Powerful Nashville Debate! Is Jesus the Jewish Messiah? Rabbi Tovia Singer vs. Prof. R.L. Solberg
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 ноя 2024
- Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2) outreachjudais... us combat aggressive evangelization in Israel: outreachjudais...
Filmed by Jim Long Lightcatcher Productions
#ToviaSinger #Judaism #Christianity #Messiah
![Kodak Black - Catch Fire [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A4ch-olIuZo/mqdefault.jpg)
I’d listen to these two on a podcast for hours a day. Really the world needs more talks like this
"Remember first things of ancient times *because I am God, and there is no additional god, and there is nothing that can be compared/similar to Me.* " Isaiah 46:9.
😅😅😅😮😅😅😅😅 1:39:05 😮
Thank you, Rabbi Tovia Singer vs. Prof. R.L. Solberg, for this wonderful debate. It is awesome that two people with different beliefs can present their views in a professional matter. It was very heated but since they both respect each other opinions, this makes this debate a success. I learned more from both sides.
I enjoyed the debate between the two. Respect of each other and humorous. I think it is for us to choose what we think is a true representation of scriptures. I believe that there is truth that had come out of both.
@@eldabarTorahObseventCommunity Easy rule of thumb: What's new isn't true, and what's true isn't new.
@@eldabarTorahObseventCommunity ,
Agreed
@eldabarcitychurch9940 For sure and, the two debaters are gentlemen and convincing, but the issue whether Jesus is the Jewish messiah is totally a hidden matter and will remain so until the messiah returns. This is beneficial for both the Jews and the gentiles so that Jesus is vindicated by The Lord of ALL creation particularly the 'unaccepting' Jews plus all other religions who don't know anything about the Jesus of Nazareth.
Rabbi Tovia should get millions of views his programs are very informative
"You [The Jewish People] are My witnesses," says Hashem, "& My servant whom I chose, in order that you know and believe Me, and understand that I am He; before Me no god was formed and after Me none shall be. I, I am Hashem, and besides Me there is no Savior." Isaiah 43:10,11.
Amen
I thought after hearing his credentials that this was going to be a very interesting debate but Rabbi Tovia Singer won hands down again. I am talking as an ex Christian for 60 years. Because I didn't believe in the trinity one elder told me I was not a Christian because that is the fundamental belief of a Christian. I said goodbye and never went to their apostolic meetings again.
Thats right thumbs up there is no saviour but I AM before Abraham was I AM Jesus indeed thanks for your support of NT good on ya be blessed .
@@williamdodds1394 don't be an arsehole it doesn't do you any good. There is no saviour outside God nothing to do with Jesus. Even the Muslims are incorrect that he went to heaven. Only Enoch has walked with God. Go and mock yr own you sad pretentious man.
My favourite Bible verse. "My witnesses" (plural) "my savant" (single)
700 years before Jesus even walked the earth
The amount of respect they have for each other is phenomenal! They can debate with respect and dignity! Love this
Didnt see it that way when Solberg gave his dig song at the beginning against the Rabbi. Pretty disrespectful.
Holy Holy Holy Holy Holy Holy it Holy
The lie b Benjamin Franklin said advertising can best be described as arresting human intelligence long enough to get money it
Life after death😊
You are spirituality dead according to the Torah. Have you thought about it where you go after you die?
What a beautiful and civil discourse. Whatever you believe, after listening to these two men, their arguments they posit are very well researched and have,both, elements of truth. I could support both. Excellent!!!
May Hashem bless you with a long life so that you should continue spreading the truth and be a light to the nations, The mouth of Hashem my beloved Rabbi.
"Praiseworthy is the man who does not go in the advice of the wicked, and in the paths of sinners he doesn't stand, and in the company of the insolent he doesn't sit, *but rather his sole desire is in the Torah of Hashem, and in His Torah is he busy with day and night..."* Psalm 1.
Why do you add and subtract Jonathan….You are just another hypocrite using scripture for your ego
"...and there is *no god with Me* " Deuteronomy 32:39
I have been waiting for this debate to be uploaded 😃👏
@ISRAEL No
@@messianicjudaism3420 no what?
@@demitrykhandree1774 no what?
@@lets_explore_the_bible its deleted but No to Jesus is not your Messiah because he is
@@messianicjudaism3420 I never said he wasn't
Oh ! This was exciting!
This is the type of respectful dialogue and debate people should be having. We can all learn from this. Shalom.
Amen!!!🎉❤
They are trying to make it respectfully but believe me there is no respect between these two ideologies,Jews don't know and don't ever want to know anything about Prophet Jesus and the Christians don't know and don't ever want to know anything about Prophet Moses .
@@naeemqureshi5819 thankfully there are those of us that understand both. I also understand both sides. Believing the other and why.
Okay, maybe I should have used the word civil. You don't have to agree with one another to be civil. There's a good book called civility. Everyone should read it.
@@naeemqureshi5819 that is because your idol is never mentioned in the Jewish holy scriptures, not even once. If he was all the jews would be in Sunday church. Xtia ity is the same paganism as Rome and greece.
"'Cursed be the man who makes any image or graven image, an abomination to HaShem...' And the whole nation responded 'Amen!'" Deuteronomy 27:15.
So why yahwe dwelt in the temple built by salomon which was fulled with graven images
You do not understand tanak
Keep praying for understanding
@@agulu772 it's so funny that one who uses a translation to read the Bible has the guts to say to a Hebrew speaking man, that he doesn't know.
@@anti_missionary_mission so why the ancestors of this hebrew speaking man were rejected by yahwe
Whereas they knew hebrew far better than their little son
Stop bragging about your hebrew
You just learned hebrew in new york
Anyone can do that
It's not bragging, it's a fact Jews study nuances in text that cannot be translated in a text. Somehow Christian think you don't need nuances, but only blind faith. And put their trust in a translation without knowing what's truth.
So may be you Can show us what we missed in enghlish about the temple being full of graven images
You may also explain why yahwe commanded moses to build the bronze serpent
Why !!! to pray was not sufficient to be cured from the snakes bites
Please explain what we missed
*"I am YHVH, and there is none else, besides for Me there is no god...so that all will know from east to west, that there is none except for Me, I am YHVH and there is nothing more/else, Whom creates light and forms darkness, Whom makes peace and creates evil, I am YHVH Who does all these" Isaiah 45 verses 5-7.*
After years I finally see what Rabbi was saying and why it seemed like he wasn't answering the professor's inquiries. The reason is that the Rabbi uses the Bible to make his case. The professor quotes humans who've read scriptures to make his case. In order for the Rabbi to engage with your arguments, the professor would have had to quote scripture to formulate his arguments. Instead you has the professor quoting obscure rabbies and atheist to make claims he already believed.
"Because all of the nations go each person with the name of their god, but we shall go with the name of Hashem our God forever and eternity. " Micha 4:5.
His Name is YHWH! His Son, our Messiah, is Yahshua. I pray your heart is softened to Him before it is too late.
@@camilla6110 About Solomon: "I will be a Father to him, and he shall be a son to Me." Samuel 7:14. What about Psalm 89 verses 27 & 28? "he shall say to Me 'You are my Father'...therefore I appoint him 1st born, highest of the kings of the earth"?... See verse 21 "I have chosen David My servant and anointed him with My sacred oil"... *"My son, My 1st born is Israel" Exodus 4:22.*
@@Yehonatan613 I’m not going to get into a scriptural debate. When the Father said there are none else-no gods besides Him, He was talking about FALSE mighty ones-of which there are thousands. HIS Name, YHWH, is THE Name above all Names, THE Name He gave to His Son, our Messiah, Yahshua, and THE Name, our Messiah came and proclaimed to His brothers and the world “Tehillah 22:22 and Ivrim 2:12. Yahshua only esteemed His Father-He NEVER took any esteem for Himself. Everything He did, said and was, pointed to His Father. Then He laid down His Life, willingly, just as the Father planned. I truly believe this-there is not one doubt in my mind. Shalom.
@@camilla6110 "..and there is NO god with Me..." Deuteronomy 32 verse 39.
@@camilla6110 "Through this did I know that You desired in me, because my enemies couldn't harm me" Psalm 41 verse 12. Opposite is true with the deeply greek zeus hercules pegasis mythical deeply pagan "eat thy flesh drink thy blood" mangod.
Shalom Rabbi Tovia, you are indeed a Bible machine. Watching you is breathtaking especially how you handle questions. Your Hochma is profound. I love you with all my heart. Keep fighting for the Jewish people. Listening to you brings joy to my heart. Toda Raba Rabbi Tovia. Shavua Tov. שלום עליכם
Well, I have some BAD NEWS and some GOOD NEWS. The BAD NEWS is: ALL religions except for Christianity are WRONG!! I know, that sounds intolerant, insensitive and politically incorrect. But it's the TRUTH!! Jesus Christ was and still is the Son of God. He was God in the flesh. He is part of the Trinity, which is One God in Three Persons. If Jesus wasn't God in the flesh, if He wasn't perfect and holy as He claimed, then we are ALL still in BIG TROUBLE. The Message of Christianity, in the Bible, says that you must turn from your sins and put your faith in Jesus Christ in order to be saved. It really is that simple. You may say, " Am I going to Hell if I don't believe in Jesus?!" That is kind of what I am saying. And YES, HELL is a place of ETERNAL fire and torment where people will spend ALL ETERNITY!!! It is not a place of the dead. It is not a place of soul sleep. And it is not a place where the wicked will ultimately be destroyed someday. It is a place of eternal, CONSCIOUS PUNISHMENT FOREVER!!!
The GOOD NEWS is: if, you repent of ALL your sins and Trust in the RIGHT JESUS today, God will save you. He will grant you eternal life, not because you earned it, deserve it or because you are a good person, but because He wants to give you eternal life as a FREE GIFT!!! The Bible says that God will make you BORN AGAIN!! He will give you a NEW HEART and NEW DESIRES!! THIS IS THE TRUTH!! Do it today! Because tomorrow maybe too late!!!!
To: Ikb Dim,
Re: > "Shalom Rabbi Tovia, you are indeed a Bible machine. Watching you is breathtaking especially how you handle questions. Your Hochma is profound. I love you with all my heart.
GLAWRAHHHH 2 GAWD! U no haz 2 Turrpurr-N-tape WRITE! GLAWWWRAHHHH! The 1st Commandment WRITE-LEE TURR-PURR-N-TAPED Meaneth Love Rabbi Tovia Singer with all your heart! Rabbi TOVIA E LU LU YAAAAA! Rabbi TOVIA E LU LU YAAAAA!
@@FrankNStein-pf9rr This is the Gospel of JESUS CHRIST:
Jesus died for our sins, was buried, and was resurrected on the third day. He shed His blood on the cross for you. Your part is to repent of your sins and trust in Him. BUT, you MUST trust the Jesus of the Bible!! YOU MUST BELIEVE THE TRUE GOSPEL OF JESUS!!! Because if you don't, you will be cast into the LAKE OF FIRE FOR ALL ETERNITY!!! Repent of ALL your sins and trust the RIGHT Jesus today and God will save you. He will grant you eternal life, not because you earned it, deserve it or because you are a good person, but because He wants to give you eternal life as a FREE GIFT!!! THAT'S THE TRUTH!!! The Bible says that God will make you BORN AGAIN. He will give you a new heart and new desires. Accept it today!!! Tomorrow could be too late!!
"Jesus answered him, I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father except through me." (John 14:6)
❤❤❤
Such a great debate - loved the dialogue, respect, humour, and knowledge. May all nations come to know Hashem, and serve in unity.
Does Hashem ever care about us, he only focused on one nation. What kind of a god behaves in such a way?
@@berry9840 God continues to give and sustain life for every human being on the planet 24/7. Mankind bring death, disease, and destruction to the world by their free will. If we turn to Hashem, and choose to take the great kindness, it will be provided. The Jewish people are the ones with the mission to reveal God's presence in the world like it was revealed. That does not exempt non-Jews from behaving in the divine image, and doing kindness in turn for the kindness they receive.
@@berry9840 I am a Christian and have never felt a lack of G-D’s love for me, ever. I have had a relationship as far back as I can remember. I have also discovered through DNA testing that my mother’s sister (mother is deceased) that she is 56% Eastern European Jewish and I am 28% Jewish. We were ALL created by HaShem and we ALL carry the Divine within. Religion practice is one thing, our Divine inheritance is another.
@@tongakhan230 We use Hashem as a sign of respect so we don't take God's name in vain, as we are commanded in the 10 Commandments. We only use God's name proper in Prayers, blessings, ect.
God's messiah will be recognized worldwide by all when he is sent. He won't need missionaries, inquisitions, or torture to convince others that he is messiah, like JC needed to "convince" others that he is messiah. God's true messiah will build the 3rd temple in Jerusalem, bring the Jewish exiles back to Israel, bring an end to evil and war, and be a teach to righteous Jews AND gentiles. Hope this is helpful.
@@berry9840
Well considering you had a chance to receive Torah and spat in His face, you should be grateful He didn't just kill you all.
Soon, this topic will be made clear without any room for doubt.
All thanks and praise be to God.
I liked this debate. No one was slandered put down or degraded. Both Prof. Solberg and Rabbi Singer gave each other respect and walked away from that debate as friends or at least as respected humans. This shows promise as there are too many heated debates that lead to no where. You can win the battle but lose the war, so hopefully we will be able to watch more debates with this kind of love for there fellow human. Thanks to all that made this happen!
"As in the days of your exodus from the land of Egypt, I will show them miracles. *The nations* shall see and be ashamed of all their might, they shall place a hand upon their mouth; their ears shall become deaf. They shall lick the dust as a snake, as those who crawl on the earth...of haShem, our God will they be terrified, they will fear You." Micha 7.
"...behold, they are a nation that dwells alone, and among the nations they are not counted... May my soul die (like) the death of the straight ones, and may my end be like theirs" Numbers 23:9&10.
Wow 🎉 That was phenomenal
We love you thank you rabbi
We will join you in Jerusalem
With tears of joy each word felt
Wins for 🇮🇱
❤🕎 ❤ ❤Let's get biblical ❤
"Because I am YHVH and I have not changed..." Malachi 3:6. God doesn't change. This isn't greek pagan theology. There's no faculty of imagination when approaching God/coming to stand before Him/His Oneness/The One in charge over every millimeter of existence.
"After all has been heard/understood, the conclusion of it all is: it is God that you should revere and His commandments that you should keep, for this is the totality/purpose of man, because for every single deed, God will bring to account/to judgement, for every hidden thing, whether good or bad". Ecclesiastes 12:13,14.
"They shall be ashamed and terrified forever; let them be disgraced and perish. And they shall know that You, Your Name is YHVH, *ALONE* , Most High over all the earth" Psalm 83:18,19.
Research noahide letters comes to 666 antichrist .
Both Jews and Christians believe this
Rabbi Singer, you were on fire. Very impressive indeed. May HaShem bless you and your family, and make your mission a success.
"I am First [ie: I have no father], I am last [ie: I have no son] and besides for Me there is no God [ie: I have no brother or co-creator, I am alone]." Isaiah 44:6.
אכן כן
Well, I have some BAD NEWS and some GOOD NEWS. The BAD NEWS is: ALL religions except for Christianity are WRONG!! I know, that sounds intolerant, insensitive and politically incorrect. But it's the TRUTH!! Jesus Christ was and still is the Son of God. He was God in the flesh. He is part of the Trinity, which is One God in Three Persons. If Jesus wasn't God in the flesh, if He wasn't perfect and holy as He claimed, then we are ALL still in BIG TROUBLE. The Message of Christianity, in the Bible, says that you must turn from your sins and put your faith in Jesus Christ in order to be saved. It really is that simple. You may say, " Am I going to Hell if I don't believe in Jesus?!" That is kind of what I am saying. And YES, HELL is a place of ETERNAL fire and torment where people will spend ALL ETERNITY!!! It is not a place of the dead. It is not a place of soul sleep. And it is not a place where the wicked will ultimately be destroyed someday. It is a place of eternal, CONSCIOUS PUNISHMENT FOREVER!!!
The GOOD NEWS is: if, you repent of ALL your sins and Trust in the RIGHT JESUS today, God will save you. He will grant you eternal life, not because you earned it, deserve it or because you are a good person, but because He wants to give you eternal life as a FREE GIFT!!! The Bible says that God will make you BORN AGAIN!! He will give you a NEW HEART and NEW DESIRES!! THIS IS THE TRUTH!! Do it today! Because tomorrow maybe too late!!!!
@@07silvali "Behold I am putting before you a blessing and a curse. The blessing is if you listen to the commandments of YHVH your God that I am commanding you today. And the curse is if you will not listen to the commandments of YHVH your God and if you stray from the path that I am commanding you today *to go and worship foreign gods which YOU HAVE NOT KNOWN OF"* Deuteronomy 11:26-28.
@@07silvali "do not listen to them, *for Hashem your God is testing you to see if you love Him with all your heart and soul,* after Hashem your God shall you go, it is Him that you shall fear, *it is His commandments that you shall keep,* His voice shall you listen to, *Him shall you worship,* and to Him shall you cling, *and that person shall be killed,* because they spoke falsehood against Hashem your God *TO MAKE YOU STRAY FROM THE PATH THAT Hashem your God commanded you to go in* and you shall remove that evil from your midst." Deuteronomy 13.
@@07silvali
انه من يشرك بالله فقد حرم الله عليه الجنة
القران ch4 v72 🔥
"And the Rules and the Laws and the Torah and the Commandments which He wrote for you, you must be watchful to observe *for the rest of all days/time,* and DO NOT fear any other god" 2Kings 17:37.
You see he tells the “ Jews “ do not fear any other “
god “ yet there’s only 1 G_d so why would Hashem say that ? I’ll tell you exactly why cuz the people he’s specifically talking to have a history of worshipping false/foreign gods aka demons of the qlippoth and are known for their lack of bravery and unwillingness to fight….You see John Nathan YHVH knows you better than you know yourself obviously. Look at their lack of belief and unwillingness to March and their willingness to return back to Egypt look at what happened since the time
Of
Solomon and how all the nations have spanked them until finally they were exiled to hide out in “ Christian “ nations….Oh the IRONY is unbelievable….According to rabbi Mizrachi half of the IDF are cross dressers and none actually worship or believe in G_d….USA/Babylon funds them and weaponizes and pledges to protect them…As they’re history proves they’re unwilling to March and pay the ultimate price of sacrifice yet claim to be superior than everyone…3000 years of disaster after disaster spanking after spanking and the one Greek king who took them out the Persian yoke today this clown John Nathan bashes the Greeks when in reality he has a not so secret infatuation with Real men Who have balls and are known in their histories to fight and annihilate foes monsters chop the heads off snakes and wants to be taken on Pegasus for a ride around a Greece…..ClowN 🤡
"The Sacrafice of the Wicked are an ABOMINATION to YHVH, but the prayers of the upright are His will" Proverbs 15 verse 8.
That means, if a person brings a sacrafice but DOESN'T ACTUALLY REPENT/CHANGE THEIR WAYS they have done more DAMAGE THAN GOOD.
Jonathan you’re just a clown 🤡
To Prof Solberg, I was I was able to follow you in everything you said because I have been a Christian for 60 years very devoted, reading my Bible, and very faithful. I was surprised, that he use so many references to people and not about scriptures. I don’t think that your point was strong enough. going back to my Christianity, I said that I have been a Christian for 60 years but a doubter for 15 years. I started doubting my faith once I started studying the Torah. The first thing that I that I saw was that God is not happy with a dollar tree. I took my scriptures very seriously and I renounce my Catholic faith. I became a nondenominational Chriatian. I continued studying the Torah, and found more verses that contradicted my new non-denominational Christian faith. After studying it, living among jews, watching how they keep the family unity together, how they raise their children, how they help the neighbors and the community, I started to confirm that what I was reading and doubting had some weight, worth spending more time and investigating even further. I visited the Vatican, many towns in Italy, visited Spain and visited Israel, looking for some reassurance. Then I started listening the rabbis explaining the contradictions in the bible, many more than what I had found already. Then Oct 7th, 2023 came. I followed the Israeli news and TBN news (Boots on the ground) and then saw the documentary of how the Jewish people treated the dead body parts of the victims, including the blood. I solidly cane to the final conclusion that my doubts about Christianity were real and I was not confused. Today, after 60 years of believing in Jesus as the son of God, I declare that I serve Hashem, the God of Israel, who is only One, and no one can stand beside Him, it is only Him who we are supposed to worship. I give credit of the Roman Empire, who created this nonsense of Christianity, with so many “scholars” who dis their best to come up with this lie. I have to say that they did a great job, but it will not last. The only thing I disagree with Tovi is that we cannot understand the translation of the Torah because words have been changed. I saw different verses that explained each other. I saw that verses together will give you the true meaning of God’s message. Even though men tried to tamper and change certain words, it doesn’t matter, because God wrote it in such a way that He was clear, very clear in His message and is a genius with His production of the Torah.
"But Samuel said: “Does Hashem desire in burnt offerings and sacrifices as much as in obedience to Hashems command? Surely, obedience is better than sacrifice, Compliance than the fat of rams." 1Samuel 15:22.
119.3Treasure laid up on earth will not endure; thieves break through and steal; moth and rust corrupt; fire and storm sweep away your possessions. And "where your treasure is, there will your heart be also." Treasure laid up on the earth will engross the mind to the exclusion of heavenly things.
The love of money was the ruling passion in the Jewish age. Worldliness usurped the place of God and religion in the soul. So it is now. Avaricious greed for wealth exerts such a fascinating, bewitching influence over the life that it results in perverting the nobility and corrupting the humanity of men until they are drowned in perdition. The service of Satan is full of care, perplexity, and wearing labor, and the treasure men toil to accumulate on earth is only for a season.
Jesus said, "Lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust doth corrupt, and where thieves do not break through nor steal: for where your treasure is, there will your heart be also."
The instruction is to "lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven." It is for your own interest to secure heavenly riches. These alone, of all that you possess, are really yours. The treasure laid up in heaven is imperishable. No fire or flood can destroy it, no thief despoil it, no moth or rust corrupt it; for it is in the keeping of God.
This treasure, which Christ esteems as precious above all estimate, is "the riches of the glory of His inheritance in the saints." Ephesians 1:18. The disciples of Christ are called His jewels, His precious and peculiar treasure. He says, "They shall be as the stones of a crown." "I will make a man more precious than fine gold; even a man than the golden wedge of Ophir." Zechariah 9:16; Isaiah 13:12. Christ looks upon His people in their purity and perfection as the reward of all His sufferings, His humiliation, and His love, and the supplement of His glory-Christ, the great Center, from whom radiates all glory.
And we are permitted to unite with Him in the great work of redemption and to be sharers with Him in the riches which His death and suffering have won. MB 88.3 - MB 89.4November 4, 1908
The Plan of Redemption
When Sin Entered
EGW
The fall of man filled all heaven with sorrow. The world that God had made was blighted with the curse of sin and inhabited by beings doomed to misery and death. There appeared no escape for those who had transgressed the law. Angels ceased their songs of praise. Throughout the heavenly courts there was mourning for the ruin that sin had wrought. ST November 4, 1908, par. 1
The Son of God, heaven's glorious Commander, was touched with pity for the fallen race. His heart was moved with infinite compassion as the woes of the lost world rose up before Him. But divine love had conceived a plan whereby man might be redeemed. The broken law of God demanded the life of the sinner. In all the universe there was but One who could, in behalf of man, satisfy its claims. Since the divine law is as sacred as God Himself, only one equal with God could make atonement for its transgression. None but Christ could redeem fallen man from the curse of the law, and bring him again into harmony with Heaven. Christ would take upon Himself the guilt and shame of sin-sin so offensive to a holy God that it must separate the Father and the Son. Christ would reach to the depths of misery to rescue the ruined race. ST November 4, 1908, par. 2
Before the Father He pleaded in the sinner's behalf, while the host of heaven awaited the result with an intensity of interest that words can not express. Long continued was that mysterious communing-“the counsel of peace”-for the fallen sons of men. The plan of salvation had been laid before the creation of the earth; for Christ is a lamb “foreordained before the foundation of the world”; yet it was a struggle, even with the King of the universe, to yield up His Son to die for the guilty race. But “God so loved the world, that He gave His only-begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in Him should not perish, but have everlasting life.” O, the mystery of redemption! the love of God for a world that did not love Him! Who can know the depths of that love which “passeth knowledge”? Through endless ages, immortal minds, seeking to comprehend the mystery of that incomprehensible love, will wonder and adore. ST November 4, 1908, par. 3
The plan by which alone man's salvation could be secured involved all heaven in its infinite sacrifice. The angels could not rejoice as Christ opened before them the plan of redemption; for man's salvation must cost their loved Commander unutterable woe. With what wonder and grief did they listen to His words as He told them how He must descend from heaven's purity and peace, its joy and glory and immortal life, and come in contact with the degradation of earth, to endure its sorrow, shame, and death. He would appear upon earth and humble Himself as a man, and by his own experience become acquainted with the sorrows and temptations which man would have to endure. All this would be necessary in order that He might succor those who should be tempted. He must be delivered into the hands of wicked men, and be subjected to every insult and torture that Satan could inspire them to inflict. He must die the cruelest of deaths, lifted up between the heavens and the earth as a guilty sinner. He must endure anguish of soul, the hiding of His Father's face, while the guilt of transgression-the weight of the sins of the whole world-should be upon Him. ST November 4, 1908, par. 4
How gladly would the angels have given themselves to die in place of their Commander if the sacrifice could have been accepted in behalf of man! But only He who created man had power to redeem him; yet the angels were to have a part to act in the plan of redemption. Christ was to be made “a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death.” As He should take human nature upon Him, they were to minister to Him in His sufferings. They were also to be ministering spirits sent forth to minister for those who should be heirs of salvation. They would guard the subjects of grace from the power of evil angels, and from the darkness thrown around them by Satan. ST November 4, 1908, par. 5
By His death, Christ would ransom many, and would destroy him who had the power of death. He would recover the kingdom which man had lost, and the redeemed were to inherit it with Him, and dwell therein forever. Sin and sinners would be blotted out, never more to disturb the peace of heaven or earth. ST November 4, 1908, par. 6
Sins need human sacrifice Jesus
Blood covers sins we need the blood of Jesus every day
Satan led them on until they seemed to possess a frenzy at the mere mention of the wonderful works of Christ, which were drawing the attention of the people from them. They at length made themselves believe that he was an impostor, and any means they could devise to get rid of him would be a virtue in them. They could not point to one act in his life which they could condemn, yet his very goodness made him a subject of their jealousy and hate, and in their blind rage they cried out, Crucify him! crucify him! The rejection of light leaves men captives of Satan, subject to his temptations. When he controls the mind, light will become darkness to that mind, good evil, and evil good. 4aSG 117.Before Christ left Heaven, and came into the world to die, he was taller than any of the angels. He was majestic and lovely. "Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God." He took upon himself man's nature. When his ministry commenced, he was but little taller than the common size of men then living upon the earth. Had he come among men with his noble, heavenly form, his outward appearance would have attracted the minds of the people to himself, and he would have been received without the exercise of faith. 4aSG 115.1The Son of God, heaven's glorious Commander, was touched with pity for the fallen race. His heart was moved with infinite compassion as the woes of the lost world rose up before Him. But divine love had conceived a plan whereby man might be redeemed. The broken law of God demanded the life of the sinner. In all the universe there was but One who could, in behalf of man, satisfy its claims. Since the divine law is as sacred as God Himself, only one equal with God could make atonement for its transgression. None but Christ could redeem fallen man from the curse of the law, and bring him again into harmony with Heaven. Christ would take upon Himself the guilt and shame of sin-sin so offensive to a holy God that it must separate the Father and the Son. Christ would reach to the depths of misery to rescue the ruined race. ST November 4, 1908, par. 2Long continued was that mysterious communing-"the counsel of peace"-for the fallen sons of men. ST November 4, 1908, par. 3The Son of God in this age will be as virtually despised and insulted by corrupt men who pretend to be good men, as at his first advent. Satan is now transforming himself into an angel of light, to hide the deformity of his character, and thereby he and his evil angels receive that worship from a blinded, deluded people, which belongs alone to God. Christ is trampled under foot. Virtue and holiness are despised. Evil angels whisper their low, corrupt teachings in the ears of men, and they are pleased. Their carnal minds are gratified. That which comes from Satan and hell they make themselves believe comes from the spirits of the dead. Their consciences are seared as with a hot iron. When the Son of God came into the world to die, man's sacrifice, he laid aside his glory and exalted stature. His height was but a little above the general size of men. His personal appearance bore no special marks of his divine character, which would of itself inspire faith. Yet his perfect form, and dignified bearing, his countenance expressing benevolence, love and holiness, were unequaled by any then living upon the earth.
When the Life-giver rose from the dead a triumphant conqueror, and made himself known unto his disciples, he was of the same size as before his crucifixion. There were no special marks which would at once cause the men of Emmaus to know that he was the Son of God. They did not know him until he told them who he was.
But when he ascended up on high, and led a multitude of captives, escorted by the heavenly host, and was received in through the gates of the city, with angelic songs of triumph and rejoicing, I beheld with admiration and wonder, that he possessed the same exalted stature that he had before he came into the world to die for man. Said the angel, God, who wrought so great a miracle as to make Christ flesh to dwell among men, and will with his almighty power lift up fallen, degenerate, and dwarfed man, and after they are redeemed from the earth, make them "grow up as calves of the stall," could in his infinite power return to his dear Son his own exalted stature, which was his before he left Heaven, and humbled himself as a man, and submitted to the death of the cross.
It is no marvel with the angelic host that their loved Commander, after he had carried out the plan of salvation, and ascended up to Heaven, should take his own exalted stature, and be clothed with majesty and glory, which was his before he left Heaven. But it was a marvel with all heaven, that the Father suffered the Son of his bosom to lay aside his glory, and come down to earth, and submit to humiliation, and the agonizing death of the cross to save fallen man. 4aSG 118.3 - 4aSG 119.3
Our heavenly Father designed to prove and test the professed faith and obedience of his people. The sacrifices which they performed under the law were typical of the Lamb of God, and illustrated his great atonement. Yet the Jewish nation were so blinded and deceived by Satan that when Christ came, whom their sacrifices and offerings had been prefiguring, they would not receive him. They led him as a lamb to the slaughter. 4aSG 118.1. Notwithstanding all the mighty works they saw him do, they were too proud and self-exalted to yield their rebellious feelings. Every token and manifestation of his divine character increased the hatred and jealousy of the Jews. 4aSG 116.3But when he ascended up on high, and led a multitude of captives, escorted by the heavenly host, and was received in through the gates of the city, with angelic songs of triumph and rejoicing, I beheld with admiration and wonder, that he possessed the same exalted stature that he had before he came into the world to die for man. Said the angel, God, who wrought so great a miracle as to make Christ flesh to dwell among men, and will with his almighty power lift up fallen, degenerate, and dwarfed man, and after they are redeemed from the earth, make them "grow up as calves of the stall," could in his infinite power return to his dear Son his own exalted stature, which was his before he left Heaven, and humbled himself as a man, and submitted to the death of the cross. 4aSG 119.2Before Christ left Heaven, and came into the world to die, he was taller than any of the angels. He was majestic and lovely. "Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God." He took upon himself man's nature. When his ministry commenced, he was but little taller than the common size of men then living upon the earth. Had he come among men with his noble, heavenly form, his outward appearance would have attracted the minds of the people to himself, and he would have been received without the exercise of faith. 4aSG 115.1Before the Father He pleaded in the sinner's behalf, while the host of heaven awaited the result with an intensity of interest that words can not express. Long continued was that mysterious communing-"the counsel of peace"-for the fallen sons of men. The plan of salvation had been laid before the creation of the earth; for Christ is a lamb "foreordained before the foundation of the world"; yet it was a struggle, even with the King of the universe, to yield up His Son to die for the guilty race. But "God so loved the world, that He gave His only-begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in Him should not perish, but have everlasting life." O, the mystery of redemption! the love of God for a world that did not love Him! Who can know the depths of that love which "passeth knowledge"? Through endless ages, immortal minds, seeking to comprehend the mystery of that incomprehensible love, will wonder and adore. ST November 4, 1908, par. 3
"But take utmost care and watch yourselves scrupulously, so that you do not forget the things that you saw with your own eyes and so that they do not fade from your mind as long as you live. And make them known to your children and to your children’s children: The day you stood before Hashem your God at Horeb, when Hashem said to me, “Gather the people to Me that I may let them hear My words, in order that they may learn to revere Me as long as they live on earth, and may so teach their children.”... And Hashem spoke to you from amidst the fire: *a Voice of words did you hear, but you saw no image, only a voice...And be oh so careful for your souls, for you saw no image* when Hashem your God spoke to you at Horeb out of the fire, *Lest you corrupt yourselves and make for yourself any image in any likeness whatever, whether male* or female...you have been shown all of this to know, that Hashem, He is God, *and there is none else besides for Him"* Deuteronomy 4.
As the all the Idolatrous Israeli kings and the Israelites asking Aaron to make them a golden calf to worship as their God….What about the molten calf of Samaria make sure to always remember that one, hypocrite !!
"And Hashem commanded us to perform all these laws and to fear Hashem our God, for our own good, *FOR ALL OF TIME* ...And it shall be considered *RIGHTEOUSNESS* for us that we shall keep to perform this entire commandment before Hashem our God as He has commanded us" Deuteronomy 6:24,25.
God was born in 1947 to Peggy Jones in London, England. Not Jesus(Not Yeshua) and not Yahweh(not Jehovah).
This Professor is so Brave! This is how anyone in any profession pushes themselves to the next level! You have to challenge yourself! The Professor is in the Light Weight Division but accepted a Heavy-Weight Fight! He stumbles, he goes don’t a few times, he gets back up, he gets rocked back on his heels…and ultimately lost. But he survives…he survives and learns. And he is a better Scholar, Speaker and Man for it. Amen!
"...to You will the nations come from the ends of the earth and say "solely lies did our ancestors inherit us, empty things with no benefit, shall a man make for himself a god? And they are not God". Jeremiah 16:19.
"So said the Lord of Hosts: In those days, in which ten men of all the languages of the nations shall grab hold onto the corner garment of a Jew and say , "Let us go with you all, for we have heard that God is with you all!" Zecharia 8:23.
Rabbi Singer I have your books. You are a brilliant scholar. You made me re-read the Old Testament. Between you and Rabbi Friedman both of you have helped me to see scriptures with different lens.
The truth matters. If the promised messiah came and fulfilled prophecy. One of the prophecy warned Israel if they won't listen and honor this promised prophet and messiah , they will be held accountable and judged by this messiah like Moses. Isn't that detrimental and imperative to overlook or just let go?????
@@davemiles3062 shalom
@@Yce_Take more circular reasoning… that’s not how truth is obtained
@@Yce_Take
I pray you see the truth and how Thor, Son of Odin, son of Bragi, is the true Friend of Humanity, and I can prove to you Thor is real because I said so.
It is only HOLYSPIRIT who shows the real truth;
No human.
When I'm feeling down I enjoy watching tovia mop the floor with this guy. 😂
I can't tell you how many times I have rewatched this lol
"...how praiseworthy is the person who fears HaShem, who INTENSELY DESIRES His commandments" Psalm 112:1.
God was born in 1947 to Peggy Jones in London, England. Not Jesus(Not Yeshua) and not Yahweh(not Jehovah).
Let me ask you do you obey every commandments of God (let me say all the ten Commandments without any fail in all your thoughts and works)
@@annjen8405obvious answer is no for like everyone on the planet
In 10 yrs this professor will convert to Judaism. Rabbi Singer thank you for your comment “salad bar Judaism” it’s so true that people do this and it’s so easy to do. Keeping focused on the subject isn’t easy to do for so many people and I appreciate your willingness to do these debates.
Gentiles are obligated to keep the 7 Noahide commandments only.
I'm a Noahide but have considered converting to Judaism if have to move to another state within Walking distance from an Orthodox Synagogue at my age 54 idk if that's a good idea
@@susanlett9632whatever is best for you beautiful ❤
@haleysalz1770i made my decision . Converting for sure. Hoping to move in the fall. Saint Louis Park Minnesota. ❤️
@@susanlett9632 amazing! Baruch Hashem! I’m planning to convert too but the nearest synagogue is around 2 hours away from me ❤️
"This entire matter that I am commanding you, *THAT* is what you shall safeguard to perform, *do not add to it and do not subtract from it."* Deuteronomy 13:1.
The covenant made with Moses is not the same as with ISRAEL
Jeremiah 31
31 Behold, the days come, saith the Lord, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah:
32 Not according to the covenant that I made with their fathers in the day that I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt; which my covenant they brake, although I was an husband unto them, saith the Lord:
33 But this shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel; After those days, saith the Lord, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts; and will be their God, and they shall be my people.
@@Yes-fe8ni Compare Deuteronomy 30 verses 1-10 with Ezekiel 11 verses 19&20, Jeremiah 32 verses 37-42, Ezekiel 37 verses 24-28, and also Ezekiel 36 verses 24-28 and then back to Jeremiah 31... all those verses describe following the laws of the Torah... & read the entire Jeremiah 31, bc in the time of the new covenant "no one will need to teach their fellow about God because they will all know Me"...does the whole planet believe your beliefs? Ie: you are mistaken about the new covenant. Study.
@@Yes-fe8ni
Big mistake of yours to bring up Jeremiah 31.
30 Behold, days are coming, says the Lord, and I will form a covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah, a new covenant.
31 Not like the covenant that I formed with their forefathers on the day I took them by the hand to take them out of the land of Egypt, that they broke My covenant, although I was a lord over them, says the Lord.
32 For this is the covenant that I will form with the house of Israel after those days, says the Lord: I will place My law in their midst and I will inscribe it upon their hearts, and I will be their God and they shall be My people.
33 And no longer shall one teach his neighbor or [shall] one [teach] his brother, saying, "Know the Lord," for they shall all know Me from their smallest to their greatest, says the Lord, for I will forgive their iniquity and their sin I will no longer remember.
1. At the time of Jesus, there was only a House of Judah, as the 10 lost tribes of israel were still lost at the time of Jesus. Which tribe of Judah and Israel together were present to receive this new covenant?
Impossible. There wasn't a house of Israel at the time of jesus.
2.Everyone will believe in God.. from the least to the greatest will all know God.
Does everyone on Earth know God and believe in him as the one and only God.
Short answer: No
3. I will place My law in their midst and I will inscribe it upon their hearts. The Torah will be in their hearts. And they will be faithful and loyal to observe it.
Now where have we seen this before?
King David.
Psalms 40:8
O' God, I desired to do Your will and [to have] Your law within my innards.
Ezekiel 11:19-20
19 And I shall give them one heart, and a new spirit I shall place within them, and I shall remove the heart of stone from their flesh, and I shall give them a heart of flesh.
20 In order that they walk in My statutes and keep My laws and perform them, and they will be My people, and I shall be their God.
A transformed heart will result in a people that will keep God's Torah.
Christians keep nothing of the Torah.
To foolishly assert Jeremiah 31 has anything to do with Jesus is preposterous.
Jeremiah 31 has nothing to do with your idolatrous belief in a dead man.
Others for good measure.
Leviticus 26:9
9I will turn towards you, and I will make you fruitful and increase you, and I will set up My covenant with you.
And from Rashi, who you Christians selectively choose to use when you think it suits you. Turns out Rashi never believed in Jesus either, but you knew that.
Rashi explains that the New Covenant will be called “new” because it will be enhanced so that not only will God keep his promise never break it, but even the Jewish people will no longer break it. This will be possible because in the future, our desire to rebel against God will be eradicated, and we will serve God wholeheartedly (Ezekiel 36:26-27).
Leviticus 26:44-45
44 But despite all this, while they are in the land of their enemies, I will not despise them nor will I reject them to annihilate them, thereby breaking My covenant that is with them, for I am the Lord their God.
45 I will remember for them the covenant [made with] the ancestors, whom I took out from the land of Egypt before the eyes of the nations, to be a God to them. I am the Lord.
There's no magical new covenant that disregards the eternal covenant made by God to his people, rather its an expression of reinvigoration of the existing covenant.
@@D18.21 Big mistake of you for rejecting your Lord Jesus. You will reincarnate as a Christian preacher to make up for this wasted life
@@Yes-fe8ni
Great rebuttal. What a thought leader you must be. 😂😂😂😂
I lament for each and every person who cares "debate" Rav Singer. His knowledge is beyond the scope of any of these, so-called, doctors and biblical scholars. He quotes, from memory, from the Tanach, the christian and muslim book all the same! No one can or does come even close!!
"But will God ever dwell on the earth? Behold the heaven and the heaven of heavens cannot contain You; much less this temple that I have erected." 1st Kings 8:27.
1 kings 6:13 just one of many refrences..
Can you build the a house and dwell in it?
"And you shall be *oh so careful* for yourselves, for you did not see any image on the day that Hashem spoke to you at Horeb from the midst of the fire. *Lest you CORRUPT YOURSELVES and make for yourselves a graven image, the representation of any form, the likeness of male or female* ," Deuteronomy 4.----->"I am YHVH, *that* is My Name; and My glory I will not give to another, nor My praise to graven images." Isaiah 42:8----->"And to whom can you liken to God? what form could you ever attribute to Him?" Isaiah 40:18.----->""Now, to whom will you compare/liken Me that I should be equal?" says the Holy One." Isaiah 40:25.----->"To whom can you liken Me and make Me equal and compare Me that we may be alike?" Isaiah 46:5.
Rabbi Tovia won the debate without a sweat! Shalom everyone, watching from Philippines with Noahide family.
🤔
@@friendofvinnie 🤯🤯🤯🤯
@@BarHawa 😂😂😂
@@chrismassey7563 christians amirite
@@chrismassey7563 that's not a argument
The purpose of debate is not to convince your opponent, but rather to show people the arguments in favor of their point of view. That’s why I love discussions between people who respect each other. Thank you for this.
"But if a wicked person turns away from all the sins they have commited & keeps all My decrees & does what is just & right, that person shall surely live; they will not die. *NONE OF THE OFFENSES THEY HAVE COMMITTED WILL BE REMEMBERED AGAINST THEM.* Because of the righteous things they have done, they will live. Do I take any pleasure in the death of the wicked? declares the Sovereign Lord, rather am I not pleased when they turn from their ways and live" Ezekiel 18:21-23.
@Caleb Stanaford so...is Jesus the Lord? Is Jesus the God of Israel? Or is he His son?? Simultaneously, Jesus is a Messiah...really?! So confusing...convoluted. Why on earth was there the need to confuse things? Judaism is so simple - One God. Nothing else.
💙🤍🇮🇱Amen, that's why the Christian will be judged for defiling the "Most Holy Sacrifice" their bible tells them so. Then God will reveal Messiah to Jews. He belongs to you.🇮🇱🤍💙🕊It's all prophesied.
*Son of Man* will bring his *SIN* offerring Isaiah 53 when thou makes his soul an offerring for *SIN* he shall see his seed
@@barbarissabrommel4883
Re: > One God. Nothing else.
What was the word following one called before 359 A.D. as THAT IS WHEN the 3 letter word God first existed. Fill in the blank. One _____
Yehonatan.
@ & Re: Ezekiel 18:21-23, >
"But if a wicked person turns away from all the sins they have committed & keeps all My decrees & does what is just & right, that person shall surely live; they will not die. NONE OF THE OFFENSES THEY HAVE COMMITTED WILL BE REMEMBERED AGAINST THEM. Because of the righteous things they have done, they will live."
Psalm 49:10 > For all can see that even the wise die, leaving their wealth to others. All can see that the foolish and the senseless also perish. < ALL ALL ALL PERISH!!!
QUESTION! How is it that all who obey WILL NOT DIE and yet it says in Psalms 49:10 ALL will die!!!?? verse 12 People, despite their wealth, do not endure; they are like the beasts that perish. And Ecclesiastes 9 says the living know they will die (cease to exist). 4 Anyone who is among the living has hope -even a live dog is better off than a dead lion! 5 For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing; < THE LIVING KNOW THEY WILL DIE!!
QUESTION!! WHY DO YOU REPEATEDLY USE BIBLE VERSES AND IGNORE OTHERS, AND WHY DO YOU REFUSE TO ANSWER MY QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS ISSUE OF ALL WILL LIVE AND NOT DIE BUT ALL WHO LIVE WILL DIE!!? YOU & RABBI SINger & IN THE LIGHT ANNIE ARE VULTURES OF A FEATHER! NOT ONE OF YOU WILL ANSWER ANYTHING I ASK ABOUT ANYTHING YOU PREACH!!!
"Behold, I have taken them to be a blessing, I shall bless, and I shall not retract it." Numbers 23:20
"And I will multiply your seed like the stars of the sky, and I will give your seed all these lands, and through your offspring will all the nations of the earth be blessed, because Abraham listened to My voice, and kept My charge, My commandments, My rules, and My Torah's." Genesis 26.
@@tongakhan230 The Hebrew scriptures clarify what the "new covenant" is ALL OVER THE PLACE. Compare Jeremiah chapter 31 with Ezekiel 11 verses 19&20, Jeremiah 32 verses 37-42, Ezekiel 37 verses 24-28, Ezekiel 36 verses 24-28 & Deuteronomy 30 verses 1-10... all these *end of days* verses depict the full observance of the laws of the Torah! ...& anyone who reads the entire Jeremiah 31 will see that at the time of this "new covenant" = "no one will need to teach their fellow about God anymore because they will all know Me, from the least of them to the greatest of them" ...does the whole planet have a personal relationship with God today? No! Ie: christians have it ALL WRONG! Ironically the Creator speaks to the polytheists from their own very mouths: "Remove the scales from your eyes".
"...and I have said: I will not ever
["לעולם" "For all Eternity"]
nullify My covenant with you". Judges 2:1.
"For 'ה your G-d is a Merciful G-d, He will not let go of you or let you perish and He will NOT forget the covenant/promise of your forefathers in which He swore to them"* Deuteronomy 4:30,31.
"Yet even then, when they are in the land of their enemies, I will not reject them or spurn them so as to destroy them *or nullify My covenant with them* for I am 'ה their G-d, and I will remember for them 1st covenants in which I took them out of Egypt to the eyes of all the nations to be their G-d, I am 'ה their G-d." Leviticus 26:44,45.
This is the 3rd ir 4th time I have watched this! I have so much respect for rabbi Singer. May HaShem bless you and yours! I've learned so much!
"With regard to everything that I have told you, be watchful to keep, and the name of any other god, do not even utter, it shouldn't be heard on your lips" Exodus 23:13.
lol Jesus is not “another god” all your verses you are spamming are actually helping the case for Christ because they line up with exactly what Christ said. Thanks and may you find Jesus❤
@@dankerdaniel3144 the end times messiah will "Fear God" (isaiah 11:2&3), he is not "their God" (Hoseah 3:4&5). Seek truth, not a sense of validation for wishful preconceptions.
"Let a sinning man leave His evil ways and a man his impure thoughts and let him repent/return to Hashem and He will have mercy on him, to our God for He is abundant in forgiveness, for My thoughts are not like your thoughts, and your ways are not My ways says Hashem, because like the heights of the heavens over the earth so too are My ways lofty/ungraspable from your ways and My thoughts from your thoughts" Isaiah 55 verses 7-9.
Rav Singer, how lucky we are to have you here to represent us and our positions. May Hashem keep you healthy and strong until 120
Man I'm sure Jackie Mason, peace be upon him, approves of all his bits that the Rav uses to lighten the mood. The delivery is perfect and the Brooklyn accent of course. 10/10
"For the day of YHVH over all the nations is close; as you have done shall be done to you; your recompense shall be returned upon your head...And on Mount Zion there shall be a remnant, and it shall be holy, and the house of Jacob shall inherit those who inherited them. And the house of Jacob shall be fire and the house of Joseph a flame, and the house of Esau shall become stubble, and they shall ignite them and consume them, and the house of Esau shall have no survivors, for YHVH has spoken." Obadiah
"Greatly merciful is God, slow to anger and great in Kindness...He does not act with us according to our sins, like the distance of heaven from earth does His Kindness pour over those who fear Him, like the distance of east to west does He distance from us our sins, as a father has mercy on His children does God have mercy on those who fear Him, because He knows our inclination, He remembers that we are but just dust...The Kindness of God is from eternity to eternity *on those who keep His covenant and remember His commandments to perform them"* Psalms 103:7-20
Great work Yehonatan! True to form.
"...and what image can you ever possibly ascribe to Him?!" Isaiah 40:18
Please explain why animal sacrifice is prescribed as a way for pleasing God and as way for forgiveness of sin in Leviticus and Duetronomy.
i have to be honest as a jew i admit i was biased, but really enjoyed this debate. if everyone of different beliefs could sit talk like this it would be a better world.
Wow this was absolutely awesome
Baruch Hashem
Fantastic debate!!! The professor got an education from Rabbi Singer - I'm neither Christian or Jewish. Toward the end it was obvious the professor had lined up so many 'What abouts' he seemed like a 9yr old trying to justify why fatty foods are good for you!! Rabbi Singer handled it like a boss!!!
+JP It sounded like it but actually Rabbi Singer didn't understand what the professor was saying. eg at 1:32 the professor said that there was an idea of two powers in heaven. Rabbi Singer then waffled till 1:36. Singer doesn't understand how to have an honest conversation and debate a point. And what Singer says around that point in the debate, when questioned about two messiahs is just bizarre,, First he denies that there are two.. Then he makes out like it's some obscure minority opinion.
@@boliusabol822 .. Again I am neither Christian or Jewish, I believe the Professor is a great debater and put forward arguments that really tested the Rabbi. Overall though, the Rabbi put it to bed.
@@JP_UK_44 You give no example from the debate, to back it up You are clearly not interested or an intelligent conversation, where you give an argument to back up your point e.g. an example. You are probably not capable of it either, and that's how you formed your conclusion in the first place.
@@boliusabol822 ... Why are you spoiling for a fight? ... I'm not interested in your crap. You're clearly a poor Christian keyboard warrior that needs to understand a few things. Jesus is NOT the messiah. PERIOD.
@@boliusabol822 same can be said about you. biased christian
"For this commandment that I am commanding you today, it is not out of your grasp, and it is not distant from you...for it is very close to you in your mouth and in your heart that you shall fulfill it" Deuteronomy 30 verses 11-14.
Matthew 22:36 Teacher, which is the ((great)) commandment in the Torah?
37 And (( EmmanuEL/Yahshua )) said to him, "You shall love YAHUWAH your Elohim with all your heart, and with all your soul, & with all your mind."(Deut. 6:5)⬅️
38 This is the ((first))and great commandment.
39 And the ((second)) is like it "You shall love your neighbor as yourself." (Lev. 19:18)⬅️
40 On these two commandments all the Torah and the Prophets hang.
Shalom
@@Non-Assumpsit"And My servant David shall be king over them, and one shepherd shall be for them all, *and they shall go in My Laws and observe My commandments and perform them.* And they shall dwell on the land that I have given to My servant, to Jacob, wherein your forefathers lived; and they shall dwell upon it, they and their children and their children's children, forever; and My servant David shall be their prince forever. And I will form a covenant of peace for them, an everlasting covenant shall be with them; and I will establish them and I will multiply them, *and I will place My Temple in their midst forever...And the nations shall know that I am Hashem, Who sanctifies Israel, when My Temple is in their midst forever."* Ezekiel 37.
@@Yehonatan613 ….. You know not declaring his name by replacing it with HaShem is bringing it to naught/ vain emptiness .
Shemoth (Exodus) 20:7 “You do not bring the Name of יהוה your Elohim to naught, for יהוה does not leave the one unpunished who brings His Name to naught. + do not add or (( take away )) Deuteronomy 4:2
@@Yehonatan613 ……..YOḤANAN (JOHN) 17
3“And this is everlasting life, that they should know You, (( the only true Elohim )), and יהושע Messiah whom You have sent.
6“I have revealed Your Name to the men whom You gave Me out of the world. They were Yours, and You gave them to Me, and they have guarded Your Word.
26“And I have made Your Name known to them, and shall make it known, so that the love with which You loved Me might be in them, and I in them
@@Non-Assumpsit *"Have no other god but Me",* not so difficult. *"...and there is no god with Me",* pretty simple, *"I am not a human",* simple, *"no god came before Me nor shall there be one after Me"* simple. *"Lest you corrupt yourselves and make for yourselves any image whether male or female",* i mean, seriously? If christians simply seeked the truth instead of a sense of validation for polytheism, they would realize how they sound.
I never get tired of watching this amazing video. Rabbi Singer is amazing.
"Salvation is far from the wicked, *because they did not seek Your laws* ..." Psalm 119.
If xtians would study the longest chapter in scripture they should run out of church. Psalm 119 is amazing, only love towards the mitzvah (laws) of G-d. Like a parent who protects its children with rules, there're all for a reason weather we understand or know or do no know, it's for our own interest.
"Knowing that a man is not justified by the works of the law, but by the faith of Jesus Christ, even we have believed in Jesus Christ, that we might be justified by the faith of Christ, and not by the works of the law: for by the works of the law shall no flesh be justified " Galatians 2:16 ..
Unfortunately God doesn't stand on law keeping to save us. Reason is obvious. I don't know if your religion believe in the first man ( Adam), If it does you will notice the first man could not even keep the law. Not even Abraham, not even Moses himself as great as he was. For example, in Number 20:11 God told Moses to speak to the rock but he angrily strike the rock leading to his death. And if by law keeping we were made perfect before God there would have not been need for your continual yearly sins offerings, and atonement for the ancient Jews people noted in Leviticus 17 :11. I don't know if these ceremonial figures are still in practice today. But If it does, then we can boldly say it's the sacrifice that blot out sin, Leviticus 17:11 and if we Christians says Jesus Christ is Gods Holy Lamb given to us for same purpose- atonement for our sin, then it makes much sense and stand better ground logically.
The scripture you quoted plus the laws in Torah was fulfilled in our place by the sacrifice of Jesus Christ . Yes, the law is good if we can keep it 1 Tomothy 1:18. The problem is that you and everyone else will keep breaking Gods commandments if you know what the law is. My point is, If God were to justify us through law keeping then He would not have anyone of us in His domain. This is where Christ was grafted in to be born without sin, born without the will of man but by God through His Spirit to fulfill the laws and the prophets..
@@JesusLord_of_lords Compare Jeremiah chapter 31 with Ezekiel 11 verses 19&20, Jeremiah 32 verses 37-42, Ezekiel 37 verses 24-28, Ezekiel 36 verses 24-28 & Deuteronomy 30 verses 1-10... all these *end of days* verses depict the full observance of the laws of the Torah...& anyone who reads the entire Jeremiah 31 will see that at the time of this "new covenant" = "no one will need to teach their fellow about God anymore because they will all know Me, from the least of them to the greatest of them"...does the whole planet believe your beliefs? No. Ie: you are mistaken about the new covenant. Ironically the Creator speaks to the polytheists from their own very mouths: "Remove the scales from your eyes".
@@JesusLord_of_lords
"...and I have said: I will not ever
["לעולם" "For all Eternity"]
nullify My covenant with you". Judges 2:1.
"For Hashem your G-d is a Merciful G-d, He will not let go of you or let you perish and He will NOT forget the covenant/promise of your forefathers in which He swore to them"* Deuteronomy 4:30,31.
"Yet even then, when they are in the land of their enemies, I will not reject them or spurn them so as to destroy them *or nullify My covenant with them* for I am Hashem their G-d, and I will remember for them 1st covenants in which I took them out of Egypt to the eyes of all the nations to be their G-d, I am Hashem their G-d." Leviticus 26:44,45.
@@JesusLord_of_lords where is it written in scripture that faith in the messiah brings Salvation? As Yehonatan mentioned, 'works' or the Hebrew word Mitzvah, is something that G-d ask from us to do forever. The word mitzvah literally means creating a connection, by doing that G-d ask from us, we create a connection.
The west coast needs you over here rabbi! We would love to have you here for a QnA. May Hashem continue to bless you 🙏
Great again from rabbi tovia singer who was the only one to speak what the almighty God of Israel says and not what is not scriptures from the almighty God of Israel 👍👍
Excellent debate. Will rewatch immediately.
Prof. Solberg wants to use the New Testament as if it was accepted fact. My hat is off to Rabbi Singer. How does he stay so calm in the face of nonsense?
Good question. I don't know how Rabbi Singer does it too . lol 😂
That's because it is a fact. Repent and believe and you will be saved. You aren't even living under the law, as there is no sacrifices performed today. That's because jesus was the final sacrifice, and their will be no more until he returns. God Bless.
@@Jerry-zz2eu Gd abhores human sacrifice. There's no SAVIOR except Hashem. Second Kings 17:35-38. Exodus 3:15 & 23:13. BTW....Jesus said "SALVATION IS OF THE JEWS".
If quote the Talmud ..the same. You could find Jesus even through the Kabbala. After they killed Jesus the temple got destroyed and all Jews expelled and a very bad time in the coming centuries. But not learning from it cause there is nothing new under the sun but they are not learning from it. I hope not the Jews will not follow the Antichrist. God bless you all❤️
@@Jerry-zz2eu Where in the Law does it say that a righteous man can die to atone for the sins of the wicked?
"Do not put your faith in princes or in the "son of man" in which there is no salvation" Psalm 146.
Greatly tooken out of context as the prophet Ezekiel had the title “ son of man “ isn’t that right Mr. I take everything out of context for my convoluted ego trip….So taken out of context we shouldn’t trust in the prophecies of the prophet Ezekiel right, you hypocrite and manipulator…
Everyone keeps saying what a great debate this was but I was so upset during most of it. I am a Christian and was hoping that Prof. Solberg would defend the faith….Tovia Singer did an amazing job! How does Prof. Solberg not understand circular reasoning? The more I look into Judaism the more scripture makes sense to me. I was hoping to have some light shed on things by Prof. Solberg but it did happen. I feel like Tovia brought facts, logic, and scripture where as Solberg brought speculation, ideas, and legend. This has been the most heartbreaking journey I have ever been on, my entire belief system has been rocked to its very core, all I am asking is that my fellow Christians show me in the Bible that Jesus used is undeniably the Messiah. If he is/was I pray that the Lord give me piece, discernment and understanding.
Jessica I pray that your faith in Christ be not shaken but search the scriptures and you will see Jesus from Genesis to Revelation. You mentioned the Bible that Jesus used. I understand you are talking about the Old Testament: Isaiah7:14. “ The Lord will give you a sign: a virgin shall conceive and give you a son. That’s Jesus! He was born of a virgin. Many Jewish people argue that it’s a young woman conceiving.. but what’s a sign in a young woman conceiving?
Micah5:2. A ruler for Israel will be born in Bethlehem. Jesus was born in Bethlehem.
Gen 3:15. I will put enmity between you and the offspring of a woman… who is the offspring of a woman? Jesus!
Psalm 78: 1-2 I will teach my people with parables. Jesus spoke to his people Israel in parables
Isaiah 42 to 55 as explained by Rabbi Toviah is about the the Lords servant Jacob/ Israel. What he didn’t expand is that it’s about the redemption of his servant Israel through the long awaited Messiah. Isaiah 53: explains the Messiah and his suffering for his people Israel. Every word in Isaiah 53 is almost fulfilled in Jesus.. why almost? because Jesus is yet to claim his rightful throne in Jerusalem which will happen.
Isaiah 9:1-2 talks about the people of Galilee seeing a great light. Jesus ministry was in Galilee
Jesus geneology is of king David. Both his earthly parents Joseph and Mary are David’s children. And David was promised by God that his throne will last forever. Jesus throne will last forever.
God has brought his people Israel back to their land. We know we are close to the end times and many Jewish people are turning to their Messiah Yeshua like never before. There are still numerous prophecies in the Old Testament about Jesus. Let me stop here. God bless you and convince you of the truth
@@susanvarghese7871 Many non-Jews are also leaving Jesus like never before, an actual sign of fulfilled prophecy. And why are you calling Joseph an "earthly parent" when Jesus supposedly had no earthly father? How could God, his supposed father, have been from the seed of David, and why couldn't the professor answer this question either?
@jessicadrake2170 Have you seen any of my attempted replies? They keep getting deleted.
@jessicadrake2170 Trying again... click either of the links in the description of this video, and then click "free audio" on top, and you will have all the answers you need, since you do seem to be sincere. Not more circular reasoning and pre-conceived notions and out of context and mistranslated verses like Susan has offered above. Success on your journey.
@@leeannep.7652 it’s easy to make claims that verses have been mistranslated by anyone. Why don’t you search the scriptures I quoted and see if they are true. The Bible will speak for itself.
Psalm 110 Of David. A psalm. The LORD says to my Lord: "Sit at my right hand until I make your enemies a footstool for your feet." The LORD will extend your mighty scepter from Zion; you will rule in the midst of your enemies. Why would David address 2 Lords here. He’s addressing the Messiah here and the Messiah happens to be his descendant. He still adresses him as Lord.
Isaiah 9:6
For unto us a child is born,
to us a son is given,
and the government will be on his shoulders
And he will be called
Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God,
Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.
Israel was waiting for this Son!! He will be called Mighty God!! How amazing are the words in the book of Isaiah! Praise God for the wonderful saviour Jesus. I hope this message doesn’t get deleted like the previous one.
For I am the LORD GOD of Israel and there are no other gods before ME".
Your final words in this event conveyed such deep love and peacefulness to all who participated, attended and listen to the recording. This is more powerful and inpacting than even all the good words you had to say. Hope to catch u on the streets of Jerusalem again
I wish Christian had left African slaves alone. It was used to enslave people and justify it.
Rabbi final words are so sweet to you and the final words of Allah the almighty don't mean anything?
@@naeemqureshi5819 cause Allah is a man creation just as Mormonism.
@@williammoran4898 alla is the word used gor g-d in Islam. Islam is truer than xtianity for sure.
@@cmain3931 your delusional
The Rabbi clearly won👍👍
@@Yes-fe8ni satan is an angel of G-d. Angels don't even have free will. You remind us of more of your warped clueless views
"The hidden matters are for Hashem our G-d, but the revealed matters are for us and our children FOR ETERNITY to uphold/keep all the words of this Torah" Deuteronomy 29:28.
It doesn't matter if you spell it with a - or an o
Spot on!
@@mrsatire9475 Then why are you wasting time by commenting on how he spells G-d?
"it doesn't matter", so ignore it.
@@ixHeretic She thinks it does matter.
Do you understand yet?
@@ixHeretic: That's exactly what I was just thinking!!
"When there will be among you a person who claims to be a prophet or a dreamer and they give you a sign or a supernatural miracle, and the sign or miracle in which they spoke happens and they say to you "lets go after foreign worships in which you *have not known of* and worship", do not listen to them, *for Hashem your God is testing you to see if you love Him with all your heart and soul,* after Hashem your God shall you go, it is Him that you shall fear, *it is His commandments that you shall keep,* His voice shall you listen to, *Him shall you worship,* and to Him shall you cling, *and that person shall be killed,* because they spoke falsehood against Hashem your God *TO MAKE YOU STRAY FROM THE PATH THAT Hashem your God commanded you to go in* and you shall remove that evil from your midst." Deuteronomy 13.
"When your fellow tells you in secret saying "let us go and serve foreign worship *WHICH YOU NOR YOUR FOREFATHERS HAVE KNOWN OF* ...do not desire them, don't listen to them, do not have pity on them, do not have mercy on them and do not try to cover for them, for you shall surely cause him to be killed... *because they seeked to lead you astray from Hashem your God* " Deuteronomy 13.
"The word that came to Jeremiah concerning all the Jews dwelling in Egypt...because of their evil, which they did to provoke Me... *to worship foreign worships, which they did not know of, not them, not you, nor your forefathers* ." Jeremiah 44:1-5.
"...worships they didn't know, *newly invented worships that your forefathers did not fear* ". Anything that is newly invented, what our forefathers didn't experience, worship, know, or fear, is IDOLATRY and against the 1st two commandments where all Jews heard God command that He alone is our God and to not have any other god but Him or to ever leave the path He commanded us in going. *Case closed.*
Maybe you should perform necromancy as your Onkelos or wtv the hell his name is and ask all the Israeli kings since the time of Solomon how the after life has been treating them…..Hypocrite
Rabbi Tovia Singer is holding back to avoid offending Christians who love Israel, Professor is still making the FUNDAMENTAL mistake of looking at the Jewish Bible through the Christian Bible grid.
It's very HARD to leave Christianity even when confronted with the Truth, but in the Messianic age the whole world will have one religion. May it happen quickly in our lives.
I noticed it as well
We do NOT need one religion. Love expands as we seek to embrace each other through our differences. God is one, a union. That does not mean that we need a singular religion.
One religion don't mean Judaism, right now we have mostly Christianity as the main religion, the next to come to power again are the muslim, do you prefer Islam? After all the vast majority of humanity need to be subdued to obey, at one point even Jews had to be forced by the sword to go back to Judaism, by Jews.
@@alejandroflores7592Study the ottoman empire and you will see how the Jews were treated under Muslim rule. Far from being forced by the sword by Islam.
Thank Rabbi for raising the truth at all times
@@07silvali because the teaching of Rabbi make sense to me and never ever before even if I would go to hell but still his teachings strike me to the core l will rejoy
@@chrismassey7563 but I can see that they are still the truth
@@chrismassey7563
AND the WAY, and The LIFE!!
@@jessedylan6162
Re: > AND the WHEY and The LIE!
Chilly Jilly!! I like WHEY!! Whey has mucho gusto protein.
BH!!!!
Excellent video! It's just a shame there are no subtitles in Hebrew
It is explained in Tractate Sanhedrin 56b that all of the Noahide Commandments can be exegetically derived from Genesis 2:16, "And the Lord God commanded the man, saying, ...," which was stated to Adam in the Garden of Eden on the day of his creation. The verse is interpreted homiletically as follows: With regard to the term “and…commanded,” these are the courts of judgment; and so it states in another verse: “For I have known him, to the end that he may command his children and his household after him, that they may keep the way of the Lord, to do righteousness and justice” (Genesis 18:19). With regard to the term “the Lord,” this alludes to blessing the name of God; and so it states in another verse: “And he who blasphemes the name of the Lord…shall be put to death” (Leviticus 24:16). “God,” this alludes to idol worship; and so it states: “You shall have no other gods before Me” (Exodus 20:2). “The man,” this alludes to bloodshed; and so it states: “One who sheds the blood of man, by man his blood shall be shed” (Genesis 9:6). With regard to the term “saying,” this alludes to forbidden sexual relations; and so it states: “Saying, if a man sends his wife, and she goes from him and becomes another man’s…will that land not be greatly polluted? But you have played the harlot with many lovers” (Jeremiah 3:1). “Of every tree of the garden” alludes to the fact that one may partake only of items that are permitted to him, as they belong to him, and he may not partake of stolen items. “You may freely eat” alludes to the fact that one may eat fruit, but not a limb from a living animal.
Jesus is your Lord and Messiah sweetheart. nothing you post is gonna change that.
@@messianicjudaism3420 I'm not your sweetheart and your idol is not the Lord.
@sheraaa If you worship a man, you have bigger problems than dividing a text.
I always learn from you. Thank you.
@@messianicjudaism3420: The "NT" is absolutely NOT scripture that was given to mankind by God and it blasphemously preaches AGAINST what God said to us at Mt. Sinai. NO FURTHER SCRIPTURES were given to mankind after Mt. Sinai. I was an Evangelical Baptist Christian and then a "Messianic" Christian for a total of 40+ YEARS, before I allowed God to open my eyes to His ETERNAL Truth. So there's absolutely NOTHING you can gaslight me with! I KNOW all the dirty tricks these blasphemous, anti-God, anti-Jewish, hate-filled groups use to deceive Jews, ignorant of their own Hebrew scriptures, into converting to their false pagan religion!
PLEASE stop being lazy and self-righteous, and do some HONEST research on this extremely important subject!! You need to buy yourself a Hebrew Bible (says "TANACH" on the cover), so you can see for yourself what God ACTUALLY said to us at Mt. Sinai. The Christian Bible and the Brit HaChadasha are only mistranslated, taken out of context, bastardized VERSIONS of what God ACTUALLY said to us! PLEASE learn from the Rabbis as commanded by God in Deut. 17:8-11. .
"Go away from me you evildoers! And I shall observe the commandments of my God!" Psalm 119.
I am so grateful for this debate, hats off to Professor Solberg for attempting a respectful argument, but I truly believe Tovia won the day as far as the debate goes, based on the idea of best "pure" evidence. Its truly hard to beat "National" revelation, and straight from scripture readings - no scholars need apply - that clearly point out what God says about Himself, that He is One and apart from Him there is NO savior. (Isaiah 43:10-11 paraphrased). As a Southern Baptist raised believer, I am literally on my knees before HaShem seeking the truth, and everywhere I turn, I find myself right back at Isaiah 43. What dear Christian are we to do with that?
@sheraaa daniel saw an angel. It even says malach which means angel.
@sheraaa Sodom was not destroyed for homosexuality, see Ezekiel.
Is your bible a Greek translation ;because, in the Hebrew translation it says angle.
@sheraaa mankind was created in the image of God. In Genesis when God said "let's make man in OUR image" he was talking to the "sons of God" who later came down and mated with women. Looking like a human does not mean that it is a human. It does not mean Jesus. Angels look like men also.
If the difference is not made clear at the time how else would u explain the event.
Here's a crazy idea, what if God isn't a Trinity? What if what we know of Jesus is rather a manifestation? Notice i didn't say mode but manifestation like 1 Timothy 3:16 says? What if when God manifested in flesh submitted himself to our same laws? As creation we call God our Father. As creations we say God is greater. The Trinity doctrine has some major flaws when we consider Isaiah in my opinion. Because God states there are no other Gods besides him. He knows none. I say Isaiah is not trinitarian in teaching but very monotheistic.
I enjoyed this. It just substantiated my love and firm belief in HaShem and being a Noahide!
@sheraaa aren't you special oh holier than thou... that's why I don't want what your selling. Super pious...
Noahides are a creation of Talmud believing Christ rejecting Jews.
There is no such thing as a noahide. Gentiles in Israel were to keep the same laws Israel had to keep.
Exodus 12:49 👉🏻 *ONE LAW* 👈🏻 shall be to him that is homeborn, and unto the stranger that sojourneth among you.
Gentiles were under the same one law as Israel. The law of Moses not Noahide. There is no such thing as Noahide laws.
@@m.cliffordswittsendproduct2380 god bless you, you make great service to the truth and God. Have a nice day.
@@miroslavmatijevic6185 there is no such thing as a noahide. Noah didn't have any different commands than Adam and eve had after the garden. The same 10 commandments they had Noah had.
I commend you Rabi Singer. I grew up in Nashville the "Bible belt". It's a tough gig lots of narrow minded people there. I was a Christian in the Assembly of god and i know how those people can and still are to this day. I discovered the Torah truth and have never looked back to that false religion. Blessings upon you for you are so strong. Baruch Hashem!
I am also a convert to Orthodox Judaism from evangelical Christianity. If you want my reasons, contact me on Facebook.
@@yisraelkillian: I'm SOOO glad to know that there is one more person who has left the false, pagan teachings of Christianity! May Hashem continue to bless you and give you much wisdom and strength on your new journey!! You're not alone - there are hundreds of us here in these comment sections, who have allowed Hashem to open our eyes to His Truth, and we continue to learn from the Rabbis, whether we converted to Orthodox Judaism or became Noahides!!
Baruch Hashem!!
@@anti_missionary_mission: Amein!!
Keith..I too was an A of G..BH ! I got the truth of Torah now..my encouragement to you, stay close to HaShem and learn more Torah/Tanakh ..that is our eternal truth!
my head is shaking and eyes are rolling While hearing Prof. Solbergs intro! Perfect xtian Circular Reasoning!
Lol Mr C !!!! Good morning! Im scrolling down the comments for the 3rd time in the first 8 minutes!! I want to listen but would rather cut to the chase. . . .I don't really have that level of patience ( think 3rd grader who has trouble not chatting and sitting still when bored, but give her something to study, glued to the seat !!! - yep, at 60+ that's still me 😂! )
Just saying hello and thanks for chuckle!
Ok. Seriously going back now. Have a great week. Shalom
You said it..circular
Hi, Wally! I really appreciate your comment. That kind of feedback is helpful to me. I wonder if you might explain where I used circular reasoning in my opening statement? ~Prof. Solberg
@@TheBiblicalRoots Professer Solberg, I think what Wally was getting at is the idea that you need to believe the NT is authentically the word of G-d first before you can assume that the resurrection of Jesus actually happened. I'd like to entertain the possibility that the resurrection actually did happen and that G-d actually did raise Jesus from the dead. Assuming this happened, would you agree with me that it is a possibility that Jesus could have been risen to "eternal abhorrence" as it states in Daniel 12:2?
Daniel 12:2 And many who sleep in the dust of the earth will awaken-these for eternal life, and those for disgrace, for eternal abhorrence.
I know this is the direction you wanted to go with Tovia, so I'm going to entertain the possibility that the resurrection could have happened and let's see where it leads us. Thanks and Shalom!
@@TheBiblicalRoots I actually like you- Prof. Solberg' but by Using the Greek Testament to validate what it says' is in its self circular reasoning! I was a very srtict xtian for over 50yrs. Just as you, Decieved by stories/lies. Using our human phyche/emotions and are spiritual nature given from HaShem, convincing us that what we feel is described in the NT. Even while still in the womb are mothers sang to us' jesus loves me this i know' for the bible tells me so! Rome was the winner, so they set the standard of the new Religion/New.World.Oder. by convincing the masses for nearly 2000yrs by fear of hell and even by pain of death.
The research from Ralph Ellis' =( jesus King of Edessa) holds Waay better and actual Historical facts for a real character ( jesus King of Edessa). than the merely concocted ideas and stories found in the gnostic based NT. The greek testament is a complete contrast to the word of God Tanakh. Sorry i went beyond the scope of the answer you requested. Thanks
"...and I have said: I will not ever
["לעולם" "For all Eternity"]
nullify My covenant with you". Judges 2:1.
Jeremiah 31
31 Behold, the days come, saith the Lord, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah:
32 Not according to the covenant that I made with their fathers in the day that I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt; which my covenant they brake, although I was an husband unto them, saith the Lord:
33 But this shall be the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel; After those days, saith the Lord, I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts; and will be their God, and they shall be my people.
Context The covenant God made with Moses is different than the covenant he made in Jeremiah for Israel.
@@Yes-fe8ni The covenant received when leaving Egypt included the task of "remove the foreskin of your hearts" Deuteronomy 10 verse 16. But in the end of days "new covenant", God will do that Himself, "and YHVH will circumsize the foreskin of your hearts...to keep all the commandments written in this Torah scroll" Deuteronomy 30 verses 1-10. Now after you read Deuteronomy 30, read Ezekiel 11 verses 19&20, Jeremiah 32 verses 37-42, Ezekiel 37 verses 24-28, and also Ezekiel 36 verses 24-28 and compare them to one another and to Deuteronomy 30 and then back to Jeremiah 31... all those verses describe following the laws of the Torah... and read the entire Jeremiah 31, because in the time of the new covenant "no one will need to teach their fellow about God because they will all know Me"...does the whole planet believe your polytheism? Ie: you are totally wrong about the new covenant. Study.
@@Yes-fe8ni The covenant received when leaving Egypt included the task of what's commanded in Deuteronomy 10 verse 16. But in the end of days "new covenant", God will do that Himself, "and YHVH will circumsize the foreskin of your heart...to keep all the commandments written in this Torah scroll" Deuteronomy 30 verses 1-10. Now after you read Deuteronomy 30, see Ezekiel 11 verses 19&20, Jeremiah 32 verses 37-42, Ezekiel 37 verses 24-28, and also Ezekiel 36 verses 24-28 & compare them to one another and then back to Jeremiah 31... all those verses describe following the laws of the Torah... & read the entire Jeremiah 31, bc in the time of the new covenant "no one will need to teach their fellow about God because they will all know Me"...does the whole planet believe your beliefs? Ie: you are mistaken about the new covenant. Study.
@@Yehonatan613 truly astonishing how you persistently want to enslave yourself to the law that you can never reach perfectly.
As a result you then work yourself up to heaven so in a way you earn heaven and God owes you!
The audacity and arrogance is truly amazing to watch!
Rabbi Singer is genius and needs no notes at all. This was a great debate. The professor had to use note constantly. Rabbi Singer nailed it!
Christians often cannot remember the illogical nonsense they are supposed to believe in.
Only one of the debaters also needed water repeatedly. He was sweating bullets.
Of course he did, christianity is a hoax.
Boasting about not using notes is like boasting about not reading the Bible, it's such a silly argument.
@@cabbalaposhala And you need the living water, it will help you a lot if you had the humility of the woman at the well.
"So that you remember and do all of My commandments so that you shall be holy to your God". Numbers 15:40. The commandments were given to sanctify a person, praiseworthy is the person who observes the commandments given to them. The 7 groupings of laws for all non-jews, and the Torah for the descendants of Jacob.
Shalom Rabbi, i love the way you say the prophet name: YeshaYahu❤️
I wonder what God foresaw and meant when this was written: "Realize, I have set before you today: Life and what is [true] good VS Death and what is [true] evil. That which I am commanding you today to love HaShem your God, to walk in His ways, and to observe His commandments, His rules, and His laws, and [through such] you shall live and increase and Hashem your God will bless you...But if your heart shall turn away, and you do not listen, and you stray and worship and serve foreign gods/faiths/religions, I declare to you this day, you shall surely perish...I call heaven and earth to witnesses against you this day: It is Life VS Death that I have put before you, [what is] the Blessing VS [what is] the curse. Choose life, so that you and your offspring will live" Deuteronomy 30 verses 15-20.
Rabbi Singer...Too good you are as usual.. God bless you..Shalom from PNG
I disagree. He is trying to be a different rabbi from the original rabbii in first and early centuries. I mean, it's funny to think one should trust a modern rabbi than way way older especially those of near Jesus' days who have their own interpretations on tanakh and various prophete books. Rabbi Singer basically dismissed every early rabbi's interpretations on tanakh and prophete books that favored views on the Messiah.
One good point that he could not convince any audience is that if he accused Jesus stories written "after the facts" after 40-50 years later, how much the flood story in tanakh is more reliable when it was "rewritten" to mimic the same stories that had existed in other cultures 800 years before.
Although this is called a "debate". I didn't see it that way. I saw a child of Israel 🇮🇱 defending the G-d of Israel 🇮🇱. (Masterfully). Rabbi is a wonderful teacher and a modern Sage. We are lucky to have him in our generation. To the Christian people who watched and in the comments I pray your mind will be opened to the Holy words of Torah & Tanach. שלום עליכם
Michael, I pray same to you 🙏
May our heavenly Father open your eyes to see that you and I who are very dirty in our thoughts and hearts , could never be able to perform one good enaugh deed to make Hod almighty counted to us as righteous act .
A dirty log like me and you need to go through the washer before we can be used to do any cleaning .
The washer is the precious person of Jesus christ my savior
@@nabillayounI've been asking Jesus to come into my heart for 10 years but he hasn't. What am I doing wrong?
dear @@omarbataineh6028 ''For it is by believing in your heart that you are made right with God, and it is by openly declaring your faith that you are saved.''
if you feel as if you still are not made right with God in your heart then you have to pray to Him to give you knowledge on what your doing wrong, maybe its a sin or just your thoughts that keep you away. i struggled a lot with skepticism and it wasnt until i started studying the arguments of 'fine tuning' the arguments of the death and ressurection of Christ that i was finally able to have a firm faith in JESUS. i would also recommend watching the testimony of Nabeel Qureshi (former muslim who unfortunetly passed away in 2017) and read the books of Amir Tsarfati (former Judaist). If you search for Him with all your heart he will step in your life. i pray you find peace
Wow, Rabbi Tovia Singer you are absolutely amazing!!!!! Omg!! You won this debate!!!
How he won? Thats your own opinion.
@@Gats8479 Christianity is idolatry God has no son and there is no verse in the Bible that supports it, it's all your interpretation and adaptation to your faith
@@yair958 you're absolutely wrong we're not Idolatry. Do you accept if I shown you a verse from the bible that Jesus is the Son of God. Let's make deal here before I give at post here let me know.
@@Gats8479 I've already seen your verses, you link them to Jesus without understanding, learn how to interpret them, they don't talk about him at all
@@Gats8479 Every verse you associate with Jesus is talking about something else
Anyone is brave for agreeing to debate Tovia... he knows his stuff, theology AND history (without notes).
For me it really wasn't a debate because the Prof really could not prove his material. Rabbi Singer excelled hands down. I agree 100% with you!
I think Rabbi was invited to debate as he traveled to the professor and not vice versa.
Either way, professor failed to prove anything whereas my belief that Christendom is built on lies, jealousy and thirst for Church control of people is now unshakable. Everything the 7 Noachide Laws tell us not to do, basically. An abomination to the Most High.
I will keep instructions for life from the Creator of the Universe, not some ego driven blood and power hungry cultists who have duped and hurt people for 2000 years. Poor jesus, they really did sacrifice him didn't they ? Using his name to kill so many over absolutely nothing but an invention. So sad. A new day today ! A chance for people to come out of blasphemy and idolatry. Thank you Rabbi Singer.
Notes = Humility
Without notes = Arrogance
@@sauloftarsus3351: Telling yourself that you can 'debate' an extremely learned Rabbi, who has been studying the original, ETERNAL, Hebrew scriptures all the way back to Mt. Sinai, and coming to that 'debate' completely unprepared, by not having a single CLUE what the "Talmud" even is, yet denigrating it, and dismissing its VAST importance = TOTAL ARROGANCE!!
@@falseprophetsthorn8723: You need to lose your self-righteous arrogance, and learn from the Rabbis, as commanded by God in Deut. 17:8-11.
The "NT" is absolutely NOT scripture that was given to mankind by God and it blasphemously preaches AGAINST what God said to us at Mt. Sinai. NO FURTHER SCRIPTURES were given to mankind after Mt. Sinai. I was an Evangelical Baptist Christian and then a "Messianic" Christian for a total of 40+ YEARS, before I allowed God to open my eyes to His ETERNAL Truth. So there's absolutely NOTHING you can gaslight me with! I KNOW all the dirty tricks these blasphemous, anti-God, anti-Jewish, hate-filled groups use to deceive Jews, ignorant of their own Hebrew scriptures, into converting to their false pagan religion!
PLEASE stop being lazy and self-righteous, and do some HONEST research on this extremely important subject!! You need to buy yourself a Hebrew Bible (says "TANACH" on the cover), so you can see for yourself what God ACTUALLY said to us at Mt. Sinai. The Christian Bible is only a mistranslated, taken out of context, bastardized VERSION of what God ACTUALLY said to us! PLEASE learn from the Rabbis as commanded by God. .
"Because for many days will the children of Israel dwell with no king and no official and no sacrafices...and then the children of Israel shall return and seek Hashem their God *[Hashem alone is their God]* and David their King [the Messiah, who is not God], and they will be in Awe of Hashem and of His goodness *that will be at the end of days* " Hoseah 3:4,5.
Who is a God like our God and King. God was the King of Israel who rejected Him and chose to be ruled by a man, a sin. He will return to His proper place as He is in our hearts today.
@@nccognito2324 You people don’t know God swt one bit! Christians took a man as a God! And God is far from all manhood! God swt almighty is far greater and bigger than a man could ever be!
@@Lion_Hamza
*Quran surah Ali Imran verse 45*
*LORD JESUS is Foremost on Earth and in Heaven*
*Quran surah Maryam verse 19*
*LORD JESUS is Holy and Sinless*
*Quran surah An-Nisa verse 158*
*GOD (ALLAH) Raised LORD JESUS back to Heaven*
*LORD JESUS is currently in Heaven*
*Quran surah Maryam verse 33*
*LORD JESUS Rose again from the dead*
*And LORD JESUS is Alive today*
*He Lives Forever*
@@Lion_Hamza
*Quran surah Ali Imran, verse 55*
*Followers of LORD JESUS are Not kafir (infidels)*
*On the contrary, those who do not follow LORD JESUS are infidels ( kafir ).*
*Quran surah Az Zukhruf, verse 61*
*Let's all Mankind Follow LORD JESUS*
*Let's all Mankind Follow LORD JESUS*
*Let all Nations follow LORD JESUS*
*Because He is The Straight Path*
*LORD JESUS is The Straight Path*
*LORD JESUS is the Way and the Truth and the Life*
*LORD JESUS is the Way and the Truth and the Life*
*LORD JESUS Said :*
*"I am the Way and the Truth and the Life"*
*"No one comes to The FATHER, except through Me"*
*( John 14 : 6 )*
@@Lion_Hamza
*Through Mary's womb, JESUS became Man*
*But before there was Mary, JESUS Existed As The Word of GOD*
*JESUS is The Word of GOD*
*JESUS is Not GOD'S creation*
*GOD ( ALLAH ) Never created JESUS.*
*JESUS is The Word of GOD*
*JESUS is GOD'S Word*
*( Quran surah Ali Imran verse 45, and Quran surah An-Nisa verse 171 )*
*GOD created the heaven and the earth through His Word.*
*So Who created the heaven and the earth??*
*Answer :*
*Word of GOD*
*Who is the Word of GOD??*
*Answer :*
*Read Sentence in Line 2 above 👆👆*
I used to be a a Christian. Ill never return to idolatry again!
Get your theology right
@@ej2832it is now!! Good luck
Please explain
I am a Christian that keeps the laws of the Torah just as a Jewish people do and I believe that Jesus / Yeshua is the Messiah
who told you that you needed to leave christianity, just because you no longer believe that Yeshua is God?
Same
These guys were great and even had a sense of humor among their politeness and respect. Good points both side and both honor God!
Rabbi Singer went real easy on him. Solberg's arguments were so silly it didn't take much
God will not go easy on him or you for rejecting your Lord Jesus thats a fact.
@@Yes-fe8ni with lots of love you are incorrect reread the story of Nineveh! The G-D of Israel the people is all so merciful that even G-D even took it easy with pegans. My friend believe in only G-D as Jews do! For non-Jews all you have to follow is the 7 universal laws which some call the noahide laws! Worship NO ONE ELSE!
@sheraaa Rabbi Singer had an easy time & won, just listen to 1:10:20 thru 1:14:10. The OT prophesy was not fulfilled. Jesus rode a donkey so he's the messiah? Give me a break.
@@Yes-fe8ni So, using your ideology as a Christian, that there is a Trinity, and this Trinity consist of The Father, The Son and The Holy Spirit, how is it that you figure that Jews will be punished for worshipping God (Hashem) directly? Why do you Christians believe Jesus has to be the one worshipped? What's the fascination with Jesus? Why can't the Holy Spirit be worshipped, or the Father? If the Trinity consist of three that equates to one, why does it matter which is worshipped? This is problem you Christians can't answer.
However, if in fact Jews are correct, in their belief of Monotheism, it would seem Christians are the ones who will have to answer for their actions. You know, Exdous 20:3, "You shall have no other gods before Me."
It almost seems like the Prof. did ZERO research and was just spewing the lies he was indoctrinated with all his life! He didn't even have a clue what the Talmud is!! .
I was introduced to Rabbi Tovia Singer by many Christians who converted to Judaism.
Bless them i also recommend rabbi skobac michael
Who chose to enter into a pact to enter hell..how sad.
@@quiricomazarin476 Hell? lol
You think any father in this world would punish his kids forever because they didn't listen or do his bidding?
Seems you don't understand God at all or have a connection with him. He would tell you the same.. there is 0 logic or reason in punishing a soul forever. What good will come out of that.
Seems you don't understand love at all or at least it very twisted form.
only christian scholars can twist the things like you do..if you cannot even phantom angels have no free will,therefore there is no rebellion possible.
But anyways, enjoy your life on earth,when you die your soul will return to God anyways.
@@quiricomazarin476 You sound crazy
That's incredible, Pamela, people are finding the truth
For those that are searching for truth, which are those people I have the greatest concern for and have concern for their safe passage. How they learn is of the greatest importance, safe guidance with care for their wellbeing drives me to be inquisitive. My passage was not easy, I see how this causes wars. Lets begin and end discussions as friends not to be caught up in prejudice and hate or fear of each other through reprisals. It's good these both have been able to discuss in peace, not all are able to do so, I thank God for this. I thank you for sharing and add it's helpful when we remind ourselves evidence sharing is not hiding truth or them and us. For those who seek, maybe your place is in discussion and prayer and the reason why you may be here. I pray you find your way in peace. Let's listen to each other with respect.