I think Rora and Pharita, and Asa really really stand out with live live vocal and rap in this version. In terms of stage presence in this version, Rami and Rora surprise me the most.
I don't know why he got critisized for his opinion , As a yg fan and specially as a "babymonster" fan he definitely know what they are capable of and their live vocals are insane , so he just shared his thoughts ...
Because it was his stupid idea. His actions at that time I consider his standards to be very high. From now on, if he reacts to another group's GG live performance, it will definitely be a worse live performance than BM's performance. If he doesn't react to that performance like he reacted to BM's performance, I will question it. Those things are definitely And if he doesn't respond well enough to the question he should explain it. His use of harsh words and cursing will follow. and will continue to elevate it He must take responsibility for that shitty act.
@@nat_wt he can share his shitty opinion on his own channel in his own video as he wants, if you don't like his comments, don't watch it. you can't come here and pontificate. ''when he watch other gg's live performance, he have to have the same reaction because other gg's vocals are will be worse than bm''haha my ass
@@nat_wt You sounded so funny. What he did on his previous reaction was valid. As a person who sings and play instrument he was right it was not a hateful comment rather an honest and valid reaction. These girls are freaking talented but YG barely gave fans the bare minimum.
@@BabuReyesI'm so fed up with this excuse. I've seen antis use this excuse to attack BM's debut song from November 27th until now. I, as a true fanboy of BM, am not a liar who pretends to be a BM fan in order to gain legitimacy for myself in order to criticize and criticize the BM group. True fans of BM who feel disappointed already have the right to criticize. But there will be only one or two reproaches. To reflect their thoughts and communicate their opinions, they will stop and continue to support and encourage them. Only antis and other GG fans still use the same old excuses to attack non-stop. As for that bastard, not only does he not support the BM girls, he also treats them unfairly. Needless to say I am a disappointed fan. There is no support but just neutrality is good. But that bastard had nothing to offer but attack. Present only the negative side Leading people to hate I can't find anything good from that bastard's actions.
Pharita become a BAT lady already. 🦇 Chiquita become a DEVIL BATTER this time. ⚾ Rami, Ruka, and Asa have 2 pigtail hair style, along with front red highlight on Rora's black hair. They're all looking good in black baseball uniform, too. BabyMonster never fail their fans, this is a good live performance again. The prominent vocals, strong dancing, and undeniable charismatic facial expressions, all are on point. Refer to hair dying colors of Ruka, Chiquita, and Rami, I think the Live Performance of both 'stadium' and 'school' versions were shot right after M/V filming. While the Dance Performannce Video (orange/olive theme) was shot a while after that because the 'remember me' choreograph changed. Then, these 3 girls hair dying color changed again and appeared in Dance Practice video along with that changed choreography. This is my opinion alone and has no bad meaning at all. 🥰🤩
This process is the same as the following clip where you react "I'm disappointed... | BABYMONSTER - 'BATTER UP' LIVE PERFORMANCE | The Duke [Reaction]" They're singing over the background vocals and dancing the same. Try reviewing your understanding about singing over the background vocals and dancing along again again ... agaaaaaaain and open your ears. It's not different. It's just that you feel that it's different. Then you shape people to feel accordingly. I still confirm that these 2 clips are the same. It was not pre-recorded and then edited. The chorus part was sung over the background vocals as before. They don't sing on the real backing track, all K-pop groups do like this. I don't hate you. You try listening to both clips with your eyes closed and having someone else listen to them by randomizing each section. You will find it the same. I think that day you may have encountered something that will shape your feelings. Let you think like that. I speak within reason. If you try this experiment Then you found out that you were wrong. You should also be aware of your responsibility to shape people's emotions.
No worries Duke, the reason I following your channel because you are giving true reaction and comments. I agree with you all the times. This live performance indeed better 'live' than the previous one 😊
Nah.. the difference is that the backtrack of that first one was louder. But both called LIVE performance in kpop world. Do you think Korean wouldn't know if YG lie? Pls do learn some facts about how music shows produced first..
Them debuting on YG stage is more so a practice for the girls, so it seems. The girls are still learning to work together, and learning the stage etiquettes.
I agree with you. This stage was so much better compared to last one. I was disappointed last time, not gonna lie. I know the girls can deliver so why not give them justice by giving them what they can do. enough with the lipsyncer GGs, we have enough of that. They are of different kind, they are MONSTERS.
Theres this saying about, "a true friend is when he/she tells you your mistake/wrong for good". And I believed, a fan should also be the same. What you said on your last vid helped the production for improvement duke. Its not directly about BAEMON, its for the company. Since true YG stan, knows YGAs are for LIVE STAGES. Dont be pressured duke. Those bashers are newbies thats why
Yup! Theres a backtrack but for this one you knownits live cuz you can hear the "S" and a bump of the mic if you got a good headphones. 🤭 Looks like YG reading some comments or watching reactors. 🤣
Studio VS Stadium. 😅 Of course, the audio quality is different. 😊 their falsettos are still the same with the prev video. It seems unreal, but that's live🎉🎉🎉. ✌️
You know what was criticized about your last reaction, it was the fact that you cut the video abruptly. You could have shown some respect by letting the video finished.
👉Ha I only just noticed Pharita's black wings!!! The girls wore black combined with red + Chiquita with her little red koreans + Pharitas and her little black wings... Is all this based on a certain concept or is it a message about the image that she will give in the future... Like BlackPink... BlackRed... 😈Well then maybe it's me who's crazy...🙃😅😄
From the first they live performance also sing live lol it's just u r ear need check up to the doctor ... Actually I read comment on korean portal ... Somebody tell us that YG give many performance bcoz no music show... It's not bcoz of u 😅
Even though babymonster has not lip-synced since its first live performance, I just said in this comment that Duke, I hope you become smart, he said, you are real, but I didn't see behind the scene Baemon? If other people say you are fake YG's reaction I think it's true thank you i'm unsubscribe
Thank you so much for your reaction ❤❤❤, I'm so happy that Asa is your bias because she is also my bias ❤❤❤. Can you reaction to Babymonster Christmas without you cover please 🙏
You should watch the behind the scenes of the school version..they are really live singing there. Its just that their voice is really same as the studio version. You must watch the behind the scenes of that. But i agree with you that the backtracks of the school version is louder
I think people were annoyed because BabyMonster have been on the receiving end of a massive hate train because they decided to not copy NewJeans and their soft music trend. Literally every fanbase and a few creators have been critical of BabyMonster. I think you just dropped your original reaction in the heat of it.
Last time, it was your offensive demeanor and how you cut the video that sent a message of disrespect to the supporters of the hard working BM girls. It was also the “disappointed” screen shot title that attracted haters to feast and cheer you. At least this time there was redemption on your part. Just be a bit tactful because there are a lot of BP followers that follows you for a long time but loves and supports their baby sisters BM.
BM tiene todo el potencial, tienen hermosas voces y por eso mismo el playback esta de más, simplemente no deberían de hacerlo, no sé porqué YG se aferra a hacerlo cuando sus cantantes si tienen excelente voz
![The Sub-Unit we NEED! | BABYMONSTER - 'Woke Up In Tokyo' Preview | Duke [Reaction]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aidpCNLxuHs/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Sub-Unit we NEED! | BABYMONSTER - 'Woke Up In Tokyo' Preview | Duke [Reaction]](/img/tr.png)
![A BANGER | BABYMONSTER- 'CLIK CLAK' M/V | Duke [Reaction]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3GoL5D8PthY/mqdefault.jpg)
![THAI Line is K*lling it! | "BABYMONSTER" - 'Last Evaluation' EP.4 | The Duke [Reaction]](/img/1.gif)
My Statement to the last BABYMONSTER video at 3:08
DUKE did you notice 🪽 on pharitas back???
❤❤❤
Duuke BLACKPINK in your area 🖤💓
#kppop3278
Ha I only just noticed Pharita's black wings!!!
real live stage is what we really needed because we know that they can sing and rap much better if its live!!!
ruclips.net/video/yTpk4fEDfTg/видео.html&pp=ygUedml2YSBtciByZW1vdmVkIGJhdHRlciB1cCBsaXZl
I think Rora and Pharita, and Asa really really stand out with live live vocal and rap in this version. In terms of stage presence in this version, Rami and Rora surprise me the most.
RUKA, RAMI & RORA standout to me a lot. Their voices sounds powerful and raw. Awesome stage presence and dancing.
Lowkey I want them to have “triple R” sub-unit 🤞
They sang live it was amazing 😭😭😭 babymonster mic is on!!💎❤️❤️
YG said ,”Your welcome Duke!”
Literally 😆
I don't know why he got critisized for his opinion ,
As a yg fan and specially as a "babymonster" fan he definitely know what they are capable of and their live vocals are insane ,
so he just shared his thoughts ...
stupid blinks as usual
Because it was his stupid idea. His actions at that time I consider his standards to be very high. From now on, if he reacts to another group's GG live performance, it will definitely be a worse live performance than BM's performance. If he doesn't react to that performance like he reacted to BM's performance, I will question it. Those things are definitely And if he doesn't respond well enough to the question he should explain it. His use of harsh words and cursing will follow. and will continue to elevate it He must take responsibility for that shitty act.
@@nat_wt he can share his shitty opinion on his own channel in his own video as he wants, if you don't like his comments, don't watch it. you can't come here and pontificate. ''when he watch other gg's live performance, he have to have the same reaction because other gg's vocals are will be worse than bm''haha my ass
@@nat_wt You sounded so funny. What he did on his previous reaction was valid. As a person who sings and play instrument he was right it was not a hateful comment rather an honest and valid reaction. These girls are freaking talented but YG barely gave fans the bare minimum.
@@BabuReyesI'm so fed up with this excuse. I've seen antis use this excuse to attack BM's debut song from November 27th until now. I, as a true fanboy of BM, am not a liar who pretends to be a BM fan in order to gain legitimacy for myself in order to criticize and criticize the BM group. True fans of BM who feel disappointed already have the right to criticize. But there will be only one or two reproaches. To reflect their thoughts and communicate their opinions, they will stop and continue to support and encourage them. Only antis and other GG fans still use the same old excuses to attack non-stop. As for that bastard, not only does he not support the BM girls, he also treats them unfairly. Needless to say I am a disappointed fan. There is no support but just neutrality is good. But that bastard had nothing to offer but attack. Present only the negative side Leading people to hate I can't find anything good from that bastard's actions.
I think yg made this live performance because of duke 😂😅
Yeah I also think the same 😂
100%😂
I think so 🤣🤣🤣
I think so
Me tooo😂😂😂😂😂
Baby Monster smashed it. Love the girls again. They blow me away every time at how powerful their performance and visuals are.
Rami's vocals are so piercing in this one! Definitely live
Nahh this live performance is better than before for me😂
The makeup, the style, stage is perfect
Chiquita & Pharita literally killed it!! They ate it!!🔥😍
Pharita become a BAT lady already. 🦇 Chiquita become a DEVIL BATTER this time. ⚾
Rami, Ruka, and Asa have 2 pigtail hair style, along with front red highlight on Rora's black hair. They're all looking good in black baseball uniform, too.
BabyMonster never fail their fans, this is a good live performance again. The prominent vocals, strong dancing, and undeniable charismatic facial expressions, all are on point.
Refer to hair dying colors of Ruka, Chiquita, and Rami, I think the Live Performance of both 'stadium' and 'school' versions were shot right after M/V filming. While the Dance Performannce Video (orange/olive theme) was shot a while after that because the 'remember me' choreograph changed. Then, these 3 girls hair dying color changed again and appeared in Dance Practice video along with that changed choreography. This is my opinion alone and has no bad meaning at all. 🥰🤩
맞아요! 확실히 이번 라이브 무대가 더 좋음!
멤버들의 노래소리가 더 잘들려서 좋아요!😊
I'm not familiar with many kpop groups, but after Mamamoo, it was Baby Monster who caught my attention due to their excellent vocals and rap.
i saw the video and i was like "YASSSSS NOW DUKE'S GONNA LIKE IT" haha
Chiquta and asa stunning out for me who agree with me❤😂
I don’t care about live vocals or not , but I still love with the present stage babymonster and visual anddddd vocal 😚
ruclips.net/video/yTpk4fEDfTg/видео.html&pp=ygUedml2YSBtciByZW1vdmVkIGJhdHRlciB1cCBsaXZl
They were singing LIVE in the last video, but the backtrack is just a bit louder, so you couldn't clearly hear the live vocals. That's my take.
Dibilangin pre-recorder akhirnya YG buktiin bahwa mereka live dan backup vokalnya beneran dah dikecilin biar beneran kedengaran live mereka❤😊
They just uploaded a behind the scene of their live performance. They were live LIVE.
Their school live performance is really live, BM posted a behind-the-scene of it.
RAMI, RORA and AHYEON are my favorite vocalists/members in BABYMONSTER
same ! they are all amazing
the K-LINE🔥
This process is the same as the following clip where you react "I'm disappointed... | BABYMONSTER - 'BATTER UP' LIVE PERFORMANCE | The Duke [Reaction]" They're singing over the background vocals and dancing the same. Try reviewing your understanding about singing over the background vocals and dancing along again again ... agaaaaaaain and open your ears. It's not different. It's just that you feel that it's different. Then you shape people to feel accordingly.
I still confirm that these 2 clips are the same. It was not pre-recorded and then edited. The chorus part was sung over the background vocals as before. They don't sing on the real backing track, all K-pop groups do like this.
I don't hate you. You try listening to both clips with your eyes closed and having someone else listen to them by randomizing each section. You will find it the same. I think that day you may have encountered something that will shape your feelings. Let you think like that. I speak within reason. If you try this experiment Then you found out that you were wrong. You should also be aware of your responsibility to shape people's emotions.
No worries Duke, the reason I following your channel because you are giving true reaction and comments. I agree with you all the times.
This live performance indeed better 'live' than the previous one 😊
U should react behind the scenes school version than before u agrre with duke lol! It's shameful both of u!
Kinda like BM hatter
I like them all this stage performance are perfected they killed it again and again!! My favorite is Chiquita with very cute Red Cap ❤so Wow🔥
The other one was live but the backtrack was louder than the mics
Im in love with @duke already best reaction so far❤❤❤❤❤
Honestly, live vocals are super hyped to listen to since they sing and dance and how they control both of them are such splendid.
BABYMONSTER - 'Christmas Without You' COVER reaction please
Nah.. the difference is that the backtrack of that first one was louder. But both called LIVE performance in kpop world. Do you think Korean wouldn't know if YG lie? Pls do learn some facts about how music shows produced first..
Thank you. Speak for people in the back 😏
Precisely!
ASA AND CHIQUITA ALWAYS STUNNING
They are so wonderful
Your hearing was originally off. Both versions were live but I think you did make YG realise that people are rather deaf.
Them debuting on YG stage is more so a practice for the girls, so it seems. The girls are still learning to work together, and learning the stage etiquettes.
Ruka and Asa our rap duo 🔥
The staging is so good. The visuals are brilliant.
Duke you should react on babymonster behind the scene (school ver.) their raw live vocals are so good, I swear you'll enjoy reacting to it
RUKA MAIN DANCE🔥🔥🔥
I think we got this live because of Duke. YG must have watched your previous video.
😂😂😂
Ruka ❤️🔥
RAMI'S VISUALS 😭✨👑
I have crush on rora
Get in the line
OMG metoo❤
Rora is mine 🤡
Finally i see smile in your face
I agree with you. This stage was so much better compared to last one. I was disappointed last time, not gonna lie. I know the girls can deliver so why not give them justice by giving them what they can do. enough with the lipsyncer GGs, we have enough of that. They are of different kind, they are MONSTERS.
ruclips.net/video/yTpk4fEDfTg/видео.html&pp=ygUedml2YSBtciByZW1vdmVkIGJhdHRlciB1cCBsaXZl
Theres this saying about, "a true friend is when he/she tells you your mistake/wrong for good". And I believed, a fan should also be the same. What you said on your last vid helped the production for improvement duke. Its not directly about BAEMON, its for the company. Since true YG stan, knows YGAs are for LIVE STAGES. Dont be pressured duke. Those bashers are newbies thats why
yG just released behind the scence of last Live performance that the girls sang LIVE. What Duke said was just his stupid idea, not honest review
Now we want a libe performance . In a award show or whatever .. im sure they will ate it
lets go babymonster🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Congratulations on reaching 300K subs
Yup! Theres a backtrack but for this one you knownits live cuz you can hear the "S" and a bump of the mic if you got a good headphones. 🤭 Looks like YG reading some comments or watching reactors. 🤣
Please react BATTER UP LIVE PERFORMANCE (School Ver.) BEHIND💖
yeah we can hear Ruka saying Loud is very emotional so she a little high pitched there and i like it. shee has CL gen for sure
baby monster live performance behind reaction
Chiquita ❤❤❤❤ Asa❤❤❤
Studio VS Stadium. 😅
Of course, the audio quality is different. 😊 their falsettos are still the same with the prev video. It seems unreal, but that's live🎉🎉🎉.
✌️
Bro why cant ya'll accept that the last live performance was live?the backtrack was way too loud that's why you couldn't hear them properly
U shud learn more how YG use live prerecorded voice..😂 im a YG family so i know the last one is really prerecorded voice without any autotune
You know what was criticized about your last reaction, it was the fact that you cut the video abruptly. You could have shown some respect by letting the video finished.
👉Ha I only just noticed Pharita's black wings!!! The girls wore black combined with red + Chiquita with her little red koreans + Pharitas and her little black wings... Is all this based on a certain concept or is it a message about the image that she will give in the future... Like BlackPink... BlackRed... 😈Well then maybe it's me who's crazy...🙃😅😄
We have the same opinion. The first time I've wanted the first live performance.
ruclips.net/video/yTpk4fEDfTg/видео.html&pp=ygUedml2YSBtciByZW1vdmVkIGJhdHRlciB1cCBsaXZl
From the first they live performance also sing live lol it's just u r ear need check up to the doctor ...
Actually I read comment on korean portal ...
Somebody tell us that YG give many performance bcoz no music show...
It's not bcoz of u 😅
C'mon duke "Christmas without you"
Ruka swag 😎
they sounds so good live 😍🥰
RAMIIIII❤
Duke u talked every time my Pharita singing you should pay more attention to her 😂 thanks to your comment tho
Listen to Mr. Remove were the same sings live. only now they low back-track to floor and let vocals shine.
BABYMONSTER 🐥😈 Batter Up 👆🖤❤️
Even though babymonster has not lip-synced since its first live performance, I just said in this comment that Duke, I hope you become smart, he said, you are real, but I didn't see behind the scene Baemon? If other people say you are fake YG's reaction I think it's true thank you i'm unsubscribe
Rami so pretty 😍
just do what u do, Duke. I like the way you criticize them. cz we love YG's artists and we always wanted the best for them
Thank you so much for your reaction ❤❤❤, I'm so happy that Asa is your bias because she is also my bias ❤❤❤. Can you reaction to Babymonster Christmas without you cover please 🙏
You should watch the behind the scenes of the school version..they are really live singing there. Its just that their voice is really same as the studio version. You must watch the behind the scenes of that. But i agree with you that the backtracks of the school version is louder
amazing babymonster
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
These performances suppose to be their music shows 😊
So niceeee RAMİİİİİİ
When you’re going to react to Lisa’s my only wish???😭 I’m eagerly waiting for your reaction video lol😭🫶🏻💌
YOU MADE YG DO IT, DUKE. KEEP IT COMING. BAEMON JUST HAVE THE POTENTIAL AND YG SHOULD NOT KEEP THEM IN A BOX ❤
Asaaaa
the theme is so monster academy so love it
LET ME SHOW YOU WHO WE ARE!
Please do reaction on Lisa my only wish cover
Waiting for Christmas without you reaction
Princess Pharita ❤❤❤
Finally 😂😂
Still performance video than a live performance but it's cool. its really hard to perform this song LIVE
Rami❤❤❤
You are right. There is still backing track but it’s just lower than before. And I so great to hear they can sing. And they sing well.
Its very good but still backtrack. Rami is so good in live and ruka. But think chiquita did only a little bit of the live
Niceeeee
Please do a reaction video for Lisa's "My Only Wish" cover ☺️
I think people were annoyed because BabyMonster have been on the receiving end of a massive hate train because they decided to not copy NewJeans and their soft music trend. Literally every fanbase and a few creators have been critical of BabyMonster. I think you just dropped your original reaction in the heat of it.
Ruka is so d ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sorry Duke but YG don't follow those pre record lypsinc trend that Hybe create it😒
Pharita ❤❤
yeah i really get what you said in the last video and i don't get why they critisized you and i love you honest opinion.
keep it up!😀
Are u the main dancer of baby monster??😂
Last time, it was your offensive demeanor and how you cut the video that sent a message of disrespect to the supporters of the hard working BM girls. It was also the “disappointed” screen shot title that attracted haters to feast and cheer you. At least this time there was redemption on your part. Just be a bit tactful because there are a lot of BP followers that follows you for a long time but loves and supports their baby sisters BM.
BM tiene todo el potencial, tienen hermosas voces y por eso mismo el playback esta de más, simplemente no deberían de hacerlo, no sé porqué YG se aferra a hacerlo cuando sus cantantes si tienen excelente voz