Bottom Line with Pravin Sawhney: Assessing Modi Gov's Foreign Policy & G20 Summit
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Join Pravin Sawhney in this episode of Bottom Line as he critically examines the assertions made by the Modi government regarding its foreign policy achievements, with a particular focus on its performance at the G20 summit.
From projecting India as an exceptional global power to its success in forums like the G20 summit and its role in ensuring freedom of navigation in the Indian Ocean region, Pravin dissects the rhetoric versus reality of these claims.
Delving into the BJP's 2024 election manifesto and the narrative of India's assertive military power, Pravin raises important questions about whether India could have done better and if it's foreclosing opportunities for prosperity in favor of projecting a certain image.
Don't miss out on this insightful analysis that challenges the status quo and prompts deeper reflection on India's foreign policy trajectory. Tune in to Bottom Line with Pravin Sawhney, exclusively on Force Magazine's RUclips channel.
Mr Pravin.. such good analytical skills backed with impeccable knowledge and understanding. Thanks for sharing 🙏
Good knowledge for Pakistani audiences... Indians have Higher literacy rate...
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
Yes we accept. But After 75 years we knows we are long way behind😮
Mr Pravin is a First Class Indian truly. Govt of India please pay heed to this loyal Citizen. He is doing this because too many morons sitting at government and most of all, he loves his country. Respect.
Lol first class citizen..who got court marshaled and kicked out of army 😂
Well said Mr. Sawhney, I hope Mr. Jaishankar shows some professional integrity and stops fooling himself and the people of India.
Agreed. Friends can be changed but not neighbours.
Just note that G20 is not only the event management or celebration like a marriage ceremony without a bride. Mostly, all events, accidents, or festivals under him are events management to save guards his image on the expenses of the public funds. Meanwhile, our Indian fellows are simply suffering of health, education, family issues and starvation too.
Joke.
Beggars cannot be choosers 😂😂😂😂
🇵🇰 beggar spotted 😂😂
When you say India is the voice of global south you’re insulting other countries but without knowing you’re actually insulting yourself. No one is looking up to India for anything. I’m sure the current Indian government understands this.
Arming the Philippines & vowing to stand with them against China when America gives the nod doesn't look like a Global south team player.
@@alanhamford2538arming the Philippine with the Russians assembled missiles so called voice of south Asian ? 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Who got Africa in G20?
@@markvelber8664 Did Philippines go to Russia or India?
India got no ability in the global south,
Typical pakistani Chinese twaddle 😂😂😂
the fact that pakistan got more spotlight in this whole current iran-israe fiasco says a lot about indias influence in geopolitics
It got
And yes......Pakistan is a nuclear superpower 😂😂😂
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
Totally agreed. As you correctly noted, India risks becoming a vassal state of the Western power who fear both China and India. What better outcome than pitting them against each other and creating an environment of fear which serves neither (except perhaps Modi's fear mongering which allows BJP to present him as the only strong leader who can standup to China and Pakistan). There is so much to be gained by pursuing peace and partnership with Pakistan and China!
I call Modi an American idolizing poodle
No country in the world can dictate terms to India. India is not a failed bankrupt country like Pakistan.
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
@adolft_official what is that even
Too late, India suffers from Colonial Mindset and their white western masters have told them their role and they naturally have accepted
G7 - Amerikkka and its 6 dogs
India is waiting patiently for a dog's license. 😂😂😂😂
@@brianliew5901 LOL
@@brianliew5901dogs are better than the foxes of peaceful community and CCP virus.
G7, for the Chinese Cantonese word was seven pigs.
@@cfu242 七猪🐷😂😂😂😂
Barely within a month after the Delhi summit G20 faded into irrelevance due the Israeli Gaza conflict. South Africa assumed moral leadership which was once the legacy of India. As Pravin Sawhney has shown there are different realignments in the world which has left India in the sidelines.
Sir, thank you for bringing the truth in front of all the people, this is great service to India. You should be the Foreign Minister of India, maybe one day you will be .
Jayashankar is just playing politics for Modi Ji.
Don't talk about jayashankar 😂😂😂 he eats west
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
@@shilpashetty5493more likely cow’s dung 😂😂😂
Optics, that's the only thing that matters for India.
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
Optics to win elections! That's it!
Modi likes to brag, does he ever improve the living standard of the poor?
Modi is the enemy of the working people
You are right 👍🏽. Stop pretending to be a super power when people are sleeping and dying in the streets.
@@mohammedziauddin601
says a begg@r from 🇵🇰 😂😂
Yes he did Adani and Ambani and him doesn’t he?
He did and upgraded from a tea seller to a president and that's hella of an improvement. 🤑🤑🤑🤑
A very highly illuminating show by a very highly intelligent, unbias and pragmatic academic of the highest calibre. ❤from Indonesia.
thank you
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
In dia is trying to play both sides. Everyone knows this.
Impeccable observation and analysis sir. Well done , I really enjoyed and learned quite a bit from this video. 🎉🎉🎉
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
Looking at reality is important. BJP and our Mainstream media keeping Indian's in a bubble of we are vishva guru and not pointing the issues and threats is dangerous for our Nation's future.
Excellent analysis. And yes G20 or G21 is going into irrelevance as the Western imperialist powers have turned it into a political grouping as well like the G7. So BRICS is now considered to be a major voice of the Global South or Global Majority countries.
Alhamdulillah and thank you for stating and elaborating this tsunami that is about to overrun the world trade - Indigenous Manufacturing. Globalization is about to wither and die and so will the numerous export-oriented economies who are under-developed and currently boasting economic gains. You are a blessing of God with your wisdom and hard work. Jazakallah!
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
For the non-Indian views the current government wishes to increase and show it's "Pride & Prestige." Not their results. How can a nation with crippling poverty, undeveloped infrastructure, limited military industrial complex, stive to be in the Global North or South? "Pride & Prestige."
Just like the Hindi movies
@@bdbusiness7896 "Mission Kashmir & War"
Real I'd se aa ja Abdul.
India is not a nation but union of nations
@@SatpalVerma000❣️da
Modi Godi did some good for the people and country.
Devalue the Rupees, makes his buddies Adani and Tata multi billionaires
over night, Choose the Japanese to built the HSR but delayed for years
compare to the Indonesia line which is operational and talk of SEA.
He segregated religion and race of India even though they are all citizens of
India. He made himself the one and only Autocracy Prime Minister of the world.
Imagine the Supreme Court Judges, High Ranking Military personnel, Indian Media,
Financial/Banking Institution and his blind followers being his puppets to manipulate.
Credit must be given to Modi for achieving all these.🙏🙏🙏
BJP may be bad but TATA, Adani were billionaire much before BJP years
Bussineses are corrupted from the era of Indira Gandhi when there was a proposal being made in many democratic nations in the west for the funding of election campaigns be provided by the governmental institutions, no such laws were adopted in india and as a result you can see our elections being one of the costliest to fight in, compared to the rest of the democratic world.
Reference: soch by mohak mangal yt channel's vid on the topic of legalization of corruption via electoral bonds
Lu mesia atau Spurs...Ah Chan
Jgn laa Chan org tau Lu c...n alif
@@nirmalbhel3231 Adani's wealth skyrocketed after 2014
You are so awesomely spot on in this vlog about this G20, as you always are in almost every vlog of yours on every issue that you comment on, Sir!
Indeed this G20 has proven to be the biggest nothingburger that we have dug our teeth into.
The Unipolar World mavericks have taken the best decades of our nation and given us nothing but pelf and misery in return.
Our rural economy and agriculture have been devastated beyond redemption by the market forces unleashed by the spearhead nations of the G20.
In the recently held G20 summit in India -- there are rumors that big-ticket grain purchase deals have been done. These deals directly impact our farmers, and have the capacity to wreck our farm sectors to the benefit of international corporate giants like Bung and Cargill who monopolize the grain commodities market.
It is time for us to wake up to the evil of these Unipolar World, G20 nations before it is too late.
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
India's Per Capita is same as per capita of Bangladesh.
No it's actually a few tens of dollars less. India is the poorest country in the G21/G20 on per capita basis.
@@thecomment9489 check recent datas. It's more than Bangladesh.
@@debajyotipatra2313 whether it is more or less is irrelevant. India is not a major power, only a developing nation.
@@mohammedziauddin601 india isn't a superpower but a major regional power. China is a economic superpower, not a overall superpower. US is still the sole superpower. And pakistan isn't a power at all, may be a minor regional power.
@@mohammedziauddin601 India is a regional power and one of the world's fastest growing economies. Voice of India matters in the grand scheme of things.
Why did you remove your post on China three-four days back? Hope you were not under pressure from VishwaGuru's militia???
Jhoot padka gya range hato. That's why he deleted the post.
Great analysis thank u.
Great analysis. The country achieved skills in the development of a new Technology of Wetdreama and feel good factors and without the need for a dose of opioid. Live on, and harvest, and develop an export market for this newly developed Wetdreama Technology for 1.3 billion people.. Work hard on it and best wishes for success in wanna be leader of south..
very good analysis 👍👍👍👏👏👏
Mr.Parvin, you are the true mind in Indian state.....I hope, the establishment of India will listen to your distinctive approach....thanks for such diverse breakdown of the events shaping lives of hundred of millions in the region and across the globe😊
Although the GDP growth of Modi's administration is around 7% in 2024, but the GDP per capita is only $2731, behind Vietnam($4624) and Thailand ($7812), so stop buying those expensive foreign military gadgets and spend it on welfare of the people.
Look at population dmb nikka..
For him Pak Army is much better tan Indian Army
India should ask to join G7
Absolutely agree
India should join G7 abd get lost from BRICS and the SCO.
India is West trojan horse to sabotage BRICS and the SCO.
❤❤❤MR, PARVAIN SAWANAY IS TRUE PERSON, WHO SHOWS CORRECT FACE TO HIS FOREIGN MINISTER.
Half served Army man now international strategist from Chinna University & did master Degree in Political science from Ravalpindi University.
Agreed, India need to be like independent but it behavior is like south Korea or Ukraine, as we all know what US did with Ukraine, like a proxy state, they messed up and US is living in peace, need to learn lesson.
There are slave owners, field slaves, and house slaves. India positioned itself to be the last.
Cant understand why Indian govt and politicians always try to make its relevance when there is nothing india to be proud of
Blowing ones own trumpet!
People are talking here forget the historical facts where we were and what we gonna do?
Well spoken sir, keep it up.
Modi loves limelight-
As always great analysis
100% agreed. I wish present Indian Government gets benefitted with your excellent analysis.
Well said I am really supporting u r analysis. Just think india china n russia in one alliance. America won't let this happen
This Indian is so much better than Kishore Mabhubani.
RESPECTED SIR, GEE, APP K URDU / HINDI V.LOG SUNANAY K APNA HE MAZA HAY. SAL MEIN 1 HE URDU / HINDI V.LOG DANAY KE BAJAY , KINDLY HIR MONTH AT LEAST 1 V. LOG DEA KARAIN. STAY BLESSED❤❤❤
Just Respect From Pakistan
This guy was caught lying.. he posted a fake video on China's "Information Force" and had to delete it... Caught RED HANDED
I think time has come for sensible Indians to seriously think about the faulty foreign policy of their governments. After losing its foothold with almost all its neighbours, including the tiny country Maldives, it is now Bangladesh's turn. A big protest took place very recently in front of London's India House. Apart from border killings and India's refusal to share water of common rivers, seeing the shameful role of India in supporting Hasina, the people of Bangladesh have become more anti-India. This seems to be getting stronger by the day.
Unless India changes its Bangladesh policy, this people's movement does not seem to stop. The result will be TOTAL INDIA OUT.
Some analysts failed to realise that the spark that ignited the India Out movement could lead to mass upheaval.
On the other hand, if America fails to live up to its declared promise to restore democracy and human rights in Bangladesh, i.e., if USA aligns itself with India by taking a stand against BNP and the people of Bangladesh, BNP's strategy will also have to change. In this situation, China will be willing to cooperate with BNP against Indo-American powers. Then a new chapter of world geopolitics can begin again. So, there is no chance to take these things lightly.
LOVE YOUR LAST POINT.
Thanks for your insightful analysis of global south
When I heard his bhashan on Muslim community of nation I feel shame that I am citizen of such country and having such RSS idiology to which people support 😢😢😢
bhimta spotted 😂😂
@@Maverick-zo4kcgey sanghota spotted 😆😆🐷🐷🐷
@@Maverick-zo4kc Paj££t putra spotted
Insightful, as usual
Nice analysis
For ten years now our country saw cultism cum dictatorial regime establishing itself as Omnipresent, Omnipotent and Omniscient at the cost of taxpayers and at the backdrop of events and headline managements. Ten years records reveal that India’s relationships with neighboring counties are at its nadir! Let’s forget about assuming Global South Leadership. G20 and QUAD are irrelevant now!! Our foreign policy for ten years has been just playing a second fiddle studded communal flavors satisfying WhatsApp University by EAM (beside the point is that BJP is poorly represented in the entire “South India”!) Modi has no contribution about India being a Vishwaguru.
Once a Financial expert said, " Economics decides the politics of a nation. " But now in India, politics decides the economics of this nation.
A FOOL always finds a GREATER FOOL to ADMIRE him- Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Very good video.
Why Pravin sir ? Why ? Y Always anti India view sir ??…….u always talking good about china and discouraging ur own country???
Always good and informative analysis
❤ Love it
Sir, unfortunately majority of veteran community had joined the G20-G20 corus.
I have been watching for a long time Mr Sawhney dishing out distorted views of Geo Politics. Please note the following.
India China border dispute long Pre dates America China discord. India China problem is independent of America China problem . Yes India needs America to safe guard it's borders and Amarica needs India to safe guard it's Super Power status . True India and Amarica are at the two ends of the Globe but they have much in common. On the other hand China Pakistan have nothing in common . Only thing that they have in common is their desire to keep India down
Find the G20 communiques from previous editions and read them. The content of the communique is becoming increasingly broad or lacks specific details. The communique is more like a superposition of opinions from all parties than a consensus.
Why so late to review G20 of India !!
Why are you not able to digest the successful handling of G20 by India? What’s your problem? Be constructive, man and talk good about India
Even better than jaishankar
You are always critical to Modi and BJP in your every video. It seems that your ambition have not been materialized by present govt.
We are not part of any block with time we want our own block don't mislead please.
GREAT ANALYSIS!!!!!
.... don't forget. India is the Mother of Democracy!!!!😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
All his videos will video ends up with China praising and India bashing. India is fortunate to have son like him
Looking at reality is important. BJP and our Mainstream media keeping Indian's in a bubble of we are vishvaguru and not pointing the issues and threats is dangerous for our Nation's future.
He is traitor..kicked out from army
@@HimanshuMahajan-zn3nq
PM is alleged for supporting communal rights and genocide in Gujarat.
@@mg.f.9023 alleged? I can also allege someone for anything doesn't matter.. he got clean chit from SC
@@mg.f.9023 how empowering people is dangerous?
Excellent !
Sir you are talking in English.. It will never reach north India.. Please do it in Hindi and they will watch and learn to think critical and rational...
हिंदी में बोला करो सर!ताकि बहुसंख्यक लोग समझ सकें और आपके द्वारा उपलब्ध कराई गई सूचनाओं का सही उपयोग हो सके!
very realistic and comprehensive analysis as usual. Indian PM Modi has made Indians that claim all types of nonsense like "we r the masters and owners of middle east and Kaaba, we r masters and owners of North America, South America because their religious books talk some historical character went their and taught them sun worship and bla bla bla. In this delusion, Indians really think themselves "Vishva Guru", but among those brain washed deluded people there r a few with alive and working brain, and in my opinion, u r one of them. I suggest u to study Islam with your such a good thinking mind. I am sure u would find it worthy to b accepted and followed to. Good wishes and greetings from Pakistan
Global South.. thanks to India, now all r talking about it. his was due to G20 summit in India. China and G7 suppressed global south. India may be behind G7 and China but but brought up global south.. global south trust's INDIA
@adolft_official Yes, World including China ignored them... India is helping to make it visible
Salaam all,
#AlAqsaUnderAttack
#AlAqsaCallsMuslimArmies
#freegaza
#freepalestine
#freekashmir
#freepakistan
#freerohingiyamuslims
#IndianMuslimsUnderAttack
#freeuyghurs
Massalaam
Suhail
What does Jayashankar eats in the morning cow’s dung foo?
One more wailing.
Ok
Vote congress✋for I.N. D. I. A Alliance, save our country INDIA
😂😂
Pravin Shawnee has become brand ambassador for Failed Chinese and Pakistan projects BRI and Chee pec.😂😂😂😂
12:30
Chinna and Russia are in north. How they can say they are in south.😂😂😂😂
Shankar is more egocentric than Modi
👍🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇳🇨🇳🇿🇦➕️😃👏👏👏👏👏
🇮🇳 OUT !!!
400 billion dollar investment in iran Chinese announced 5 year back . Not even a 50 cent invested.😂😂😂😂😂😂
Africa people ko 105 billion dollar 😂😂😂😂
What nonsense
Just now Iran confirmed at the Iran China meeting- $ 106.8 Billion already invested plus Oil Deal for $ 80 Billion invested already
Yes because you are an absolute eddiote
Fibre optics and 🚆🚂 in Iran
Oil and gas E & P by Cnooc, Cosle,sinopec strong foothold in Iran.. Which western drilling company can drill in Iran... absolute edddiote
A discourse on G20 now? Aren't you a bit late in the day? Btw what the Chinese do to poor nations under garb of development which is entrap them in a debt trap. You Mr Sawhney conveniently skip that. Overall your monologue is incoherent, jumping from one issue to another without any connection. Your only aim is to put the BJP government down by whatever means it's clear as day. No recommendation, no suggestions just a morbid monologue. I'm pretty sure someone is stuffing your pockets to do this pessimistic piece and that's why you are a favorite of Pakistani commentators. Peace with Pakistan,, shall we handover kashmir? Peace with China.. shall we handover arunachal, Tibet to them. You are in a stupor sir and stuck in a time warp of Congress times when whining and tail wagging was our foreign policy.
In podcast with moeed pirzada. Pakistani anchor exposed pravin.
😊😊
@@santhugowda7179is there a link that you can share?
@@venkatavilla9818
Sure.
ruclips.net/video/Ty5o0b6khLw/видео.htmlsi=HgwkN_sFi-gY7O_Z
Sorry ladakh not Tibet.. my mistake
The indians are going to find out soon enough what it means to be a "friend" of the usa.
This man clearly has a political agenda. He claims to be a military expert, foreign policy expert, and what not , all rolled in one..
He has anti Modi agenda, as if India was very stong before Modi and has become weak after Modi...
India was not strong before 2014 but also India was not making big claims to be this or that power. First the masses have to be lifted out of poverty, socioeconomic and human development indicators have to be raised up significantly before any such deluded claims are made.
In fact on almost all human development indicators India's rankings and scores actually match that of African countries and specially the Sb-Saharan Africa often considered to be the most backward and poorest region of the world.
@@thecomment9489 This channel is primarily on defence subject. .. So far as economy is concerned, large number of people have been uplifted. Still, considering population size & density , India needs to work hard, irrespective of whether this govt rules at center or that.
@@thecomment9489 correct your facts. India is way better economically and socially than 95% of the African countries. South Africa, Morocco, Seychelles some 2-3 other small African countries are better than us.
@@debajyotipatra2313 Well I guess if anyone here needs to get his facts correct it is most definitely you. So go and check the per capita GDP, life expectancy, sanitation coverage, global hunger index and many other human development indexes to clear your doubts.
@@thecomment9489😂😂 Ya sure go ahead and give us the data where does India stand
This Gentleman is Foreign funded To Gang. Somehow all Good things are things worth appreciating are seen as Dark thing and wants yo see how bad it can be presented.
His post should be shunned. Bad man
How? Can you point out those bits in his video where you think he can be rebutted by you. Please provide some intelligent rebuttals to his points you think are biased rather than making usual low intellect claims that so or so is foreign funded. Usually low IQ and CIA bots make such claims as they have nothing intelligent and factual to say.
When you can't counter him you character assassinate him lol typical of chaddis
@@safashaikh2894lol typical k2aa getting orgasm by anti india rant
Excellent analysis.....sir.