Amorphis Albums Ranked

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 окт 2024

Комментарии • 74

  • @Snake3004
    @Snake3004 2 года назад +12

    Nice.🤘🏻 I loooove Amorphis.😍 My top 3 are:
    1. Skyforger
    2. Under The Red Cloud
    3. Queen of Time

  • @darksideinferno3454
    @darksideinferno3454 2 года назад +10

    I'm a really big Amorphis Fan!
    This is one of my Alltime Fav Bands and this are my Top 5 Albums!!
    1 Tales from the tousand lakes
    2 The Karelian Isthmus
    3 Elegy
    4 Silent Waters
    5 Under the red Cloud

  • @damnation89000
    @damnation89000 Год назад +3

    1. Skyforger
    2. Silent Waters
    3. Under the Red Cloud
    4. Queen of Time
    5. Eclipse

  • @Toroslim
    @Toroslim 2 года назад +5

    As a new fan of amorphis I gotta say I’m glad you described the feel of each album it gives me an idea of which one I want to pick up next since they have so many

  • @houseofclouse1509
    @houseofclouse1509 8 месяцев назад +2

    My Ranking:
    1. Tales from the Thousand Lakes (1994) - 10/10
    2. Skyforger (2009) - 10/10
    3. Silent Waters (2007) - 10/10
    4. Eclipse (2006) - 10/10
    5. Queen of Time (2018) - 10/10
    6. Under the Red Cloud (2015) - 10/10
    7. Elegy (1996) - 10/10
    8. Halo (2022) - 9.5/10
    9. Circle (2013) - 9.5/10
    10. The Karelian Isthmus (1992) - 9.5/10
    11. The Beginning of Times (2011) - 9/10
    12. Tuonela (1999) - 8.5/10
    13. Am Universum (2001) - 8/10
    14. Far from the Sun (2003) - 7.5/10
    Rating Scale:
    10: Masterpiece
    9.5: Amazing
    9: Excellent
    8.5: Great
    7.5 - 8: Very Good
    6.5 - 7: Good
    5.5 - 6: Decent
    4.5 - 5: Mediocre
    3.5 - 4: Bad
    2.5 - 3: Very Bad
    1.5 - 2: Awful
    0.5 - 1: Terrible
    0: Garbage

  • @PatrickWDunne
    @PatrickWDunne 2 года назад +3

    It's been a while since I've tuned into this channel and I gotta say Questy, your backdrop looks so much better! Love the Torchic in the corner

  • @erikberg5363
    @erikberg5363 2 года назад +6

    I haven’t heard the last 3 yet but I’ll definitely be checking those out soon! Really solid discography, I don’t think any of the albums I’ve heard are bad, though there are a few that aren’t quite as interesting (your bottom 3). Those early EPs are awesome too!
    Here’s my top 5:
    1. Tales from the Thousand Lakes
    2. Elegy
    3. The Karelian Isthmus
    4. Skyforger
    5. Eclipse
    Thanks for the great video as always! 🤘🤘

  • @joepplaysdrums
    @joepplaysdrums 2 года назад +5

    Been waiting for this! Amorphis is one of my all-time favorites! I actuall agree with you a lot (The softer Pasi albums lowest, Circle, Beginning of Times And Queen of Time weakest of the Tomi Joutsen albums, Silent Waters getting the recognition it deserves). Just one note: Tuonela is not as loved as you claim, it's generally ranked pretty low. My top 5:
    1. Silent Waters
    2. Under The Red Cloud
    3. Tales From The Thousand Lakes
    4. Skyforger
    5. Elegy

  • @GabrielMGoncalves
    @GabrielMGoncalves 6 месяцев назад +1

    Passing just to remember the Tales from early years with Tomi on vocals. Awesome versions for those who don't enjoy early vocals

  • @karirytkonen5811
    @karirytkonen5811 2 года назад +6

    I think that either Elegy or Queen of Time is the best. Somehow I appreciate Elegy really high as an piece of art and innovation though Queen of Time is album that I have ever listened the most (probably 100+ times from beginning to end). It sounds odd that you value Halo higher. However I think that it is just praise to the skills of Amorphis that people have so different opinions of which album is best. Let's face it - they are all great.

  • @leonscoretzka801
    @leonscoretzka801 3 месяца назад +2

    1: Queen Of Time (2018)
    2: Under The Red Cloud (2015)
    3: Elegy (1996)
    4: Silent Waters (2007)
    5: Eclipse (2006)
    6: Skyforger (2009)
    7: Tales From The Thousand Lakes (1994)
    8: Halo (2022)
    9: Circle (2013)
    10: The Beginning Of Times (2011)
    11: Am Universum (2001)
    12: Karelian Isthmus (1992)
    13: Tuonela (1999)
    14: Far From The Sun (2003)

  • @MetalTrenches
    @MetalTrenches 2 года назад +4

    One of my favorite discographies to go in blind with this year

  • @bredexponjadea7007
    @bredexponjadea7007 Год назад +1

    Great ranking, here's mine
    1. Queen Of Time
    2. Under The Red Cloud
    3. Halo
    4. Skyforger
    5. The Beginning Of Times
    6. Silent Waters
    7. Eclipse
    8. Tales From A Thousand Lakes
    9. Circle
    10. Elegy
    11. The Karelian Isthmus
    12. Tuonela
    13. Far From The Sun
    14. AM Universum

  • @DavidQuessy
    @DavidQuessy 2 года назад +2

    Skyforger was my intro to them and was addicted to that album for. Long time. But other than that, my 2 favorites are very different versions of amorphis but Queen of Time & Tales From The Thousand Lakes

  • @HeavyMetalAlicorn
    @HeavyMetalAlicorn 2 года назад +3

    With "Skyforger" and "Silent Waters" on top your List is more than okay. I also put the same three on the bottom, followed by "Karelian Isthmus" (never really warmed up to it idk why). Places 3,4 and 5 would got to "Eclipse", "Queen..." and "Red Cloud", the rest in unspecific (i.e. what mood I'm currently in) order with "Tales..." "Halo" and "Elegy" mostly in the upper half.
    Also very much agree on the underrated comment on "Eclipse", absolute Gem that never seems to get the recognition it deserves.

  • @erickribeiro4516
    @erickribeiro4516 2 года назад +1

    I also between Immolation and Amorphis for album of the year, with Soliloquium running a little behind. And boy, we still in april, that year is already a banger!!!

  • @kaptaink1897
    @kaptaink1897 2 года назад +8

    3. The Karelian Isthmus
    2. Tales from the Thousand Lakes
    1. Elegy
    Elegy is in my five "desert island" albums.

    • @Questformetal
      @Questformetal  2 года назад +4

      Its grown on me the most out of all the albums tbh used to be last for me but really enjoy it now

    • @kaptaink1897
      @kaptaink1897 2 года назад +2

      @@Questformetal I didn't like it the first time I heard it, either. Mostly because it wasn't Tales From the Thousand Lakes, which I thought was perfect. It's a grower, not a shower.

    • @marcinhajdasz6807
      @marcinhajdasz6807 2 года назад +1

      Same

  • @panoskarliotis382
    @panoskarliotis382 10 месяцев назад +1

    another nice review :) Skyforger is my favorite Amorphis album as well, other albums I liked are Silent Waters, Eclipse, Beginning Of Times, The Karelian Isthmus and Tales From The Thousand Lakes...I didn't really like the Pasi Koskinen albums...

  • @juhavaris2144
    @juhavaris2144 2 года назад +3

    1.Tales from the thousand lakes
    2. Under red cloud
    3. Halo

  • @nonserviam7723
    @nonserviam7723 2 года назад +3

    14. Far from the sun
    13. Am universum
    12. Tuonela
    11. Elegy
    10. Karelian isthmas
    9. Beginning of times
    8. Silent waters
    7. Eclipse
    6. Halo
    5. Under the red cloud
    4. Skyforger
    3. Circle
    2. Queen of time
    1. Tales from the thousand lakes

  • @Soydrinker999
    @Soydrinker999 2 года назад +3

    Privilege of Evil is really underrated

  • @aaronrose7090
    @aaronrose7090 2 года назад +2

    Hey questy do you think you will do a cattle decapitation album ranking soon ? But anyway keep up the good work man I hope you get to 20k subscribers soon man you deserve it 🤘🤘🤘🤘😁😁😁😁

  • @Dreamwar19
    @Dreamwar19 2 года назад +3

    Tuonela is the first one I heard I love it

  • @simond1574
    @simond1574 2 года назад +4

    I bought Tuonela, when it came out. Loved it and then ignored the band for the next 15+ years :-)
    That was a really dumb move.
    The ranking is really hard as f.ck. The first 5 are fixed. But between 8 and 12 it can change on a daily base. Tales might really be the best Melodeath album ever.
    1. Tales from the Thousand Lakes
    2. Skyforger
    3. Elegy
    4. Queen of Time
    5. Under the Red Cloud
    6. Halo
    7. Silent Waters
    8. The Beginning of Time
    9. Circle
    10. Eclipse
    11. Karelian Isthmus
    12. Far from the Sun
    13. Tuonela
    14. Am Universum

  • @Transilvanian90
    @Transilvanian90 Год назад +1

    As a huge Amorphis fan, I must say that I concur with Questy's ranking pretty thoroughly, except that I'd switch Queen of Time and Halo around! I'm especially glad to see Silent Waters getting the love it deserves, it's an utterly amazing album. In fact, it's my favorite. But their discography is very hard to rank, I love a lot of the albums.
    1) Silent Waters - a masterpiece.
    2) Karelian Isthmus - a godly good death metal album with excellent folk metal hints.
    3) Elegy - unique and beautiful.
    4) Skyforger - a great companion to Silent Waters
    5) Tales from the Thousand Lakes - amazing transitional folk melodeath album.
    6) Eclipse - a huge return to form after the band's slight dip in quality the previous years.
    7) Queen of Time - a masterpiece.
    8) Under the Red Cloud - an excellent album, the benchmark for Tomi era stuff.
    9) Tuonela - the best of the mid-era stuff, and it's underrated.
    10) Circle - better than Beginning of Times, but a bit below-average for Tomi-era Amorphis.
    11) Halo - I enjoy this, but after the stellar Queen of Time it's been a bit of a step back. Just not as memorable for me.
    12) Am Universum - a solid album, bit slower and moodier but I enjoy it.
    13) Beginning of Times - Even the worst Tomi-era stuff is still good and I return to it, just not as often as the others.
    14) Far from the Sun - a couple of good songs on here, but overall the album is the band's creative slump. I don't mind Pasi as a vocalist, but I don't revisit this album hardly at all, so it's got to be last.
    Apart from Far from the Sun which is just okay, I love all their albums and listen to all on a regular basis. Ranking them is extremely hard past my favorite 2-3 and the last one.

  • @benng4376
    @benng4376 2 года назад +7

    I actually love AM Universum. I think I'm in the minority though. I celebrate their entire catalog frankly.

  • @MY1BLACKCAT
    @MY1BLACKCAT 2 года назад +5

    Amorphis is my favorite metal band - the order of my favorites changes because every album they have with Tomi Joutsen are all my favorites and are all amazing - Under the Red Cloud, Halo, Circle, Silent Waters Queen of Time are my favorites but also skyforger,beginning of times - theyre all great - I never listen to any with Pasi - it just doesnt seem like Amorphis to me

  • @natanteam
    @natanteam 5 месяцев назад

    Skyforger is how I met Amorphis on a webradio in 2010.

  • @KnightJirka05
    @KnightJirka05 2 года назад +2

    Yeah, I was waiting for this! :D (wondering if you even like them :D )

  • @aaronrose7090
    @aaronrose7090 2 года назад +2

    Nice album ranking man

  • @RWalters81
    @RWalters81 2 года назад +2

    I have seen them with Pasi live so I like those albums way more than you guys do. Nothing sounded like Elegy and Tuonela when those came out so they are way higher ranked for me. Agree that Skyforger is best Tomi album.

  • @martinnapier6286
    @martinnapier6286 2 года назад

    Silent Waters was my introduction to the band and will always be my favourite. Love the artwork as well

  • @markpalavosvrahotes5575
    @markpalavosvrahotes5575 2 года назад +4

    I will be honest. Except for TFTTL I am not that familiar with Amorphis. So I listened to Halo for the first time today. The verses sound like decent melodeath but the choruses mostly sound like a radio friendly version of A7X. Not one of my favorites.

  • @olegdepapa
    @olegdepapa Год назад

    All you really need with Amorphis is Tuonela, and first 3 albums, because Tuonela was a big shift in musical and vocal direction of Amorphis around 2000, as a result of which every single album afterwards ends up sounding like a blend of Tuonela and Elegy together.

  • @spencergrady5501
    @spencergrady5501 2 года назад +1

    Sorry if I sound like a stuck record, but any UK viewers wanting to do some CD swaps - I got some decent titles that need a clearout. Or is there a forum for this sort of thing?

  • @stasa-X
    @stasa-X 2 года назад

    I discovered Amorphis few months before the Hallo album released with Queen of time and under the red cloud and this moment are my favourites albums,i have also dive into their discography after Hallo album and i love many other albums till now but some albums maybe need more time to grow inside me,so i need more time to say my fair opinion.
    I don't think 🤔 that Amorphis have any bad album just some are more close to the genre that everyone prefers.
    I am not a fan of death metal at all, but Tomi's growls and his melodic clear voice is soooo beautiful plus the beautiful riffs and fantastic solos of Esa Holopainen made them my favourite bad,i love melodic death folk progressive metal now and i love Amorphis's music deeply.
    Between the last three albums that i have buy and have listen many times now,Hallo is higher in my list, second is under the red cloud and third is queen of time, very close each other to my preference.

  • @fightingelements4338
    @fightingelements4338 2 года назад +1

    I'm new to Amorphis, I really love the deep growling kinda Melodeath. I do like the experimentation of this band but i lean more towards the more agressive melodeath like Amon Amarth, Wolfheart and the dark etmosheric like Insomnium, wich album would be a great listen based on my taste?

  • @BradJones-vr2wl
    @BradJones-vr2wl 11 месяцев назад

    I didn't like Elegy at first, But years later I put it in listened. I was blew awayed. Cares and elegy are my two favorite songs by them. Elegy,forger,silent waters and are my am universium are my top four albums by them. I think the vocals on elegy and tales of thousand lakes influenced Be'lakor and dethklok.

  • @ilves6664
    @ilves6664 2 года назад +2

    Hello! We have same taste. Skyforger is their best Release album. And Last put not really bad is Far from the Sun..

  • @techdeath3609
    @techdeath3609 2 года назад +2

    1. Under the red cloud
    2. Skyforger
    3. Eclipse
    4. Tales of the 1000 lakes
    5. Elegy
    Last one is Far from the sun which is boring

  • @astragalusson
    @astragalusson 2 года назад +2

    1) Elegy
    2) Elegy
    3) Elegy
    4) Elegy
    and so on.... :)

  • @BradJones-vr2wl
    @BradJones-vr2wl 8 месяцев назад

    Elegy feels more pure, then there albums. I think cleans are ok because it's not overdone.I love the low growls. I think elegy, better unborn cares are the best stand out tracks.

  • @TheFuriator
    @TheFuriator 2 года назад +1

    TORCHIIIIC!!! ❤

  • @magellan1000
    @magellan1000 2 года назад +2

    I thought that you’d rank Tales From the Thousand Lakes higher since I know you love doom metal, and to me that album actually has a lot of doom!

    • @Questformetal
      @Questformetal  2 года назад +1

      It was my 1 for a long time so yeah love it still but others have grown on me more

  • @henrikkoponen3615
    @henrikkoponen3615 10 месяцев назад

    My list, worst to best:
    Far from the sun
    AM Universum
    Circle
    Skyforger
    Queen of time
    Silent waters
    Tuonela
    The Karelian Isthmus
    Elegy
    The beginning of times
    Tales from the thousand lakes
    Halo
    Under the red cloud
    Eclipse

  • @GeeVanderplas
    @GeeVanderplas Год назад

    My top 5:
    1. Under The Red Cloud
    2. Skyforger
    3. Tuonela (yep I'm one of those guys 😅)
    4. Silent Waters
    5. Halo
    Other than Far From The Sun the band hasn't made a bad album.

  • @Kindred_Wolf
    @Kindred_Wolf 2 года назад +1

    Can u do some gothic / doom metal bands with female vocals like Draconian or something else? 😃

  • @Cattani1982
    @Cattani1982 2 года назад +1

    I completely agree with your top 2 and... disagree with pretty much everything else. :D

  • @chrisbull232
    @chrisbull232 2 года назад

    questy what do you take in for consideration when you rank albums

  • @FaustianSpirit1997
    @FaustianSpirit1997 2 года назад +4

    14) Tuonela
    13) Far From The Sun
    12) Circle
    11) Silent Waters
    10) Am Universum
    9) Halo
    8) The Beginning Of Times
    7) Eclipse
    6) Skyforger
    5) Queen Of Time
    4) The Karelian Isthmus
    3) Under The Red Cloud
    2) Tales From The Thousand Lakes
    1) Elegy
    *
    I suspect that an Anathema ranking is coming in the future now that you've done the majority of the classic Death-Doom bands. C'mon we all want to hear you gush about The Silent Enigma.

  • @BradJones-y3h
    @BradJones-y3h Год назад

    My favorite off of elegy got to be elegy,better unborn cares and song of the 10:37 trouble one only four,I like off there. I think these songs might have influenced the be'lakor singers style. Some my favorite songs come off elegy, tales, even next three albums

  • @matthewjames9939
    @matthewjames9939 Год назад

    My Amorphis Ranking (there are no bad
    albums)
    14 Far from the Sun
    13 The Karelian lsthmus
    12 The Beginning of Times
    11 Tuonela
    10 Am Universum
    9 Halo
    8 Silent Waters
    7 Tales from a Thousand Lakes
    6 Skyforger
    5 Eclipse
    4 Circle
    3 Elegy
    2 Under the Red Cloud
    1 Queen of Time
    😊😊😊

  • @safekeeping2923
    @safekeeping2923 2 года назад +2

    I always liked the "prog rock" feel of Am Universum and Tuonela. Amorphis's first five are in my top five for Amorphis.

  • @wastelander1015
    @wastelander1015 2 года назад

    1. Skyforger 9/10
    2. Tales From a Thousand Lakes 9/10
    3. Eclipse 9/10
    4. Circle 8,5/10
    5. Elegy 8/10
    6. Queen of Time 8/10
    7. Tuonela 8/10
    8. Halo 7,5/10
    9. Silent Waters 7,5/10
    10. The Beginning of Times 7/10
    11. Under The Red Cloud 7/10
    12. The Karelian Ishtmus 7/10
    13. Am Universum 6/10
    14. Far From The Sun 4/10

  • @damiankarras
    @damiankarras 2 года назад

    Tuonela is my favourite by far

  • @thegermanmetalhead
    @thegermanmetalhead 2 года назад +2

    I Don't no what my Favorite is at the Moment Eclipse but i Don't hear Halo. The Dark Waters is a great Song.

  • @tyleragnew
    @tyleragnew 2 года назад +1

    Elegy
    Tales from the Thousand Lakes
    Tuonela
    Halo
    Queen of Time
    Am Universum
    Eclipse
    Under the Red Cloud
    Circle
    Beginning of Times
    Skyforger
    Silent Waters
    Karelian Isthmus
    Far From the Sun

  • @TGTR-06660
    @TGTR-06660 2 года назад +1

    Probably my second favorite band of them all, and I have quite the opposite view. I loved Pasi Koskinen icy vocals. 1. Tuonela. 2. Elegy. 3 Tales from a Thousand Lakes. 4. Am Universum. Then come all the Joutsen albums.

  • @Therionsylar
    @Therionsylar 3 месяца назад

    How can you put Am Universum and Tuonela so far? and Elegy not even in the top 5 ?
    woaaaah

    • @Questformetal
      @Questformetal  3 месяца назад

      Much prefer tomis vocals tho elegy is still great

    • @Therionsylar
      @Therionsylar 3 месяца назад

      @@Questformetal huh? the music is much more important than the vocal. Elegy is better than all albums with Tomi

    • @Questformetal
      @Questformetal  3 месяца назад

      @@Therionsylar the musics better with tomi too, do you not understand preferences ?

  • @BradJones-y3h
    @BradJones-y3h Год назад

    But don't really care for the singles/videos off any of those except alone, divinity and evil inside. Far as an entire album being great by them, I would say skyforger.

  • @MrOmac09
    @MrOmac09 2 года назад +2

    14. Far from the Sun
    13. AM Universum
    12. Eclipse
    11. Circle
    10. The Karelian Isthmus
    9. Halo
    8. Tuonela
    7. Tales from a Thousand Lakes
    6. Silent Waters
    5. Queen of Time
    4. Elegy
    3. The Beginning of Times
    2. Under the Red Cloud
    1. Skyforger

  • @lafarharding1929
    @lafarharding1929 Год назад

    14. Far From The Sun
    13. Karelian Ithsmus
    12. Am Universum
    11. Tuonela
    10. Beginning Of Times
    9. Circle
    8. Tales From The Thousand Lakes
    7. Elegy
    6. Eclipse
    5. Halo
    4. Silent Waters
    3. Queen Of Time
    2. Under The Red Cloud
    1. Skyforger