How Wrong Is MyAnimeList Top 10? | Fake Fans #2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 июл 2024
- Scar and Pete give their hot takes on the MyAnimeList Top 10 anime list. Are they right? Are they wrong? Find out in the new episode of Fake Fans Podcast!
⏰ Timestamps
0:00 - Intro
0:26 - Scarra’s First Anime Figure
0:55 - Podcast Stalkers
1:35 - What’s the most overrated anime?
2:00 - Lily’s A Fake Fan
2:28 - Figurine pt. 2
3:18 - Metallic Rouge
5:35 - Top 10 Anime
6:35 - #10 Legend of the Galactic Heroes
8:19 - Friend Group Doesn’t Watch Anime
9:44 - #9 Bleach Thousand Year Blood War
11:38 - Naruto vs. Bleach Last Arc
14:56 - “Boruto Is Decent”
15:42 - Tite Kubo Artistry
18:30 - JJK Cursed Power
20:20 - Bankai and Domain Expansion
22:53 - Scarra’s Black Clover Obsession
25:25 - #8 Gintama’
28:00 - Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu
29:28 - #7 Hunter x Hunter
38:08 - #6 Gintama: The Final
38:20 - #5 Attack on Titan
40:46 - Global Influence on Anime
42:30 - Endings
43:34 - #4 Gintama°
44:16 - #3 Steins;Gate
48:17 - #2 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
48:36 - Podcast Stalker Makes A Comeback
50:01 - What To Watch If You’ve Never Watched Anime
52:11 - Sydeon’s FMAB Outtakes
54:11 - #1 Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End
58:41 - Ping Pong the Animation - Should be Top 10
1:00:21 - Vinland Saga - Should be Top 10
1:02:47 - Hana Kaoru & Romance Anime
1:02:30 - What Scarra and Peter are reading?
1:08:24 - Outro
☝ Follow Scarra:
• RUclips - / @scarra
• Twitter - / scarra
• Instagram - / scarra
✌ Follow Peter:
• RUclips - / @peterparktv
• Twitter - / peterparktv
• Instagram - / peterparktv
🎧 Audio versions:
• Spotify - open.spotify.com/show/4nEJMF8...
• Apple Podcasts - podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
🎞️ Edited by:
• Needy - / needdyedits
📋 YT manager:
• Amanda - / nepheloyd
#Anime #Manga #Podcast 
Кино
I wasn't expecting a Filler Arc cameo this soon.
They reminded me to check out what Lily's voiced recently though and God Damn It! - I was already watching CFV Overdress (friends got me into the TCG) and would have switched to English if I knew my favourite character was Lily!
idk if yall are reading comments but one topic that could be good is fav manga that got cancelled too soon in your opinion. one of my favs was mx0 that didnt even get an ending before it was pulled.
Ty this is a great idea
I know that manga the one like harry potter but with card it's a fun read
Someone spit roast that man Toast, how dare he say haikyu 👺
ayo?
bonk
HUH
Can I join?
roasting toast. so put him back in his natural habitat?
Scarra and Peter hating on Steins Gate is evoking the same emotion that your grandparents being racist does. I like you guys, so why are you paining my heart so bad 😭
They're right though
Ooohhh no I haven’t gotten to that part in the video, i love Steins;Gate it’s one of my favorites 😭😭😭
Peter, check out the 2018 remake of Legend of the Galactic Heroes (subtitled as "Die Neues These"). Same story with modern art and animation and music. Highly recommend if the old animation is too old for you.
There are differences but it's still worth watching but I don't think people will fully understand why the original is regarded as the GOAT by many if they just watch the new one
The original is something else the remake is good I’ll give them that (and I believe it does one or two things better) but the 1988 ova is one of the craziest things I’ve ever seen
It's funny how they call the series too old when DBZ came out just a few months later.
Did the 2018 anime finish? I thought it didn’t? Maybe I just didn’t finish it
@@kassygo1375 No, it's still on going.
About the new Bleach - they add some scenes that were omitted in the manga due to time constraints at the time of publishing but is mostly the same as of the current episodes. You won't get a rewritten story but it's a damn fun and good-looking action show and it's still hype as fuck (I'm biased)
Love y'all for bringing up Silver Spoon and Kaoru Hana
This Podcast is the hidden carry man, GIVE IT TIME. You guys are fun af to listen to.
Surprise guest appearances! Love to see some guests on this podcast.
I could just be a stoner but the relaxing-ness of Mushi Shi and the flowy light heartedness of it and very loosely tied story is amazing
Loving the podcast! Any chance of a drinking episode or a book swap and review (peter suggests for scarra and vice versa)
The fragrant Flower blooms with you is great
I dropped Steins;Gate after one episode but I kept hearing how good it was, so I gave it another shot and was glad I did. In the beginning, you have to be OK treating it like a slice of life anime with a cast of weirdos.
Let Lily have a seat at the table please LOL
I love attack on Titan during it's discovering the world's mysteries phase and the Outside world revealed phase for very different reasons.
These are some spicy takes, and I’m all for it haha! I don’t agree with some of them, but at the end of the day, we are all different ppl with different interests and I respect that.
Keep it up, im enjoying the podcast
I swear if the special guest is sungwon I'm gonna scream
It would interesting to see if Peter or Scarra to read something like Kingdom ( although its super long, all the arcs are pretty engaging)
Whoa, PP's a Kaoru Mori fan, had not expected that. Her detailed art in Otoyomegatari/Bride's Story is so insane. She makes a piece of flatbread look like a museum exhibit, it's crazy.
Oh my god. Emma was mentioned!! That was such a good anime. Never read the manga, but that one absolutely got me in the heart strings. The opening music still immediately rings in my ears when I think of it. So good.
... I had no idea that A Bride's Story was made by the same person. It's actually really good too. Such a good mangaka.
Jeeez two episodes in one week :O
Pog new episode. And I have to say, scarra is just wrong to stop at the best part of vinland saga. The gore in the dreams and peace at the farm is so good.
I am so happy to finally have another scarra podcast
All i gotta say is.... Man they make trash taste look like they should be called GOD taste
I lol'd but I disagree. Trash Taste guys are anime hipsters that only let themselves like something when few people know about it, and if a show is already popular they want nothing to do with it. Shows get popular for objective reasons. I just want a show that acknowledges that.
thoughts on The Climber (Kokou no hito)? personally one of my favorites and definitely a hidden gem
I finally met another fan of Ping Pong the animation!! I fkn love that show! One of my favorite of all time! I’m so glad Scarra is giving it the love it deserves!
Peter’s Kyouma laugh was actually spot on took me off guard LOL
A recommendation for a wholesome manga is yotsuba. It follows a 5 year old kid who discovers life with a great surprising cast. It’s funny and almost always has a feels good ending
It's funny how at just about every crossroad of information they encounter and discuss they decide on the exact wrong fact direction 😂. Ya can't even get annoyed about it either with the title "Fake Fans." Well played.
FWIW, Peter was not wrong when he recalled Alluka as Killua's brother. Varying characters refer to Alluka as the brother, although Killua refers to Alluka as his sister. The official databook lists Alluka as male. I interpreted this as the mangaka author subtly writing in a gender identity story in the sub-text, as it might not be received well in conservative Japan if made blatant and obvious. I like to think Alluka was born male, then used her power to make changes to reality so that she became the sister she felt she was inside.
I liked black clover for the first 100 chapters, afterwards I pushed myself through the next 100 chapter hoping it will get good again but after a while I just didn't bother reading it again. I guess you can say it also suffered from power creep
Ascendance of a Bookworm light novel has some of the best world building - it's anime isn't as well polished and not the most accurate adaption for part 2 (season 2 & 3 for the anime), but the 3rd part will get adapted soon by WIT studio (animated AOT, ranking of kings, spy x family, vivy to name a few) which hopefully will follow the source material closer
I really enjoy romance manga but the drama can get too much sometimes like the main characters finally getting together after nearly 100 chapters but they nearly brake up for the dumbest reasons. So something like Hana Kaoru with no drama is so nice to enjoy a series about an unrealistic healthy relationship.
Wow, it's so interesting to hear fake fans opinion on the MAL list. Might as well continue this to the #20 until #50 or #100. So many good animes are there!
50:56 full metal alchemist was vibes ngl - but you know how you guys dislike endings of shows and anime’s stiens gate is one of those anime’s where the ending is perfect where the entire anime builds up to the ending it’s like a trance song that’s building up over time over 23 episodes
The new Trash Taste since they actually talk about anime!
Let's see if they are still talking about anime 200 episodes in 😋.
Trash Taste deserves the playful jabs, but I understand their need to mix in varying content.
D.Gray-man mention pog 32:20
I'm pretty sure Thousand year arc is the last arc, its more of a continuation not a remake.
irs pretty crazy how confidently they they talk about things they apparently do not know about. 😂
scarra talked about hakari getting introduced soon and i burst out laughing. as a jjk stan that was a moment i was like "nah i'm skipping the text i can just tell the power is `win out` or `better luck next time`"
honestly i think anime yt needed a new well produced podcast, refreshing and fun to watch/listen
The thing about steins;gate IMO since i watched long time ago was you need to know that half of the series just the built up of what's gonna happen in the last half of the series because the last half of it was just pure intensity of the consequences that happened because of it. Also the science adventure series just like that most of the time the occultic;nine, robotic;notes, chaos;head also had that same pacing you guys should watch it or play the game if you like VN games
As a fan of Bleach (anime only) I see why some people dropped it in the start of the Hueco Mundo arc as it is similar to the Soul Society arc. The fullbring arc fell flat because it followed up the conclusion of the arrancar arc. That being said, the fullbring arc did a good job of showing Ichigo's character as he not only had to deal with being powerless (literally and figuratively) from being able to help his family and friends, but the despair he goes through when everyone in his life has been brainwashed and turned against him. It just made the pay off of him getting his powers back so much better.
The way scarra felt about hana kaoru is kinda the way I felt about the great cleric. I always thought there is going to be a really bad plot twist coming but no, this is just a feel good anime lmao
Ping Pong is not quite in my top 10 but it definitely deserves to be up there. Same with Vinland Saga
Eh I would rather stuff like ashita no joe, tatami galaxy and sakurada reset myself though that last one is never happening in a million years 💀
@@danielgwynne7266 You watch Hajime No Ippo?
@@DomLeSup read
Have you guys read blame! by Tsutomu Nihei? I'd love to hear your opinions on it if you've read it. That shit is goated
20:19 I was waiting for that answer
gintama is not just gag manga there is some serious arc on it that have good sword fight
On the topic of mecha anime, what are your twos opinion on Neon Genisis Evangelion
I never knew you guys could be so based. Silver Spoon and Fullmetal Alchemist were indeed both incredible, but I too loved Silver Spoon more. As for Kaoru Hana, if you really liked how they communicated, you should really watch Skip and Loafer!
Steins gate have a really slow start but if you get to episode 11 it really pays off
Here for the algorithm!
Ping Pong the Animation is my favorite anime of all time and I love hearing it mentioned
I sometimes understand how people call the first 9 episodes of Steins;Gate slow, but calling episode 1 boring is mind blowing to me. We find a corpse / someone that was just murdered with a stab wound and at the end of the episode that person is alive again. How is that not an interesting setup?!
Also calling the Steins;Gate characters annoying but not having an issue with Edward Elric is insaaane haha
He had me with the Ping Pong praise but then lost me with dropping Vinland Saga at farmland arc 😭
When Steins Gate came out the number of anime being released is not as many as today, I think thats a big factor of why people were able to give it more patience. also people were younger.
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is also my number one.
I think the first episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist (not Brotherhood) are a little better than the first episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood.
But overall Fullmetal Alchemist brotherhood is so grate.
The old Ghost In The Shell (1995) is one of my favorit movies of all time.
I have just revisit Avatar the last airbender (it is still good), Neon Genesis Evangelion (it is fine) and I watched Blue Eye Samurai (surprisingly good, for adults only). So I am on a roll🥰. Maybe it is time for Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood again.
so to clear things up on bleach manga the author was getting axed. So he had to rushed the ending I think it was 3 months to finished the series. also the original anime ended at the fullbring arc.
Please make a reaction to the top 10 manga 🗣🔥
Gintama has a slow start but it is necessary to get familiar with all the characters. The appeal of Gintama is that the comedic moments make you invested in the characters so when the serious moments occur, you fall in love with them. Also Sugibro, the seiyuu of Gintoki, is the GOAT.
Pausing in the middle again, because Scarra my dude, Hinamatsuri is indeed the BEST comedy anime I've also watched! Just absolutely based take on that one. I'mma watch the rest now :]
What’s the best place to read manga/manhwa online that’s free or subscription???
Terrible opinions, excellent content. Love it.
I prefer 'slower' media but I still think the Frieren manga has pacing issues - we get the same story reskinned a few times. Peter is absolutely right about the animation elevating the story though, it creates something that's just not possible in manga
my top ten would include ttgl, cowboy bebop, monster, and evangelion
Have you guys read The Fable?
You got it mixed up a bit; The brothers in FMA tried to bring their mom back and, as part of the backfire, the elder brother lost an arm and a leg, and the younger brother lost his entire body. Older bro used his blood to bind his brother's soul to a suit of armor
Almost. Ed just lost his leg from the backfire. He sacrificed his arm to bind his brother's soul to the armour. Which is why in the finale SPOILER Al sacrificed his soul to get Ed's arm back.
Where do you read your manga at?
Scarra shouting out Hinamatsuri felt so good. Actually amazing show
I want peterpark's MAL or animelist something pls
Naruto nails its final moments better than Bleach. Like it thematically comes together better. Ending on a Naruto vs Sasuke fight.
But the build up to that climax was a slow, drawn out, pain. Even in the manga it's pretty slow. We really didn't need a "greatest hits" of all the villains? I like Zabuza and Haku, but like...did they need to return? Bringing Nagato back actually felt more like a slap in the face to his death.
But Bleach definitely paces itself better leading up to that final moment, but then...it really fumbles the ball...or more like it just...loses the ball...what even was the ball? Oh and as Scarra mentioned. The power scaling lost itself way too quickly. Right from the beginning of the arc. (Hey that ties into one of the things I really liked about Fullbring)
For Gintama, the anime wasn't that fun at the first 50 episodes (the comedy felt like it was only made for Japanese) then it gets its first serious arc and its comedy becomes way more fun (becomes the GOAT anime).
The best thing production of Gintama did, was splitting the anime into seasons, so its later seasons have high rating.
Robotech is Macross ..... Well, living up to the podcast name I guess. Also not a remake at all but they are changing things because people HATED the ending to the arc and the worst arc is actually the Bount Arc.
I'm not gonna shill too much about Gintama but it's my favourite anime of all-time cause the voice acting is god-tier. The voice actors truly made this series shine and elevate all the random crap they have to act out 🤣
Haikyuu so much of a force in the sports anime/manga genre that there was a noticeable increase in volleyball teams in Japan after its release.
i wonder when is the manhwa episode, light novel episode, manhua episode
any steinsgate fan will say the first 8-9 eps are painful, you need to get to like ep 11 before it gets interesting. the last 10 eps are the reason it is where its ranked
thats insane
Steins;Gate is essentially written as a long movie. The first 10 episodes of so is just build-up, the same way how a good thriller movie is just build-up the first act.
As a steins;gate fan, no they aren't painful. They're slower and take their time building the characters and story, sure. But saying it like that is a disservice. The only reason the second half is so good is because of the first half.
@@Heatranoveryou No, it really isn't.
So glad this podcast was created. The cancellation of the noodle shop podcast left a void smh lol
not the description saying "scar and pete" 😭
the bleach 1000 year blood war is worth watching even if u read the manga kubo intends to put bleaches proper ending into the anime
Legend of the Galactic Heroes is one of the best animes ever to exist. If you love the politics of early game of thrones, then you won't be able to stop watching
Peter, Emma IS literally Jane Austen (Pride and Prejudice)
Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu is wonderful. Legitimately. It's long, but it's a fantastic space opera. There's key moments in there that pay off emotionally so well.
Gintama is the funniest anime I've ever watched. The first couple episodes didn't do it for me, but it got way better.
I'm of the same mind as Peter about Attack on Titan. It crashed and burned at the end.
Steins;Gate was good and has some memorable aspects, but I wouldn't necessarily put it in the top ten. But clearly it has a timeless quality to it if it's still that highly rated. Maybe if I rewatched it I'd reevaluate it even higher than I did previously, which was pretty high to begin with.
FMA:B is deserving up there. It may not be the absolute favorite of most people, but it is probably considered great by the most people. Even if other anime get more 10s, they usually also get more 5s or even 1s than FMA:B. It is so universally regarded as good that it deserves that spot.
I've read Frieren up to a point (and set it down as I focused on other things). Maybe I need to re-read it from the beginning to reevaluate it more accurately since I don't really get why it's so highly rated.
If there's one that I can think of that deserves to be in the top ten, I suppose I'd say Monster. It's legitimately so fucking good.
you must record it so long ago if frieren has only 9.14. it's on 9.39 right now xD
Hey hey nothing wrong with being the person who read the black clover manga.
i imagine i couldnt watch steins gate now. I dont really even want to try honestly.
Why? Because someone else said they didn't enjoy it? These guys couldn't recognize a great show because of their limited attention span.
There's a reason it's so highly rated. Just watch it.
Hinamatsuri is Goated. If you haven't seen it, it is so so good for a laugh. Many many laughs.
Romance anime is my fave genre too!! Peter you are my spirit animal!!! 😂😂
I am only here to say I agree with Peter’s take about Silver Spoon being better than FMA 🤷🏽♂️
i need episode 3.
this podcast is amazing, they talk more about anime and manga in 2 eps than trash taste in 199 !
Too bad their opinions are dogshit
I also can't get into Stein's gate.. I dropped it after episode 2
Steins;gate first 10 episodes was definitely a slugfest. I watched it a decade ago and I dont know how I persevered through 10 episodes. At the time I didnt even know that the first half was a drag, I went in watching it with 0 knowledge about the show. Not to hype to much, because hype often leads to disappoint, but it definitely gets good on the second half. I dont if it is because I watched it as a teen, but steins;gate left a huge impression on me. I still remember the op to this day
Gintama definitely grows on you. nowadays audiences want the first episodes to be action packed bangers to get hooked.
All of their confusions for jjk power can be answered by one youtube video it seems.
Damn these guys need to find manhwa lowkey
The Couple Breaker
Need more
It should be illegal for Scarra to stop at the farmland saga arc.
for Steins Gate you need to watch 13 episodes for stuff to make sense, 9 is not enough.
FMA Brotherhood sooooo goodddd