PES - despite all its faults- still remains the superior football simulator for me. Yes, FIFA is superior in all the areas off the pitch, and I'll concede that it seems to have improved on the pitch as well. Nevertheless, PES 2019 is at least attempting to accurately recreate how football is actually played at the top level, whereas FIFA is more of an unrealistic goals fest. Yet I must admit I'm very frustrated with PES' AI this year; the PC mods show that there's no excuse for such shoddy and repetitive gameplay. Konami really need to sort the AI out.
I agree, using your defenders to track runners and stop low crosses at the front post is very simple. But that creates another problem: the AI isn't enough of a challenge. Low crossing isn't the only problem either; wingers don't use enough skill, strikers and midfielders rarely shoot outside the box and AI defensive decisions can sometimes make it too easy to score. Yet I still think it's the best football game ever made.
@mohd ikram: No. People play Fifa because it has proper physics, momentum, presentation, commentary, user interface, user experience, online, modes, depth, seamless gameplay, licenses, tactics, variety of teams and stadiums, atmosphere, shooting system, defense mechanism. Also mainly because Pes sucks.
PES transfer fees kinda sums up the game, it's stuck somewhere in 2010. I mean presentation, menus, commentary wouldn't even be good enough for an indie game. Anyone from Fiverr could come up with better designs in 10 minutes... Graphically it's a mixed bag as well. While player models look great (they always did, EA just can't get it look like humans for any game they make, likeFIFA, NBA, Madden. Models just look weird) in game cam, the crowd in PES looks like FIFA 06, so pixelated and dead. PES gameplay is still ahead of FIFA no doubts but at the same time it's very unresponsive and AI is just terrible. I can bet they will mess up the gameplay while fixing AI as well like they always do.
FIFA will always be bigger than PES, no matter what Konami do. From a gameplay perspective PES plays a better game of football, which is what matters to me.
Biggest dissapointment on Pes this year was removal of D2's. Cant believe you didnt mention that. It took a huge chunk of realism out of ML and its unforgivable. I thought they will add fake D2's to every new league but instead they removed the ones that were there! Now only french and english leagues have relegations/promotions. Ridiculous! As for FIFA - they might have not add much to Career mode, but overall experience is vastly improved, thanks to Champions League and new league licenses. I mean - when you play Premier League or La Liga, they have almost all stadiums from these countries! Its huge advantage! Most likely Serie A and Bundesliga will follow next year. How good career mode will be having almost all major european stadiums and different atmosphere on them? Its amazing. Yes, gameplay still is slightly better on PES, but FIFA is constantly moving forward while PES add one thing and removes two
Lol I’m glad we don’t have whining babies like you guys playing pes... all we care about is gameplay. Go play your d2 career modes like sad little twats on fifa and don’t ever play pes again 😂
@@Rocksteady365mac no wonder Pes is going downhill having such a muppets playing it. Cant even have normal discusion without resolving to insults. FYI I have both and play both. And waiting for both to get patched. Fifa doesnt have any fouls this year, PES has repetitive, boring gameplay with every single AI team playing same way. So do us all a favour and fuck off back to your myClub. If you eat your dinner mommy might give you few quid to buy some Legends
Let’s be honest, most people aren’t very gifted at football and therefore have no idea what makes a realistic game. The ones who do all realise pes is so far ahead. Also, most gamers are sad acts who care about menu screens and career modes. That’s why fifa is more popular
I don't understand the hate on Fifa, for me it's pretty solid. The presentation is just mind blowing you know with broadcast package and such. And the Journey is basically football movie with a lot of stars in it and it's playable. Gameplay wise is playable and so fun. The presentation on PES 19 is ugly, even previous series look better. I like the gameplay tho but it isn't enough. Fifa beat Pes in overall football gaming experience.
well pes 19 gets a update patch in end october it will probably then fixed with ai and then im sure pes 19 is better then fifa 19 i cant take fifa 19 gameplay and gamplan serious.
It really is personal opinion on what you like and I ended up getting both for different reasons. Gameplay wise pes is king and I've been playing fifa since 09 but if you love football and play in real life pes just has that realistic feel with every pass touch and build up it's beautiful when you understand the mechanics and that's something I can never get in fifa every game feels the same running down the wings quick 1, 2 passes constantly sprinting but non the less it's fun in it's own way but fifa just has presentation down to the core you see it and you feel like it's the real thing you're watching also online is much better than pes I can easily get into a game on fifa unlike pes but as a fan of football in real life I have no problem buying both this year you get the best of both
The best PES 19 vs FIFA 19 analysis on RUclips. Great job TTB! The Gamespot discussion on this topic totally sucked - in comparison. I'am a PES fanboy and an offline player, so here is my take. Menus - Don't care Presentation - Don't Care. Okay, maybe PES can add scores from other games at half time and other stuff recommended by TTB. Graphics - PES is way better. The player models suck on FIFA. The grass this year is beautiful on PES. Gameplay - PES! PES! PES! Even a simple pass feels so good! I cant even watch FIFA in comparison. GameModes - Don't care. I only play offline and plain vanilla leagues. Konami League is awesome! Master League is just not realistic with AI transferring willy nilly! So as TTB says, Its upto your choice. What game modes do you prefer? What do you enjoy? Base your decision on that. Don't listen to IGN or Gamespot. p.s Am disappointed TTB is playing FIFA this year. Oh well, he enjoys it and we all want him to do well!
I'd have to disagree about the graphics. Player models, you're absolutely right. They are better and more realistic than FIFA, although some of the more famous faces look weird. I think both grasses look stunning. The one thing I have to give an advantage for to FIFA is the kits. They look like they are actually made of textile instead of being seemingly solid in PES. The lighting is better in PES though. Really brings in the atmosphere. Otherwise, both games look very good. Gameplay: PES all the way. It feels amazing. The pass animations are great. The part I like more about FIFA is the fluidity in the change of directions. It feels a little bit "angular" in PES at times. The presentations isn't a big deal but it feels like it wouldn't take that much effort to make it look and feel better. For the menus and overlays at least.
PES definitely feels more like real football but i just prefer the feel of FIFA at least for console. Its all preference but FIFA feels more fluid to me this year than PES. Might mean it’s a little faster but i dont mind that, im used to playing NHL which is way faster than both games. Plus I like online as well and PES online just sucks so FIFA. If u want PES buy it on PC because being able to mod will add all licensed leagues, about 8 other stadiums and a whole host of other stuff.
If PES was $20 cheaper, I think the sales would be way higher, it's an incomplete game every year, so if they're going to continue this way at least price it right
For me personally superior gameplay, graphics & freedom of customisation of PES offers absolutely trumps FIFA’s superior online / ultimate team modes that I never liked or played anyway
Fair review of both, I haven't bought a football game for about 5 years now, I'm thinking of getting one this year and have been debating which game I am more of of a pes fan but I do feel more like getting fifa just as you say more of a full package
content and licenses = fifa. gameplay and realism = pes. Was quite surprising to see on twitter that fifa19 is getting an absolute hammering from players. Everyone complaining about gameplay and ridiculous ball physics
I love both games, I have started actually playing pes 2003 back in the day. Now I play fifa and Pes too, both are awesome and have their own pros and cons...Like in PES the realistic graphics but they do not have the right teams, emblems etc which you need to rely on SmOkE patches etc and pes has less arenas/stadiums wherein more repetitive of generic looking ones but a different name for each team; Fifa in the other hand have these details I love, flags waved in the crowd which makes the environment more hyped, the camera shaking after a goal, teams are available on set and over 70 stadiums which makes the product awesome. With all this said the only thing needed in these games is the PES 2012- PES 2013 feature when you can upload your own picture on a created player's face which gives you a legit feel that you yourself are in the game and can edit other player's faces with real pictures.
At the end I think that you are right when you say that both games are great! It's a good thing to see that there are still people using their brains when they give an opinion. I personally enjoy the content of your videos and that's one of the main reasons. I used to play Fifa since fifa 2000 and then one day I decided to change to pes because the gameplay gave me a better feeling. I'm still playing pes and fifa sometimes both games are great for what they are. With developers as a developer I can say that normally those decisions about what do we do in projects are taken way above of the technology part and for me the developers team do their best. Hi from Mexico!
PES19 has so much potential, gameplay wise it’s much more realistic than FIFA19. Not just that you can actually feel the ball. The passing, shooting and running with it. I’m hoping with the AI patch at the end of the month can really set the gameplay apart. Like I said it has so much potential. They need to work on more errors from the AI in tackling, I can’t win penalties and hardly any free kicks, even though there are more this year than in previous it still needs adjusting. The thing letting PES down are game modes. Too much time on my club, which let’s face it will never catch up to ultimate team. See this is where they could really win one over on FIFA with a ML league mode online. Or offline. Just spend the whole year doing this game mode. Can you imagine you and a few of your mates not only going up against each other on the pitch but also off it with bidding wars on players. Maybe on the online you could add real money into ML transfer funds. Say 1£ = 10 million. £5 = 50 million. You can adjust it into your wage. Maybe add sponsorship deals back also. If I were Konami I’d get rid of theMY CLUB mode. FIFA off the pitch PES on the pitch. Quality content as per usual TTB.
Yea no im done with pes been buying them for 5 years now since 2014 and this is the end for me ,instead of making it a simulation soccer theyv made it rock em sock em soccer its veryyy arcade and passing movements always the same, power bar for passes doesnt matter nor where u aim,everythign plays very automatic, pes2019 seems like a huge step back even from 2016 actually where there were more outcomes ,speedy wingers mattered. Fifa19 has won this year and i dont see pes coming back next year until they go full sim and new graphic engine
Judging from the demo I agree that I'm not coming back to it after buying it for 5+ years. Not because it's more arcadey, in fact, I love the first touch pass so much. But the promises they keep giving us and with only a tweak to the game makes me feel like I'm d**ked around. I just can't give them that money any more. They can redo the menus, make more broadcast presentation, add the broadcast camera we've been asking, fix the annoying AI.. I like they've finally fixed the grass on the pitch but for now I'm not sold.
Im not a fifa fan really, but FIFA smahed PES yet again. I had PES on release day, i got bored after few days. Fifa are far from perfect, but the entertainment value on fifa is so much more to do on fifa than pes.
I am not a pes or fifa fan. yeah i agree fifa players are fast looks like they got spring under their shoes but come on didn't you see how pes players sometimes move, dribble in a robotic way but yeah i must say that it is improving.. in pes 15,16,17 even 18 players are more robotic than 19 but as gameplay yes i prefer pes over fifa, it's more realistic, slow but fifa is fun...
Very lenient with some of your scores TTB. For example you say games modes severely lacking in PES but still give it 7.5 out of 10 for that category. As a PES fan (until now) fixing the AI 2 months after release, for a game that for most people has a shelf life of 12 months, is nowhere near good enough.
@@TheTrueBrits You may like to read this article from Adam Bhatti and then compare it to what was released. www.dreamteamfc.com/c/gaming/370631/pes-2019-konami-adam-bhatti-ronaldo-fifa-19/.
Here we go again nerds let me say this again GAMEPLAY on the pitch is the most important thing and Fifa gameplay is pure garbage and unrealistic. Pes have always been superior gameplay wise and even if pes 19 is not my fav pes it is still much better than fifa. 3 year olds can master fifa . I see so many narrowminded idiots in the comment section with zero eye for quality . Fifa has license but it is on the pitch where it matters the most and and pes wins that category easily PERIOD.
I can't understand how people just play the CPU. That is not playing the game. Playing the game is playing vs another HUMAN opponent. PES has major positives (speed, gameplay, realism, feel), but that is why FIFA is the better game. The online experience is much better, and the feel/look of the game is still fantastic.
Fifa kill pes this year and I was a huge pes fan all the years.the game pace and the players delay at pes are critical this year.fifa is such a fun game with amazing presentation .for me 18+19 are fifa years .
To everyone that has been playing pes for years. I want to ask you guys something, what does pes have to do in order for it to overtake and become better than Fifa? And if you could add/ come up with any game modes. What will it be?
If you love a game you buy it and load it up your console or PC for weeks and weeks unless it's bad and you will be all over RUclips defending it...yes ! Am talking about that feeling when you gaming alone in your room and no one is watching you and the only thing between you and the screen is the controller...thats when you know which game is better...Fifa or PES?
R' Zio for me i want to like PES for the realism that is vaunted on RUclips, but alone in my room, i get bored of it quickly and switch to FIFA. I like to watch others play PES but i enjoy playing FIFA
I got FIFA yesterday and it not that bad, there are few annoying things like the speed of the game and the ball physics, but I still PES for the playgame and realism, I will play FIFA online!
hello i watch your videos but why do you never answer when i comment you a question ? what do you prefer more pes 17 or pes 18 ? and between pes 18 and pes 19 ? if you had to choose from this 3 games what would be 1 and 2 and 3 ? what is your top 3 of pes 17,18,19 thanks.
Been playin FIFA for many years but Im really done with stupid unrealistic gameplay and stupid AI. I used to try PES every year and get back to playing FIFA in routine but this year I haven't bought FIFA after I had tried the demo. Pes has improved so much this year to be fair. 👍🏻
Fifa has stagnated, Pes has declined. Alot of Pes has gone backwards, additions have made things worse, things that needed looking at got neglected. 2019 is more of the same. Its the direction we have been headed in. AI has been complained about for years, it was better 10 years ago. They wait until its broke and theres a riot before patching it. It will work better, but still be terrible, but will be praised for improving. When they are just lowering the bar some more. They have done this with every part of the game. Thats why its in the state it is in.
I laugh at these clowns who say fifa is a ping pong game. I put the game on the new legendary ai put realistic sliders i slowed down the game by half quite enjoyed best fifa in years with the licensing
Von Mistelroum hahaha have you played it? Layoff the youtube. With the new Ai from fifa. Ipswitch will get slaughtered by bigger teams. I bet ipswitch on pes plays realistically more than fifa oh wait... pes doesnt have lower leagues 😂😂😂😂
Fifa smashes PES this year. I can't believe im saying this, but Fifa's gameplay this year is getting very close to PES. At this rate, i believe we wont have PES in 3 to 4 years time.
2 & 3 star games on myclub are over and it's a saddening thing. Not sure if I like new ranking system although I like the fact you don't just get a scabby contract renewal
For me tis is 2nd most disappointed pes after pes 2014.Lack of league license or mediocre presentation never been an issue for me as long the gameplay is good. But tis year the ai & scripting issues totally ruined my gameplay.
Yeah I figured it was different from 2018. Champions league games are the most scripted and I find that any mention of a "David vs Goliath" game in the beginning would mean the goliath team will lose
Yea every time I score the Ai scores like not even 2 min later. In pes. That hasn't happened to me in fifa yet. And on pes I'll play high defensive line, then in transition they'll drop deep invite pressure when my defense is not set to deep defensive line. Tactics seem to not make a difference in pes.
Super Console Gamer you’re so insecure 😂😂. You just hate facing the truth. You keep commenting fifa is trash but know damn well fifa is the bigger game. Pes is not that famous outside Indonesia you know 🤷🏾♂️
@@bishopwilliams6817 it's ironic saying FIFA is "heavily scripted" tho Pes repeats the same thing in every game and knowing exactly what they're gonna do but i do agree some gameplays in FIFA r scripted especially if u play d journey
I don't get the big deal with PES' transfer values. It's all relative to the economy of that game and, whilst values aren't huge, you've not got huge amounts to spend. What is annoying is how there is almost a clockwork reaction to the AI going behind. They'll immediately look to switch on and smash you and it doesn't feel organic. It leads to a lot of matches where you hold what you've got rather than push on for more.
My problem with PES is that the scripting makes it unplayable. At points in the games the game decides there's going to be a goal and there's nothing that can be done about it. Comebacks from nowhere, drastic momentum shifts, the ridiculous amount of last minute goals in every half. It even stops you changing playing to make sure there's a goal. If not for the scripting it's gameplay would be better.
Konami rushed released PES19 and by time patch comes out it will be 2 months since release. Thats not good enough. That said for all FIFAs sparkle I prefer PES on the pitch. The option files are outstanding as always so the "not having licenses" isnt really an issue. If you want the broadcast packages then youll need fifa.
Pes graphics r better from a far angle, i just want to know y their jerseys still get stuck to their bodies, w their hairs too. It doesn't move when running, just stagnant. Like in more recent years games have added that clothing and hair movement and i don't know whether it has an official name to it but it definitely adds a real feel to it.
Pes only wins in one area, and that is the game play, but fifa wipes the floor with presentation and that makes fifa more enjoyable, I tend to play fifa for career mode and be a pro mode, but pes if im playing against a friend in same room.
I would recommend both games but I like PES more, because it feels more fluid. One thing that annoys me is hat neither have done a particular good job at making a really realistic game, especially if you compare to other sport games. As usual I would say play Fifa online and PES offline.
Even with some of the frustrating faults it has I still think PES is better in terms of gameplay. I've enjoyed it more since the latest patch, I don't know if they've tweaked a few things but it feels a bit better. To be honest the best football game is PES 19 patch for PS2.
so does PES 2019 have the equivalent of Fifa online seasons where you play with your favorite team with default rosters. if so im buying it. Fifa plays pretty bad right now.
I agree with almost everything said in this comparison, but I disagree that the gameplay difference between the two games is not big. I own both games and PES is much more rewarding as a game. Fifa is fun but not even close to PES when comparing only gameplay. I play both games but PES is my choice if you want a simulation
Both games are enjoyable , both games have their problems aswell but with the issues PES has at the moment with poor AI , master league being broken and fast players running through treacle you really start seing it's problems so Fifa 19 edges it for me this year . Konami say they'll improve their game every year ........I'm still waiting .
I agree somewhat... But if you wasted your money on Pes 17 then Pes 19 is worth all the money, FIFA is still superioir, but remember the STILL... FIFA literally BARELLY changed since last year, while PES jumped a MILE
First time since 1998 I won’t be buying either. Enough is enough. There’s very little difference from last years games to warrant another £50 of my money.
Out of the box without the MODS and the PES Universe additional licensing ... PES is sh#t. FIFA is lacking in gameplay, and some licensing, but FIFA is the better game. If FIFA and PES had a baby, it would be the best game.
@@xze23 yeah. Pes 11 for me was the last really great pes game. It is definitely dated now but the passing was spot on and the scoring was really rewarding. When you look at pes 2011 and then Pes 2019 you really realize how lazy konami have been. If you compare fifa 11 to Fifa 19 it is worlds apart.
I play um both, not arsed with menus, or presentation the game on the pitch playability is what matters and FIFA is shit same old same old shit and PES is superb playability.
![[TTB] PES 2019 In-depth Gameplay Review - The Good, The Bad, & Everything In-between!](/img/1.gif)
We've been saying "hopefully Konami next year will" for like 10 years now let's be honest
Rich Franklin ever since pes 2008 released it has been the same story every year
Rich Franklin yesh and people saying dont worry a patch is coming.. yeahhhhh right
Yeah but FIFA is absolutely trash.
Its been on its death bed for 3 years now. How people still buy it Or why I have no idea. Its a complete shambles.
@@dolanSWEG facts 💯
PES - despite all its faults- still remains the superior football simulator for me. Yes, FIFA is superior in all the areas off the pitch, and I'll concede that it seems to have improved on the pitch as well. Nevertheless, PES 2019 is at least attempting to accurately recreate how football is actually played at the top level, whereas FIFA is more of an unrealistic goals fest. Yet I must admit I'm very frustrated with PES' AI this year; the PC mods show that there's no excuse for such shoddy and repetitive gameplay. Konami really need to sort the AI out.
The defending is quite easy when you just have to put someone in the box to defend a low cross :') but it still has amazing gameplay
I agree, using your defenders to track runners and stop low crosses at the front post is very simple. But that creates another problem: the AI isn't enough of a challenge. Low crossing isn't the only problem either; wingers don't use enough skill, strikers and midfielders rarely shoot outside the box and AI defensive decisions can sometimes make it too easy to score. Yet I still think it's the best football game ever made.
"I'm not really an online guy..."
You earned my sub immediately right then
Gameplay is the most important thing in a game. FIFA's gameplay is awful and outdated by any mean.
Βασίλης fifa has good game play. Just because it's not as good as pes doesn't negate that. Fifa is the overall package
PES gameplay + current PES licenses + all FIFA licenses = excellent footie game...
The dumbest comment I have ever seen....basically a patched PES
The Best Gamer lmaooooooo
99% people playing fifa because of epl
@mohd ikram: No. People play Fifa because it has proper physics, momentum, presentation, commentary, user interface, user experience, online, modes, depth, seamless gameplay, licenses, tactics, variety of teams and stadiums, atmosphere, shooting system, defense mechanism. Also mainly because Pes sucks.
@@vatonohablo proper phisycs? this is proper phisycs ruclips.net/video/KbCC7EToP-Y/видео.html
PES transfer fees kinda sums up the game, it's stuck somewhere in 2010. I mean presentation, menus, commentary wouldn't even be good enough for an indie game. Anyone from Fiverr could come up with better designs in 10 minutes... Graphically it's a mixed bag as well. While player models look great (they always did, EA just can't get it look like humans for any game they make, likeFIFA, NBA, Madden. Models just look weird) in game cam, the crowd in PES looks like FIFA 06, so pixelated and dead. PES gameplay is still ahead of FIFA no doubts but at the same time it's very unresponsive and AI is just terrible. I can bet they will mess up the gameplay while fixing AI as well like they always do.
FIFA will always be bigger than PES, no matter what Konami do. From a gameplay perspective PES plays a better game of football, which is what matters to me.
If you like pes, buy PES, play and have fun. If you like FIFA, buy FIFA play and have fun.
I like your comment. That's how it's suppose to be
simplest word, but ppl still arguing
Fucking amen finally
yeah , nice comment !
Sorry, It's not about Have Fun or What, it's about Money we throw, cause they're not cheap. That's why we need video like This.
That's a fair review. I'll agree with that 95℅. Great analysis. I'm kinda surprised you have only 61K subscribers. Nice work👍👍
the definitive comparison video, love your objectivity
i think the exterior staduim view and the tunnels make pes presentations better for me
Biggest dissapointment on Pes this year was removal of D2's. Cant believe you didnt mention that. It took a huge chunk of realism out of ML and its unforgivable.
I thought they will add fake D2's to every new league but instead they removed the ones that were there! Now only french and english leagues have relegations/promotions.
Ridiculous!
As for FIFA - they might have not add much to Career mode, but overall experience is vastly improved, thanks to Champions League and new league licenses. I mean - when you play Premier League or La Liga, they have almost all stadiums from these countries! Its huge advantage!
Most likely Serie A and Bundesliga will follow next year. How good career mode will be having almost all major european stadiums and different atmosphere on them? Its amazing.
Yes, gameplay still is slightly better on PES, but FIFA is constantly moving forward while PES add one thing and removes two
SirEmes yes i love my career mode on la liga because they have stadiums for freaking real betis!
i swear
Lol I’m glad we don’t have whining babies like you guys playing pes... all we care about is gameplay. Go play your d2 career modes like sad little twats on fifa and don’t ever play pes again 😂
Rocksteady365mac don't deceive yourself mate, pes game-play is just repetitive for all the teams, No wonder they never have sponsors.
@@Rocksteady365mac no wonder Pes is going downhill having such a muppets playing it. Cant even have normal discusion without resolving to insults. FYI I have both and play both. And waiting for both to get patched. Fifa doesnt have any fouls this year, PES has repetitive, boring gameplay with every single AI team playing same way. So do us all a favour and fuck off back to your myClub. If you eat your dinner mommy might give you few quid to buy some Legends
Let’s be honest, most people aren’t very gifted at football and therefore have no idea what makes a realistic game. The ones who do all realise pes is so far ahead. Also, most gamers are sad acts who care about menu screens and career modes. That’s why fifa is more popular
I don't understand the hate on Fifa, for me it's pretty solid. The presentation is just mind blowing you know with broadcast package and such. And the Journey is basically football movie with a lot of stars in it and it's playable. Gameplay wise is playable and so fun. The presentation on PES 19 is ugly, even previous series look better. I like the gameplay tho but it isn't enough. Fifa beat Pes in overall football gaming experience.
well pes 19 gets a update patch in end october it will probably then fixed with ai and then im sure pes 19 is better then fifa 19 i cant take fifa 19 gameplay and gamplan serious.
and about licences i have everything with pes 19 on a option file so yeah.
Ferry everything but the realistic stadiums and atmosphere 😬
It really is personal opinion on what you like and I ended up getting both for different reasons. Gameplay wise pes is king and I've been playing fifa since 09 but if you love football and play in real life pes just has that realistic feel with every pass touch and build up it's beautiful when you understand the mechanics and that's something I can never get in fifa every game feels the same running down the wings quick 1, 2 passes constantly sprinting but non the less it's fun in it's own way but fifa just has presentation down to the core you see it and you feel like it's the real thing you're watching also online is much better than pes I can easily get into a game on fifa unlike pes but as a fan of football in real life I have no problem buying both this year you get the best of both
I don't hate FIFA, it's just simply that there is no perfect games. Fifa isn't the best game ever but seems like it's mile ahead of Pes.
The best PES 19 vs FIFA 19 analysis on RUclips. Great job TTB!
The Gamespot discussion on this topic totally sucked - in comparison.
I'am a PES fanboy and an offline player, so here is my take.
Menus - Don't care
Presentation - Don't Care. Okay, maybe PES can add scores from other games at half time and other stuff recommended by TTB.
Graphics - PES is way better. The player models suck on FIFA. The grass this year is beautiful on PES.
Gameplay - PES! PES! PES! Even a simple pass feels so good! I cant even watch FIFA in comparison.
GameModes - Don't care. I only play offline and plain vanilla leagues. Konami League is awesome! Master League is just not realistic with AI transferring willy nilly!
So as TTB says, Its upto your choice. What game modes do you prefer? What do you enjoy? Base your decision on that.
Don't listen to IGN or Gamespot.
p.s
Am disappointed TTB is playing FIFA this year. Oh well, he enjoys it and we all want him to do well!
I'd have to disagree about the graphics. Player models, you're absolutely right. They are better and more realistic than FIFA, although some of the more famous faces look weird. I think both grasses look stunning. The one thing I have to give an advantage for to FIFA is the kits. They look like they are actually made of textile instead of being seemingly solid in PES. The lighting is better in PES though. Really brings in the atmosphere. Otherwise, both games look very good.
Gameplay: PES all the way. It feels amazing. The pass animations are great. The part I like more about FIFA is the fluidity in the change of directions. It feels a little bit "angular" in PES at times.
The presentations isn't a big deal but it feels like it wouldn't take that much effort to make it look and feel better. For the menus and overlays at least.
What do you care about then?
PES definitely feels more like real football but i just prefer the feel of FIFA at least for console. Its all preference but FIFA feels more fluid to me this year than PES. Might mean it’s a little faster but i dont mind that, im used to playing NHL which is way faster than both games. Plus I like online as well and PES online just sucks so FIFA. If u want PES buy it on PC because being able to mod will add all licensed leagues, about 8 other stadiums and a whole host of other stuff.
If PES was $20 cheaper, I think the sales would be way higher, it's an incomplete game every year, so if they're going to continue this way at least price it right
A decade of sub-standard improvements. Konami just don't care
@Gab Cahig a year on. 😂
Some things never change.
Pes used to be unbelievable for presentation and never had any licenses. 🤷🏻♀️
For me personally superior gameplay, graphics & freedom of customisation of PES offers absolutely trumps FIFA’s superior online / ultimate team modes that I never liked or played anyway
3:50 in PES there isn't even a replay when you hit the crossbar
tac tic qszzlldllll,,øll
I think a 7.5 for PES in terms of presentation is extremely generous. If PES is a 7.5, then FIFA is a 15 in that area.
Fair review of both, I haven't bought a football game for about 5 years now, I'm thinking of getting one this year and have been debating which game I am more of of a pes fan but I do feel more like getting fifa just as you say more of a full package
I Feel like last year was the first time Pes was better than fifa but this year i think fifa took it to another level and is the more pleasing game
content and licenses = fifa. gameplay and realism = pes. Was quite surprising to see on twitter that fifa19 is getting an absolute hammering from players. Everyone complaining about gameplay and ridiculous ball physics
Very honest review! Great video!
Great video mate 👍
THE BEST AND REALISTIC COMPARASION!
That word very similar means same as pes 18 just to let ppl know. No changes at all!
Both games should really go over to a two-year release cycle instead of every year.
I love both games, I have started actually playing pes 2003 back in the day. Now I play fifa and Pes too, both are awesome and have their own pros and cons...Like in PES the realistic graphics but they do not have the right teams, emblems etc which you need to rely on SmOkE patches etc and pes has less arenas/stadiums wherein more repetitive of generic looking ones but a different name for each team; Fifa in the other hand have these details I love, flags waved in the crowd which makes the environment more hyped, the camera shaking after a goal, teams are available on set and over 70 stadiums which makes the product awesome. With all this said the only thing needed in these games is the PES 2012- PES 2013 feature when you can upload your own picture on a created player's face which gives you a legit feel that you yourself are in the game and can edit other player's faces with real pictures.
At the end I think that you are right when you say that both games are great!
It's a good thing to see that there are still people using their brains when they give an opinion. I personally enjoy the content of your videos and that's one of the main reasons. I used to play Fifa since fifa 2000 and then one day I decided to change to pes because the gameplay gave me a better feeling. I'm still playing pes and fifa sometimes both games are great for what they are.
With developers as a developer I can say that normally those decisions about what do we do in projects are taken way above of the technology part and for me the developers team do their best.
Hi from Mexico!
Agree with you completely, both games need to put more effort in career mode.
PES19 has so much potential, gameplay wise it’s much more realistic than FIFA19. Not just that you can actually feel the ball. The passing, shooting and running with it. I’m hoping with the AI patch at the end of the month can really set the gameplay apart. Like I said it has so much potential. They need to work on more errors from the AI in tackling, I can’t win penalties and hardly any free kicks, even though there are more this year than in previous it still needs adjusting. The thing letting PES down are game modes. Too much time on my club, which let’s face it will never catch up to ultimate team. See this is where they could really win one over on FIFA with a ML league mode online. Or offline. Just spend the whole year doing this game mode. Can you imagine you and a few of your mates not only going up against each other on the pitch but also off it with bidding wars on players. Maybe on the online you could add real money into ML transfer funds. Say 1£ = 10 million. £5 = 50 million. You can adjust it into your wage. Maybe add sponsorship deals back also. If I were Konami I’d get rid of theMY CLUB mode. FIFA off the pitch PES on the pitch.
Quality content as per usual TTB.
Yea no im done with pes been buying them for 5 years now since 2014 and this is the end for me ,instead of making it a simulation soccer theyv made it rock em sock em soccer its veryyy arcade and passing movements always the same, power bar for passes doesnt matter nor where u aim,everythign plays very automatic, pes2019 seems like a huge step back even from 2016 actually where there were more outcomes ,speedy wingers mattered. Fifa19 has won this year and i dont see pes coming back next year until they go full sim and new graphic engine
👍👏👏👏 took the words outta my mouth
Judging from the demo I agree that I'm not coming back to it after buying it for 5+ years. Not because it's more arcadey, in fact, I love the first touch pass so much. But the promises they keep giving us and with only a tweak to the game makes me feel like I'm d**ked around. I just can't give them that money any more. They can redo the menus, make more broadcast presentation, add the broadcast camera we've been asking, fix the annoying AI.. I like they've finally fixed the grass on the pitch but for now I'm not sold.
Nah you’re just clueless about football
You got some good pot to have written some shit to right off against a good football game
To me, it's down to the gameplay and I enjoy PES more on that front. If the gameplay update works out, that's an extra point for that alone.
Im not a fifa fan really, but FIFA smahed PES yet again. I had PES on release day, i got bored after few days. Fifa are far from perfect, but the entertainment value on fifa is so much more to do on fifa than pes.
Fifa has better games mode but the gameplay is awful
I agree with you...in pes sometimes players move like robot but gameplay is good, shooting is improved, fifa is fast but enjoyable yeah really it is..
calling pes movement robatic is age-old myth that no pes fan will agree. FIFa players move and act like cartoony robots
@@NeverQuit87 your comments suggesting that you're not the sharpest tool in the box yourself...
I am not a pes or fifa fan. yeah i agree fifa players are fast looks like they got spring under their shoes but come on didn't you see how pes players sometimes move, dribble in a robotic way but yeah i must say that it is improving.. in pes 15,16,17 even 18 players are more robotic than 19 but as gameplay yes i prefer pes over fifa, it's more realistic, slow but fifa is fun...
Very lenient with some of your scores TTB. For example you say games modes severely lacking in PES but still give it 7.5 out of 10 for that category. As a PES fan (until now) fixing the AI 2 months after release, for a game that for most people has a shelf life of 12 months, is nowhere near good enough.
@@TheTrueBrits You may like to read this article from Adam Bhatti and then compare it to what was released. www.dreamteamfc.com/c/gaming/370631/pes-2019-konami-adam-bhatti-ronaldo-fifa-19/.
Pes needs a pro clubs mode, a lot of fifa pro club player would switch im sure.
Here we go again nerds let me say this again GAMEPLAY on the pitch is the most important thing and Fifa gameplay is pure garbage and unrealistic. Pes have always been superior gameplay wise and even if pes 19 is not my fav pes it is still much better than fifa. 3 year olds can master fifa . I see so many narrowminded idiots in the comment section with zero eye for quality . Fifa has license but it is on the pitch where it matters the most and and pes wins that category easily PERIOD.
mana beast when you don't have money to buy FIFA just bark kid
I can't understand how people just play the CPU. That is not playing the game. Playing the game is playing vs another HUMAN opponent. PES has major positives (speed, gameplay, realism, feel), but that is why FIFA is the better game. The online experience is much better, and the feel/look of the game is still fantastic.
Fifa kill pes this year and I was a huge pes fan all the years.the game pace and the players delay at pes are critical this year.fifa is such a fun game with amazing presentation .for me 18+19 are fifa years .
To everyone that has been playing pes for years. I want to ask you guys something, what does pes have to do in order for it to overtake and become better than Fifa? And if you could add/ come up with any game modes. What will it be?
Honest review mate. I must say this years Fifa is the best i played in years
If you love a game you buy it and load it up your console or PC for weeks and weeks unless it's bad and you will be all over RUclips defending it...yes ! Am talking about that feeling when you gaming alone in your room and no one is watching you and the only thing between you and the screen is the controller...thats when you know which game is better...Fifa or PES?
R' Zio for me i want to like PES for the realism that is vaunted on RUclips, but alone in my room, i get bored of it quickly and switch to FIFA. I like to watch others play PES but i enjoy playing FIFA
pes
As a lifetime fifa player, i like what pes has become, yet i cant get a feel for the gameplay somehow.. Its so different then FIFA is.
PES should focus entirely on club management by expanding Master League and take a bite out of FM.
FIFA this year for me
I got FIFA yesterday and it not that bad, there are few annoying things like the speed of the game and the ball physics, but I still PES for the playgame and realism, I will play FIFA online!
It's very easy and fast to get the real names, logos etc. On PS4 and PC that is.
is it easy to get stadiums, atmosphere, commentary, and league themes as well?
This is better than the Gamespot 9/10 review. If Konami invested that money into the game then they might not need to keep paying for reviews
You probably shut out the commentary on PES, but I have it on and it's very low in sound for some reason, I can barely hear it.
It all comes down to gameplay and pes19 kills it.
You’re like comparing nba live 19 to 2k19.. EA sucks with gameplay..
hello i watch your videos but why do you never answer when i comment you a question ? what do you prefer more pes 17 or pes 18 ? and between pes 18 and pes 19 ? if you had to choose from this 3 games what would be 1 and 2 and 3 ? what is your top 3 of pes 17,18,19 thanks.
1:55 “pes has realistic graphics”
Been playin FIFA for many years but Im really done with stupid unrealistic gameplay and stupid AI. I used to try PES every year and get back to playing FIFA in routine but this year I haven't bought FIFA after I had tried the demo. Pes has improved so much this year to be fair. 👍🏻
Fifa has stagnated, Pes has declined. Alot of Pes has gone backwards, additions have made things worse, things that needed looking at got neglected. 2019 is more of the same. Its the direction we have been headed in. AI has been complained about for years, it was better 10 years ago. They wait until its broke and theres a riot before patching it. It will work better, but still be terrible, but will be praised for improving. When they are just lowering the bar some more. They have done this with every part of the game. Thats why its in the state it is in.
I laugh at these clowns who say fifa is a ping pong game. I put the game on the new legendary ai put realistic sliders i slowed down the game by half quite enjoyed best fifa in years with the licensing
can I have those settings u playing on?????
let me have all those settings please😭 including the sliders
Sheldon Branch just search it on youtube
Von Mistelroum hahaha have you played it? Layoff the youtube. With the new Ai from fifa. Ipswitch will get slaughtered by bigger teams. I bet ipswitch on pes plays realistically more than fifa oh wait... pes doesnt have lower leagues 😂😂😂😂
Von Mistelroum but you have to mod it right? Sorry stopped playing PES since 2010 because that game is better than 2019.
PES needs a big improvement in their modes next year.
Fifa smashes PES this year. I can't believe im saying this, but Fifa's gameplay this year is getting very close to PES. At this rate, i believe we wont have PES in 3 to 4 years time.
Unless konami work together with fifa
budbuddingding 299 that's impossible for EA
I've tried fifa 19 demo and deleted it after few days playing, glad I bought pes 2019..
So its FIFA getting close to PES nw.....Wow.. Love that
But fifa is heavily scripted so it's pointless buying it
2 & 3 star games on myclub are over and it's a saddening thing. Not sure if I like new ranking system although I like the fact you don't just get a scabby contract renewal
I am early wow, love ur vids.
Gameplay and the ability to replicate the game of football realistically - PES 2019
Everything else - Fifa 19
Why haven't you mentioned anything about the awful scripting in pro this year? It's the most obvious it's ever been.
For me tis is 2nd most disappointed pes after pes 2014.Lack of league license or mediocre presentation never been an issue for me as long the gameplay is good. But tis year the ai & scripting issues totally ruined my gameplay.
Gary Lewis its so bad
Gary Lewis it's so obvious to see pal it's a joke .
Yeah I figured it was different from 2018. Champions league games are the most scripted and I find that any mention of a "David vs Goliath" game in the beginning would mean the goliath team will lose
Yea every time I score the Ai scores like not even 2 min later. In pes. That hasn't happened to me in fifa yet. And on pes I'll play high defensive line, then in transition they'll drop deep invite pressure when my defense is not set to deep defensive line. Tactics seem to not make a difference in pes.
So in short TTB Konami has let has down again with PES no matter how good it looks. On the other hand Fifa is an overall better game😔
Super Console Gamer you’re so insecure 😂😂. You just hate facing the truth. You keep commenting fifa is trash but know damn well fifa is the bigger game. Pes is not that famous outside Indonesia you know 🤷🏾♂️
Prince Smalling bro even fifa memes has more recognition than Pes lmaaooooooooooooooo
Arinze Luiz 😂😂😂
Fifa is heavily scripted so it's pointless buying it
@@bishopwilliams6817 it's ironic saying FIFA is "heavily scripted" tho Pes repeats the same thing in every game and knowing exactly what they're gonna do but i do agree some gameplays in FIFA r scripted especially if u play d journey
So what was the final points for each game??
PES 8.2 FIFA 8.6
I don't get the big deal with PES' transfer values. It's all relative to the economy of that game and, whilst values aren't huge, you've not got huge amounts to spend. What is annoying is how there is almost a clockwork reaction to the AI going behind. They'll immediately look to switch on and smash you and it doesn't feel organic. It leads to a lot of matches where you hold what you've got rather than push on for more.
It's beyond dissapointing,Konami is so damn lazy
My problem with PES is that the scripting makes it unplayable. At points in the games the game decides there's going to be a goal and there's nothing that can be done about it. Comebacks from nowhere, drastic momentum shifts, the ridiculous amount of last minute goals in every half. It even stops you changing playing to make sure there's a goal. If not for the scripting it's gameplay would be better.
the screenshot at 11:13 are 90's quality....
Are the Fusion product of Jordi Alba and Rio Ferdinand ?
Konami rushed released PES19 and by time patch comes out it will be 2 months since release. Thats not good enough. That said for all FIFAs sparkle I prefer PES on the pitch. The option files are outstanding as always so the "not having licenses" isnt really an issue. If you want the broadcast packages then youll need fifa.
True britt pls tell me the tune in the background its sounds sick
Pes graphics r better from a far angle, i just want to know y their jerseys still get stuck to their bodies, w their hairs too. It doesn't move when running, just stagnant. Like in more recent years games have added that clothing and hair movement and i don't know whether it has an official name to it but it definitely adds a real feel to it.
Pes only wins in one area, and that is the game play, but fifa wipes the floor with presentation and that makes fifa more enjoyable, I tend to play fifa for career mode and be a pro mode, but pes if im playing against a friend in same room.
I would recommend both games but I like PES more, because it feels more fluid. One thing that annoys me is hat neither have done a particular good job at making a really realistic game, especially if you compare to other sport games.
As usual I would say play Fifa online and PES offline.
I must have a unique game of PES then... since last time I played, they sent in some high crosses
Even with some of the frustrating faults it has I still think PES is better in terms of gameplay. I've enjoyed it more since the latest patch, I don't know if they've tweaked a few things but it feels a bit better. To be honest the best football game is PES 19 patch for PS2.
so does PES 2019 have the equivalent of Fifa online seasons where you play with your favorite team with default rosters. if so im buying it. Fifa plays pretty bad right now.
I'm finding fifa 19 ridiculously easy on legendary. Yet to concede a goal in 10 games in career mode.
I agree with almost everything said in this comparison, but I disagree that the gameplay difference between the two games is not big. I own both games and PES is much more rewarding as a game. Fifa is fun but not even close to PES when comparing only gameplay. I play both games but PES is my choice if you want a simulation
How do i play pes on full manual?
in regards to the prices in ML, you need to consider the economics in the game, not the real life prices...
The first game that gets a online career mode is the Winner no debate
Both games are enjoyable , both games have their problems aswell but with the issues PES has at the moment with poor AI , master league being broken and fast players running through treacle you really start seing it's problems so Fifa 19 edges it for me this year .
Konami say they'll improve their game every year ........I'm still waiting .
Only problem with pes 2019 this year is stupid AI, other than that pes 2019 is great.
Give us a sine if they fix the issuses witch the patch .
I'll be playing Lego dc supervillains deluxe edition until the pes patch.
Dont worry a patch is coming to save our asses - konami says fuckkkkk youu consumers 😂😂😂😂
Too be honest if pes fixes the gameplay I'll be happy with pes , I still get FIFA later in year but at a much discounted rate
Pes is finished and now fifa win the race
Badshahking sorry but Fifa 19 is dull and boring
I agree somewhat... But if you wasted your money on Pes 17 then Pes 19 is worth all the money, FIFA is still superioir, but remember the STILL... FIFA literally BARELLY changed since last year, while PES jumped a MILE
Fifa hasn't changed?.. lol you clearly haven't played fifa 19..
A MILE backwards
First time since 1998 I won’t be buying either. Enough is enough. There’s very little difference from last years games to warrant another £50 of my money.
You can get PES for way lower price than FIFA so I think it evens out their worth
Unfortunately Konami is not going to listen to their fans for next year.
Out of the box without the MODS and the PES Universe additional licensing ... PES is sh#t. FIFA is lacking in gameplay, and some licensing, but FIFA is the better game. If FIFA and PES had a baby, it would be the best game.
Plus I put pes 2011 on last night. Same God damn replay cameras for 8 years.
is it just me because
cut backs in pes 11 is impossibe?
@@xze23 yeah. Pes 11 for me was the last really great pes game. It is definitely dated now but the passing was spot on and the scoring was really rewarding. When you look at pes 2011 and then Pes 2019 you really realize how lazy konami have been. If you compare fifa 11 to Fifa 19 it is worlds apart.
@@CasperLD I tried PES 13 recently and it genuinely has the same commentary, I'm talking word for word smh
Gameplay is all that matters and FIFA won’t surpass PES. Pes 2019>
You only workout twice a week yet you're fuckin jacked mate. How? XD
I play um both, not arsed with menus, or presentation the game on the pitch playability is what matters and FIFA is shit same old same old shit and PES is superb playability.
I just have one problem with Fifa, and it's called EA