Greater Jakarta Malls Tier List [70 Malls][Part 1]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июн 2024
- DISCLAIMER:
1. This is just my opinion, F tier doesn't mean it's objectively bad
2. This video is not sponsored by anyone or any mall
3. Mapping may not be accurate
4. This video only covers 30 malls, the other 40 will be in Part 2 which will be out tommorow
Ranking 70 malls in the Greater Jakarta area based on public transport access and my preference.
Sources:
Google Maps
Mitra Darat
transjakarta.co.id/peta-rute/
commuterline.id/
By JDipterocarpus - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, commons.wikimedia.org/w/index...
Timestamps:
2:36 F Tier
3:25 E Tier
8:41 D Tier
13:57 C- Tier
![Greater Jakarta Malls Tier List [70 Malls][Part 2] + My top 10 favorite malls!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ST1KRzWAIwE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Greater Jakarta Malls Tier List [70 Malls][Part 2] + My top 10 favorite malls!](/img/tr.png)
Part 2: ruclips.net/video/ST1KRzWAIwE/видео.html
I don't live in indonesia, never visited and wasn't planning to visit and I just watched a guy talking about malls in jakarta for 20 minutes
how many malls do you have in your city?
Part 2 will be even longer
Same, from Malaysia, but watching this lmao
Hey do surabaya
@@rizkyadiyanto7922more than 5
About Mall of Indonesia, there used to be a huge theme park in the atrium that was closed circa 2016. I used to spend time there when I was in the elementary school.
Sama😢
Wait moiland is closed? :(
I saw it in 2023, though idk if this is the theme park being referenced.
F Tier
CBD Cileudeug 2:38
E Tier
Sumarecon Digital Center (SDC) 3:24
Mall Alam Sutera 4:22
Baywalk 4:58
Lippo Plaza Ekalokasari 5:38
Carstensz 6:22
Aeon Mall Deltamas 7:13
Ararasa BSD 8:19
D Tier
Pusat Grosir Cililitan (PGC) 8:41
Cilandak Town Square (Citos) 9:35
QBig 10:16
Cibubur Junction 10:38
Living Plaza Puri 11:03
Living Plaza Bintaro 11:35
Pesona Square Depok 11:55
Mall Basura 12:36
Cipinang Indah Mall 13:07
Bintaro Plaza 13:29
C- Tier
Mall of Indonesia (MOI) 13:56
Gajah Mada Plaza 14:47
Mall Ciputra Tanggerang 15:29
The Breeze 16:12
Sarinah 16:44
Revo Mall 17:52
Mal Ciputra Cibubur 18:32
Kuningan City 19:01
Trans Snow World Bintaro 19:44
Teras Kota BSD 19:58
Poins Square Lebak Bulus 21:08
I think the reason why so many malls like Cilandak Town Square exploit food and beverage businesses are because they are the most often visited by the people who visited the mall. People eat every day, but not shopping and watch movies. Food and beverage are usually the most affordable things you get in the mall, even though indeed there are a lot of fancy and expensive restaurant inside the mall. Most people who visit mall weekly or monthly at least do visit restaurant or food court on the mall, but they mostly skip shopping or watching cinema unless there is a hype of certain movie or big discount on the shopping place. FnB are also often serve place for hangout for group of peoples where people can sit down, chatting, and eat together. This also applied with single visitor who visit mall just for the vibe, they often looking place where they can sit alone and mostly it's on the FnB area. Not to mention the rise of online shopping so the need of visiting shopping place is getting decreased now day, unlike FnB and cinema which still needed for people "Third Place", meaning a place for people to recreation.
BTW, that was a great video. Im looking forward for the next part (and kinda lowkey about your rate about Bintaro Exchange Mall).
Thank you! I wont spoil too much but BXC is in the tier list.
I remember one of the downfall of cipinang indah mall was the flood of 2019(or 20) the flood gets inside the mall and shuts down the entire mall for like a week or so, and since then the mall just got empter and emptier. It used to be one of the crowded place in that area and me and my family used to go there for monthly shopping since it’s WAYY closer than our previous mall(buaran plaza), and for bassura its trash, it’s literally translated as trash😂
and If you're feeling rich just go to Casablanca
lol i prefer visit GGP rather than CIM
@@golarp yeah but the traffic is just shit, i still need to take a u turn above the casablanca underpass and it’s jammed asf from smpn 115
@@DevaraGian1998 ggp?
The dedication you put in this... Great video!
Post part 2 quickly omg, I need to hear about my favourite malls!
WOW Finally someone doing a Jakarta Mall tier list! I wish you added more footage of the malls though rather than the maps. But all in all great video! on my way to watch the next part!!
Thank you! Yeah I haven't been to some of the malls in a while so I don't have footage of it.
please make a video about each MRT phase in details
This is a pretty reliable list as it also mentions some very new malls as a person living in South Tangerang
I was hoping you'd mentioned how strangely managed Ararasa and Carstensz Mall are as they both are glorified high-income target market malls with elite membership gyms inside, but have seen a lot of tenant flops already for bringing in low-mid income target business. People mostly go to Ararasa for the supermarket, while Carstensz sees attraction for the dining and the game centre.
Carstensz' arcade (CPCM) may have lost some of its advantages, the regular arcades like Timezone and Funworld have bought the machines previously only seen in CPCM.
Great video, cant wait for part 2
Ahh I love this, reminds me of that Twitter thread from a malaysian transport enthusiast listing malls accross Malaysia.
the dedication bro!!
This is a great video, it's so cool to see some of the local malls I go to get ranked.
Perhaps it's good that none of the malls that I frequent is yet to be on this list, maybe I have the same ranking criteria as you do lol. Can't wait for part 2!
WE HAVE 70 MALLS??
Few of Them are in Tangerang like CBD Ciledug, Bintaro, etc
Most sources say Jakarta has well over 100 malls but idk what criteria they use
Jabodetabek. Bukan Jakarta Aja. 😂
jakarta has more than 100 malls, including trade center like ITC. that"s why jakarta is "City with the most malls in the world"
So many to the point Jakarta Govt put brakes on new mall permits I think
Good vid, was thinking something aobut these when I was going out on public transports and always wondered what other malls I could try to visit since I pigeon hole to a couple ones nowadays and getting bored of them 👍
This video concept is fun as a mall enthusiast myself! I wanna add up I think this is quite neutral and objective enough if you count in the "budget" of the person visiting too, if you're well off or well budgeted, i think most of the C malls here would only be visited if u need to buy something or appointments like VISA, repair service, item cleaning services (shoe/laundry/leather goods) instead of "going to the mall for the free ac and look around"
Some of the D and E class malls would still be fun to visit to just grab a quick bite or try out new food at some restaurants most Indonesians deem relatively overpriced (My head always circumvents around conversion from Yen and USD so any mall is heaven to me) As Japanese, when in SEA I tend to convert or compare mall services and resto prices to Japan's, whereas in indonesia i could eat the same food for half or a third of the prices.
Also gotta mention the Car park quality tier or grabcar accesible or nah etc
It might also sound snobby but it is also a huge plus for me and my family and friends at least if a mall has shuttle service or Silverbird pool, or joint contract with big hotel chain like Intercon or raffles, like PIM 1-2-3. Sometimes i drink there. But i do realize if these are mentioned, ppl would straight away think its a tertiary neccesity or luxury and slam me rightaway for being "snobby" :(
Good idea, when it comes to parking access I don't think I can do that as a mainly public transport user when inside Jakarta but lets hope someone does that.
But If I ever remake this video several years from now, maybe I can include a scale to show if this is a low/mid/high end mall.
the amount of research that must have gone for this, damn...
I've been trying to visit all the malls in Jakarta and Google map misses a lot of them, so this helps a lot
Not the video we asked for, but the video we need.
Fun fact about Revo Mall, it just got on fire recently on June 22nd, 2024. I went there 2 days ago and while the underground and 1st floor are safe, the rest of the mall are kinda f*cked atm because of the fire. They did try to salvage the situation by relying on the fire stairs and 1 lift (yes, just 1) to move people from the LRT to the GF or LG floor ofthe mall.
From what i heard the fire was caused by a portable stove caught on fire at Gokana Teppan Kitchen in the Food Court area.
I just hope they get better future down the road. That mall has such high potential, will be a huge shame if its closed due to accidental reason.
On the bright side, Metropolitan Mall is close by (and they have shuttle to Grand Metropolitan which just 200m away), so those two mall are probably the best mall to visit while waiting for Revo to recover 😢
Man that's not really a fun fact 😢 the LRT has done wonders for Revo Mall, there's weeb events there every Sunday, and they will soon open a Fogo de Chao Brazilian Steak Restaurant there too.
@@mapk1516 ye, just used that word too often
Lets just hope that they recover soon
I say it's a scheme so that Pakuwon can buy it up
Okay so for Kuningan City, I would rank it higher. Here are the reasons:
The access is actually pretty nice. Even though it doesn't connect to main corridor, and the frequency of each buses might not be the best, there are a lot of options such as 5F, 6D, 6K and JAK48 that stop in front of the mall. 6D and JAK48A directly brings you to Tebet station, while 6K stops at Departemen Kesehatan (below Kuningan LRT) and main corridor 6. It has a dedicated traffic lights for crossing the street to the mall - I mean, it's basically the norm for all malls in Satrio street. The sidewalk is also decent, especially across the mall. Its proximity to other malls & shopping center is also very good. Roughly, it only takes 5 minutes walk to One Satrio, another 5 minutes to Ambassador and yet another 5 to lotte shopping avenue.
The food option here is basically unlimited, from cheap shit to overpriced stuffs. It also has a large lotte supermarket, much larger than lotte shopping avenue's ranch market - which is strange since lotte shopping avenue doesn't have lotte supermarket. The supermarket also has a small sushi bar with affordable prices and a cheese dough shop that sells a criminally underrated pizza slice in the city. It also has billiard bar, cinema, board game area, and karaoke bar.
That's all, overall. Probably a very biased opinion too as I used to work near the Kuningan area. But compared to other malls around it, Kuningan City is definitely my favorite.
I need to explore kuningan more 😁
@@shindoride nice video btw, looking forward to the next part!
Ayo great video idea, I can already guess how MKG is gonna rank in this tier list, can't wait for the part 2
Also about the statue of two girls smelling durian, I think it's some sort of ciputras' signature or something since I've seen a lot of those statues in most of ciputras building (even in their office buildings lmao)
Well, I think that statue is good art
As I remember, Ir. Ciputra really loved this guy's art pretty dearly.
Mall Alam Sutera might be E tier but there's one reason that for me brings it up to A or even S tier
The Pedro and Charles and Keith there typically have huge discounts because it's a sort of dumping ground / surplus store for them, precisely because the mall is such an E tier mall
Yeah. Aeon has greatly revived Mall Alam Sutera. I remember the opening week for Aeon, it was probably the most crowded I've seen Mall Alam Sutera been. Theres a weird periode between the closing of Gramedia (literally the only reason I still went to Mall Alam Sutera back then) and the opening of AEON mall in which Mall Alam Sutera was basically dead. No one went there, everyone just went to Living World Alam Sutera.
Ooh, a Series. Look forward to see the rest of the Malls xD
This is awesome! A bit of suggestion, I think it would be better if you show the mall names throughout the explanation of each mall instead of just showing it for a few seconds. Other than that, such a well made video ❤
Thank you! Part 2 is like that
As somebody who used to go to Ciputra Cibubur Mall its good. The AC is cold there are snack stands, restaurants, clothing stores, electronic stores, optics, an arcade, a supermarket, and a cinema on the top most floor. Almost if not every slot is already filled with stores. Though after Trans Studio Cibubur opened the mall has been getting less visitors since it's in this akward midd range position between Trans Studio Cibubur, Living World Kota Wisata, and Met mall Cileungsi. I used to go there via the Cileungsi angkot line, the angkot terminal is under the cileungsi Overpass just in the front of Ramayana Cileungsi. There used to be a traditional market under the overpass and it was filthy, though now the market doesn't exist anymore I havent used the angkot line for some time.
You are such a legend
For the additional information :
I usually go to carstensz and, i go to carstensz by T12 (if i from tangerang), and depart to Kebon Nanas (before the toll entrance). and then take Kalideres - Serpong angkot to RS. Ashobirin, and take a grab / gojek to carstensz. or using S11 and depart to RS Ashobirin. and then take a grab / gojek to carstensz.
if you want to avoid the grab / gojek. you can use Commuter line and go to Cisauk. take the Intermoda BSD bus Route 1 (free). and depart to Greenwich. you can walk from there to carstensz (but it took like 15 minutes from greenwich to carstensz by walking). the intermoda bus available each 30 minutes. and it depends on traffic jam.
but sometimes i see Royaltrans passes the carstensz (i forgot the line) but the bus start from lebak bulus (i dont think the bus stop in the front of the mall because i never try to take that bus)
The S14 stops in front of Cluster Catalina which is right next to the mall, I say this as someone who has used the S14 multiple times. You can also take DAMRI's JR Connexion thats cheaper but slower since it goes through East BSD/Teras Kota first on the way back.
@@shindoride thanks for the information. btw i never see S14 very often. is there any schedule each minutes or hour the bus will arrive, i want to try it at least once. thanks
Yeah you need to join the WA group for that bus for live tracking and information on delays. But normally, buses depart from SDC at
6.00 6.30 8.00 9.00
Buses leave Lebak Bulus at
17.30 18.00 19.40 20.10
But its kind of expensive at Rp 35,000
@@shindoride Thanks for the information!
Thanks, now I have a to do list of 70 (or less) malls to visit
Bro wakes up and decided to create a god-tier content
The tier list everyone was really asking for /j
QBig is great if you are into inline skates / skateboard / rollerskates. In the weekends, the "empty space" you mentioned is jam-packed with skaters, because the floor is the perfect texture for playing skates. I would rate it higher since QBig is unique in that it is a gathering spot for such niche communities.
did you visit every mall just for this video or is it based on past visits? either way, insane dedication bro
Thank you! Id say both, in the months and weeks leading up to me making this video, sometimes I could visit up to 3 malls in Jakarta in a single day.
The angkot to mall ciputra cibubur are pretty frequent especially the ones to and from cileungsi. you can stop one from just outside of the mall gate. not much for other types of transports tho. dont know if it does exists
the amount of research is insane
Surabayans watching this be like: ok not bad
Oh boy, I wonder if Lippo Kramat Jati will show up in this series
as a self proclaim mall surabaya connoisseur i welcome you brother
Hopefully one day I can go to Surabaya and make a Surabaya malls tier list
@@shindorideIn my opinion Malls in Surabaya (ignoring transit):
S - Pakuwon Mall, Tunjungan Plaza
A - Galaxy Mall
B - Ciputra World
C -
D - Plaza Surabaya (or Delta), Grand city, Pasar Atom mall
E - Lenmarc
F -
There is a lot more mall tho, but these are the only malls I ever visited even as native
@@TysonoeooSurabaya guy approved
please do bandung next 🙏
You should make a tier list video ranking the transjakarta fleet
Also the bus stops
@@revimfadli4666 kebanyakan
Maybe not the bus stops, but the BRT shelters, I have things to say about Tanjung Duren and Monas BRT shelter (not good ones).
@@shindoride isnt that too much? Over 100 bus shelters
The mampang and highwayside ones are horribly narrow
Last time I went to Lippo Plaza Ekalokasari (around last april) there are still a ton of empty stores. Honestly, I can see why. There's this certain vibe to that mall that really puts me off, especially if you go there during the early afternoon. The only reason we go there is to go to matahari. Otherwise just go to botani square. (Also the traffic there around maghrib time UGH)
Also, I ❤ Roti Venus. It is a tradition for my family to bring back roti venus whenever we went on vacation to Bogor. It's such a convenient gift compared to buying souvenirs. It is pretty expensive, though😬😬😬
Yeah I think the combination of lots of empty stores+dim lighting+dark ceilings+way too many kids play areas gives this mall a "weird" vibe.
Hey dude you should also rnak the ones in bekasi, we have a coming soon mall called pakuwon anf trust me its so massife
3 Bekasi Malls made it to part 2, but yes il visit Pakuwon Bekasi once it's done.
4:39 I wonder if the "old machine" of what you said is old arcade games...
Yep, old arcade games I've seen maybe from 10 years ago
@@shindoride well, you might disagree with this but imho having old arcade games (if it well maintained) on a mall beside newer is better than having the whole newer arcade games in the mall.
Well umm, I agree actually
recana mrt nanti ada MRT JORR 1 LOOP line south part of JORR 1 has a lot of density and highrises and midrises along the toll road
I guess the problem regarding Kuningan City pretty much affects all buildings located in the Prof. Dr. Satrio Street. TRAFFIC IS BULLSH*T HERE. Like literally the 5F won't come even after 30 minutes because the traffic here is so crazy especially on rush hour. Last week I went to Ambasador Mal and Kuningan CIty and then when I was going to go back to the place i'm staying in Duren Sawit -it was the 6PM weekday rush hour-. When I exited Kuncit, I could literally see a 5F stuck in traffic just after Ambasador Bus Stop, which eventually I board after I waited for around 4 minutes at the Kuncit Bus Stop. And because this street could get clogged so easily just by one goddamn truck breaking down at the flyover just around Tebet Station, Kuncit to Kampung Melayu took 2 hours
Some of the malls i visited was mentioned in the video and all of them have some reasonable ratings, you should try some of these malls i visited:
- Arion mall
- Bella terra lifestyle center (empty mall)
- green pramuka square
Need to edit some cuz already mentioned
I swear, Carstenz everytime i visit it feels like an enigma
The only reason i go there is because their arcade, CPCM, are the only ones that has CHUNITHM, the only place to play them (hopefully once CPCM opens more branches, CHUNITHM becomes more available).
Can't help but think that every time i go there though, i see it as, the most boujee a mall can be, like strictly high class
Statue of "Two people smelling a durian", now that is something you won't see in a foreign country.
ah yes, CBD in F tier, shocker to literally no one who doesn't breathe air
So it's Jabodetabek Malls isn't?
Medan’s malls tierlist fitting in a yt short:
Doing God's work here
LIPPO KEMANG,ONE BELL,THE PIMS,KOOKAS,KUNINGAN MALL,CINERE AND CITOS FOR LIFE BABY!!!
People these days prefer buy food than buy others so mall that have a lot of food usually more crowded. Aeon use this approach and Aeon often give chairs so people can relax. Old mall have lack of chairs to sit.
This topic was arised in me and my gf (non-jakartans) conversation a few days ago about visiting every mall and many thanks in advance now we have a raw list where to go.
We’ll provably visit not in order though, because no way in hell she’s willing to visit an E tier mall after visiting CBD Ciledug. 😂😂
Your welcome! Btw some malls in E tier are good, just that it has no public transport access.
Waiting for Bintaro xchange and Blok M mall / square to be on top of the list
Handsome, why don't you change the title from "Jakarta" to "Greater Jakarta" or "Jabodetabek" because it seems like you're also including malls from other cities/districts outside of Jakarta.
Done
@@shindoride Also, your videos are so good, I'm honestly a fan. I would love to collaborate with you and help you with your videos.
Alright I know who to call when I have an idea
wheres the part 2 dude, u promised
It will be out 8 hours from now
so there’s malls outside LMP and CP…. 😃😃😃😃
R06B... Yeah I study at UMN, not once I see any angkot around SDC
I study at UMN too! What major are you taking?
@@shindorideTeknik Komputer. Correction, I studIED at UMN, class of 2019
Nice, I study Journalism, class of 2021
Im an indonesian, and i love puri mall, i can walk there
"and the previously untrackable D11 line" and isn't it dead again now too
It isn't as dead as last time, the new Transjakarta app is at least slightly more usable than the previous one.
But its still bad. TJ live tracking is basically on life support.
considering that you're also rating malls in tangerang, i wonder what rating you would give to the ABSOLUTE MESS that is balekota 😭 public transport is definitely decent there, albeit one of the better ones in tangerang, but my god the mall is so horrible and so empty that it doesnt even matter 😭😭 iykyk this mall
I rarely visit Tangerang Kota so unfortunately Balekota is not in the tier list. I've never been there but the google maps reviews are not good.
I remember when they first opened the place about a decade ago, half of it was still under construction and it remains that way today lol.
But as someone who lives in Cikokol, it's still one of my go to options if I needed to go to ACE Hardware or Hypermart and not wanting to circle around searching for parking space in other malls.
Not to mention the cinema there is one of (if not) the cheapest in Tangerang. Back in my high school years, I would hangout and eat with my friends in TangCity and then took an angkot to Balekota to watch the movies because it's just cheaper that way 😂
@@MaulanaAsgaf im in 12th grade and that is exactly what i do with my school friends 😂 the cinema is the cheapest in tangerang with tickets that are 25-30k, it's the only saving grace left for balekota and the only hanging thread for it, if it hadn't been for that cinema the mall would've closed down ages ago 😭 that cinema is the only thing that mall is known for, everyone in tangerang kota has colloquially agreed that balekota is "the mall with the cheap XXI in it but nothing else" 😭😭 aside from that, it only became a resting place for gojek & grab drivers waiting for orders from the nearby tanah tinggi station while they get drinks from the starling bikes parked beside the mall 😭
can you talk about the gloriest city in the world (Bekasi)
Sure, like a specific video on Bekasi public transport or just about the malls? Because multiple Bekasi Malls made it to Part 2.
@@shindoride sure something like that, even though the only reliable and far reaching transport here in bekasi is angkot
>"gloriest city"
>hell
16:42 England 🤝 Indonesia
Having inconsistent weather
1. You're Indonesian
2. England didn't have rain or stuff, Its heat wave. You're just stereotyping British
@@golarp I lived in england for four and a half years, specifically the city of Leeds. I've seen stuff. It gets hot and cold. It'd be sunny when it rains. I guess perks of living far from the equator is that you get hot and cold, not just hot.
I think the title should be renamed since it not just jakarta only
"greater" jakarta
He means Jabodetabek
I feel like gajah mada should rank higher, it IS an MRT stop after all
I'm expecting Blok M Plaza to be on A tier
Lists of mall i know in jakarta:penjanten mall
Thats the only mall i like
"Shopping mall city" if i may say
Fakta bahwa jakarta adalah kota dengan jumlah mall terbayak di dunia .
dan kepadatan pertokoan m² / km² terbesar di dunia.
Entah sebuah fakta yang harus dibanggakan atau tidak aku tidak tau
Mal ciputra should've been in D-F tier imo
Wait the Tangerang or Cibubur one? I don't think both of them deserve to be in the same category as Cipinang indah/CBD Ciledug
What have i stumbled upon
CBD Ciledug as expected, fuck those angkots and metro mini back then
All we got is one mall with only one floor and no basement parking
What city?
@@shindoride Kota Serang, it's 2 floors if the ground floor counts
LOH KOK MALL JIR TIBA²
Wait bekasi are actual places? I thought y'all been joking this whole time about this otherworldly location called bekasi
It's real, just on a different planet and Transjakarta B11 is actually a space shuttle line.
@@shindoride we might have a data breach but we do have a space shuttle eh that's cool
i am indonesian an i litteraly know basically 95% of this lol
Surabaya hadir
Timestamp where
Like timestamp for each individual mall? There's timestamps but only for each tier
@@shindoride Ah aight it doesn't show up on the progress bar. Keep up the good work
Manado hardir
TIME see manado im born
CIPINANG MALL D TIER IT'S SO OVER
fuck malls, we need more parks
We need more good/big parks to be exact, Jakarta has a lot of small parks that are not really worth travelling 1-2 hours for.
Plus il still end up going to the mall anyway to cool down
Tempat Hiburan / Wisata di Jakarta adalah Mall-mallnya.
Recreation / Tourist places in Jakarta are Malls.
- Me Probably...
Yes, in Jakarta, we go to the mall, this is what everyone I know has said when it comes to going out in Jakarta.
where is a tierlist? do not deliver. F