ORIGINAL Luke vs Darth Vader & The Emperor | Return of the Jedi (1983) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, LPP]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 окт 2024
- Learn more about these sources here: goo.gl/Ff15mN
Please like and Subscribe! Follow us on Twitter: / starwarscompare
![ORIGINAL Sarlacc Pit Scene | Return of the Jedi (1983) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, LPP]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/a60HAK0qW00/mqdefault.jpg)
![ORIGINAL Sarlacc Pit Scene | Return of the Jedi (1983) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, LPP]](/img/tr.png)
![ARGENTINA vs. BOLIVIA [6-0] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 10](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/C3wPtKNbAOA/mqdefault.jpg)
![ORIGINAL Cloud City Escape | The Empire Strikes Back (1980) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, Renegade]](/img/1.gif)
1:21 It's over, Vader! I have the ground!
Vader: Obi-Wan has taught you well!
Vader: "I'm not falling for that again!"
🤣
0:38
Imagine if that went in the final cut!
Before Vader is throwing his lightsaber: "I'll try spinning, that's a good trick."
Empire Strikes Back, might be the best Star Wars movie, but Return of the Jedi, is still my favorite of them all. The whole Luke and Vader, character arc completion/redemption is so damn touching, it always, every time, hits me so damn in the gut. Not to mention, the Luke (destiny) Vader theme, it's so glorious.
zycane nah ROTS was better
@@MCJonCRLKLLR rots is a terrible movie
Barkley no it's the best
@@MCJonCRLKLLR it's a really bad movie, but a great Star Wars movie lol. What I mean is that it's really fun to watch as a Star Wars fan, but terrible if you are judging it.
Kyyy no it's the single greatest film in cinema history
Now that's how you overthrow the chancellor
fluffytoaster427 down a Reactor shaft
fluffytoaster427 You mean, the Senate?
@@JinxTheLooneyToon915 Same thing, isn't it?
@@vomErsten he literally dissolved the Senate
Alexgaby r/whoosh
I love Return of the Jedi so much
Shadow __ I love Star Wars and Return of the Jedi in my Original trilogy Fan way you also.
Who doesn't really?
People who don't like it
@Sir Knight Errant it's only ruined by the sequels if you let it
Sir Knight Errant it means you can’t let things you hate ruin things you love. If you don’t like the sequels but love the originals, ignore the sequels. Ik everything in the sequels is technically still canon and I hate how Luke is written in the sequels, but that doesn’t mean the amazing character development in the originals never happened. Just watch the originals and don’t watch the sequels man, that’s what I’m doing.
@Sir Knight Errant just consider the sequels to be non-canon
So be it... *Jedi.* The moment when Luke has reached the top of the mountain
You know you're a Jedi when you are declared one by the Dark Lord of the Sith.
perhaps palpatine a bit mocked Luke and with disgust or with hatred towards the jedi (or luke), by the way his tone said it
They all still have the lightsaber shadow at 0:35
Ironic.
Underrated Reply ^
they're pretty visible in Ep3 Ani Obi vs Dooku
i mean why wouldnt they be shadows?
+@@abdmin3268 Light doesn't cast a shadow
My God the scene where Vader throws the emperor off the rail is so much better when Vader isn't screaming noooo. I remember watching the newest version of it and hearing it for the first time and just questioned why?!?! What makes it great is that when he's looking on you already no Vader feels this is wrong we didn't need to hear him actually say it
Agreed. Worst change to the originals that Lucas made. Put as many CGI critters in Mos Eisley you want, get rid of that damn "NOOOO" and let us have that scene of silent internal conflict.
@Star Wars Gamer I have it. The only problem I have with that is that Lucasfilm just ripped the theatrical version off a Laserdisc so the quality is crap. We live in an age where they can restore and upscale old Black & White films like It's a Wonderful Life to 4K so it should be easy to give us Theatrical versions of Star Wars on BluRay. But Kathleen Kennedy has said they won't do it because that isn't what George Lucas considered Star Wars anymore.
@@CaptainCardsworth She didn't actually say that, the person who asked her the question asked it in such a ridiculously cryptic way that you could interpret it to mean that they were asking if they would make further alterations to the Special Editions. It was far from a straight question about the theatrical versions, the phrase theatrical version wasn't used, not even original cuts or anything. Also technically speaking they didn't rip it off the laser disc version but rather used the master tape which made the laser disc
@nathaniel amaya He doesn't grab him out of nowhere. With the close ups of his mask you can tell he is thinking about what he should do and also he looks at the Emperor for a moment before he picks him up and throws him off
I never liked the NOO at all. Would have been better if they got Liam Neeson to reprise his role as Qui-Gon Jinn (by voice) and it goes like this. Qui-Gon begins motivating Vader to save his son and at the scene where the Emporor becomes more violent in torturing Luke (6:46), Qui-Gon says "Anakin, with all the strength you gained from your son, shall we finish this together?" (which alludes to Luke screaming "Father, please help me!") and then before Vader lunges to grab the Emperor, he would say "Yes master" (which indicates that despite his fall to the dark side, he still had respect for Qui-Gon). Everyone should know that aside from Anakin's love for his family (his son after seeing him in pain) being the key element, Qui Gon was the core instrument in his redemption.
4:25 If Ian said “Dew it” it would make this scene 10 times better
Dont give George Lucas ideas
Which ever version of this scene you watch, you're in for a treat. It's the best scene in the original trilogy and one of the best in any film.
I am 28 years old and I've seen this since I was a kid. I've read a lot of books, seen a lot of movies, but I will always be amazed by this trilogy's characters. This scene is so fucking perfect. Sure you could have a more flashy fight, but you don't need it. You see how much Luke has grown. At the start he only ignited his saber to defend himself. He tries to pull the good out of Vader. He no longer wants to harm anyone. But then Vader tempts him again with the Dark Side, and you can see Luke's face, half in the light, half in the shadow, symbolizing how he could still fall to either side. And then he finally attacks in rage at the mentioning of his sister. But then he beats Vader, cuts off his hand, and realizes that he's following the same path of hatred as his father. He throws away his saber for he knows that fighting like that isn't going to bring him victory, only defeat. He as risen so much above the emperor that Palpatine doesn't even understand it.
In 5 minutes we have so much character depth and development that it truly still amazes me after all this time.
Well said. I'll never forget watching it for the first time. The tension in this scene was incredible, I could feel my heart beating faster. And then there was a big shock when Luke refused to fight. It was the first time when I saw a movie where a "good guy" refused to fight a "bad guy". No classic final fight. Instead, we got a beautiful story of sacrifice and redemption. For me it was and still is perfect.
00:14
*gets kicked*
huh?
*flies down stairs after*
gaaaaaah!
*palpatine laughs*
0:50 underrated part imo. I love the chilling music as Vader and Luke fight. Not some full on orchestra song, but just chilling almost creepy like chords just as they continue fighting. It’s awesome
A bona-fide John Williams moment.
Just creating a tiny unique emotion through the music.
I bet y'all never noticed that Vader's holding Luke's Lightsaber in the wide-angle shot at 3:09.
DJfrog909 I noticed it due to a deleted bit of dialogue.
Mistake like in many movies
Wym so he took it with the force?
I don't see it, which one is it
@@kylefelipedasilva2432 all of them, check Vader's "free" hand as he turns around looking for Luke
Omg finally a video with out Vader saying "Noooo"
That's either from GOUT, LPP or Harmy's.
Thank you for not playing the audio where Vader yells "NO".
Empire Strikes back is my favourite movie, but this scene is the best in Star Wars. It gets me emotional every single time. A dad’s protective love for his son breaks decades of complete immersion in the Dark Side.
4:24 how come they've never fixed that lightsaber?? The tube just cover it
That's another one for the "Can't Un-see It" department.
its like vader holding lukes saber at 3:10. idk why it didnt get edited.
BurningValhalla that was due to a deleted bit of dialogue.
LUKE: “I will not fight you, father. Take my weapon.”
VADER: “Give yourself to the Dark Side.”
Because George was too preoccupied with making sure we knew that Vader was internally conflicted. By voicing it out loud. Because we’re all idiots apparently.
maybe its under it and we cant tell
My only beef with Harmy's is the close up shots of the Emperor are really dark. Like the deatils on Emperor's face are almost impossible to see and his hood is so dark it's like he's sitting in complete shadow.
Subjectively, that could be seen as a positive, given the mysterious and dark nature of the Emperor.
1:48 Mace Windu purple blade!!!
Only on blu ray disc from 2011.
never noticed it before o.O'
1-Harmy's
2- Grindhouse
3- Blu ray.... I think uh..
4- DVD
DVD is good color grading wise but not video quality wise. But on the dvd the movies look more neutral, blu rays and even despecialized have bothersome tints.
3:18 harmy’s despecialized is the best high definition for original theatrical version of Star Wars trilogy.
The GOUT DVD may not have the best quality, but it does have the most accurate color grading imo. Which is why I will always prefer that version.
so much character in this scene. More than the entire new saga.
harmy's is clearly the best one. The weird purple hue in 2011 is irritating.
I prefer the Grindhouse scan myself.
Studio G Vision Yeah have to agree with you
It turns light pink when he throws it in the blu ray.
that and grind house both look great
Dooku had pink one too.
I hate how they brought back palpatine in rise of the sky walker. Vader’s death went to vein
This fight is shorter than i remember. Still a great and pivotal moment nonetheless.
?True with the transfer to blu-ray, I can agree the the DeSpecialized version is the best.
Gregg DiStefano it’s a recreation a really good one I recommend it over the grindhouse. I think the dirt is a little bit distracting at times
3:17 I have the despecialized version this year.
1:20
Luke: I have the highground father!
Darty vader:oh you...
“highground” “darty”
Darth Vader: Wait, the green sab...!
3:17
Luke: DARTH!!!
Vader: What?!
I kind of like the 2011 Blu-ray version of Return of the Jedi. Because Luke's Lightsaber is completely in a better color. But I'm sure that Vader's Lightsaber in the Blu-ray version still needs more improvement cause his Lightsaber is purple and on the multiple shots where Vader is making a little speech, his Lightsaber is less vibrant and the colors of his Lightsaber blade is changing too much. So Blackout Despecialized should make the Adywan Revisited Edition of Return of the Jedi when the Lightsabers are more vibrant like the prequel trilogy Lightsaber effects and also add more light effects when the Lightsabers are crackling each other and add more special effects too!😊
lacombe75 "True, but for me those Lightsaber effects looks weird in the original. Adywan Revisited only his own Fan edit Star Wars
with A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back. Cause you know that in the 2004 DVD edition their Lightsabers look very unrealistic
without the Bright Light cores on both of their Lightsabers. In the Blu-ray edition, that's when the film fixed and washed out the Lightsaber effects.
Alejandro Vélez right on my man
Alejandro Vélez Now you sound like a fan
Vader's saber is pink. in sides Saber change color.
VITALIY PLISKO
"True, I'm hoping that Adywan Revisited can have his
Revisited version of Return of the Jedi done for a few years later.☺"
The grindhouse version finally corrected the purple force lightning issue
One True Vikingbard it’s supposed to be purple for a reason
My eyes tells me that it’s red pale
@@nintendorakyamato1859 Magenta here...
@@-thebatman- Yes, the reason is poor colouring.
Schadenfreude no it’s not
For some reason I kinda like the look of the Grindhouse 35 mm LPP. It reminds me when I saw Episode IV at the drive inn in 77.
Gregg DiStefano you look like 35
It's honestly the best version, it sure could look better with a better print and scanning but the color is perfect.
The grindhouse is a source from a 35mm print that was released to theatres I think.
I like the lightsabers from Grindhouse but the rest from Harmy. The hazy core and edge gives it a more mystical aura appearance rather than a colored light bulb. Also the color for the Sith lightsaber is more blood red which I feel is suiting.
Before: You underestimate MY power!
After: You underestimate the power of the dark side...
It would be cool to see some of these compared to the washed out lightsabers from the 2004 special edition
2:50 - 2:57
What Vader should’ve said afterwards:
“I HAVE A DAUGHTER TOO?!”
AxeSoccer You stoke that from Hishe
JD04 soooooooooooo what’s your point?
He knew he had a daughter so it wouldnt make sense.
Return of the Jedi is the Best of the original Trilogy.
Have you heard the tragedy of Darth Vader the Redeemed ? This is not a story the Siths would tell you...
Why in the 2011 version is Vader’s lightsaber pink in the middle instead of white?
They fucked up during restoration(when they changed colors, contrast etc in general) it was even worse in dvd in ESB Vader lightsaber was pure pink
Also, the audio that's playing
is from
Harmy's Despecialized Edition
and the Jedi Fury sounds more extended than the Special Edition,
but on the part where
Luke cuts Vader's hand off,
Luke's yell and the
Lightsaber crackle when he cuts
Vader's hand off, both sounds sound weird in the original. In the
special editions Luke's grunt and the
Lightsaber crackle came out perfect!
3:51
(LIGHTSABER CRACKLING)
(LUKE GRUNTING)
God Harmy's looks so damn good. The video quality combined with the color correction just makes it look perfect.
The only differences I see are in Quality and Colours. I like how in Grindhouse, Luke's clothes completely merge with the shadow at 0:50 but the footage has some random red shade, which disappears later. The shade change goes the other way in 2011 version but is equally distracting, it also uses a purple lightsaber once but it is not noticeable in real-time. Harmy's does not have this problem and it also has the most intense lightsaber colours. 2006 has the worst quality and no advantages. Overall, I think the other 3 share the 1st place.
So to make this scene scarier for (in a reboot version) Vader's sake, when Vader is looking for Luke, they could do it entirely from Luke's perspective, only appearing when Vader strike first.
And he shouldn't yell when attacked because he's mostly a cyborg, it takes away his scariness.
The 2011 version was actually better here. They added reflective effects from the lightening onto Vader's armor which seeing how it reflects the practical lights on set makes sense that it should also reflect the lightening effects. That is after all an added light source and it looks weird when Vader's suit doesn't reflect it, almost as if it's not really there... One of the few changes that actually works...
I know the 2011 version was over all terrible but that doesn't mean remove EVERYTHING they changed. Keep a few things that actually do work better and just get rid of the stupid shit like the giant ass that covers the entire screen so you can't see what's happening, the added musical number that sounded like a dated real world song rather than something that would actually exist in Star Wars, get rid of Hayden Christensen's face... yeah those are the more major problems with the 2011 version that have to go.
No. Hayden is the most recognizable Anakin Skywalker and it was changed for a reason. Since that was the last time he was truly a Jedi and that was his view of his Jedi self. Almost all the changes are for the better in my eyes.
Hayden makes more sense. First that's how he remembers himself as jedi and second Anakin/Darth Vader was 45 years old when he died and the original actor was 78. I know that he got burnt and some people say you age faster when using dark side but still.
Palpatine looks creepy in the Despecialized Eddition and Grindhouse.
Force lightning difference?
More bright in 35mm version
Personally I believe Harmy’s has the best cinematic color, but Blu-Ray has the best skin tones
3:53 the 2006 bonus version was the only one that removed the crack in the handrail
I still see it, the lighting just makes it very slightly less noticeable.
You would think they could change vaders lightsaber handle properly when he threw it up.
I think I’m happy as long as there isn’t that “no no”😂
I personally love the 2006 Bonus Disc. It's not anamorphic, and is a poor transfer from a Laserdisc, but I'm willing to trade those off. Whenever I watch the original trilogy, I watch the GOUT DVDs. Many people will like a certain version, and that's okay.
1:38
Luke: *Has the high ground*
Vader: You underestimate my power!
"You've failed, your highness. I am a Jedi, like my father before."
6:52 Bye Darth Sidious, see ya later bro. 🖐
In the portguese version, Vader screams "No!" when he grabs Palpatine
I have no idea why they made it like that but it actually doesn't sound bad
That one in the bottom right is clean as fuck
The 35mm negative looks amazing in this.
3:17 Never!! (Part Of The Dark Side Triggered By Hate)
Miguel Reyes wait he said never? I always heard NOO!
I always heard DARTH!!
My favourite powerful movie "NO"!
A mad Luke yelling at Vader, enraged.
did anyone else notice when vader is saying "if you wont turn maybe she will" he's got the lightsaber pommel in one hand but the beam coming out the other?
Never gets old
Star Wars: A New Hope is my all-time favorite movie ever, The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi are both outstanding hit Star Wars in the Original Trilogy (The Luke Skywalker Saga)
Holy moley! Pause around 1:49 when Luke is dodging Vader's saber. You can see that the blade is coming out of the wrong end! :O
I always enjoyed Star Wars and Jedi/Sith more when they were like knights/samurai who would duel and could do a little magic. Now they flip and spin all over the place and can do anything including literally surviving being sucked into the vacuum of space.
For some reason when I looked at it everything became 3D.
you looked at it crossed eyed that's how things like VR look 3D its overlapping images but their so far apart on this video I barely can do it myself
love star wars episode 6 return of the jedi and like lightsaber deul between luke and his father darth varder in episode 6
Emperor looks best in special edition
thank goodness he doesn't say NOOoOOOOoooo. I just watched the scene on disney plus and I had to find the original sound ...phew...
6:52 Vader: NOOOO!!!!
I love that change! There I said!
What's the grindhouse version?
A digitized scan of a 35mm print that's not received any cleaning.
@Mammoth Supremacy 55 An old print, but yes. A negative isn't used for viewing but for optical processing.
Does anyone else kind of like the coloured cores from the Blu Ray and DVD versions?
yes i love that actually, i always like seeing lightsabers with cores that aren't completely white, gives it a more real and gritty feel
The only shot that the Blu-Ray improved was the Emperor falling to his demise. That’s the only Special Edition change that I think is better.
2011 special edition Blu-Ray looks the best
So the one on the top left is from the second disc of the singularly released Jedi DVD that was released along with New Hope and Empire, first time they were sold separately and not in a box with the whole Trilogy, cause my dad has those I believe
Vader's pinkish Blu-Ray Lightsaber lol
Return Of The Jedi
Special Editions Remastered 2009 And 2010
VHS Y Dvd Y Blu-Ray Y 4K
Which one is the original?
none
The Grindhouse version is the one you would've seen if you walked into a theater in 1983, down to the dirt and scratches from being projected quite a few times. The 2006 Bonus version is the same in theory, but has a lot of digital artifacts caused by poor encoding and bad color grading so it should be avoided. It's also only DVD quality.
The Despecialized Edition is an edit of the 2011 Blu-ray to match it as close as possible to the original version, but it's not perfect particularly in color.
But if you want to watch the original movie in it's best quality, try the 4K83 project, not featured in this video. It's 4K and it's colors are a perfect match to those you would find in an original print, can be downloaded either with and without DNR depending on your taste (DNR removes the grain and makes it look like a digital movie, like the Blu-ray does), and has no scratches whatsoever.
@@uwirl4338 ugh........what about just like the VHS that it was originally sold on? Does the technology not exist to screen cap the entire movie so it exists digitally?
Even though Return of the Jedi is not as good as the other 2 OT movies, Ian nails it in this movie. Every single line he says is awesome. Incredible actor. He even saved The Rise of Skywalker.
It would've been nice to see these in comparison to the remastered special edition version(s).
Someone can tell me which of these versions is the one without any CGI adding? I want the one with just image's quality upgrade...
Is there a way to combine both luke vs vader into one episode
Purple 1:48 Lightsaber
I’m personally a fan of the blu rays all of them
Small thing but noticed the emperor's body falls slightly different and colored in the lightning
Very emotional scene! My one nit-pick is the original seems to have color and lighting consistency issues, in some shots the background looks really dark and in others it looks a bit washed-out. Nothing huge, could be just technological limitations at the time. I’m a photographer, I pick up on these things.
They STILL haven't edited out that g**damn saber shadow? 🤦♂️
The shadow would actually happen. Bright things still cast shadow.
Vader should have just grabbed Lukes lightsaber with the force and stabbed Palpatine in the back instead of picking him up and dying from the lightning
grind house baby
I keep crying in the Jedi Fury scene
the 2011 special edition gave Vader a hot pink saber....
Palpatine is very blue in some scenes in the 2011 blu ray
This is a classic
Harmy's color grading results in Vader losing detail/blending into the background in darker shots. I'm also not sure how I feel about how warm the colors are allowed to get given the environment that they're in.
Might be an unpopular opinion but I really like the first "no" but not the following "noooo"
So much better without the annoying “noooo.”
love that
Grind house is definitely the best version
the scene is more effective without the No NOOO shit
If you will not turn to the dark side, then, perhaps, SHE will!
NO!
just realised the lightsabers don't cut throw the guard rail
its over, father. i have the high ground
Where is the no of the 2011 version
3:10
JOKER: If you will not be nerfed in
Smash ultimate, then perhaps
Daisy will be nerfed instead.
PEACH:
(ANGRILY STANDS UP,
IGNITES LIGHTSABER AND SCREAMS) *NEVER!!!!!*