@@默默-z1b Still, Yoga Lin is the original singer. Who writes the song is not necessarily the same as who sings it best. I think most people agree on that. That's why we need reaction to the original singer.
I'm not complaining, jazz is my favorite genre and I really like this performance, but... are you only interested in Chinese singers who sing like Westerners, or could we have a little more reactions to Chinese singers singing like Chinese singers ? Could you try for example "Farewell My Concubine" with Yang Chi and Huo Zun (霸王别姬霍尊杨赤) ?
I agree with you but if she listens to actual Chinese singers singing traditionally she's just going to be confused. Watching her commenting on Chinese singers is like watching a kung fu master watching a Western boxer and saying the boxer needs improvement because the horse stance not stable enough. 😂
@@alhkcblack9617 This is obviously likely, but failing to express a well-founded criticism, she could discover new ways of using the voice and that would be enriching for her.
It will be better to do comparison with Yoga Lin and Tiger Hu. It is a little boring, because James Li is more famous in song-writing than his vocal skill
敲碗林宥嘉!!!
很喜欢多才多艺的李泉,一种桀骜不驯的随性感,他的歌是那种你可以一个人在一个小剧场,或小酒吧,端着一杯烈酒又或是鸡尾酒🍸,身体随着他的节奏摇曳,慢慢细品,很有松弛感,赞👍
還以為會跟林宥嘉的版本比較:)
Actually feel that recently Coach has been more and more careful about her critics on performances. As a result, less and less negative comments.
They are trying to meet as many requests as possible. It becomes less value added. Will also give most of them a miss.
想看林宥嘉,點評男歌手怎麼可以缺少林宥嘉
希望能看到 YOGA LIN!
+1敲碗林宥嘉!!!!!!!!!
Yoga Lin is the original singer of the song.
歌是李泉写的
@@默默-z1b Still, Yoga Lin is the original singer. Who writes the song is not necessarily the same as who sings it best. I think most people agree on that. That's why we need reaction to the original singer.
很認同老師的觀點!
可以敲碗林宥嘉嗎? 🤭
太帅了
希望可以聽聽原唱歌曲
林宥嘉
一看9成认为这歌手是上海人,特别能装很享受很高级很绅士的感觉,像极了周立波的风格。
他是上海人,从小在钢琴室长大,都在音乐学院系统里小中大学里上完课,又在音乐学院当教授,一辈子阳春白雪,是装吗?承认别人和你不一样粗糙,是不是很难。
说李泉的风格像周立波?作为一个上海人我有礼貌的笑了。都不在一个平行宇宙好吗。
@@justinbao369 吃汉堡要用刀叉那种。一个搞音乐一个脱口秀而已。
Yoga
可以敲碗林宥嘉嗎❤
徐佳瑩,A-LIN,Yoga
都放李泉的版本了,林宥嘉为什么被忽略了?是男up主个人不喜欢林宥嘉吗😂😂开个玩笑。强烈想看林宥嘉!!!!!!
这歌是李泉写的
300多將近400個評論視頻,竟然沒有林宥嘉,是故意忽略吧!?哈哈哈哈哈...
@@suesue8920 应该是。我猜是因为林宥嘉的唱法完全和他们的理念相反。但林宥嘉又长的很好。很难评论他。可能听完只能说一句话well,他唱的很好,但不是我喜欢的风格。我猜大概是这样
@@默默-z1b 我覺得最有可能是你之前說的男up主不喜歡他,不過不重要啦!😆
@@suesue8920 男up主是嫉妒我们林宥嘉的才貌双全吗😂
給我林宥嘉吧🙏
I'm not complaining, jazz is my favorite genre and I really like this performance, but... are you only interested in Chinese singers who sing like Westerners, or could we have a little more reactions to Chinese singers singing like Chinese singers ? Could you try for example "Farewell My Concubine" with Yang Chi and Huo Zun (霸王别姬霍尊杨赤) ?
I agree with you but if she listens to actual Chinese singers singing traditionally she's just going to be confused. Watching her commenting on Chinese singers is like watching a kung fu master watching a Western boxer and saying the boxer needs improvement because the horse stance not stable enough. 😂
@@alhkcblack9617 This is obviously likely, but failing to express a well-founded criticism, she could discover new ways of using the voice and that would be enriching for her.
唱爵士風格歌曲的人很多,其實不是誰模仿誰,所以像誰又像誰?而是採用爵士歌曲的技巧類型唱的人多了,很難不用到和某人相近的唱腔唱法,即使是爵士歌曲的唱法通常很隨性自由,也免不了某些歌曲段落的相似性!很多都被誤解成是誰模仿了誰,其時很多時候演唱者或許根本不知道他們所說的誰,更何況是那誰的唱法唱腔?歌曲千千萬萬,旋律與唱法若都刻意要避開不與前人前曲有相似之處,做到獨一無二的唱腔唱法和旋律?我猜地球上那麼“獨特”的歌手少之又少?包括你們甚至你們所熟知的九成九男女超級國際天王天后都做不到!😂😂😂
We haven't watched ghost for a long time. When can we have her video?
YOU MAY WANT TO LISTEN TO FILIPINO SINGER JOINED SINGER 2018 SHE'S KZ TANDINGAN SHE DOESNT BELT BUT U WILL BE AMAZED🥰🥰🥰
怎麼不放林宥嘉的版本🥲
這首歌的原唱不是林宥嘉嗎?怎麼沒給老師一起評,太可惜了!
詞曲原唱是李泉
@@zhouannie9561 《眼色》是李泉為林宥嘉創作的第一首歌,收錄於林宥嘉2008年發行的專輯《神秘嘉賓》。
我反而覺得他不用顫音是維持某種清冷感,尤其是典型30/40年代爵士太多顫音了,他處理得很有自己的個性
老师最后的评论是李不太会颤音,😊博主最后也说了李泉是个作曲人,😊
@@user-xili 顫音只是一種審美和選擇,不要用這個去框架歌手,老師也說自己有自己的取向。麻煩大家如果不是專業的,不要看一個解讀影片就只學會了一種觀點。自己獨立思考吧
@@broca1279 不会和不用(处理)是两个不同的结论,😀
阿云嘎(希拉草原)🙏
阿云嘎的唱功在年轻歌手中真是顶级的。而且还有深厚的舞蹈底子,舞台感特强。
@@awesomeexpressionexp 好想聽老師點評😃可惜還未有回音😅
應該評一下林宥嘉的
黄丽领 / 李佳薇 pleaseee
朱桦的好听
好膩😂
please react to KZ Tandingan cover of the song "Rolling in the deep". by Adele in the same competition Singer 2018
还有曾比特,炎明熙,A-lin和毛不易,应该轮到他们了吧?
毛不易的好友周深有了,毛不易的伯乐薛之谦有了,毛不易的恩师李健有了,毛不易的CP单依纯有了,连毛不易的“宿敌”华晨宇也有了。毛不易真的应该有了。
毛不易的粉丝也在敲碗了@@awesomeexpressionexp
he is professor of Shanghai music university,he can not allow himself vbr like pop singger
i guess
Plss react to kz tandingan...rolling in the deep...from philippines in that same stage also...
太刻意了,可以唱的自然一點嗎?
It will be better to do comparison with Yoga Lin and Tiger Hu.
It is a little boring, because James Li is more famous in song-writing than his vocal skill
pls react to KZ tandingan's Rolling in the deep
李泉本來就是原唱,之後有多人翻唱,我還是喜歡李泉
李泉不是原唱
@@canacecheng9874這首本來就是李泉的歌吧
@@tiahsian7014 李泉和小林作词,李泉作曲,但原唱是林宥嘉,收录在林宥嘉的专辑
jazz不需要用力唱….
Jazz怎麼不需要用了,所有風格都需要維持共鳴和平衡,張力和釋放都是用身體擴張的力量啊
那只是你的狭隘的认知
是太刻意做作了!
李泉比林宥嘉強太多了 拜託
唱的太难听了😂
難聽
唱得太刻意,不自然
boring singer who isn't that great either
以为自己很爵士。
何時換王心凌?
得了吧...他的聲音都是修出來的...