Thanks for watching our documentary. Tell us what you think in the comments below. If you'd like to watch more episodes from Witness, find them here: ruclips.net/p/PL6698BA1F3CDC7323 More from Witness on: Facebook: facebook.com/AJWitness Twitter: twitter.com/AJWitness Instagram: instagram.com/AJWitness
Very poignant, very sad... however, I could not stop watching. I am so sorry that people's lives and fates are different. How lucky I am. Al-Jazeera always makes excellent heart-felt documentaries that reflects the realities of peoples that would otherwise would not have any representation. AL Jazeera makes their struggles meaningful. Thank you al Jazeera.
Out of many immigrants that made it to Europe, pass through here, if you came through Mali. And I'm one of them, it's not an easy road 🛣️, but God is always merciful to his children, R.I.P to brothers and sisters who passed away. Many won't understand it but it's real. Thanks Al jazzera for this documentary.
Not surprising where Esther ends up - she is eloquent, and has a poetic and beautiful form of French. What a testimony to hope and resilience. Hope to learn from Al Jazeera more about the post-Sahara lives of the young souls that survive this fiery experience.
We need a follow up on Esther. Wow! Esther is such a beautiful girl in and out. I pray she finds all the happiness and fulfillments she truly deserves.
Watching this made me realise that I have completely no right to complain about my life. That sometimes we have to learn to be comfortable with the little that we have regardless of all the challenges we might face in life. Thank you @Aljazera for shinning a light on those lives that people seem to mistake for rejects. This will show the world that everyone has got a home they come from and dream that they are chasing and regardless of the skin or culture or religion or tribe, we all want to find the right place in the world that makes us feel comfortable about ourselves.
Wow, Esther knew what she wanted and she achieved it. She didn't see the obstacles, didn't hear the warnings, didn't think of the possible dangers...she just knew she wanted tk go and she made it. "I learned here that you have to love life and life will love you back "❤. - Esther
she got lucky and is confusing that with being blessed. the mediterranean sea is full of the corpses of people who loved life, but whose boats sank. so are cemetaries around the world. cancer cells don't care if you love life either.
No one leaves home, unless home is the mouth of a shark. Be inspired by the tales of this souls to find and give gratitude as you look for more. Thankyou Aljazeera for this piece.
Thank you Al Jazeera for producing this sad yet beautiful documentary. I pray for Esther and all of the beautiful souls who keep searching for a better way of life.
Although we are light years apart in terms of opportunities, I see in them the same goals and desires. What a harsh reality, what a contrast to my life. Inspiring and heartbreaking at the same time.
It's so sad really watching people as young as this taking dangerous risks that they don't really know the outcome. No one should judge them for doing this. Relevant agencies and international organizations should work with governments to find a lasting solution to these kinds of things happening. It really is disheartening, sad and painful seeing what people are passing through and the circumstances surrounding their decision made. I really don't know what it means to have a roof over my head and to be around at least one person who cares. Thank you Al Jazeera for this documentary. It really is impactful
Thank you @Aljazera for shinning a light on those lives that people seem to mistake for rejects, This really touch my heart and I wish all those who risk their life to find themselves good luck and may God protect them
This docu opened my eyes. Ive never looked at migration through Esther's eyes; family rejection and a hopeless societal emotional support system. I've always assumed it was mostly for economic purposes and lack of appreciation for the little that one has. I feel so ashamed of my presumptions 😢 I really wish her well, God's blessings and hopes she realizes she can write her own story and doesn't have to let others define her. Hope she always meets kindhearted people that will protect and guide her. Kudos to the Centre for their care, counselling and offers of alternatives. Taking a moment for a personal, but realistic, one on one talk means alot when a person is observed to be making a life changing decision in this harsh world.
Great Documentary by Al Jazeera Teams highlight the Human side and sufferings of the Refuges dispalced by wars and Famine Its Tragic that some country and people has so much wealth and some country spend so much in defence that Refuges crisis and sufferings can end...if the Intention of people and country or grooing of counties wants to Great work by the Team to bring this Documentary
BRILLIANT DOCUMENTARY ,THE BEST I HAVE SEEN RECENTLY.THE HOPE OF THE FUTURE IS THEY RE PERSISTENCE IN TRYING TO HELP AND PROMOTE EACH OTHERS WORTH.THERE ARE ONLY THE HUMANS AND THE TERRIBLE PRIVATION OF THE DESERT......THE HUMANS KNOW THAT THEY MUST PREVAIL THEY ARE THE LADT 300 000 000 YRS INCARNATE....THAT SORT OF LOGIC I CAN RESECT AND ADMIRE!
They see them living in pleasure but they don’t know how the westerners totally abused blk in the tabacco clothing and sugar industry which made them very wealthy
No problems for this 79 years old, who moved to Querétaro, Mexico Do not forget to have cash when ATM runs out of money,and stores will only accept cash. Besides your preps. Thank you. Please do not get in a hot truck 🚛🚛🚛 to come to the USA. USA is deadly and expensive. Stay home and live, or R.I.P. Take individual photos of deceased and cremate.Truth thank you. Have cash when banks close
Africa population 1990 = 816 million, 2016 = 1,200 million, and by 2050 will be 2,500 million.. why do these documentary channels refuse to address the real issue ?
The problem isn't population , idiot .India has 1.3 Billion people with smaller land mass and resources and has the huge portion of its population sunk into extreme poverty too what makes the difference is poor Governance in African states , also adding to that things like corruption , embezzlement , despotism , abuse of human rights by these brutal regimes ,climatic changes specifically prolonged drought , political instabilities and civil wars have ruined lives of many people within these countries to an extent of making civilians so desperate and thus running away like vagabonds . Poor governance in African states is a longstanding ( chronic ) issue and it is the root cause of many problems that faces the continent in general .
Africa has enough space for its population. Why don’t you address the exploitation of African countries by the west and their poppet leaders they impose on africans. Africa is not poor.
@@TheYayefatou what a typical dumb stupid ignorant statement from another African who just wants a free meal ticket.. google.. african demographics .. then images and see if you have the brains to see what the problem is and if you can who do you want to blame for this .. its a matter of jobs you idiot .. and what jobs might they be. I would say get an education but in your case I can see that is not possible .. are you some child still at school ???
@@TheYayefatou have you worked out what demographics means yet ? go back to mud huts and herding cattle, make you own industrial revolution.. should only take you 200 years.... if you want to see what is wrong with Africa, take a good long look in the mirror.... Africans, always looking for a free meal ticket ... correct ?
@Charnelle Roberts I do speak to a lot of young people in Africa and yes, they are in a terrible situation with no hope. A life with no hope is hardly a life at all. The problem is very simple.. it is spelled "demographics".. this trumps anything and there is no way out. Google "Africa demographics" images, then you will see the problem. Add 5 or 10 years and you can see the disaster unfolding. There are a few more successful African countries but there is no free movement of Africans within Africa. Even South Africa has been protesting other African brothers in their country and they want no more. Nigeria seems to be one of the worst places and I think will descent into a civil war. But it is the numbers of young people and the wave of young people who are growing up now. I can see NO solution. I am currently in NZ and get people from Africa contacting me asking how they can get here. Then I point out that the population of just Nigeria goes up more in one year than the total population of NZ - so how can this ever work. But because a lot of the population increase is religiously driven, then no one will touch it as a topic, no politician will raise the issue - I cannot think of a worse situation to ensure absolute disaster... so my original question was tong in cheek to try and get people to think....
@Charnelle Roberts The biggest problem is many have a big family to support. And the monthly salary from any african country isn’t enough. Salary in EU is at least 1200€ and 200€ can feed the whole family in africa. While a monthly salary in africa won’t be enough to sustain yourself + big family (grandparents, parents, wife, busband, childrens, brothers, sisters, nieces, nephews, aunts, uncle.....) If africans start to reduce their birthrate, the need of higher salary outside africa won’t be necessary.
Breaking : Israel joined western countries yesterday in joining a coordinated statement condemning China's human rights record in the province of Xinjiang.
Documentary..,..., But what's your point ? it wasn't specific enough in your title. What are you trying to relay to the public that this is the way they live in the Sahara.......so what......... it's not a crime. The only reason you made this video about my people in the motherland to get views and likes THAT IT ..... you didn't show nothing about you contributing to the community to make their life a little bit more comfortable did you ? You keep making videos like this just to exploit my people.... the Gods of our ancestors will rain destruction on your life and your future generations. They will not show favor on you....I'm just saying.....ok!
This really touch my heart and I wish all those who risk their life to find themselves good luck and may God protect them give them what they wish for safety, I know they are so much amazing stories out there like this it needs to be hear ❤️🫶🙏
Thanks for watching our documentary. Tell us what you think in the comments below.
If you'd like to watch more episodes from Witness, find them here: ruclips.net/p/PL6698BA1F3CDC7323
More from Witness on:
Facebook: facebook.com/AJWitness
Twitter: twitter.com/AJWitness
Instagram: instagram.com/AJWitness
Very poignant, very sad... however, I could not stop watching. I am so sorry that people's lives and fates are different. How lucky I am. Al-Jazeera always makes excellent heart-felt documentaries that reflects the realities of peoples that would otherwise would not have any representation. AL Jazeera makes their struggles meaningful. Thank you al Jazeera.
If you can, please conduct a follow up interview on them, especially Esther.
Out of many immigrants that made it to Europe, pass through here, if you came through Mali. And I'm one of them, it's not an easy road 🛣️, but God is always merciful to his children, R.I.P to brothers and sisters who passed away. Many won't understand it but it's real. Thanks Al jazzera for this documentary.
Not surprising where Esther ends up - she is eloquent, and has a poetic and beautiful form of French. What a testimony to hope and resilience. Hope to learn from Al Jazeera more about the post-Sahara lives of the young souls that survive this fiery experience.
We need a follow up on Esther. Wow! Esther is such a beautiful girl in and out. I pray she finds all the happiness and fulfillments she truly deserves.
Watching this made me realise that I have completely no right to complain about my life. That sometimes we have to learn to be comfortable with the little that we have regardless of all the challenges we might face in life. Thank you @Aljazera for shinning a light on those lives that people seem to mistake for rejects. This will show the world that everyone has got a home they come from and dream that they are chasing and regardless of the skin or culture or religion or tribe, we all want to find the right place in the world that makes us feel comfortable about ourselves.
Many thanks, dear Mbuusi.
I think challenges per person are different. It's just the way you look at it.
Wow, Esther knew what she wanted and she achieved it. She didn't see the obstacles, didn't hear the warnings, didn't think of the possible dangers...she just knew she wanted tk go and she made it.
"I learned here that you have to love life and life will love you back "❤. - Esther
she got lucky and is confusing that with being blessed. the mediterranean sea is full of the corpses of people who loved life, but whose boats sank. so are cemetaries around the world. cancer cells don't care if you love life either.
That small girl spoke heavy words.
No one leaves home, unless home is the mouth of a shark.
Be inspired by the tales of this souls to find and give gratitude as you look for more.
Thankyou Aljazeera for this piece.
great quote by Warsan Shire " no one leaves hoe, unless home is the mouth of a shark".
@@deega1234 yes. The somali poet. It's just a reflection of how our lives are connected in different spectrums.
Wonderful job on this documentary! Sadly this story is going to repeat at an ever increasing frequency.
Thank you Al Jazeera for producing this sad yet beautiful documentary. I pray for Esther and all of the beautiful souls who keep searching for a better way of life.
Although we are light years apart in terms of opportunities, I see in them the same goals and desires. What a harsh reality, what a contrast to my life. Inspiring and heartbreaking at the same time.
Really profound and wonderful -and best of all is Esther's happy ending.
It's so sad really watching people as young as this taking dangerous risks that they don't really know the outcome. No one should judge them for doing this. Relevant agencies and international organizations should work with governments to find a lasting solution to these kinds of things happening. It really is disheartening, sad and painful seeing what people are passing through and the circumstances surrounding their decision made.
I really don't know what it means to have a roof over my head and to be around at least one person who cares. Thank you Al Jazeera for this documentary. It really is impactful
I love it . Keep up the good work
A very insightful look into the journeys and fears of the young trying to find a better life.
Thank you @Aljazera for shinning a light on those lives that people seem to mistake for rejects, This really touch my heart and I wish all those who risk their life to find themselves good luck and may God protect them
I need a part 2 that focuses on Natacha.
This docu opened my eyes.
Ive never looked at migration through Esther's eyes; family rejection and a hopeless societal emotional support system. I've always assumed it was mostly for economic purposes and lack of appreciation for the little that one has. I feel so ashamed of my presumptions 😢
I really wish her well, God's blessings and hopes she realizes she can write her own story and doesn't have to let others define her. Hope she always meets kindhearted people that will protect and guide her.
Kudos to the Centre for their care, counselling and offers of alternatives. Taking a moment for a personal, but realistic, one on one talk means alot when a person is observed to be making a life changing decision in this harsh world.
People shouldn't plan to migrate to another countries, they should face the problems with courage and patience in thier own country.
Yes it’s easy to advise that if you are not the one living that life…🤷♀️
I was amazed that even in a village as remote as this they have cellphones and services.
Great Documentary by Al Jazeera Teams highlight the Human side and sufferings of the Refuges dispalced by wars and Famine
Its Tragic that some country and people has so much wealth and some country spend so much in defence that Refuges crisis and sufferings can end...if the Intention of people and country or grooing of counties wants to
Great work by the Team to bring this Documentary
Many thanks for your comment, dear Jawed.
BRILLIANT DOCUMENTARY ,THE BEST I HAVE SEEN RECENTLY.THE HOPE OF THE FUTURE IS THEY RE PERSISTENCE IN TRYING TO HELP AND PROMOTE EACH OTHERS WORTH.THERE ARE ONLY THE HUMANS AND THE TERRIBLE PRIVATION OF THE DESERT......THE HUMANS KNOW THAT THEY MUST PREVAIL THEY ARE THE LADT 300 000 000 YRS INCARNATE....THAT SORT OF LOGIC I CAN RESECT AND ADMIRE!
Many thanks for your comment, glad you enjoyed it.
Esther was really determined to make it to Algeria. The other had a lot of doubts. Belief is important. Believe in yourself.
Lets stop glorifying europe and embrace growth in africa..Honestly you can see the disappointment in those mens eyes..its such a sad documentary
Most depressing thing I've ever seen.
I JUST WANT TO JUMP THROUGH THE MONITOR, GIVE HER A BIG HUG THEN BRING HER HERE TO LIVE WITH ME!!
I wonder why Kady returned home🤔 For me, it seems like an update is needed for the update that was provided.
Conviction and belief is a powerful thing or drug!!!
Why is it that people around the world are dying to go to the west?
Commercial opportunities, Joseph.
They see them living in pleasure but they don’t know how the westerners totally abused blk in the tabacco clothing and sugar industry which made them very wealthy
It's a pipe dream, we have them in the west to.🤔
Because capitalism doesn't working.
$€£
How can I help?
Contact aljezeera
No problems for this 79 years old, who moved to Querétaro, Mexico Do not forget to have cash when ATM runs out of money,and stores will only accept cash. Besides your preps.
Thank you. Please do not get in a hot truck 🚛🚛🚛 to come to the USA. USA is deadly and expensive. Stay home and live, or R.I.P. Take individual photos of deceased and cremate.Truth thank you.
Have cash when banks close
Africa population 1990 = 816 million, 2016 = 1,200 million, and by 2050 will be 2,500 million.. why do these documentary channels refuse to address the real issue ?
The problem isn't population , idiot .India has 1.3 Billion people with smaller land mass and resources and has the huge portion of its population sunk into extreme poverty too what makes the difference is poor Governance in African states , also adding to that things like corruption , embezzlement , despotism , abuse of human rights by these brutal regimes ,climatic changes specifically prolonged drought , political instabilities and civil wars have ruined lives of many people within these countries to an extent of making civilians so desperate and thus running away like vagabonds .
Poor governance in African states is a longstanding ( chronic ) issue and it is the root cause of many problems that faces the continent in general .
Miles dugmore: you wanting to see the depopulation of Africa shows how evil and wicked you are coloniser
Africa has enough space for its population. Why don’t you address the exploitation of African countries by the west and their poppet leaders they impose on africans. Africa is not poor.
@@TheYayefatou what a typical dumb stupid ignorant statement from another African who just wants a free meal ticket.. google.. african demographics .. then images and see if you have the brains to see what the problem is and if you can who do you want to blame for this .. its a matter of jobs you idiot .. and what jobs might they be. I would say get an education but in your case I can see that is not possible .. are you some child still at school ???
@@TheYayefatou have you worked out what demographics means yet ? go back to mud huts and herding cattle, make you own industrial revolution.. should only take you 200 years.... if you want to see what is wrong with Africa, take a good long look in the mirror.... Africans, always looking for a free meal ticket ... correct ?
Why go to Europe, why not get on a bus and go to a successful African country, there are more than 50 to chose from ????
@Charnelle Roberts I do speak to a lot of young people in Africa and yes, they are in a terrible situation with no hope. A life with no hope is hardly a life at all. The problem is very simple.. it is spelled "demographics".. this trumps anything and there is no way out. Google "Africa demographics" images, then you will see the problem. Add 5 or 10 years and you can see the disaster unfolding. There are a few more successful African countries but there is no free movement of Africans within Africa. Even South Africa has been protesting other African brothers in their country and they want no more. Nigeria seems to be one of the worst places and I think will descent into a civil war. But it is the numbers of young people and the wave of young people who are growing up now. I can see NO solution. I am currently in NZ and get people from Africa contacting me asking how they can get here. Then I point out that the population of just Nigeria goes up more in one year than the total population of NZ - so how can this ever work. But because a lot of the population increase is religiously driven, then no one will touch it as a topic, no politician will raise the issue - I cannot think of a worse situation to ensure absolute disaster... so my original question was tong in cheek to try and get people to think....
@Charnelle Roberts The biggest problem is many have a big family to support. And the monthly salary from any african country isn’t enough.
Salary in EU is at least 1200€ and 200€ can feed the whole family in africa. While a monthly salary in africa won’t be enough to sustain yourself + big family (grandparents, parents, wife, busband, childrens, brothers, sisters, nieces, nephews, aunts, uncle.....)
If africans start to reduce their birthrate, the need of higher salary outside africa won’t be necessary.
No ..they must stay in their countries and fight for the better
I wonder
@@milesinnz Africa's youth full population is a ticking time bomb, what should be a great asset Is laid to waste.
Breaking : Israel joined western countries yesterday in joining a coordinated statement condemning China's human rights record in the province of Xinjiang.
#hypocrism
It was funnier the first time I saw your bot post this.
没太阳能工程师，没医生，没建筑师，啥也不会，咋过好生活呢？
.
Documentary..,..., But what's your point ? it wasn't specific enough in your title. What are you trying to relay to the public that this is the way they live in the Sahara.......so what......... it's not a crime. The only reason you made this video about my people in the motherland to get views and likes THAT IT ..... you didn't show nothing about you contributing to the community to make their life a little bit more comfortable did you ? You keep making videos like this just to exploit my people.... the Gods of our ancestors will rain destruction on your life and your future generations. They will not show favor on you....I'm just saying.....ok!
This really touch my heart and I wish all those who risk their life to find themselves good luck and may God protect them give them what they wish for safety, I know they are so much amazing stories out there like this it needs to be hear ❤️🫶🙏
Many thanks for your comment, dear Ousman!