in the gut for us book readers. After this we waited for Lady Stoneheart but she never showed. I am happy that they did the book justice, but it was tough. I cried and I knew it was coming.
@@grego-geek Thanos.... Not tanos
@@TheKukulkan I remember when I read the books I somewhat suspected him meeting this cousin was all a setup by the Lannisters to put a rift between the Starks and Freys. I don't think they knew it'd pay off this well though. In the show that's all pretty neatly avoided though.
@@TheKukulkan "The thing is in the book Rob Stark married a Lannister Cousin."
Jeyne Westerling is not a Lannister cousin
"She was "kidnapped" moments before the wedding."
She wasn't there at all, Robb wanted her to stay at Riverrun with the Blackfish
Even though it made us all feel like shit after, this has to be the most brilliant episode in television history.
Literally caught the whole audience by surprise.
Except those of us who had read the books.
*Cough* Ozymandys
Book readers were rubbing their hands in silent glee for two years just waiting for this
@@vighneshpillai7996the Red Wedding > Ozymandias
@@Mycernius That was your silly mistake. One should never read the books. 😃 But in all seriousness. For me it's better to read the books afterwards, to fill in the details missed by the show. I'm visual so books do nothing for me other than provide rote information. I can't get excited or emotional or even visualize the action from a book.
Well, now you know to expect it. George RR Martin who wrote the books said in an interview "You know you watch something like Spiderman and you see him backed up in a corner against 20 thugs and he beats them all up with ease. You are never scared for him, but in Game Of Thrones no matter if you are the main character or not if its unrealistic for you to survive then you wont."
This is, until Benioff and Weiss replaced Martin's narrative with Hollywood sh*t.
Of course, that's all utter nonsense, because who lives or dies has nothing to do with realism and everything with what GRRM wants to happen.
If realism was an issue, Tywin Lannister would have thanked the Freys, then have them hung, drawn and quartered and sent their bits and pieces to all the seven kingdoms as an illustration as to what happens to people who break their oath of fealty. You don't reward people who put the axe to the foundations of the social compact and scoff at the very foundation of your own agency and power.
The "inspirations" GRRM has cited in the past for the Red Wedding have precious little in common - both with each other and the Red Wedding - other than people being surprisingly killed.
@@victormanteca7395
Oh my sweet summer child. You still believe that they introduced wholly original ideas. They may have rushed the ending, but I can guarantee you that what the narrative was based on GRRM's notes.
Of course, given the "speed" at which he progresses, he has every opportunity to disavow his own words and change his concept in order to distance himself from the outcry. That is, if he ever bothers to finish the stuff instead of raking in HBO cash for prequels.
@@ohauss Possibly; still that does not explain the egregious amount of plot armor we saw in the last seasons.
@@ohauss George RR Martin has repeatedly changed his story outline. I wouldn't put it out of question that he changed it again after seeing the backlash to the last season. Could be a reason for why it takes him so long to get winds out.
You where wondering why she was so worried when they started playing the music. Because it was the song of the house Lannister.
We need to get Magy some waterproof mascara. She's gonna need it for this series!
oh no ,please say that I won’t need it
I was not prepared for how this reaction ended Magy. I just want to hug you!
@@MagicMagy OK. I'll say it. "you won't need it." But, I hate having to lie to you.
@@MagicMagy better to be prepared just in case. Game of thrones has a lot of twists and turns
she needs to buy some before season 5 episode 10
Magy: "I'm so done with Game of Thrones!"
Me: "Don't worry Magy...the North remembers!"
Without a doubt, one of the most heartbreaking episodes of the entire series. I'm a grown man and literally had the same reaction as you when it first aired.
The show BUTCHERED The North Remembers plot
@@ben1ben2ben1ow? Jon Snow and Sansa literally avenged one half of the Red Wedding by ending the Boltons, and Arya avenged the other half by killing the Freys. The third half was avenged by Tyrion when he murdered his own father. How was "The North Remembers" butchered? It may not be as good as it was in the books, where grand conspiracies are coming, but it was still good
@@nikoloznasaridze6328 well this isnt at all a spoiler
@@nikoloznasaridze6328 I'm not sure you know how halves work.
Fun fact from one of the biggest GoT fans ever:
This was my introduction to the series. First episode I watched. I had a friend that had read the books and thought this would happen in episode 10, so he said it would be fine for me to watch with them and get a feel for the series. I watched this the morning after it aired and immediately bought all of the books and began watching the series. He apologized profusely, but having this bandaid ripped off before I had a chance to love Robb was such a blessing.
lol
Omg, I had a similar experience. I saw a gifset of the red wedding deaths in Tumblr and I thought, "this looks very intense and impressive, I'll start watching" so I knew all along looool. I usually don't mind being spoiled but I kinda regret it being this one thing.
"They are all so happy."
- Oh you sweet summer child.
To this day i still remember reading this scene, about 20 years ago when this book came out. I got to the scene, i read it and turned the page to the next chapter and i just sat there for a solid 30 minutes thinking about what i just read. I put the book down and i didnt finish reading it for almost a year. I know your reaction well, the TV series really did this scene justice, even with the changes they made.
Now I want to see Maggie reacting to her reaction of this episode. Seeing herself so joyful and excited before it all happened
I can’t even watch the episode again,maybe after a year I will have the strength haha
@@MagicMagy how do you feel about the idea now that a year has passed?
It's a fine idea!
Dang! Magy watching the Red Wedding and Duaffy watching Infinity War on the same morning.
yep, about to indulge my appetite for tears of sorrow 😭😋
@@shadowfire_08 🐸🍵
funny how i just did that lol
Hehe, same here.
Oh, so we all follow some beautiful ladies? Go subscribe to SuperMechaFrieza as well, then.
Her: "I'm super excited for this episode"
Me: Yeah, that's what they all say. Before.
I remember reading this in the books before Season 3 aired, and was heart broken. But now I knew to expect my favorite characters to get whacked, after they killed Robert and Ned off. I also remember a Dave and Dan interview where this was the episode they were looking forward to filming and showing the most. Game of Thrones, never a happy ending.
A trivia about the Red Wedding. Everyone who planned the Red Wedding ended up dead in the same way.
Roose Bolton got stabbed by Ramsay ( He killed Robb by stabbing)
Walder Frey got his throat slit by Arya (His soldier slit Catelyn's throat)
House Frey were poisoned by Arya (Robb's army were tricked into drinking by Lannister and Frey soldier)
Tywin Lannister was shot with a crossbow by Tyrion ( Catelyn and Robb were injured by crossbow shots)
12:25 jorah looked like that because he loves dany and was jealous
I like how everyone is so kind and they don't try and give Magy spoilers, may that continue so that she can enjoy the series like we all did. Of course we were all waiting for your reaction to this episode 😀
Oh poor Magy, I'm so sorry, but this was the moment we've all been waiting for since you started with episode 1😘
Well you knew Magy would react poorly to this episode, so that makes you a sadist for making THIS the episode you waited for and wanted to see her react to.
@@jeffburnham6611 Dude, you're serious? 😅
@@jeffburnham6611 It’s literally a reaction channel. Everyone who ever watched this show went through this. Go outside, talk to a real girl, stop simping for a RUclipsr.
@@jeffburnham6611 get it right, it's called emotional vampire, and that's what we, excluding you of course, are. But then, we're not here trying to suck, no pun intended, well maybe a little intended, up to anyone. Our GoT family own what we are.
I can't wait for 4x2 "Purple"
How wonderful is it, that something as simple as a story, written and performed can evoke such pure emotion from people. It goes a long way to say how well a thing is made
Catelyn is weird because the music playing is the Lannister's anthem: the rains of Castamere.
It's not their anthem. It's a song that was written after the Lannisters utterly destroyed another House. Basically a small house rebelled against the Lannisters and Tywin wiped them all out. He literally had every man, woman and child of the smaller house killed. It's a very infamous song in Westeros and when Catelyn hears it she instantly knows what is going to happen but it's too late.
@@Riggswolfe I know. But I said that it was their "anthem" because it would be too long to explain. Don't forget that I talked to a person who doesn't know everything about the universe of Game of Thrones.
@@sachamnc17 Fair enough.
@@Riggswolfe So it's actually the opposite! The Lannisters used to be a much smaller house but one of their ancestors (Lann The Clever) tricked the Casterly's out of their castle and destroyed the entire family to take their place. That's why their home is still called Casterly Rock.
@@EmeraldDreams7 But that's not what the song is about. This song is about how Tywin annihilated house Reyne of Castamere, a vassal house that got too big for their boots. The song is basically a boast: stand up to house Lannister, and all that will be left is broken stone and ghosts.
I'm late to the party but I felt the same way. It was so sad. I had no idea what was going to happen. Was so excited for Rob his queen and all the starks. I cried to. Love your reactions!
Almost feel bad saying that as she’s gotten closer to this episode I’ve been looking forward to it more and more.
Dont be done.. want revenge.
We will remember
I’m looking forward to ‘Hold the door’ 😂😂😂
@@drummerboy2834 I actually like the next episode it took me a month to watch it after this 1 though lol
Lol it was easy to tell which part of the video the red wedding was in, just scrolling through the thumbnail I can see Magy with a big glowing grin on her face all the time up until a certain point in the video where the grin is completely gone.
Finally a woman of winter.
@Not Alfie i agree
Jon Snow didn't take Ygrette with him because the Night's Watch would kill her. He knew she would be safer with the Wildlings as long as she didn't kill any. That is why he stopped her from defending him.
Great reaction to the emotional "Red Wedding" episode, poor Magy..
13:17: "That a nice wedding" me: reeeealy (with knowledge what's coming)
It's an honest and genuine reaction. Its exactly how I reacted while watching this episode. Loads of love and blessings from India.
She went from happy to confused to sad then full on depression at the end. This episode played with our emotions
Poor Magy. All of your fans are sending you virtual hugs.
The Red Wedding is what started the whole "TV reaction" trend on RUclips.
Yeah, that and TWD's Hershell. I remember bingeing reactions to both of those around the same time.
In the books, The Red Wedding is from Catelyn's POV. She went mad after Robb gets killed and started scratching her face before her throat was slit and was thinking don't cut her hair..Ned loves her hair 🥺🥺
And she comes back to life unlike the show
and Robb may have warged Greywind because Greywind goes nuts and kills dozens....his last word was Greywind not mother like in the show
Uh, bless her sweet heart! I have never seen anyone react so 2 things:
1. truthfully to the whole episode, scene by scene
2. so happy to the 1st part, which was half decent at best
Uh, just bless her sweet little heart!
(From the third A Song of Ice and Fire book "A Storm of Swords")
Tywin: The blood is on Walder Frey's hands, not mine.
Tyrion: Walder Frey is a peevish old man who lives to fondle his young wife and brood over all the slights he's suffered. I have no doubt he hatched this ugly chicken, but he would never have dared such a thing without a promise of protection.
Tywin: I suppose you would have spared the boy and told Lord Frey you had no need of his allegiance? That would have driven the old fool right back into Stark's arms and won you another year of war. Explain to me why it is more noble to kill ten thousand men in battle than a dozen at dinner.
I remember watching this with my friends, and when the episode ended we were all just silent form what felt like an hour. I think this episode has rightfully earned its spot as one of the most heart breaking episodes of any show made.
Seeing your tears in this episode absolutely broke my heart 💔😭
13:20 "This is such a nice wedding".
Me: Famous last words
One of the best reactions I've seen... takes me back to the first time I watched this with friends who read the books and just waited for our shock and breakdown... don't worry Magy the North remembers.
Everyone who has seen game of thrones was eagerly waiting for your reaction to this episode...you didn't disappoint Magy. I think many fans of the show needed therapy after watching this episode.
well at least I know I needed
The joy and happiness Maggy has early in the wedding...and even being annoyed at Kat's nervousness when the Rains of Castamere is being played.
Me: 🥺 Oh this will be shatter her heart 💔
An episode "9" reaction?
Ooh.
Clicks on link.
Starts video. Aah, there's her smile, so giddy, so welcome.
Notices the title of video, re-reads the title... SEASON 3... episode 9...
:/
Look back at video... SUCH a big happy smile on her face.
I can't do this. I can't start the weekend like this.
I can't watch this.
--- I shall return :/
well it ruined my mood and weekend too so I can understand you perfectly 😞❤️
@@MagicMagy We understand! That was us when this episode first aired... only we were ALL caught unprepared.
@@paulfeist Not all of us.We book readers knew what was coming because we already had been traumatized by the books years before. Though the show upped the ante somewhat because Rob was so much younger in the books (I think he's 15 in the books or close to it) and they added his genuine relationship with his wife (in the books he married a Westerosi noble man's daughter he had sex with when he was recovering from a battle against her father's forces, who were allied with the Lannisters. She wasn't present at the wedding and her family had ensured that she didn't become pregnant). We were all expecting betrayal from Talisa at some point, so seeing her get stabbed in the belly by Lothar Frey was even shocking to us.
@@YouHaventSeenMeRight I started the books after starting the show. I tried to stay "behind" in the books as I watched. It was like getting the "cliff notes" before reading the book. I wasn't to the Red Wedding yet when it happened in the show. It was brutal. Masterfully filmed!
This is the turning point of the show. Once you’ve reached this point, it’s almost like reaching the halfway point to the summit of Mt. Everest. You’re committed now, no turning back. But the road ahead looks so bleak after what you’ve just been through.
Man, this show was good. Hands down the most shocking, brutal, mind blowing bit of storytelling I’ve ever witnessed. Truly a master stroke.
Thank you, Magy, for one of the best reactions in GOT history. I wish I could click the like button a hundred times for you. I need to download this to watch over and over. 😍😍😍😍😍
I came here to witness this pure and nice soul of this woman crumbles. Welcome, my sister, you became one of us now.
This is the power of writing. Thank You George RR Martin, I've given up hope on the show and now am eagerly waiting for the books
"I've given up hope on the show" What????? You mean they aren't going to re-film Season 8? ;-)
Watching people react to this episode never gets old
I haven’t started the RUclips video yet, but oh dear god I already know when I see Magy crying that I’m gonna start crying with her!
Edit: yup I’m balling just as much her 🥺😭😭 I know how you feel watching your favorite characters die like that it was hard for me to watch to I started screaming at my laptop and slammed it shut afterwards and cried too, but hang in there, girl!
One of the last things Catelyn Stark (Rob Starks Mother) thought of before she died was "Make it stop hurting Ned". Broke my heart when I read that in the books 😥
Magy: "I'm done with Game of thrones"
Me: Save it season 8 lmao
"she's still alive.. please tell me she's gonna run away..."
show them how it feels to lose what they love - Catelyn Stark
Officially, this was the best reaction to the red wedding, I ever seen
It is sad but just think, how good a show must be, to get reactions like that. It's beautiful really. No character is safe at any moment and not many other shows are like that, it makes it very special. A masterpiece. To make you feel these feelings, it must be.
“Such a happy episode” - you’re about to loose all innocence
Sweet Magy. Just know that many of us who have seen this episode dozens of times, felt your pain and shed tears along with you.
"why does she look so worried" Oh sweet summer child.
You can't be done with Game of Thrones. Without this emotion, what would it be? This emotion is the reason it's great.
Your reaction is right from the heart and I loved it. Keep doing this.
I have to say first, that i too LOVE this show. I have seen many different crowd reactions, and MAGY, BY FAR, YOU HAVE THE BEST REACTION THAT MIRRORED MINE THAT I HAVE SEEN THUS FAR!! THE SADNESS, ANGER, AND JOY, IS INDICATIVE OF WHAT A MASTERPIECE THIS SHOW HAS BECOME. THANK YOU!!
What an evil scene. The way it was done was vicious
😭 this episode was a huge shock to everyone 💔... I wish I could give you a big hug Magy 😢.... This is one of the hardest episodes of the series and it always hurts to lose your favorite characters. But I hope you continue to watch, because there is amazing moments to come in later seasons.
I feel for you, that was a really hard episode to watch.
This is THE EPISODE! Definitely the best episode of the series imo. This episode changed everything. This changed the game completely. It revolutionized this show and pulled off one of the best twists ever.
I have waited for this so long. One of the best reactions ever. 😁😁😁👍👍👍
Rains of Castamere is Lannisters song, their biggest enemies song, that's why she got worried when they started playing it
They stabbed Charlie Chaplin’s granddaughter right in the baby. Talk about holding malice, haha. The reactions to this great show are so entertaining to watch.
Hey Magy. That might be the fastest I've ever seen someone go from denial to anger to depression. Keep ya head up better episodes to come.
"I'm so done w GOT" We all said this several times during the series Magy. You have to get through some dark stuff to reach the other side. Great reaction as always!
What an honest and beautiful reaction, knowing what would come I was totally at a loss of words when u said "This is such a nice wedding" with that huge smile all over ur face, then those tears in the end broke my heart :(
"I"m so done with Game of Thrones!" Yup, that's what everyone says after they watch this episode...LOL.
Poor child was so happy. By the end of the video her mascara was all over her face and the way she said thankyou for watching and see you in next episode, made her sound dejected of life. Poor soul!
I almost couldn't bear watching this one. Magy was so HAPPY watching the wedding. And all the while, I knew what was coming, and I couldn't warn her. I couldn't warn Magy, I couldn't warn Robb. I couldn't warn any of them.
I remember the day this episode came out. I remember the next day when you instantly knew who was a GoT fan or not.... we were all very sad that day.
The Stark motto is "Winter is Coming".... Now you know what "winter" looks like. (big hug from a GoT fan who knows how you feel!)
"You are so lucky my guy!" LMFAO that was great
Imagine having to wait a whole week after this episode to see the next one.
oh no no no ,I could never ,I am so sorry for the people who had to do that
At least it was only a week since it was episode 9. Imagine if it was a season finale and you had to wait a whole year for the next one? 😉
@@boldwulf879 Hey hey hey I know what are you talking about :P
She's a legend, so many subscribers and she still likes most of the comments ❤️
'This is such a nice wedding'
I remember I was watching this when I was in the hospital and when this happened, I accidentally screamed ” nooooo!" so loud that 2 nurses ran into my room
Yeah the North remembers....and I also remember the first time I saw this episode.. I never wanted to watch GoT again, and that's kinda the best about it. Because I did.
Such a gut wrenching episode - probably the most shocking and heartbreaking in the entire series. Your reaction broke my heart again - cheers to you Magy for powering through!
17:00 I feel like King Jeoffrey, because I enjoy seeing you cry 😝
15:18- 20:35 the most striking and very dramatic reaction.I cried myself when I saw such a scene.