Agniveer is DESTROYING Indian Army?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 июн 2024
- Prepare for UPSC CSE with India's top educators at Unacademy, now more affordable than ever! Enroll today: unacademy.onelink.me/nWi1/3ds...
******
With the recent election results, the Agnipath scheme has come back into the spotlight. This controversial recruitment system for the Indian Armed Forces is under renewed scrutiny as BJP’s allies have called for its reconsideration. But why? The Agnipath scheme, which recruits soldier-rank personnel, has faced significant criticism both from outside and within the Indian Army. So why did the government introduce it? In this video, we explore both sides of the argument to help you make up your own mind about the Agnipath scheme.
📃Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1f...
******
🔍✍️Research:
Mohit Priyadarshi: / mohitprior
Zaira Khan: / zaira-khan-7435a9189
Nidheesh Manipal: / nidheeshmanipal
Antara: / that_musical_note
✂️🎛️Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
CharanTej: / mograph.charantej
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
Aditya Chowdhury : / infjt_me
Shreyas Jahagirdar: / shreyasnvids
🎨Thumbnail :
Aanchal Verma: / aanchal_creates
Subtitles:
Dhruv Bambhaniya: / dhruvkumar_2920
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
Prepare for UPSC CSE with India's top educators at Unacademy, now more affordable than ever! Enroll today: unacademy.onelink.me/nWi1/3dshvtcz
Kya hoga preparation karke sir abhi NET cancel hua hai NEET ke baache phle hi pareshan
Education ko mazak bna diya hai
sir unacademy ne sponsor kiya tabhi video banaya kya?
one thing that i noticed, was you called INDIA, INDI alliance ???? what going on with you bro ??
agniveer bro not agnipath 😅😅😅
@@johndhillon99 The scheme name is Agnipath, and the recruits are called Agniveers.
Brother you're 2 years late 💀
?! Really??
@@imaddicted8aur kya kabka issue h yeh
Because modi didn't went 400 par now youtubers are openly making videos against him.
It's an ongoing issue. Khatam nhi hua hua kuch. Doesn't matter when you raise your voice.
Bhai ki chatukarita khatam ho gaya shayad 240 ke baad
If the Govt is so concerned with saving money they can cancel the pension of the politicians instead of the army.
That will save more money 💰
bhai army me log jyada h to overall pension of army politicians ki pensions se bahut hi jyada h . aur m support krta hoon ki MPs MLAs ko pension nhi milni chahiye .
Phle ki government hi achhi thi fir unke pas har cheez ke liye Paisa tha
@@sarthakrohilla1988mp mla ki networth 200-300 core hai..aur abhi to bjp ke pass 5000-6000 core to hai hi so budget ka to issue hai ni
dono ki kardo fir jaada savings hongi
Come on dude, the total defence pension is about 1.4 lakh crore right now. Total pension for all politicians combined would be max 0.1 lakh crore (10 thousand crore), so there won't be any dent made at all. And 10 thousand crore is really an overcalculation, it would be much less than that
Cancel the pension of politician first
Pension not only one but as many times as he is elected, he will pension for every term.
BJP BUSS ARMY KA MONEY 💰 BACHA KA ELECTION MA USS KAR KA VOTE LANA JANTI HAY 😢😢😢😮😮😮😮
Bro think of it this way... If you reduce any perk of a politician, you are essentially making it harder for honest people to come in politics... For the corrupt ones, these are just peanuts... Real money goes under the table... So no difference for the corrupt... By doing so we will be sidelining the good people (which we anyway have very few of)...
Like imagine it yourself... Why would you toil more in politics if you could earn more elsewhere...
Full support
Right 👍🏻
Why aren't we cutting the salaries and pensions of corrupt politicians instead of playing with Agniveers? After the completion of the Agniveer , who will give them jobs? This government has no logic
CAPF will easily absorb millions of Agniveers. And please don't use that cliche ghisa pita dialogue for politicians
@@shikharashish7616 hahaha jadaa pain hora for corrupted politician
As said in other comment politicians the count is way less tha army person
Be practical on solution....
@@sandeepjadon8150 exactly. but fir cool bhi toh lagna chahiye na. corrupt politician pe ek dialogue bol deta hu shyd cool ban jaunga
@@shikharashish7616 Jada logic mat de Tera famili hai kyaa politician
Agniveer scheme army se zyada politics mein chahiye, jaha politicians ko 4 saal mein retire kardiya jana chahiye.
Sabse zyada paise save honge.
Je baat ! 😂😂😂❤❤❤ Dil jeet liye 😂❤🎉
Wow that's great
That too without any pension
100%
When i was in class 8, i read in S.S.T that if a person becomes MLA for 1 day he gets life time pension, salary and allowance and many more benefits, why government is not changing that instead of cost cutting from everywhere.😢
If they cut cost from there, I swear, our country would have an unimaginable amount of money to spend on different projects, but any politician who would try to do that, would be removed by all the MLAs. The only ones that can take such a huge step, would be WE, the people of India.
If we unite and protest together!!
@@M16-bf4kuIf we protest, we will be called Khalistani, Chinese and Anti-national. Sad reality of BJP government. We used to protest against everything, now we can't even do that. You may remember students protesting against ministers, then ministers used to resign 😢
@@Anime_Watc29 very true, but we the people have to change that or we would see a china like state (without the development)
Bhai konse school mein padhte the jahan 8th class ki book mein MLA ki salary, pension, allowances wagahrah padhate the 😂😂😂
@@deepaksharma5680 tum nhi padhe usme hamari galti nhi h
If age reduction is the concern, govt can talk to states and get 75 % agniveers absorbed in state police forces and forces like cisf, crpf, itbp etc.
Not possible for states,
Yes that will be
It is tragic for “Yuva Bharat”
One side, a 74 year old was asking for 3rd chance to rule country and here a 25 year old will be taking retirement from service of nation. No doubt why young Indians are struggling so much, old folks making policies for young India aren’t working. And still masses don't want to vote young candidates in their constituencies.
Young folks who think army jobs are regular government jobs have a dubious mindset.
The average of an Indian army soldier is very high compared to most countries and most countries are shifting from man power to machine power .
So less man power is needed in the armed forces .
Still after 4 years of non selection the agniveers are getting quite good money which they can use to do business and studies .
And one needs to be a oxymoron to think that a young country should be led by young person.
Last time we saw Ukraine having zelensky as the youngest and we know what happened.
Experience and track record in governance matters which u all don't have.
@@vibhorejaiswal2997 where is the machine power..there also we suck
@@counterpoint9260 for machine power we need investments.
The current government has opened gates for private investments in defence(many so-called secular parties have problems with that also even after knowing how public firms function).
And most of the defence budget goes into pensions which need to be mitigated in a way to increase the r&d portion in the defence sector.
This boils down to the psychology of human mind.
Am I willing to potentially sacrifice my life for a mere 10lakhs, ruin my 4 years wandering distant lands, disconnected myself from my studies and potential regular employment and get nothing absolutely nothing in return not even a proper funeral?.
The answer should definately be a big NO. I don't care if they call me anti-national or anything but this is not good.
Absolutely 👍
💯
You're not anti national for having higher value for your life
Plus we cannot replicate the success of similar schemes from other countries without matching their level of social safety net.
You will get
Agniveer ke karan Army selection 4× badha hai
Pehle sirf 10,000 ko Entry diya jata tha
Aab 40,000 ko liya jaayega
1 lakh mein mein se Best 25000 ko Permanent rakh lenge
So Extra 75000 are getting Job
That's Agneepath Scheme
+
Those who get retirement after 4 years will get 15lakh + Rupees and other benefits
Not Pension
If they die / Sacrifice themselves for the Nation the Nation their Family will get 1crore rupees
Only those who will be staying Permanent will get Pension
Those get retired after 4 years
They will be take by Assam Rifles, CRPF, SISF etc
If you become politian for a month and you get benefits of pension for your entire life....
And when you serve your country fighting and dying and you get nothing... ❤
Nobody stopped you to become political
Who is fighting war in the first 4 years of service? Is there a war going on that we don't know?
The solution is to take away pensions from the political class, no body should get a pension
Bro you name only suggest that u r not human@@braineaterzombie3981
If you want to take pension from army job you should give upsc cds
Well firstly stop pensions for politicians 💯✔️
Giving pensions to 6k politicians and giving pensions to 12lakh soldiers are two different things. Eventually quantity matters.
@@alluh4261don't try to justify BJPs work. Politicians don't work on their life's. We have no problem if they Spends more money of Army and still give penshione
@Anime_Watc29 You are not the only who pays taxes dude. China, the US and Israel prefer quality over quantity but in India, people think the military service is a job provider. China is cutting their military personnel numbers and spending on UAVs and others.
@@Anime_Watc29Bro think of it this way... If you reduce any perk of a politician, you are essentially making it harder for honest people to come in politics... For the corrupt ones, these are just peanuts... Real money goes under the table... So no difference for the corrupt... By doing so we will be sidelining the good people (which we anyway have very few of)...
Like imagine it yourself... Why would you toil more in politics if you could earn more elsewhere...
Bro think of it this way... If you reduce any perk of a politician, you are essentially making it harder for honest people to come in politics... For the corrupt ones, these are just peanuts... Real money goes under the table... So no difference for the corrupt... By doing so we will be sidelining the good people (which we anyway have very few of)...
Like imagine it yourself... Why would you toil more in politics if you could earn more elsewhere...
In Airforce agniveer denied to work round the clock … pressure on permanent soldiers increased tremendously. Total security is compromised no motivation in them and neither willing to work. They are doing manhandling nd abusing seniors . Working environment bohot Ganda ho gya hai…
Pahle NEET ko lekr vivad tha ab NET exam cancel kiya gya maze ki baat yeah hai ki dono hi NTA karwati hai
Education is a joke in our country 😢
If you don't like vishwaguru Bharat then go to Pakistan....
@@afnankhan7086 are you serious or its sarcastic?
@@Satyam_1404 lag toh sarcastic hi raha hai
@@ankurjoshii tab thik hai nhi toh ache se suna deta
nta= nakli topebaazi agency, kya he hope rakhenge is agency se
Fund Education,Defense,Research etc❎️
Fund Ministers✅️
true bro they keep increasing salary and funds of politicians but cutting costs everywhere else
They give new cars to politician...worth of 30 to 50 laks after every 3 or 4 months@@Its_just_Avi
Really you think defence are better in upa 1 and upa 2
How old are you bro..
@@Its_just_Avi
@@tamaldutta1352 I just said that politicians keep increasing their funds and salaries, did not mention of UPA or NDA anywhere. Also, this is about how tax payers' taxes are utilised and how government's stance on it seems hypocritical by steps like "Agniveer". This is a governance issue as a whole, so try not to make it a ruling party vs opposition issue
About 60% of Defence Budget goes to Just Pensions like literally when are we going to modernise the army
I think the growing number of NEET candidates is equitable to the case of NDA/CDS . The back breaking competition is also due to people wanting an assured govt Job with respect and having future possibilities of expansion, such a mindset will not create Pioneers and leaders, but people whose entire existence is filling a criteria, such deplorable employment condition kills creativity and increases societal pressure, we dont only want govt officer and doctors, but also musicians, shopowners, businessmen, woodworkers,religious teachers, cleaning staff (with proper training, education and gear) .
If we introduce internships in highchools in such jobs all over the country with focus on practical skills once a month or as workshops with joint aid from public, private sector and govt, we might create a diverse workforce who are happy with what they do and are good at it
Being a pioneer in indian mindset society is a crime
अगर army का budget कम पड रहा है,.... तो उनका budget बढ़ाए पैसे नही हो तो mp,mla,ministers को जो lifetime Heavy pension , allowance मिलते है उन्हे भी कम कर लो😂 कोन कोन सहमत है like करो 👍
Brother, why don't these leaders give up their own pension? They themselves are taking four pensions.
Bill pass karwana padta hai bro
number of people as MP is way less
@@nemesiszzwhat about MLAs? On average each state has atleast about 80 MLA
@@tanmay6207and how many members in the army. Bro thinks 80 is a large number
@@nemesiszz Less or more point is why should they get pension all their life even if the serve just one term
I was one of the aspirants . I cleared my physical and medical test on 02/02/2021. Centre - 2STC GOA .but my writeen exam was postponed atleat 5 times throughtout the year .The reason behind the postpone was covid according to the govt but the govt was conducting huge election campaign amidst that covid for 2021 lok sabha election. Atlast our written exam was cancelled and the complete panel was dismissed . after that agniveer scheme was introduced . This govt has wasted our complete one year . After this i applied for soldier nursing assistant exam and i cleared the exam but by that time i lost my moral and motivation so i didnt practice for the physical round properly and i couldnt qualify the physical round.
I also have almost same story
Stop pensions for MP/MLAs. 99% of them are crorepatis.
Literally every one is crore pati and most of them earns 100 crores 😅😅
And usse kitna bachega?? Kitno ko milta
Angniveer is not for saving govt money and directing it to get better equipments. Its for the greed of peoples. I know r&d budget is low. It should be increased. But it doesnt mean we have to cut the stomachs of our mighty soldiers. Who will be willing to spend precious years of life(teen age) hardworking for a job that doesnt even recognise ur value. If u want more budget, then give Defence ministry more budget. Why mp and mla should get so much pension. Dont u see, how much these mp and mla get pension and other benefits. Most unacceptable thing is that, if u are elected as mp or mla more than once, then u will get more pension. Why dont they implement a rule of, only getting pension once. Not only pension they get a ton of facilities including bills, fuels, healthcare and many more. They have ruined the literal meaning of pension.
Mo it is not at the cost of soldiers stomach
Those who are selected will get good pay. .
@@namangupta3160why are Officers not selected on Agnipath schemes if the scheme is do good?
@@Dvlogzilla because they are very less in numbers. So they don't incur too much cost. Age doesn't matter for the officer level.
@@Dvlogzillaas mentioned in the video. The officer class is only 4%.
Should they target the 4% or rest of them/
Source : trust me bro
Central government can talk with state governments to absorb the 75% of Agni veers in state police services.
Then what happened to the other local police aspirants, ur unemployment bar jayaga
@@Movies-eq6xy as per UN standards, there should be atleast 222 police per 1 lakh people. In India, the actual posts are around 180 per 1 lakh. If we consider vacancies it is 142 per 1 lakh. So you see that there is severe shortage. State governments do not have any money for recruiting, training and operating the additional workforce.
Since the Agniveers are already recruited and trained at the military level, state governments can save on these expenses and can get additional workforce. It's a win-win situation for both the parties.
@@hanuma1512 what do u think? What would be reasons behind for not filling vacancies of police personnels by state government? Is it because they can't? Or is it because they don't want to? If this was ever about happen this would have happened a long time ago. What do think why are they not filling vacancies of Indian railways? See government is definitely trying to do cost cutting.
@@swapnil..12_ your point maybe correct. But there is another issue here. We see that the reserved seats continuously go unfilled. And these seats have to be carried over next year.
So it is highly possible that when you see that no. a large chunk of it is for reserved posts.
@@Movies-eq6xy nah those people are aspirants they can prepare for many other exams also that way we can easily provide long term employment to agniveers while retaining the benefits of the policy from economics perspective this is a good idea
as a personn living in army area(cantonment) i can see the impact of this agniveer scheme in front of my eyes - the new agniveers are not very passionate,there is shortage of army personnels . i just cant explain the situation before agniveer and after agniveer it had just gone bad and worse....
I think corruption will increase in army. The soldier who is close to officer will be given priority among top 25 %. We know how promotion works in corporate and officers might demand bribe also because end of the day they are human being.
Yeh apko abhi pata chala, kabhi socha hai nco ki promotion kaise hoti hai.
Then: Modi ji
Now: Narendra modi 😂😂
Power of election results
koi nahi bechare ko dard hua h....koi nahi...
@@BhupenderSingh-mm2rk to Pakistan chala ja
vo toh apna sanskaar h
❤
@@ayushnews5735uno reverse😂
Decrease the perks of upsc aspirants then see what happens 😂 in the name of saving budget
Yes... enabling bureaucrats might be one of the biggest expenditures of our government.
Stop pensions to every one ,politicians ,bureaucrats, diplomats,officers on special duty ,judges,chief justice everyone ,with immediate effect.even to those who are already getting it ..stop there pensions..
If the Aim of Agneepath is to reduce pension given to retired army officials
Then why not start with MLAs & MPs 😂
MLA & MPs numbers are in few thousands
Where as army soldiers numbers are in millions
@@yuvraj1971 even retired one get pension and one who become even for one day
Not just 543 members plus 245 of Rajya sabha
@@yuvraj1971Each MP has money in crores. While army person make so little.
@@yuvrajsingh099
You have to be rich and powerful if you want to become MP
@@yuvraj1971 How many of them got it legally.
Mohak bhai, even in officers there's something called short service commission, who also serve for 10-14 yrs without pension
That’s a lot of time. And officers are college graduates so they have a backup to fall upon. Almost all officers can do mba mtech in premier institutes for free cost.
@@mverick5444 bhai esse tho anyone can take higher education in india
@@mverick5444 Ha bhai jaise graduation krke job badi aasani se mil jaati ha 😂
@@kingofcosmos289 toh bina graduation se aur bhi easy hoga ghar pe unemployed rahna ka plus officers get posted as managers of banks not as watchman or security guards like normal jawans
bhai sun officer 14 saal karte hai unka salary package bhi bhoot jada hota hai or unko bank manager ki job mil jati hai jese he vo retire hote hai
Military Modernization ✖️🙅 Buying Third Class Ammunition and Military Equipment at a high price from Defence Contractor Adani so that Adani becomes richest man of the world ✅
Mostly government companies me banta hai... Rare kabhi ye sab se khareedte hai...
If you don’t know shits then don’t talk
@@RajivKumar-xp9qn Adani has entered this market and is now a defence contractor.
@@abhimanyusuryawanshee4470 Agniveers are use and throw labours. Yahi reality hai.
So, what's your point? Tata, L&T, Bel, Mahindra and many other indian companies supply equipment and products to the armed forces. Its better to buy from Indian companies then purchasing from russia and the west.
Rather than saving money by creating temporary post and reducing salary why can't government stop permanent pension of MP MLA Ministers, why can't they take over assets of corrupted officials Netas and auction it publicly to earn money? Today railways are accident prone, Army is casualised, banks are government banks are under employed, Police and Government employees are less compared to our population.
Justice for Students 🇮🇳
Most are joining on their own, non are forced
@@SnoXMafiaare you a soldier or not
@@hulk_6963 i am an agniveer
Such students are being motivated by anti India forces
@@SnoXMafiatayari kar kavhi pata chalaga
How does the government think that they can play with the future of hardworking students first future soldiers and now doctors too?😢
Main baat to capital ki hai
4% log ITR bhar rahe hain
Modern weapon kaise kharidega govt bataao bhai???
😂😂😂😂@@upendraodiavlog
@@upendraodiavlog Bhai logical baat mat kar, inko 4 saal ki service mein bhi pension chahiye. Ye logic-phobic hain!
@@undefeatableyt7 han bhai ghuma phiraake baat "PAISO" ki hai
Army is for defence not for providing sarkari naukri. If you want sarkari naukri please do not look for army
This shows that it doesn't matter even if you have honestly served your and loved your country, if you don't have money or job. Nobody is there for you. I know the reality but never thought would realize in such a way.
Now I think as it would affect the experience of our soldiers and hence decreasing quality of soldiers due to lack of training and trust bw soldiers and can cause internal security problems. Agnipath be removed and they must consider 17 years service with pension of half the salary for JCOs
Politician ki pensions se bhi to weapons karide ja sakte hai....
This type of arguments make you look weak. How many politicians are there and how many soldiers are there. Is there any comparison by the amount of money spend.
@@user-kg2ij8km3hyou are weak to understand how these mps and mla hold money of many soldiers
Dude stop trying to reason with ppl those who find army an employment bank.@@user-kg2ij8km3h
If a person becomes mla or mp for five,he will get five pensions...So see how much pension a politician get
@@user-kg2ij8km3hthere are totally 5631 MLAs MPs MLCs in total plus huge amount to retired and even if u will be representative for 1day
Pension of a Soldier is headache for government but what about those curropt polititions 😢
If govt. had to make army more youthful they should bring down retirement age of all recruits of all ranks.
Bro idk how they commenting just after 2min, like JUST WATCH THE VID FIRST!
Agreed 1 min after vid I find a 1000 comment
And why will people listen to you or anybody?
they are from the - this is why education is important - gang
Then why you opened the video 😅@@souravpaul2179
literally if you see the comments its all the same arguments regarding pensions etc.
we want same scheme in politics, eligiblity ke lie pehle written exam do upsc ki terah, uske baad election lado.....4 saal kaa tenure, naa koi pension naa koi suvidha, na laakhon ki salary...4 saal baad retire karo 11 lakh rupiya ke saath...uske baad jegah mila to inlog kaa niyukti panchaya sachiv level pe karo, nahi to tally sikha ke data entry kaa job kare....jo is scheme ko sahi bata rahe wo apne ghar se suru karen
Not possible bro , for that bill has to be passed
Right brother
Koi politics mai interest nahi dikayega aur desh satyanash hoga
written exam rattebazo or gawaro ke liye hota hai jo luck pe dependent hote hai...asli insaan skill or practical kaam me biswas rakhte hai..politician bachpanse clg school dropout krke netao ke piche bhag doud krte hai network banate hai...leadership skill sikhte hai...logo ke aage bhasan deke bharosa dilwana sikhte hai phir jake mp/mla bante hai...15-20 year lagjate hai....upsc exam deke v 70% ias ips ghotala krte hai..ratt ke exam dene se koi intelligent ya accha insaan nhi hojata nhi to itna ghotala nhi hota...wo exam khud ke liye dete hai ias/ips khud ke liye bante hai...isliye chip indian mindset ye exam se intelligence ko check krna chorke practical kaam me focus kro....jitne bade bade billionaire hai or bht se millionaire jo khandani business chala rahe hai wo sab dropout hai...skilled hai practical kaam krke bane hai...or jitne academic educated hai wo govt job tak simit hai...kucj hin business krpate hai...
😂
Good Research Bro and covered All the aspects bout the scheme thanks for this detailed video.❤♥
"A business minded leader,may approach national security issues with an eye towards identifying potential economic opportunities, which can sometimes lead to prioritizing financial interests over national interest".
Hence, " Suit-Boot ki Sarkar",always favouring his billionaire friends.
We need to encourage these kind of RUclipsr who spread awareness among us and share knowledge so that our world become livable, Nowadays I see the people who shows us shittest content get more fame than youtubers like mohak. We need to get aware to make our lives livable by thinking ethically and logically.
Why modi don't retire in 75 and he is retiring 23 yr in agnipath 😢 such a shameful scheme
He might retire really soon. This is his last term
The retirement age of the Prime Minister of India is not mentioned in the Indian Constitution.He serves at ‘the pleasure of the president’.
The term of the Prime Minister is five years, which is the tenure of the Lok Sabha.
As long as a person enjoys the confidence of the majority of the Lok Sabha, he can continue in power.
25% best personnel ko permanent recruitment milegi uska kya? Sabko baitha ke Paisa khilayenge to millitary ke different sectors ko modernize karne ke liye tum apni jeb se paise doge?
@@braineaterzombie3981 75 yrs m retire nhi liya 23 wle phir se naukari search kre vaise govt job m paper leak ho rhe h job kya ghanta milegi
@@vibhutisrivastava2789ye modernization ki baat kaha kahi gai he bhai?
I think agniveer is a good scheme the motive of the scheme is good but how it is made and implemented is totally wrong.
First of all the age limit which is 17-21 is okay. Then the training is of 3 years and after just 1 year the soldier is made to go. This is not good as the army invested time money resources in training of that soldier and in just 1 year of service he is thrown out this is not good. Therefore the service period should be of minimum 4 years. And after that 25% of total people should be recruited in the army. 25% should be recruited in central armed forces like crpf, itbp, bsf, cisf etc. remaining 50% should be directly recruited in police force of different states as constables and promotions for these should be fast as compared to others. One more benefit from this will be that there will be regular recruitment of people in police no matter exam happens or not and these are trained disciplined people so the efficiency of police would also increase.Also, the people who do not want to become constable or do not want to join central armed forces then he should be given faster promotions as compared to others if he joins as an ias ips irs or other similar services. Also, if he does not want to go for a government job then the fund which is collected during his 3 years of training and 4 years of service that would nearly become 15-20 lakhs and by this if he wishes he can complete llb from top university of India like nlsiu Bangalore after cracking the entrance. Or he can go for a mba degree from top colleges or he can start his own business and as govt. Mentioned that these agniveers can get loan of 20 lakhs also this can help them in setting their business.
In this way the scheme can be beneficial to the people as well as the nation. But reservation in govt. Exams or any other exams should not be given to them as they are already reputed because they served in army and they have a decent amount of money. So they are not backward neither socially nor economically.
That's it.
The people who join army are mostly from middle class or poor families and u think they can save 15-20 lakhs from their salary to study at iim and all..they have a responsibility to take care of their families...overall the suggestions u gave is good but in this point it's totally incorrect...and the only solution is population control
@@Mrpositiarmy need less soldiers for future wars you know that?
@@AryanSingh-xu1ng that's why i said population should be controlled
JAI JAWAN JAI KISAN✊
It is about the security and defence services of India Their dignity should be justified. Indian govt . really need to make changes about the Agnipath scheme .
I think for the growth of the Indian Army in terms of tech and mindset, Agniveer is a good scheme introduced by the govt. Normally people think that agr army mai hogya toh life set hai(in regards to pension and benefits) but doesn't think about the army. with this only the best of the best will be taken and there will be a mindset of being good at everything during the training.
I don't think unemployment should be fixed by adding people into the army.
Also govt should focus on the dropouts of the Agniveer, i.e. where they will get a job after 4 years of training bcz involvement of Trained personnel with unwanted elements (eg naxals) can become a great issue.
That's my thought. Me being the son of a Indian Navy Personnel.
10:39 Paise ki baat hi mat karo. Full budget ka 50% Politician ke Pocket aur election me jaata hai. 11:35
Source : trust me bro 😂
Dimag se paidal ho kya? Kon se budget ki baat kar rahe ho? Government budget ka 0.5% tak sayad MP's ki salary mei jata hai aur elections sabhi party apne funds se ladti naaki government funds se.
Whats ur source 😂...matlab kuch bhi ..do u even know whats budget ?
@@vibhutisrivastava2789 toh ek kam karte hai MP or MLA ke liye Agniveer lagu kar dena chahiye.
govt gets more than enough revenue from GST, PSUs, Dividends, Challans, CESS, SURCHARGE, TDS, TCS on foreign remittances, Stamp Duty, STT, Custom Duty, VAT, Corporate Tax, Non Debt Capital Reciepts, Gift Tax, Octroi, etc.
Even if the "4% ITR" people are exempted from Tax, then too govt have more than enough capital.
The problem is careless spending. If they spend the revenue wisely, they will solve all of the problems.
Just do three things to reduce revenue wastage:
1. Eliminate all the subsidies
2. Eliminate freebie culture
3. Eliminate all type of Pensions.
That's all they have to do. But they won't do it, because vote bank and power retention is much high in priority list.
The honest taxpayer is already milked to the fullest.
True
Honestly I would love if the government could eliminate freebie culture and educate indians how it affects our economy but sadly it wont happen cuz both the opposition and the current government needs vote bank.
they want to show we are developing fast so they save that money and tell our value have increased, so many government job vacant but they dont want to fill the job because they have to give money
More than 80 crore people rely on free ration (Gov data)
You can abuse freebies however much you want, but the demographics of India doesn't allow you to abolish it.
It's easy to say "eliminate freebies" for someone who doesn't earn less than 100rs a day.
Bro, no sarkaar can do even one of the points you mentioned. Because they would be out of the government asap and the decisions would be reversed. We can't talk fantasy, we have to live in reality.
Something that USA has that we can also opt is having certain amount of seats reserved for veterans in public and private sectors, and also providing them free education after 4 years of service..
That’s why, you must have strong economy, if you want to be a superpower in terms of military power. Instead of doing hindu-muslim, focus on economic growth.
If people think that a Jawaan knows what to do in the first 4 years of service then they are grossly misinformed ……it takes much more than 4 years for a fighting force jawaan to become well trained in his weapon be it small arms or “the big guns “ ……we should never forget that a soldier of Indian army is not that well educated ……it takes a lot of training not just with the weapon but also with the people they go on operations with ……wars are not just one guy killing 20 guys as they show in the movies ……the chemistry that soldiers develop by working with familiar faces also takes time
Having poorly trained younger than before jawans is not the net positive people think it is
Or else why has the army opposed this from the very beginning …..such is the political environment that a RSS affiliated retired Army chief cannot even publish a book post retirement
You do realise, the intend to keep 25% of the people for full time. They will be the ones fighting. Let's face it, the future wars will not be fought with that much man power. Future wars will be fought with advanced weapons. Even with 25% agniveers, we will have enough people who are trained to do well.
There are legit problems with the agniveer policy but the 4 years window is more than a lot of other countries with successful and functioning army's. The best Example is Israel.
@@dakshmore1383Israel has high class Research money. They spend 20 percent GDP on Research, and make their own guns. Do we have the same thing? Israel is just a small country
@@Anime_Watc29 but the conversation was not about research money but about the 4 years policy, money and research is a separate issue. Classic Modi move release a good policy in principal fuck it up in practice and slowly try to improve it with changes.
@@dakshmore1383 you should also think about the geographical situations too of our country it is very difficult to fight a war or to serve in our military or armed forces due to the extreme conditions on our borders especially when you compare it with countries like Israel
At 3:16
You are briefed wrong Mohak
There are also Short Service Commission ( SSC ) entries for officer cadre of Indian Armed Forces. A SSC officer in Indian Army serve for 10/14 years. At the end 10 yrs you have 3 options. Either elect for a Permanent Commission or opt out or have the option of 4 years extension. They can resign at any time during this period of 4 yrs extension. And Most important SSC officers do not get any "Pension".
Hope you will correct
But bro instead of pension they get more money like more than 50-70 lakhs
This money is enough to start a best business
And they are officers they can be a CEO of any company because of management skills & leadership qualities but not a Agniveer soldiers can get a sure shot pvt job
Not at all. Army simply makes you of no use at all in the civil world. Maybe you looked at top 1% of the retirees . Other officers also struggle after coming out. But atleast Army teaches the mindset of Never giving up .@@anuraggautam4933
@@anuraggautam4933army is there to defend the country, not provide sarkari Naukri with pension and medical facilities
@@anuraggautam493350 Lakh for group A officer at retirement are peanuts
Agniver type schemes should be applied to other government positions. The biggest share of pension cost comes from there not the army.
It is a really good video that talks about the genuine issues faced by the youth. Moreover, You talked about solutions and ideas. That should be appreciated. Keep up the good work man
Agniveer 6 month ki trainnig aur 4 saal ki duty se kuchh nhi sikhne wali , retired officers ke interview dekho
To NDA do CDS do , agniveer me kahe atke ho .
@@user-wr6yi2nh5c Bhai selection rate dekho NDA/CDS or bharti ka
Or Army sirf officers se nhi chlti , jawano ka bhi utna hi yogdan hai jitna officer ka
@@user-wr6yi2nh5csabhi ias bano is logic se fir
@@toughesttakecoverbutnotme4404 agniveer se pahale kaise bharti hote tha JCO s, hawa se prakat to hote nahi the
@@toughesttakecoverbutnotme4404 JCO Examination
Make similar video on conditions of GDS employee in post offices >>>>their conditions are far more worst than agniveers ... please i beg you to make a video on GDS employee topic🙏🙏🙏🙏
Very nice video on Agniveer and its shortcomings. The new system is a must for current military warefare. Really liked the solution of absorbing agniveer soldiers in police force. Kudos to your team for research and presentation !!!!
Mohak
Please talk against the saffronisation of NIT colleges in India.
- regional language books removed from library
- all religious books other than bhagavat Gita removed from library
- professors talk pro bjp ideologies in social media
- pro ayodhya temple rallies not stopped on inauguration of temple
- students who protested against ram rajya rallies were suspended
- students fests including Ragam one of the biggest campus cultural fests cancelled to supress protests
- library time curtailed and night curfew imposed to contain students protest against ram rajya rallies in campus
- students who protested received 6 lakhs as fine. The highest student fine in the country?
All these happened in NiIT Calicut in the past one year
Except education everything is happening
Also make videos on why Muslims have UCC?
Why Congress tried to Paas Communal Violence Bill? .
Why JL nehru didn't want to Make hindi as national language...?
Why Bal Thakrey were banned from doing Elections?
Anti Hindu laws passed by Congresss...
Why Everything is given on the name of Minority? Why is there nothing for Majority
Based
@@Shantanu_x_777 these all problems look nothing to what above comment is
That's why defence aspirant must prepare for clearing NDA exam ❤.
Me too defence aspirant but I know the background of Agniveer that's why I am preparing for NDA.......😊
NDA,CDS,OTA aur baki officers exam ko milake bhi 2000 bhi officers nhi bante per year
To baki log kha jaye
@@RemoveAgniveerScheme Yes,you are right.Some people are saying government Is providing varied opportunity but In contrast their is higher youth unemployment in Country.
Competition now a days bass Government competitive exam Mai hi nahi hai balki yeh toh private sector mai bhi hai....
@@SagarTidke-NDABut after elections In some Government exam seats were drastically increased like in Gd Constable from 26000 to 46600 and also in Rrb Alp from 5700 to 18800
@@AD-ob3im if you argue in one thing then it won't be change.Aspirant is protesting against agniveer scheme and another incident whole india knows that is neet Scandal....
@@SagarTidke-NDA I am not taking government side I was just spitting the facts and there were some speculations that agniveer scheme can be modified and nta should be criticised for neet paper leak not ruling government but you can criticise the government for not taking right actions against paper leak and you can't unseen that more vacancies are now coming
Really bro my friend's father was a fauji and he also wanted to be one but this agniveer bs changed his mind he wanna settle in US now
Great topic bro and your Whole research is awesome 😎 bhai . Great job . Keep it up😊
National security should not be compromised at any cost.
50 thousand civilian employees should be removed from the ministry of defence from our defence budget. Special budget should be allocated for salary and pensions for them.
Why? You can't clear competitive exams the why blaming them? Lol
I think persion schemes should be suspended for all politicians and high rank officials and should be given only to those Army officers family who had lost their life during duty or on border.
And who will pass these laws and make these schemes? Right. Politicians👏🏻
Ur right
@@HDB41 Exactly😂
Main baat to capital ki hai
4% log ITR bhar rahe hain
Modern weapon kaise kharidega govt bataao bhai???
true bro they get separate pension and funds for everything each time they are elected but can't afford money for other govt. workers
This could also lead to armymen switching loyalties for financial stability or may join some private mercenary army which would make things worse.
The recruitment of the 25% agniveer will most probably be through a lot of recommendations and nepotism and not through merit for sure
Mostly poor family boys consider to serve in army casue they can't study for so long cause of money problems.. but government is targeting only poors for profit..
Bs sarkar ko yahi se paisa bachana h, NPA har saal badh rha udhar kch ni ho rha, problem solve krna h but rural India ko suffer krna hoga
NPA ke aakde dekho dost they are at an all time low year on year.
@@omgajananhs write off kardiya bhai🤡
Bhaiya
Jo apni puri life de diye military me .
Unke bacche jab 12 complete karte hai tab wunhe retire hona hota hai. Aab college fees kesse bharege woh only itni kam pension par.
Agar onduty chot lag jaye toh aage koi job bhi nahi kar sakte . Aab aage kya.......
Jinki family hai unse pucho bhai😡
Military se dur rahe government
Is scheme ki vajah se meri jindagi kharab ho gai nahin to bhai army mein hota Aaj
Physical medical sab ho gaya tha last mein exam cancel kar diya😢😢😢😢😢😢
agnipath scheme is only launched for doing corruption so that they can eat soldiers money in the name of buying weapons
❤️❤️❤️
Being extremely anti-social is an important point. Take a look at Sainik Schools (or other strict hostel schools military/non military), people who don't clear NDA exams so many times end up struggling in the real world after being in an old school hostile environment after learning by abuse with no internet etc. Now imagine that but with Life and Death Scenarios in the Army - you come out with either PTSD or one of those brute minded people who only see people's worth in rank. At least before they lived in the armed force circle. 4 years whatever mental treatment has been done would be extremely detrimental in the real world.
Why didn't they reduce the pention of politicians?
Thanks for the detailed video,point In can arrive at if the idea is new so will take time to settle in ,but govt should be open to feedback and understand the success metrics and do course correction for a successful execution
Brother ab jara Delhi water crisis per bhi video bna lo ....🙏🙏🙏
Finally, I have been waiting for your video on this topic for a long time.
Always satisfied with your episode sir 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you so much for making this video ❤❤❤❤❤ from Nagaland 🙏
Sometimes I believe Mohak ka sabun thoda slow hai. Yeh scheme ko aaye 2 saal hogaye hai.
Making ministers and politicians rich is every government’s first priority. We are a nation of billions, who cares about us!
I have a simple solution.
Government should cut off the pension of Politicians and use the same amount in defence.
Army ka budget Kam kyu karna Neta ji ke pass fortunar ha apni toh Sarkari Gaadi ki kya zaroorat hata do 😊😊😊😊😊😊
The scale of army pensions under OROP is such is that, any such simple solution won't make a dent. I understand agniveer is not perfect, and it should be reformed and tweaked but it's the right direction taken
Come on dude, the total defence pension is about 1.4 lakh crore right now. Total pension for all politicians combined would be max 0.1 lakh crore (10 thousand crore), so there won't be any dent made at all. And 10 thousand crore is really an overcalculation, it would be much less than that
Average agniveer opposer math skills:
Average agniveer opposer math skills:
@@tarunyadav3567 kya tum khud ya apne bhai ko agniveer ma Jaane ke liye kaho ge Mera Bhai Jaa Raha ha.............
Baat karta ha
Your videos make Mangal my mind to open the mind to explore 😊
What we need is more police force for maintaining internal system. The agniveer should be given preference
I've qualified in all the three forces in agnipath scheme but I didn't go in the second stage.... because I've lost all the confidence and morals when people come and say " 4 saal bad toh nikal diye jaoge toh fyada kya hai.."😢😢
Then u r fool that u listened to people or u r lieing ( sorry if u r not)...
This coalition government instead of single party majority is the best thing to happen since 2014.
Yup.They will not be able to do anything on their own
and then you guys say ki china itne aage kyun hai....jara sochna kyun hai....
@@BhupenderSingh-mm2rk Bjp will again get the majority if they remove agniveer
@@AntikBasu-hk3ibnah agniveer scheme is important for armed forces
@@AryanSingh-xu1ng it needs modification
Lovely video. Excellent explanation. Such video is strength of your Channel.
Mohak bhai why you don't talk about Navy and airforce technical personnel who require minimum 4-5years to learn the equipment whatever. Hello is doing ,
But same thing is happening with technical and gf personnel.
Before recruitment of agniveer ,everyyerar soldiers are recruited by army is approx 60k ,but with agniveer scheme it is approx 43k ,
Upgrade your microphone your voice is deeper and doesn't loud enough
no one is happy with agneveer yojna.
Andhbhakt's are happy...
Just bcz of modi ji laye hai 🤡
even army officials criticizes it 😢
Main baat to capital ki hai
4% log ITR bhar rahe hain
Modern weapon kaise kharidega govt bataao bhai???
No you are not ! If you are then tell me why ?@@theepankajsinha
@@hhariommmay be pankaj ji is a tax payer like me, that' why hi is happy and u don't pay taxes so u are sad
2 years service period should be done so that everyone can get the experience
My grandfather is a retired but not tired Indian Armed Forces veteran .... He served our country in 1971 war and Kargil war .... He and Maj.GEN. G.D Bakshi sir were commissioned together in forces , they both call each other as Brothers in uniform ... My grandfather , my father and my elder brother and many more are all Armed forces officers ...I'm only 17 ....
My grandfather said the exact things that you said that this agniveer scheme is absolute bullsh*t , he said that government will unknowingly add weak and incompetent soldiers in our forces which is very lethal for our country ..... He said that these soldiers will not at all perform well in the battlefield because of immense pressure , lack of hardcore training and knowledge ....
He actually watched your video and shared it to me ..and he said this video is very good because you covered all perspectives and mentioned all imp points ... KEEP IT UP !!!
Bhai agar yahi neta ek baar lok sabha mein Jeet jae toh usse zindagi bhar pension milega per jab baat army mein aati hai toh
Remove 95% pensions, rather facilitate opportunities for other areas
Y can't Govt cut salary of entire politicians in India to 50% as they are already millionaires and transfer these amount to modernization of defense...
also compare the budget of other country and india
Why youtuber don't raise the issue on pension of politician eg. MLA, MP etc
If money is the problem
Apart from nal se jal
Awas yojna
Ration
Mnrega
Ayushmaan
All other freebies should be stopped
70 sal k budde ko 5 sal or chaiye desh ki seva krne k liye or 24 sal k yuva ko retirement k liye kaha ja raha h
As someone who has very closely followed defence modernisation, I support the Agniveer Scheme although with changes like tenure extentions upto 7 yrs or phase wise retirement of Agniveers + Disability Pensions and Medical Benefits for family.
That being said, I feel as far as MLAs and MPs are concerned, all MLAs and MPs should be eligible for pension only after they have served 3 terms.
Also, if you are getting Pension from Parliament, you should not be eligible for MLA pension from Assembly (Some leaders serve 3 terms in State Assembly & 3 in Parliament which would make them eligible for both).
Countries like Israel Russia China where serving for armed forces is compulsory for all atleast 2 years and after that they have choices
But for India 🥹💀