Porsche 911 Turbo S vs Nissan GT-R vs Noble M600 | Fifth Gear
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- In this Fifth Gear shootout, first broadcast in 2014, Tiff & Jason are joined by Bruno Senna to test the Porsche 911 Turbo S, Nissan GT-R & Noble M600.
#FifthGear #BrunoSenna #Porsche
For more fantastic car reviews, shoot-outs and all your favourite Fifth Gear moments, subscribe to our Official Channel: goo.gl/IPXAgl
Check out our website for the latest car videos and news from around the web: fifthgear.tv/
Keeping that Noble on the track with that conditions, is the biggest performance showen in that race. Wow, Tiff is an amazing driver!
That's why he drove it i think.
He is the most experienced driver in my opinion.
And they senna is to valuable haha
Yes he’s blinking good driver !
But to be fair all 3 are great
Love the rivery
Fab come on top gear take a leaf from these guys 🏆
Tiff is a former F1 driver. He's pretty much the most capable of the three to take on the Noble.
Tiffs vast experience in quite a few different forms and classes of Motorsport make him the obvious choice, not least his days wrestling Lister Storms around race circuits,don't imagine that was an easy task either.
The GTR did well considering it only cost almost half the price of the 911.
@oneviwatara What video did you watch?
when you start piling on the Porsche options, it's less than half the price
Why they don't get the New GT-R?
@oneviwatara yes. It does look like a tarted up beetle when parked next to a Ferrari.
Zzzzzzzz.... when you have driven and owned a 911 then you will realise why it’s King ... sod all these tuned cars
Love my Noble. Especially on track
Brilliant,one of the best fifth vids ive seen in a while
As far as I'm concerned, Tiff wins simply by showing up :-) It'd be nice to see this comparison done with updated cars, maybe 2018 models. IMHO the 991 Turbo S is the best "daily driver" Porsche I've ever driven.
The Noble has basically remained the same ever since its release, although they did away with the analog radio and have 3 different versions. And I think they added about 12 more horsepower.
This was a lot of fun to watch!
You guys need to travel to where there is less rain. I want to see dry comparisons.
Love all the 3. Would love to get the Porsche but my budget gets me a my 12-13 gtr. And I owned a skyline gtr so the choice is obvious.
Call me silly but no one even wearing a helmet during these tests? Where's department of health and safety?
Maaaan, there's just something about Noble... Spectacular car! But, the Porsche, I'd say, is the one to have and to hold.... Phenomenal, at the least 👍🏻
The double clutch should of used on Lamborghini Avantador ... But no WV won't allow it..
Porsche wins, of course.
Well, it didn't.
Ауто камере Србија / Dash cams Serbia You should replay the first 2 minutes, in slow motion. And Porsche holds record laps around 10x as many tracks as Nissan.
Weird comparison really :-) all 3 cars have different purposes, unless the only comparative is speed.
Love Tiff! Such a gentleman. Only he could drive the Noble
Perhaps you should have tested all three cars on snow as well! Does it rain everyday in car reviews? I'm so sick of seeing car reviews done in the rain, is there not a better location to film in? It's fine to see how they handle the elements, but if you want a real review, perhaps some better conditions would make sense.
Spend 30 more grands on GTR
No chance any of the other gonna be even close to it
And if you spend a total of 140 grands
Not even the best hypers have any chance
the porsha...we all know porshas will win I have 3 porhas, and a nissan micra :D..but something about the noble...
The noble is one hell of a car,but you need to be one hell of a driver too.
Remember when the Stig ran that lap time on top Gear with sleet on the track? Fuc.king outstanding.
If only it was dry and we would have seen the true pace of the Noble, love those things!
“And Senna is in the lead” is always a nice thing to hear even though it’s different Senna 😊 We still miss him
Somehow, I'm reading this with Murray Walker's voice in my mind.
Rear whee drive, wet track and no driver aids and Tiff still kept up??? If anything, this video just shows how great he is.
Tiff is just at another level
Tiff is the most down-to-earth maniac I've known. What a gentleman, what a driver... I love him.
He is discounted version of Clarkson
@@CriticalCorrie Apparently he taught Clarkson how to powerslide a car
9:53 Tiff: "I've got two more go-s...I've got two more go-s"! Love Tiff!!
He's the Stig
Would have been nice to see on a dry track
On a dry track the lack of 4 wheel drive wouldn't have counted against the Noble as much. I'm pretty sure the Noble would have won in the dry.
@@tonyb9735 😂
Tony Becker oh it definitely would have won
For it to be that close on a wet track it would easily be a few full seconds faster per lap in the dry
Plus it sounds sooooo much better and has to be so much more fun to drive as well
Keep dreaming. I don't think I've ever seen a test without at least a little rain.
@turk turklington on a track that only happens once. The rest of the time the Noble would be ahead.
"I don't even need to think about what I'm doing" .... the very last thing I want to hear. Give me the Noble. It's car not a computer.
M600, always. So beautiful and great sound. And manual.
My S89 V8 is as close as I’ll ever get to the M600.
@@Dontworryaboutit23 Still an awesome car.
That Noble is such an unbelievably underrated car😍 what a beast
💯
Damn it, Nissan delivering this performance for such a price is too good to be true
So this has come from direct from Fifth Gear in May 2020. Showing us footage shot in... 2014....!!??
Good to see FG keeping us all bang up to date :-))...
I've driven the noble. It's not easy to drive. I don't know how many laps it needs, but if you can find your groove at 10/10ths, there remains only a handful that can take it after all these years.
What a great video! This is what top gear used to be: enjoying driving cars
So you're comparing a 76k sports saloon vs a 200k supercar and 140k sports car?
So what if that's the case? They all perform about the same.
There are no saloons in this test they are all coupes. Nissan themselves claim the GTR is their supercar
Well it's a nissan, it better cost less than a Porsche and a Noble lol
Josh R You actually hit the nail on the head without saying it!
@@MarkWright1963 That the cheaply made computer on wheels costs less? It should. The performance is outstanding though cannot fault the GT-R for that it's fantastic.
GT-R hanging with the big boys for a fraction of the price and will be more reliable and cheaper to work on.
Launch the GTR and the 911 over and over again and see what happens.................
The GTRs an absolute bargain! Love it.
Gtr for me.
The Porsche may been £64k more than the Nissan, but I would definitely take that German super sports car all day long. But between the Porsche and the Noble, it's a really tough decision to make as I truly love both of them.
I absolutely love all of these cars!!!😍
"curbs are not part of the racetrack" - the most pointless thing to say to a touring car driver
He’s just trying to mess with his head.
Kerbs, grass, gravel trap, all part of the racetrack to a BTCC driver
Man, that noble is such a Dream. The manual gearbox alone gives it the edge imo
Dry conditions, the noble smashes it! The noble was built to be driven not like some of the more modern cars with all the tech which is amazing. No better feeling driving a manual rear wheel car fast round corners!
The Noble is definitely the car you should respect the most. But between the Nissan and the Porsche, well that's an easy choice for me - 911 all the way.
Turbo S easily the best of the three all round. The GTR is impressive due to weight but meh, R34 that is all. I'll take the Noble, thanks. Seriously and quite honestly criminally underappreciated.
when you consider the price differences, its a bit different - 70k vs 140k vs 200k :D
*yes finally , thanks fifth gear!*
Porsche really knows how to make cars. Now and then.
The new 911 turbo as a beast all together
Road was wet for all the standing start races. Would really like to see a dry track start or a rolling start.
who would doubt that Porsche will win???? VERY NICE RACE!!!! Thanks from 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
I rate the 911 Turbo S as the ultimate daily driver, my lottery win shopping car :-)
Crazy to think my remapped crappy M140i has almost as much torque as these mega machines !
Do these guys have a death wish? Racing with multiple cars at 150+ without a harness, helmet or HANS device? In the rain! Why
Put Bruno in the 911 and he wins all 3 challanges
I don't care about the drag race. I love the manual transmission Noble. Thanks.
Is there a 2020 fifth gear?
Why don't you fifth gear folks understand that different drivers driving different cars and comparing it is bullshit?
The year is 2020 and not one beautiful drone shot of that close race 😳
Um Senna não combina com Nissan!!!, Senna combina com McLaren ou Honda. ( 720 ou NSX). Porém um Senna fez o que um Senna sabe fazer, ganhar uma corrida com um carro inferior aos concorrentes. Outra coisa é que deveriam usar o Nissan nismo ai ficaria mais equalizado. Parabéns Bruno Senna...
if the track was dry for the laps at the end... the noble would have been much more of a problem for the other 2
So the German benchmark and British epitome are slower than Japanese 4 door family mover 😁😁
Yes, but the GT-R is boring compared to the Noble. It’s not unique, not special, just quick and that’s it with no driver’s satisfaction.
I would personally choose the noble m600.. good test..
I'd easily take the Noble mainly for that proper gearbox. Non of this paddle shite
The weather conditions have been worsening in Britain since the Neolithic. 😂
I would buy the GT-R, and used the money that I saved, to give it better turbos and tyres. 👍
Probably good choice if you dont want to visit tracks as much and can live with the lesser interior and higher running costs
The GTR is a tuners dream, they can get 1000+bhp out of the GTR. Definitely my choice, especially considering how cheaply you could buy a second hand car for nowadays. Plus it'll no doubt be a damn sight more reliable than the Noble and possibly the Porsche too.
Actually with the service intervals being at 6k, costing £700 at least every time tbh you're unlikely to have any savings, eats fuel too but if you care you can't afford it anyways. Porsche is just more refined, classy & raw car than the GTR, has a manual option with a rear engine - that's just more sports car than the GTR
The race is my fav part.
The noble making the turbo and gtr look like hot hatches on a track day 😂
Is this an old episode? These are all old cars?
If this was the return of Tiff i would subscribe i guess o was wrong, this is old fith gear...no Tiff bye bye
I remember meeting Plato pissed up in a urinal at a festival and arguing about the best car to buy for under 100k.
🤣🤣🤣 must’ve been cracking
He admitted the gtr was faster. But the Porsche was a better every day car. I argued. You're a race care driver, comfort should not come into it!
A Porsche is a Porsche is a Porsche is a Porsche that’s all best car off all time a supercar a car for shopping a car for showing off a car for everyday errands a car for touring a car for adrenaline you name it it’s got it
Porsche wins , I think.
I'd take the noble still
OMG Noble. Haven't heard bout them for ages. Are they doing all right?
damn the porsche can out drag the gtr? nice one
a bit unfair as the GT-R here is a base model whereas the Turbo is not. Should have been the Nismo version to make it really fair (and much more interesting)
Would have been same outcome
ruclips.net/video/YOwO5iM4QP8/видео.html
turbo s is really god of the line
Great chemistry between the three of them makes for fantastic viewing. ❤
Love you guys. Much love from Northern California
i'd take that noble in a heartbeat. i love that thing.
I like Noble, don't like the price. Volvo engine , volvo xc90 rims ...It's Half volvo..:D
I love sports cars with 4 seats. Fun to share with the family. I suppose the Lotus Evora would fit into this comparison just as well.
Those rear seats in the Evora, GTR and 911 Turbo are tiny though.
Tiff reminds me of c3po
I might be 4 years late but today the RUclips Algorthim decided that it was time to show someone the hugely impressive driving skills of the Noble driver. My Huge respect! It takes loads of Skill to not just keep it in one peace but hold it at the limits over such a long time!
I doubt it is the newest 911
This was proper fifth gear 💪
Noble for me💪🏽
So the Nissan had to block the others to win. What a polite way of saying the Nissan was slowest on the track LOL 🤣🤣
Tiff is an old school experienced driver...hence the needle nailed it 😜
The Nissan and Porsche are not track cars, why such an emphasis on track performance? Yes makes for good TV but as daily driver AWD supercars they should primarily be tested on the street. Test the Noble on the track with GT3 or GT2.
I would personally choose the noble m600.. good test..
Why is it always wet over there?
Take these cars to another country
What kind of a "test" is this? 3 guys having fun with teir cars. That's okay. The fun for the audience is .....where? What does the test say about the cars? Nothing. What we know is, they all can definetely NOT drive. Was this the reason for this...whatever you call this video?
The 911 Turbo S is easily the best car here undoubtedly
every car manufacturer is lying with numbers... porsche is doing it in another way lol
Porsche has 50 lb ft more torque. Its always the turbo S in these types of videos not the turbo version. Twice the price of the gtr. That noble is fucking crazy.
I like fifth gear but it's completely pointless to compare a 2WD car to 4WD cars on a wet surface.
The nissan gtr is the best, look at it's price £76,000 ,porsche £140,000 , noble £200,000. A value for money supercar.
Listen good people, when it is not the better engine, chassis or driver that won the race there is no race. That Noble is a legend. Motorsports are dying while transitioning to video games, you no longer can tell the better car or driver, it's just about who is the better hacker. RIP
Gosh that Noble is such a beast. Lottery car for sure.
Gotta say that Nobel is the most desirable and the most expensive also .
Well... If we talk money, the GTR is the best (But with unlimited money, I'd buy the Noble haha)
Why do they always test the good stuff is when it’s raining outside? Do they have to film on that particular day or something? Sucks
Conclusion:
Only one car requires driving skills; the other two are toys for beginners.
5th gear rules...thanks
200,000 quid for a noble u must be on drugs ..id take the porsche the nissan not to bad for a ricer
Turning traction control off the Noble was a stroke of stupidity.
the noble is a copy of every European car manufacturer, what is it an audi a ferrari a porsche???