This song feels like it has a whole lot of emotions behind it, ranging from sadness to anger to fear. Carr stands out to me (based on what little I've seen) as being a complex character who is generally unhappy with her current state of being and is deeply hurting. If this is truly where Carr is mentally, I can't help but feel sad and wish for her to find some kind of peace and solace. (Maybe I'm reading too deep into this???) I mean, nothing says "this character is broken inside" more than the sound of literal glass breaking.
V3 is definitely the 'Carr arc' and im really excited to see where her character goes and the interactions she will have with her brother... Also someone really needs to give Carr a hug, poor girl.
The dissonant scraping noise in the background at the start gives off this feeling of being trapped. Like being locked in a room with something you dont want to be anywhere near. And similar noises persist through the midsection too. It reminds me of Silent Hill music, creating this looming sense of panic and anxiety. But the pace doesnt get my heart racing either. Id say its kind of like the picture we are looking at. Imagine being locked in a room with a mirror. You dont want to look at the mirror because you know you wont like what you see looking back at you. You are not in any physical danger, but the mirror represents a constant challenge to your sense of identity and self. Then at the end it becomes almost childlike, like a lullaby. It sounds tired and nostalgic. As if looking back on a simpler and easier time that you know you can never return to. I believe Carr is a character who is deeply discontent with her reality. And her attempts to change said reality only bring her more anguish, but despite this she feels as if she must continue with it.
still thinking about that one line the carrite says in the cloning room, "how could you possibly be this weak?" "i wouldn't exist if you were any better." it probably weighs on carr enough that she can't reach her goals, having her own creations reprimand her to her face must be crushing her
@@trishschamont8961 car saying "why would he(it? can't remember, likely word is some sort of pronoun) be sending these to her" makes MUCH more sense now, woah
Finding this after having finally collected all of the badges is actually making me tear up. I didn't expect to get so attached but the care seeping from every polygon in the project is impossible to miss. Thank you for making something so special, it's moved me more than I ever could have guessed it would and Im so pumped for the future of it. Totally Garnular.
It looks like the Where is tormenting Carr from her childhood. Manipulating her into creating the Garn47 world as it is. And now that she's mature, she tries to fix it, but is still hurt from the Where. Garn47 just doesn't care about it, and Car learned to overcome it, as he is still scared of it, but yet seems to be the happiest creature in this whole world. Possibly because Carr knew how horrible it is, to feel "Pain", so she guarded Car from it.
Why Carr and Car are so cute in this style i love it! Edit: ITS FIRST TIME MY COMMENT EVER GOT SECOND MOST POPULAR Edit 2: ok its now 3rd highest but still thx guys!!! Also on 0:55 we can hear The Where's sound Edit 3: its now only 5th wah
Carr contemplating her life choices anf introverted nature, wishing she could be as outgoing as her little brother, going so far as to imitate him just so she can feel comfortable enough socializing... And right now, she is in need of a god damn hug
Tbh the visuals and music of garn47 world feel like something i would create if i actually had motivation and determination to create a world based on my dreams and nightmares, on my emotions and memories which constantly blend together, get blurry and stuff. Its a shitpost game inside an FNF mod, yet it really feels like its gonna be a whole adventure in a world full of darkness and light filling out the familiar and totally alien places. Just like in our memories and dreams. I always wanted to create a world, so beautiful yet so eerie, with characters and story full of mystery. This track really not only inspire me to try writing my own world like that, but also wakes up something in me, something that says me i need more of music like that, that i need t ofocus, listen to it, forget meaning behind and it and interpret it in my own ways to create something new with help of it. My drawqing skills arent perfect, but lets look at how Car and Carr look like, they are really amazing even if they dont got so many visible trais and stuff, i mean Carr is literally almost a flat cute png file of a simple cat with pointy outlines and it already look amazing, matching the rest of the garn47 world. And if someone can make a simple drawing amazing, i can do it too! Thank you for sharing those tracks with us Floombo, they mean a lot as an inspiration and also motivation for artists like me and you!
*Uhmm hmm ummmm ignore most of this comment because it kinda sucks and I don't believe this anymore.* "I like being you. I want to be you forever." The upcoming "Shattered" boss makes more sense now. This line, along with the distorted Carr theme at the start of Shattered leads me to believe that this character is *pretending to be Carr.* Seeing it from this angle, no wonder the Carr-clones in that hidden room are treated so harshly. Also, the (Carr) at the end implies that this theme could have different variations for different characters?? That or I'm reading too much into this. (Turns out I really wasn't reading too much into this). Edit 47: wow I really like editing this comment huh. I don't really follow this theory very much anymore, because im starting to lean more towards Shattered just being a pseudonym for Carr herself. It makes more sense that she's killing off the Carrites because The Broadcasted is using them to mock her, rather than out of trauma from an encounter with something that copied her. Despite this, it still doesn't explain the quote at the end. Is it The Where? Is it a Carrite mocking her like the others? Is it LD, however he works? The Where does seem to be closely connected to mirrors in a way, so I'm leaning towards that rn. I still think it's possible that Shattered could be a seperate entity, but that has it's own slew of problems.
Good ideas all around, but are you referring to the secret room having the Carr clones killed because they might be The Shattered, or is The Shattered killing Carr clones to have less competition or something else?
@@stress1300 definitely to the former one. The framed picture in the secret room confirms that Carr is/was often in there, but I don't think its because they might be The Shattered. I more see it as a ptsd of sorts, killing them because they reminds her of her experience with The Shattered, but you might be right about the boss disguising itself as a Carrite. Whatever the answer is, I'm excited to see where this all goes when V3 released. The update so far seems like it's gonna have a major focus on Carr. Edit: I said latter instead of former and then somehow didn't notice until a week later
@@DanzTheGB if thought that too when I first stumbled upon this fever dream, but there's so many small things that show that there's a huge story behind this silly goofy garn game.
Floombo, please keep going with this game! It has so much potential. The character designs are incredible and the whole experience is like a fever dream.
That face is the scariest thing in the game and nothing else compares. All it does is sit there and beep until you get close, and then it disappears, and it's somehow terrifying. So simple, yet so perfect. Like just about everything in this game.
I'm still not exactly sure what the Where is, but I have my guesses. To me, it doesn't seem like any one thing or entity, but more a concept, a state of being maybe. As of now in V2, we see the Where in mirror worlds, and in one case, literally a mirror. In game, it looks kinda like a glitched out garnite, but maybe, that's just how it appears to us. Notice that Carr is looking in a mirror, and remember that the Where only appears in mirror worlds. I'm thinking that what Carr is seeing in that mirror is the Where from her perspective
Silly how a lot of the game is inspired by vent art. Seems very clear with how nonsensical an eerie some worlds and characters are! cant wait for the next update oh my goshhh,,,,,,, hhiiss,s,,,,,
As someone who delved into Blender Game Engine (both BGE and UBGE) it’s honestly really hard to make a dynamic save system using it… So honestly I can understand why the devs haven’t added it in. The more Yee know
Turns out, it is very hard to beat Praiseforall with a broken headphone. Took me an hour. Good thing it doesn't remove a badge as it did in V1, but does that also mean that the Formspire ending is removed?
hmmmm interesting to see the wheres creepy noise in the song. weird that they are only found in very specific diamond rooms, specifically cars area. idk garn is so cool cant wait to see what happens next
Everyone asks "Where is Carr?" Maybe we should be asking "How is Carr?"
i like how the entire garn47topia is dark and grim with horrifying creatures always trying to kill you and then we have Car and Carr
hey. you'll never guess who created those creatures,
ironic considering the lore surrounding them
@@Beltboy i am a very friendly fellow!
"The Garn47 V1 was dark and gritty"
and drilly
This song feels like it has a whole lot of emotions behind it, ranging from sadness to anger to fear. Carr stands out to me (based on what little I've seen) as being a complex character who is generally unhappy with her current state of being and is deeply hurting. If this is truly where Carr is mentally, I can't help but feel sad and wish for her to find some kind of peace and solace. (Maybe I'm reading too deep into this???)
I mean, nothing says "this character is broken inside" more than the sound of literal glass breaking.
5 stages of grief
Denial
Anger
Bargaining
Depression
Acceptance
the glass breaking is used in a few of floombos other works
another note is i feel as if carr is just scitzo
that thing cannot be made by a sane mann
Floombo hearted it so this is now canon.
"are you car, a car. I'm in await of your response"
Do you go on the highway and go VROOOOOOOOOM VROOOOOOOM HONKE HONKE?
Yes
@@Moffman_The_Furbug Ok last question before i go i been looking around your comunity and uhhh
I was told not to talk to A.I. voices
have been hearing talk about a garn48?
Carr is having an existential crisis
W pfp.
Rivulet!
hi riv
wet mouse
He thinks hes a van
You can only relight a dying fire so many times, until even the embers beg to you to stop…
Damn your cooking
47 likes, it's a sign
The entire plot of the Dark Souls franchise in a nutshell
ALREADY STARTING ON V3?!?!
wait until you see the OST playlist
The Garngrind never stops
Me not knowing there was a v2:
@@SamiTheAnxiousBeanthe Cygarngrind
@@toasttheif5ultrakill YAY!YAY!Y
V3 is definitely the 'Carr arc' and im really excited to see where her character goes and the interactions she will have with her brother...
Also someone really needs to give Carr a hug, poor girl.
The dissonant scraping noise in the background at the start gives off this feeling of being trapped. Like being locked in a room with something you dont want to be anywhere near.
And similar noises persist through the midsection too. It reminds me of Silent Hill music, creating this looming sense of panic and anxiety. But the pace doesnt get my heart racing either.
Id say its kind of like the picture we are looking at. Imagine being locked in a room with a mirror. You dont want to look at the mirror because you know you wont like what you see looking back at you. You are not in any physical danger, but the mirror represents a constant challenge to your sense of identity and self.
Then at the end it becomes almost childlike, like a lullaby. It sounds tired and nostalgic. As if looking back on a simpler and easier time that you know you can never return to.
I believe Carr is a character who is deeply discontent with her reality. And her attempts to change said reality only bring her more anguish, but despite this she feels as if she must continue with it.
still thinking about that one line the carrite says in the cloning room, "how could you possibly be this weak?" "i wouldn't exist if you were any better."
it probably weighs on carr enough that she can't reach her goals, having her own creations reprimand her to her face must be crushing her
Cloning room in the superstructure or under the fountain?
Well... It isn't a cloning room. It's a lab, and those "clones" are carrites created by the Broadcasted and sent to her, presumably to cause her pain
@@trishschamont8961 car saying "why would he(it? can't remember, likely word is some sort of pronoun) be sending these to her" makes MUCH more sense now, woah
@@theman13532where does he say it?
@@axosotll In Carr's lab
Finding this after having finally collected all of the badges is actually making me tear up. I didn't expect to get so attached but the care seeping from every polygon in the project is impossible to miss. Thank you for making something so special, it's moved me more than I ever could have guessed it would and Im so pumped for the future of it. Totally Garnular.
It looks like the Where is tormenting Carr from her childhood. Manipulating her into creating the Garn47 world as it is. And now that she's mature, she tries to fix it, but is still hurt from the Where.
Garn47 just doesn't care about it, and Car learned to overcome it, as he is still scared of it, but yet seems to be the happiest creature in this whole world. Possibly because Carr knew how horrible it is, to feel "Pain", so she guarded Car from it.
interesting lore
I saw "V3" in the title and I clicked so god damn fast
Ultrakill real.
V2 Ultrakill may be gone, but get ready for V3
oh hi mister Trav guy
Real
@@Winkwing I wasn't even thinking about ultrakill lol, I was just excited to see more of Garn47
Why Carr and Car are so cute in this style i love it!
Edit: ITS FIRST TIME MY COMMENT EVER GOT SECOND MOST POPULAR
Edit 2: ok its now 3rd highest but still thx guys!!!
Also on 0:55 we can hear The Where's sound
Edit 3: its now only 5th wah
Thats her sister
@@SuperSpidervgaming that's his sister.
Carr contemplating her life choices anf introverted nature, wishing she could be as outgoing as her little brother, going so far as to imitate him just so she can feel comfortable enough socializing...
And right now, she is in need of a god damn hug
I'm so glad I get to listen to Garn Music! I love all of it!
Tbh the visuals and music of garn47 world feel like something i would create if i actually had motivation and determination to create a world based on my dreams and nightmares, on my emotions and memories which constantly blend together, get blurry and stuff. Its a shitpost game inside an FNF mod, yet it really feels like its gonna be a whole adventure in a world full of darkness and light filling out the familiar and totally alien places. Just like in our memories and dreams. I always wanted to create a world, so beautiful yet so eerie, with characters and story full of mystery. This track really not only inspire me to try writing my own world like that, but also wakes up something in me, something that says me i need more of music like that, that i need t ofocus, listen to it, forget meaning behind and it and interpret it in my own ways to create something new with help of it. My drawqing skills arent perfect, but lets look at how Car and Carr look like, they are really amazing even if they dont got so many visible trais and stuff, i mean Carr is literally almost a flat cute png file of a simple cat with pointy outlines and it already look amazing, matching the rest of the garn47 world. And if someone can make a simple drawing amazing, i can do it too!
Thank you for sharing those tracks with us Floombo, they mean a lot as an inspiration and also motivation for artists like me and you!
Good luck!
@@GlaceonIcc Thank you!
Good luck on that friend, hope to see successful future of your dream
This carr drawing looks cute tbh
amero hola
The end says "I like being you. I'd like to be you forever" for those who are wondering
car.exe may not be canon... carr.exe on the other hand-
@@ADuckInBlack I hope not. Carr is my favorite.
LORE
Also is that Carr as a kitten?
yes actually
I thought so, thanks for clarifying it.
@@Floombo LORE
@@FloomboLORE
@@Floombo LORE
for such a simple character design it's probably my favorite
*Uhmm hmm ummmm ignore most of this comment because it kinda sucks and I don't believe this anymore.*
"I like being you. I want to be you forever."
The upcoming "Shattered" boss makes more sense now. This line, along with the distorted Carr theme at the start of Shattered leads me to believe that this character is *pretending to be Carr.*
Seeing it from this angle, no wonder the Carr-clones in that hidden room are treated so harshly.
Also, the (Carr) at the end implies that this theme could have different variations for different characters?? That or I'm reading too much into this. (Turns out I really wasn't reading too much into this).
Edit 47: wow I really like editing this comment huh.
I don't really follow this theory very much anymore, because im starting to lean more towards Shattered just being a pseudonym for Carr herself. It makes more sense that she's killing off the Carrites because The Broadcasted is using them to mock her, rather than out of trauma from an encounter with something that copied her.
Despite this, it still doesn't explain the quote at the end. Is it The Where? Is it a Carrite mocking her like the others? Is it LD, however he works? The Where does seem to be closely connected to mirrors in a way, so I'm leaning towards that rn.
I still think it's possible that Shattered could be a seperate entity, but that has it's own slew of problems.
Good ideas all around, but are you referring to the secret room having the Carr clones killed because they might be The Shattered, or is The Shattered killing Carr clones to have less competition or something else?
@@stress1300 definitely to the former one. The framed picture in the secret room confirms that Carr is/was often in there, but I don't think its because they might be The Shattered.
I more see it as a ptsd of sorts, killing them because they reminds her of her experience with The Shattered, but you might be right about the boss disguising itself as a Carrite.
Whatever the answer is, I'm excited to see where this all goes when V3 released. The update so far seems like it's gonna have a major focus on Carr.
Edit: I said latter instead of former and then somehow didn't notice until a week later
@popslyme4280 I am also quite excited for the update, Carr's probably my favorite Garn47 character so I am extra hyped
This game cannot be that deep bro😭
@@DanzTheGB if thought that too when I first stumbled upon this fever dream, but there's so many small things that show that there's a huge story behind this silly goofy garn game.
fly high floombo 🕊️
Wait what he died?
@@Dinklenut yeah this is the last upload of him
@@Dinklenut yes 😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
@@idk-rl4he so what he die from
SO GARN47S GONE FOREVER? IM GONNA MISS CAR
"He'll never understand what i'm going though. My intentions - to him - will always be a mystery."
starting to think about deeper meanings in this game; with carr and car creating a world that they’ve lost themselves in, both in different ways
The implications of this are insane im going to cry
Floombo, please keep going with this game! It has so much potential. The character designs are incredible and the whole experience is like a fever dream.
I love the intro, its so soothing yet so sad
Beyond that glass is a future,
cant wait for the where’s siblings: the what, the why, the when, and the how
I actually quite enjoyed the music that was quite surprised though in the end what good music 😺👍
Wao... Profundidad para carr sabía que debía haber algo más de ella , te queremos carr
This started melancholic and then devolved into pure fucking fear.
I hear the sound of the beeping red face in the song… that thing scared the hell out of me whenever I found it
wait really? where?
@@raventheampwave1900 All throughout but you can hear it the best at 0:55
Oh yeah that one also scared tf out of me when I looked behind while running
That face is the scariest thing in the game and nothing else compares.
All it does is sit there and beep until you get close, and then it disappears, and it's somehow terrifying.
So simple, yet so perfect. Like just about everything in this game.
@@popslyme4280And it will be expanded apon more in V3, perhaps it's the Where that is speaking at the end of the song
Carr lore going insane
carr looks particularly cute this time
Finally, actually something about Carr!
"i like being you. i want to be you forever." FLOOMBO WHAT DOES THIS MEAN!!!!!!!
V3? We haven’t even figured out v2 yet!
Floombo is two steps ahead XD
@@Chestnutshepsonlist
Carr origin story song real?
Yo, we apreciate how much work you're putting in the project, but v2 just came out. Take a break. You deserve it man.
it's always the where, but never the why
Holy moly this goes existentially hard
really really gorgeous and i love how the noise and distortion is used to drown out the prettier parts!!
I'm still not exactly sure what the Where is, but I have my guesses. To me, it doesn't seem like any one thing or entity, but more a concept, a state of being maybe. As of now in V2, we see the Where in mirror worlds, and in one case, literally a mirror. In game, it looks kinda like a glitched out garnite, but maybe, that's just how it appears to us. Notice that Carr is looking in a mirror, and remember that the Where only appears in mirror worlds. I'm thinking that what Carr is seeing in that mirror is the Where from her perspective
something tells me Carr is going to be the real final boss of this game
one diamond for life, two for death
This is the second comment I saw on this, where did you hear this?
The where is coming.
the reflection of spongebob popsicle
Car's Silly Sister
oh my goodness. why so splingle. the mipy. thank you floombo
im a simple person
i see carr
i am happy
edit: so if this is apparently carr as a kitten are we gonna see characters backstories in v3 then
Why does carrs eyes on the mirror reflection remind me of the waker boss..
Diamonds in Garn47 are symbolic of life and power I believe. The shapes pop up all over the place.
Carr, yes new garn47 v3! So joyous
Carr is fighting with the anxiety
Garn47: Limbo
Yeah, I Will Name V3 Limbo.
Hope It At Least Has ONE Carrite, Seriously, Carrites Are Apart of Garn47 Lore But Not In The Game!
@@wyattsfilms4451there are several carrites _and_ carrrites in game actually.
@@uboa8060 oh!
I noticed that Carr's pupils are always shaped like the symbol of life, while Car's only sometimes. What could this mean ?
car is half sentient
One diamond for life, two for death
how tf did this game start out as a shitpost to having actual lore
Silly how a lot of the game is inspired by vent art. Seems very clear with how nonsensical an eerie some worlds and characters are! cant wait for the next update oh my goshhh,,,,,,, hhiiss,s,,,,,
Slow down, we can wait for v3, don’t rush yourself.
Yeah, where? I wanna know.
Yeah, who? i wanna know.
Yeah, when? I wanna know.
Yeah, why? I wanna know.
yeah, which? i wanna know.
carr's melancholic song
"I like being you. I want to be you forever..."
THE FUCKING REVEAL
She's had the earing the whole time she isn't Car CAR IS AN IMPOSTER
carr
I don't think Car is an imposter. The imposter is something else, the Where most likely
Carr needs a hug guys 🫂
I bet Carr is going to be a boss fight. And defeating her will make her realize she's better off playing outside with Car and his friends.
i love how haunting this sounds :)
I think this is beautiful
i think carr is my favorite character in garn47
Carrbon dioxide
Keep putting out psycho bangers!
This is my favorite track so far 👍
carr'll start a rap battle with "herself" on the mirror
"Garn V3 - Carr's arc" incoming????
i love this :0
I love the V3 ost so far. Are you considering adding saving to the game? I never have enough time to get all the badges at once lol.
As someone who delved into Blender Game Engine (both BGE and UBGE) it’s honestly really hard to make a dynamic save system using it… So honestly I can understand why the devs haven’t added it in.
The more Yee know
This is my favourite so far
Fly high Floombo, lost to the Farm Merge Valley virus….
Ive only listened to ten seconds and its already peak.
I’m Floombing out rn
Reminds me of "the world looks white"
not only do we have the W, but now the Whewre? truely good!
I feel like a Mashup remix of the where (carr) and numb would go so hard
We’re spinning with this one ❤🎉
best way to wake up
something something lore something something hell yeah
i like how car is just silly while carr seems pretty dark as of now
AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHGHHHHHHHHHH I AM SO EXCITED
deep.
baby...
Turns out, it is very hard to beat Praiseforall with a broken headphone. Took me an hour. Good thing it doesn't remove a badge as it did in V1, but does that also mean that the Formspire ending is removed?
The formspire ending was lengthened to 13 badges. Once you've done that, go to the 3rd floor of the superstructure and you can get the ending.
Bro who deep fried that one ultrakill song
1:58
WHAT.
THE.
HELL.
i like being you...i want to be you *forever*
oh this is going to go crazy
hmmmm interesting to see the wheres creepy noise in the song. weird that they are only found in very specific diamond rooms, specifically cars area. idk garn is so cool cant wait to see what happens next
Car and Carr!
Reminds me of the Citizen Sleeper OST, slaps
Floombo, Is it possible to create Russification on Garn47 if it is taken up?
I just noticed
There are 47 comments
There are 47 videos in the OST
TOTALLY GARNULAR
no longer garnular 😭
V3!!!! YIPPEEEE PLS FIX THE BOSS CRASHING ISSUES IN V3 🙏🙏🙏
This is the sound of horror.