I wanted to edit that I was right the Palooza Glitter is not eye safe (it’s written very tiny on the back of the palette.) I have to say I’m extremely disappointed. I know some people are willing to take that risk but as someone who’s had two eye surgeries I am not. I really wish they had done something eye safe and left the chunky glitter as a single.
I completely agree. I ordered the uh huh honey palette on friday and I wish I knew the glitter was not eye safe. I totally assumed bc it was in a dang eye palette. That is pretty dangerous and irresponsible on CP's part and I hope no one has any complications from it :/
I would be terrified to try that glitter because of previous eye surgeries and the fact that I probably should be giving my poor eyes more of a break from makeup ... But that apparently doesn’t stop me from applying glitter everywhere else.
Yes, especially since palooza isn't new. It was released as a single pressed glitter when they released their neon colors! So, it was a strange choice. Maybe they tried to use up leftover stock with that?? Idk, but a super shock in the middle would've been better. I'm waiting for my palette to arrive.. I'm collecting all of their 9 pan monochromatics! Great job💛💛💛
It's not eye safe, either, so they used less environmentally safe packaging just so that they could include a glitter that's both bad for the environment and dangerous for the eyes. I just don't get that choice at all.
I love bees so I definitely want that colourpop palette, even tho I'll never use it. I wish they would donate a percentage to protect the 🐝🐝🐝🐝🐝 or something
That would have been amazing! I love bees too. Especially random facts about queen bees. I live for them. Well.. I live for the idea of them. Not a big fan of them being near me 😂😂
I just came from the CP website and the Honey palette is sold out. I think for me, knowing I'm not going to use a yellow palette very often, I would get CP because of the price and possibility of getting it at a discount. Thanks so much for this video. Both looks were beautiful!
Midas does have discount codes as well so they only end up being a few dollar off from each other and their shipping was pretty low for me. Thank you for watching! 💛💛
Thanks for this video! The Lemonade wins, for me. 1st..I am passionate about supporting small business. 2nd..I dont think that the ColourPop mattes have enough depth. The mattes are too similar.
@@lightheidi9009 Your 100% right! Most of the time, a small business welcomes constructive, critiques. In my opinion, The Lemonade Palette was carefully curated. I really want to keep my eye on this brand 👍
@@TheCupatcake I understand your feelings about the glitter. Some people wear it in the immediate eye area and dont have complications. Thats a personal choice. Personally, I have had an eye injury, from stuff getting in my eyes and I will not risk it.
@@AmyLovesMakeup Not your fault my dear. I enjoyed seeing your video none the less! yellows are so a special case. They look so different depending on your skintone
Seeing them swatched side by side was really helpful. I love ColourPop eyeshadows and am disappointed that the pressed glitter isn’t eye safe. Cooler colors look better on me so I’m glad I decided on the Midas palette instead.
I tried the Midas Cosmetic palette yesterday, and I’m in love. I have no yellows in my collection, so it definitely added something. Thank you for the comparison!
The minute you touched that shimmer yellow with a hint of blue I fell in love with it. Before even seeing how it looked like, just because you got so excited 😂 you probably already know this but the yellow glitter isn’t eye safe 💛
I think the thing that I love the most out of your videos, is the fact that you describe the shades. A lot of you tubers show the shades on camera, but the camera does not do the shades justice. I feel it’s so important to see if there is a shift, if there is a dual chrome, or if they lean more yellow, more orange and someone. You do such a great job describing each of the shades and I love that about you! Your videos are very unique and I think you deserve a bigger audience!
If palooza isn’t eye safe what are you supposed to do with it- put it on your shoulders. Maybe some people could use it as a highlight or put it around eyes for a costume look? I love that uh huh honey palette though and will probably still get it or maybe get the Midas one as well
*WELCOME BACK!!!* 💞❣️💋🌟 PS. I'm 💯 here for *Midas Lemonade* !! It came yesterday & I love it. And I'm gifting my unused CP 🍯 uh huh honey. The pressed glitters in palettes is really triggering me 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I'm refusing to purchase any palette from ANY brand if it has a pressed glitter at this point. *** CP states on that palette that palooza is not intended for use on or near eyes...🤷
@@AmyLovesMakeup it's just a bit disappointing in my opinion.. They have the ability to create gorgeous formulas. They have proven that so.... Why not give us a duo flip metallic or a super shock 🤷
@@lunagirl4039 a supershock would have been great. Actually anything that wasn't a pressed glitter if I'm being honest. Such a strange choice to put an 'unsafe for eyes' product in an eyeshadow palette. I know pressed pigments are also officially unsafe for eyes in the US but that's just because of staining, glitter is actually dangerous if it gets in your eyes.
@@minkg8178 my point exactly. I have enough eyes issues lol when I was a kid I got shattered glass in my eyes- so I am super weird with anything going in my eyes/on my actually eyeball. like I have to use special eye drops & still I am the biggest baby & I miss more than actually getting the meds into my eyes LOL.. getting my eyes dilated for an eye exam... ooof! my poor ophthalmologist & optometrist 🙄 for having to deal with my tantrum as a grown woman 🤣🤣😎
Midas definitely won this round for me. I’m not into the pressed glitter in a palette situation with Colourpop or the plastic packaging. They actually sell that specific pressed glitter as a single shadow, so even if I liked pressed glitter and that really pretty duochrome, I would just get the glitter as a single and then get the Clionadh single you mentioned that’s a dupe for the duochrome shade (plus I LOVE Clionadh shimmers so that’s even better imo haha). Also, that pressed glitter is “not intended for use on or around the eye” so I’d rather avoid scratching my cornea 😬😬😬 But yes, awesome video! Your look came out amazing as always 💕
I think after finding out the pressed glitter is not eye safe the Lemonade is my winner as well but I could see how they would both work for different people 😊
I totally can see your point of view on your opinions on both palettes. Makes total sense. I guess it's always about what someone is going for and how much of a collection you always have already. Love your work😊💕
I love the colourpop palette! Seems very wearable to me. Sadly its sold out, now that the 25% off sale started. Gonna wait til the next sale. Love your look!
Hi, sweetie. I love your enthusiasm and your smile. Yay, two monochromatic yellow palettes!!!!!!! I can't wait to see what the differences are between the two. You're so beautiful!!!
@@AmyLovesMakeup , you're welcome. I hear you. I have been on a no buy for June so I went ham yesterday. Hahaha. But, I bought stuff that I really, really wanted and stuff i had never tried before like the kaliedos palettes, and the whalesong.
Okay not only is this video great because you’re amazing but it has also shown me that I need to buy some softbox lighting because my video is SO reflective that it’s a little tough to see my swatches. So thank you for helping with my setup too!! 😂😂😂
I just got my Lemonade palette and I adore it! It is on the “sour” side of yellow, but the darkest shade has this beautiful greenish-olive undertone that allows me to create true chartreuse color when mixed with the yellow....just adore it!
So excited about this video! I decided to order Lemonade first and hope for a comparison ... I think I can go without CP’s palette even though I have five of their monochromatic palettes...
So excited you did this comparison. I tried the Midas pallet this morning and love it. I was wondering if I was missing out on the colorpop one but now I know I made the right choice.
that was a great idea! from here, colourpop looks more mustard and makes your eye look bigger. I do like the midas better and the glitter is a deal-breaker for me. but both look pretty on you.
Thank you for comparing these two palettes! Was so curious to see what different between them. Bought the ColourPop but after seeing this video, think I’ll get the Midas as well. There’s a difference in the weight listed here (from the box) versus what’s on their websites. Midas has the weight on their website now, almost at the bottom of the page as net weight 0.63 ounces (0.07 ounce/pan) versus ColourPop’s website weight as .03 ounces/pan. Midas is the better deal. Plus I wanted a more pure yellow palette. 😊💙💙
Welcome back 🤗Lovely palettes,but the colors in the lemonade palette seem more versatile plus there’s no pressed glitter in it (my eyes are bit sensitive),so it’s more appealing to me.
Great comparison! The Midas one has definitely more depth to it. Drives me crazy if a palette does not have a shade to create depth. 😅 Also I love how the yellow in the Midas one are more cool toned.
I think in this specific situation it’s hard because people were asking for a full yellow palette so Colourpop gave them what they asked for. I personally think a rich deep brown would have added well to the Uh Huh Honey Palette (and I don’t say that often lol)
I was interested to see you do this comparasion. As a fellow redhead, I tend to avoid yellow because I'm concerned it will make me look ill. It looks beautiful on you, and it gives me more confidence to try to mix in some yellow into my looks. I don't think I'll get either palette, but I might get the Clionadh Soul when they reopen their store.
I honestly love yellow. I used to always have people tell me what I should wear based on my red hair and it drove me crazy. I just wear whatever I want now 😊💛
I've ordered the Uh huh honey palette from Colourpop last night. I can't wait to see how those shades look on my skintone. What a great content for a video Amy. I hope you had a fun vacation💛.
This is a great comparison Amy. I just received my Colourpop palette and now I wish I had known about the other one instead. But I'll work it out, LOL! Thanks for the video.
Very pretty palettes!!!! Every time you talk about inner corner shades , I always would put them in my lid . Lol .. Thanks for the reviews ( I like the look you came up with today) 🌸💕🌸👍🏻
This was such a helpful video! I was kinda tempted by the Colourpop palette but something stops me buying from them every time. I’d never heard of Midas but their palette has more range & depth & if I was buying a yellow palette that’s the one I think 🤔. Your nails even match! Love your dedication to your channel 💛😘
I feel like with yellows you can't get enough variation between shades. Go pale and you end up with a straight up cream. Dark yellow is basically just brown. Warm toned yellow is orange and cool toned is pretty much green. I know you can have variations on yellow but honestly not enough to make a 9 pan palette without incorporating different colours that are just strongly yellow toned...Then again, I know people would then get upset they weren't 100% yellow so the only option is to have a lot of veeeeeeeery similar shades together :/ A yellow toned grungey palette would be awesome though!
Thank you for th comparison. I've been hesitant about a yellow palette because I'm not sure how it would look on me, but I'm really liking the different tones in the Colourpop one. The Lemonade palette not only seems more cool toned, but I feel like the depth of most of the yellows are pretty similar with the exception of the brown-based color. For only $12, I might pull the trigger.
New subscriber! Annette from Annette’s Makeup Corner recommended you and I’m glad to have found another honest fun makeup loving channel to watch! Thanks
My Colourpop Uh Huh Honey came in today and I'm so excited!!! I hadn't bought any affordable eyeshadows in years until the Colourpop sweet talk came out months ago and I've gotten almost all their palettes since!!(Disney villains but it wasn't my thing and I returned it, main squeeze, blue moon, ooh la la, California love...) I'm so happy they make affordable amazing high quality palettes. I literally can't stand to pay for Sephora priced eyeshadows anymore and I used to work at Sephora JCP!
@@AmyLovesMakeup yes! And it's awesome that they have after-pay as well and Instagram pay with free shipping and no taxes. I also loved your video, you got a new subscriber!
This was so fun! I'd definitely go for the Midas palette. I already have Sol and Palooza is also available as a single (but I never use glitter anyway). The other shades in Uh Huh Honey seem a bit lackluster, so I'll pass!
Really enjoyed watching your comparisons of these palettes, Amy, and the beautiful look you created using each. Definitely agree the Midas has more depth & the chunky pressed glitter in the Colourpop palette would definitely be a deal- breaker for me. I don't wear a lot of yellow, but do have a few in my collection (probably enough to make do). Still, if I was in the market, Midas would win! 😊 💖 👍🏻 🥉
Thank you I’m glad you liked it. I could get past the glitter when I thought it was eye safe but now it would be a deal breaker for me too. Very disappointed.
@@AmyLovesMakeup, exactly! And as others have said, there's probably no glitter that's really considered "eye-safe" , but my understanding is that when the particles are round (spheres) & smaller, there's a chance that your eyes can flush them out naturally more easily as opposed to the big, chunky stuff. I don't wear contacts, but if I did, I definitely wouldn't touch anything glittery with a 10-foot barge pole in regards to my eyes. Mercy! 🙀
scotzmnswife yeah I believe so too. I didn’t know that none were technically considered eye safe. I bought a pressed glitter shadow when trying a new brand for July and I feel like an idiot now 🙈😂
@@AmyLovesMakeup, well you shouldn't feel stupid, as when something is marketed as a glitter shadow (or is a pressed glitter stuck into the middle of an eyeshadow palette), it is misleading customers into thinking it is meant for the eyes, with most people presuming it is safe to use in the eye area. Frankly, I don't think companies should be allowed to market unsafe glitters in conjunction with eye products/palettes, as it gives some customers a false sense of security. If McDonald's can lose a lawsuit for selling coffee that's too hot (despite their disclaimer on the cup), I'm thinking one of these cosmetics companies is just waiting to get the pants sued off of them. All it takes is one customer having a serious eye injury, & their disclaimer on the package will mean zilch in a court of law.
I really like this video, I have no yellows and I'm a bit scared of them - I have very pink skin so not sure how it'll look - but I think I might add 'uh huh honey' to my list of palettes to choose from after Christmas. I might even depot it and just keep 1 or 2 yellows (especially that blue-yellow) and give the rest away :) Thanks so much for such a detailed review - this has been really helpful!
I think it could be fun to try! I don’t really allow my undertones to stop me from using any colors that I want to. I think if you feel confident in it and love it that’s what matters and what makes it look good 😊
@@AmyLovesMakeup Thanks Amy! I think I will try it, if I don't like all the yellows I think the yellow-blue as an inner corner colour on a blue look will still look nice! Thanks for the encouragement :D
Ahh you got me thinking that my skin will turn the colourpop ones into orange lol I think my undertones are definitely not right for that one buttttt it’s going to be delivered today so I’m still excited ! Thank you always Amy 💛
Midas wins this one for me! 💛 You look gorgeous in yellow! 😍 That glitter in the Colourpop palette is such a fail for me and a waste of space. Why would they include not eye safe glitter in the eyeshadow palette?!?! 🤔😣
RawBeautyKristi use the Cp glitter shade and she mentioned it was hurting her eye & it’s not eye safe! I was thinking that a lot of shades say that , but she was seriously wondering why they put that in the palette and she thinks the glitter may have irritated her eye! She used the sweet talk palette which has the pressed glitter in it , but that one she had no issues with. I herd Cp pressed glitter formula is better than most pressed glitters but something about the huge chunky glitter is why it could scratch the eye. Idk I ordered it but afraid to use the pressed glitter! Oh and it’s an existing shade that Cp already has.
I have to watch her video on it. I completely agree with her. Hopefully Colourpop will listen to this feedback. And it’s not even like a normal pressed glitter. It’s chunky.
I have so many wishes for these palettes. I wish the CP one was in a more environmentally friendly packaging and that the glitter was actually both eye and earth safe. To have a not eye safe glitter right in the center means I’m buying eight shadows and a placeholder, not 9 shadows. And I kind of feel like the Midas palette has four of almost the same matte yellows. I wish that there was more variation there. And I think that at this point I’ve bought so many shadows that I do have these shades, albeit not in one place. I kind of wish that instead of a green palette with pops of yellow, I wish that Blush Tribe had released a yellow palette with pops of green. Sigh. Maybe this is all saving me money.
I’m really hoping someone does a Grunge mix of greens and yellows! Fingers crossed!! And yeah I feel the same on your thoughts on CP. The Midas mattes i actually feel like yes they’re all yellow but they their own variety. I quite like them.
I’m not sure if I will. I used the flamingo for my shop my stash in June and I have some thoughts on it. I might carry June’s products through July because I’m off schedule.
One more point to put out there, and maybe you touch on it, I haven’t finished watching yet, but Midas is a black-owned makeup brand, and so if that’s important to your viewers (well, aside from the fact that they might already know), it seemed worthwhile to emphasize that.
Your excitement made me all excited for these palettes. They are our kryptonite gal! LoL. 😂😂😂💸💸💰💰💵💵😂😂😂 Now I want these. . . LoL. I can totally get behind these both. . . And to validate my future purchases of these Coldplay's "Yellow" started playing at Illinois Cancercare while I am sitting with my mom. . . LoL.
@@AmyLovesMakeup It's OK Amy I too am on the mess express. LoL. I don't have too many yellows in my collection. So these would both fulfill a need/gap. . . Thank you she's a tough ole bird --- her name is Robin. ❤❤❤❤ She's fighting. So we have hope and great medical care. 😊
Midas Cosmetics was kind enough to accept me an affiliate so you can now use my code AMYLOVES to save money off if you would like 💛💛
I feel like the Midas yellows look like a green yellow, whereas the colourpop yellows look more orange yellow
Those are my thoughts exactly.
Good point. Although that makes the "honey" title fitting.
That's a good observation
I wanted to edit that I was right the Palooza Glitter is not eye safe (it’s written very tiny on the back of the palette.) I have to say I’m extremely disappointed. I know some people are willing to take that risk but as someone who’s had two eye surgeries I am not. I really wish they had done something eye safe and left the chunky glitter as a single.
I completely agree. I ordered the uh huh honey palette on friday and I wish I knew the glitter was not eye safe. I totally assumed bc it was in a dang eye palette. That is pretty dangerous and irresponsible on CP's part and I hope no one has any complications from it :/
I would be terrified to try that glitter because of previous eye surgeries and the fact that I probably should be giving my poor eyes more of a break from makeup ... But that apparently doesn’t stop me from applying glitter everywhere else.
I avoid glitter for 2 reasons--eye safety concerns & environmental impact(unless it's biodegradeable)
Yes, especially since palooza isn't new. It was released as a single pressed glitter when they released their neon colors! So, it was a strange choice. Maybe they tried to use up leftover stock with that?? Idk, but a super shock in the middle would've been better. I'm waiting for my palette to arrive.. I'm collecting all of their 9 pan monochromatics! Great job💛💛💛
100% agree!!!
*I wish Colourpop would switch over to environmentally safe glitters!* 😓 🌎
It's not eye safe, either, so they used less environmentally safe packaging just so that they could include a glitter that's both bad for the environment and dangerous for the eyes. I just don't get that choice at all.
I wish everyone would switch over to environmentally safe glitters.
I'm so interested in both but I need to see someone my complexion demo these. Beautiful look Amy!
Totally understand! Thank you for watching still 💛💛
I can't see your picture very well, but maybe this one?
ruclips.net/video/MY74Og6uOIg/видео.html
I love bees so I definitely want that colourpop palette, even tho I'll never use it. I wish they would donate a percentage to protect the 🐝🐝🐝🐝🐝 or something
That would have been amazing! I love bees too. Especially random facts about queen bees. I live for them.
Well.. I live for the idea of them. Not a big fan of them being near me 😂😂
Since CP is already a giant brand I think I will get the Midas palette to support indie brands. They all work so hard to earn a living.
What a wonderful idea 🐝
I know I don’t need two yellow monochromatic but I want both of them😫💛
Me too so I don't have to decide which to get 😂😂😂
Right! I already told myself if anyone else comes out with a yellow palette I’m not allowed to buy it 😂😂
I already ordered the colourpop..but the lemonade one is so enticing!
I just came from the CP website and the Honey palette is sold out. I think for me, knowing I'm not going to use a yellow palette very often, I would get CP because of the price and possibility of getting it at a discount. Thanks so much for this video. Both looks were beautiful!
Midas does have discount codes as well so they only end up being a few dollar off from each other and their shipping was pretty low for me. Thank you for watching! 💛💛
Thanks for this video! The Lemonade wins, for me. 1st..I am passionate about supporting small business. 2nd..I dont think that the ColourPop mattes have enough depth. The mattes are too similar.
I feel the same about small businesses 😊
I totally agree. Supporting small businesses support dreams.
@@lightheidi9009 Your 100% right! Most of the time, a small business welcomes constructive, critiques. In my opinion, The Lemonade Palette was carefully curated. I really want to keep my eye on this brand 👍
Yup, same here plus that glitter in Colourpops aint nice, I wouldnt use it.
@@TheCupatcake I understand your feelings about the glitter. Some people wear it in the immediate eye area and dont have complications. Thats a personal choice. Personally, I have had an eye injury, from stuff getting in my eyes and I will not risk it.
I really need to see both on deeperskin tones before I can decide 😂😂😂
I understand. Sorry I couldn’t help with that ):
@@AmyLovesMakeup Not your fault my dear. I enjoyed seeing your video none the less! yellows are so a special case. They look so different depending on your skintone
Definitely! I’ve noticed even if you slightly change the undertone of the primer it will completely change a yellow.
Seeing them swatched side by side was really helpful. I love ColourPop eyeshadows and am disappointed that the pressed glitter isn’t eye safe. Cooler colors look better on me so I’m glad I decided on the Midas palette instead.
I’m glad I could help!!
I tried the Midas Cosmetic palette yesterday, and I’m in love. I have no yellows in my collection, so it definitely added something. Thank you for the comparison!
Mee too!!!🌟💛🌠❣️
I’m happy you love it!! I can’t wait to play with it more 💛
The minute you touched that shimmer yellow with a hint of blue I fell in love with it. Before even seeing how it looked like, just because you got so excited 😂 you probably already know this but the yellow glitter isn’t eye safe 💛
Haha I get a little too excited about shifts 😂😂
Yessss ! Best of both for the ultimate yellow look 💕🙌🏼
I love the way you phrased that!
Amy Loves Makeup 😭😭😭 it has a ring to it
I think the thing that I love the most out of your videos, is the fact that you describe the shades. A lot of you tubers show the shades on camera, but the camera does not do the shades justice. I feel it’s so important to see if there is a shift, if there is a dual chrome, or if they lean more yellow, more orange and someone. You do such a great job describing each of the shades and I love that about you! Your videos are very unique and I think you deserve a bigger audience!
SOOOO EXCITED FOR THIS VIDEO!!! I got the Midas palette but not the Colourpop so I’m dying to see the comparison!! 💛💛💛
So glad you’re excited!! I hope it’s helpful!! 💛
If I were to buy one I too would grab the Midas palette. We should support indie brands. You did an awesome job 😊
If palooza isn’t eye safe what are you supposed to do with it- put it on your shoulders. Maybe some people could use it as a highlight or put it around eyes for a costume look? I love that uh huh honey palette though and will probably still get it or maybe get the Midas one as well
Put it on your shoulders 😂😂 that made me laugh
I wish CP went more neon here instead of neutral. I do like come of the colors though.
Same!!
I do wish there was a Neon Yellow in the CP palette.
*WELCOME BACK!!!* 💞❣️💋🌟
PS. I'm 💯 here for *Midas Lemonade* !! It came yesterday & I love it. And I'm gifting my unused CP 🍯 uh huh honey.
The pressed glitters in palettes is really triggering me 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm refusing to purchase any palette from ANY brand if it has a pressed glitter at this point.
*** CP states on that palette that palooza is not intended for use on or near eyes...🤷
PS YOUR NAILS!🌟💅💛
Ugh that last part about it not being intended for the eyes.. that honestly makes me mad
@@AmyLovesMakeup it's just a bit disappointing in my opinion.. They have the ability to create gorgeous formulas. They have proven that so.... Why not give us a duo flip metallic or a super shock 🤷
@@lunagirl4039 a supershock would have been great. Actually anything that wasn't a pressed glitter if I'm being honest. Such a strange choice to put an 'unsafe for eyes' product in an eyeshadow palette. I know pressed pigments are also officially unsafe for eyes in the US but that's just because of staining, glitter is actually dangerous if it gets in your eyes.
@@minkg8178 my point exactly. I have enough eyes issues lol
when I was a kid I got shattered glass in my eyes-
so I am super weird with anything going in my eyes/on my actually eyeball. like I have to use special eye drops & still I am the biggest baby & I miss more than actually getting the meds into my eyes LOL.. getting my eyes dilated for an eye exam... ooof! my poor ophthalmologist & optometrist 🙄 for having to deal with my tantrum as a grown woman 🤣🤣😎
Great comparisons, I think the lemonade is a little more yellow I think I actually like it more . Great video 😊 🙏
It definitely is! Thanks for watching 😊
Midas wins all the way here. No dangerous glitter, small business, and B.O.B brand. I'd choose it over colourpop for sure.
Midas definitely won this round for me. I’m not into the pressed glitter in a palette situation with Colourpop or the plastic packaging. They actually sell that specific pressed glitter as a single shadow, so even if I liked pressed glitter and that really pretty duochrome, I would just get the glitter as a single and then get the Clionadh single you mentioned that’s a dupe for the duochrome shade (plus I LOVE Clionadh shimmers so that’s even better imo haha). Also, that pressed glitter is “not intended for use on or around the eye” so I’d rather avoid scratching my cornea 😬😬😬 But yes, awesome video! Your look came out amazing as always 💕
I think after finding out the pressed glitter is not eye safe the Lemonade is my winner as well but I could see how they would both work for different people 😊
💛 Thank you for the wonderful comparison... I think my colourpop palette should be arriving todayish!
Thanks Theresa! Can’t wait to see yours! 💛💛
So excited!! 🌻
I totally can see your point of view on your opinions on both palettes. Makes total sense. I guess it's always about what someone is going for and how much of a collection you always have already. Love your work😊💕
Yes I think they could both work and definitely have their own unique qualities.
I love the colourpop palette! Seems very wearable to me. Sadly its sold out, now that the 25% off sale started. Gonna wait til the next sale. Love your look!
Hopefully it restocks soon! And thank you 😊
Sale?? Damn it ...
What a fun video! I got the cp palette, but lemonade palette also looks amazing :)
Possibly the thing I most enjoy about this video is your enthusiasm! It seems pretty hard to choose one because together they cover a lot of yellows!
Thank you! I was so excited 💛💛
I'm SOOOO happy you're doing this---I was literally searching for reviews like this 2 days ago when the CP palette dropped. So thank you!
Happy I could help!! I rushed to get it up 😊
Hi, sweetie. I love your enthusiasm and your smile. Yay, two monochromatic yellow palettes!!!!!!! I can't wait to see what the differences are between the two. You're so beautiful!!!
Thank you you’re sweet!! Haha the sale made me want to grab some empty palettes but I’m holding out.
@@AmyLovesMakeup , you're welcome. I hear you. I have been on a no buy for June so I went ham yesterday. Hahaha. But, I bought stuff that I really, really wanted and stuff i had never tried before like the kaliedos palettes, and the whalesong.
I hope you love Whalesong!! I’m planning on trying it tomorrow! I can’t wait
@@AmyLovesMakeup, thanks, me, too.. I'm so excited for it to arrive.. lol. I hope you Enjoy playing around with yours. :)
Okay not only is this video great because you’re amazing but it has also shown me that I need to buy some softbox lighting because my video is SO reflective that it’s a little tough to see my swatches. So thank you for helping with my setup too!! 😂😂😂
I definitely recommend the softbox lights! They are so flattering and bright and I got both of mine for like $50 😊 Happy I could help!
liking this before the video even plays because i love the idea of comparing two similar toned palettes :)
Thanks 😊
I just got my Lemonade palette and I adore it! It is on the “sour” side of yellow, but the darkest shade has this beautiful greenish-olive undertone that allows me to create true chartreuse color when mixed with the yellow....just adore it!
I can see that 😊 So happy you love it too!
So excited about this video! I decided to order Lemonade first and hope for a comparison ... I think I can go without CP’s palette even though I have five of their
monochromatic palettes...
I hope you love lemonade!! 💛
This is just the kind of video I was waiting for. Thank you so much Amy!!!
You’re welcome 💛💛
I think the cp palette would be unique in my collection I don’t have very many yellow shades
This video came just in time. I was debating which palette to get and you helped me make my decision. I hope you had a great vaca.
What did you decide?? 😊 And thank you!
@@AmyLovesMakeup I've decided to go with the Midas Lemonade palette. The CP Honey palette has too many non-yellow colors.
Aww well I hope you love the Lemonade!! I can’t wait to do more looks with it 💛💛
So excited you did this comparison. I tried the Midas pallet this morning and love it. I was wondering if I was missing out on the colorpop one but now I know I made the right choice.
Happy I could ease your mind! I think if I only had to pick one for me I would choose Lemonade too 😊
I think using both palettes together will be awesome! I, too, ordered both. Can't wait!
I’m going to have to do that! And I hope you love them!
Aww even your nail polish is yellow, so cute :)
Love matching! 💛💛
that was a great idea! from here, colourpop looks more mustard and makes your eye look bigger. I do like the midas better and the glitter is a deal-breaker for me. but both look pretty on you.
I’d love to see your perfect yellow palette with singles!
Funny you say that.... 😉
Thank you for comparing these two palettes! Was so curious to see what different between them. Bought the ColourPop but after seeing this video, think I’ll get the Midas as well. There’s a difference in the weight listed here (from the box) versus what’s on their websites. Midas has the weight on their website now, almost at the bottom of the page as net weight 0.63 ounces (0.07 ounce/pan) versus ColourPop’s website weight as .03 ounces/pan. Midas is the better deal. Plus I wanted a more pure yellow palette. 😊💙💙
Dang it my horrible eye sight I thought the .03 was .08 😅 I’ll update the description box. Thanks for the correction 💛
Welcome back 🤗Lovely palettes,but the colors in the lemonade palette seem more versatile plus there’s no pressed glitter in it (my eyes are bit sensitive),so it’s more appealing to me.
One side's cooler lemon lime neon. The other is warmer - like honey! I prefer the Colourpop one
Thank you. I was waiting to see someone do this. You did a great job showcasing both.
I have the color pop one I'm ordering the midas one and the love from midas looks beautiful I have a yellow eyeshadow problem
How does the formula measure up to the beloved Banana shade in the Slush Palette? 🤔
I will keep you updated 💛
Great comparison! The Midas one has definitely more depth to it. Drives me crazy if a palette does not have a shade to create depth. 😅 Also I love how the yellow in the Midas one are more cool toned.
I think in this specific situation it’s hard because people were asking for a full yellow palette so Colourpop gave them what they asked for. I personally think a rich deep brown would have added well to the Uh Huh Honey Palette (and I don’t say that often lol)
I was interested to see you do this comparasion. As a fellow redhead, I tend to avoid yellow because I'm concerned it will make me look ill. It looks beautiful on you, and it gives me more confidence to try to mix in some yellow into my looks. I don't think I'll get either palette, but I might get the Clionadh Soul when they reopen their store.
I honestly love yellow. I used to always have people tell me what I should wear based on my red hair and it drove me crazy. I just wear whatever I want now 😊💛
I've ordered the Uh huh honey palette from Colourpop last night. I can't wait to see how those shades look on my skintone. What a great content for a video Amy. I hope you had a fun vacation💛.
I hope that they work for you!! Thank you 💛
This is a great comparison Amy. I just received my Colourpop palette and now I wish I had known about the other one instead. But I'll work it out, LOL! Thanks for the video.
Thanks Kalmele! I can’t wait to see your thoughts on the Colourpop palette 💛
Very pretty palettes!!!! Every time you talk about inner corner shades , I always would put them in my lid . Lol .. Thanks for the reviews ( I like the look you came up with today) 🌸💕🌸👍🏻
This was such a helpful video! I was kinda tempted by the Colourpop palette but something stops me buying from them every time. I’d never heard of Midas but their palette has more range & depth & if I was buying a yellow palette that’s the one I think 🤔. Your nails even match! Love your dedication to your channel 💛😘
So happy I could share the Midas with you! They’re getting more popular and seem to have a really sweet owner! And thank you 😊💛
I feel like with yellows you can't get enough variation between shades. Go pale and you end up with a straight up cream. Dark yellow is basically just brown. Warm toned yellow is orange and cool toned is pretty much green. I know you can have variations on yellow but honestly not enough to make a 9 pan palette without incorporating different colours that are just strongly yellow toned...Then again, I know people would then get upset they weren't 100% yellow so the only option is to have a lot of veeeeeeeery similar shades together :/ A yellow toned grungey palette would be awesome though!
I feel the same way. I wasn’t necessarily expecting a full nine yellow shades. It made sense for this one to have accents 😊
Thank you for th comparison. I've been hesitant about a yellow palette because I'm not sure how it would look on me, but I'm really liking the different tones in the Colourpop one. The Lemonade palette not only seems more cool toned, but I feel like the depth of most of the yellows are pretty similar with the exception of the brown-based color. For only $12, I might pull the trigger.
I think yellow can be such a great accent shade so for $12 even if you don’t use it alone it can add a lot to other colors 😊
@@AmyLovesMakeup That's a really good point. You're sold me on it!
New subscriber! Annette from Annette’s Makeup Corner recommended you and I’m glad to have found another honest fun makeup loving channel to watch! Thanks
Aww thanks for coming over! Love Annette 😊
I never heard of Midas before, thank you for the comparison swatches 😘
You’re welcome 😊
This is such a great video idea! I ordered the Colourpop palette & I can’t wait to try it 😊 the Midas palette looks beautiful also 😍
Thanks Kellie 💛
Loved this video! It was super awesome seeing how these both perform in comparison! Both looks turned out beautifuuul!
Thank you!! I’m so inspired by the look you posted on IG yesterday! Think I’ll defiantly have to recreate that with the Midas palette 💛
Literally 1 minute into your video and I love your vibe. had to subscribe, thank you for being so lowkey and happy to watch!
I'm actually wearing yellow eyeshadow today! With red lipstick - pretty intense, but I like the combo 😁
That sounds pretty actually!! 😊
Thank you for the comparisons, Midas is really enticing me with their last two palettes💛🍯
They’re definitely doing something right! Can’t wait to see what they do next 😊
I was seriously wanting on this video sooo ty 💛💛💛💛💛
Btw I love the way you’re comparing on each eye! 👏👏👏
Thanks Jessica!!
My Colourpop Uh Huh Honey came in today and I'm so excited!!! I hadn't bought any affordable eyeshadows in years until the Colourpop sweet talk came out months ago and I've gotten almost all their palettes since!!(Disney villains but it wasn't my thing and I returned it, main squeeze, blue moon, ooh la la, California love...) I'm so happy they make affordable amazing high quality palettes. I literally can't stand to pay for Sephora priced eyeshadows anymore and I used to work at Sephora JCP!
I’m glad you like their formula!! Gotta love when something is affordable and works perfect for you 😊
@@AmyLovesMakeup yes! And it's awesome that they have after-pay as well and Instagram pay with free shipping and no taxes. I also loved your video, you got a new subscriber!
Sweet, so I definitely want the colourpop
This was so fun! I'd definitely go for the Midas palette. I already have Sol and Palooza is also available as a single (but I never use glitter anyway). The other shades in Uh Huh Honey seem a bit lackluster, so I'll pass!
Yes I think the Lemonade Palette and sol as a single would be a winner combo! 💛💛
Is the Color Pop Honey Palette comparable to the Juvia's place Warrior Palette?
I wouldn’t say so. Warrior is much less yellow and lots of true rich golds.
Love this idea to compare the two, thank you for this!
Thanks for watching it 😊
Really enjoyed watching your comparisons of these palettes, Amy, and the beautiful look you created using each. Definitely agree the Midas has more depth & the chunky pressed glitter in the Colourpop palette would definitely be a deal- breaker for me. I don't wear a lot of yellow, but do have a few in my collection (probably enough to make do). Still, if I was in the market, Midas would win! 😊 💖 👍🏻 🥉
Thank you I’m glad you liked it. I could get past the glitter when I thought it was eye safe but now it would be a deal breaker for me too. Very disappointed.
@@AmyLovesMakeup, exactly! And as others have said, there's probably no glitter that's really considered "eye-safe" , but my understanding is that when the particles are round (spheres) & smaller, there's a chance that your eyes can flush them out naturally more easily as opposed to the big, chunky stuff. I don't wear contacts, but if I did, I definitely wouldn't touch anything glittery with a 10-foot barge pole in regards to my eyes. Mercy! 🙀
scotzmnswife yeah I believe so too. I didn’t know that none were technically considered eye safe. I bought a pressed glitter shadow when trying a new brand for July and I feel like an idiot now 🙈😂
@@AmyLovesMakeup, well you shouldn't feel stupid, as when something is marketed as a glitter shadow (or is a pressed glitter stuck into the middle of an eyeshadow palette), it is misleading customers into thinking it is meant for the eyes, with most people presuming it is safe to use in the eye area. Frankly, I don't think companies should be allowed to market unsafe glitters in conjunction with eye products/palettes, as it gives some customers a false sense of security. If McDonald's can lose a lawsuit for selling coffee that's too hot (despite their disclaimer on the cup), I'm thinking one of these cosmetics companies is just waiting to get the pants sued off of them. All it takes is one customer having a serious eye injury, & their disclaimer on the package will mean zilch in a court of law.
The Midas collection shades looked too similar to each other until the final 3 shades. The CP seemed a little more varied in color....💛🧡💛
Thank you for this comparison! I have the CP palette and was wondering if this was worth it!
Glad you had fun a vacation! 🤗🥰🤗
Thank you 😊
I've been looking for this video!! Thank you so much for making it.
Glad you found it! 😊
I really like this video, I have no yellows and I'm a bit scared of them - I have very pink skin so not sure how it'll look - but I think I might add 'uh huh honey' to my list of palettes to choose from after Christmas. I might even depot it and just keep 1 or 2 yellows (especially that blue-yellow) and give the rest away :) Thanks so much for such a detailed review - this has been really helpful!
I think it could be fun to try! I don’t really allow my undertones to stop me from using any colors that I want to. I think if you feel confident in it and love it that’s what matters and what makes it look good 😊
@@AmyLovesMakeup Thanks Amy! I think I will try it, if I don't like all the yellows I think the yellow-blue as an inner corner colour on a blue look will still look nice! Thanks for the encouragement :D
I’m so excited for this video! As soon as I saw the Colourpop palette come out I was waiting for you to do a video! 💛
I’m happy you’re excited 💛💛
Great video, thank you for the comparisons. I think I want both
Thanks for watching!! 😊
I didn't love the Uh Huh Honey as much as I was hoping to!
Welcome back from vacation! Hope you enjoyed yourself!!!
Thank you I did 💛
I was waiting for someone to do this video!
the midas palette has more actual yellow shades. so I'd pick that one myself xx
Ahh you got me thinking that my skin will turn the colourpop ones into orange lol I think my undertones are definitely not right for that one buttttt it’s going to be delivered today so I’m still excited ! Thank you always Amy 💛
Don’t judge it until you try it!! I hope you end up loving it 😊
Amy Loves Makeup yeah! Keeping my hopes up for it 💕💕
Yes use both please.
SO EXCITED FOR THIS ONE!
Yay!!
I like how you're doing this video of comparisons. Keep doing these..🥰🥰
Thanks! 💛
@@AmyLovesMakeup welcome💚
Midas wins this one for me! 💛
You look gorgeous in yellow! 😍
That glitter in the Colourpop palette is such a fail for me and a waste of space. Why would they include not eye safe glitter in the eyeshadow palette?!?! 🤔😣
I think Midas wins for me too! Definitely a fail on their end 🤦♀️
The glitter shade is not intended for use in the immediate eye area. Hope Colourpop can do another version without glitter
Thank you for this. Usually yellows and golds on youtube are used by people with darker skin tones. It's not common to find someone more fair skinned.
🌟Thank you for this video!!! You have a beautiful glow, I'm sure vacation was so good!!! ☀️💖😘
Thank you! It was so much fun! Plus lots of good food 😂❤️
RawBeautyKristi use the Cp glitter shade and she mentioned it was hurting her eye & it’s not eye safe! I was thinking that a lot of shades say that , but she was seriously wondering why they put that in the palette and she thinks the glitter may have irritated her eye! She used the sweet talk palette which has the pressed glitter in it , but that one she had no issues with. I herd Cp pressed glitter formula is better than most pressed glitters but something about the huge chunky glitter is why it could scratch the eye. Idk I ordered it but afraid to use the pressed glitter! Oh and it’s an existing shade that Cp already has.
I have to watch her video on it. I completely agree with her. Hopefully Colourpop will listen to this feedback.
And it’s not even like a normal pressed glitter. It’s chunky.
Before i even watch i have already got Uh huH honey. Got Midas Lemonade today (earlier than estimated delivery) can't wait to try it!!!
Nice!! Yellow lovers unite 😂💛
I'm not huge fan of yellow shades and still enjoyed the comparison
I have the colourpop one on its way to me... I know I won’t use yellow all that often so I went with the cheaper one!
Totally understandable 😊
Lovely video, great idea!
Thanks!
I have so many wishes for these palettes. I wish the CP one was in a more environmentally friendly packaging and that the glitter was actually both eye and earth safe. To have a not eye safe glitter right in the center means I’m buying eight shadows and a placeholder, not 9 shadows. And I kind of feel like the Midas palette has four of almost the same matte yellows. I wish that there was more variation there.
And I think that at this point I’ve bought so many shadows that I do have these shades, albeit not in one place. I kind of wish that instead of a green palette with pops of yellow, I wish that Blush Tribe had released a yellow palette with pops of green. Sigh. Maybe this is all saving me money.
I’m really hoping someone does a Grunge mix of greens and yellows! Fingers crossed!! And yeah I feel the same on your thoughts on CP.
The Midas mattes i actually feel like yes they’re all yellow but they their own variety. I quite like them.
I want Midas to do an all red and all black
Can you do 3 looks with the flamingo palette, and if you could only recommend buying two violet voss palettes which would they be?
I’m not sure if I will. I used the flamingo for my shop my stash in June and I have some thoughts on it. I might carry June’s products through July because I’m off schedule.
One more point to put out there, and maybe you touch on it, I haven’t finished watching yet, but Midas is a black-owned makeup brand, and so if that’s important to your viewers (well, aside from the fact that they might already know), it seemed worthwhile to emphasize that.
Yes I did mention they’re a small indie brand and woc owned 😊💛
Your excitement made me all excited for these palettes. They are our kryptonite gal! LoL. 😂😂😂💸💸💰💰💵💵😂😂😂 Now I want these. . . LoL. I can totally get behind these both. . . And to validate my future purchases of these Coldplay's "Yellow" started playing at Illinois Cancercare while I am sitting with my mom. . . LoL.
Haha I’m a mess because I would justify two yellow palettes.. but I swear they’re different 😂😂
And I’m sorry I hope your mom is okay! 😞
@@AmyLovesMakeup It's OK Amy I too am on the mess express. LoL. I don't have too many yellows in my collection. So these would both fulfill a need/gap. . . Thank you she's a tough ole bird --- her name is Robin. ❤❤❤❤ She's fighting. So we have hope and great medical care. 😊
pretty earrings