Magic the Gathering Mystery Box Found at Thrift Store

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
  • I found another AMAZING mystery box of cards at a local thrift store. This time it is Magic the Gathering cards. Hundreds of cards from Revised up to current day. Check out what I found... spoiler... there's a BIG hit in here !!
    How to follow me:
    eBay Store: www.ebay.com/s...
    Mailing info: Mike W. / PO Box 7077 / Chandler, AZ 85246
    e-Mail: mikescards@cox.net Instagram: thatresellerguy
    That Reseller Guy: / thatresellerguy
    That Card Guy: / thatcardguy
    KK and Her Dad Open Stuff: / kkherdadopenstuff
    #MTG
    #MagictheGathering
    #MysteryBox

Комментарии • 752

  • @a_stumble1046
    @a_stumble1046 Год назад +98

    Say what you might about him not recognizing most of the high-price cards, but there's a certain type of joy that I had watching him go down memory lane, taking out cards that weren't expensive but held clear sentimental value. Thanks for sharing this experience with us and congrats on the great find!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +13

      FINALLY.... someone who understands how fun this video was for me !!!! Yes the valuable cards were nice, but I enjoyed getting the Serra Angels, Nightmares, Force of Nature and those more !

    • @sket179
      @sket179 7 месяцев назад

      I don't have nostalgia on these, just new to this topic and videos. So this video is different to others I've seen that are concentrating on current values. And that's what I thought your motivation was to buy. So this video is kind of mixed for me.

  • @joshuamcbroom2370
    @joshuamcbroom2370 2 года назад +474

    I loved how he casually passed up the lion’s eye diamond….. always nice to get a dually too!!! I would be stoked to get that thrift store pick up!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +31

      I know, everyone was yelling at me for just passing that one up while going through the lot. It sold quick for nice money!

    • @alonsomarcucci79
      @alonsomarcucci79 2 года назад +7

      I make a shriek noise when I saw that

    • @karlhungus5725
      @karlhungus5725 2 года назад +2

      Yeah I about jumped through the screen and offered you 50 cents for it

    • @karlhungus5725
      @karlhungus5725 2 года назад +5

      And a mystical tutor

    • @ihatethewind
      @ihatethewind Год назад +13

      And a necropotence!!!

  • @ExtremeMedium
    @ExtremeMedium 2 года назад +222

    Unreal find, this is the kind of find MtG players dream about discovering at thrift stores or flea markets, but never do. Thank you for sharing and congrats!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +3

      Glad you enjoyed! Thanks for watching.

    • @ChickenMcThiccken
      @ChickenMcThiccken 2 года назад +2

      makes you think. right? why not video tape the place you went to get them?

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +2

      I don't usually record in thrift stores. There are a few videos on my main channel That Reseller Guy

    • @aliosgerber2200
      @aliosgerber2200 Год назад +1

      No, u cant cause the whole thing is a fake for klicks.

    • @marcellachine5718
      @marcellachine5718 7 месяцев назад

      ​@@aliosgerber2200I've found similar boxes before 40, 60 dollars. Once not too long ago too.

  • @fernandoorozco3751
    @fernandoorozco3751 2 года назад +218

    LIONS.EYE.DIAMOND. Check the price. Also I saw a Mystical Tutor and a Necropotence. Demonic Tutor paid for the box by itself. And of course the Bayou. Nice pulls.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +5

      This was a crazy box/find. So many great cards. Even all the lower dollar cards really added up.

    • @matthewgoodridge1579
      @matthewgoodridge1579 2 года назад +2

      @@ThatCardGuy you sell that necropotence yet? I'm interested if you still have it :)

    • @benjaminharding6386
      @benjaminharding6386 2 года назад +1

      where was the LED. I was kinda skipping through

    • @leeread1234
      @leeread1234 2 года назад +3

      There was also a number of RL cards in there ( mudslide, glacial crevasses and at least 5 others ) I forgot which 1's by the time I wrote my comment lol

    • @steventhrasher3608
      @steventhrasher3608 2 года назад

      @@benjaminharding6386 ruclips.net/video/PC1_NSiS4ek/видео.html

  • @MrNuthaShot
    @MrNuthaShot Год назад +20

    The art and style of vintage magic just hits so different. Legitimate feels like finding and wizards spell tome. Thanks for sharing this, super exciting to see

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Thanks for watching.

    • @Pehr81
      @Pehr81 Год назад +1

      Yeah, todays art is way too dark imo. Also a little too perfect 😅

  • @dumediat_
    @dumediat_ 2 года назад +23

    That miscut necropotence is definitely worth looking into. I’m not an expert but there are groups that specifically look for misprints and will pay a premium for them. Some can get 10x the NM price depending on how rare the printing anomaly is.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +5

      A lot of viewers have talked about that card. My first time finding a misprint/miscut.
      Ended up trading it off to a friend.

    • @Mtg_MoBrocks
      @Mtg_MoBrocks Год назад

      Who/where looks for misprints because in literally have so many misprints/miscut/printer almost out of ink

    • @KainiusTheGreat
      @KainiusTheGreat Год назад

      @@Mtg_MoBrocks There's Facebook Groups for sure...maybe some on Twitter.

  • @GATECHMANgames
    @GATECHMANgames Год назад +13

    Loved how he pointed out the miscut on necropotence, not the fact that he had a $40 necropotence 😂😂

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      If you watched it all, you know I missed a lot of cards and values!

  • @joncarroll2040
    @joncarroll2040 Год назад +9

    The Demonic Tutor by itself probably makes the buy worth it for $25. Also white border cards with the column (Legends), moon (The Dark), anvil (Antiquities) and scimitar (Arabian Nights) are from Chronicles which was a reprint set.

    • @CYCO1631
      @CYCO1631 Год назад +1

      More like $45. I have one from Revised.

    • @crax83
      @crax83 Год назад +1

      Those pesky white border reprints have fooled me more than once.

    • @crax83
      @crax83 Год назад

      Not monetary though. Just when sorting through the collection 😁

  • @Suicidekings_
    @Suicidekings_ Год назад +5

    The Serendib Efreet is interesting @18:43 it's a blue creature on a green background. It was a common misprint in revised. The art for ifh-bin Efreet (or something along those lines) along with it's associated green background was printed with the name, casting cost, text, and power/toughness of Serendib Efreet.

  • @CreateWorlds
    @CreateWorlds 2 года назад +25

    Crazy find. I’ve never seen anything like this at a thrift store

  • @rivuletscug
    @rivuletscug Год назад +3

    I really like how unlike most unboxing channels you dont completely overreact, it’s therapeutic to watch and the commentary is always very nice

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      Thanks, I appreciate that.
      The Force of Nature and Nightmare were still my favorites from this box!

  • @ImThatGuy17
    @ImThatGuy17 2 года назад +5

    Wow, I've bought about a dozen thrift store boxes and never come close to this! Finding a dual land, LED, or any of the multiple reserved list cards you hit would be a dream! Congrats on the score!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      I've bought a few mystery boxes/lots of both sports cards, MTG, Pokemon and more.... this is my best find EVER!

  • @athanr171
    @athanr171 Год назад +2

    He casually passed the bombs and set aside all the trash. Lol.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Nothing wrong with liking the “trash” cards! 😁

  • @rorschach1
    @rorschach1 8 месяцев назад +1

    When he passed that Lions Eye Diamond I spit out my drink.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  8 месяцев назад

      I think everyone did! Luckily spotted it afterwards.

  • @grain_death
    @grain_death Год назад +6

    this is so fun i love seeing how excited you were for cards you cared about!! genuinely very very fun. but still extremely funny to see you pass by Lion's Eye Diamond

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      I think there have been 100 comments about me and that LED !!!! But I like what I like... and those Revised are my favorites.... regardless of value!

  • @CyberCross222
    @CyberCross222 Год назад +1

    Crusade, Swords to Plowshares, Serra Angel, Sol Ring, Demonic Tutor, Bayou, Strip Mine, Necropotence, Lion's Eye Diamond, Phyrexian Vault, Serendib Efreet, Sorceress Queen, Mind Twist, and Demonic Attorney I believe are all worth money

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      What about my beloved $2 Force of Nature?

    • @CyberCross222
      @CyberCross222 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy Just as amazing as ever :) I still love old cards, whether they're worth money or not

  • @matc241
    @matc241 6 месяцев назад +1

    Just seen this today. The funniest thing was the cards he kept pulling out saying I think this may have been a rare were mostly from the Fallen Empires set (the crown symbol ones). It was an expansion set sold in 8 card boosters only, the boosters had 6 cards from the common sheet and 2 cards from the uncommon sheet. There literally were no rares, just some uncommons which were rarer than others (which were on the print sheet multiple times).

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  6 месяцев назад

      Yep, I had stopped playing a ways before Fallen Empires. Did a LOT of research after the video. Lots of great cards I missed... and lots I thought were good, but weren't !!
      Thanks for watching.

  • @trumpetperson11
    @trumpetperson11 2 года назад +3

    People talking about LED, but he also just passed up like a $25 mystical tutor like it was bulk.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      I passed up a lot like it was bulk. Did find it all after I did the video.
      Thanks for watching.

  • @MtgLonestar
    @MtgLonestar 2 года назад +8

    Unbelievable what a treasure find! A lot of value here.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Crazy the quality of cards in here..... I even skipped over a bunch I didn't know about during the video !

  • @coooolibri
    @coooolibri 3 месяца назад +1

    id take days of my time to slowly get through all of this.
    i have a collection like this, but some sets only more of
    certain colors, and such. but id still say there is 1500-2000 euro
    in it.

  • @johannesfischer9087
    @johannesfischer9087 2 года назад +12

    Great Find! Worth about 1500 Dollar for sure

  • @timmysemporium8835
    @timmysemporium8835 Год назад +1

    Lions eye diamond halfway through the right side the box $800 white border cards with such symbols are chronicled cards

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Found the LED later on. Had no idea at the time!

  • @mikematij2
    @mikematij2 2 месяца назад +1

    I dont know why i can't stand the fact that this guy isn't a magic player, but ends up finding such nice cards.

  • @martinpattinson5303
    @martinpattinson5303 Год назад +1

    I know they’re not worth tons but I love seeing the zombie masters in there. If you happen to have one left I’d love to take it off your hands

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Sorry, they're all gone.
      Thanks for watching!

  • @jonnymmac
    @jonnymmac 2 года назад +4

    Dude so pure. Takes me back.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      It was really fun for me too. Haven't seen many of these cards in a long time!

  • @walkthroughit5198
    @walkthroughit5198 2 года назад +1

    4:25 had me dying
    "This is one of my favorite cards"
    *read more into the card"
    Ahh...has first strike

  • @rwxstudio7173
    @rwxstudio7173 Год назад +1

    The banners are Alliances.
    Fun fact: Alliances had an interesting rarity system. C1, C2, U1 & U2. Certain card variants were harder to get than others.

  • @Dracula_sb
    @Dracula_sb Год назад +3

    This is amazing, I ran into something similar at a comic shop, I bought 2 boxes of singles and found many cards from beta-legends!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      That is awesome! I've never found Beta. Nice!

  • @BlurredSignals
    @BlurredSignals 2 года назад +6

    my man just skipped over a lion's eye diamond like it wasnt shit :D

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      I know, I know…. Now. Did sell it for good money a few days after I published video.

    • @BlurredSignals
      @BlurredSignals 2 года назад

      @@ThatCardGuy think weve all done it bro... was just giving you a hard time. if you ever need any help with mtg pricing, hmu

  • @shorgoth
    @shorgoth 11 месяцев назад +1

    With old cards common can also be worth a lot of money. Don't count too much on creatures though, 95%+ of them are just outclassed by today's standard,

  • @diverseventures8063
    @diverseventures8063 2 года назад +4

    Very nice score! Going through the cards really took me back to the 90's, hanging with the guys playing Magic.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Glad you enjoyed it.
      It was fun going through these and remembering all the fun (and bad) card I used to play with.
      The big scores made it nice too !

  • @davideunknown8930
    @davideunknown8930 Год назад +2

    Great find for 25 dollars! As people already told you, you passed up a Lion's eye diamond. I will get the Bayou you found checked, it seemed a little bit too "glossy" imho, but was probably the light ;)

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +2

      Thanks.
      The Bayou did check out. For sure was something with the lighting.
      Sold the LED and Bayou quickly after. Traded a bunch to a friend and slowly trickled the $5-$10 sales over the next few months.
      Thx for watching.

  • @laurent5367
    @laurent5367 2 года назад +2

    (The white border ones with an extension sign are Chronicles. They're mostly worthless)

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Those tricked me for a minute.... yep, mainly junk.

  • @sfquigle
    @sfquigle 2 года назад +11

    19:58 - "hope you like the mystery boxes, these are a lot of fun for me, definitely worth the $25". I'm sure the nice few thousand return on the $25 will be nice too lol

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      Yeah, this was a crazy good one.... Sold about $1K, traded off a bunch and still have a stack of sub $10 cards still here.

  • @josephpayne9011
    @josephpayne9011 Год назад +3

    wow, whoever is working at that thrift store must have no idea what they missed not buying this themselves. great find!!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Local, religious charity thrift shop. They don't pull anything for themselves (as far as I know).

    • @ChaoticNeutralAnimation
      @ChaoticNeutralAnimation Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy a religious store selling MTG cards. How times have changed since the satanic panic.

  • @adam551982
    @adam551982 Год назад +1

    There's my box of priceless cards my mom gave away when I went to college.

  • @ChristopherSmithNYC
    @ChristopherSmithNYC Год назад +1

    20 new Legendary Human Artificers in Brothers war to utilize all those old-school artifacts. Good score.

  • @CYCO1631
    @CYCO1631 Год назад +1

    The Bayou alone is probably worth 200 times what the guy paid for it. And, a revised Demonic Tutor.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Got $300 for the Bayou and $450 for the LED.

  • @NeoN-PeoN
    @NeoN-PeoN Год назад +2

    That Goblin Digging Team with black boarder and the crescent moon symbol is an original "The Dark" card. Don't think it's worth a ton but I'd sleeve it.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      I played a lot of Goblin decks back in the day!
      Thanks for watching.

  • @l33_generic37
    @l33_generic37 Год назад +1

    The Demonic Tutor in the front paid for the lot. The rest were just extra padding for the wallet. Dear God man, if I had found this I would poop YOUR pants out of excitement.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      When I saw that Tutor on top..... I just bought and the rest was pure profit !

    • @l33_generic37
      @l33_generic37 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy definitely a great call on your part. 😂😂

  • @daveweeks4748
    @daveweeks4748 2 года назад +3

    Great find sir, thanks for sharing:) The collection reminds me of the range of cards you'd typically see in trade binders during the Mirage block, even with the sleeving of only a few cards and not sleeving the dual land. Makes me think the original owner gave up collecting/playing many years ago and just stored the box in a closet. All the best.

  • @devekut2
    @devekut2 Год назад +1

    I still have 90% of these in my binders from 1999; makes me happy.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      Nice! Wish I had kept all mine.

    • @devekut2
      @devekut2 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy Many got played with before anyone thought to preserve them with sleeves, but still have 24 home-brew decks from that era. Problem is: everyone plays 'Commander' format these days, and they're afraid of my geezer decks. 🤣

  • @alexgaspar2525
    @alexgaspar2525 2 года назад +2

    The white border from legends, the dark, Arabian nights and some of the other sets. with the set symbol makes them chronicles not from the original set

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Thanks for the info.... did a LOT of research after filming the video.

  • @houndoom51
    @houndoom51 Год назад +1

    Casually net's at least $1000 dollars with of magic cards for a slim $25.Wild!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Got about $700 for the two big cards and pieced out the rest. For sure a once in a lifetime MTG find!

  • @Dagarian
    @Dagarian Год назад +1

    The demonic tutor alone is a reason to buy this mystery box, u got ur value back and then some since a used revised demonic tutor sells for atleast 40$

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Yep. Saw that one card and bought them all. Turned out way better than imagined.

  • @justinscatina5321
    @justinscatina5321 Год назад +1

    Love how you pass up the djinn just to call out the trash warlord...😆

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      I missed/passed up a lot! Had to do a lot of research after.

    • @justinscatina5321
      @justinscatina5321 Год назад

      Right on sorry I ve played since alpha

  • @korn_bjbj4779
    @korn_bjbj4779 2 месяца назад +1

    I use this to sleep... Love the sound ❤

  • @danieljones8191
    @danieljones8191 Год назад +1

    Green with jealous rage lol good find

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Thanks. Ended up being worth way more than I thought!

  • @thebanours
    @thebanours 2 года назад +1

    Mystical tutor, 2 mystic remora, strip mine, bayou, LED... 25$ worth almost 1200$! So jealous, congrat!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Thanks. Was an amazing find.

  • @gregfotos6463
    @gregfotos6463 Год назад +1

    The Demonic Tutor alone pays for the whole box lol

  • @danielgraves13
    @danielgraves13 Год назад +1

    "ill stop at any good cards. oh, look at the cut on that...."
    ice age necropotence worth more than the price tag on the box.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      I didn't realize at the time how collected those miscut cards were. Traded that to a friend.

    • @danielgraves13
      @danielgraves13 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy oh, i was looking at the base value. not even anything miscut.

  • @borexxx01
    @borexxx01 11 месяцев назад +1

    I can actually make a White Weenie Deck from that pile.. Nice find! oh, that Lions Eye Diamond! hahaha And many more!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  10 месяцев назад

      So many good, fun cards were in this box.
      Had those nice “hidden” cards I didnt know about (LED). But the memories were worth much more!

  • @luciencloutier3035
    @luciencloutier3035 2 года назад +1

    Demonic Tutor, Demonic Hordes x 2, Nature's Lore, Jeweled Amulet, pyroblast x2, sol ring x2, STP x2, Howling mine, BAYOU, strip mine, Necropotence, Jokulhaups, LION'S EYE DIAMOND!!!, Mystical tutor, Bazaar of Wonders, Darkpact x3, Zombie Master x3, Gustha's Scepter, mind twist, Contract from below x2, Demonic attorney x 2, Mystic Remora, OMG, I don't smoke and I need a smoke after that one. Congratulations buddie on a great deal!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Thanks... it was a crazy one.

  • @crush3146
    @crush3146 8 месяцев назад +1

    This world is nothing but chaos 😂

  • @Vitalquelle
    @Vitalquelle Год назад +1

    First i was "ha, he casually went over the pyro/hydroblast and the hymns" then he found the necro and i thought "thats a good find for 25bucks with the tutor, nice" then the bayou.... And then the FREAKING LED and he closses over it.... This the box everyone is dreaming to find when buying random collections on ebay ect. :D

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      My best find ever! I'm out looking for deals just about every day and doubt I'll get another box close to this good.

  • @AngelusNielson
    @AngelusNielson Год назад +1

    fun fact, back knight and white night will never be able to fight because they have protection from each other.

  • @danmackneyii4750
    @danmackneyii4750 Год назад +1

    The only thing more baller than cruising past a LED would have been to find an old Alliances' Force of Will and rip it in half while commenting about how garbage it is because of the high casting cost. Great video man, Serra used to slap!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Thanks.... appreciate the comment. Had fun going thru these.

  • @waynehumphries6970
    @waynehumphries6970 Год назад +1

    Every magic players dream is finding old boxes of magic cards

  • @bgtmscotty3146
    @bgtmscotty3146 Год назад +1

    Legends and chronicles have the same set symbols but legends has a black border

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      I sort of knew, but was so excited checking out these cards I didn't talk about it. Lots of fun reliving my MTG playing days.
      Thanks for watching.

  • @busterfishyman
    @busterfishyman Год назад +2

    I saw a mystic remora at 16:35, cool find

  • @christianbergeron2519
    @christianbergeron2519 2 года назад +6

    *Stops abruptly at necropotence*
    (He must surely knows its worth something)
    *Hey look at the cut on this one*
    *Facepalm*
    Haha, very nice finds, congrats !

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      That was a very strange card. It's authenticity was questionable. Card felt a bit off. Gave it to a friend.

    • @cotefigueroa
      @cotefigueroa 2 года назад

      @@ThatCardGuy It is a Miscut Necropotence (wich gives it a very higher price than a normal one), I don't think any of those cards are fake

    • @njensen218
      @njensen218 2 года назад +1

      @@ThatCardGuy Misprints / cuts are more valuable to the right collector - and Necropotence has such history, its value is always high!

    • @matthewmcmahon1541
      @matthewmcmahon1541 2 года назад +1

      Yeah, that miscut Necro is probably worth 2-3× the normal price, and that's a $50 card normally.

  • @GyaradosFreak
    @GyaradosFreak Год назад +1

    😱😱that lions eye diamond is REALLY valuable too!!!

  • @clintengelbretson2810
    @clintengelbretson2810 2 года назад +13

    Makes me sad inside that the person who found this has no idea what he has. Means absolutely nothing to him but $$$$. Any real magic player would have been so excited to have these.

    • @epicsketchers
      @epicsketchers 2 года назад

      Yeah… made me alil pissed too. It’s like guy? This shit money. Sports cards aren’t worth the dirt on the floor

    • @clintengelbretson2810
      @clintengelbretson2810 2 года назад +3

      @@epicsketchers not pissed, more sad then anything. I play with my 12 and 15 year old boys. I can only imagine there faces had they got to go through these. Either of them would have been jumping and screaming running around with excitement after seeing a dual land or lion eye diamond, he completely misted the Tutor and diamond, went by them like they were commons. Not to mention he had no idea what chronicles is. Just wish someone could have found these that would actually appreciate what they got.

    • @epicsketchers
      @epicsketchers 2 года назад

      @@clintengelbretson2810 :((

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +2

      I was very excited to find and go through these cards. As I said in the video, I played "back in the day" with Unlimited, Revised, Ice Age and such. I haven't kept up with newer releases as it seems there have been 100s of series since then. Seeing the Dual Land, Serra Angels, Nightmare, Force of Nature and more made me happy to relive my youthful days of playing.
      I don't have kids who are interested in MTG, so absolutely I'll sell these. Get them to players/collectors who will use and appreciate them.
      Thanks for watching the video.

  • @craigstuckey319
    @craigstuckey319 5 месяцев назад +1

    Why is it always people that won't fully appreciate these cards that find them?

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  5 месяцев назад

      I 100% appreciate them. I had an amazing time going through the cards, reliving memories of the early days of MTG. I no longer play, so sold some, traded some and still have a small batch here.
      Thanks for watching.

  • @that1guyluken862
    @that1guyluken862 Год назад +1

    Casually passing mystic remora
    "Pretty sure these are all commons"

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      That wasn't the only card I missed!

    • @that1guyluken862
      @that1guyluken862 Год назад

      @ThatCardGuy congrats on the finds, those are the type of cards us new magic players dream about 👍

  • @jakepetruolo1847
    @jakepetruolo1847 2 года назад +1

    The mystical tutor and necropotence were casually flown by too lol

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      I did miss a lot while filming, but caught them all when researching after.
      Thanks for watching.

  • @clintongriffin2077
    @clintongriffin2077 2 года назад +2

    I was going to say L.E.D but someone else caught it. Nice buy. Fun to watch and takes me back to middle school

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      EVERYONE, but me knew about that one right away. It did sell for a huge price soon after video done.

  • @ericcarman8345
    @ericcarman8345 Год назад +2

    man for old cards some of them are still in pretty good condition. what a lucky find!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Overall they were pretty nice, light play on a few

  • @callmethreeone
    @callmethreeone Год назад +1

    Goodwill sells them for about 75+ per lot. I saw one lot at nearly 700.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      Yeah, the Goodwill online auctions can go crazy sometimes !

    • @callmethreeone
      @callmethreeone Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy I just started collecting them, and it seems all auctions do.

  • @Quarkkie
    @Quarkkie 2 года назад +2

    When it comes to valuing old Magic cards, you can’t judge just on border color and commonality. You can find a black border common worth hundreds. Also be mindful of black border cards without a set symbol. Could be Beta/Alpha. Also some white border could be Unlimited and worth a lot.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Thanks. Unfortunately found no Unlimited in here.

    • @joeycote480
      @joeycote480 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy I can tell you for a certainly that the darker Serra Angel was Unlimited. I know I saw a few more Unlimited cards as well.

    • @rx7782guncannon
      @rx7782guncannon Год назад

      @@joeycote480 that 5th Serra Angel with the 1995 copyright date is from 4th Edition, the other four were definitely from revised.

  • @shawnhardman9607
    @shawnhardman9607 2 года назад +2

    Had some good stuff. Lucky hits on few big money cards but even some other stuff. Looked like a few mystic remoras. Hot commander card at about $15 each. Revised sol rings for for a decent amount too.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Yep, lots of nice cards in this lot. Thanks for watching.

  • @timmysemporium8835
    @timmysemporium8835 Год назад +1

    2002 I picked up 87 lions eye diamonds for $0.15 a piece and yes I have 87 of them 😆🤙 everybody put them in a deck and went to play them you go no discard your hand before you get to play anyting smoking powerful back then with wheel of Fortune and timespiral.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      WOW.... that's crazy. I sold so many of these type cards in the early 1990s when I stopped playing.

    • @timmysemporium8835
      @timmysemporium8835 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy I don't know if it's just me but the duel land looked a little too shiny. If you take a Jeweler's loupe and look at the casting cost with the loop it should look like a perfect print if it looks like a bunch of stars it's not real . but you can only see it with a Jeweler's loop. Or go into a dark room and shine a LED light through it it should look like gel and you should be able to read both sides of the card. 😆🤙 Keep rocking my friend

    • @timmysemporium8835
      @timmysemporium8835 Год назад

      @@ThatCardGuy but 25 bucks for all the nice great playables and two cards were 12:00 that's awesome 💪😎👍💯%

  • @tyrannoeil1609
    @tyrannoeil1609 11 месяцев назад +1

    With a Demonic tutor on top, you cant really go wrong.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  11 месяцев назад +1

      That's what I thought too! Got way better as I got into the box !

  • @gryphonprovenzano3156
    @gryphonprovenzano3156 Год назад +1

    I know this is a year old but so much value passed over like it’s nothing hurts

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      I know.... biggest comment is how I missed just about everything !

    • @gryphonprovenzano3156
      @gryphonprovenzano3156 Год назад

      Wow didn’t expect you’d actually respond wow I love these types of videos ( mtg not Pokémon or yugioh but still cool

  • @Kuz929
    @Kuz929 Год назад +1

    I know this video is a little old... but that Bayou is Unlimited, not Revised. One of the giveaways is the "T" for a tap symbol. For Revised, they changed it to the arrow and got rid of the "T" because it didn't work in other languages

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      I think someone mentioned that in another comment. It sold quickly after video was done, so I couldn’t double check it.

  • @peterlindquist9951
    @peterlindquist9951 Год назад +1

    once i found two perfect force of wills in a seven dollar bulk thing

  • @joe-di6zf
    @joe-di6zf Год назад +2

    This is why u don't buy mtg cards if u have no idea about them. Passes up the lions eye diamond, pulls out force of nature.....

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Regardless of value. I still like the Force more!

  • @cmsfhms
    @cmsfhms Год назад +1

    You found thousands of dollars! Those sol rings are expensive too

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Yeah, had a friend who wanted those Sol Rings. Traded them to him.
      Total was over $2k sold

  • @gootvansquid
    @gootvansquid 22 дня назад +1

    I mean, seeing the Demonic Tutor alone is reason to buy it, seeing as it's worth more than $25 lol. Always have to wonder if a video like this isn't fake though. It's an absurd find.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  21 день назад

      I was surprised to see them selling it with the Demonic Tutor on top as this was sold at a Church based thrift store.
      One of the top 10 finds in my 20 years of Thrift Store hunting!

  • @richardhermogeno7245
    @richardhermogeno7245 Год назад +1

    2 Lhurgoyfs in the second to the last stack LOL

  • @peterbruno657
    @peterbruno657 2 года назад +2

    Breezed right by the best card in the box. Awesome find.

  • @bokeshow
    @bokeshow 2 года назад +2

    The necropotence and lions eye diamond are worth a lot of money, along with mystical tutor. Nice pulls for $25.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +3

      Thanks! Sold the LED for $450 just after video was made.

  • @slimpickins43ttv39
    @slimpickins43ttv39 Год назад +1

    I dont know if anyone already said but depending on what set that dark ritual is from it can be worth a little bit also that necropotence is worth a bit

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      Traded those both off to a friend.... I think he kept them and didn't sell.

  • @treetrimmerbear9899
    @treetrimmerbear9899 2 года назад +2

    Saw a “mystic Remora” in the second to last stack hiding good EDH staple nice hit

  • @jettblade
    @jettblade 2 года назад +2

    I'm curious what the total price of what he found was. I'm guessing maybe up to $1,000. I know Bayou is probably about 1/2 that depending on the shape of the card, a minimum of at least $300. Definitely not bad for $25 and some tax.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      I got $450 for the LED and $300 for the Bayou. Traded off a few hundred worth to a friend as well. Still have quite a few $3-$10 cards.

    • @jettblade
      @jettblade 2 года назад +1

      @@ThatCardGuy Very nice. You really never know what you can find.

  • @pallyxav7597
    @pallyxav7597 2 года назад +1

    That Goblin Recruiter he just passed over too

  • @allenbarr4428
    @allenbarr4428 Год назад +1

    Guy is working a RUclips channel and he got a hell of a lot of hits to this post! I don't believe for one minute he bought this box for $25.00! He sucked in a ton of Timmy comments! Good Job!

  • @tylerjohnobrien7744
    @tylerjohnobrien7744 2 года назад +1

    I'm sure someone already said this but I'm not going to read through the comments to see lol. Around 14:00 there's a necropotence thats worth decent money

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      It was an odd miscut. Card felt "weird" too, not sure if legit, but a friend wanted it, so traded it to them.

  • @iantorres4639
    @iantorres4639 Год назад

    Yea, came across this video a bit later than most of the other commenters, but I noticed a lot of missed cards.. Honestly I would go and price every single one from the box. Even things like the Sol Rings and things u might immediately disregard are worth money. I know lots of other commenters have mentioned specifics and that is great but you should probably just double check everything. There are a lot of cards, but with that stack in particular im sure it is worth it.

    • @iantorres4639
      @iantorres4639 Год назад

      At least a few things that people didnt mention, the mystic remora is worth at least $10 or so right now and some other things that add up quickly.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      After I made the video I spent hours researching everything. Learned a lot. So many good cards in this batch.

  • @Agmanthion
    @Agmanthion Год назад +1

    goodwill has a policy to throw these out as soon as they find them. call your local goodwill and call them stupid. for the sake of classic mtg collectors everywhere

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      I have found a couple smaller bags of MTG at Goodwills, but not many.

  • @seanbullough6296
    @seanbullough6296 Год назад +1

    Shuffled right past the Lion's Eye Diamond!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      I think 100 people told me that! 😁
      Caught it after I went thru them all later.

  • @DiabloTommaso
    @DiabloTommaso Год назад +1

    Sol rings, demonic, mystical, swords, necro, led and a dual.... man noone checked that box before you for sure

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      My best find of the year! So many great cards were in there.

  • @patrickgill-dube9482
    @patrickgill-dube9482 5 месяцев назад +1

    You pass up a lion eye diamond!!!!😮

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  5 месяцев назад

      Yes.... and about 2,000 people commented and told me, scolded me and made fun of me. But I found it after.
      Thanks for watching.

  • @rockey709
    @rockey709 Год назад +3

    What a trip down memory lane! Awesome stuff.

  • @ElCaudilloTV
    @ElCaudilloTV Год назад +1

    Nice find! If you aew aelling, im interested in the Necropotence. Let me know!

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад +1

      Thanks.
      Video was done several months ago and all the big cards have already been sold.

  • @lightninglukemtg580
    @lightninglukemtg580 2 года назад +2

    If u bought them to resale you might as well just hold them because they are all going to go up and then you can really tax the players

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      I traded the reserved list cards to a friend who stashes them away.

  • @WarhavenSC
    @WarhavenSC Год назад +1

    I've yet to find a single MtG card at any of my thrift stores.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  Год назад

      They may send in all cards to Goodwill.com auctions.

  • @zacarious97
    @zacarious97 2 года назад +6

    I am an experienced collector and recently bought a collection from roughly the same era, I can tell from the quick glance, you have over $1500 in cards there. If you’d like any help with valuing them or selling them, let me know and I can give you a form of contact. I personally would love to buy the Necropotence from you if I can.

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for the offer. I did this video a couple months ago and have already sold the higher dollar cards. Lots of $2-$5 cards still on my desk in a pile.

    • @mcslappynuts857
      @mcslappynuts857 2 года назад +1

      @That card guy, I'm collecting ice age block. Do you have a website?

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад +1

      Link to eBay store in the video

  • @jasonsutherland3496
    @jasonsutherland3496 2 года назад +1

    Half moon, the dark. Flag, alliances. Earth globe, homelands. Crown, fallen empires

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      Kind of crazy how many different sets were in this one small box.

    • @crimsontrench9230
      @crimsontrench9230 2 года назад +1

      And, if the border is white with the set symbol, it's from Chronicles. The first reprint set!

  • @treetrimmerbear9899
    @treetrimmerbear9899 2 года назад +1

    That Miss cut necropotence is a good hit.. it’s worth quite a bit normally, but people like to collect old misprints and they go for a premium

    • @ThatCardGuy
      @ThatCardGuy  2 года назад

      First time I've ever saw a miscut MTG. Traded that one to a friend.