@@RaptorT1V imo it lacks the power (horowitz is very good at it). Just listen to the climax on both videos. There is a clear difference in the dynamics and tempo.
@@RaptorT1V Could not agree more with Duen. Both this and Horowitz's version really highlight the emotion of the piece. They almost emulate the feeling of one losing its sanity. Whereas Rosseau's version - although respectable performance - lacks that energy and emotion.
@@cubepiano4630 definitely not for me, Horowitz isn't enough intense. Sultanov has just so much rage, despair, passion and fire! Also that middle section is very delicate, pratically elegant. That's why I love sultanov so much, and also the voicing!
@@pattexx I would like to thank you very much for introducing me to this Genius, the Greatest Pianist of the last 60 years. Thank you very much! I've watched dozens of videos of his performance and I'm not going to stop! :)
As a person who learnt this piece, I really appreciate the fact that brought out the middle section (0:52-0:54 is one example) where alot of people (including me) forgets about the complexcity of the Scriabin etudes and how much emotions are packed into every note, Bravo.
@@derekpintozzi2498 what a stupid question, no offent. I mean, we can see he’s as good as rousseau when it comes to technique, so it’s about interpretation. If I play a piece i’ve mastered, it’s exactly what I want from it, like it can’t get any better because it’s the way i like it and i want to play it, same by traum i guess.
@@derekpintozzi2498 oh i see, and yes, he played technically harder pieces than rousseau. Rousseau plays perfect, nearly robotic and traum interpreters more, so you can’t really compare them but like i said, traum played technically more difficult pieces.
This. This actually made me feel something. I’ve heard this piece before, but could never feel what Scriabin was trying to describe. The way you play, though, brought it all out, I can feel every note inside my heart. This is beautiful.
Благодарю за возможность просмотра этого контента! Прекрасное исполнение шедевра мировой Музыки!! Очень мужественно и харизматично!! Исполнитель выразил своё отношение и понимание характера и смыслов, заложенных в этой , любимой многими, Мухыки!!
This is so Powerfull!! Like my favorite interpretation from Horowitz! This etude inspires me so much to study more and get good enough to play and compose like this! Hope someday i can watch you live!
If you are a pianist of top calibre, I think you can fully perfect a piece of this difficulty in two weeks. Not that I am; I've been on this piece for two months and counting :'-)
I guess the reason is that the channel is established for only five months. Most for who want to do this kind of performance must have learned a lot of pieces. Maybe he is just playing the pieces that ha has already learned for a long time.
Oh my goodness!!! This piece destroyed my soul when I attempted to play it, and showed me I am but a mere mortal. Scriabin is a BEAST and this man playing it is the man. Its like dude was like, "you know what's fun? Polyrythmns. Let's just make a song of that." Been playing for a very long time and still struggle with polys. Any tips you've found that are effective??? Thank you!!
Wow really good performance, much better than Rousseau's version and at 0:36-0:40 that buildup and then the sudden soft moments is so beautiful. You played it like Horowitz himself!
Btw, I’m pretty sure the section with the counter melody starting at 0:52 is done with the middle pedal. So imagine him shuffling both of his feet while playing while playing the actual music.
Honestly I'd right now, i'd like to hear an interpretation of this piece played at Rousseau's tempo and Traum's dynamics. Great preformance btw! i love this piece. Edit: nevermind what i just said. Traum's interpretation transcends what i thought was possible with this piece
I started practicing this piece last Feb-Mar 2020... Now, I'm still practicing it... LOL! I need to play the part starting at 1:45 over and over again just to perfect it... This is amazing and you have a very balanced finger... I'm only an amateur piano player (never taught by any professionals) and my weakest finger is my left ring finger. I was thinking of injecting steroids on my left ring finger just to induce muscle formation fast... HAHA!!! Kidding aside, amazing piano playing!
Thanks Dominique. Scriabin Etude is not an easy piece, especially for the amateur pianist. but I believe that it is good practice for you. Don't give up!!👍
You did a great job, your performance was very similar to how Horowitz played this piece, all he did different was highlight the bass notes more and just of course the supreme Horowitz dynamic control
Ich muss sagen, du bist ein besserer Pianist als Rousseau, nachdem ich mir alles was du aufgemommen hast angehört hast. Du spielst die gleichen Sachen auch besser als Rousseau, wie zum Beispiel diese Skrjabin Etüde. Du bist phänomenal. Liebe Grüsse, ein Hobby Pianist.
Vielen Dank Milo. Meine musikalische Ausbildung basiert auf Deutschland. Ich habe so viel schöne Erinnerung in Deutschland. Willkommen in meinem Kanal!!
Phenomenal performance 👏👏👏👏👏 Although i do think you could have listened to the 32nd note rests a bit more (at the ends of the phrases, for instance at the end of the second, fourth and sixth bars with the climbing sixteenth note octaves)
Your interpretation is one of the best. Congrats! May I ask a question: In bar 4 beat 1 and bar 5 beat 1 in the left hand, do you recommend to play the base tone together with right hand cord or do you recommend the upper note together with right hand cord ? Although I realised that in bar 2/beat 1 (l.h.) you are playing an octave d# and in bar 3/beat one you play octave f#. Is this intentionally ? In my sheet music they are both d#/f# ?
Much better than Rosseau's version. Do like the sudden soft moments before building up.
It is my honor! Thanks itz itzaKi.
Yes definitely. The rousseau version lacks intensity imo
Please, explain, why Rousseau's version is worse?
btw, I very like Traum's version
@@RaptorT1V imo it lacks the power (horowitz is very good at it). Just listen to the climax on both videos. There is a clear difference in the dynamics and tempo.
@@RaptorT1V Could not agree more with Duen. Both this and Horowitz's version really highlight the emotion of the piece. They almost emulate the feeling of one losing its sanity. Whereas Rosseau's version - although respectable performance - lacks that energy and emotion.
Beautiful voicing at 0:52! I don't think I've ever heard that in this piece before.
Listen to Sultanov performance. You will hear one of the bets performance ever, if not the best, with a voicing extremely original on that part!
@@SeigneurReefShark I don’t get why everybody is so in love with that recording, Horowitz’s far surpasses it in my opinion 🤷🏾♂️
@@cubepiano4630 definitely not for me, Horowitz isn't enough intense. Sultanov has just so much rage, despair, passion and fire! Also that middle section is very delicate, pratically elegant. That's why I love sultanov so much, and also the voicing!
@@cubepiano4630 just compare both recordings with the recording by Scriabin himself
@@alanleoneldavid1787 imo Scriabin plays it quite crappily. And it’s not 100% fact that it is him.
0:51-0:54
1:02-1:03
Ah, these two notes
Maybe you already know it but listen to the version of Sultanov !
@@pattexx I would like to thank you very much for introducing me to this Genius, the Greatest Pianist of the last 60 years. Thank you very much! I've watched dozens of videos of his performance and I'm not going to stop! :)
there are three notes, not two, a new story begins with the third
First heard in Sandro Russo’s version, i m going check Sultanov’s one
i felt it when i heard those two accented notes.
As a person who learnt this piece, I really appreciate the fact that brought out the middle section (0:52-0:54 is one example) where alot of people (including me) forgets about the complexcity of the Scriabin etudes and how much emotions are packed into every note, Bravo.
Very mezzo soprano coded, I love it.
Incredible!!!
Traum music's version is the best.
Thank you so much!!
This is so much better than Rousseau’s version. Thank you for this
My great pleasure!
@@TraumPiano you agree that it is better than roussues right?
@@derekpintozzi2498 what a stupid question, no offent. I mean, we can see he’s as good as rousseau when it comes to technique, so it’s about interpretation. If I play a piece i’ve mastered, it’s exactly what I want from it, like it can’t get any better because it’s the way i like it and i want to play it, same by traum i guess.
@@philippeuler6937 I was asking to see if he sees himself better than roussue
@@derekpintozzi2498 oh i see, and yes, he played technically harder pieces than rousseau. Rousseau plays perfect, nearly robotic and traum interpreters more, so you can’t really compare them but like i said, traum played technically more difficult pieces.
BEUTIFUL I ABSOLUTELY ADORE THIS PIECE THIS CHANNEL IS AWESOME GOD BLESS
🙏🙏
This is such a cool and interesting piece! It brings lots of cool imagery to my mind and your interpretation is amazing!
This. This actually made me feel something. I’ve heard this piece before, but could never feel what Scriabin was trying to describe. The way you play, though, brought it all out, I can feel every note inside my heart. This is beautiful.
Rousseau: I fear no man, but that thing (Traum)...it scares me
What do you think traum is?
Traum is a man
He fears traum
lmao this guys is no near rousseau's level tho
@@mathieutdf5446 exactly he’s so far beyond
My favorite Scriabin Etude. Love the voicing you added!
Благодарю за возможность просмотра этого контента! Прекрасное исполнение шедевра мировой Музыки!! Очень мужественно и харизматично!! Исполнитель выразил своё отношение и понимание характера и смыслов, заложенных в этой , любимой многими, Мухыки!!
the greatest video on youtube
Love the extra notes at 1:53, idk if it was intentional but that dissonance adds to the thunderous feeling of the last note, it's awesome.
This is so Powerfull!! Like my favorite interpretation from Horowitz! This etude inspires me so much to study more and get good enough to play and compose like this! Hope someday i can watch you live!
Amazing stuff I love this etude. Scriabin's music is so bizarre and unorthodox its beautiful, I love it. Could you possibly do op 42 no 5?
I love this interpretation! It has so much direction, contrast, color, and emotion.
incredible performance. one of my favorites.
Incredible performance. It's breathtaking how effortless you make it look like even though the peace is so insanely difficult. I admire you!
PERFECT!!!!
Wow awesome!! So glad I came across your channel😀 You’re really brilliant 👏👏
How big is your repertoire??? Or how fast do you learn pieces like these? Feels like you uploaded 40 pieces in 2 months
If you are a pianist of top calibre, I think you can fully perfect a piece of this difficulty in two weeks. Not that I am; I've been on this piece for two months and counting :'-)
@@carlosortegahigueruelo5900 i think rosseau has stuff going on, i think family wise
@@carlosortegahigueruelo5900 i dont know if i can agree, those played by one of the members is just excellent
@@carlosortegahigueruelo5900 hola
I guess the reason is that the channel is established for only five months. Most for who want to do this kind of performance must have learned a lot of pieces. Maybe he is just playing the pieces that ha has already learned for a long time.
I have finished Scriabin etude in C sharp minor and now I want to play this.
Very good 👌👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This is the best version it makes me so emotional😭❤️
Nice performance! Scriabin is such an interesting composer, often skipped in the piano repertoire.
Epic!
Things to Do
RIght. pretty interesting composer. mysterious and genius!
+Things to do, did he wrote any easy piano pieces?
@@krzysztofq7420 Yes, I believe he wrote some Preludes and some easier Etudes
Things to Do
2:12 like oh yeah finally its done :) bwt good interpretacion
Good interpretation too! lol
One of the best interpretations here
Has to be one of my favourite pieces to listen to
wow amazing attention to detail brining out all the different voices.
Next ballade n.1 Chopin or Liszt trascendental etude 6
Hi again Leonardo! I will play both in the near future definitely!!
He already played ballade no.1
@@nathane7914 this was 2 months ago
No play #5 feux follets
cool
came here again after listening to more renditions of this masterpiece, your delicate touch gives me life
Oh my goodness!!! This piece destroyed my soul when I attempted to play it, and showed me I am but a mere mortal. Scriabin is a BEAST and this man playing it is the man.
Its like dude was like, "you know what's fun? Polyrythmns. Let's just make a song of that."
Been playing for a very long time and still struggle with polys. Any tips you've found that are effective??? Thank you!!
You're a freaking beast
So good:)
Thanks!
Congrats on 40K I am so happy to be your 1000th subscriber!
this etude in D♯ is just amazing
메이저 국제 콩쿨 우승하신분이 아닐까요 스크리아빈 연주 정말 정말 대단하고 훌륭합니다 아무리 생각해도 잘 알려지신 분이라 익명으로 남고싶어서 이 채널 운영하시는거 같아요
하하하... 과찬이십니다 ;)
Visuals: Rousseau
Performance: Traum
Amazing.
Wow really good performance, much better than Rousseau's version and at 0:36-0:40 that buildup and then the sudden soft moments is so beautiful. You played it like Horowitz himself!
Superb rendition
Wow! Such an amazing piece! Great playing!
The monster, Traum
처절하게 아름답다 🥹🥺
Incredible!!
Btw, I’m pretty sure the section with the counter melody starting at 0:52 is done with the middle pedal. So imagine him shuffling both of his feet while playing while playing the actual music.
Q maravilha!!! Lindíssimo!!! Q artista!!! Q interpretação!!! Parabéns 👏👏👏👏👏👏
This is more powerful than SPQ at Rousseau's channel. Love it
Love the intensity!
Wow, what a great performance!
Love the colours!!
A fiery interpretation! Love it!
Одно из лучших исполнений!
Love the left hand chromaticism at 1:48❤
Juste incredible😀
Oui oui beautiful
Honestly I'd right now, i'd like to hear an interpretation of this piece played at Rousseau's tempo and Traum's dynamics. Great preformance btw! i love this piece. Edit: nevermind what i just said. Traum's interpretation transcends what i thought was possible with this piece
Did you hear Scriabin's own performance of this masterpiece of his?
Your a virtuoso pianist😉 go 10k !!!😊
Красивый глубокий этюд.
You should put more of your pieces on spotify!
traum you are a fucking boss man.
I started practicing this piece last Feb-Mar 2020... Now, I'm still practicing it... LOL! I need to play the part starting at 1:45 over and over again just to perfect it... This is amazing and you have a very balanced finger... I'm only an amateur piano player (never taught by any professionals) and my weakest finger is my left ring finger. I was thinking of injecting steroids on my left ring finger just to induce muscle formation fast... HAHA!!! Kidding aside, amazing piano playing!
Thanks Dominique. Scriabin Etude is not an easy piece, especially for the amateur pianist. but I believe that it is good practice for you. Don't give up!!👍
0:39 that control🫡
Like this version！！
I like this interpretation, well done Traum. Still, i miss the bass banging like in Horowitz's version. It adds some deepness in the interpretation.
You did a great job, your performance was very similar to how Horowitz played this piece, all he did different was highlight the bass notes more and just of course the supreme Horowitz dynamic control
Ich muss sagen, du bist ein besserer Pianist als Rousseau, nachdem ich mir alles was du aufgemommen hast angehört hast. Du spielst die gleichen Sachen auch besser als Rousseau, wie zum Beispiel diese Skrjabin Etüde. Du bist phänomenal. Liebe Grüsse, ein Hobby Pianist.
Vielen Dank Milo. Meine musikalische Ausbildung basiert auf Deutschland. Ich habe so viel schöne Erinnerung in Deutschland. Willkommen in meinem Kanal!!
Could you publish this on spotify? I think it deserves to be there
Phenomenal performance 👏👏👏👏👏
Although i do think you could have listened to the 32nd note rests a bit more (at the ends of the phrases, for instance at the end of the second, fourth and sixth bars with the climbing sixteenth note octaves)
Please play an alternative version of this etude. I will be very grateful to you
42-5 도 기대되네요~~!!
Lindo. Música das esferas.
Faster but more emotional than Rousseau's powerful but at the same time more apleasing great preformance
... Das ist.... Ich hab keine Worte dafür....
Danke dir!
Scriaban etudes, not too common but still really interesting
Much better than Rousseau's version (but I didn't mean he's bad) I love how he interpret this piece, this is what should it sounds like
This reminds me so much of Rachmaninoffs etude op 39 No 5
idk if im asking for too much, but can you do scriabin sonata no. 4 / 2nd mov./ in the future?
Your interpretation is one of the best. Congrats! May I ask a question: In bar 4 beat 1 and bar 5 beat 1 in the left hand, do you recommend to play the base tone together with right hand cord or do you recommend the upper note together with right hand cord ? Although I realised that in bar 2/beat 1 (l.h.) you are playing an octave d# and in bar 3/beat one you play octave f#. Is this intentionally ? In my sheet music they are both d#/f# ?
To me this sounds all over the place.
You play so brilliant. What kind of piano are you using?
How do you do that with your left hand. Rachmaninoff Paganini variations 17 & 18?
scriabin etude op.42 no.5도 시간될때 해주셨음 좋겠어요
분명 나는 저것을 치느라 애 먹었는데 너무 쉽게 치시네요
Wow, since I know you, I like you more tha Rousseau.
How often do you learn new pieces?
Could you play Op. 42 no. 5?
is he Vladimir Horowitz?
BROOO what is his piano??? it's soo good please someone tell me !
Noice
Which piano do you use?
Yamaha C6 and P515
@@TraumPiano do you record on a acoustic piano? 🤔
@@EduardoRamirez-wx6ng Yes I do. but not in this channel.
@@TraumPiano Do you have another channel?
Some Scriabin finally, how about some Feinberg...3rd piano sonata is a good workout.
Dear Traum Piano, what Email can I write you to? I make a documentary about Scriabin, will appreciate your reply!
r/scriabinworship
NOT HUMAN!! WHAT IS THE NAME OF THE PIANIST PERFORMING THIS ABSOLUTELY NOT HUMAN!!!!
Look up any video of scriabin sonata 5 and see what you think of that
The answer is in his newest upload
1:22
브라보
All I see is floating hands
It sounds so easy to play.... Until trying to play it by myself... I can't pass the second bar. *&#&$*@
A