SOOOO I talked to someone who is professional at mixing vocals. He told me it sounds like live pre-recorded vocals in a studio and than lip synced on set to those live pre record. So basicly the same thing that I said, I just thought they may took the audio from the mics on set and mixed that with the pre record :D
Even if that someone is correct , what you saw is SK's version of a music show live performance. YG delivered what you would see if BM performed in a SK music show, as requested by the fans. I think they sang live with a backtrack sound. Most groups lip sync. Not justifying, it is what it is. If you want pure live performance with a band, you have to watch their concert (hopefully soon). You are disappointed because your expectations are way off the roof this time.
Bro ITs not that deep lmfao. Enjoy the girls performance why are you so gung ho about some damn pre recorded or live when BP does the same shit. You’re whack LOL
Of course they sing live. There are two sounds, namely the backtrack sound and the vocal sounds of the members singing live. The members' original voices are above the backtrack and the volume of their live voices sounds greater. Their mic is on, that's the point. If you are kpop fans, you will know this video is like a music show on Inkigayo or Music Bank. The video had been pre-recorded but when the video was taken all the members sang live even though there were back vocals too. If you are looking forward to a real live performance then just look forward to their concerts or when they perform at award shows like MAMA, AAA, GDA, or MMA. ** this is a live performance but not real time. but all the members actually sing, not lip sync.
Yes , almost all idols do that when singing live on stage , there are even some agencies that don't allow their idols to sing live , the idol will lipsync from the beginning to the end of the song , there is nothing disappointing about babymonster's performance , they sing live so well, their energy and voices are so beautiful.
Yes, it is 'live', but it was certainly recorded many times, and then in post production nicely edited. Anyone familiar with K-pop knows that this is normal for them. If you think otherwise, it means you must believe in Santa Claus. This 'double track' is a fact. But 'double track' was recorded many, many times and they chose the best version (after all, they won't do otherwise ;) ) and still in post production they could improve something.
@@coman6143This is the same as a music show system such as Inkigayo or Music Bank, they take repeated videos, then there is a backtrack vocal, finally there is live vocal from the group singing + dancing and they do this repeatedly. babymonster have done well and this is their first stage, I look forward to their future performances by performing at award shows like MAMA or others.
@@Jennieee199 if you hear it for the first time , it seems like it’s not live , but if you hear it couple of time , you will realize that it’s live , you can hear the difference.
@@narcisfedor6316 ikr they are so talented and there is nothing wrong with having backtrack like why these people taking so serious when we say they are having backtrack and not really 💯 live...
@@jasperalc to be honest ..baemon are better singers than them...Sandara voice is not taken seriously in she was known as krung krung and her songs are novelty ..same standard as ocho ocho and Pamela one!
I'm not sure about the others but I'm confident that Ruka is 100% rapping live. Her raw voice can be heard clearly, and it's different from the MV. I even zoomed the video and her mouth, dance and rap truly matches.
Or it's like he said; playback of their live vocals. You can also see how Rukas mic is sometimes well below her chin due to head movements but that doesn't affect the volume of her voice which it should. This is a very common thing in kpop especially with 4th gen idol groups. This is a problem to blame the companies for, not the idols.
Asa and Chiquita sound exactly like the record one (They ate CD that’s why🥲), it’s understandable if you think they are lip syncing. But Ruka, Haram, Rora, and Pharita sound really different from og track for example the difference weight in some words it’s so clear that they are singing lives.
I personally don't think so. Although Asa's voice doesn't sound as Rae as Ruka's but that's just how her voice is no? Like.... we have already seen in their pre debut days. But regardless of that, you can still hear Asa improvising at some points. Also in the 'volume up light em up' part, you can clearly hear her take a breath and singing in a slightly modified tune than the actual tune (note it- modified tune as in changed tune which blends in well with the actual tune; not completely out of tune). For ex- in the beginning of her rap, the actual song has precise Korean accent but here her voice sounds a bit more high pitched and kinda Hyunsuk-coded as im having a stylistic, stretchy and 'western-y' accent approach.
@@iainturbarbie1101 Right? They say they don't care, but then they clicked on a video that made it obvious what he was going to say (titled "I'm disappointed") and then left butthurt comments. 🤣🤣
Its not easy to sing,rap live while you are dancing that kind of steps,you may catch your breath,stop criticising them,just enjoy and watch whatever they do,
Why do you dare to raise yourself as the norm? The song is only 3 minutes long. Divide the singing part among 6 people. Each of them didn't sing a lot. And the songs are not difficult to sing, have high notes or difficult notes that require the use of energy. It's funny how you make yourself the deciding factor.
Ikr! People should not expect so much from a newly debuted group while most of the 4th gen group( 3-4 yr. Experienced) can't even sing and lip-sync all the time even when they are just standing straight. Lol No hate and I am not mentioning anyone.
I think this is just your first time watching a kpop idol singing live. If you watch more of inkigayo or music bank contents, you’ll see that they always do the mixing of live vocals and having the MR while singing. Even Blackpink and other Kpop groups do that when they are performing live. Mixing of live vocals while having the MR is common in kpop live shows, since many idols have difficulty singing while dancing to intense choreography.
You can be disappointed but don't be too confident in saying this, this is an opportunity for the haters. Congratulations, you have opened the way for more haters for BabyMonster. Some people even pretend to know that their dancing is a mess instead of saying they agree with your opinion. In the end, your reaction becomes a field for haters to blaspheme Babymonster, are you satisfied? because I still hear them singing live. Even though the backtrack sound is loud, I'm sure they sing live.
people will always see something wrong to criticize, enjoy the video and the girls charisma instead of being paying attention on how their sound, and their mic, omg
He wasn't even criticizing tho!! Like he was literally saying he was disappointed that they didn't really do it live because yg idols is literally known for stage presence and live powerful vocals like bp, big bang, 2ne1, Y'all really making deal out of honest video review..like chill no one hating on bm
@@yoshinori-cq8jithere is literally a live recorded in the backtrack like yes their mic is on but they sang some part but didn't sang in most especially pharita and chiquita in the first it's so obvious..
Why should we support them when YG gives them no comebacks and they are doing the same to them on what they did with 2ne1 and Blackpink?!!! You are just giving YG more money!
Giving valid criticism is not the same as not supporting them. If nobody voice their displeasure with YG's direction with a "live performance" like this, it will end up being all we get.
BABYMONSTER antis might be happy seeing your reaction why can't you just enjoy, if it doesn't reach your expectation also you don't have to act that way saying you're disappointed and such they're just a new group such a small things can effect their images so much also they're singing live and play backtrack at the same time and we all know that this is not new in kpop we all know they have the hardest dance steps that needs so much energy...if you want to sing them with raw vocals then watch their vocals performance!! how can they sing while jumping and dancing like that they're not a robot
When I watched this video I was shocked by their live voice like indeed they got best live vocals n rap like I can clearly hear their all raw vocals except the outro. 90% they sang live I have no idea what u r saying I think its because they’re are too good n u just can’t believe it. I listen to it for 20 times n 90% is raw vocal 10% are outro n some Chiquita n haram part which is 2%
They used backtrack, and their backtrack is live AR, but they are singing live too but some part are not, esp when part are hard with dance. And thats understandable because this video live performance for youtube, not a concert. Well for me honestly as fan of YG since 2008, I'm very uncomfortable with your words about YG. BABYMONSTER not even a month since debut and what? You disappointed? Lol. Just know you said "if you are YG fans follow my channel" If you are YG fans please spread love n support about YG group. BABYMONSTER is a new group but already have hater, haters will be happy with ur opinion on this video. If you are truly YG fans.
@@shar12ja49 only finding out now? 😂 he loves BP and it stops there. He appreciates few YG grps (may be or may be not 🤔), too naive to call himself a YG stan. From what i have seen he just knows them, nothing more nothing less. Im not saying u shld know 100% to stan an artist or a grp, u can criticize u can be disappointed, etc., but when u say stan u just express things n a diff way even if u complain u wont shut the video on their face. I don know, whenevrr i saw him reacting to any YG grps excluding BP it seems like he doesn enjoy as much he claims! Well, i may be wrong but thats how i feel. Finally, i don think he "stans" stans them....
I think it's a live performance, but it's not 100% vocal, maybe because they have to dance to the fullest, that's understandable, even if it's a little disappointing.
@rwo4h9 I can agree they don’t sound the best but my point is they are live, I prefer to hear the raw and real if they are going to be live. I do however also love a full choreography lip syncing performance!
i don’t think all of them sang live. there are no movements in their voice that are indicative of live singing, especially since they’re dancing as well! it’s most likely pre-recorded, but they delivered nonetheless.
this is the exact same thing that happened to BLACKPINK 7 years ago, accused of just lip syncing. you will not succeed in destroying BM. And we don't care if you're disappointed
idk but its clearly live, you can hear it if you really pay attention to it or watch it more times. like of course there is a back track but its really hard without it when they are dancing this much so i dont see the problem with that.
How can you say they not singing live, I can hear some part they sound different with recording, yes they do have backtrack on it, and BP also use it in their performance. Backtrack always use in kpop live stage. But we still can hear they singing live..
They forget that BM is a rookie group. They expect too much from this group, some criticizing them for not being good, not being in the charts, not being par w/ all the expectations surrounding them bcoz they're from "yg". No. Kpop Idols regardless of what agency they are are humans and not robots they cannot all be the time perfect and not all the time cater all your demands. The members did their best for this debut and some people are just so negative and hateful which is so below the belt already.
@@Jennieee199of course there is a backtrack but their live sound is above the backtrack and the volume of their live sound is greater. Their mic is on, that's the point.
@@dwiwi8326 that's what I'm saying too they are singing but there was some backtrack... nothin said anything about them not singing or mic not being on..just said there back track..
Am i the only one who did hear their live voice/vocals? Haram and Pharita is so obvious also the rappers. Same with chiquita and rora, the problem was the backtrack is louder in their parts. But if you focus and did not just watched it once you will eventually gonna realize it. There is a difference in the weight of the words and sound when they sing on their parts and when not. If you are doubting then make your own mr remove of their performance. Anyways i know they can serve and slay if they did it in an actual live performance (like awards shows/festival/concert).
I listen to the clean ver of their live performance. They all sang their parts well and all of them are very stable compare to other rookie groups. Maybe that's the reason why you cant hear them and thinks its not live. Their vocals are live.
there are no movements in their voice, though.. no matter how stable you are, singing and dancing at the same time you are bound to hear those movements while singing, but you can’t in this performance.
@@alyanah if you try to listen to the clean version of their live you can hear them catching their breath and its shaky too but still I can say its stable.
@@Anlin00 maybe the "ohhh" part because it was hard to stable with that choreography though but she still sang the rest of the part. Try checking the clean version ☺️
Why ASA now looks so pretty 😂 she is like visual of the group right now, suddenly forgot she is rapper 😊 she grow up well ❤ love you asa, i think you got my attention.
We can confirm now its LIVE..just check out Batter Out LIVE Performamce behind the scenes..the girls practice this song backstage n they sound exactly like in the cd..thanks
Bruuhh... I MISSED THE TIMES WHEN YG ARTISTS doesn't conform to the strict dancing. That's the reason why I love YG so much! The adlibs and live singing is on another level, especially the one who is singing their part, its not a strict choreo. Just like BIGBANG, 2NE1, WINNER, IKON. That's why I'm disappointed on LIVE performances for Blackpink, Treasure and now Baemon. At least the 3 rappers of Treasure does the typical YG adlib antics sometimes.
The way I hear it... Rora, Rami, Ruka and Asa sang 100% live. Pharita like 90% live and Chiquita like... 60-70%? and yes, the dance break was totally playback, but that's normal cause it's a dance break, they're supposed to dance, not sing. However, I do agree with you that getting a 100% live performance would be nice. But for that to happen, they have to compromise dancing. Can't jump like that and sound perfect.
THIS CHANNEL IS TELLING ALL THE TRUTH, IF YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT IS SINGING LIVE, JUST WATCH MAMAMOO & NMIXX MR REMOVED. WE KNOW BM ARE TALENTED BUT THIS IS PRERECORDED, INCREASED YOUR KNOWLEDGE BEFORE JUDGING OF PEOPLE.
I’ve watched vocal coaches state moving while singing is extremely, extremely hard. While some are better than others it seems most artists have prerecorded or backtrack vocals playing while dancing or doing any sort of movements. Unless you just want them to stand there, this is what you’re going to get. I don’t mind it, personally I’ve spent many a nights trying to sing Michael Jackson and dancing and you can barely get a sound out after like 10 seconds lol.
Why do you dare to raise yourself as the norm? The song is only 3 minutes long. Divide the singing part among 6 people. Each of them didn't sing a lot. And the songs are not difficult to sing, have high notes or difficult notes that require the use of energy. It's funny how you make yourself the deciding factor.
then they should've not called the video a "live performance" if most of what we will hear are backtrack vocals. NMIXX's stage practices will put this to shame.
They are dancing while singing and rapping and still giving their best ..god ...they were trainees for more than 4 years practicing how to sing live while dancing ....... Were you there ...to be pretty sure that they are having playbacks
Bro this is k-pop. Everything is under control. All groups sings with the original pitch behind. Don't wait an authentic song singed at least it is a balad 🫡
I completely agree with you Duke!💪 I think they should’ve let us listen to actually live vocals and not pre recorded. If they really want to show their artists and let us know that Babymonster is capable, they should try harder
It is not that "they didn't let them sing live", because they are clearly singing. It's the editing that made it this way. Plus, this is live performance, which you might not be accepting because you are thinking about "live singing". What I mean is, this is what they deem as live performance. Or do you want them to not use the performance they work hard to prepare just because you want them to hold mic and minimize dancing?
For any part that everyone's voices put together like that, in this case outro, it's 100% normal to not sing live or sing quietly to not make it sound bad. Every group do it like that. For chorus, groups often sing softer than normal or not sing at all to focus on dance to increase overall performance quality. They just put on loud backtrack for this performance, so it didn't sound that raw, which fits the song. They sang live but chose where to sing loudly or quietly. For example, for Chiquita first part, it should not be sang louder than the backtrack or it will sound off. Also with that dance move, her voice is sure to be shaky no matter what, so they might not let her sing at all. For part like Rami's or Pharita's first part, it fits to sing strongly. So, the girls sang loudly and confidently. Those two have always been stable in their singing. When we say a group sings live, it doesn't mean they sang 100% of the song or 100% volume the whole song. It's absolutely normal for groups with energetic choreo.
it’s funny you say that when blackpink lipsyncs some of their parts or even some performances, mostly jenlisa 🤷🏼♀️ and you never pointed it out no hate 🙌🏻
I think you have to look behind the scenes LIVE PERFORMANCE (school ver) , They really sing very well when they are dressed up, the sound is really stable like in the music video recording
Duke คุณไม่เหมือนเดิม คุณกำลังจับผิดแม้รายละเอียดเล็กน้อย ทั้งที่ผ่านมาคุณสนุกกับการแสดงที่นักร้องหยุดร้องเพื่อเต้นแต่มีเสียงร้องของเขาอยู่อันนั้นน่าเกลียดมาก ขอบคุณ
LOL why pre recording mixed with live vocals is became a BIG DEAL now? Most 4th gen GGs out there literally lip synced and it's OK cause dancing while singing is hard but BabyMonster really sing live in this one
if bro watch other group music bank preformance or inkigayo he will report those videos . its more live than 99 percent of kpop girl groups do right now
I’m surprised people really thought it was going to be live. Anytime a kpop act says it’s live vocals for a performance like this, 90% of the time its full playback or 50/50.
No if you watch lalisa Jimmy Kimmel live or blackpink pink venom special performance it is 💯 live because their voice is louder than backtrack and idol who is good in singing if they sing live and dance some difference can clearly seen.
@@saniyaadhikari5271but when blackpink sings 100% vocals then look at their dance power is reduced except for lisa because she is the main dance. There are times to sing 100% live and there are also times to sing with the help of a backtrack. Even when I watched Blackpink's concert or performance on Inkigayo, they also used backtrack.
@@saniyaadhikari5271ruclips.net/video/rZYxzen9uEA/видео.htmlsi=2XhtYykq31CkuMbq you calling this LIVE? Like be for real. It's screams backtrack LISA rarely do LIVE and if she do she always out of breath specially when she raps
I agree with you Duke. Thanks for not sugarcoating your reaction here. Just let them sing live while dancing rather than making them sing live and then putting it on top of the video. And for the others who are fine with this, it's not. You're just supporting YG and other groups and other companies with this. We know Baemon can sing live and they all sound great so don't just be satisfied with what you're getting here. Let them make mistakes let them be humans. It's more adorable that way.
actually YG, never creates main visual in his talented students, YG never does it, they are all created with talent, so stop saying main visual, who is main visual , hello they are all very beautiful and talented, they are in their position because they compete with hundreds of thousands of people to debut, and they compete not from looks but talent, we have to respect their talent and indeed they are all very beautiful
and maybe old YG fans definitely know, every time a junior debuts, we definitely feel something in common with their seniors, and that has become a YG tradition, maybe YG says this is our generation, like some of us feel the presence of their seniors in their personalities and stage actions they are like, lisa, rose, jisoo and jennie, likewise when blacpingk debuted, we felt there was a 2ne1 personality on blackping, both from the concept, video, song, voice, face, personality, for example lisa on chiquita and parita, jisoo on ruka and Rora, Rose on Haram and Jennie on Asa and Ahyeon
I felt your reaction was very exaggerated The girls didn't breathe into the microphone and above all, it didn't sound forced. in my opinion they did it well and naturally
I think all kpop girlgrup do that. Background vocal is louder than their live vocal because the dance choreography is intense. It’s different to compare with boy groups cause male idols ‘ voices are more stable even they danced.
Disappointed with what? Isn't it too soon to be disappointed? There will be a separate live performance soon. It's only been a few days since their debut. Don't be impatient.
Whatever it is I know Baby Monster strength. Their vocals, dance and visual absolutely stunning, no judgement needed😌. They just new being idols, leave them alone.
DELETE THIS. They are already experiencing a hate train and a grown man doesn’t need to share his ridiculous and bias opinion that worsens their situation. I hope YG starts coming down on some of you. They are mainly minors so watch your views.
I completely agree with you duke. We all clearly know, the girls are so talented and as usual yg isn't giving their best to them. Hopefully something good is on their way.
![A REAL Live Stage!!! | BABYMONSTER - 'BATTER UP' (Stadium Ver.) | The Duke [Reaction]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ib2M_LowCc8/mqdefault.jpg)
![A REAL Live Stage!!! | BABYMONSTER - 'BATTER UP' (Stadium Ver.) | The Duke [Reaction]](/img/tr.png)
![YG is F*CKING with us! | BABYMONSTER - Debut Member Announcment | The Duke [Reaction]](/img/1.gif)
SOOOO I talked to someone who is professional at mixing vocals. He told me it sounds like live pre-recorded vocals in a studio and than lip synced on set to those live pre record. So basicly the same thing that I said, I just thought they may took the audio from the mics on set and mixed that with the pre record :D
Even if that someone is correct , what you saw is SK's version of a music show live performance. YG delivered what you would see if BM performed in a SK music show, as requested by the fans. I think they sang live with a backtrack sound. Most groups lip sync. Not justifying, it is what it is.
If you want pure live performance with a band, you have to watch their concert (hopefully soon). You are disappointed because your expectations are way off the roof this time.
Bro ITs not that deep lmfao. Enjoy the girls performance why are you so gung ho about some damn pre recorded or live when BP does the same shit. You’re whack LOL
@@fel1237 but like that isn't sk music show tho😶 and about expectations , aren't bm in yg, isn't yg idols known for live vocal..
@@Jennieee199they did sing live with backtrack sound.
I heard them singing live against a backdrop. They were not lip syncing
Of course they sing live. There are two sounds, namely the backtrack sound and the vocal sounds of the members singing live. The members' original voices are above the backtrack and the volume of their live voices sounds greater. Their mic is on, that's the point.
If you are kpop fans, you will know this video is like a music show on Inkigayo or Music Bank. The video had been pre-recorded but when the video was taken all the members sang live even though there were back vocals too. If you are looking forward to a real live performance then just look forward to their concerts or when they perform at award shows like MAMA, AAA, GDA, or MMA.
** this is a live performance but not real time. but all the members actually sing, not lip sync.
Yes , almost all idols do that when singing live on stage , there are even some agencies that don't allow their idols to sing live , the idol will lipsync from the beginning to the end of the song , there is nothing disappointing about babymonster's performance , they sing live so well, their energy and voices are so beautiful.
True 🔥
Yes, it is 'live', but it was certainly recorded many times, and then in post production nicely edited. Anyone familiar with K-pop knows that this is normal for them. If you think otherwise, it means you must believe in Santa Claus. This 'double track' is a fact. But 'double track' was recorded many, many times and they chose the best version (after all, they won't do otherwise ;) ) and still in post production they could improve something.
@@coman6143This is the same as a music show system such as Inkigayo or Music Bank, they take repeated videos, then there is a backtrack vocal, finally there is live vocal from the group singing + dancing and they do this repeatedly. babymonster have done well and this is their first stage, I look forward to their future performances by performing at award shows like MAMA or others.
Bro , am I the only one who have ears , they are clearly singing.
No same, I feel like everytime someone hears a backtrack then they immediately jump to the conclusion that it's not live.
The singing part of chiquita and pharita in the first was clearly not singing live 0:58
@@unknowngayuserthat's a live... Rami, Rora and Ruka are singing
@@Jennieee199 if you hear it for the first time , it seems like it’s not live , but if you hear it couple of time , you will realize that it’s live , you can hear the difference.
@@narcisfedor6316 ikr they are so talented and there is nothing wrong with having backtrack like why these people taking so serious when we say they are having backtrack and not really 💯 live...
babymonster: *breathes*
kpop fans: IM DISAPPOINTED 🥺
Fr bro
real
REAL
Fr
fact =))
Dude, Ruka's voice is so clear, powerful and raw, it can be easily distinguished. She's obviously rapping live.
Fr
Yes you're right
Ruka was rapping live ..and some were too but most didn't do live and it's so obvious
i know right he is just a hater
Yes
Pharita is an outstanding in this stage for me 🎉
Why he is so disappointed???............... Everyone sing so powerfull and amazing.
I'm 101% statisfied with this group performance
Pls go watch chota bheem
Maybe he wants them to be like 2ne1 and blackpink. They also sing with backtrack music.
@@jasperalc to be honest ..baemon are better singers than them...Sandara voice is not taken seriously in she was known as krung krung and her songs are novelty ..same standard as ocho ocho and Pamela one!
@blairbass2232 Yes, bm vocals are really good compared to their senior (rosé excluded). Well, they were just debuted, so there's a lot to watch for.
Yeah he looks disappoint lol .
We love babymonster what ever
Pharita’s deep voice got my attention 😊
Rora and ruka is clearly singing live
I'm not sure about the others but I'm confident that Ruka is 100% rapping live. Her raw voice can be heard clearly, and it's different from the MV. I even zoomed the video and her mouth, dance and rap truly matches.
Yes i heard RUKA'S breath❤
Or it's like he said; playback of their live vocals. You can also see how Rukas mic is sometimes well below her chin due to head movements but that doesn't affect the volume of her voice which it should. This is a very common thing in kpop especially with 4th gen idol groups. This is a problem to blame the companies for, not the idols.
@@Emmas123 I zoomed in her video and her mic is in the right place. Don't make stories.
Asa and Chiquita sound exactly like the record one (They ate CD that’s why🥲), it’s understandable if you think they are lip syncing. But Ruka, Haram, Rora, and Pharita sound really different from og track for example the difference weight in some words it’s so clear that they are singing lives.
exactly
I personally don't think so. Although Asa's voice doesn't sound as Rae as Ruka's but that's just how her voice is no? Like.... we have already seen in their pre debut days. But regardless of that, you can still hear Asa improvising at some points. Also in the 'volume up light em up' part, you can clearly hear her take a breath and singing in a slightly modified tune than the actual tune (note it- modified tune as in changed tune which blends in well with the actual tune; not completely out of tune). For ex- in the beginning of her rap, the actual song has precise Korean accent but here her voice sounds a bit more high pitched and kinda Hyunsuk-coded as im having a stylistic, stretchy and 'western-y' accent approach.
Yep chiquita is sadly a star nobody cares but she was lisincy
I don't care if you're dissapointed😤, these girls are still talented
I agree❤.
Well obviously you do or you wouldn't have clicked on the video and commented... 🤷🏾♀️
@@iainturbarbie1101 Right? They say they don't care, but then they clicked on a video that made it obvious what he was going to say (titled "I'm disappointed") and then left butthurt comments. 🤣🤣
Thanks to support them ❤️
he did not say that they were not talented 🤦♀️
Its not easy to sing,rap live while you are dancing that kind of steps,you may catch your breath,stop criticising them,just enjoy and watch whatever they do,
Fr.... People act like rookie kpop groups are not humans and are robots🤦♀️
Why do you dare to raise yourself as the norm? The song is only 3 minutes long. Divide the singing part among 6 people. Each of them didn't sing a lot. And the songs are not difficult to sing, have high notes or difficult notes that require the use of energy. It's funny how you make yourself the deciding factor.
Ikr! People should not expect so much from a newly debuted group while most of the 4th gen group( 3-4 yr. Experienced) can't even sing and lip-sync all the time even when they are just standing straight. Lol
No hate and I am not mentioning anyone.
I think this is just your first time watching a kpop idol singing live. If you watch more of inkigayo or music bank contents, you’ll see that they always do the mixing of live vocals and having the MR while singing. Even Blackpink and other Kpop groups do that when they are performing live.
Mixing of live vocals while having the MR is common in kpop live shows, since many idols have difficulty singing while dancing to intense choreography.
You can be disappointed but don't be too confident in saying this, this is an opportunity for the haters. Congratulations, you have opened the way for more haters for BabyMonster. Some people even pretend to know that their dancing is a mess instead of saying they agree with your opinion. In the end, your reaction becomes a field for haters to blaspheme Babymonster, are you satisfied? because I still hear them singing live. Even though the backtrack sound is loud, I'm sure they sing live.
Facts!!!!! I totally agree
Just unsubscribe him. I think he aren’t rlly supporting the girls
people will always see something wrong to criticize, enjoy the video and the girls charisma instead of being paying attention on how their sound, and their mic, omg
He wasn't even criticizing tho!! Like he was literally saying he was disappointed that they didn't really do it live because yg idols is literally known for stage presence and live powerful vocals like bp, big bang, 2ne1, Y'all really making deal out of honest video review..like chill no one hating on bm
@@Jennieee199 they are singing live. if you watch ruka and asa it doesnt sound like the record. I just that it was backround vocals
Maybe they are Def 😂
@@Jennieee199you can clearly see the difference from recorded to live coz ruka proving that coz her mic is a little bit down
@@yoshinori-cq8jithere is literally a live recorded in the backtrack like yes their mic is on but they sang some part but didn't sang in most especially pharita and chiquita in the first it's so obvious..
Support them ...instead of expecting too much.
They are talented we all know...but its a performance not just vocals.
yeah I agree with u
Fr
Why should we support them when YG gives them no comebacks and they are doing the same to them on what they did with 2ne1 and Blackpink?!!! You are just giving YG more money!
@@ArtIsDrawingWhat are you even talking about? They literally just debuted and you're talking about comebacks? WHAT??
Giving valid criticism is not the same as not supporting them.
If nobody voice their displeasure with YG's direction with a "live performance" like this, it will end up being all we get.
BABYMONSTER antis might be happy seeing your reaction why can't you just enjoy, if it doesn't reach your expectation also you don't have to act that way saying you're disappointed and such they're just a new group such a small things can effect their images so much also they're singing live and play backtrack at the same time and we all know that this is not new in kpop we all know they have the hardest dance steps that needs so much energy...if you want to sing them with raw vocals then watch their vocals performance!! how can they sing while jumping and dancing like that they're not a robot
yeah this reaction made me think that some people went to haters side now maby thats more fun for them and their chanel😒😒
And I'm already unsubscribe his channel
@@shar12ja49 me too
It was not live period
Bro ,we don't care if you are disappointed as long as we all know BABYMONSTER can sing live and that's the FACT 😎
You clearly do care what his opinions are since you saw his channel, the thumbnail, and clicked on it.
@@Official-OpenAINo, he doesn't care because he only came to comment and assume the fact that babymonster can sing live.🙄
When I watched this video I was shocked by their live voice like indeed they got best live vocals n rap like I can clearly hear their all raw vocals except the outro. 90% they sang live I have no idea what u r saying I think its because they’re are too good n u just can’t believe it. I listen to it for 20 times n 90% is raw vocal 10% are outro n some Chiquita n haram part which is 2%
They used backtrack, and their backtrack is live AR, but they are singing live too but some part are not, esp when part are hard with dance. And thats understandable because this video live performance for youtube, not a concert. Well for me honestly as fan of YG since 2008, I'm very uncomfortable with your words about YG. BABYMONSTER not even a month since debut and what? You disappointed? Lol.
Just know you said "if you are YG fans follow my channel" If you are YG fans please spread love n support about YG group. BABYMONSTER is a new group but already have hater, haters will be happy with ur opinion on this video. If you are truly YG fans.
I’m agree
Louder please
yes please!!
Now I think we know he's not actually YG Stan.
@@shar12ja49 only finding out now? 😂 he loves BP and it stops there. He appreciates few YG grps (may be or may be not 🤔), too naive to call himself a YG stan. From what i have seen he just knows them, nothing more nothing less. Im not saying u shld know 100% to stan an artist or a grp, u can criticize u can be disappointed, etc., but when u say stan u just express things n a diff way even if u complain u wont shut the video on their face. I don know, whenevrr i saw him reacting to any YG grps excluding BP it seems like he doesn enjoy as much he claims! Well, i may be wrong but thats how i feel. Finally, i don think he "stans" stans them....
I think it's a live performance, but it's not 100% vocal, maybe because they have to dance to the fullest, that's understandable, even if it's a little disappointing.
Well that's how it works bc Dancing while singing is Hard as Fuck
@@al_alea Yes, I understand, and I know it's hard to do two things at once. While they have only debuted a few days ago.
@@al_aleamany have done both. Stray kids for example do it all the time. So it can be done. This is not raw live vocals.
@rwo4h9 I can agree they don’t sound the best but my point is they are live, I prefer to hear the raw and real if they are going to be live. I do however also love a full choreography lip syncing performance!
Asa clearly is singing live I can literally hear her breathing what are you saying💀?
Ez to see They don't sing live, they just re-record their voice and come dance and lip sync.
Dude not even finish until the credit scene for our baby monster, what a dissapointed video reaction 😢
The fuck then don't watch it
@@enparksunghooncalm down
As a long time subscriber of this channel, i am disappointed in Duke.. They clearly sang live and i think Duke gave in to the hate bandwagon of BM.
Same
i don’t think all of them sang live. there are no movements in their voice that are indicative of live singing, especially since they’re dancing as well! it’s most likely pre-recorded, but they delivered nonetheless.
Pharita is shining ,she's jumping notable with her charm
this is the exact same thing that happened to BLACKPINK 7 years ago, accused of just lip syncing. you will not succeed in destroying BM. And we don't care if you're disappointed
I'm very satisfied with what they done. I think it's good stage !
YG singers are very good at singing live, so far no YG idol has ever lipped
idk but its clearly live, you can hear it if you really pay attention to it or watch it more times.
like of course there is a back track but its really hard without it when they are dancing this much so i dont see the problem with that.
I think they sang live but it was overwritten with prerecords cuz I can hear the sound of rami and pharita it's little bit different
Yesss
How can you say they not singing live, I can hear some part they sound different with recording, yes they do have backtrack on it, and BP also use it in their performance. Backtrack always use in kpop live stage. But we still can hear they singing live..
They forget that BM is a rookie group. They expect too much from this group, some criticizing them for not being good, not being in the charts, not being par w/ all the expectations surrounding them bcoz they're from "yg". No. Kpop Idols regardless of what agency they are are humans and not robots they cannot all be the time perfect and not all the time cater all your demands. The members did their best for this debut and some people are just so negative and hateful which is so below the belt already.
Bruh their live though 🙄 it's so obvious their mic is on
Even ruka voice was more louder than the original . Haram and rora too
It's so obvious that there is some recorded one in the back so I Don't know what y'all about
@@Jennieee199 of course let them breath for a second bro cause y'all damn saw their dancing so hard plus + live singing
@@Jennieee199of course there is a backtrack but their live sound is above the backtrack and the volume of their live sound is greater. Their mic is on, that's the point.
@@dwiwi8326 that's what I'm saying too they are singing but there was some backtrack... nothin said anything about them not singing or mic not being on..just said there back track..
Dude if you are disappointed stop it cuz every other kpop group is doing the same, no one sings live in kpop anymore but it's yg hate will come
exactly, That's point!
👍🏻
Am i the only one who did hear their live voice/vocals? Haram and Pharita is so obvious also the rappers. Same with chiquita and rora, the problem was the backtrack is louder in their parts. But if you focus and did not just watched it once you will eventually gonna realize it. There is a difference in the weight of the words and sound when they sing on their parts and when not. If you are doubting then make your own mr remove of their performance. Anyways i know they can serve and slay if they did it in an actual live performance (like awards shows/festival/concert).
Duke is monster.
Respect your opinion.
But hate your attitude.
I listen to the clean ver of their live performance. They all sang their parts well and all of them are very stable compare to other rookie groups. Maybe that's the reason why you cant hear them and thinks its not live. Their vocals are live.
there are no movements in their voice, though.. no matter how stable you are, singing and dancing at the same time you are bound to hear those movements while singing, but you can’t in this performance.
@@alyanah if you try to listen to the clean version of their live you can hear them catching their breath and its shaky too but still I can say its stable.
Ah come on chiquita wa lipsync
@@Anlin00 maybe the "ohhh" part because it was hard to stable with that choreography though but she still sang the rest of the part. Try checking the clean version ☺️
@@marianmae1588 its not hard in a headvoice :) but she diddnt sing live also the sting like a bee
Their live performance is very good and their expressions are very on point interesting let's show more support for Babymonster
If you mad, stay mad Duke, we not alike!!!!!!
Ruka, Rami & Rita part obviously sound live!!
Why ASA now looks so pretty 😂 she is like visual of the group right now, suddenly forgot she is rapper 😊 she grow up well ❤ love you asa, i think you got my attention.
Ruka asa killed it🔥🔥🔥😮😮
Pharita thumbnail. She's gorgeous. Her stage presence and facial expressions are everything ❤
You don't enjoy the show.
Because you always looking for something wrong.😢
I put on headphones.
I'm 100% sure they're singing live.💖
We can confirm now its LIVE..just check out Batter Out LIVE Performamce behind the scenes..the girls practice this song backstage n they sound exactly like in the cd..thanks
I hear a lot of windmachines
@@DUUKE100 i hope they dont use backtrack next time..they clearly dont need it..
@@DUUKE100 bungol
Their live vocals and stage presence is insane 🔥 i am wondering how you can't hear their live vocals
Bruuhh... I MISSED THE TIMES WHEN YG ARTISTS doesn't conform to the strict dancing. That's the reason why I love YG so much! The adlibs and live singing is on another level, especially the one who is singing their part, its not a strict choreo. Just like BIGBANG, 2NE1, WINNER, IKON. That's why I'm disappointed on LIVE performances for Blackpink, Treasure and now Baemon. At least the 3 rappers of Treasure does the typical YG adlib antics sometimes.
Idk but i fell so sad for this reaction 😢 i love duke reaction BP n BM , but here u look like not enjoying reaction our baby for the first time stage
Fr I hate him now
That's right, this is the first time I've been disappointed with his reaction
dude, they sing live I'm sure of it. YG not gonna lie especially BABYMONSTER
The way I hear it... Rora, Rami, Ruka and Asa sang 100% live. Pharita like 90% live and Chiquita like... 60-70%? and yes, the dance break was totally playback, but that's normal cause it's a dance break, they're supposed to dance, not sing. However, I do agree with you that getting a 100% live performance would be nice. But for that to happen, they have to compromise dancing. Can't jump like that and sound perfect.
THIS CHANNEL IS TELLING ALL THE TRUTH, IF YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT IS SINGING LIVE, JUST WATCH MAMAMOO & NMIXX MR REMOVED. WE KNOW BM ARE TALENTED BUT THIS IS PRERECORDED, INCREASED YOUR KNOWLEDGE BEFORE JUDGING OF PEOPLE.
I’ve watched vocal coaches state moving while singing is extremely, extremely hard. While some are better than others it seems most artists have prerecorded or backtrack vocals playing while dancing or doing any sort of movements. Unless you just want them to stand there, this is what you’re going to get. I don’t mind it, personally I’ve spent many a nights trying to sing Michael Jackson and dancing and you can barely get a sound out after like 10 seconds lol.
Why do you dare to raise yourself as the norm? The song is only 3 minutes long. Divide the singing part among 6 people. Each of them didn't sing a lot. And the songs are not difficult to sing, have high notes or difficult notes that require the use of energy. It's funny how you make yourself the deciding factor.
then they should've not called the video a "live performance" if most of what we will hear are backtrack vocals. NMIXX's stage practices will put this to shame.
@@nat_wt lol what?
@@mateyo_ yea..I don’t care about whoever you said. Thanks, have a good day.
I would love for him to dance full out and give 100% clear vocals without an backingtrack
They are dancing while singing and rapping and still giving their best
..god ...they were trainees for more than 4 years practicing how to sing live while dancing .......
Were you there ...to be pretty sure that they are having playbacks
Bro they’re literally YG artists so what lip sync are you talking about ☠️
The owner of Butter Up is RAMI 😊 she got more part in lyric & performance.
Bro this is k-pop. Everything is under control. All groups sings with the original pitch behind. Don't wait an authentic song singed at least it is a balad 🫡
Dari awal mereka debut saja reaksi kamu tidak merasa puas🤣 semoga kedepannya kamu bisa menyukai BM😚😁
I completely agree with you Duke!💪 I think they should’ve let us listen to actually live vocals and not pre recorded. If they really want to show their artists and let us know that Babymonster is capable, they should try harder
Bro you have the voices in the video, and you can see when the girls stop in parts of the song ... What the hell you say.
It is not that "they didn't let them sing live", because they are clearly singing. It's the editing that made it this way. Plus, this is live performance, which you might not be accepting because you are thinking about "live singing". What I mean is, this is what they deem as live performance. Or do you want them to not use the performance they work hard to prepare just because you want them to hold mic and minimize dancing?
i love the show as always! so much time left for them to show off! Love and support BM from Thailand! 😀 everybody please enjoy the show and be happy!
ฝรั่งเขาชอบความเรียล 😅 แต่ดูยังไงก็ไม่ใช่ร้องสด
@@กัสสึ-ฎ3ธอืมม ก็เข้าใจนะครับ แต่การดูไม่จบคลิปแล้วตัดจบเลยเพราะเหตุผลเดียวนี่....อืมมมม ก็ช่องเค้าเเหละ 😢
I love chiquita with the bangs 😢 bring it back to make her more cute please
For any part that everyone's voices put together like that, in this case outro, it's 100% normal to not sing live or sing quietly to not make it sound bad. Every group do it like that.
For chorus, groups often sing softer than normal or not sing at all to focus on dance to increase overall performance quality.
They just put on loud backtrack for this performance, so it didn't sound that raw, which fits the song. They sang live but chose where to sing loudly or quietly. For example, for Chiquita first part, it should not be sang louder than the backtrack or it will sound off. Also with that dance move, her voice is sure to be shaky no matter what, so they might not let her sing at all. For part like Rami's or Pharita's first part, it fits to sing strongly. So, the girls sang loudly and confidently. Those two have always been stable in their singing.
When we say a group sings live, it doesn't mean they sang 100% of the song or 100% volume the whole song. It's absolutely normal for groups with energetic choreo.
it’s funny you say that when blackpink lipsyncs some of their parts or even some performances, mostly jenlisa 🤷🏼♀️ and you never pointed it out
no hate 🙌🏻
Fr he is biased
There's a lot of editing in kpop guys ... just so y'all know
I think you have to look behind the scenes LIVE PERFORMANCE (school ver) , They really sing very well when they are dressed up, the sound is really stable like in the music video recording
Clearly its live sir ...
Duke คุณไม่เหมือนเดิม คุณกำลังจับผิดแม้รายละเอียดเล็กน้อย ทั้งที่ผ่านมาคุณสนุกกับการแสดงที่นักร้องหยุดร้องเพื่อเต้นแต่มีเสียงร้องของเขาอยู่อันนั้นน่าเกลียดมาก ขอบคุณ
PHARITA 🎉❤
I feel the same… Btw, I wish to see them join any music shows.
And we blinks and baby monster fan, you disappointed us too. The anti-blinks and antibbmonster are happy seeing your video. Well done
Love Batter Up. So Good. Record breaking debut. Best ever.
LOL why pre recording mixed with live vocals is became a BIG DEAL now? Most 4th gen GGs out there literally lip synced and it's OK cause dancing while singing is hard but BabyMonster really sing live in this one
if bro watch other group music bank preformance or inkigayo he will report those videos . its more live than 99 percent of kpop girl groups do right now
I’m surprised people really thought it was going to be live. Anytime a kpop act says it’s live vocals for a performance like this, 90% of the time its full playback or 50/50.
No if you watch lalisa Jimmy Kimmel live or blackpink pink venom special performance it is 💯 live because their voice is louder than backtrack and idol who is good in singing if they sing live and dance some difference can clearly seen.
@@saniyaadhikari5271but when blackpink sings 100% vocals then look at their dance power is reduced except for lisa because she is the main dance. There are times to sing 100% live and there are also times to sing with the help of a backtrack. Even when I watched Blackpink's concert or performance on Inkigayo, they also used backtrack.
@@saniyaadhikari5271ruclips.net/video/RkKXbweBCcI/видео.htmlsi=nxDjXzP3glDIyCbI this is pink venom special stage and they used backtrack to
@@saniyaadhikari5271that Jimmy Kimmel is literally 100% not live vocal it's just a prerecorded with back up of backtrack
@@saniyaadhikari5271ruclips.net/video/rZYxzen9uEA/видео.htmlsi=2XhtYykq31CkuMbq you calling this LIVE? Like be for real. It's screams backtrack LISA rarely do LIVE and if she do she always out of breath specially when she raps
They are just like other idols, all idol groups sing like that. What is the problem? They don't have to be PERFECT. They are what they are.
well other artist dont even sing this much live they just lipsync its more than enough live in kpop standards
They just posted a behind the scenes for this one and clearly the mics were on. Now you can take away your disappointment.
I’m also disappointed in your reaction. I mean, I don’t think YG will lie about them singing live
I'm not sure about other members but I'm fucking sure that Ruka live rap cuz her rap give the most powerful,clear, and raw!
i heard RUKA'S BREATH ❤ 💯
I agree with you Duke. Thanks for not sugarcoating your reaction here. Just let them sing live while dancing rather than making them sing live and then putting it on top of the video.
And for the others who are fine with this, it's not. You're just supporting YG and other groups and other companies with this. We know Baemon can sing live and they all sound great so don't just be satisfied with what you're getting here. Let them make mistakes let them be humans. It's more adorable that way.
They are singing live! There will always be backing tracks.
All very talented! I’m not disappointed at all.
You may be creating hate for people who don't like babymonster😢😢😢
is it a trend to jump on hate trains today, congratz you gave haters another thing to attack baemon honestly cant these girls just enjoy their debut
its live preformance dude not live singing and all kpop groups do that even blackpink and bts do that
Exactly! And a reaction like this only attracts more hate for girls
actually YG, never creates main visual in his talented students, YG never does it, they are all created with talent, so stop saying main visual, who is main visual , hello they are all very beautiful and talented, they are in their position because they compete with hundreds of thousands of people to debut, and they compete not from looks but talent, we have to respect their talent and indeed they are all very beautiful
and maybe old YG fans definitely know, every time a junior debuts, we definitely feel something in common with their seniors, and that has become a YG tradition, maybe YG says this is our generation, like some of us feel the presence of their seniors in their personalities and stage actions they are like, lisa, rose, jisoo and jennie, likewise when blacpingk debuted, we felt there was a 2ne1 personality on blackping, both from the concept, video, song, voice, face, personality, for example lisa on chiquita and parita, jisoo on ruka and Rora, Rose on Haram and Jennie on Asa and Ahyeon
There is obviously a backtrack because the girls have to dance as well. And they are freaking stable even after dancing.
I felt your reaction was very exaggerated
The girls didn't breathe into the microphone and above all, it didn't sound forced. in my opinion they did it well and naturally
I really appreciate that and I also want them to sing full live without background vocals. YG is actually underestimating their talent.
Their dancing is intense, how can they sing without a backtrack. Come on
Their dance is very hard...so it's very hard to sing live,, u'll be out of breath so that's y they added a little backing vocals
I think all kpop girlgrup do that. Background vocal is louder than their live vocal because the dance choreography is intense. It’s different to compare with boy groups cause male idols ‘ voices are more stable even they danced.
The problem is idk why yg used it there’s no need at all ruclips.net/video/yTpk4fEDfTg/видео.htmlsi=1nfuvbUP-mvQP7WP
@@MimieyTV boygroups are meh! only exo can literally sing! if you want live as in raw ...watch SB19!
Disappointed with what? Isn't it too soon to be disappointed? There will be a separate live performance soon.
It's only been a few days since their debut. Don't be impatient.
Now go watch their latest video you'll take back your words seeing the way their voices are so steady and powerful
He talks like a professional while he ain’t even one lol I could hear the girls voices and they were stable
Yup, hope he stop using their fame
@@SONPHAM-hi8iv Yes absolutely
Whatever it is I know Baby Monster strength. Their vocals, dance and visual absolutely stunning, no judgement needed😌. They just new being idols, leave them alone.
DELETE THIS. They are already experiencing a hate train and a grown man doesn’t need to share his ridiculous and bias opinion that worsens their situation. I hope YG starts coming down on some of you. They are mainly minors so watch your views.
This live its like all kpop nowdays, live vocals with support vocal 😅 only few groups can sing without pre recorded
I completely agree with you duke. We all clearly know, the girls are so talented and as usual yg isn't giving their best to them. Hopefully something good is on their way.
Who is dancing without backtrack nowadays?
Yup
React now to their live vocals..latest bts about that video just released….you’ll take back your word